Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 27 by R’ Eli Stefansky

all right we're ready to go i'm blowing at my shoulder yes everybody how's everybody doing today and a very special sponsor has very very dark humor who wishes to remain anonymous okay one very short email this is from ari bloom he says hi rebellio just a quick email to say that i know i'll have another reason to thank you you see this week is a time uk shasta this year of course rather than learning together on the one roof with a big serum we're all having to learn at home on our own everything's good gary okay great i chose the first template of irvin and i get to do hazor of yeshurim and laugh those jokes a second time only english people were left twice they're not watching us so we can make fun of them and yes i'm still following the daft those usually on twitter anytime youtube and i can now say that i missed a day and carried out because last time he sent in i yelled at him for trying to be a perfectionist and bar hashem he learned not to be a perfectionist he missed the day and he carried on culture bloom p.s when you're ready let's talk about the mdy newsletter sometime and we should do that too i just want to tell you a quick story that i read today fresh off the press and uh it's i'm very impressed my favorite stories about rip slime is i'm ariba and this is a beautiful story that he was on a bus every day he would take the bus from shari hessed to buy vegan to call tyra she's taking a bus and it's telling me that we're following him you know they're in the bus watching the the reshiva and the stop came to get off at yeshiva and he didn't get off he got off the next stop so of course they asked him rebbe why why'd you miss the bus he said well the guy next to me had to salim full of fruit so if i had to get off i'd have to ask him to move i didn't want to be matriarchy unbelievable those are the kind of stories that i love and i thought i would share with the islam so today we're starting zain it's a brand new peric which starts in afghavam bays we finished oyster passing and now we're starting kulma irvin um you make an error of with every kind of food what kind of aero says rashi katseyroys of course is when a person wants to go more than 2 000 allotted amis that he's allowed so he puts a meal at the end of where he's able to go to let's say he's able to go to two thousand dollars he puts his bread over there and then from that point on he goes another two thousand dollars his makhan so he he's actually hanging out on shabbos where his bread is that's how so that's why rashford says khattarashanam discuss it because at the end of the day this doesn't apply to aruba katsura says thais was fine he says according to everybody at the end of the day you need bread it's not bakoma but rashi is just bringing out the suggy you could use any type of food you can use meat fish we'll see fish later there are two two foods that you can't use for a native water and salt why because it needs to be a meal that nourishes you and water is not a nourishment water is liquids not a nourishment salt is salt and once we're mentioning aerov says the mission of aha called nicaragua because of myself so myself we're talking about maestro cheney to khazr hazard time we have a chance so step number one is you give true magdala approximately two percent depends how large you are if you want to give more you give more it's a problem there's no real shear so let's call two percent then now you have 98 left now you give my surresho which is ten percent it goes to the levy and then step three is you give meister cheney ten percent to who to yourself you have to bring the fruit ten percent of your fruit up to your slime and eat your fruit but if it's too much the fruit then you trade it into cash what do you do with the cash we're gonna be discussing a lot of it you take the cash and you buy what the tire tells you basically food items food items or even oil that key anoint yourself but food you go to a nice restaurant you go basically you go to the supermarket and you buy everything so you fill up your cart with meat and flour bread and when times when it comes time to pay at the cash register so you pull out your cash your mice or shiny cash and you pay but you tell the you tell the cashier wait a minute here's my credit card for the water the bottled water and the salt that i can't pay with cash everything else you could pay with cash from the meisner shane that these two items again are not included in muslin muslin is something that sustains you nourishment and water are not or my melaka should say arvin now the mission goes on to say that you don't necessarily have to be able to eat the food for instance let's say you're another you made a nether that you're not going to drink wine you're permitted to make a roof out of wine why because other people could drink the wine uli israel the truman and if you're you stroll and you can't eat truma the kumar is obviously going to discuss why and where different reasons will you struggle with rumor yuri swell you can't eat trump but the kind could eat ruba i can make my ear of out of truma not true a yisrael could only use hulen he doesn't argue that another could use wine why not also disgust very famous there was a grave that somebody plowed over it it's unknown where the tuma is so it's a sophic tumor so the cayenne could place his a-roof in the base of press why because he could go into the base of past hal i got to show you this picture this is back from nidalee time but i couldn't really find a picture on the internet of a guy blowing blowing something because he could get down on all four why are you laughing you know what's coming up what's coming up let's see if you know who michael jordan with the um anyways this is the picture of a guy blowing he literally this is what it looks like he could get up on all four you get on all four and blow his way through the base of press until he gets to zero since he could do so so no this is a firm guy what do you do he has sids he has yamaka this is allowed under the rules this is allowed he says anyways matashabas nobody really watches this his friend also became a gear just recently what's his name uh starter meyer amari they all become games soon so mario yeah irae would i did i just tell you the story i didn't tell you the story with michael me and my friend sender i forgot his first name in sega i might have just said it did i just say it i just told somebody else because he just told somebody we went to the airport to pick somebody up and the guy was coming from chicago he's a hoshiva now uh send it what's his first name i don't remember anyways i live with him and um all of a sudden this giant guy comes off the plane it's like whoa and then another giant and like this was in 1987. and these giants like and i look at him like very communist they said you know in chicago they're very tall not realizing that the entire chicago bulls were on this united flight they didn't have a private plane then and then also this guy michael jordan comes up and they started screaming people yelling and autographs and i was the first guy there like yo how tall are you he says something like that i don't remember he actually answered me oh sorry we're holding the last few words of khov you could go to the base like far as the the coin could do it in the basic virus because he could show up in a in a helicopter without any toma or in those days it's called the sheet of table mcdonald he could just show up in the basic fireworks rashi says before shabbos before when he smashes okay the point is he has a way to do it and therefore he could use he could put he could place his arrow in a place that's awesome to go to or food that's awesome to eat um every rule has some sort of and by the way solanter says this he says every cloud has a team in a cloud including this cloud that has the iot in the cloud in other words every rule has an exception to the rule including this rule that every rule has an exception to the rule because not every rule has an exception to the rule there are some rules that don't have an exception and that's basically what rebecca is saying here if a mission says a rule it doesn't mean that it includes everything even in a place where it says the word what does that mean if the mission says this is besides a and b so you would think since it says and it says besides a and b it already included everything it's already telling you all the rules you need to know the rules and the exceptions to the rules no even in a place that says khus there are more exceptions himself and says even in a place where it says the word now in our mission it says quotes right so the kumara obviously rebecca wasn't giving over this mishna when he said this rule it doesn't make any sense they say even in a place you're in that place you want to say even in a place where it says he would say even over here he would use a different wording from the fact that he says even in a place wasn't in this mishna when he said his special rule about rules where was he when he said this and now the gemara is going to take us on a very wild trip through shas i love when the gemara does it because we get to see many many different alakas or we're going to go through a lot of stuff a lot of them were very very familiar with some of them not so much but it's a great hazara starting off with a very geshmaka gemara and a very famous one hassam kai i'll tell you where he was call mr sensation as my grandma were very familiar with this that any place where the time is what dictates when you do the mitzvahs that's mysterizations my grandma women are potter vicious when it's not not time bound has nothing to do with the time so for instance what's a time-bound mitsu sokka lulu far so women are potter bishops my grandma what's a good mitzvah that's magical you have to do it all the time so mellow women visualize my grammar everybody is hive whoa chloe is that a a solid rule they call mrs aze as mangroma nosh harimato what about matzo the first night of yantev of pesach women archive even though it's time bound why are women because they're they're in the license of hummus they cannot eat comments and whoever's candy comes has to eat mata simcha you have to be happy on yantef it's coming up soon simcha literally it's not a joke you have to be happy on yantef women also because it says you're your wife as well the hackel the baptists are very familiar with this we're not so we don't even know what that is but hakul is every seven years on the shemitah year after shemitah everybody gathers they all gathered the melech stands on a platform and he reads from dvaram he reads the parasha hako but women have to go annoshim notion it's only once every seven years so it's not a clear-cut rule and more than that the homicides i say is my grammar now i'm going to bring a few examples where there's no time limit there's no time constraint it's not time bound minos you're supposed to learn rashi brings all the time right does rashi bring it here all the time [Music] that only men are high even because of the mitzvah which is the 30th day then the kiev goes on forever you have so it's a rule but the rule was meant to be broken a little bit the field and even over there even where it says more i'll bring you more proof oh in order to bring this peruv we're going to go through some a little tumentara just a little bit and they said another cloud anything that's on top of this of this tummy even if he's not touching it and that's called a leonis of it's tommy as a reshone so he's carrying a bunch of stuff everything is tame a love tahar now if azov sits down on something it doesn't touch it there's no hesses so it's tahar makalaki is very shiny if tar means literally tartar 100 or tar that it's very it's a very light um let's call it tar okay tar he's completely tar you'll remember we had this if azav sits on a bucket it's not a cheer because we could tell him what are you doing on my bucket i have to do sponge or get off my bucket so since it's not meant to sit on therefore it doesn't become tommy at all whereas a couch even bismanenu now oh i forgot to mention what is is of okay i'm so we're we're coming out of neither so i thought it's obvious if a man has an emission that's not kerry it's some weird fluid that comes out we're not very familiar with it today if he sees it twice zob is of course the kids are doesn't matter how many times azov also the same thing it's a different type it's it's a sickness it's a disease it's not has nothing to do with neither has nothing to do with kerry this is of ziva and ayurvedas anyway at they when they sit down they make things tommy if they are meant to be sat on so that's why couches in every house would be the completely tome of zamayya leaders sitting on it would create if it's meant to sit on like a couch then when azav zavila sit on it it becomes tremendous and a human being who lifts up azov he becomes a rishi great so we have some sort of idea of what the zov does as imam sulekha markov there's something called america writing when you write something it becomes stomach sigma what are you talking about high america dominating l.a if he's riding on a donkey and he's sitting on a on a saddle hi to my shop so why is that any different than a couch of course you have this guy this is part of the saddle this you're right this is like a couch you're doing the whole zoom thing gary i don't see anything but i'm watching and zoom i don't what do i see i don't see anything how come i don't see it popping up on the screen no i'm saying i have zoom like everybody else has i'm seeing what they see how come my screen not anyway so on the saddle you have these little guys that if you ever went horseback riding you know what i'm talking about in those days everybody had it every car which is a horse has it so this guy they hold on to this is the toy fest you hold on to it or the guy in the back well in the back that is the criticism that it becomes tommy look of tommy tommy what happened i am he just called me a nice name in front of a thousand people maybe 2 000 right now oh you mean forget about me i'm just the regular guy watching it on zoom they're seeing that okay whatever anyway so we're talking about this little chip chakra rashi says anything that's similar to this guy whatever that means i don't know if it means let's say a handle on a chair whatever he means by that but anything that's similar to this is is in this america thing okay so especially a lot of america but the bottom line is that it wasn't brought down in this whole process in this mission doesn't say anything about about this this toughest thing the thing you hold on a saddle so you see again the concept that it says a cloud and it includes other things and we're going to continue we're going on in chats other stuff uh in our mission that says you can make an a-roof with all foods why do i want to see myself gary i want to see the oil home get me off the screen no no i don't want to see them i don't want to see me i want to see them anyway there's more foods truffles i think it's like one of the most expensive foods in the world maybe the most expensive i don't know but it costs like what thousand thousand pounds what other prices petrioids and mushrooms these are things that you cannot make an air with el shma no ain't made them in a close [Music] oh you know i see here i see libby libby how you doing how's bido treating you and this is the first time i've seen you on zoom in months you usually do it on the phone unbelievable lie be isn't it did you make it to your sister's wedding or you're in b dude you didn't make it to the wedding unbelievable unreal why you have corona it's just your son you don't have and you couldn't go to the wedding wow all right i call mine unreal we're living in crazy times everybody say he's in arizona sister hasn't heard it couldn't go to the sister's wedding we miss you in kylo we hope to see you soon even in a place like in our mission where it says i would think that the mission is coming to tell us exactly the exceptions to the rule water and salt no there's other exceptions this truffles there's mushrooms that you cannot make a nerve with says the gemara colony [Music] so right so going back to meister shane step number three is ten percent of your fruit goes to you and if you don't want to bring schlep all that fruit to your slime you trade it into cash and in your slime you buy all these food things and oil for for the body says the gemara revelations going to explain myself is going to explain this that it says that you don't make an arrow if it means bottled water and a package of salt but what if you took the two together hey you made salt water i always have to show the picture from england and i'm sure you can find the same product in pomegranate in flatbush but they do sell salted water unbelievable it costs how much a euro for those who are too lazy to take the salt and mix it in water they make it for you crazy no i always get a kick out of this one fine but this rabbi sai you can make an arab out of this this you could make an a roof according to everybody can make an arrow out of this the question in the macholic is could you could you could you make could you buy this with mice or shiny money that is the mclaren so let's see inside my rv i could make an a-roof out of salt water that's the number one the hadmaster myself i cannot purchase salt water in the store even though it's a nice mixture and it costs a full euro to buy the salt water i cannot purchase it with my social any money i have a melanie cochran because of i'm sorry that i haven't gone let's do it again each one by itself i cannot purchase but for my sashini i could buy this so again so the more explains made the master my sir should i do it again or i confused everybody by confusing myself let's do it again let's start from the top when it's sold by itself water by itself economic if it's salt water i can make a heir of great veg and myself and the other one says this exactly but am i sushi any money another might be freezing when what can you not purchase with my sushi any money water and salt denis that's what you can purchase if it's ready made like this picture even with my shading money nikon because of myself i could purchase it so it's the difference between the two very simple mandamai this which we just said a second that i could purchase with meister shady money ready-made salt water hey i can't make fun of them anymore they used to sell it in those days that's what it says i could purchase i could have somebody make this for me so certainly i can make a narrative with it if i could buy with my shiny money certainly with i can make an air with it so according to the sheet i could make an area with salted water and according to the first uh the same thing as well the only difference between them is could i could i purchase my sushi with my shiny money salty water but an area of according to everybody i could use out of salt water and salt and water mixed together availability my timo pero binon when it comes to mice or shiny according to this mandama the first mandomer i need to purchase a fruit that was born from a fruit something that's born from another something that's what it means yeah doesn't necessarily mean fruit it means an animal who was born from another animal or anything that is was created in the ground from a from a seed but it has an origin now i don't know i just saw that that that the richard are saying like mushrooms are considered premium free i have to look into that why kyocera sir rizzo came and said oh if you have my sushini money cash you could purchase in the store ready made saltwater mesa vey so they asked the question hey rabbi the big goddess left everybody lazar so remember this name because we're going to bring him up soon rabbi huda ben goddess said shall base abba in my father's house in other words in goddess's house because of myself seer is a very famous food throughout shas it's fish brine it's the lowest on the totem pole of food this is like the only the only thing lower than that is like water water and salt the water salt and the fish brine that's like very shack of food it's the juice that comes out of the fish so he says you could purchase fish brine but not water not salt water oh my gosh you should give your dog in more of them maybe maybe the shot is that the reason why you could purchase it is only because it has some inners of the fish in it mixed in but not stop but i feel reviewed bengali called my little bits here the schumann of the pay rahee and now so step number one maybe we're talking about fish bride that has some fish in it it's like thick that's why you can purchase it with my sashing money and even what if you if you're not going to go with that but you're going to say the reviews have been got this set specifically fish brine without any innards but okay it's still better than salt water why the shrumana de pero hai it still has a little bit of the oil from the fish light so where did you get this that you could he's asking me how could you repeatedly say that you could with my sushi any money you could go to the macaulay and purchase salt water the most you could do is purchase fish brine fish brine has a little connection to fruit to something that that that was born from something else to the fish itself it has a little bit of a fish oil in there so it's considered a pre but stem water from a faucet and salt what's the connection to the fruit fruit meaning created from another creation by the way i just don't want to forget this tysus and the ritual says the same thing says maybe even easier if you want to look in the ritual that something oh and this is also a very important thing i i hope not to forget it okay remind me the gra so the twice is right here the spartan tyson master miser he says the biggest side he says if you turn the page you'll see like the two lines down that the reason why you can't make an aero with different truffles and and mushrooms is because they're not ready to eat right now and in a room you have to be able to eat it now on shabbos you can't take a frozen piece of meat no maybe it's but you can't take let's say a pumpkin okay something they have to cook you cannot use as an a-roof whereas mice or shiny you could purchase any type of food you could purchase a pumpkin with my zucchini because you're going to cook it up and eat it later you have to be able to eat it right now an arrow is a lot of of a something that nourishes you right now so it has to be roy lahilla right now so talking about that the vulgarin says you could make an aero out of out of uh mushrooms and and that sort of thing i think that's what he says and something to see on your shallam i i don't know what it is i think it's some spartan rav says of the village how dare he say such a thing and on all the russian there's hardly a region that says like the villain in in the igris in the the the igor's fazinish says that the village i want to he says that you're allowed that the the vilna going was one of the only people that he was allowed to argue on rushing him that's what he says okay so this is enough between maybe about who's the i have to find out who this is something says whether he has the right argument so now we're turning to zion on the base i have to go all the way back here to see the names lilo nishmas raise the basement yeoman and make it a great day and the ido nishmas dr lust house [Music] this water and salt you see this salt water this salt water has some oil in it that's why you can purchase it with mice and shiny money otherwise you wouldn't be able to overlay by um if that's the case table so he's buying oil you let it buy oil why can't you buy oil in the mcculloch you let it buy oil so what why are you so why are you talking the entire time about water and salt water and salt it's the oil um what's going on over here is a brand new concept rabois unbelievable sugars right the concept of allah well we're learning in shabbas we learned the concept of allah also like when uh when a person works on shabbos so he gets paid for sunday monday tuesday and you pretend sort of that you're paying same idea over here what happens is let's take coke for instance i buy a can of coke for a dollar what am i paying for i'm paying for 95 cents i'm paying for the syrup the the the 14 uh spoons of sugar etc and the five cents maybe is the filtered water in there oh so i'm not allowed to buy coke with my sashing money because it has five cents of water so the answer is i could why because it's baja vla it's swallowed in the price you jack up the price for the syrup and it includes also the water i'm not charging you for the water i pretend that the water is not charged there that's that's the shock i'm charging one dollar for the syrup and the water is for free the maiza the coke company does the whole kashmir they say no 95 cents is for this and five cents is for the water there is you're paying something for the water no how logically i could just swallow it and pretend so the same thing would happen over here this this battle that costs 99 cents i'm paying 99 cents for the oil oil by itself i would only i would only pay about 50 cents but i'm also paying 50 cents for the water and the salt but that's baja we're pretending that you're not paying for the water and salt we're pretending that you're paying just for the oil that's over here is there such a concept in yes if you were here every day there's songs there's a second arabian we're gonna have to sing them back bug but i have a bunch of people don't sing oh gershon's here [Music] cow an axe sign so really what's going on here if you look over here we're going to have this positive swing the positive says this is talking about my sashini i come to your slime with all my cash what do i do with it the third tells you what you do with it you could do bakala green light you could buy everything you want and then the tartar limits you babakar ubatsoin these are limitations and then it continues that includes why is everybody laughing what is going on here okay i see also laughing [Music] [Applause] [Music] okay we got the idea why is he playing the entire song it's what's the shabbos people want to go to sleep babalkar says that when i buy a cow with my sachini one i could buy a live cow but i could buy also the hide that comes with the cow but it's not edible if you were to purchase a bunch of hide you're a cypher could you buy hide with my shiny money no but if i'm buying a cow i could buy the hide what does that tell me that's baha'u'llah i'm buying a cow for a thousand dollars i'm buying all the sticks without it happens to include the hide that i'm not paying for it at all the same thing with sign sign comes to include also the wall yayan comes to include the barrel why can i keep the can the coke can because i coca-cola for sure charges you for the can it's not free they paid money for it they have to charge you for it it's all it's included it's swallowed in the price shaykhar means old wine says rashi comes include temid temid means that you take water after you have you're done with your wine you take water and you add water to the sediment and then you have some sort of you know a little bit of a drink it ferments it's actually a little bit alcoholic that temet also the water that's entertainment is nibla okay we're going to get back to this by the way these four things what grappa it's called they still use it today they still do it tonight grappa all right they don't sell kosher grappa but there's such a thing as grappa i got it does if after ferments it tastes like whiskey says okay beautiful we learn new things every day ten min so let's eat inside [Music] you permitted even though of course wool is not included in the pasta you can't just go to the store and buy a bunch of yarn but when you buy a sheep it's included uba yayan you can't buy a bunch of barrels but this barrel is included milam's gabi gangan even though it has a bunch of water in it and water you're not allowed to purchase with my shiny money but this water is bottled into the its nivla into the rest omer says an amazing thing mandem and targetingly by bokker i leave it whoever could get up here and explain to me what bimbag just said but only one of the words this word right over here everything else i understand i don't understand bakar if you could explain it to me my vilna money abbas that uses this lotion it's exclusive to him he says it a few times only rebecca he's saying if you could explain this to me i'm willing to be your talmud i i don't think anybody it's like a bet he's all out i don't think anybody will be able to do it if somebody could do it i will take his clothing to the basement like a slave like a shamish says [Music] why am i so confident and why am i upset over here because i don't understand why you need the word babaka mystery so let's just go over belpe real quickly what he does is he goes from top to bottom and then bottom to top and he says this piece of hide this r is not part of the animal yet so i need to say okay even though it's not part of the animal so it's it's included in in this in this uh in this positive batsoin is another level away so the r is attached the art is completely attached to the animal so okay so it's a little schwa but what about giza giza is on top of that it's completely separated from the animal so i need to tell me that even that i could buy with my shiny money kankan kankan is a barrel that protects the wine protects the wine okay so that's really completely detached what it protects and then you have tement temed is a big kiddush tamed is is water so i could i could be in water now if i go backwards so i go temed to cancer giza but once i say that if i go backwards this way so i'll ask you a question why didn't the tires say then yain then sign now i'm stuck at green giza it includes i could buy with my shiny money i could buy whoa so of course i could buy hide that's attached to the animal for that i don't have an answer then why in the world does tara say bucker once i say giza which is one step removed it's further away than hide hide is literally attached to the animal but over here i'm saying that wool that you don't need the animal doesn't eat wool i could just shear off the animal and he'll live i can't take off the animal's skin when he's alive and he won't so he's part of the animal so if i tell you that giza i could buy giza with any money so of course i could buy hide that i don't know understand says so basically he's going to take us a trip from top to bottom then he's going to take us back up and he's going to get stuck that he doesn't need our what happened i'm not kidding this is colder what happened you you took ah you know what now i realized the water that he gave me before is probably from the toilet or something this is geshmaka water or maybe it's just a plastic cup that changes the taste i'm serious it's much better water but this is gonna fall off the table all right here we go it says inside the i cause of rahman you have it two four six eight twelve lines down because if the third would just say bakar but when it comes to sheep the wool is not part of his body imaloi it's not included at the end of the day the wool is attached to the animal okay it's not part of it but it's attached but wine inside a barrel is not included you can't buy it with my sushi any money because why that's the way you you keep it fresh with a nice barrel temed is just colored water that's what the third says so i need all four of them now we're gonna go backwards because because okay each one makes sense you need it after the other one but what if you go backwards what if the tire would have said first shaykh then what would you do because [Music] uh when i told you to say it wasn't very accurate so that's why you have to see it inside tomorrow i would say shekhar doesn't mean old wine to include tamit i would say sheikhar means a fig that comes from us in fact we had rashi brings here increasos that if a person eats this fig he shouldn't walk into the basement she can make him drunk it's like not an edible fig it's not something that you typically eat you don't give it to your kids they'll they'll be sicker so fine shakhar means develops even such a fruit you could buy with my sushi money because at the end of the day it's a fruit but why that's inside a barrel no you can't buy the barrel it's extra it's not part of it because okay the the wine needs the barrel why without a barrel doesn't exist you know why because we'll be all over the floor aval sawying but perhaps the the sheep doesn't need all that wool because therefore the tar says so if you were going backwards from bottom to top why do we need the word okay so maybe if the torah only said that sign and wouldn't say by bakker i would think sign is going to include the height of the sheep we're not talking about the wool of the sheep it's only because we have an exclusion or a reboot to say the height of a cow so that's why we also say that soi means the the wool but if i don't have hide of a cow so maybe sheep comes to include the hide it doesn't even come to include the wool says why because if i want to tell you hide the best way for me to tell you is a cow because a cow doesn't have wool if i want to confuse you really well then i tell you sheep because sheep has hide and it has wool so which one are you talking about so if aamaku right in the torah i'm going to tell you bakar i don't want to confuse you so why in the world did the tires say sign to tell you uh will not hide i would never think that a sheep comes to tell me hide because if i want to tell you hideout i would say something very clear bakar from that's being clear obviously i'm telling you so means so therefore once this green sign comes to tell me whoa so if whoa i could buy with my sushi any money of course i could buy hide so then why do i need the word babakar whoever could explain it to me i'm gonna take his clothing to the base america the gemara so we had before a mccoy who'd been goddess whether or not you could purchase fish brite i think mars says well even if you say you could it has some oil in it what about the fish itself of course you could buy fish right that's a beautiful bengal goddess but we are talking about we're going to bring here a sheet that says fish are not included fish are different than all other fruits i mean this needs a half hour explanation we'll do it in the four minutes that we have left there's two concepts in the torah satellite cloud cloud one of the things is cloud of product cloud so this is your typical cloud protocol you have a generalization and then a specification it says over here but call you can buy anything you want this is uh and then it says cloud tomorrow we're going to see there's a cloud of pratt just two and there's a pratt and a cloud tonight we're talking about cloud pratt or cloud but this same exact thing could also be called rebuy miyot uriboy i looked in the art scroll what did he say amplification and limitation i don't like it but if you want to be because i don't have anything better really reba means to be marble to to include he calls it amplification it's a very fancy word and limitation okay i don't like it that much let's just call it a reboot mute reboot it's the same thing but it's not the same thing in other words let me just tell you this that if you learn clado prata cloud then throughout the entire entire tire you're going to be learning clavo prata cloud that's your mahalakonda toro and if you're the type of guy or you're the tana that says rebuy me or three boy then the whole time you go reboot me and rework okay so but what's the difference between the two the very big difference is that clown means i'm making generalization and then pratt i'm making a specification so when i specify i'm basically explaining everything i'm explaining this cloud i'm saying this cloud is not like you think it's not everything it's very specific to these things and then i add okay so i added these things but it's it limits you very much when you have a reboot meal and reboot so you're just being minimized a specific thing you're saying the third is not explaining this claudu protocol is more of an explanation when you read this position everything no no no let me explain to you i didn't mean everything i meant let me explain to you what i meant is not an explanation it's more to limit one or two items and therefore i'm going to limit let's say in our case water and salt a limit brine but it's not to explain to you a whole category so says the gemara let's see inside but michael mifflin review them goes i told you we're going through the entire chasse here all different concepts and different things what we learned before those who say that you could use fish it's only in shiloh whether you could use brine of the fish which is review them in goddess river they learn and the thai that we're about to discuss they do the cloud product cloud review [Music] it's a tremendous amplification i hate that word it's like not natural it doesn't flow in the game amplification it's a reboot it includes everything [Music] the final puzzle comes to mind of everything rebuilding it through viriba reba ko so the second one includes everything my robbie what does it mean rabbi call me lay everything um realizing me it's here according to realize that there comes to exclude one item only brine fish well of course salt and water also if dry fish not then certainly salt and water not okay we got this but of course according to us you could purchase brine fish brine did i say brine fish fish brine okay whatever you get the idea but so what is the common comes to be made two items called water and salt vanita protein however the other 109 that now we're finally revealing the sanyo they darshan cloud product cloud this but they learn it a little differently instead of calling it a cloud protocol they call it and they the these particular ones call them claudio product it's a explanation of the entire past of the pratt look at these things so when it's a rebooting me of the reboot i don't learn anything from the meat i'm not saying oh just like salt water is very salty and it's bitter on your tongue so anything that's salty and bitter no that's not how it works i'm just gonna exclude one item that's it but over here this is an explanation the hull means it has to be like this it has to be like the red it explains you what the puzzle is talking about so what what are these things what do they have in common cows sheep wine and sheikh what do they have in common oh my prima foyers prima pri they all grew they all had parents even grapes have parents they have little seeds certainly sheep and uh and and cows wiki do lay carica and they grow off the ground different than all of sha's the in chats usually we say you do the character means they grow from the ground over here it means grow they nourish from the ground animals animals are not they don't come out of the ground but they eat the ground they eat grass from the ground i've called prime privilege so therefore this is the list and what's not on the list salt water things like that not a slight one it's a pretty big one and he says let me tell you something else map ramapharis vlad vladisarets that these things were created from the ground where where the grapes come from the ground where do cows come from where they originate from on day one of creation when they were created from the ground i've called fish were not created from the earth fish were created from gershon the water so if you're gonna say something that nourishes off the ground fish nourished from the ground in the ocean there's ground and they peck at the stones they eat off the ground they eat plants from the ground it's still ground le mandomar pre me pre with the but it has to be created from the ground dog fish were created from water and therefore you cannot purchase fish air of shabbos from your mice and shady money according to this one manda omar that holds cloud of practical cloud but the other mandarin cloud of product cloud says you could have a wonderful night have a wonderful week and there's no tehillim amateur shabbos