Daf Yomi Eruvin Daf 24 by R’ Eli Stefansky

hey good morning rabbi sai surprise surprise if you haven't been with us before we just came back to the basement for the first time in how long too long we're giving it a try everybody promises to be on their best behavior masks etc social distancing today's share is being sponsored in honor of my beloved son much after he's a great kid he's on zoom every single day he's a 13 year old from montreal if you recall he had a goat during his video during the season so his father is saying for putting in so much energy and effort in rebellion always touched a little sadness as it's for his birthday which was yesterday in honor of my birthday i'd like to honor them today that the nazis murdered his that entire family uh whatever it's hard to read it's a little bit out of order made the learning of so many bring them i'm sure they're [Music] in the house and two tremendous simchas today big parts of our share sponsored by dove at address mazel tov to my son eliot dress and you hooded horowitz on their wedding today in woodmere new york he's the machabir the balman nagin it's all about the young man he's the one that put out the video sponsored by israel goldstein we all know you still go through bar park for the source of my daughter's wedding that's taking place from tonight the civic should be oily yuffa and they should build the bias number b through oh man all right your boys say no time for emails so i'll skip all this just one very very short one this comes from this comes from moisha zarat somebody just waved to me i should wave off the emails i'd rather wave off the gemara than just moved to the neighborhood four days ago he made aliyah i'm not exactly sure from where from highland park from highland park no where's yeah yeah he sat right next to me for a month and he says please give the following message to her belly i so much enjoyed the scene bro and the ruach that i resolved to move to the neighborhood what he means he made an aliyah and moved to this neighborhood based on the experience you had by the seam my wife so much enjoyed your wife's warmth at the table at the cm that night that she wholeheartedly endorsed the move moishe zarat so the leo should be off whatever you say okay this one we'll have to read a different thing going into some serious beautiful irvin sugis here you have a karafev a carpath is an enclosed area that's not for residential use at this point now this one happens to be residential use oh lily nishmas does it say it here look at that with that with this mirror kind of should there's something something that's like uh when you built this thing you built it because you wanted it for residential use that's why you enclosed the whole area says if you planted most of it now i didn't have patience to print two pictures this one picture that looks like this here two pictures this these are vegetables you planted vegetables these are trees so let's say but this is not the picture i'm looking for because this is not rhubarb he plant this is less than roof up to the fen up to the up to the gate is half right so over here he went way over the halfway line he planted most of it this is a java mean of the gemara hyreo kigin of ulcer now if you plant vegetables in your chiropractic you can't walk on vegetables who walks on vegetables so it's not for residential use so therefore it answers it answers the whole karifaf ah sir now this is that we're going to take with us through this if you have one area that's usur so even though this area right here is mutter but everything becomes also because this area the motor area is open to the user area and anything that's open to an other area becomes asur so this entire karafab becomes asur okay this sugi by the way goes like eight lines down to the top of dalaran and that's it so let's hold cub just for this suggest here this is the tough one for today maybe it might be lying a little bit so malay from zoom guys you're far away from me but i see eye rodenstein and i see the whole island okay great rasnar and that i hear you perfectly no i'm louder than in my own house you're scary you're coming out of these massive speakers zoom in on the pictures who's who's in charge that's gary and the sound is very very green okay that's the the first day we have we had an issue with the with the sound that's why we didn't start right away okay thanks uh menachem is supposed to be doing the pictures where is he he's not doing it today he's coming on soon oh he's on good ellie dykman is in his regular spot top left corner i see uh the the lin kid gevaldic everybody's in place ten minutes we have david feinberg here which by the way tomorrow he's already you know the ten minute guy fight zog mara nisraru boy hareyo kiginova osser but if you planted trees like in this picture somebody zoom in on this here goes on zoom this is fine why people walk through trees you don't walk on tomatoes and tomatoes but you walk through the trees this is beautiful you planted it nicely for your garden so this doesn't do anything umoter nizoruboying oh my rav who is this is a havamin rabbi so don't get excited if he planted more than two saw let's say in this picture he planted more than two saw and it's more it's the raw it's 51 percent which happens to be two things 51 percent and it's too so la morenolo it has to be a little bit more than two saw avo motor if it's exactly two saw we have three measurements three measurements right by side less than two saw more than two saw and two saw zero zero under that and we're to see that the macholicus is on zero zero under that so right now in the half meter gemara says that if it's exactly two saw motor you're allowed to carry now what's going on here so the mars brings uh uh a much like us there are three areas this is the roof you see on top of this guy's a roof you have a carafe this whole thing and a hutter hold on chavez you cannot carry from one to the other it's like going from one which is to another resource so can i jump off my my roof and carry something into here or from here into here so a corner of shimon is not a problem according to her shimon i could go from my carafe from a planted area into my clutter they don't they don't make it also for each other so therefore if i'm at zero zero at two saw two saws a motor area so far according to according to everybody some other area so it doesn't answer me and what's the what's the other problem that perhaps i can't walk from here into here that's the problem but i could according to and i could walk from here to here because there's no such thing as going from one which is to the other according to shipment the only issue is going from a house and directions but for one which is not a problem hold on we're going to get we're going to tighten this up a little bit we'll understand it great motor camera goes rooftops courtyards carpify these guys so it's considered one which is like you go from one to the other that's not a problem we're going to say the reverse and when we say the reverse you'll understand exactly what we're talking about the lord the killer however and this is the difference sugar he holds that you're right if something was in the house and was taken out of the house into the clutzer now you're not going to move from the hotel to some some other issues that's not important for now that's the gemara and we're going to go away from this and then we're going to come to the mascara and we're going to clamp down on this what's the case the case is that he planted only exactly two saw perfect two saw but it happens to be that's 51 percent of this enclosure so if it's 51 percent that's arrived and arrive you have to take the whole carf and consider the rife you hear hello you have to take the roive and consider that this whole thing is part of whatever is going on here this is let's say this is 51 here there's a better picture for this for a second here we can see it more clearly this is arrived right everybody sees that there's more trees than empty area so who cares about this small area this small area should become part of the trees now what do you have sorry i said rove 50 percent exactly so maybe this picture forget this picture 50 i'm 50. that's the gemara but now this uh no sorry rove back to this hold on this whole move you see what you did to me masks you're sitting on a stable no no i said i'm going to call him i said i'm going to call him talk to him tell him invite him anyways it's mario now if you have arrived now this should go to the river this should go to the planted area and make it arrive says the gemara kevin is what happened there all you have is two saw exactly you're calling this tusa right but it should be a little bit more than too soft why because of this empty area this empty area should go together with the two saw and make it two subplots two saw everybody agrees you can't carry in right two sub plus all you have now is to saw so this meat a meal always goes after the rave this meal should be part of the trees pretend there's trees planted here and now all of a sudden instead of having exactly three saw you have two soft plus it should be awesome okay so we're going away from that says the gemara oh i need this guy this guy is very important says gumbaro about the gabby rubber heavily careful so it turns in to a chiropractor that's more than two saw the uh sir look at the standard ah i have different compartments throw things in there but i don't have a water holder that's a problem if you have any closure that's more than two so we've got it was built for residents now nisra rubai if most of that area was planted seeds no good so now ravuna is saying something else homie uttashari but let's say a part of it the lesser part of it was planted so again i'm telling you right now we're almost done five more lines we're done so if he's spacing it out and it's too complicated and i don't know what i'm talking about five more lines that's only when do i say that it's multicarry there when it's not suicide now let me just tell you real quickly here's what we have here this is the mascara make it easy okay if someone planted less than half of what he has right now if he planted more than half whatever it is i don't care how big it is more than that everybody holds this also you ruined it but let's say he planted less than half of what he has half of the area you see here's the gate the gate is the 50 line he planted less so depends how much he planted in that less in the 49 of the enclosure how much did he plant how much is 49 if it's you see the red red is no good if it's more than two saw everybody agrees you cannot carry here in everything this would answer on this part also if it's less than two saw everybody agrees to get the green light everybody agrees that you could carry here why less than two saw everything becomes bottle here you could carry in everything now if it's exactly too soft this planted area is exactly exactly through saw mach like shimon listen to this this is this is geshmaq why reps look at saying amazing thing say if this is exactly two saw are you allowed to carry an exactly to saw yes so then why is this whole area awesome here's the hop the hop is because according to you're allowed to carry here but you're not going to carry from here to here it's awesome to go from here to here it's tourish right it's like going from a rooftop to hotzer from a hudson to karafev so i can't go from here to here okay over here oh so now this area i can't carry into here so this is it's open to an area where i can't carry if i can't carry then it answers it on me anytime i'm open to an area where i can't carry then everything becomes user so if i'm standing here and it's too so so too so significant it doesn't become bottle so i cannot carry from here into here then everything becomes also just tremendous hop you hear what's going on here no let's do it again shear is over today at 8 45 for boise yeah what did i say open same word no okay we have two saw of this planted area tusa halachically if this was enclosed with a fence you could carry inside two saw because it's not more than two swords two saw zero zero but because have another that says you're not allowed to carry from one type of virtuous to another type of resource and these are two different types this is called the kharfaf this is called the khatsar so i can't go from here to here so now and they they are wide open to each other there's no fence over here so mamelia can't carry either of them they answer each other on each other but that's only because you hold you cannot carry from here to here but of course derbyshire says that you could carry from one to the other so you're allowed to carry this whole thing because there's no one area that asserts on the other area [Music] from one area to another and just the flip side we're just going to do the other side of here we may dip the mast in the cooler and he says the opposite that what we're not going to rabbana we're going going there beshiman hamiyoto shari it says that if you plant it on the road you answer the whole kharifa but it's mashmal marshmallow if you do a miot if you're like in this picture you didn't plant most of the character if you planted less than 50 percent it's you're allowed to carry on in other words shimon holds that if it's exactly too soft zero zero it's motor y because one area doesn't answer on the other area and it's only two saw available but more than two saw according to everybody everybody agrees that if it's more than two so you can't carry there if it's less than two saw everybody agrees they could carry there if it's exactly too saw according to a shipment you could carry there because one area doesn't answer on the other area it's also if it's exactly do so because one area asters on the other area very good says the gemara brandon everybody said forget that okay forget that we just learned that bran so if you plant trees like where's that picture here if you plant trees not grass you'll it doesn't answer anything because it's part of your garden you have nice trees everything is great says gemara wait a minute omar have you done a video that's only if it's planted beautifully in nice rows where it's easy to walk through but if it's like one of those uh you know crazy terrains you can there's three hair tree there you can't walk through so you can't you can't use it comes awesome i remember this rav nachman we're gonna have him in a second half of the suburbs says i don't care how you plant your trees you plant them crooked a tree is a tree it's not a tomato you could walk there it doesn't answer your carafe says the amara's story marijuana is a place where the trees were planted all sloppy they come in value and they were carrying within them says you have to plant them perfectly in order to carry there oh my lay i don't care if nothing's relay i don't know like that i hold and that's what the rush pass kills like revlachman you could plant them sloppy and it doesn't ruin it trees do not ruin your karafev if you have an enclosed area that wasn't built for residential use case advice [Music] very important allah we're learning major al-aqsa today in arabic if i have a car fav and it was built for i don't have a good picture for these guys for the lumber it's a lumber yard i cannot one day decide oh you know i want to use it for my family i want to make it a playground for my kids you can't do that so what do you have to do you have to knock it down and build it over again or there's a easier eight says the camaro okay pirates by appear to yourself you break it open more than ten i was i thought i had a picture somewhere oh he has the picture take that thing off yeah here it is how come i don't have it i don't know okay somewhere it's on zoom right by side turn oh here it is it's just not in the right order i break down the wall only 10 hours now we learned many times if it's less than 10 ounces that's not considered a break in the wall why that's opening it's a door doorway doesn't ruin my car oh if i knocked down the wall 10 amaze i just knocked down my entire car hola quickly and all i have to do is rebuild 10 amaz priced by pizza sms if i go through and then i build it back umuta now becomes i built my new car five when i built up the wall 10 minutes i built it for residential use umotor part time of a goddard ammo what if he didn't knock down tenamas he knocked down one ammo and rebuilt it and he repeated that ten times no everybody's looking at us and saying what's going on there of course he didn't do anything he only built it he knocked on a nama and put back in amma so at any given time the wall was complete who cares that he did it 10 times right that's your typical logic but guess what just like we had yesterday digimore is going to go against our logic he did this ten times but at every given time he only had a one ammo breach in the get there in the fence and therefore he never broke down his fence at any given time of this when you have a wooden clay and it has a hole in it if it's the size of an olive people don't throw it out why because they could put the larger fruit in there whatever is larger than now the next step up and that it keeps on going until it gets to the size of a pomegranate once it gets to the size of a pomegranate the guy throws out his clay and we said that only applies to private people but if he's in a store and he's selling caleb even if it has a small hole the size of an olive he'll throw it out right away boys same question that we have right now what happens if you kept on having small holes like you see in this picture a small cause is plugged it up a small cause eyes plugged it up and it keeps on going small small small plug plug plug until he has the entire size of a pomegranate he's doing beautifully guys if you look over there on his little arrow mata the man i can do it again show them how you do it all around ah give out do they add up the answer is yes they add up so if it adds up over here it's going to add up by us by a fence i knocked down one ammo put it back knocked on another output no another ammo until i have tanamas i broke my entire fence because uh until he had a full pomegranate said rebbe shanice alana you told us sando oh boy so you probably remember this from seth the shabbos if you were with us then i didn't want to go with the i don't want to cheat i want to take out of the old picture so you guys remember remember the sandal here's the znaim here's the tarziosov we had this now one of these red guys i wanted to slip you up over there i didn't put this is from chavez deficio food base but okay he has a different picture it's a nicer shoe i have to tell you but maya's name are much better so the red one of the reds went came off and he fixed it so tommy madras so the tomah that dissolve by stepping on it put into the shoe remains tommy nifsikoshnia with but if he removes if you remove the second one and by the when you remove the second one the first one is already fixed we're not going to go into that it still has some sort of tomah depends how you learn rashi here rasheen chavez it has a little bit of a little residue of of tumor of considered a regional tumor ah here let's get to the end you'll see what the mars says varma sallallahu here maishna rishona the kaimushniya when the first strap came off you said no it remains completely tum of the tommy the shoe why because it has one more strap and the problem is when the second strap came off the first strap was there it was already fixed at any given time there was one strap left that's pretty much our question and hours ago at any given time he had nine amis he had a full fence only one armor missing and you told us over there this is a brand new shoe pony had a s you take everything that happened in the past you put them all together and at the mice at the end of the day we had a breach here that was 10 wide we had a shoe that was missing two straps we have a a dish that has a whole a hole the size of a pomegranate it all adds up and mamela that's why in our sugya it's as if he broke down the wall and he rebuilt it and it's a good car valve corey alley lays dane this is not a human being unbelievable what are you saying this is a human by the way i'll remind you the gemara over there says that he's a human if he's a human then what are we so it says if they're like malachim the next generation is human and if they're human what are we we're like donkeys not only donkey is not just a dog not the donkey ever but stam donkeys fine and i saw the micellar reverse i saw in the dhamma to i saw the academic to the guy with the leo he says there he says like oh so if the tana i mean are our donkeys so what are we and he says rabbi said we are there's a gemara over there also in shadows like two dot before that that uh if a woman wants to stop her ziva she should take the barley that's within the dung so we are not even barley that's within the dung and when i read that i was like what about gaiva how could a guy write about himself that he's such an honor such that dark vanova that's already guyva that's what i was thinking when i was reading that says the gemara what [Music] if you have this back what is it called um outlet the slot in the back what is it this is behind we have pictures of it basically it here right over here hurry about them doesn't it's behind the houses not in the front this is not the picture for now but you see this is the back of the house the backlot oh back left so let's call it by the way i missed the whole the the whole sugi rashi keeps on saying it's a carl's communist comments every time it's oscar it's a caramel it's fine but this is also this is considered like a caramelist this is a makkum user but even in a caramelist you could carry four amis you could carry even aurora's raven for ramas so that's why he says oh you get four amis [Music] but if he opened up a door from his house into it here like this he has a door you'll have to carry there wait a minute pesach material because the door makes it that's only if he had a door he built a house with a door going into a backyard and then he enclosed it but if you have this guy first and then you open up a door that's too late we said that before right once you have a chiropractor the only way out of it is to break it down or break down 10 amaze we can't just open up a little door to it and say oh now it's residential use put up a sign uh from now from today on it's not a lumber yard from today on it's a backyard it's a playground it doesn't work says the gemara applause what do you mean if you built a house and you built a giant backyard for your kids posture that it's mother what's the big deal that's this picture right over here that bait dari means he's doing he has a uh a wheat plant over here he's doing his he does he's he's taking care of his is this is his business he grinds it he look he has a he has a donkey here that's that's uh threshing it the whole thing so i would think that even though he decided he screamed out this is my kid's playground but look the donkey proves that it's not the weed proves that it's not commercial alone that it is says the gimbal karpa somebody so saying gary let me see what it looks like on zoom for a second if you don't mind like character have you guys made some science video i don't see blow it up for a second i want to see what it looks like on the zoom what no could you blow it up please for a second that picture it should take up the whole screen okay carpenter if you guys invasive time sugarload how i don't see okay fine caviar is invasive sugar i see something else i see a big dory all right rabbi say another case we're going through cases of going through our lockers amazing stuff what if a guy has a swimming pool in his backyard he has a car fire full of water what's that sovereign you can't step in it so it's like uh planted tomatoes and cucumbers you can't step on it so becomes awesome omelette the brother of rover the son of beret the raven showers made the rabbit this is what they said in the name of rava mayim kinder time dumbo it's this the swimming pool is not like a bunch of vegetables this is more like trees turning to the roman bay sponsored by asher leadership's mother rosie basman yeoman make it a great day and shemas house no you think we could do this ahmed in five minutes we do regular i'm within there are much larger five you have to be able to drink the water now if you can drink the water that's the most residential possible drink we said anytime you have a bar you have this it makes you residential so if you could if it's drinkable great even if it's you can drink it it's only on condition that the depth the deep end with the lifeguard is is tenth fahrenheit that's deep and it's not more the entire area by the yellow lines between the yellow lines i don't know if you can see it on the picture is not more than two in other words you don't have two saw that's tense oscar the whole entire backyard is awesome once you have an area that saucer and the rest is open to that area the whole thing is awesome villain milsi says the gimbal mistake just like a mound of fruit in the middle of your backyard doesn't answer your whole backyard so a mound of water a deep hole of water doesn't ask for anything oh raboisa here we go this is the picture of mr sequin so far it is very detailed and very very geshemak actually we have a side view and a front view all sorts of views here's what's going on let me give you the map hello do not leave now by the best picture of aravind yeah versus rob him here you have a river over here you have a movie this is called the muscle that's what's going to be called there the muscle motherboard that goes into the surrounding the movie leads into a rehova this is a backlot really bad problem you cannot carry in a backlot this is a giant backlot it was built for non-residential use no way to carry in this thing then you have a shivoham a pathway that goes through the vineyards this is a true story there's a story that happened in this place so you have vineyards not important to us really but this path leads into the water guess what goes from there just around to the water animals people try to bring it's a nice beach so they bring the animals to drink so what do we have here again we have a path that leads into uh us or place to carry that leads into almavoi that leads into there's rabbit what happened was they wanted to take away they wanted to make the recover they want to make the rehab multitude to carry on in chavez now what's a good way to make it multitude to carry on chavez knock down no hold on we're going to go through that knock down the wall knock down one of these walls rebuild it with in mind that it's now residential use but they don't want to do that it's too much work it's a big wall it's a nice cement wall they don't want to do it so the mark is going to go through four options what we can possibly do here let me show you the four options real quickly option number one is build a wall by the entrance to the beach i put it in red red lines over here red condom no good not a good option now by the way we're we're talking about this at surah passa by the rishi so therefore this movie has three sides so another option would be putting a tsurasa pesach by the entry way to this swillacromim this pathway that leads to the through the vineyard because look there's vines on both sides it's a path through the vineyard another option would be to put a lucky a blue stick right over here leading into the rehava into the open area and alechi on this side by the end of the srivakram leading to the on this side by the mahvoid leading into the those are the four options says what do we have a minute start a little late i get a little credit oh you're a boy side why is this backwards only over here everybody else is backwards okay i believe you that's why i said i want to see i want to understand i like the new standard buzz you like the new standard the normal questions why i think the lights are not on and they're uncreated but i think okay tomorrow it's going to be the better says again like this is the name of the place there's the backlot that is very problematic for us one side have a so one side was opened and the other side of the one side goes to the mavoi one side goes into the path that goes through the vineyard and the path leads into the water what's the best idea for them which is going to cost the least amount of problems and money leveling if they're going to make them over here by the water and this water by the way some giant mojito look at this mojito you see 10 fahrenheit that's considered a mojito so if i'm going to make another merch it's on top of it it's as if you just added dirt to this pile of on the beach you raised it up and that's nothing so you can't add another mojito here so that one is bye bye [Music] here by this red by the entry to the vineyard that's problem also gam leveling left okay no no more but it's okay we got this it won't be he went to the bathroom bathroom berry he's back so if i do it seriously by the opening to the srila krame what's going on there's a nice picture in kalalashan you have camels you don't need a picture camels come to drink all the time and they're going to rough it up they're going to knock it down so what do you do hello episode let's put a tiny little blue guy over here alechi la he explains rashi could be a it's as thin as paper it's just ten twelfth tall camel's not gonna rub himself on the lucky it'll stay there for a long time and why and how does this work it works as follows i cannot put a lucky like you were saying and be mata my rehab it's a it's a it's not residential use how could how could i make it i can't i can't use it i can't put a lucky there what i could do is put a lekhi and make my schwill motor since it works for my vineyard so it's like a miguel not a miguel but since i'm using this luchi and it works it helps me walk over here so now i can't ignore the lefke anymore and the lucky is going to work for the rehab as well omelette when somebody looks in here he doesn't notice that there's a river that there's water and there's a whole beautiful makita and this this village is actually enclosed from three sides and you just put the fourth side on he thinks that you just you have two sides and a lucky and that's it he doesn't realize he when he looks at it he doesn't see that there's an ocean below and he's going to mimic this somewhere else without an ocean a river whatever it is over there yeah it's not it's not salt water fresh water that's why the camels are drinking it says what you need to do is put a la by the mavoi and you do the same trick now since i could carry in the movie why can't i carry them over i have it two seconds on one side two walls on the other side i already have three enclosed walls i put a lefki on the other end and it works since i'm allowed to carry in the mavoi called masa so i can carry in the backyard in the back lot fine should we stop right over here mimosa to go from here to here um from the back backlot to here each one individually you can carry here you can gary here you go to go from here to here at the end of the day nobody lives here if nobody lives here you don't have to do a rubber cat series on it is when people live in a place but nobody lives there so it doesn't answer it it's faker than what you think because people don't live there you don't need uh excuse me people will would use this as residential therefore requiring the heir of kaziris and don't forget melo we said it's also forever have a wonderful wonderful day nacho you want to see some dylan for us or you know what we can hear you over zoom we're here we're here we hear norm no let's go let's hear you alex [Music] foreign [Music] foreign you