Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 25 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rap boys today we're back do me a favor gary could you turn on the lights behind me we're back in the basement i didn't even have time yesterday to say this in case you haven't noticed we're back in the basement soon the lights are going to go on ah there's going to be a door behind me on our koi dish it's going to be a beautiful massive how many people do we have we have a minion here just about and let's keep it like that we got to keep it very very low wow sponsored by mayor finger does anybody remember this guy mayor finger i do he's that kid that uh was in a what no he's the guy that said that he's looking to move out of town okay schmucky guy and sponsored by arie aries lasky lily nishmas eliot joseph should have an alia oh not too much okay great all right one email reboys i it's kind of late already this one is from ronnie sterling from silver spring maryland i've been attending this year since the start of the cm cycle i feel like i have been stalking you since january and i've witnessed close to 200 hours of your life but i've yet to contact you i sincerely appreciate all ever that you put into preparing the illustrations and moving through the daf i find that you do a great job on the more difficult concepts that would have trouble without your deeper dive but the real punchline to how i connect with you is through your constant obviously throw right david and your enthusiasm which i sincerely appreciate thanks for all of the mdy team's dedication my boy said once again i'm asking that everybody have a mask on their nose if not i'm going back home tomorrow basil hashem this is the last chance i'm giving it dolum i did it on condition that the island wears masks thank you thanks for all of the mdy team's dedication i watch him diy youtube and hope to attend in person or in some time or on time some day shikaya karani sterling i have to apologize this is new to me i'm used to being at home by myself i'm like a ben yorked that doesn't know how to get along with the islam so lat lab give me give me a chance and um but barcelona we started on time so that okay here we go we're holding daf hey and it's a pleasant surprise if you turn to that base you'll see it's a very short almond and so was the ramen base and the base is also very short basically all of shas as you know that ahmed bayes is much shorter and much easier than ahmed alef and i've proved that from the beginning of brachas throughout and today is no exception let's see if my credit card works on this new incline that we have no it's still sliding we'll have to use it anyway so we're talking about a car 5 still and we have a car five that's lediro meaning this was for non-residential use wow automatic as you can see there's lumber in here this is a lumber storage and it's more than two saw more than two saw means i cannot carry in it so saying hook of the ubala he wants to do a trick he wants to be able to carry here on shabbos without breaking down the walls so what does he do he reduces the size the inner size of this carfax by planting trees now if you recall yesterday we said that trees don't do much to ruin anything because people plant trees they like the trees in the cariff it's good especially if they're planted straight we even passing you don't have to plant them straight miyabi it doesn't do anything to reduce the size of the carafe therefore it's awesome to carry in it here another picture gary uh is that gary doing it so the camera has a special setting he pushes the button and goes straight onto this picture pushes another button and goes on to here and we got that if you look behind you we have the ptz optic camera best camera on the markets like a 2 000 camera two of them one for zoom and one for youtube all right so you build a beam smack in middle or wherever you want in the middle of the car if the beam is a significant beam in other words this fourth falcon wide and we learned the entire massif the fourth fachem is significant and it's tenth fahm high like so this can reduce the the total area of the kharpav and therefore let's say the car 5 is two saw and three inches and that doesn't allow you to carry the car if you reduce it by a few inches now becomes less than two saw and i could carry in the carafe trees don't work a beam works that's considered a reduction of the chiropractor pakistan what if the beam is like an insignificant beam it's less than three for him but have a meal right if a bunch of leaves fall into your chiropractic that's not going to be a reduction so a small beam means nothing muslim but from three to four we're going to have two mach like this in two cases this case rab anything less than three tvhem is considered that it's attached it's together let's say you have a gap in your fence that's three two and wide we pretend that it's closed in other words anything less than three twichem is insignificant i could be medic that a little bit over threet falcon or three more is significant why do i bridge the gap why do i always say loved if i put a piece of string by a sukkah i could go all the way down to the bottom i could go from strength to stream because anything between threet's fakhem is not significant meaning above three it's welcome is significant ah so i have a beam that's significant it's street says rava what are you talking about but when it comes to say the entire we were saying that you need a real significant area to be fourth falcon the whole time we're talking about fourth falcon where did you come up with three twelve says [Music] limitless love it by the mere fact that i can't say loved on anything more than three two him that means that more than three to beckham is significant less than three falcon is insignificant the fact that more than three trim you can't say love it doesn't mean it's significant it just means that it's not insignificant but in order for something to be significant even though they have them downloaded you need forth fakham to be significant so according to this mandarin is between three and four okay and we're seeing a lot of that mahlikinsen in like a few inches we had by rebecca on a few ammo yesterday we had if it's exactly two saw the machlagues rip same type of case same type of shiloh here's the shiala you have a large karfaf and you want to make it smaller so now we're jumping we're toggling to something else for a second we're not trying to reduce the size of the carafe we're trying to build a new wall in the chira5 why let's say this car valve is 25 saw we said the limit is too soft so by you adding a wall over here you're not going to reduce the size of the of the car you might reduce it minimally but it's still too large to carry in what you want to do is you want to build a wall that's a residential wall we said in order to to flip a car from from not residential from a lumber yard to playground you can't just say it you have to do something so what do you do you build a wall so he built a wall more than four away from the original wall in in pink is not on zoom anymore he's not doing it that's uh oh that's our screen but he's on a different screen okay he's not doing it because you can see it there's only 15 today only 15. all right i stopped counting i stopped numbering them at 12. it might be more than 15. anyway by the way we're taking a big break from pictures from daf to laminate bases there's not a single picture in any of these books we'll see why when we get there so again the reason why i'm making this red line over here is not because i'm trying to reduce the size of the carafe but rather i'm trying to build a new wall like we said yesterday you knocked down a wall and you build a wall so over here i'm building a new wall and when i build it i'm saying to myself this is a residential wall how big does this wall have to be in our has brought down that it only has to be 10 ammos very interesting i could build a 10 ammo wall anywhere in my car like in the line maybe with the other wall but as long as it's not 10 minutes away from this wall it's a good wall even though it doesn't take up the whole side ah here's the picture if you want to see what it looks like on zoom it's over there um the writ for others the rhythm says it has to be the entire wall fine so here's the same shiloh like we have with a with a beam why here if he distanced the the new wall fourth from the original wall and he made him akita hail it's a good majita it's a new brand new wall with the shame he had in mind that should be for residential use hoyo so now your car fav even though it's 25 saw but it's a residential car i just made it residential but less than three it doesn't work why because now it's part it's like as if you built a wall on top of a wall that's a mojito that's nothing as we're going to see soon we had it yesterday so let's say you build one wall on top of another wall you didn't make a new if you have an existing wall of the chiropractic and you add a couple of feet to it you didn't redo the name from non-resident residential it's just building a type of it doesn't work so over here by adding another within three which is lovely love it tells me that they're together they're one so i just added a little bit to the makita it doesn't work say that it works because we see that a little bit by three or more it's no longer leveled therefore a little bit more than three is considered a significant distance so i built my wall significantly further away from the original wall and therefore it's a new wall rubber and email even though they have a magma bar you need four to have a makham khashov you have to have a distance of four for him in order for the the wall to be considered in the wall and all you need is 10 ammo [Music] everybody agrees that it's leveled and it works threet's is love and it works the whole mach like this is below threeth that's how he learns it says if less than three two him is considered a wall or not says the gemara talkbait so now i want to reduce i'm trying the entire time in another case how do i reduce the size of my kaifa yeah mm-hmm i don't know you tell me you have a good shot yeah i don't know but it sounds like a basketball like it comes out of the ceiling sorry can't help you come down to this world coming to the esmedras we'll be able to help you okay here's another way gary hit the button here's another way that you reduce the size of the kaif by adding a layer of cement to the wall so let's say we said a sosaim this is tusa what is it 50 ammo by 100 ammo so if i have 50 arm and 100 and a fraction of ammo i can't carry there anymore so what i do i lay on a little cement and gray over here and like that i reduced it so let's say i laid on a alma of cement now i brought it down to 99 ammo out of cement is two feet of cement that's a serious piece of cement it's a nice wall if i remove this flimsy fence my cement is going to stand there forever says the gemara i need that um i lost my my piece and oh yeah yeah yeah show me rock i'm back to that thing again okay um no it's not here i have one it's just the slipping it's on an incline talk about it i need david hagal's thing here talk about you put some cement and it's so strong it's so thick to cement it could stand on its own have a meal that's a significant reduction of the cariff and we're good any yakalam atsuma you put a a layer of lime like they do here in israel they put a a quarter of an inch if you remove the wall the cement falls down omar rabbi have a meal attached to me who cares if you remove the original wall or fall down but right now you have a nice piece of cement it's standing and as long as the wall is there it will stand so it's great says no at the end of the day you can't consider it a significant wall and reduction if it cannot hold its own and since if you remove the wall it will fall down like lumo it's not a reduction to the cariff you cannot carry in that car valve we're like in the middle of the page like 20 lines down case after casemak here's the story i had to switch to this uh for these pictures whatever i believe is a better picture that's what i'm going to use i'm not tied into the million dollar book this is the million dollar book had a very um it wasn't as noticeable to tell over here you can see that there's a mountain there's a mountain in the middle of your caravan from the mountain to here you have more than two saw and it's enclosed for non-residential use i can't carry here so what do i do i build a wall i build a new wall new wall is great but here's the problem if the new wall is too close to the mountain to the mound of dirt then it's as if i built a wall on top of a wall because a mountain is a wall and we said before you know i build a wall on top of a wall what what's going on the basketball somebody's fighting with this kid and we have to hear it all right that's it so if he built it says the imam like it's very simple if he built the wall on the mound everybody agrees on the bottom of the mound the mound itself is a wall halal right we had telamus locket right rise to run that you could use a mound as a wall so if i build my new wall on the bottom of the mound then i'm building a wall on top of a wall wall on top of all is not good so if i distance it forward from the mound then it's a proper brand new wall i built the wall of sham residential use it's hook of ladiero now all this area becomes motor for me to carry in here what if it's less than three take them away from the mound of dirt or on the mount of dirt um one of them says it doesn't work one of them says it works says the more i'll prove to you that's that says that it works this time we want so first let's say the first allah if i build a wall on top of a wall for shabbos it's great that's our case we're talking about jabba's i want to be able to carry in this area right over here i built a wall right where this is considered a luckily a wall you don't see it's an invisible wall corner is the building a wall on top of a wall it's okay it doesn't work what's next again if a convert dies without children has nobody that can inherit him then all his belongings are hefcker so you could go and grab it what do you do you build a wall on top of a wall he has a nice wall around this property you're going to build another two feet nothing loyal that's not that's not how you kind of how you kind of got the knowledge you have to do like we learned in in bubba bassro you have to lock up the property you have to break the property stir up the dirt a little bit we're going to see interesting story about this we have to say it doesn't work those are the two sheets here it doesn't work on shabbos to style so you see that is the one that says that works on shabbos so so too in our case if you build a mojito right by the amount of dirt hoyo it works who argues with me and says that on top of another makita doesn't work on shabbos what's going on here here's the mound of dirt he builds a mojito around now rashi over here seems to say like this picture that it's four four walls around although enchilada has brought down one wall fine but he's accurate according to ashi now the you see this mountain this is a wall right here and the continuation of the wall are these pieces of wood that he stuck in here as a majita now we just said that according to have sheishas there's no mikhita on top of in this case it does work why says the gemara what does that mean because he's living on top of the mountain and he doesn't have any walls he has a wall you know what kind of wall an invisible halachic wall but that doesn't help him because the cats keep on coming into his property he can't keep out the the bad guys so what good is this invisible wall for him so mamela since he's building a visible wall even though it's right on top of an invisible wall it works halal because the two wipes it who's to zaif ooh i'm forgetting my yiddish now two wife i know but it it already happened it was open fine the point is that since even ravshes who says you cannot build a wall on top of a wall in other words it doesn't work for shabbos and this is literally a wall on top of a wall because look you see this mound of dirt that's a great wall it goes all the way up to the sky yet if i build a physical wall and it helps my deorium because i live in ba'advira el ya and i live up here so he'll have to admit that it's a good majita for shabbos what he's because he's making a physical monkeys and now cats can't come into this property he just to life that cats can't come into this bravery so that itself is enough to make it if you don't do anything with your numerical you just put a makita on top of a another mechita that doesn't do anything and if the second piece doesn't help it doesn't do anything over here it helps because he lives on the top part and he he always wants he told his wife he wants to buy him a pizza and his wife told him why do you need him the robbers can't come in because good asking and he said what are you talking about they do come in so he went and he built this thing and it helped him they don't come in anymore mma law that's considered for shabbos even refugees would admit where does he live he lives in the aliyah and he lives up above he's the hype in a man she lives up there and he needs boy rabbits said in case you didn't hear he said there was a wife that somebody poured water on her but it was a cliche she and she didn't scream because unluckily it doesn't burn that's what he said are you making fun of the cliche isn't that okay fine we didn't hear anything avi we didn't hear boy noise now oh to life now we're going to say the dawn's going to start talking about two dive what if this makita two dive in other words you built a machita type of mojito so it doesn't do anything because it's already there there's already machines but on shabbos there's quicksand you built it on quicksand and the entire thing got swallowed by the ground the entire original makita got swallowed what was left your brand new mojito your brand new pizza just accomplished a lot two dog means a combo it accomplished then now you have a mojito before it didn't do anything because there's one on top of the other but now since the original disappeared now it comes out retroactive that what you built was a perfect mojito but when did it come out when did we find the south on chavez now if we found this out on friday of course yumekit is a good mojito beautiful you built the majid originally you did you didn't accomplish anything but before shabbos you we see that you did accomplish but since it happened on chavez what's that what's the shiloh if you want to buy you want to be koino not by you want to be kinda everything that he owns with these with these that didn't accomplish anything but today they we figured out it did accomplish hainu the if somebody takes a turnip without touching the ground one it doesn't touch one uh what's the word uh no a piece of dirt not even one uh grain i love smack over envy author i'd rather have the doctor than the author one what particle's not good because you wouldn't put it in your book you put a grain of salt grain a particle of salt or grain of salt i roast yes a grain of dirt so what are you saying particle dirt okay we're gonna argue now i'm gonna get 15 emails a sticker okay you're right it is i don't know how to say particles no no no okay everybody said we'll discuss this later on so what do you what is it what does this hoverman do he takes a turnip and he finds a crack in the ground you know like the ground is all dry he puts the turnip in the hole without touching the ground because if he would touch the ground what would happen it would be his just by stirring up the ground he didn't do anything he threw the tournament pin what happened a week later rain came there ten turnips grew says the gemara since he threw it into hole the ara daguerre in the land of the convert was israel then comes the second guy and stirs it up a little bit bastard connie kamala connie the second guy is kind of and not the first guy so if i build a wall and it i don't accomplish anything and then by itself the ground swallowed up the original wall and now i'm left with my second wall it's just like me planting a turnip and a week later i get some paris out of it but i didn't do anything today therefore he's not kind of the property with the wall that he built my time of the it not the shuttle when he built the wall he didn't accomplish anything he didn't improve the property and when it happened a week later after after there was some sort of quicksand situation that happened by itself not by his doing it's like planting a turnip and by not you doing anything it grew veloli in chavez having a shabbos oh we're all familiar with this so what are you telling me that it happened on chavez so isn't that considered a mojito that happens by itself and we had the continuation of this if you have a mojito that happened it's a good mojito so what's the problem [Music] lizard means again lizard means to to throw and that always refers to a riser that if i threw something into a place that i built a merchant or it happened by itself in shabbos i'm will never allow you to carry within an area that you built the mechita on shabbos says they only gave you a knack when you did it on purpose you built the fence on shabbos now you want to carry they said stop the rice here right it's a good mojito but since you did it on chavez we're going to punish you but over here that it happened by itself the quicksand happened by itself it should be a perfect mojito says good morning there was a woman who lived next door to a convert and she realized that he's about to die so she kept on visiting him kilo like she's trying to be nice to him and and he has a 2.6 million dollar mansion and then he what exactly by mistake she stepped on the plug and he died and then what did she do the abdomen she goes and she spends 150 and she takes the the the fence that she had that the guy had around his house she made it like a fence in south africa if you ever went to south africa 15 20 foot fences around every single house with barbed wire in that fifth hundred thousand hundred fifty thousand dollars because it's a giant mansion beautiful now she's all excited she she's kinda the next aguero comes the guy from davio me he learned aloha he comes with his plastic fork and he went like this he stirred up the dirt in the front yard she starts crying and screaming carrying the belt turn over the world oh my lord i can't help you out no i'll go to pirates stirring the ground is how you do how you kind of not by building a hundred fifty thousand dollar wall what no it was already a mojito she it was you're right if she would have made a new makita to begin with great all she did is improved and existed that doesn't do anything another story beautiful story not a story case so if you have three saw of a karfaf you can't carry it right so what did this guy do he built a pergola over one saw how much are you left with two saw yeah left with two saw you'll add a carrying two saw is it considered that you have three saw or two so what are we looking at over here does this reduce the carafe by just having a gazebo over there by having a pergola that's the shia la rava mar aver kiri of miata says he didn't accomplish anything by building a pergola it's as if you have three saw and then three so you can't carry verbs because rip zero holds the concept of pea tigra yaya the soism the edge of the roof goes downwards allah this is one of the messina is he goes downwards says the gemara robert zero before this story a guy builds a pergola smack in the middle of the desert i have look you see i have four walls they're invisible but they're full of damage they're nothing you don't say peter gravier besides him and all i get is four atms i can get in every surrounding every caramelist so is that the same machis as by us why because i mean and peter you ever saw some you don't say the kinds of peep degree ever since we're turning that coffin base sponsored by asher lee lindesh massey's mother rosie basman yum in make it a great day what make it a great day oh we already have a customer it wants to make it a great day and by dr lustaus is his father remarkable if it looked exactly like this pergola nice and flat everybody agrees that this p thicker yard of assaism there's no machogs in this case it's going to go down in other words by us the people that are arguing by us robzera and everybody and his friend rav nuna they're all going to agree that it goes peter gary versus him it's not the same mclaughlin is the raven smoke the avadoki or zilo it's not flat it's a pitched roof it's something like this so this if you look at it logically speaking it continues this way why would i go down this way so maybe it's a pro maybe it's problematic it's on an incline it's on a pitch maybe continue the pitch visually you just go in the direction of the roof so you don't have a p-tick or you ever say them so that's the mach legs by us so again when robzers says pete ticoriary some in our case where he built a pergola in his three saw the pergola that he built is not this pergola that with a flat roof because the flat roof there's no mach like is that it goes down and cuts off the property and here's a property that's too soft i'm a lot of carrying two so here's the property that's one saw i could carry the one saw and therefore i could carry the entire car the macholicus is because it's on an angle and since it's since it's on an angle ramuluna says you don't say peter you ever saw him and i'm left with three saw which asteroids me to carry in the entire cariff bomber zero um dino and i admit even though i just said a second ago in a case where i want to reduce my car from three to two by building a gazebo but here's another case that i want to reduce my karfav and i admit that it doesn't work um here basically you have a carafe and a cutter and they're completely separated by a wall there's a wall i built this carafe for non-residential use then the wall falls down so now my chiropractor is wide open into a hotel now how big is this chiropract two saw zero zero i add one inch to the carafe it becomes also for me to carry in it right now i could carry it because it's two saw zero zero by this wall falling down did i just add to the chiropractor did i just make it a slightly larger than two saw says rubzeria yes um i'm gonna take a little bit of the green grass and add it to my car and now i have a little bit more than two saw oh now that's the gemaro wait a minute how could that be masculine think about it i'm allowed to carry in here because it's too soft you're a lot of carrying two so in my backyard are you allowed to carry a thousand percent it's a backyard it's booker vladiro so how could two rights make a wrong i'm allowed to carry in the green i'm glad i carry the yellow and because you opened one to the other so now i'm going to take a right and make the other right wrong how can i do that how could a little bit more motor area make another motor area larger area to make it awesome doesn't make sense i'll explain to you he tells her of yosef is rebbe i have a grape shot chemical rib shimmy your whole back and forth could only work according to rip shipment up until now why because retrieval is of the opinion that i'm allowed to walk from a car after you're just saying that i'm taking a little bit of here and putting it over here according to the comment where i cannot walk from here to here so now i have a area that's awesome for me to go to if it's also for me to go to carry in i cannot carry from here there gordon so automatically they both become muscle because it's pirates like no i'm saying pirates into the area that i can't go to so maybe obviously we're talking about it for shimon shimmer says i couldn't walk from one to the other i could carry from one to the other so what's the problem so i'll tell you what the problem is let's find this one somewhere oh avoided how did it get messed up here's one picture here's another one let's go with this one oh he has my real picture that i wanted with the colored red and blue but we'll go with this picture for now you see the dotted yellow line here there used to be a wall here and the wall fell down what was this area with the dotted yellow line it wasn't much of ledira you can't live under a wall so at most it's not residential so that area or whatever thickness of the wall is let's call it a half a foot of wall you add that to the carafe now your car 5 is more than two saw not from the green it's not shot that you want to take from the green the green is mutual area that you're right doesn't shouldn't be allowed to to be added to the kaifa but what you're doing is you're taking the area of the wall says the gemara and i'll prove it to you says and is going in the sheet of now in the beginning let's talk about what according to your according to you're not permitted to carry from the carafe into hotzer and from a roof into the hot turn from a hudson into a carafe right you can't go from one property to another property therefore chiropractic shouldn't first be our case that a chiropractor was broken into a hutter hatsumu teres the kharafaf also you're allowed to carry in the hotzer why because the hotzer's mook of ladeera look at this it has four walls around so i could carry in here but i cannot carry the in the clutzer now what's my time there's this like fufe so you have to explain if you hold like the only reason you're allowed to carry in this hotzer let me see if i have the picture printed yeah here this one it has giffe meaning when you're in the hotzer looking from your house let's say you see walls beautiful walls so in his brain he's enclosed by four walls that's a little open here but you could continue the fufe right we had a hat we had that says the gemara but you forgot about another case what about this case they look very similar to the pictures let me show you the side to side in this case when you're in the clutter you don't see any walls it's it's wide open into the carafe so in this case it should be a problem where you don't have walls like in this case now we have to go back that is the whole grip that you could go from one area to the next area you could carry from one to the other elegin so once again we're going back to this isabella we must say you're forced to say that we consider this area where was which was under the wall before it fell down and it's a lay hook of ladies non-residential area and i add it to my car fav i don't add it to my hotzer i add to my car phone because it's not residential and my my car 5 doesn't have gefufe and therefore now my carpet became larger than two saw and i cannot carry in my character we have one minute to do this again we're only doing four lines now there was an orchard avatar lagudada padna look at this mice what happened this is a beautiful from the million dollar book somalihim how are you there's a mansion a palace and it's open to an orchard now the only lifeline that this orchard has this orchard is surrounded by mercies this is not residential orchard but because it has a wall that leads me into the palace so becomes residential so what happened the entire wall fell down let me show you what it looks like and i'll show you why i printed another picture for a second here's the million dollar picture from the million dollar book you see the wall broken down nunu here's the izadar now you could see into the mansion this is important for us i'm going to go with this one now rabbi said you know what you're right that the wall fell down but there's a wall with the mirror and the you see the dining room wall inside deep inside that should be the wall for the orchard i have another wall that was much of ledira i built what's the whole point when i built my palace i built this wall with d-ro and that made my whole orchard ladiero guess what i have another wall my dining room wall over here is also i built it yes it's uh it's a interior wall but it was mook of ladiero oh you have to understand david we have to understand how this works sometimes they used to insult each other a little bit it says like this because you come from a family that don't live very long i'm receiving so you're saying things that don't have legs to them you're saying you're saying they're interior walls they're made out of drywall they're three inches thick they're made for your dining room living room separation they're not made for your orchard how could you use them for for a mook of ludhira end of the story rabbits i have a wonderful wonderful day and now a special basketball rendition of tehillim from noam figs [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music]