Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 37 by R’ Eli Stefansky

okay and you're recording good morning raboisai today's share is being sponsored and his wife is really not doing well so the islam should have a tremendous kavanaugh revolution for out there no that's somebody else althea rahmeel benjavid is also one of the kids of somebody that's in the habura day and night in zoom and rafa where's that one oh did i throw that one out my mistake zahava bass you know what happened i printed it out and i thought i printed out small and i printed out you don't have one oh that's it okay this one sorry zahava basmatichano is somebody from kabur's wife who's not doing well sorry i apologize is that eight-year-old kid in lakewood whose father watches the shirt twice a day and she responds to your son how did it go we said a lot of time for him not not then throughout the months this uh robbie lando himself is here beautiful all right uh i want to update you this is from mark ashkenazi i want to update you with the good news that my father bench for whom i sponsored this year the other day has been discharged from the hospital on thursday they determined that ammonia is called making such an inspiring captivating experience best wishes for siberia mark we hope that you stick it out i know you started an irvine and arievan is tough but uh whoever starts an aravind is certainly going to go places it's a lot more difficult starting than to start in brachas and if you start then give special seat of the shimaya this is from simcha frid uh unfortunately no one wants to be mistaken nobody wants to join me what's going on here i have a prescription wise he says he did it he took it upon himself his first day without a phone he's telling me unbelievable he loves it right scream it out he said he was able to do more work more stuff um i i didn't i thought i was going to get 40 50 emails no it says like this simcha fred i will try the no internet smartphone challenge until shashana i'm assuming that besides news this includes sports it's listen i didn't say what to do if you take out one thing that's great anything take out one if sports is your thing take out sports watch the news snoozy thing one thing you can do anything that's toy related i will only use my internet for spiritual matters simply ps missing the giant steeler opening game tonight will be hard i get it i get it so whoever watches sports and needs to watch sports okay fine i'm just saying try something a little bit you don't have to go cold turkey in ghansen one guy one email i got how can you tell people to go cold turkey though they're going to do some other stuff okay whatever [Music] um should we do it okay you know what i'll be miss gabber we won't do this email today so that the ireland can make it to sleep for some time we are holding daf la medvement bays by 10 lies from the bottom omarav lesa le mas nissan so we had a mishna discussing breira breira is if you have two choices or you have a choice two choices the mission is discussing a person places two iron your only allowed to place one arrow for shabbos he decided to place two he's going to call out which one he wants to use on chavez depending on where the rabbi shows up or depending where the guy is coming to get him from that's called breira he could retroactively decide which one he wants to use nisin this mishna is no good is the name of atana the only time he appears in shas is regarding this that's it he rep he appears in shasta a number of times four or five times but only this is the only thing that he says i'm not going to call you out i'm just going to stand up for you but nobody knows who i stood up for leslie now if you look at the last last line in the mishnah it says that if the let's say two rabbadim showed up he could pick and choose any rabbi that he wants in other words yes breira and the mishnah says he could choose pick and choose in review review this says if the if there's one of them is his rebbe and the other one he doesn't really know he's to go to his rep he says review though but if both of them are israel he could pick and choose what does that mean yes he could decide on shabbos which one of the two are he wants to use what's the dish we said yesterday that one of the rabbeim is is rabbi mubak you think he should go to the red ribbon no he could go to the other one but what does ayui say the exact opposite of a person cannot make two conditions and then decide which one he wants to make so in other words on two tamil that show up he cannot decide which one he wants to go to and you hear what rap says because of this we have to scratch the mishnah get rid of that why maybe the mishnah should get rid of ioi so that's going to be discussed in the gemara inaudible he doesn't know what direction the rabbi is coming from but we're only discussing one rabbi two rabbis is a problem because a bravery you can't decide in chavez which one you want to go to but one rabbi you just don't know what direction he came from that's okay i think maury's gonna ask right away why what's the difference both of them you're choosing you're choosing east versus west that's also choosing who cares if it's one rabbi versus two rabbis it's you're still choosing you can't choose on you can't decide retroactively which direction you want to go to ellen come from both sides well then you can choose as the more imaginative if you have to rob bottom you can't decide the embryo because you cannot choose retroactively so too east or west is also considered choosing omar rabbi we're talking about a situation that already came the rough came before shabbos and when the guy placed his 2a rule of him he didn't know which direction but he placed it on condition that he's going to go to the direction that the rabbi showed up so mama before shabbos only one of these worked he just doesn't know it's just a hassan is the idea he he doesn't know which direction but halal it was already established before shabbat showed up that he's going to be using this area because the rav showed up on this side he just doesn't know so mama we're not discussing breira at all we're just discussing a guy that has no idea and he decided that the facts should determine which arrow works and the fact is that this rav came before shabbos this rub never showed up may mela this is the heir of this is not the heir of and that's the end of the story i don't understand something you're bringing me a aoi who only appears one time in shaas and you're scratching into the mission of rebuda adaraba lesli the mission is much stronger than abrasive why don't you just say that the mission is the correct one because i have another source that also tells me the same idea as i always says that rebuttal does not hold of the concept i cannot go retroactive in another story so i'm going to bring different cases of breira ambrera [Music] is somebody that became aguero from the nation of course in the is he a true girl or he's a girl out of fear from the lions the kusim many times they they take on mitzvahs they certainly don't take on the rabbans sometimes they ignore the missus but the misses that they take on sometimes the gumbar says that they they do it better than classroom we're talking about truma over here they don't care about truma we're also talking about before the gemaran of a desire that tells us you know how to buy wine from acoustic and if you buy wine from acoustics like you're drinking before that situation now you purchased the wine from akushi da flames now what's going on here is that you don't have a klee with you okay you're at the wine store who walks around with a battle with different cups and different uh caleb or whatever now when you buy wine you have to take truma two percent when you're done with the truma you have 98 left you have to take 10 of the 98 percent and give it to the lady how much is that 9.8 percent so you give we'll call it 10 to round it out from the 10 percent you also have to take meister cheney from from whatever is left over in other words from the 88.2 percent you have to take 10 percent of that which is 8.8 percent 8.8 percent of the green goes to mice or shiny okay now you could sit and drink the wine the problem is he doesn't have where to put all the stuff where he's going to pour the truman to on the ground he can't do that he has to give it away to the kite to the lady what is he going to do so he could pretend that he's taking it he'll just announce it that's what people here in australia do when they buy uh fruit they're not sure if the amaretts took trump some ice was they'll say mamish this kind of lotion over here he says schneid lugin channy acid he has a hundred lug so two percent which is truma right two percent two logan shani asid la hatfish in the future i am going to set it aside right now i'm drinking wine without being mafish what is that if we stop right here what is that called brero tomorrow i am going to decide which two percent it is but right now i didn't decide and right now i'm allowed to drink the wine because tomorrow i am going to be masters of true muslim maestrous so again what does he do two percent is truma asara and then whatever's left over from the 98 percent 10 percent my cereal shine i give it to the lady in red how much am i left over now 88.2 percent so 10 of 88 percent is of 88 is 8.8 fine tisha we'll just round it out says tyson's we call it nine instead of eight point eight tisha meister cheney and now i give nine mice or shiny to who to myself now here's the thing mice or shiny is for me so i could drink it right now i don't need a cleave for my sushi i don't have to pour it anywhere all i need to do is redeem it on money well i have cash i just came out of the liquor store i have cash so i'll redeem it right now here and then i'm doing i'm going to do my zuchini so that's why it says um he does it right now he's he redeems it so let's read it nicely liberated mayor period who says yes breira rebbe mayer remains says i could set it aside in my mind i don't even set it aside i say in this bottle of wine some of it two percent is like this ten percent like that another ten percent like that but i'm drinking it okay so whatever's left over at the end that will be will be my freya that's breyra i'll decide retroactively that that part that was left over oh that's the two percent that he decided should be true that's the ten percent should be miser but look at this it says ripchimin we must remember these names cannot set reviews truma pretend that you're setting it aside why because they hold an error summa law i have here a bracelet that says ambrero it says this it's a mishna twice it says it's a bryso we're talking about a bryson okay we have a bracelet that says rabbi who says specifically ambre rio we have ayo ayo the one time in chad he says ruby that says embraer and we have our mission that says rebuke that says yes breira so it's two against one that's why we knock out the mishnah not knock out io because ayo he has a good price that says okay viter ulomar now just so you're on the same page with me here's the wine store this is case number one could you zoom in on this for a second are you able to it's white i don't know i can't see it so well on the screen no here we go here we go there we go cootie wine and spirits this is the kuti wine store okay so remember this is case number one [Music] is review and i'll prove it to you from our mission our business says that review the holds yesh breira it says ambree but we just brought another proof to ayo we just brought this kusi's wine store valhalla tony robbie we lump them all together rabbi huda rabiosi and shimon say that there's nobrero he says the gemara oolo zuze zuzik tony he made them into peers he doesn't read it remember says yes he puts them together are one zug one pair zuze is a pair pair number one in other words he reads it with a vove in between he he that's how he got by tradition it's not like he's making it up now he's saying that when the brices says the names it goes like this period the period goes after the name review then fact holds yes breira that fits right into our mishnah that you could pick and choose any rabbi you want yes breira the kuti wine store holds embryo so that's two against one okay and then we have rabioisi verb shim in ice rim so we have this pair right over here named ruby icing shim and they say ambrera now the gemara is going to challenge these two right over here do they in fact hold ambrero i need to slow down a little bit it's only 33. how's everybody's day stay there vistavir rabbi ro that mama sound like knock himself that new but uh he's not here vis-a-vis oh that was the basket that's it no the sovereign of you does in fact you see hold that you cannot go retroactive was not review i completely forgot we learned this keenum it was a mishnah's only remember reuben remembers every mishna the bird went this way the bird went that way crazy it was the same pictures over and over but two birds four birds six birds eight birds goes like this a woman who gives birth has to bring two kirbanis akhata sena aila pretend she's poor she has to bring two every woman brings one at least one bird but if she's wealthy she brings a carbon also a an animal if she's not then she can bring two birds two friends met each other at the at the hospital they're gonna buy the birds together so they buy four birds two keenum a can is two birds each one has ring one can mean two birds they buy two kingdom four birds now let's say they bought a ken the ken is a hattus and aila another can hat over here is since they didn't designate it yet they bought it together they could take the one can and say both of these are katas both of these are oil that's a huge kiddush or they could say this candidate goes to rocco this one is goes to leia the bigger dish is that you can make the two you can even though they bought them as a hat sort of they can make them both katos the point is that the cayenne collator on the side whatever he wants he can decide which one of the four birds is katas for leia which one of the four birds is hottest for rocco what is that called breira you get the side retroactive what he wants who says this rebbe i see you just told me rabbi i see holds and he's certain ullah cannot say oh rabbi belongs to this zug he's in the second part rabbi says hey breira over here he says yes which is they didn't buy the birds they gave them the cash hey this year it's the shirts he could do whatever he wants now just to point out tyson says that at the end of the day according to this queen doesn't have to say this bird is for leia this bird is for rajo he could take the birds throw it on the mizbeh so what's the problem why does he need brayer over here you hear dr factor you hear the kasha says twice is because ahatas goes on the bottom a bird khatus goes on the bottom below the red line below the secret the oil goes above if it's a bird if it's an animal it's different that's why he has to decide not to who but which one it is that's going to go on top and the bottom jacket is now by the way just rashi points out that if you mess up if you're a kind and you mess up and you take the khattas of broccoli give it to leia not only does it not work for leia but it's possible when it comes to katos okay we'll let it will it won't work for for leia but it's not possible this khatas you throw in the garbage if you give it to the wrong person you do it for the wrong shem it's called that's the message says the gemara rabbah holds that we're not talking about bravery here they made atnai they purchased these birds and they said listen we don't know what's going on we have no idea all we know we have to buy four birds whatever the kind decides he will decide when he's macro of what we bought he'll decide the kenyan so it's not retroactive it's not that they bought it and then he decided he's deciding the purchase right then and there yahima is if he could decide to purchase then there's no kritish at all of course the kind could be he could decide commercial so it goes like this if i went to target and i bought with my friend we bought two cups together i paid for it and then we walk out of the store i say here you take this one i think this one happens all the time right you go to the store your friends is but it works well there's no shiloh that it works i you take the cup i take this cup everything is great when it comes to birds it's different why when it comes to birds the tyre says she decides when she buys it the woman the at the kiha at the kenyan she makes the she she decides what it is is it going to be the creation of the possible but there's another pasuk this is paraguay based but in period above it says he decides oh this is the gemara there's two times but only two times at the time of the purchase and at the time of the hakrava if a woman doesn't decide which one is khatis ayla she cannot decide once she steps foot out of the door out of the store at a target by the way i'm thinking if there was a target in there to throw thousands of more women would make aliyah territorial i guarantee you right i think that's the only one thing that the women complain about if you live in bar park you have no idea what target is costco some people have amazon and target yeah you're right amazon is awesome amazing savings i don't know i don't know if it's probably knowledge i can't even say what he just said we have somebody online that that has something to do with amazing savings okay mark mark the guy that sent the email his father he works for amazing savings but there's other things also going on okay so that's what the gemara says over here bikrita says that this that's what we want to say that the queen is the one that decides the women cannot decide once they move out of the store once they purchase it they pay the money they're locked up the only person that could decide from that point on is the cayenne commercial those birds today's da flamethanom pace sponsored by asher lila nishmasa's mother rose of basman yeoman her boy said should make it a great day and by dr listhouse that's okay so that's not a case of breira fine not a case of breira why because they just the kind didn't decide the women decided that whatever the client wants he could do he's fine but cathy sovereign yoshi you're still going to tell me that rabiose is in this category by the way you notice green is yesh it's good you go green is go red is we got to keep this uh we got to keep a certain standard there red stop ain't brero vacation omar le cover an amaritz that tells a cover something that's not in amarettos buy me a bread no that happens all the time so remember this case this is the case of a gluco here i have it in here case number two is a nam aritz and a bread buy me a bread now and it's our class is if i buy bread from an ammo or at store i or a cover must take true semistress but i'm not buying for my i'm buying for myself also i'm buying for the for the mars so let's say just example i buy two breads that happens all the time i tell my friend you're going to the bakery buy me khalifa shabbas he goes to the bakery he buys two houses one for me one from him does he know which one is for him which one is for me no he grabs two puts it in the bag when he gets to my house he gives me one challah he doesn't say oh this is ellie's khala he doesn't do that oh but when he buys it he's high even through some israelis because he just bought it from amaranth if you say that when he gives me the khala two hours later yes breira now we know at the time of purchase that he bought it for me this is the kyle he bought for me then that holly is spotted from truman miser he's not going to give us some isos for me i'll give her myself but if there's no breira so when he purchased it he bought both of them for himself later on he made another transaction he made a deal with me he went and sold it to me at my doorstep i mean that's not really what he did but hilariously that's how we have to view it he bought both of them and he had a heel to give them some maestro's and then he gave me one so what do you see from here from the fact that it says or divi ribbi rabbi says you don't have to take my sword is a raya there are yours yes by the time that he when they when the cover gives the loaf of bread to the amarettes retroactively we know which one he purchased for the amaretts even though at the time they were both in this bag all mixed up and there was no differentiation there's no distinction he decided at the time when he gave it to him that it says and retroactively we understand that's what happened since something very powerful april we know that rebeocy holds ambrero he's in this category it cannot be the rebels he holds by a gluzko yes we can't we can't understand that when it comes to a loaf of bread he said we have to flip him around him say that he doesn't have to give my sir because josh breira everybody is going to say amber we have to flip around their names tashma another case here's the case i have my shiny have ten percent fruit in my house the ten percent that goes to me the ten percent mesochina i could eat a condition that i redeem it and i bring the money to your life but i say whatever money comes out of my pocket whatever i pull out of my pocket that's the money that's going to go for the redemption that's going to be the meister shading money now right now i didn't do it yet in the future so what is that called that's called yes breira so here are the three cases we have the cousy wine store we have the gluska and now we have the money the seller sellers it's good later on when i pull out a 100 bill any one of these bills retroactive i'll figure out that's the one that i meant to be my meister cheney redemption money this is the gemara we have to flip this also this we have to flip around and this we have to flip around so that what it could match this this right over here remember allah says two of them are remembering you though two of them are beautiful schmidt he says embraer in what case did he say this that rebecca says zambrero in the kusi store so now we're flipping money and bread and we're saying rabiot says ambrera hey breira so you can match kusi wine ambrero why don't we flip koosi wine to match these guys these it says mafurus in the brightest everybody says yes breira that's pereira and say that wine is the espresso why are you flipping two to one it should be the opposite the majority should win the majority says robici holds yes breira it's just the wine store that we say ambrera says the good the continuation of this story right over here that a guy says that whatever money i take out of my pocket should be my sashini what does it say right afterwards it says and rabiose admits if he says that the money that's in my pocket is brand-new it works so if he's admitting that yes breira that means that right a second ago he didn't say israel i admit i said in the first case when it's old money it doesn't work ambrera umaida and i admit that if he said on brand new money and the commander's gonna explain what that means brand new money then it does work you could only admit to something that you argue on you're not gonna admit to something that you say it's just say rabbi says in both cases is good what's and i admit i admit means that he says hey breira so we have a case of embryo with the case of embryo by wine so it's two against one by the glucose let's flip the gluska in other words yes he does say over here yes by the by the money but that has to be a messed up bracelet and we proved it from the end of the bracelet from the fact that it says in the end of the price that it's a good it's a good meisterscheini that means in the beginning of the price it wasn't a good master cheney says gemara just let's explain the case [Music] we have another tour guide we have so many of them hashem anybody come there it's all the curry of mamesh we have a host look they're on top of each other my screen the wrong corneluth and the tour guide rocky unbelievable arie rosenstein for being here america for being here continue no seriously if you want to learn from about them are you rosenstein a guy that learns every single day has zorus about hazardous he knows count i was by a seam of his i don't remember how many he's going to yell at me if i say the wrong number thirteen fifteen i don't even know more he knows about because he does every single thing he left us and now he promises he's gonna come back for aravind and he's back and he's already 37. into it and he's still here what what why is a new coin that says oh the message changed should we call my new coin that would be i see if he has a whole packet full of money like this the espresso in that case he says so that you could decide resurrectively hindu commission so why is that different than old money old money no money ello what it means new means he only has one bill in his pocket but it says tala whatever comes out of my pocket comes out of the pocket means that he has a choice one out of a few i did underrated safe and amitabh okay we're just using the same language as we said in eurasia but twice is asked whatever money comes out of my pocket that 100 bill i have in my pocket if it comes out that's the only one that could come out there's only one in there so of course it's going to be my zucchini says tyson's top line i would think that i'm a geyser for a case that is three four bills and that this doesn't work you have to hold it in your hand commands when it does okay omelette revelation unless librero so who's the tana that says that there's no breira no brayer at all even in the rabbana i can't say brayer i can't go retroactive the sanyo rabboissai this is the bryson discussing the world's greatest control freak the sanyo he points at his five friends and became some i'm making an arrow on any one of you that i decide if i decide you're going to go you're going to go you're not going to go you're not going to go mama sugar to this guy wrote something about yo meru vegeta if he figures this out before shabbos goes in it's a good a-roof what's in here of the rabban over here it says ambrero because he says once chapus goes in he doesn't have the right to retroactively decide which area of it is no that means a breira if if you hold yes breira so i could retroactively decide on shabbos and continue to be a control freak in the side uh shimmy could use it no ruben can use it ishtik rav nachman was quiet to rava again we had ravi yesterday also boy revealer of nachman i don't know i i have to do a search because you can't really do a search although it says only revelation how many i don't know hundreds of times that rava s his rebbe river in chance you didn't know didn't know is the one that decided his one time in shaas that he decided that the mishnah that says yes he says embraer what's our mission we're even talking about which is the rabbana so here we have a tana called who says even on the rabban unlike an ayrov this is immoralism never heard of the never heard of rav this there's a thing in the gears here who it is exactly um i forgot to look but i know that the marshall whatever takes it out maybe ribby i see i don't know ravioli are you getting rid of all the tanai what do you mean tanay there's more than ayo yeah now the guy is being a control freak on himself not on his friends and himself i'm going to make an era of for every single shabbos of the year rotisse he realizes his friends don't listen to him so now he's controlling himself oh i'm going to tell myself when to go and when not to go see a declaration if i decide that i want to use it i'll use it same exact thing if he's if it's khal before shabbos great like any other if it works mr kasheko once shabbos comes in nothing doing in other words ain breirro so the tanaka says ambrero listen to this this is a big bomb here rip shimmy oy man hey rube rip shipment says yes brero big big problem oh reboy so we're gonna do in the category of embraera who's on the rib ruby i see rob shimon rip shimon says ain't breira we just we just finished up with the rubio you see does he have all the experience we did a bunch of aprils and now we have a problem with rip shimmin because you said allah says the shipment holds ambrera and over here it says mafurish that a person could decide on shabbos whether or not azerive works whether or not we go retroactively in this side it was the area of banishmashes that's called yeshbrera and say hey and the gemara is going to bring four very simple terutsum terrace number one is our favorite apoc flip the names around him are the ones that say yes brera is going to say or in a rabbanan like an arrow rib shaman will admit yes breira that was the question before can we differentiate between the rabban under there right so here she will say before when we're talking about wine in a store of acoussi we're talking about trumas and mice risk a day riso but over here not and then we have two more shot them that wine is different why wine you cannot see where the truman is it's all mixed up into a battle so there's a special halal controller that you need the fourth shot is wine as a problem what if you drink this wine because you're assuming that you're going to take truma tomorrow and then the battle falls on the floor and explodes you are going to be high of misa for eating devil retroactively because you never took it through some stress that's the concern shema boca hanoid let's see it inside really easy stuff says the gemara and this is where menachem gets nobody told them to live 25 minutes away from the show we just said in in in wine wine we said he he holds embraer kashi the shimon evershim it's a contradiction we got to flip around rip shim and she though that's shot number one my cashier shot number two duma que lesler shimon breve rip shipment in the wine store which is the right to take truma he says embraer there are a bottom by a roof it's like he holds you could go retroactive the resolution of islay uh it doesn't matter if it's at the rise of the rabona he'll hold the ashbrero oh man the lesser ribose holds you can't no you have to take a sheet and go with it through and through whether it's the rice the robot no matter relation with the robot on less lay now rather too simple shot them what is the difference between a roof and wine why we said embraer racist it says in the past racist when i separate my truma i need to be able to say oh that's my trimmer right over there says the gemara founder of whatever person is holding in front of him to fruit and he makes a funny try he says if it's going to rain today the one on the right side is going to be my triumph this will be the truman but if it's not going to rain today the one on the left will be the truman i can't differentiate they're both the same they're right here it's not surrendering you can't say that this is true and if you'll say yes i'll prove to you from a mistletoe says rash he should have jumped right away to the mission why does he bring this case that he made up he's looking at a pile of grain and he says this right over here in the center should be true um first you take trauma then you take truma smizer or you take myself and then you take turmoise myself right so the truman and the mysore should be right over here um who says embraer here he says kara hashem it's perfect it works it says the gemara that's not a good writer from there shannon has five he's pointing over here this is where i want my truma guess what all this over here is not so it's very it's distinguishable this is truma this area is not a battle of wine it's liquid it's all mixed up in there you can't distinguish anything another shot now we're going to shot number four we're concerned wine is different maybe it'll explode you're not concerned that the wine is going to explode and then it comes out that he never were able to take troublesome stress and what you drank yesterday was complete tevel mesa omelette i'm not worried no if it happens once in a blue moonlight and i'll worry about it then think about just just to finish up ulamai the salga died to me card to being a racist but according to chat number three we said that by wine it has to be distinguishable so then how does it fit in he says they they said aren't you concerned about explosion an explosion and he says no i'm not concerned about explosion but how does that fit in why it's like anatomy card demeanor registry or any karim you said the whole concern is it needs to be distinguished so what are they telling him about exploding what does an explosion have to do with being distinguished mike emily we hold that the problem is you cannot take troublesome mysterious retroactively because it needs to be distinguishable where the tumor is and it's liquid and it's all mixed up you don't hold up that you don't hold this whole positive relationship with russia i'll bring you another kasa but there's another issue what if it explodes and then retroactively you're high of miso you believe what's going on here i had all suda i drink wine everything was perfect and then all of a sudden retroactive i'm kai of miso the next day i find that i am afraid if that happens i'll worry about it boys have a wonderful day sheer hamaloise know