Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 48 by R’ Eli Stefansky

you got it okay all right boys are you ready um we're live good vacation it's friday afternoon in chicago it's a half a tie it's not a real it's a it's a it's a muttsy shot i forgot to bring my thighs for marriage trouble we have to go shopping today i found the a zenya it must be like from uh the collection of 1965 or something so we are not going to wear it it was just for the good rabbi yeah so basil hashem this will be transmitted energy stroll on matsujavas matsushab is in chicago it's a little confusing for me as well matashab is here in chicago at 11 15 p.m transmitting live from chicago which will be 7 15 and energy stroll in the morning eric william kipper airbnb kipper in chicago 11 15 in the morning transmitting once again so that people could see a sheer matsuyam kipper and their it's all about the yoyomi we got it gotta learn every day give a every day sometimes it turns out that it's in the morning so this is the evening but it's once a day exactly what happens after even kipper i'm not even sure oh we got are you mack from passaic what are you what he's wearing a mask he thinks that the corona goes through the the screen or something all right fine today's sheer sponsor or a foreign in a five-year battle against esophageal cancer joss underwent another very serious surgery requesting your feelings and learning for a foolish lame or forced lame-o sponsored by you val cavoche in memory of fair dos kayo bat ester versio it's a three day sponsorship you score joseph sponsored the the food last night similar to what we have in the spanish and schnitzel oh this is from mark ashkenazi in reference to ellie for his dedication to his mishpacha of learning de da fiomi and for giving equally captivating shiorim while on the road which can't be easy mark has imitated [Music] it's difficult because i'm like half asleep at night that one also vado listen to this one a short email this by jesse sanders my mother came out of the hospital just before rosh hashanah the sheer sponsorship worked bar hashem he sponsored the day of so what do we have here it's this one right over here for paul ballots should have her for slamo we also have some very bad news one of our loim de adaf one of the people in the mishpacha of the daf his name is afraid friedman he's from ramapa chemish we were saying to him for his wife zahava and unfortunately she was niftares today i don't know her name i know they were saying tell him for zahava bass malcolm khanna so i don't know what her name right now but who knows her name should have been aliyah the the very she's very very young very very young you know babies little little kids uh the asylum should be able to grow up you know normally it's a very it's very very difficult for for you simon so ephraim should be miss khasik and he's simon too unbelievable okay oh it's torah we have to be bisimra so now yeah so if everybody stephen we don't have a guy that's um in charge so we got everybody has to mute themselves if it's possible you know what i'll make this quieter here so it doesn't disturb me as well and then you guys will be in charge of them okay so what we have here is are you able to see these charts from back there yeah so basically if you look closely you have two cities and there's a body of water smack in the middle and the 2000 amis reaches midway to the body of water on both directions now water obviously mixes in and everything and what do you do are you allowed to carry the water on chavez so he says like this if you put a net you put a kharim in the water you divide the water sorry oh so if you take this metal piece of you take a piece of metal a piece of steel and you put it right down the center of the body of water now you can yo you can't sit next to people you have to be very careful because somebody in your class has corona so you're atlantic i let you come you can't sit next to other people so if you put a piece of metal it works it divides the water equally half to this guy you have to that guy so you can take the water out says the gemara by the way today we're going to see something very very interesting something i'm i'm passionate about i don't speak too much about it because it's controversial and that is the derek halimod in today's yeshivas how they learn and in our gemara it's a very very important gemara to remember it's interesting teaches us a tremendous decide about how to learn again i'm not saying that you mean is the way to learn it's great for us balabadan but then there's a there's a there's a happy medium because the yeshiva guys they learn two three daf a year and that's also extremely disappointing in my opinion so we're going to see in a second left it's a joke what you're going to put a piece of metal down the middle of this body of water it doesn't make any sense it says let's analyze this why is he laughing my time ago why is he making and we talked about objects they're also kind because according to you could take this out according to rabban on he holds like rabban on that an object doesn't have a visa um this is just because he doesn't hold like you so you're gonna make fun of somebody it doesn't hold like you that's not nice you don't make fun of people that don't hold like your sheet up so what's the reason it made fun of italian this we had and this is agreed upon that moving objects moving water we spoke about moving clouds moving water or a spring that moves harian kiragi kalada anything that moves anybody that grabs it he becomes the owner and that object becomes his object in other words wherever he goes that's where the water could go it's not limited to the water it's limited to the person so wherever he could go if he can move two thousand armies so count the water so what's the problem over here this water is moving so the it's moving from side to side it's in the it's in the middle of two properties and it moves so wherever you grab the water you could bring it back into your property it's not a problem because water doesn't have a trump the hardest maybe we're talking about some sort of well and the well doesn't move a lake even a lake forget about a well a well even though that's uh y'all y'all please meet yourself thank you so even though a well or a lake there's a large body of water and it actually moves you have waves etc but it's considered non-moving object because it's it's limited what it's not a river exactly a river is really moving this is yes it moves here and there it goes up and down and the water kind of anything even a lake la michonne since it has defined mercury's so it's not like a cloud that goes from here to there it travels hundreds of miles it's not like a river that travels hundreds of miles it's within a certain defined area therefore it's considered not moving so maybe you'll tell me that's what we're talking about right and that's what it is in the picture it's a defined area so we'll let's consider this non-moving a non-moving object hello so if it's not moving why do you make fun of him oh that's very funny he says you need a metal wall well they call him the lie but you need metal reeds are not good you make it out of something flimsy it's not good because water could go through the reeds guess what should bars you ever try to stop water impossible to stop water with metal especially says rashid so let's say this pond is 40 trachem so you're going to put a heats of 10th falcon in the middle and the water goes from underneath it even if the metal goes all the way to the bottom you take a nice piece of metal what are the chances that the water is not going to seep from one side to the other how difficult is it to contain water we know so then why is he saying oh don't use reeds use metal that's what's funny about it you can't stop water you need metal he didn't say if you put a piece of metal or works he was saying you need something like metal meaning forget about it doesn't work it's not going to work that's all you're saying since you need metal and it doesn't work forget about it you can't carry from one side to the other ella so why did you make fun ello miss so this is a sugar we had a number of times already in the let me you know what let me just shut this so we added a number of things let me remind you if you have a kurva and the wall down here of the corva breaks it's a suspended wall it's standing in mid air now lot cause it's not considered a wall i don't know if you could tell really from the picture but anyway that's what the picture is meant to be that the bottom right over here it's broken just holding suspended it doesn't work whereas you have the same idea by water this we added himself the shabbos that the wall is suspended it doesn't go into the lake it doesn't go into the into the pond that wall is considered a wall we pretend that the wall goes all the way down another this will have this one for sure we'll remind you yeah you guys see this a guy could build a box by his window and then he with the take the pail and put it through the boxes consider that his box goes through through into the water it's a mojito through and through why special dispensation special cula that we have by water the baby neighborhood what if the mojits is hanging both of these pictures they're hanging this is hanging this is hanging they're both hanging the first case that we showed the building that's broken it doesn't work you cannot consider a wall that's hanging in mid-air because the stones on the bottom fell out to be a makita but it does work in water kalu so then why was he laughing he was laughing because if there's a special cooler by water so what difference does it make if it's made out of steel what difference does it make if it's made out of reeds it's a special cooler so you can make you can take paper and put it above the water and we're going to pretend that it goes into the water you don't have to make it out of metal to have this special kula that's why he was laughing why did he say why did there be a secretary say oh it has to be a mechita sho barzo the first first words those words don't make sense yes you can make a makita yes the water is going to go penetrate go from side to side that's not our issue it's a special coolant and once it's a special cool it doesn't matter what material you make it out of all right we learned in the mission let's go back to the mission for a second last mission on the bottom it says like this someone who wakes up on shabbos realizes he fell asleep and didn't have a chance to make an heir of trouble he's on his way to the city what should he do say he only has four ammos okay why because you need intent you can't just say oh i can i made it uh when you're sleeping you don't have dance and you can't make you weren't question visa you didn't reside you're not residing there because you had no idea that you're that you're alive comes review let's go one line fighter is there a difference review who say four amis and rabi huda who says four almost in any direction what's the difference it seems like they're saying the exact same thing omarov here so you have a circle that's where the guy is he's in a circle he has four ammos in every direction well say that the total is eight because it's four atms in any direction so his box is this entire thing it's eight by eight packs rabbit says no pick one direction one of these arrows and go with it you can only go in one direction four atmos that's it in other words your box is four by four that's your box you just could pick in an eight by eight box to which direction you want to take that four by four but you only have four by four according to the note you take the entire four in every direction that's your box even if you went this way let's say you could go back and go this way according to everybody you didn't know if you decide to go this way now you're stuck between the red and over here that's it you can decide you could also go this way you go downwards but once you decide it's all over yes now who's this for mayor you must say this remains the tanaka who argues i when you have an argument between your view there are remains andrew glass was listening yesterday so that's it so we got i'm serious this is you have to internalize this especially in a mishna we decided yesterday well maybe that love is not like like like like that in a bryce only in the mission but it remission is certainly but the gamora studied it mama's listening there's no he wanted to know what ruby she says about this does rebecca from kensington it's great to see you we're your sons don't they also listen yeshiva one five sons the kid sir the younger one you know what i'm coming hashem to new york very shortly so we'll try to get together hashem isaac trigger the hold the whole island can't wait this is walking but carrying we know that inrushes for any riches around if you're stuck you can carry four ammos so carrying your eliminating four ammos to walk we haven't sit stay beneath you now what how much does a person take how much is below a person now you have your feet they're about a foot wide okay but there's more than that what if you lay down on the floor what area do you take up on the floor when you laid down like below you have a comment of goofy your body is three ammos six feet that's pretty generous what's very interesting that tyson says that doesn't even include your head so it seems like in those days the people are about seven feet tall it has all different caches you know a mikvah is three amis tall by one by one amma right that's a mikvah so how does a person fit into that if it's three hours tall and it doesn't include your head how do you fit into the make of us you have to bend down a little bit bend your head okay great according to tyson this is tysons rufus almost your body is three hours if i am okay they lift you up you know when a person gets up in the morning you start stretching like this so you want to give another ammo above your head just uh so you could stretch out a little bit yeah it makes a lot of sense if you think about it now i'm looking at the screen so my elbow is basically by my head and then because an ammo is from your elbow to the tip of your finger so when you stretch your stretch you're basically going another amma past your head okay so that gives you four amis and that's basically in the past below you below you means a person has four hours so remember says it's for amis comes reviewed and says you have three you'll sit up grab something from below your feet you have a little nash there a little candy you want to get up so you have your a little extra not on top of your head but below your feet um so how many hamas is that four amis so what is the mahlokis ramirez says four am so review this is four amaz it's exactly for amis whereas according to mayor it's slightly more than four ramas that's how rashi learns it over there libre i need you to ask republica question for me um these four amish that the torah tells us they had measuring tapes right had a couple of sticks over there one was sixth for so we're going to go with the standard measuring tape sixteen or are we gonna use every individual's ammo you go from your elbow to the tip of your finger if you're very tall you're in you're in the mba then you have we'll call it i don't know tenth if you're a short jew you have five talk each person it's based on on the size of his hand now this is very interesting law you'll probably all remember that story that i said over that my father sent me with the chicken how could you forget that story sent me with the chicken through her niece and careless and he told me to ask him if the chicken is kosher or not and then he said and if he says that it's kosher i should ask him if it's same thing over here depending on when he answers you i need you to ask him to follow a follow-up question if he tells you everybody there's a standard everybody has the same four amis it's exactly the same you take a measuring stick that sixth long wide and you times it by four and that's it that's what you get now otherwise known as shaquille o'neal or of our generation you gotta ignore it was way larger but you got a guy that has a 12 inch hand 12 inch right that's what we decided when we're learning the circuit of the hand somebody looked it up on google and shaq has a 12 inch hand and a 22 size shoe so what's a guy like that gonna do with a four four ammo area of a little guy he can't maneuver he can't even fit into that box it doesn't work so what is he going to say he's going to say he might tell you ref papa no each individual has their own measuring stick you take you take something you measure from your elbow to the tip of your finger times it by four and that's your backs so if you're very tall you get more if you're very short you get less and everything works out a mla so i want you to ask him my son my time electanillo now it's very interesting when we were rosh hashanah what was that eight days ago we mamish had akash baruch patting us and saying i'm here with you why we were learning about the brachas of sheban estrella on rosh hashanah on rosh hashanah it was crazy the whole suggy of rosh hashanah the day before roshana rosh hashanah a mishnah it wasn't like it was a mission that talks about rosh hashanah i said i don't think it'll ever happen again such a thing as crazy okay so here we have this is a typical thing this is this it's nice it's very nice we're going to be talking about yum kipper the mention of him kipper especially in our destroy they're going to be learning this 24 hours before him kipper we had this earlier that there are certain shiurim in the torah that are dependent on the individual what are they for instance you have the climate of the min if you have a bowl of flour for minha that goes into his bear the cayenne sticks his hand in like this and he he grabs a bunch of flour and he i need his three fingers and he goes like this and like this with his pinky but this this amount is based on the cayenne if he's a giant cayenne the milk is much larger a tiny little cayenne smaller okay then tyrus onion kipper you go like this two hands like this yum keeper and the famous malay look of yom kippur that's how much liquid are you high of on drinking him kipper is the size of your mouth where you can fill in your mouth every every person's mouth is different a 13 year old's mouth is not as big as a as a 400 pounder so i'm a mela they have different cheering yum kipper so we had to mention you could not like talking about the schmidt estrella versus what it means and why do we say unbelievable about rosh hashanah fine but still doesn't mention it's still maybe in his padding of still a path it's not a hug but it's a path fine this is it this is this is unbelievable what is it what does my papa tell them you're asking such deep questions if you keep on asking questions like this you'll never be able to learn tarot look at rashi you're not going to be able to go oh if this is the shot so what do you do with argument and this is so this is a big question on what the shiva guys do today they ask question after question and they they they tear apart every single word so the bottom line is that's to be a happy medium you can't learn a daf in 20 minutes and you can't learn to dab in three months that doesn't make sense this is we had many ravis so talks about first you have to learn the whole torah then you can go back and go deeper but here you have this idea he was asking very a very good question are we going based on on your elbow to here and if he has a shadow of it oh no you're going too much too much you're not going to be able to finish the tire if you have so many questions it's very interesting it goes and again i'm not saying that you is the way to learn it probably isn't it's great for us but maybe a daf a day if you learned the entire day or daf every two days i'm saying over from daily i'm not saying the girl from the previous generation couldn't believe how what happened especially in america it became a thing to just manage learn to dial a half a month it's crazy so much you're not going to have to learn tyro anyways it says at the end of the day we go with each individual like tonight so what are you going to ask me if each individual has his own ammo so why isn't i mentioned in that bryson that talks about the different chi europe you have a mouthful formula that goes by each individual and you know what to measure your trouble goes by each individual it says because it couldn't be in there there's a person who's vertically challenged and he has very short arms and his short arms if you're going to give him four times his short arm he himself won't be able to fit in there because his arms are this proportion of his body so it's not that he has a smaller body that can fit into four of his arms because his his his hands are so he actually has to go with the ammo of the base amigos which is sixth you can't say a rule does this there's a does the item in a cloud if you say a rule every person goes from his elbow to the tip of his finger times four it's not true somebody is short really short or has short arms as you say doesn't go with that rule mamela can't be in there says the gemara so if you remember we had this case three people sitting next to each other and they each have four atmos here this is better maybe again i don't know why the yellow it's very difficult to see the yellow but you see the blue and there's a yellow line going down the middle of the blue basically the guy each guy could go halfway into the middle but they can't go into each other so this guy who's sitting next to this guy he could go they could share but he cannot go to this side what does it say in the mishnah and he tells him rip ship says you know what it's very similar to this case instead of people you have houses and khatsu this huts are these guys from this hots are made of air if they put the arrow over here these guys from this closer put their arrow in the center as well the set the center could go to both sides each side can go to the center but the side guys cannot come around to each other yeah they don't have an error the two guys on the side don't have an area with each other that's very similar to this case the two guys on the side cannot share with each other but they could cheer with the center guy why do you have to tell them since the game why is he bringing more examples here how you doing y'all everything good yeah great okay absolutely this case of three people is similar to this case of the series that opened us why is there a big problem how come in this case everybody agrees it's okay or in this case it's a fine and this case is not good why why is this not good imaginable it says the iron there are many people that live here if you look over here each hotzer has at least two houses in order to have a hudson you have to have two houses so you have a bunch of people sharing everything and we're concerned that there's going to be confusion ha ha but we have three people so they know what to do they're not going to make mistakes so that's why i brought the case of the houses to ask the question why is it when it comes to house there's no the it's a it's a problem and when it comes to people it's not a problem so now that guimara says this far that we already mentioned when we learned it is the problem is ask the gemara if i'm going to take an a roof and put it in the center and i'm going to take an area put in the center isn't that what a typical area of kotzerus seriousness every time you have a rubicon series it means we all gather our food we put it into one location now how does that work is a partnership we all live in the same hotel we all live in the same house the same huts are how by putting our food by combining our food we're together now so then we just combine our food together it should be a problem oh my ravi huda let's remember this ravi who the night rabbi yehuda ravi huda that the guys on the side they brought their food to the center the opposite the guy in the middle brought his food to each side so therefore they don't share a common ground if the guys from the side brought it to the center they share common ground that's a perfect area of haters that's what every concert says we're all sharing but over here now he's spread out he lives a little bit on the right and a little bit on the left so he's dividing the property so let's remember of you the review that says it's the center guy puts it to the two sides right so if you say by the way if you go like review though that the the middle guy brought his area to the side that means that the other guy on the side has no connection to the center they both don't have a connection to the center so think about it no we don't have to change the shot that we thought to begin with the guys in this in the side brought their area up to the middle in the center as you can see from this picture the center hutter has two houses so this guy put his arrow in this house and this guy put his hair in the other house that's problematic so we just turned it off from the base sponsored by mark steinberg for his son he apologized he couldn't be here today he said he has to go make a paranoid living that's why i mean it's very it's a difficult time 11 15. and by anonymous so he puts it in the center in two different houses and that doesn't work come on what do you mean it doesn't work why not that's that it doesn't work this is if five people gather the era of unusual and put it into two vessels it's not a good arrow no so what's the problem with this bishop obviously if it's besham how could we say shadow according to bishop it doesn't work with shaman we have to go according to bisilla um it is a good arabs according to basil this answer there if she just said doesn't work and we go according to basel no it could go according to myself what does they still say they still says if reuben takes his area of puts it in the top drawer in the in the one house in the top drawer shipment comes and takes there puts it in the the second drawer in the same house says basil it's a good aero okay because it's both they're both in the same house if you're in the same house so you accomplish everything so what if they're not in the same vessel the two the two males are not in the same exact doesn't have to be the same house we're sharing a house we're not sharing a clique maybe they still agree that if one reuben puts his zero in this house and jim puts his error in the second house that shouldn't work because you're not cheering only we rather have available okay so we have two shatter mirror one is ravi huda nawat that is the center guy that put his arrow to the side and we have rav shashas now what they put it in the center but in different houses says mario i have a problem with this cash and the terence that what over there is the cash dealer of changes cash i have a question on both the review domain that they they put their arrow into different houses sorry what happened ravita says that the middle guy put a zero on both sides says the gemara but that's a problem why if the middle guy put his head over here so now he's a partner with this guy on the side the place that he put his arrow he's a partner with him now he's gonna go and put another arrow on the other side the key even if i'm sorry now they're partners they're one it's considered one property you hear the kasha it's a very nice question if the center guy goes to the right and he makes an arrow so now he he and the right guy are one property that's what area does then this one property goes and takes a narrow and goes to the guy on the left so now they're all partners why are they not all partners isn't the guy in the middle doing the schlichos of the guy on the right he's his partner they're buddies now they're allowed to carry in each other's hearts because i already made it now i'm going to take that partnership and buy more property buy the guy on the left and now we're all partners one big happy family that's question number one so the kumar is going to answer on this that he didn't do you see from the fact that the guy in the on the right didn't want to do it to begin with you can't force him into it he didn't want it so it's not a good schnitzel that's the gemara's answer we'll have sheisha's casio and what other rep she should say that no they both the guys in this on the side they're the ones that made their own but they made the area in the wrong place they made one guy did it in this house the other guy did another house not a good day i'll ask you if that's the case so what happens if you have five people one cutter three people make an arrow together and another two people make your narrative together is that a good partnership absolutely not no one can carry in that cutter why because a partnership means we're together not divided you just divided us you just took three you said oh the chassis go over here and the litvax go over here no that that's that's a period that's separating that's not putting together you have to do it all together says the gemara and therefore what it should be us sir now that these guys if if the guy in the left puts his arrow in this house and the guy in the right puts his area in the other house then the guy in the center shouldn't even be able to carry he just they ruined it for everybody let's see inside now what no if they wouldn't have done anything then the guy in the center at least has an error he he owns his property with his other buddy he made a but they just came in they ruined it says the gemara exactly oh maybe the gemara says something similar to what you're saying in the in the answer similar says it should be similar to the case of five people that that share a khattar and they all have to make a rubric in order to carry their own chaves in a case where one of the five doesn't make a nerve then the entire qatar becomes asur if he's there for shabbos so too over here when the guy on the left puts it in one house and the guy in the right puts it in the other house it should make it us shouldn't be able to carry at all it's as if you have somebody in this center that didn't make an arrow and if he didn't make a narrow then the guy in the center cannot use his own cutter none of your questions are good where have you the casio that what you're asking me how come it's not ashley to the right now we're buddies and now i'm going to go and make area to the left so i'm taking his das my buddy's rutsen and i'm making a on the left side now we're all partners since the guys on the side didn't make an arrow it was the guy in the center that's initiating everything gaito so the guy on the side showed him that he doesn't want to be buddies with the guy on the left why because he didn't do it he's just lazy so that laziness shows you what it where he is you can't just be lazy it shows you where his head is his head is not to be friends with that guy well i have she's just like cash oh that's similar to what joseph was saying maybe this is exactly what he was saying in fact that the whole concept of a rove is to make it better for people to make it easier for them to carry so you're asking me that when this guy on the left puts his arrow in house number one and the guy in the ride puts his house there house number two they should ruin it for the guy in the center the error is to make it good for the for everybody not bad how could you make it bad i can make a hive for somebody else so just ignore them or say that their doesn't work but it's not going to ruin it for somebody and then mellow your cash doesn't work rabboissai have a wonderful week if you're nervous troll have a wonderful shabbos if you're in america and uh there's no there's no there's no dylan at night even though right now it's during the day it's no telling now have a wonderful wonderful show is everybody voice unbelievable so when when did akashborjo decide that mrs friedman should be nifty last year no it wasn't this year mr