Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 42 by R’ Eli Stefansky

how good you are how's everybody doing that's okay ago today is a double header you're welcome to stay for two shoe room you could stay for one after the shear we are going to cut the the youtube not the zoom the zoom could stay on and then start all over i gave this shirt ready on rosh hashanah it's all about the yoimi we gave shirt on rosh hashanah the first day the second day is now so the program is we're doing daf members first and then after the shira members because today's death members just like if somebody somebody had a cash on that it's like tash lumen you know if you have to make up a shimano esre you first do my riv and then you do minecraft so we're first doing daphne bays and then we're going to do mel malef now if you haven't done mem aleph it's a fascinating duff unbelievable death it really could die to be there you were there for my mouth right you were there yesterday what that's that's the fascinating part actually yeah it's all about rosh hashanah it's an amazing amazing death but we're going to start with members now today's cheer sponsor that's it now let's go back there are four slima a person who's a big sadiq sponsors a lot of urim lurefu assay his father is on zoom all the time now he's in america but he's not on right now but it's a tremendous acid i just want to share with you no emails today share with you an ace niggler mama cheney's so in this room we had a minion for rosh hashanah the two days we only had 11 people there was a family was supposed to be part of it and uh their kid was exposed to covid so they had to be in quarantine and uh they bailed on us the last minute so not only do we have to look for people to fill in the spots but we also needed a baltic a so i told them i'm about to care because 10 years ago i once how you doing rabbi i once uh blew shorty for the middle of ello after chakras and i only made three mistakes so i said i'm about the cat i could do it's not a problem so but i don't have a shafer so i borrowed a schweifer on uh air vershana and uh and then uh we were talking about it like after my river and i said yeah i'm gonna blow it tomorrow the guy goes uh do you know how to blow yeah 10 years ago oh one of the guys like i don't think i could dive in here and by the way do you know nishima akash i was like what what's he's like you don't know that like oh this is also the kids i ran through cyranthropy pessim rosh hashanah night i go to rabbit pest and he teaches me all the alakaz outside the door and today i got here come here you sure come here come here because if i say the story nobody's going to believe it and uh so come here come here a second come right over here i'm going to ask you a question this is not prepared how many mistakes did i make today during kiosks about the mockery made a mistake he told me to to to say it true or to do a true instead of a tequila whatever zero mistake that is what we call a nice next niggler not a single i didn't have to go back on a single avi mendelbaum is going like this oh my god that my wife tells me afterwards she goes like so all these years i had to go to show for no reason you could just blow it in the hell whatever okay fine she doesn't realize that it was because of the nice the next year i'm not going to be able to blow fine zach the halo gemara will hold enough mem alive from a base a new sugya five lines from the bottom on my raf papa believe it or not all objects have at home so just like a human being can only go 2 000 almonds in every direction so too his watermelon and his shauper whatever it is could only go two thousand arms perish you busted the limit you went out of the trum and then you brought it back in so by the way all these charts that's why i'm late i apologize for being late tonight all these charts that i don't know many like four or five of them all from after meyer of tonight so i had to draw this and write this and all this stuff so excuse if they're a little sloppy whatever here's this is where you are this yellow line is the trom you bringing somebody brought the fruit over here lai mekaiman okay let's get used to this lawyer macrame it's not their place their place this is makaiman this is where the the fruit belongs the the object belongs the chair the shai for whatever is in here somebody took it out past the line and then somebody brought it right back to where it started out from what's that it's right where it started out from because says an amazing allah even if you took it out deliberately you passed the line you passed the dotted line and you brought it right back to where it came from pretend it never happened you're a big russia you were over under the button of chrome according to your bikini you ever did the riser you bring it back nothing happened my what no no you stopped why not it was here but it's not quite enough so you can't be kind of malcolm this it smoking for shabbos this is where it was baina smashes right over here it doesn't matter how long it was here it could be here six hours then you brought it back now maitaima anusem nino now we have to pretend that we learned this already in the share because we did the mishnah talks about if a guy lifts up a jew brings him out of the trum and brings him back or if his brain failed he had a meltdown a mental breakdown and he finds himself outside of the trump and then he comes back in it's not his fault because he's meshuga at the time not a problem he could pretend nothing happened so two the fruit the object was taken the the the fruit doesn't have a das somebody did it without asking him permission and brought it right back in ask the gemaro so we're going through a little bit of a back and forth here so try to hold cup here a sphere of you said by smile or a papa a question or a pup again a puppet says nothing happened even bemazed even the worst the guy is bad he did it on purpose he could still carry his watermelon in any direction he wants in the city two thousand dollars so as forever it says so this is bryce this is the first saying so there's two things that are said here number one it has to be back in the makaiman mekaiman meaning the initial spot that it left you see in blue mekaiman two conditions has to be mccoyman the initial spot and shogigen what does red papa say amazed even if you bring it back on purpose be mesid i can still carry it over here they say not repub is an amara he can't argue with them he doesn't have the power to argue with the rib nuclear blaster the twitter i'm saying you can't move anything until it's makimon back over there and shygig certainly not past the dotted line and even if you bring it back to the city it has to be beside you not amazing or a papa said amaze it well if i can find a tana that holds like rappapo then i'm good if fruit go outside the home right over here in this area it doesn't say it went back yet if it was by mistake let's say somebody else took it out whatever happened it rolled over there you could eat [Music] right over here it has to come back it went it has to come back then you could eat it now was it shige or amazing which one maybe if you're going to tell me that it happened deliberately you can't tell me that he's saying that if it came back be mesid i'm allowed to use it look it says mafoorish rabbinichamya says shygig it can't be bemesed oh so not to say that this new bryso this new where is it interesting maybe i didn't print it okay better like that i think maybe not okay i forgot to print something so you have to say that when it says in the second statement says that if it has to be back in its original spot it can't be amazing because he said before in the beginning it can't be amazing and i have to stick in a few words this is this is how this goes [Music] and that's because it's in the red light you see loy bim kaiman pass this data light is not where it originated from also uh but if it goes back [Music] and he adds and he says i argue and it has to be even if it came all the way back obviously it was over here no but if it comes back then it has to be short only and the time coming says amazing that if it comes back to the city i feel it'll be amazing who does that go according to beautiful this is a riot tour papa this is a tana argument and he says if it went and came back so i have somebody to corroborate with or a papa to say that even if it comes back if it comes back even be amazing i'm allowed to eat it the guy was over doesn't matter if it's an original place you could eat it and on that ribbon he says no you can't eat it has to be beshogging okay but at least your papa has somebody to rely on so now when the gemara says that's bad for us bad news for our papa meize perhaps no perhaps if it comes back don't worry about it it's going to get easier to suggest if it comes all the way back everybody's going to say that it's us or if it's been mazed everybody's gonna in other words puppet doesn't have somebody to to rely on and then the the question remains where did rob puppet get his idea from we're gonna go away from this eventually we're gonna go away we're gonna go back to the original step which is in one minute because we're coming to calamity pleaser if you go back to original spot right over here you go and come back everybody agrees if you did it on purpose you cannot eat it you cannot move it and therefore rappaper is in fact that soros he has nobody to rely on the whole mach lucas is over here past the dotted line out of its place if he did it by accident if it happened by accident go ahead and brought it over here could you eat the food you move the food [Music] says yes since it's not in its path it's user says the gemara oh wait a minute so right now we have a we have a big cast on our papa where did he get a sheet from that amazing climbing back over here it's okay in the second bryce at the top of memphis both of the champions number one lim coimon has to come back to its spot and sure gin it says two things you need two conditions right just so we understand there's two things going on here first of all there is the original spat and there is shaygeek as we're going to see soon tanaka holds one of these is enough so if it's in mekoima even be amazed i could move it and if it's beside even if it's shilling i can move it says i need the combination of these two things together i need it to be its original place and i need it to be a shy gig but if it's not in its original place and it's not a shogi no so in other words even if it came back to the original place but it was bemazed no good according to him i need both conditions according to the tanaka one of the two conditions is okay but the governor proves it why because rebellion says you need two things you need at your asylum command you need the original spot and you need shrug again two things why does it even mention the word trigger here if the whole argument is only whether or not to bring it whether or not it's in its original place or not original place so it shouldn't even mention the word trigger game ishari so the bottom line is that the tanakama holds that just shy gig alone even loyabim coiman so if this object got here by mistake not deliberately the tanaka holds you could use it right there you can you can move two thousand dollars you could eat it you do whatever you want because all you need is either shy gig or malcolm and if it goes back over here even be amazed it would be okay who holds like that rav papa papa says once it comes all the way back to the original spot you pretend it never happened even if it got there deliberately and the guy was over so republicans would be saying we have the tanaka that says exactly where papa said again papa said coming back bemazed if he came back with amaze that it's okay he was like because look the titanic says all i need is the place i don't i don't need mikhaime and shige mikhaima amaze it is enough and not me is also enough one of these two things is enough according to tanakama sura papa is fine all right great ishmael coming out of uh rosh hashanah i'm sure everybody has a lot of kaikas now he's trying to get me used to the fast i guess he's just you know weaning me off the water gave me a half a cup all right listen waters holding in the middle of the page as long as you're not giving me toilet water we're good he said he didn't want to give me toilet water and the only water available was there's nothing left okay a guy's walking has no idea what the troom is what does he do he doesn't have a measuring tape how can he measure 4 000 feet it's a lot of feet to measure how do you how do you do it says benigno's your typical stride one step is considered an ammo so if you are in a bra you don't know where your thumb is and you need to go and you know that you have 2 000 ammos you take you count 2 000 steps are you allowed to count ominous on chavez are you are you letting measure on javas no isn't this measuring are you letting you know like people take their foot and they go oh my foot is about a foot my shoe is about a foot they go on two and they they measure a room you allowed to do that in travis no so why is he allowed to measure why is he measuring two thousand amis anybody shot something live he knew it's not exactly so it doesn't matter but he thinks it is the mark says it's basically an ammo it's not a shoe it's a step so the answer is the ritz says because he's measuring the only time you'd like to do is the var mitzvahs he's measuring a medida of mitzvah okay so now you know what to do if you get stuck you measure 2 000 amis with your feet in the name [Music] a guy he took up residence in an open field huh i'm back the small temporary okay a crazy story a guy is in a field come to guy him they want to play like a practical joke on him it actually reminds me of murder i just i just i just i was saying i don't have any mices to say but a good thing a guy imagine this you go you know those portable bathrooms a guy goes into a portable bathroom i saw this on one of those things i forgot what it's called like those you know like those guys the the screens when i was younger a guy goes into a portable bathroom one of those green portable bathrooms he does this thing there he comes out he opens the door and there's a long long conference table and there's 30 executives around the table there's tvs and everything and he doesn't know what happened like what he he thinks he lo he lost his mind what happened was when he went to the bathroom they set down a table right hundreds of people came they set down these tables and the tvs and the screens and there's 30 executives sitting around and he just happened to walk he he went right back into the bathroom he didn't know what to do he goes back in then he comes out he peeks like what that's what happened over here the mice something like that he's sitting in a middle of the field he's open field he's minding his business and he gets up and there's a there's a thing all the way around them like a fence like why so they it's a practical joke they they basically surrounded him with michigan's so what do you do now it's better for him right because they just made it could you make merches on chavez we learned before a few times you can make it in shabbos what doesn't change though is the trom the trauma can't change his throne remains where it is he only has 2 thousand armors but he could carry until now he wasn't able to carry he's in the middle of an open field but now he could carry within his trump says the gemara viki foreign excuse the beautiful are there this is actually taken a little bit of it is taken from the uh r squirrel so this red dot is the middle of the field that's where this guy is at he's in the red dot and he has 2 000 ammos in every direction everything is great the game come and they make a blue fence all the way around them so all this becomes so now he's atlantic carrying within the two thousand dollars where before he was not allowed to carry because his middle field and he's also allowed to take a football and chuck it over here into the this area where he's not allowed to go his two thousand amis and at the at the red line but because it's within uh he's allowed to throw a ball or throw an object into this into this area he can't walk there but he could throw it there yeah understood kiwi got it oh did you learn the sugar before very good he's asking a good cash we're going to see it in the gamer in a second akiva wants to know if there's a kashashi gonna run after the ball and get it we had things like that before you see he's holding cup he's holding cup and chas what are you going to finish ass how old are you going to be when you finish us 18 years old when he finishes chas unbelievable his father's here finally covers hershanna yeah every day till next verse [Music] could throw the ball any way you want now let me ask you a question this is a very very important question if just for this question is cadet the beer how could he throw a ball from here to here when his ball we said we started off the the sugiya that the ball is like a person a ball also has 2 thousand armors so if he cannot walk past this red line how could his ball walk past the red line huh how could the ball go past the red line the ball has a schwiz also has a trom a ball could only go 2000 amps this way if it's a watermelon we said it only goes two thousand armors and if a guy will hold sugar go took it put it over here could you bring it back you can't roll it out of the trunk the answer is that it's not his it's not his ball you have to say it's not his ball it's to understand the suggest the the ball has a different drum the ball streams this way so therefore he threw it into the guy's thumb that's okay but if it was his ball it's very important to remember your your cafeteria your calum cannot go further than yourself wherever you go that's where they go virabono is nothing changes zero the fact that they built a fence doesn't give you any leniency whatsoever what does he say mahalo he was able to go 2 000 before the fence went up how much could he carry arab zero everybody gets arab amounts you could carry four hours and it was just to rob him you carry four amis is nothing four times so because you got nothing zero big fat zero from this blue fence all around zero as the gemara of the coolest ricoh why why why can't just throw it what's the big deal says because he's concerned that if he throws it then he's going to come over here to the area he's not allowed to oh so now what just happened it's very interesting beautiful thing happens here if i cannot throw a ball over here because i might come to grab it then this area becomes oscar to me midora bonon the zigzara that i might come to carry m mela what's that when there's an open area to your area that's usual then your area becomes us to carry in that's any time you have a wide open area that's completely awesome and why is this aeria austria only because of xerator abanon that if i throw it there i'm going to come retrieve it so my mainland this whole area becomes asura as well because this is open to here because it's considered as if you have a wide open this whole area this whole spot over here is completely awesome for you to carry and it's open to this area therefore this whole area also becomes awesome we had it a few times you had it like uh one example that comes to mind you have a khatsu or whatever big place and that you planted seeds over there and you can now let it walk there and because you're not there you're now walking the whole place the kits are open area is a problem [Music] big problem he says he could walk over here and he could carry over here now he cannot throw over here so what's the problem if you can't throw over here we just said if you cannot access this area and this area is open to this area then the whole thing should become awesome that's what the gamer asks this whole area should be awesome if you could throw a ball over here i understand then everything is motor to you so it's over but if you cannot throw anything any object into this area this year becomes user and because this series is outsourcing the whole thing should become awesome your assistant is you're 100 right now i just took away a thousand nine hundred and ninety six arms from you i thought it's two thousand no you only get four say the exact same thing that you get four ramas you cannot carry over here and you cannot throw over here i have proof to my rebbe the sanji give us and now we're going to be turning rabbi i already said it on rosh hashanah but we have a bran brand new sponsors we're turning to the fan base on the base sponsored by mark steinberg this is what would happen if he gets engaged this month huh well the sponsorship will go up to 20 thousand dollars my friends you better dive and he doesn't get well get engaged the day after what twenty thousand is too much i'm not done it shouldn't work it should work the following day no i don't i don't want people to have to pay twenty thousand dollars michelle it's gonna work for for me and for anonymous by anonymous guy to be yiddin all right now we're turning the tiny guy will say the sanyo hoyo de duba interesting case a guy is measuring his trom right he measures either he's measuring his steps with the measuring tape oh baba calls him he does so his home started outside of the city he's walking through the city poof and his two thousand elements are up now believe it or not he doesn't get the whole city as a freebie his trump stops wherever it stops as a matter of fact let's say he stops in this shoal in this basement and by the he has to stop by this table he cannot even go to another table even though he's indoors his thumb snaps love so you're allowed to carry in the whole city but it just says uber actually he's not allowed to pass let's just uh for argument's sake ignore the football guy maybe not the he walked he got this 2000 amis this is it right over here he cannot pass go but he's allowed to carry there if he can't pass the lines how could he carry oh what's up shot we already know the shot what throw it we're talking about throwing very good mommy tattoo lava is rico you have to say he's throwing it it says you can't walk there's a you can't even walk of course of course you can't carry so it means he threw it so you see araya to shmuel that yolada throw into this area two gear system rashi let's go with the with the gears that says here thais brings it what's going on here is that he's not throwing this direction rather he's pulling something from here into here he's pulling it what do you gain by pulling that there's no kasha you're gonna go run after it the whole problem is you're gonna run after it there's no problem ah unbelievable 86 people on zoom close to 10 people over here might say rosh hashanah 25 on youtube unbelievable he says there's a lot of dishes that need to get done that's why everybody's on zoom and they're all everybody's gonna stay for the second for the second chair as well because of that i'm sorry i gotta go it's till eleven o'clock sweetie so it's no no this is tonight because he's he is measuring measuring and he gets stuck his 2000 amis ends up in the middle of a of a cutter we can use this picture why not aimle elohati hutter he could only go we're talking about walking now he could only walk up to this line and he cannot go in here of course he can i mean his his room ends here so what's the half a minute they could walk here i would think he shouldn't be able to walk here because it's open to here he could that's also the same i would think that he could carry everywhere commercial on now texas says why is it actually different it should be us or and he gives two tea roots him over here he was his friends he was able to call him huna instead of ravuna dubois tikra oh hold on a second maybe i did have it also from uh the heritage foundation art school heritage foundation so he is walking and he's walking this way towards you see this wall this wide open wall he's walking and he hits the blue line the blue line is his throne could he go into the room no he can't go into the room but what he could do is ravuna who says you're not allowed to throw in this case in this case ravuna says you can't throw past the red line but this house he could throw into the house he's allowed to throw into the house why whatever means again to throw he himself cannot go past the red the blue line so of course he can't carry in there it means he's allowed to throw it in there my timer holyoke is this is a beautiful sign this shows me hey stop this is like a it's a surprise you see he'll realize not to run after his ball the whole akiba said before the problem is you're going to throw the ball you're going to chase it no not if there's a wall not if there's an opening so i could throw it into the into the house p think where you're even seizing me says that's what the kiva says sounds like that a little bit i don't think that means it here i also thought that in the beginning when i when i read it but it gives you a little bit we're not talking about a makitsu for the inside we're talking about a a hacker for you from the outside there have no seizure are you that you're going to in this case what's the what's that what's the problem if i throw it over here you might come and grab it you have to be concerned [Music] they pick you up they put you in another city in a snoop deer or we can use the pictures from aleph if we want to here's a deer a deer not a deer like a venison but a deer basically that you put a fence around your field and the animals they do their business here and they fertilize your field and then you just pick up the field and move it over that's a deer and a sahar is the same exact thing just it's permanent that's why you'll see this this one has grass still has grass it's nice and everything and this one is just a mess because that's where the animals live permanently so if there's a dear visit they put you in this neighborhood what's beautiful about this deer inside that has a fence all the way around it's like so they pick you up unwilling they decide to punish a jew and put them into a farm on chaves opinion that in order to be able to walk everywhere you have to be there before shabbos as shabbos goes in you can't just come into a new place and say oh i own this whole so unfortunately for him it's a terrible story what happened the picked him up and brought him there or his own brain he went mental and he went there but he only gets four hours so it's two steps over here we're talking about xavius here so if you're in a enclosed area a barn a deer and a siren we're not geyser that perhaps you're going to come to walk further in an open field and if that's the case and within that geyser one one type of walking in an enclosed area for another type of walking in an open area [Music] and therefore we're not going to be geyser throwing a ball into another area because you might come to get it you see that with geyser in this case sigma makes some sort of comparison if i'm not geyser if i say you're allowed to walk in an enclosed barn why because i'm not going to say you might in a different tomorrow the guy's going to pick him up and put him in an open field and he might walk in the open field no one thing has no there's no connection there's no connection over there says the gemara then there shouldn't be a connection if i could if i could carry if i throw a ball he might also run after it no you see that we're not going over there we're not going there over here the kimono is going to ask but what's the connection the very different stories that say you only have four ammos in the enclosed barn the gaza hill of diversity of why because perhaps they say that we are geyser we have to make zerus over there once you make zerus and you say that you should never be able to walk even in a closed area the guy might take you next time to an open area so therefore i'm glad you're in all areas and if we're going to compare open area geyser also that in this case of throwing the ball past the red line you're also officer you can't you can't you can't carry anywhere because he might go get the ball he says what's the connection you know why they made there's no connection between they said there's no reason to be geyser a barn to say this also to walk in in a closed barn because you might come to walk in an open area honey millionaires understand me saying the two very different places if i allow you to walk in an enclosed barn where is that guy this place you see hey there's walls everywhere that's why they let me walk here why would i make a mistake and confused with a wide open desert there's no reason to be avo tilto but in this case maybe i should be geyser why because it's one and close the area and if i allow you to throw the ball here you'll come to walk and get it you're not going to be able to distinguish between throwing and walking and carrying that you'll mix up so there's no comparison to and let's look at it the other way oh who said we're even talking about xavius over here dilma from the kosave kiamrin kalabhais kula karabami's dummy when do you say that entire house entire or let's say this guy if a guy picks you up and puts you smack in the middle of this when do i say that you could go anywhere you want no matter how big it is it's considered one house this is nothing to do with the xavius rocket said you have to be here before shabbos starts and if they pick you up and they force you in here you don't get that right to carry in the entire area because you want you aren't here during venusmash's nothing to do with xero i'm not it's not shot the reason why you can't carry here is because maybe they'll put you in an open desert in an open desert you'll carry no it's because there's says you have to be here before shabbos oh so if ta'ala tells me i have to be here before shabbos how could i learn from there a zero of throwing a ball they're not connected if you're telling me that this is axera and you want to compare this xerath to the throwing the bulk there you might come to retrieve the ball okay we're not really talking about xaira over here we're talking about you have to be in a place before shop has nothing to do with i was geyser because of a desert hello and we're going to be done in two three minutes i don't have a clock here i have no idea what time it is anybody oh it's behind me we're going to learn about it well hopefully everybody learned over rosh hashanah and they did learn about it but that loves the green um leo that if i'm on a boat here is the picture if i'm on a ship i get to go in the entire ship according to gamaliel the entire ship is my domain and rebecchiva and rubyshua are in a little box they made themselves a box they're in a four ammo box that's it similar to what we just had a second ago deer vasar the barn on the grass or on the mud rubber keeper gives you a box he says four ammos says you go in the entire thing so the kitzer says rav you go everywhere wherever you want whether it's a a ship whether it's a bar and a permanent barn or a temporary barn i'm calling it a barn just le saber-size bisphino says i argue on my contemporary rav and allah is like in a ship in other words i agree to rav that allah is like on the ship i don't agree with rav miyazaki everybody agrees that you have the entire ship maitaimo omarabha this was a very interesting argument with the gemara is actually going to talk about it tomorrow but think about it we discussed this on rosh hashanah the first day of hashanah mama's going to talk about a little bit it's a very very interesting shiloh if you're on a bus let's say you're on a plane go you're on a plane on chaves plane is flying over europe it's going 600 miles an hour over your it's busting the four rounds that you have in the trump every second are you allowed to walk on the plane you're not a walk because as you're walking walking over germany and then you're walking over england are you louder it's a good shiloh it's it's flying over maybe you have to sit in your seat it's doing it for you but how do you know you let her walk because physically if if i slow this down and i look at you what are you doing you're walking down at amaze you're walking outside of the right over germany yeah it's 30 000 feet up in the air still you're walking over germany you're going from city to city you walk maybe in aladdin it's a it's a shiloh here in the gemara says rabbo no what i'm looking at is the walls of the boat i don't care about the boat is going over water not over water this country that country at the end of the day you're on a boat this is your city that's it these walls and you were kind of within these walls every time you pick up your foot to move the boat already took you out four amis it's moving you so every second you're kind of new for amis you have a new area that you are that is that becomes your four ammo so to speak because the boat is constantly moving you four ammo is over the water a new four hours every two seconds every second that you move every step that you make this boat is moving in more than four ammos out of your thing so you can sleep being kind another four arms another four hours and what's the difference between the two cheetahs if it's the walls or the swara that the boat is moving you give it what if there are no walls rabbit says that the walls you're kind of these walls but it doesn't have walls doesn't have walls you were kind visa in this boat boat hey during shabbos he jumped over to another boat boat b you never coined his fees in that boat now banished mushrooms you have to be kind of schwiz according to zero that you're constantly moving so you you you always get a new four amaz so if you jump boat right if you jump over from both the boats they do it in the army that's how they fill up the the the aircraft carrier it keeps on moving and then the boat comes right next to it and they put a chain from both the boat and they go from thing i don't know if human beings do it but i know this higher it goes bad the missiles and the fuel from both the boat as it's going you know 30 miles 60 miles an hour whatever they do though 30 knots so i jump both according to zero would be fine because i'm constantly moving and i was never kind of chiseled but according to rabbah who says it's the walls that you're kind of but once you go to another boat you're not going to those walls rep the walls of a ship are not walls to fence you in and not allow predators to come in and get an oven it's not to allow water in that's a different type of wall it's not a wall of america rapoissai have a wonderful year have a great year have a great evening