Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 32 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabboissai how's everybody doing today's share is sponsored and we have a very special sponsor here i don't know if i'm allowed to say the sponsor i don't remember is it the this computer goes over here all right so today's share sponsored in honor of all the young kids that watch the sheer including the young kid is jack friedman who's not so young he's not married how old is he turning 19. okay so he's the oldest of the kids we don't know of all the kids and we might not have the full list but here's the big list and it says because it's daf lamin bays live they are the heart of the sheer yo bergman these are guys that are on every single day without fail schmuli lemmer the kid that came in for the seal drove him from the mountains to kensington jonah simcha gargier he's here with us right here in the building gavriel lynn harry seltzer you the tv seltzer yaakov factor david factor probably the youngest kid this year besides double feinberg's four-year-old who didn't make to the list akiva rosenbaum alicia seltzer not related to the other seltzers jack friedman the 19 year old he's going to be so upset that he's on this list schwein is young he's a 14 15 yeah it's really david benite comes every single night akiva factor not related to the other factors maybe they are related but the nephew zalman sv billyak that's uh yosef's son naftali mate comes every single night to zoom well he's on zoom now with his grandfather moroccan he's a kid from kensington but his three brothers i don't know their name they didn't see him with him so we're all so proud of you each and every one of you is a true live hashier keep it up yes we have a lot of sponsors today that's why we have to start a little early well it's not early we're on time in honor of tamar epstein that's it atkan reforest lama for my father rebecca benjano who himself is a magic sheer daffy magician for at least 40 years he's in the hospital battling a serious infection and all this week he couldn't give a share because of that so you should have his house nothing to do with covert shane del devorah bass avraham new york i believe i have yes i have a short email here and uh for four schleim are for tina benzema bracha all right so everybody should have a rufus lima and tamar should have a it's garnished garnished what are you you're worried about money oh it's a very good horror thank you thanks thanks thanks nachman not all of these people are sponsoring somebody yeah so what are you counting the money the this year what do you count what what you know what i'll put it this way more money than you raised while you were emceeing the uh i'm just kidding i'm just kidding what i don't know i have no idea how much money well they're all for all i know it's all freebies that's you could have you should have all right uh this is a real quick email i'm sponsoring this year on the 21st development occasion of the first days of my mother shane devoid of at the age of 16 her father sent her to the warsaw ghetto and he said go wherever your eyes will take you she was the only one to survive she ended up in auschwitz she came back to paul and she married her father blessed with children and great and grandchildren great-grandchildren her memories of our family's strong devotion to yiddishkait were always an inspiration to us may your memory be a blessing i want to thank ellie and the entire mdy team for presenting that in such an enjoyable manner lg's charts and interactions with the groups making sure lively and in a way entertaining oh we have some time um [Music] you guys want to come this is a very interesting email because i was in a store just a few days ago and a gentleman came over to me recognized me with my mask on he says you're ellie stefanski yes there's a guy benny giddleson in uh in england that works in a bakery i think he said bakery but i remember maybe that's my own memory because benny once wrote wrote us the email and he says oh he's doing great and he loves to share and also i get an email from benny so i'll read this harry belly it's benny gilson from manchester unboxing i'm still doing the daf every day with you i love your shirt best magazine in the world i love you any one of those emails comes to the top robot is sending the emails kadai i love the live demonstration today finally somebody said he liked the demonstration please can you do it every day the same one over no i really enjoyed to see him on shabbos when i went on holiday i went to wales and there was a 70 inch plus screen there here's the caddish the tv screen i watched the share on the screen and it felt like i was in the same room as you i look forward to one day coming to israel and coming to the live share my days are feeling much better after doing the dive with you every day i have a wonderful have a wonderful day his mom she's catching on to the lingo here benny giddleson okay gevalde more there's another guy from london today is 250 days of the cycle if anybody wanted to know 250 days since bronchus dear rebellishly though as a lake hummer and joining but now subscriber must say that your cheerfulness is very refreshing singing them was very predictable was it and a very nice way of doing the simcha and it goes on to say that we're just learning this it's interesting cloud product cloud we just i thought we're done with cloud private cloud is all excited and he brings it back of course cloud protocol he says all the sheer members it's all you see oh yeah tomorrow avrami fell from london allah from the base going into death sometimes they really give everybody physical i'm sure when you see well it makes us a little depressed at least me like when the eight-year-olds come every single day what were we doing when we were eight ten fifteen twenty forty these guys are going to finish that soon it's unbelievable all right overall man the the special numbers in this world where did you get it from michelle so he just finished saying by the way robots i announced yesterday very very important announcements that i thought was a murder idea that if people want to bring people to the sheer but they don't feel comfortable not everybody's yeshua erin price go over to random strangers little kids in the store women or wherever come come to the chair he thinks they're adults i don't know i saw him walk over the three-year-old then he started saying daft he's a a super super what do they call you super recruiter no the kid i saw him try to recruit was his own son his son's first words were daf that's this thing right so anyway so what and he did not call his daughter daphna for whatever strange reason so you could donate money towards the nan kim ad campaign and the sourcing you get from that ad will be yours and you'll get other people so just yesterday three people total of three thousand dollars it's unbelievable so keep it up our boy's side over having achmen talking about did i tell you what happened the bus line we got to start learning but a guy walked in there his name is jason he's been here ready for three four nights already jason win win jason wind he said that he gave me a ride once from the airport and i convinced him to do the death but that didn't happen and then all of a sudden he saw my face on the bus so he came to the chair so the bus the ad works the ad works yeah that worked so it was worth it no i'm they spent i don't remember how many thousands of shekels on the bus has one guy it's kadai for one guys could i but there's better ways of doing it so we just finished yesterday saying that you could rely on you tell us they have to do if he's going to do the heir of all of a sudden he says but when it comes to uh you can't he can't he can't rely on the guy sorry for him we could assume that he that a guy is going to listen to you because worse what's the worst case scenario he won't listen he'll tell you he's going to do something he's not going to do it he's going to tell he's going to do an arrow and he didn't do there so worse comes towards you even in the rabbana it's not the end of the world so we could rely on a person and worse because if he's not going to do it fine it's not me i don't make stuff up i'm just reading from the gemara i'm just a conduit here we're talking we're going to talk about amaritzim but people that know how to learn this is the gemara this we understand we can rely on there is a hazard but together the syria of these two things we don't have to be concerned just real point that real quickly thaisis brings up that says this is all many many machines and shadows between when it comes to momminess like when it comes to surum like ravishes this would be in this sir so that should be like then he goes into it maybe they argue on it but are you saying because many machines you should know the bahad very interesting bag depends if it's mumminess it goes like if it's he's super goes like yours [Music] going to bring three rice basically will take us all the way to the base of sheisha says three proofs and rav nachman disputes the proofs one by one are sheishas i could count on another person telling me he's going to do what i asked him to do this nan mishikara valley the oymer that is the new grain from the new year coming into pesach you cannot eat it until you make the minecraft on the secondary peso by the way i mentioned it a few times that replies even today even unless you saw me which most people aren't he's that's in america they seem to like oh we can rely on that but it became very popular to be macbeth on even in america you you could get it you could you could do okay most pizza shops and all that to make today not so 20 years ago when they bring the carbon ointment they can bring it anytime from the morning on you could eat khadas the new grain right away or haike but those who don't know if they brought the carbon so they can't eat it the first thing in the morning what if they didn't bring but it says that even if you don't know for sure you could start eating the new grain but if you eat the new grain and they didn't bring the carbohydrates [Music] they have a job to do they have to bring that um they're not they're not going to wait around they're not going to mess it up they're going to do it we're talking about an individual that promises you he's going to place your heir of 2000 amis over there maybe he did maybe he didn't it's not a besdon the ico d'amri and some say the exact opposite it's such a strong answer or if nothing says that it's actually proof to her of nachman omarov tony thai maleficent i could prove to you that odor raiso only the right song why because it says the tony time official because over there it says the reason why i can count on the armor being brought is because besides are not going to be lazy hashtag but that's because it's best then but you see from them a foolish that the shliyak could forget and cannot rely on here it's a writer of nachman that i only count on besdon and i don't count on so it's a beautiful writer that's whatever nakamura says when it comes to diariza like arimir i don't count on the shaliyah otherwise the gemara should say that he's a shaliah he's going to do his job no the gemara goes deeper it's the best in him because it's going to do his job or shaliah doesn't do his job only in the rabbana who can rely on us the reason why the gemara goes so far to say that it's the best thing because we want to give this guy the ability to eat but halfway through the day so that you need something strong but over here we're saying that the schleich probably brought the aero like most people they procrastinated okay so i'll do it by the end of the day but a person will do his job he's not going to tell you he's going to do something and he won't do it says roshan's omrav sheishas try number two so this one didn't work out so well for us it's not uh not much wiggled his way out of it not not that he wiggled his way he actually turned it around our ashes and brought it right against the rafters give you another ride a woman whose tummy via she gave birth so she has to bring her bones or she's a zava she has to bring birds oh yeah this also brings at least one bird and if she's poor she brings two birds in a sense well so instead of bringing physical birds what you could do is you take money you put it in a pushka called the shayfir it actually looks like a shiver talking about rosh hashanah it's uh avi mandelbaum will show you over there what it looks like it it's very narrow on the top and it curves and becomes white on the bottom so if you're trying to stick your finger in there first of all it's very narrow second of all turns you're not going to get the money so you put the money into this driver is lyric so she puts the money in now what has to happen in order for her to go to the mikvah she has to assume that the cayenne took her money out of the chauffeur bought birds was macro the birds fur and now she she's a full she's a fullest young she go and well she already went to the makers she has to go again to the mikvah because she wants to catch him she has to be she'll be touble but that's all assuming that the carbon was brought uh who said the car somebody brought the carbon you're relying on a car in the basement and she could eat cochin but it has vacation which if she's tommy she gets caught us very severe penalty for this but you can rely on the client because i'm going to assume that the client did what are you supposed to do says different reasons again once again we're jumping the best then over there in the basement is the best thing who takes care who makes sure things happen yes there's a coin here there's a coin there but there's a president telling rabbi schoenberg and his friends do this do that they take they're the heads they tell you what to do the best is not going to mess up they make sure nobody goes home until they empty out the shower every day it's so they make sure things happen that's why i can rely on it but it's not a typical that i'm relying on um okay not a good ride third raya here we go is he a learned person not a learning person so ruling tell shimon go to my tree and grab i was just thinking about you hello i'm not exaggerating this thing i didn't see on zoom in a long time so malaya thanks for coming i hope you got rashes though to come there's no oi okay your game is just good because it's very limited we have to be careful for corona here you got rashos robots i don't learn from this so reuven asks tell shimon you have permission to go to my fig tree and grab a bunch of figs and eat them now what do we do about true muslimizers what are the troublesome meisters given to those to these figs says the says the braiso raboisa in the kitchen we can hear you very very loud and clear um so what you do is you could eat the figs if you're just a temporary aquila just like by grain if you're going to eat the grain before remember that nice pile the smooth pile you're not going to eat it anymore but before the smooth pile you go and grab some of the grain so two over here you could grab a fig or two eat it next to the the tree you're okay you don't have to take any miser however um but if you're going to make a whole suit out of it then you have to you have to take my sir vada means you're a hundred percent taking myself it's not a suffix so what's going on here if i tell you that you can have figs off my tree how many figures are you gonna take off the tree i don't know there's no there's no limit i don't know how many you're gonna take you might take two you might take 200. so i'm the owner of the tree i don't know what to do i'm not going to give my sir truman some mysteries for you if i don't know how much you're gonna [Music] so again the first albuquerque is the same he could eat temporarily take to take a fig without mice or no problem um but he has to take turmoil maestrous as if he doesn't know what the owner did it's very possible the owner took truman semesters because the owner knows how much to give the owner knows that in this basket there's a hundred figs that could fit in there baylor is going to take 12 figs off for truman's homestress let's say two for true mcdonough and another 9.8 for meisser so he's going to get rid of those figs but on the on the other hand maybe he didn't take trump semesters it's a suffolk so he'll take demaid oh my what's going on here i don't know so take it again fine rash just points out something very very important a big big aside what's the difference if a person takes trauma because he has to or because it's a suffolk it's the same idea so you should take truma why does the gemara say it takes umass from demai and before that it says um is there a difference in the way he takes it through some maestrous between the two cases anybody if you take troublesome mysteries is it any different if you take troops of myself says rasha what bracha no i hear it but no this is actually a very very big difference the difference is in the micer that you give to the lady and the micer ani that you give to the awning both of those go to the scroll in the case where it's a suffix why because the sufficient and every suffocal might seem javier alvaria so the true magdala he gives to the kite but the meister that he gives to the lady so the trump daily doesn't have to give to the korean but he can't eat it because if it's true while he's in big big trouble but mice are you could you could eat your own myself you could eat your straw could eat mice so he doesn't have to get to the lady you could eat him for himself you hear the nafcamino truma uh meisser de mai means that he could keep the micer that you would give to the lady now the bryce explains that the owner of the tree is an amaritz then i could assume that he took the truman miser of the tree while he promised he told his friend go take a basket full go take a basket full of fruit so obviously since he's done he doesn't want the guy to be over and available see the mitchell assumed that the tomato did his job and took the troops to meisters [Music] compared to rebbe here's the list i pulled it out some for some reason i was able to find it it goes hillel famous hillel basil hilar zakin robin shimon gamlia lazakin but that's not what we're talking about robingham leo revan shimmering him believe that's the one we're talking about review that and i'll see review in other words rebbe who's arguing here is ripping him a little son is arguing with his own father [Music] rebbe says that i could assume took true muslim mysteries and therefore you don't have to take any mysteries what the bryson says that you should take muslim maestrous dumas is because you took it from an amaranth river [Music] had this yesterday that is not going to take troops from mysterious from not within that same vessel within the clear it has to be right there and therefore says reprimand leo i'm sorry son but how could you assume that gave trump some maestrous on a basket that's so far away when he's not there tamil hachem doesn't do such a thing and the gemara is going to explain what where's what i'm saying is better than my father why and not cause his friend to eat without troublesome ancestors fine and we're going to get a little bit more into it the gemara takes a pause for a second and the mark says well here's my raya we're trying to prove rasheed is trying to prove the khazaka that does is even in the arizona okay what's the riot please subscribe if he's not next to the food that he's doing it for wouldn't would he not but there's no macholicus if that wasn't an issue if tommy are permitted to take turmeric and maestrous on things that they're not next to then they wouldn't be shy they're going to be able to be a macholic irish would admit his son of course is not going to want our mars to walk around without troublesome so what is that called that's called i just want to stop here for a second and point a beautiful texas out it's on the bottom we can see it inside of the microphone [Music] the hallmark like is in the gemara between one case in the direction but there to take what are we talking about we're talking about figs to take through some ice cream from frig from figs is only middarabana mri says grain grapes olives that's it figs are not in that list amazing question right it says this is an amazing you saw each other was almost a year ago that you started this year right ansookas beautiful in the sukkah all right to be discussed a different time says the gemara so says this look at isis is an amazing there is a saying so this doesn't appear anywhere in the torah that's a made up thing midair amid rabbanam but this figs is very similar to diaries it's there a bunny you don't have them in there but it's the same alok that appears in the torah regarding grain rabbit took it and put it by figs that we have a mach like isaan whether or not because it has a shem my seminar has that name okay says man so is that is this a good raya for sheisha's there's no machines that will do troublesome doesn't let unfixed food come out of his hands he's not going to let something like that happen that is going to be over he's soon because of him that doesn't happen nothing to do with it's a different kazakh doesn't allow these kind of things to happen and now we go back to the suggyo of covername arts varma moritz so we learned an ammarest that owns a tree that's where the maclaique says he says that owns the tree the other person that the receiver doesn't have to take troops and meisters because the owner will take troops who's this ammar is talking to so here's aleph mem even spelled like ammar's amiritz if he's talking to another emirates well if you don't know why it's your first time here okay let me let me fill you in for a second in chicago you have chicago ties in chicago when i was giving cheers i was giving from gemara like you'd do today i didn't know how to read then i still don't and so i use the gemara with nikudus i love it i also use the siddha with nakudas by the way because i don't know how to read and also mr brewer with questions also has nakutas so i so so guy comes over and he says bishop has a beard and he's he's a ravi smith bishop if you're an amrits i understand why i have no kudos so i also put them here so every time i'm fine who's that maritz talking to him from that day on his name is amaritz he needs the kudos and i put the nakudas here for him to read ah maritz if the guys i'm a ritz and he's talking to another emirates am i written don't listen to them why do why do we have divide my means who says i took trump some israelis we can't we can't rely on him because maybe he didn't take jerusalemize so who is he talking to he told his amarett's friend to shout him they both picked their nose he tells us the other nosebigger guy go take off the tree uh figs and are going to tell them by the way you have to take troublesome maestros again why because your other amma or his friend that gave it to you he would crush it him you think he's going to listen to ham don't trust his friend so they don't trust me so i'm going to listen to you that's in the story so now that we know this is that it's the receiver was oh probably uh avi mandelbaum probably loves this tomorrow this is his window i hope i'm already gonna lay the man in the comments from demaio do you think da mars is going to listen to ham when he knows that his friend gave truman to maestrous or is the comment little cover so you must say that it's that gave fruit to him you have to be really careful with this amara's guy you should give yourself a ma safa so the second case the first case is that he told him take it off the tree what's the second case that he told him to take to put it in a basket so we have to be we have to flow here right so who's the receiver the receiver is and i'm alright but that's not what it says it says the receiver was got a major problem here well we're switching we're switching cases and not only we're switching cases we've flipped it around the giver is an ammar is a zamaret's they gave to them it really says that it's let's see and it says it's not a picture but it says that it's a tamitham who gave tana maaretz that's what it says the right that we had the whole discussion is the talmud i'm going to give truma when it's not in front of him he's not but it's giving to who tamara rebbe says mafoorish they don't want to feed that marathon so the receivers and arts but the first case he told me the receiver was and now you're telling me that he's on my wrist says it's my body awesome where does that mars fit into this whole thing we just said that i'm an artist cannot be the receiver because he won't take trouble from meisner's anyways so he doesn't think rumors advisories he can't be the guy getting it it has to be talking about that it's not tom hawk i'm getting it omravinda raised shabama or okay so that's why i did it like this the ratio the first case that he's picking off the tree is rs that owns the tree telling the time to take off the tree great sephora you're right it's a different case so omar la amo are behavior go fill up your basket but the receiver cannot be an ammar as we said because ahmad doesn't listen he says very good the real receiver at the end of the day at the end of the line is it and you could assume that doesn't want to be maxwell says rebbe damaris because he's not going to do anything with it so he's going to take troops meisters can the the the talmud that's eating over let's say by the ammo artist's house can he rely on it could he use that fruit relying on the first time gave right so returning to the flaming base almond base sponsored by dr lust house lily nicholas have to find the name here morgan yosef ben iron asher's mother rosa bass bin yeoman who says make it a great day by the way i had to use that line on my uh my kid the other day my kid told me i'm just saying this because it's a muslim i think he said what do you want from me you brought me to israel when i was this in this age i didn't speak hebrew i had a very hard time here i said it's a very good taino but you know what think about all those people that came out of the camps the concentration camps they had zero to their name and they came to america and look at these lives they made for themselves you have to take responsibility for yourself everybody has excuses i heard that they're saying in america the reason why we're protesting is because we were sliced through take responsibility make it a great day a voice like today you have the choice don't blame other people that's what asher is trying to say here says the gomorrah reviews yeah but your father is actual child of the holocaust survivor he's a he had a rough your father that's different than you had enough because you had your father my father we're swiss so we didn't really have but i came up with it myself says the gemara so rebecca what's rebbie svara here huh huh oh okay i lost my thing you know but i have other ones we're going to the green now the rebbe saw oyster club sir glasser the third guy in line the the guy at the end of the line doesn't have to take myself why the vadi is remastered i will cover kamilave the first guy for sure took mice or why because he knows that the guy receiving it is an amaritz and he's not going to do it for himself so he's going to take the troops from isis for him and therefore the talmud could eat it but the father says it's impossible for this when he's not in front of the troops he's not in front of the basket it's awesome for him to do it so what would he do in this sir oh so what's in my legs and now finally guimar explains so rebbe tells his father what do you mean if the talmud doesn't take troops and mysterious this hammer is going to be eating devil and that's it you get me so they shamayim for eating devil [Music] it's better that i'm going to do a like this or a rabbanam not to be my first room or somebody's in front of the basket and not allowed to do a major issue of miso ask priceless we learned to massachusetts because the talmud is at fault he caused the samaritans to be over israel because he gave him fruit who told you to give fruit now take responsibility be over a small listener so that he shouldn't be over a big one and later on this says a guy that puts bread into the oven he did it right before he yes it's a shy gig but it's his fault he should have known better over here that marriage had no idea that there's no troops in the mistress come home come go eat he figured go eat but what rupturing is going to say wait a minute before you put something in your mouth figure it out that's your problem to figure out whether or not it's uh or not it says [Music] even though it's going to save damaris from a greater issue says the mishnah nissani you can't eat it as igumar is going to explain so therefore it's not considered the area of it's above 10th fahrenheit the camaro explained beautifully where and how la mata master if you could reach it it's less than tenth i'm not talking about reaching i'm talking about a logically getting to it a ruby arrow it's a good arrow so below 10 is okay and this branch above 10 on this bench not okay nissani bebar what if you put the aero inside a pit if you want to know what a pit looks like there you go i believe there's a piece of salami in here especially if you're from chicago romanian salami this looks like a salami to me no this red thing look so a guy throws the salami into the bar and it's a certain size so even though i feel almost it's a good arrow of says the mark i'm not so worried about where we get to because if you take a peek on the flaming gimbal and la meda not so no it's it's kind of it's kind of awesome to finish kind of sorry nothing kind of awesome [Music] another one of the rovers i counted from the 53. where in the world is this tree that we're discussing you put it on now in order to understand this we have to go back for a second and understand that everything is taking place in venus muscles it cannot be taking place before banished smashes because you can flip it around you can do things you cannot be talking about on shabbos it's too late if i am kanesh visa if i make my residence okay if you just join us today because i know of a person that just joined today so let's start over for a second just for him we're talking about heir of truman we're talking about a person is allowed to go 2000 amis from the city limits 2000 namus now if he wants to he could extend it by another 2000 amis by placing a meal two meals at the end of two thousand amish and now halakha is considered that he took up residence at that roof at that meal and now from that milan he goes another two thousand amish okay what if the food disappears animals eat the food it's not a problem because during bana shmush's when the era of israel that was my residence what if my house burnt down on shabbos it's not a problem because during venus masters i had a house so we're talking about muscles okay says where's this tree there if the tree is in a private domain i place my suda in somebody's backyard he lives 2000 away from my house let's say in another city and i'm placing it in his backyard on a tree mali lima la mata we're talking about restrictions now where does rochester start where does it end it's just like i think well there's in manhattan there's like ear rights and stuff like that but typically speaking your issues goes up to the sky it goes there's no limit to your shoes but it's just a rabbit where this is just a rabbit right we learned in second shot 100 times 10 falcons to robin goes through and through so okay so what's the difference if i'm standing in the bottom of the tree so what difference does it make where my area is it could be ten my twenty twenty twelve of my we're all in the same place within the same resource i can retrieve it what's the problem i'll take the error off the tenth and inviting the law so must say the koi versus a rabbit okay sticks with that that we're talking about that he's in urushiou sarabin only goes to ten then and where does he want to be we have to figure out where does this guy want to be for shabbos he's living in this guy he wants to be in the tree hooves so that's not a problem he'll be in the tree with his arrow and he could access his arrow because he's the same result as azeroth when he's together with his arrow if you can access it you're telling me he can't access it why not helen and scavenge he was trying to be on the bottom of the tree the bottom of the tree is what a russian because this tree is in regional surat there's some picture here i don't know if this will help or not here we go also from kuala lumpur million dollar book history is a million c middle school surround him here's the tree put his hair up here falcon let's say you can't bring from one domain to the other mate that's the homosexual first mission of javascript right you can't carry from so therefore that's why he this is not a good area because any sudo that you can access to eat even banana smushes he cannot access the banished muscles why can't he activate his house because banana shmashes he's also not permitted to move things from are you allowed to drive a carbon and smashes no because it might be shabbos so then i can't take my arrow off the tree on banishmoshes because i might be carrying from rashford saying this was a rabbit so that's why it's not a good arrow because it's in a place that no one in the world could eat from that a-roof says the gemara so you're telling me that it's up in a tree welcome but this is the rabbit on to use a tree you're not on the climate tree so how's he getting to it anyways eve now so time out we're going back to this below 10th falcon on the in the case that he's standing interesting and it's below 10th falcon you told me the mishnah that it's a good arrow of below 10 but he can't take anything off a tree even if your code is hanging on a tree you know how to take it off the tree because you're using the tree and are concerned that you might break a breath so what do you do says the gemara a very interesting lesson i'm not sure why the gemara does this the gemara repeats everything we just said as if it's we just came off this the march should have just jumped to the end but the mars says it anyways a bunch of new work a bunch of words that we just said la ilam the kybushes around him he is standing in the rabbit venezuela island he's standing he wants to be below the tree he wants to be on the ground virabihi and rabbi holds the omar called over we had this concept yesterday means it's only is it there a bottom to take something off a tree on shabbos to move something from ritual of this raven that says to their but your your concern of me using a tree that's only the rabbana and that i could do banana smashes it's not like driving a car being mahal shabab is the raisa this is the schwarz this is the rabbana and they're abandoned we don't mind so much you doing your banishment so melee you're asking me this aero that's in your head how are you able to use it because during banishments i was able to access it why because it's only the rabbaran and that is it doesn't apply banished mushrooms and that's what shmuel said as well omar lay pastries what you went through the whole shot and you this is how you you figured it out and everything is good so he says you're telling me that i did this so quickly we did this together you also came up with the same conclusion allah so what did they say is it such a great shot that that's it this is going gonna be in the gemara forever omar luo in this is the shot it's me and the gemara just repeats the shot is illinois and we're talking about a tree that's in versus raven that makes it if the tree like in this picture well over here don't read it says eight i talked about these two pictures one says eight one says ten the exact same picture i think four by four summon melee that makes it a four by four by ten is it he's standing down here below that's just a rabbit venus lamato and he wants to make his residence below he wants to be understood very he and he goes according to review any time they said it's permitted to do during that is the final shot and we're sticking to it have a wonderful day [Music] why over there don't go don't don't go on job it's totally to go yeah no no we're talking about mitzvot we're talking about the developments you don't have to go anywhere why do you have to go you're going to to be nikomanvale we're talking about it you can only make area developments you're forced to go with nikon above you don't have to go