Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
good morning today's share
is sponsored
amazing one here this dedication is
honor of my son mayor's
10th hebrew birthday from anonymous
mayor ben rifko basha
is my hope wish and prayer that the
source of this dedication will help him
succeed in this critical step in his
life as he will start to learn gemara
this year
every year is important all right so
this one is amazing the second one
i see this this morning oh oh i could
look over there give valdic
sponsored by the saka family
in memory of their beloved mother bahia
bachmual
becky today's your second yard site now
i don't know for sure it's a very small
world i'm pretty sure
that they're related to me somehow my
wife's first cousin sv friedman married
becky saka
guys salim you remember salim came to my
house many many times
salim that he has a salim
slim and then avram just had a wedding
the other day
so they related so it's a very small
world the
three freeman from detroit the kids sir
all right i think it's the same family
from uh miami
i never knew that they watched the shirt
i'm assuming they watched the show
no oh what's this no
it's my cousin it's he's their
son-in-law
all right boys listen to this this one
is from david brandes i love this one
good morning rebelli double brand is
from south bend here i haven't emailed
in quite a while but bar hashem be
keeping with the share
i want to thank you for everything you
and the crew are doing throughout all
the challenges we have had to face this
year we are now holding right around
where i dropped off last cycle
and i'm glad to say that this time
around with the share i'm holding much
stronger with no signs of slacking off
i enjoyed my wrist charge on the flaming
base and attached the t-shirt idea
for mdy to add for the merch section
it's amazing her voice i love this this
is gaval dig this is going to sell
thousands see this
i don't know if you can see it says if
you do the daf
former amaritz
skip valdec all right
so thank you david that was great um
it just it needs nikuda's well we'll get
it we'll get it
oh you know it would be cool if you put
the niku this also under the english
four mil yeah whatever
that's really that was a little risque
taking that
off the internet like that i usually
have permission that one i had to go for
it
with your share shh don't tell it with
your share may we
maybe may we there be many more former
amiritsim
wishing everyone likes david brandes wow
here's from our good friend pressman
you guys know pressman he presses the
issue
for the magic show this morning all that
was missing is a top hat wand and a cape
not your ability not getting creative to
maintain my attention is more than a
million dollar picture book it's prizes
even considering
you had to try twice to spear the apple
i'm just wondering hoping that there
will be more demonstrations forthcoming
considering your announcement the other
day
there will be a big break from showing
charts well what it doesn't happen is
that
that week that was a week ago it's over
charts are back today
as much as i enjoyed the show and i
really did i hope it's not that
expensive of
i think it means gearing up here for the
huma share
so we we so eagerly wait
it's fourth coming initiation answering
hashem not going to happen this year
if i don't write again before shauna
please accept this as a special broker
for a new year
massive albertson's toyota minute for
you and your entire family you should
ask felix that if something needs to be
catchy and needs to spread like wildfire
next year it should be your share
and not corona or maine but because
do we have time one more quick one and
here
dear valley thank you for all your
favorite especially like the live
demonstration
on the tv yesterday i really look
forward to listening to your daffy
stream i hope that we get to see more
demonstrations soon
you tell me
also not going to happen that often
maybe i actually was
trying to do one for today it's like
it's impossible too much
too many of these guys too many charts
all right
so yesterday today is that gimmel we're
holding the
llama bay's lave the the children the
lathe of the sheer
so daflam bay's omud bayes
has a mission that tells us that if you
put an a-roof on top
of a tree if the tree is tenth fahem
the a-roof is no good and if the tree is
less than 10 fahren
then it's okay now what do we say we
said
is and said oh
this is such a great shot me we said
this
we stuck it into the gemara became part
of the gemara that what we're talking
about a tree that's in russia's herabin
and the man
is on the rochester raven he's on the
asphalt
the trees above and let's say we're
talking about the case that it's less
than 10
the issue is how could he retrieve the
aerovanchabas
you're not going to take something off a
tree the answer is
because it's only they're abundant to
take something off the tree in javas and
we're only talking about a very specific
period called venashimashi's
as long as the area of hal banashmash's
then it's a good area to go we don't
care if the air disappears after shabbos
comes in
so at that point the chavis comes in
baina smashes you're permitted to take
something off a tree
because it's a suffolk it's sufficient
sufficiently let's manage muscles
so to drive a car you can't drive and to
move something from
surrounding you cannot but to move
something off a tree which is only is it
there about on it
that's permitted mma that's a good error
of
oh my rava comes rava and drops an atom
bomb here
loishano
10 lines from the balance say four six
eight nine lines from the bottom
[Music]
this whole thing that we just discussed
is talking about
here's the city here's the
the iburu shillier ibura from a lotion
of pregnancy
every city is allowed to be slightly
pregnant seven months pregnant 70
ammos and a third right we had a 70 and
a third from
the the hotter
so that's all considered part of the
city all this is considered part of the
city
so this is considered so the whole
shiloh is you see this tree
this tree is past this dotted orange
line here
it's past the iburu here illinois
there's no there's no problem
this is a great a-roof the masa
commander malidami
this is unbelievable thing he says
that an aero that the entire city
is considered as if it's full we pretend
it's
ryan it's ki-ilu remember the lush and
ryan we
we we imagine as if this the city is
filled
to tenth faccum everything is full to
tenth
so mama he when it comes to the halakhas
of aerov
he's on top of tenth falcon he's already
with the tree
with his arrow the whole issue is that
he has to be kind of swiss he has to
have a place on shabbos he has to settle
down as the take up residence
with his aero now he's on the bottom
he's on the asphalt
and his area is on top so the area of
his apostle it's not a good area because
he can't get to it but you know what
he's in the same area as the era of why
because we pretend
that everything is full till 10th
there's a bunch of dirt they
came with a
halachic dump truck and they dumped a
bunch of dirt 10 fahrenheit and he's
standing on top of the dirt
now if he's standing on top of dirk
could he reach over and grab that area
of
absolutely not the arrow is in russia
and he's in robin but in terms of
halakhas of ayr of him being in the same
area as azerov he's considered as he's
in the same
area why because the city is completely
full
it's full of dirt and he's he's within
that he's in the same area as
is arov that's robert's bomb
now i have a riddle for everybody think
about this for a second
why in the world is this guy putting an
aerov on the outskirt of a city
you see if you live here in the city you
get 2000 amaz
from the city limits starting from this
orange line so what did he gain by
putting a roof right here he gained
nothing
if he wouldn't have put an arrow he
would have the same amount of 2000
albums
he could walk 2 000 almost from this
orange line
going that way away from a city without
an arrow
so why did he put an arrow
orange line is 70 arms from the city
it's considered part of the city you're
allowed to walk
two thousand dollars from city limits so
he's gonna walk from this orange line
two thousand
uh anybody have an answer no okay razzie
addresses the question
one foot away so he's he's making his
ear for one foot
so let me tell you i'll tell you the
answer and then you'll understand the
question once you see the answer
very very simple this individual doesn't
live in that city
he lives in a different city he lives
over here
and this city i just made this picture i
put it together
so excuse if there's any problems here
so it's within alpa mama so let's say
this city from this city is let's say a
thousand hours just to make everything
simple
so he lives over here he's allowed to
walk a thousand i'm into here
once he reaches this city he's let it go
the entire city because that's
considered one
trum oh and now he puts his arv over
here so that he could go with another
2000 amis from this city
he wouldn't be able to go 2 000 from
this sea because it's not a city
okay just the simple shot in the gemara
why does he have to put a
why does that have to put an arrow okay
let's keep on moving
is on today is he doing the the charts
yeah okay
good luck because there are a lot of
charts and there's some charts that are
not
on the drive if you want to look up i
have heike kim from daffodil aleph
i also have from shabbos i don't know if
you have shabbos we have the algolos
over there
if you want to look that up shabbos
memphis and from davidolf
anyway sorry i didn't give it to you
before oh he doesn't even have it on the
pitch so
it's not okay says
so what does robert say robert says
there's an afghana if um
in the city limits i am unluckily
standing on a mound of dirt that's 10
fahrenheit because the whole city
is as if it's 10 fahrenheit tall you see
these imaginary walls there
everything is imaginary so everything's
filled up to ten i'm on ten
so what if i place my arrow on top of
ten but i'm in the same domain i mean
i'm above ten with my arrow but if i'm
past the orange line
or orange line anyway you wanna say it
then
it's not a good arrow asks the gemara
why
are nami even if you're outside of that
limit kievan amarava let's take rava and
put him against himself
hanoisen look at this beautiful picture
i don't know if they meant for this but
if you look closely a person
wherever he resides wherever he takes up
residence he gets four amis you see this
imaginary box here everything's
imaginary he gets
he's within his box and where does the
rashes go
all the way up to the sky he has an
imaginary sayaka around him
so goes up to the sky so he's in the
same domain as azerov so who cares if he
puts his heir of above 10th fachim let's
say he puts it above 10 fahim he said he
can't reach it because it's
and his feet on he can't grab it baines
mushrooms
but he's in an imaginary box it goes all
the way up to the sky so in terms of
hilche's arrow he's in the same domain
who cares if his feet are on the ground
he had luckily he's in the same domain
could he could he carry it on chavez no
because he's
but in the same in the same domain look
he's in this box
his even if his air is on top of the
tree and he's on the bottom look they're
in the same imaginary box
it should be perfectly okay for an era
of
says the gemara you're 100 right if that
was the case you're right
what is the case here differently we
have a little problem with the branch
the branch if you're looking at this
picture extends past the box
so you cannot reach it it's past the box
where he puts his arrow
is outside of the box he thinks outside
of the bag you put it over here
um
we're talking about a tree that its
branch sticks out
further than four ammos that's why you
can't get it
so the scavenge and he meant
to reside and take a presidency or
residence
on the bottom on the on the ground
so above your face is considered
below yutfachem is a carmelus
so mela it's a good area of why is a
good herb because from a caramelise i'm
allowed to take it
off the tree i am not allowed to use a
tree
but
and we're good now he could move it
pakistan's medallion even if it's
so the the is over here
outside of his box how could he
potentially move it over here
by moving it less than four four
amas because it's only in a caramel so
you gotta move it along less less than
four hours five
one is on top one is on the bottom
explains rashi beautifully
if it's like this picture which is not
so accurate sorry
and i'll show you why i think the other
picture is more accurate but i think the
art school went with this picture as
well
sort of and i'm not so happy rash
explains
that if we're talking about one branch
that goes horizontal
then it doesn't make sense to use the
lashes
it's high and low it's not above
and below it's high and low it's one
branch one is higher
up one is lower down it's one branch
de la mala is referring like to two
floors to two
to two areas ah says the gemara
the hader zakif the branch takes a wild
90 degree angle turn
mma it go and it shoots right up so
here's
here's a good picture i believe
this is all within under 10th fachem
and it's nice and horizontal and then it
takes a 90 degree angle upwards
so now i have a lamala and alomato if i
put my bread
up here it's lamallo if i put my bread
down there on this on the first floor
it's la mato
second floor is lamallo but if it was
just one single angle like this
it doesn't make sense to say la mata in
la mala it's not below and above
it's high and low yeah you mask him in
hebrew that's how it would work
it's romero's masculine i think that's
the
rashi anyway so again
we're talking about a guy has you see
this dotted yellow line this guy
has his makhan visa the bread
is outside of his of his makkah it's
past the dotted line
it's on a branch that's outside of four
amish and therefore if it's above
tenth face he cannot get to it why can't
he get to it
because he's down here below
in rochester abbott and this is a
russian
so he physically he cannot move it from
him
from into the rashos
and yeah from the true
why not what's the problem
you're right he can't go downwards he
cannot go
from russia up here into the system
that's a problem but why can't he move
sideways
let him climb up a tree paint a smosh as
we're talking about
this is all happening management when
the area of israel let him climb up a
tree
and let him move his khala you see the
khala right over there let him move it
sideways
towards like the the bark of the tree
what is this called
the trunk of the tree thank you the
trunk of the tree
and all this is a yucker over here
what's the problem
what comes up with the trick
how could i make this branch or surround
is it possible that luckily for me all
of a sudden on this street
in particular to make this branch versus
around yes there is a way
what no
if people use this branch to unload
their loads as they're walking by which
are available rabbit mechatronic this
branch turns into original surabam
so says the gemara if that's the case
it's awesome for me to move a
bread from here to here because i'm
passing by irish
arabim right over here robin mccarthy
catholic
let's see the cash inside and it's a
very interesting picture but this is not
for perverts
for whatever reason the graphic designer
decided to use
a yellow dotted line i'm not exactly
sure why
so don't use your imagination here
why can't the guy get his collar and
come from over here to over here
yeah these chiva blocks are driving
right now with you israel ghosting to
the mountains
turn off the radio
but anyways here's the point that's the
point you see why can't the guy grab the
khala and go this way
says the gemara
[Music]
what happened was that the tree branch
i mean he could have used blue red other
colors i think he was trying to yeah
okay whatever the guys put their stuff
down
on the branch down here and the mail of
this branch becomes a
surrounding we're talking man in such a
situation
situation if you don't have the
situation you're right he can move it
this way to here
and the melee cannot move from here to
here why can't you move from here to
here so if you remember mr
chavez we learned the the sugya of the
agolais
in the midbar they used to transfer
the wood the beams of the mishkan from
one
wagon to the other wagon each wagon is
considered
but between the wagons you have this
area that's a russo-sarabam
and mela it's us sir to transfer
something from ursula sayaka to
in the middle and that's why in our case
you would it would be awesome for you to
transfer
your aerov your your bread from this
area to this area
if there's a ceramic in between now this
doesn't count this was wrapping because
you were talking about the branch over
here
and this branch turns into rosh hasha
rabbit
zog
[Music]
if he he could transfer it
above the tree sideways why does he have
to go downwards into the register of
him
[Music]
kiss your rabbit may catch him all of
because many people
unload their loads on it
from allah we had this a number of times
if you have a bean that's nine
fahrenheit
nine is not usual and three
is too low it's part of it but if you
have a alma that's nine
and we said over there i remember now
that we discussed i think some
restaurants has to be exactly nine it
can't be
a little bit less or a little bit more
but mama's line it can't be eight
viral because it is too low also it's
not so comfortable if you're having cats
a lot of people
adjust their knapsacks on it
and you threw something in the landing
over there there's a mamas
on that tree okay
now we discussed yesterday and we
started off this year
because nobody uses this tree how many
trees do you know that people
unload their burden on it most trees are
not like this this is a very specific
case
one in a million trees in the world that
happen to be a middle resource
and because the branch is so low and
it's nine dog people
use that branch how many trees do you
know like that in the entire mapping
service is there a single tree that has
a branch like this
so talking about a very specific case
that you go from
the verb that's why the arrow is no good
otherwise it would be okay because i
could just grab the arrow
and bring it over into my four amis
domain
no you don't have to
you could if you could get it there then
during finish monsters i had the ability
to do it and email it smoother
i don't have to do it all this is
theoretical
i if you could do so and so then it's as
if
the arrow is in my domain the whole
gemara's answer is that there's a giant
branch that goes
on a horizontal thing it's mama straight
then it shoots up 90 degrees
you're talking about a crazy case and
that's why
and it's outside of your four amis such
a giant branch that's outside of your
mouth
and that's why it's not a good area but
i have a way that it could be a good
area because i could climb up the tree
and grab it
no it's talking about that it's it goes
four hours this way
it shoots up at 90 degrees and people
use it over here
and then melee that's why i can't use it
in that crazy case
says rava that this is not a good heir
that's it
it's a it's a heck of so we said
yesterday
that we have to move we have a very long
daf here
and we're actually running out of time
says the gemara i know
told noam this morning i guarantee you
even though i didn't hear the
conversation i wasn't
i could guarantee you one set to the
other i guarantee you ellie is going to
mess up on the timing
he thinks it's a short dive and i know
how these conversations go every single
time
anyway right tell me
you didn't say it okay
something that's obvious it's not okay
forgiven
yo tabasco i'm right to given anyways
doctor gamara
so we decided according to rebbe
you're allowed you're permitted to do
something
i don't know who said that what's that
no okay
we gotta go we gotta go it's already 41.
20 minutes to do
a almond and a half so yesterday we
brought down ravi we mentioned today
that rebbe holds that if this is the
robot on
banishmoshes you're permitted to do it
so let's say taking something off a tree
moving your aerial off a tree
banishmashes is okay driving a car in
chavez banish
on banishment's officer take something
off the tree management mutter rabona
say it's a sir
therefore this tree that's below tenth
fuchem
is not a good aero because you had no
right to move that aero
or move it to you and eat off of it
my rebbe my rabbanon where is this
mahlike is the sanyo
nissan ilona
again if you put your this we're just
repeating the same
case that we had before you put your
arrow on a tree
above tenth what kind of tree
this kind of tree
that makes a turn and goes upwards and
you put it over here on top
it's out of your fourth out of
before amis why because if it's in your
four amis
then you're in that bubble that we said
is okay
the if you're if the air was within this
bubble it should be okay according to
rava so it has to be
outside of the bubble okay just bringing
it up again
that's the sugar you just learned
on chavis you're not going to grab the
khala right off that branch
you see this low branch right over here
it's lower than 10 it's a good arrow
but you're not going to take the challah
why
because you're not allowed to use a tree
in chavez so why is it a good arrow
if you're not allowed to use a tree in
javas you can't get the you
because banished mushrooms you couldn't
get it banished mustard you're allowed
to and all we care about is banana
smushes but now practically speaking
you're you are hungry on chabas it's a
great area if you're hungry and choppers
you want to grab the challah could you
eat it
no cause you're not allowed to touch the
tree in chaves you're not going to take
something off a tree in japanese either
so it's a great aero just you can't use
it besides
if it's so low to the ground this branch
is so low to the grounds within three
it's as if it's sitting on the ground so
then i could take it that's not a
problem
nissani because what if
you put the bread inside a basket here
we go
here's a basket you put the bread inside
a basket
with laura
okay so here we have the idea
that banished mushes if you could
do it is we mentioned before it's a good
area of
if and if you can't if you hold you
can't do it on banish mushrooms not a
good area of
now we're talking about the case of a
basket so he puts
his bread in a basket on a on a tree on
a pole
now throw out a statement
anytime you're not going to move it it's
not a good idea
where where exactly what are they
talking about if they're talking about a
basket
that you cannot use this as an aero
layma cassava abundance
this doesn't mean something that's
attached to not part of
i'll remind you there's a tree that had
a peg
and you put your ladder on the peg so
it's not really touching the tree
it's touching the side of the tree
that's done in the tree and there's a
macholicas asar mother
we pass can us as the gemara from here
is a good raya that's
also abundance say you can't use this
basket because it's touching the tree
it's part of the tree allah airasia so
we must be talking about
our case that the tree branch is lower
than tenth
and say what i'm saying the case that
the tree branch over here
right over here what i'm have to say
about this case i put an arrow of below
10 fahrenheit
no good you know why because during
bananas moshe's i can't access my bread
because this is the rabbanan and it is
there are bottom according to rabbana
you cannot do banish mushes
so i can never access the bread as i'm
making the heir of ayurve is no good
says what kind of tree are we talking
about
eat the lesbian if the if this
beam let's say this doesn't look so wide
it's not fourth wide
anything less than fourth wide
it's not um
it's mma love making tour becomes
bottle to the roshusa rabbin
in fact it's a hundred percent mutual
there's no even is there a bundle we
learned
if a guy's on a scufa if a guy is like
on some sort of
uh porch that's a making tour it's the
hair
it's not it's not a resource so i'm
permitted to take something out of my
house
and put it on the porch somebody else is
allowed to take something from the
traffic put it on the porch we just said
don't be
don't be able to go and put it on the
portion and go to the side and take it
off
that's uh but it's multi to put
something on the okay so making tour is
not a
we're not talking about a mukbang tour
because this tree would be part of the
raven and it would be a good aero when
does it become a not good arrow when
this is
and you're standing on him then i can't
i can't access i can't move it
from there and then it's not a good area
but if there's a mockingbird i could
access my arrow
perfect beat this ball
so let's say the tree has sport
so what did i gain by putting in a
basket i put it in a basket so it's
just a rabbit it's like holes in it
so who cares if i hung it in a basket
just because it's all the way at the end
of the suggest so let me just say real
quickly so we have some sort of
reference to what we're going to say
the last tires in the gemara the last
thing we're going to learn today
beijersham is
that this is yes but i want to
tilt the basket into the rabbit area
you see this peg over here so i can move
my basket downwards
so i'm going from from into register
that's one turret
says gemara omra vino
rachel
two lines from the bottom
you're right the first part is talking
about
that we're we're four fourth say
for this
this case of a basket the let's be our
ball
the tree doesn't have four they call
them
you see it's a very nice picture the
basket is curved out
the tree and the basket together equal
fort falcon
it's a beautiful beautiful answer why
so today's turning of the daf
sponsored by asher leelanen's
make it a great day and by dr listhouse
the doctor was his father
is joel bergman online anybody see yo
bergman it's not like
okay fine not for today says the gimbal
so we're talking about uh
now we're not done with the answer it's
a beautiful answer vireby saw our law
rebbe must hold of two big cheetahs
savada curry mayor we had this
throughout chats we had it a number of
times and i'll remind you inaudible we
had this case
of
on a door that has uh an arch to it
so the answer is if it has tenth falcon
and it's fourth wide in addition
to the arch
then you take this circle and you
pretend
it's nice and square and i put a mezuzah
here
that's where mayor sheet of khaikhim i
pretend halal
that it's carved out you carve it out
like you give me a carve out
oh so mama says the gemara i'm carving
out here what's going on i think this is
the shot
the bottom of the basket well the top of
the basket has a hole in it
it's not a surface if you
hold that you need four tahim you have
to put your air on a fourth
surface that's a special sheeta rabe
so the number one is that i i need
a four surface but i don't have
a fourth service why
because all i have is let's say 2120 for
a tree and a
and a gap just a hole in a basket that's
not a surface
so what i need to do is use the bottom
of the basket the problem is the bottom
of the basket
lines up with the tree and the tree is
not hollow the tree is solid over here
so here i do i pretend there's no tree
over here i chop down the tree right at
this red line
there's no red line in that picture
because i did it afterwards with the
magic marker
so the live guys have it you don't
oh no they do so there's a line here i
pretend there's no tree here and now the
basket
and the tree a line up and there's a
fourth
surface where i could place my heir of
review the whole dini for
and remember hopes i could do the
concept called together a combination of
yuhu the remainer
i have a fort tafa surface huh
so remember the actually i use the slam
dunk
it's probably the wrong picture but i
hope i printed that one
i knew i didn't do it okay
you know what i have an idea maybe i
could go to my computer real quickly
sorry guys because i believe it's i
believe i took it out
just i didn't and even if not yeah here
we go this is good hold on
you guys will be able to share my
computer screen okay for when i need it
says the gemara it's a beautiful picture
i don't have it
there's too many too many things going
on this morning
review the dharma being an area of agape
above so
together with review that holds and you
need four and together through mayor
that says you could carve out
i have a perfect idea veleko
here a guy puts
a little pole here
but on top of the pole he has the proper
surface area he has four by fourth
but the bottom is a stick the bottom is
not the perfect area
what do i do says
if it's tenth high and it has
the surface area it's a great arrow
vim live a rouve and if not it's not
a good arrow
so if it doesn't have then it's like
hanging in the middle in mid-air
says what are you talking about
let's say this this this little stick
doesn't have 10 fahrenheit so where is
it
it's below 10 it's eight falcon
let's see this thing
so where is my heir of now in rochester
and where is this man standing ira
sister adam it's perfect
that's a perfect day room you're in the
same you kind of swiss in the place of
the here of the name tourist
is the one who shows the only problem is
when it's above 10th falcon that
it goes into say what are you telling me
if it's below 10th falcon it's a problem
that's not a good idea of the opposite
but low temp is beautiful it's a hideous
that above 10 fahrenheit is a good aero
and why is it a good idea of taka
because
we have rubber's bubble your
area goes all the way extends all the
way up to the sky even though your feet
are just around but your
rava gives you a four amaz area and
those four arms extend to the sky so
you're you envelop that arrow if you're
both in the same area could i grab it
off that pole
no because the pole is just a rabbit but
i'm in the same area as my arrow
but if it's below says the mario right
we're not talking about the height we're
talking about the width
govaya asaro shiba roshar ba
by the way rashi brings here that it's
like this boat that we said
that even though on the top you have
fort falcon but on the bottom it becomes
narrow
no good you need the whole thing to be
fourth through and through
it's a very sharp now if it's
above 10 it's problematic so then i have
to say
it has at least fourth fuchem surface on
top
en govayasara you're right ain't sorry
showerball
then we can invoke sasrashi kuluto
kimisho
damio remember we had the childhood i
think it was
i don't even remember it was maybe
rebecca sounds familiar don't quote me
on it
if you throw something does the ground
catch it in mid air as if
but that's not what we're talking about
here we talk about it even more we're
talking about
there's a challah with intense falcon of
the ground not above
below so the ground grabs it the the
asphalt grabs it
it's as if it's laying directly on the
asphalt
fine says the gemara
command the like this we do we carve out
and it's not just
vineyard barracuda trasco if a person
puts a beam
this this case right but there's a
better picture i believe
what yeah but the slam dunk doesn't work
here
i might have been wrong in the slam dunk
and i'll show you in a second lasagna
review that i didn't want to bring it to
not confuse dialogue
no it's kind of just around this is the
sugar we learned and i brought a
basketball hoop from the you know the
original game maybe it was one of the
first basketball games
so there's a conversation around him and
there's a hoop the whole thing remember
that
vinnie averages he put a basket on top
and the the original basketball game
bizarro and he's throwing mamish they're
throwing things into the basket in those
days also
and it landed on top this 9mm guy
whatever his name was the guy that
invented basketball
he also had a problem he had a basket
and they used to have a ladder
and every time they threw it they made a
basket they had to climb the ladder and
take the bat until they realized wait
i could put a hole in the net okay but
that's what happened
landed over there like the original
so affilotemo says the gemara it's very
different affilotemora
suburb hassam hadron
that's why i wanted to show you this
thing here so the kamara understands
here i'll just go like this
just ruin it here we go
could you zoom in
it's not bad not bad here we go so the
mar understands that the basket
it might be upside down and
we could say the concept of of good
aches
the walls around the basket extend
downwards and create
fort fuchem around and around everywhere
whereas in our case
there's only a basket on top of a tree
so now like this so why don't they say
good aches in our case
right so good access means that the
walls even though you know
even though it's narrow over here but
halachically we extend the wall of the
basket downwards
especially if it's flipped upside down
if you look over here
this is the bottom of the basket so the
basket's flipped upside down so the
walls
are pointing downwards and when the
walls are pointing downwards it's a lot
easier to do good ah
however in our case
in our case we can't say good ah over
here
why why can't they extend the walls here
explains rashi beautifully
because over here we want to invoke two
halal messinais
or two crazy halakhas two concepts one
of khaikikin
and one of guraka's mahita to combine
two al-akhas
to make a versus a four by four that
we're not gonna do
very interesting you have to do because
i don't have a surface
so i have to pretend that this tree is
cut down right over here
and i also want to pretend so too
pretending to pretend twice he can't
pretend twice you could pretend once
you want to do great
game and now i have a surface of four
it's beautiful but to say
hikikim to take off the tree pretend
that the tree doesn't exist
and to pretend that my mercies of my
basket go all the way down to the ground
uh-uh no we got a there's a limit of how
much we're going to imagine
says the gemara
[Music]
so review have a basket on top of a tree
and we ask the question that if it's
fourth wide
it turns into ursula
right we have a tree over here a pole a
tree
my mother says it's the fourth
fourth one we just came off a turret
it's not for it welcome together with
the basket it's for
him in the whole situation this whole
ahmad says
no another shot it so what did you ask
me if it's fourth falcon it becomes
if it becomes you just attach the basket
to it
and what did you gain so you attach the
bat so it's still in
the answer is i gained very nicely i
could take this basket and
flip it upside down and go like this
it's called naito you're here you see
gary you're focused
i don't see it on the screen but okay
they do
and i just took it from my virtual side
into the roshusaraba without moving the
basket without moving the bottom of the
basket
it's on a hinge it swiveled nicely
boom like that downwards and now i can
take
i have access to my challah i have
access to my
oh wow you want to zoom out and show
them what it looks like the island on
youtube so they can see what the islam
here sees
no beautiful
and that's pretty much the end for today
we finished at eight
zero zero hold on one second hoyo biacol
entails
sorrow very good
so now you're going yeah
fight and that's mother this is
something that you could do
baina shmasha's because even though it's
a tree
you're permitted to move stuff on a tree
being a smashes it's a good arrow
rabbi said for slichos we
staff your me every day cassidrone
so the daffy me the yeah what
why can't they hear me
why don't they hear me but okay whoever
could hear me
uh sleepless we're not changing the
timing
during sleepless shears at the same
exact time 7 15. mutsy shabbos
cheers at nine o'clock have a wonderful
wonderful shabbos have a great day