Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 38 by R’ Eli Stefansky

we are live in the bottom says the Gamache if you wanna thumb it is around ask if he knows some oil to come into the rod love it sighing with the days on the battery oil the famous rabbit walk run small bumps into the Tommy the McGraw oh my oh my oh my rather to Venice tell me please what round the one that I will close with ninety percent of the time in shots what does he have to stay in that one super high overlay unreal a hulking morale going on a cow that's a mooing beetle array and yeah way the Kiska shahboz not washing with her ear iris is a vehicle description when it comes a sign of life is seen whether or not this animal made it through she's alive if she can move it here you good morning here is pretty difficult it's it's not like the moving of the tails it's a whole other level and I wanted I can't exactly thank you I can't move my tail you know what that's just not a voluntary driving so much graphic right releasing way that we're gonna see in a second that to your point releasing waste better types released wait we gotta get into details business impact Oh matter who it's three to Leila I bought I bought is the way he called rather lot some people like a father it seems like liability Susie you name it he's really required does you really require moving in there so ptosis explains here that basically the mock like used to ravage small intimate links we had in the Mishnah between the time ripping him wheel and the who was it over there I'm Shin Young will and you have to move your fourth leg and your hind leg you have to move to come on say only one or this one so Rob is saying that you have to do something extreme like moving your ear come on says you don't need that much I hold like that like the common you could go less even one left shanyna crochet means boring chamois soy so as long as it's not something that's caused by death itself my needle first Varsham I saw I saw a marathon only didn't partially my native action well I see other for up short Otto that Rashi says when talking about a behemoth Dhaka so in the Bahama data if you have a bent for length and he straightened it out that's nothing that's no sign of life at all that's just typical death as an animal dies it will spring out its leg is there's no right that it's a life dovish I have me saw for you so now by since rashes and brushing points out that's only my venue with that by Behaim of gases we're gonna see the Gabara straightening out of limb any limb even though your leg is a sign of life that's why I'm a man that God that it's nothing to go like this and that just happens automatically when it died but for a larger animal takes strength and anything that requires muscles and an approach that's the silence of life barn china me salsa sure Sammy Sosa shooting missiles shooter offer if it was extended and she bent it that borange ain't me so I so thank you so that's already that takes strength that's something that a dead animal doesn't do this is similar to animals alive till tomorrow mikromasch walk Toninho which says in our mission of the hey most actors you punch the other lives you Abdullah it says the portion arm is now one life says that a behemoth doctor that extended its fore leg the front leg the lion zero did one movement from bed to straight sulla why she ain't no LOH last message now we can infer from that we can make us a simple deal boy it's zero zero meaning that phantom of Cairo is a sign of life Gomorrah MMSD Sonata mean adapt to the type of first of all the title since the only the only thing we can be mad Ike is is that the Mishna says that if the animal extends its legs it's no good meaning that it if it made a second move back to bent position then it's a sign of life but all the mission is saying is that is to move there's going from bent to straight and their chemistry to bend then it's okay then it's a sign of life but how do you know if you just did one it out of the tomb in other words from straight to been how do you know that that's a sign of life again the Mishna says from bent to straight is no good and we want to say okay but if you continue doing step number two which is straight to bend then it's okay okay but he started out in the bent position went to straight then went from straight to then he went back and forth okay that's a good that's a sign that he's alive how do I know that if the animals are already in a straight position and just in one move important we'll just in one room it was a very strong one who but it was one it was from straight defend how do I know that that's considered in line that's what smells coming from in cash a [Music] one directional movement another one direction but only direction from very bad then from our mission we would never know that because from our wish I think you need two things you need bend straight straight bend and then that's a sign of life MSD staring at what even my sister have Amina's the Deaf get the kite for a poster Mordecai for a bit to move I will shoot a book format of Lloyd but it was it was straight and then Ben that's not enough for mash Malone yeah I miss me really see you in there oh you're a mayor in there garbage trash it's all if a cow makes noises the Moose out the famous move ain't appear goes that's not so that's the fire our problem with what we just stand on the top the first word on this arm it says Gaia is considered a sign of light never lies on a birdie I see a memory I feel it with you yo ray even if it what have you say released the way everything is better concealer ray victory shield is not about anger fear causes so again the second word on the psalmist says concealed array is considered empirical so now we're saying that it's nothing so passion go out go you up cash your earrings we have a contradiction so the Gemara know we have to go deeper go yeah go you're like a co-holder be color or the army Colo color if it makes a real nice gazook the moon then it's arrived it's alive then it's not so live really casual how you want to see you want to hear it okay here we go no let's go and we don't have a good passion on the release of waste why time this resets this can't be my treasure as you were singing for people that died things that died if they usually released waste but that's not because they are alive it's because they're dead it's basically the relaxation of the muscles involuntary inbounds there so how does it come out it just come down but if it comes out with fours that's a sign of life that's muscle that's the portion that's the side of life so there's a big knife community tomorrow morning projectile you have to yesterday yesterday yesterday I guess there's no real way of itself but kishkes off is on like you know there's no hardened coil do that like low and high Mars ah do you think the whole spirit think Martha doesn't address this theorem I thought it was this think I should get our consciousness I don't know no you have homework you should see my homework my friend I've been working two hours for you last night around system you didn't even hear I did I made him a nature tracker yeah of course I'm not gonna leave them dry I got it all it's all right love already he's charting the course to deliver oh my god mr. pickle Sean room that means mr. Shido okay Roger pissed along and says okay so now we know what purpose looks like how it's done starting with with Gaga's I'm sorry come with the sale but at what point of the animal's life is it done Cedric is the research done but my position is done before we go any further we have to explain what this means we have to clarify what's at the end of Keith oh man such people laugh okay let's get to the life that was that in order to show signs of life there's no Raya if the animal does some sort of sound at the beginning of street there's no there's no sign that it's a life that could be right before it was shifted in the beginning we need to see that it that it had a sign of life throughout the ship even the industry thought and by in having the middle of the schita a sign of life that that's enough to show us that was alive and had enough life in it to the passage finger all rough is Lebanon middle ah how do I see this the snarling says in our mission of Bahama danke Schwester yo Dawg the lawyers erupts to low then a a small animal a sheep a goat extended its hand and then and pull it back it's not enough it's possible Amos when this happened Elin was searched he saw Kuwait that they to the taken at asel now if it happened at the end of kids in other words at this at the end what you found the terrorist or you're saying manopoly okay now if it means that it happened when she do is finished what we need that animal to live that much longer after schita needs to extend the ten to pull Sam back that doesn't make any sense there's no reason for us to assume that it has to live after schita hello laughs that's a cheetah so male oh right it has to be the middle of the street though not after speaker okay oh hey robo learn no I'm just looking to maybe really you need pure cause you need signs when it's dark after it's done shiny white Merrick call Shane oyster cane be searched or if it cannot do this at the end of Aikido in other words it can only go to a straight position it can only go one way from bent to stray because do I finish most in the thulium in our closing look and the reason I need to go back and forth is because if it could only go in one direction then it's not a we don't have a riot that it's a life not right it's not on my pink Oshun room it's healing Naaman said that the signs that we're talking about is even in the beginning of schita and he comes with a beautiful ride from our mission I'll prove with you this knot and sense in our mission though we learned yesterday over-ambition I showed them the lies on one sixth of the laying down it's one chef did an animal at night and he couldn't see whether or not the animals the stupendous or not so what's this Riya forego the next day and look in the walls and see that they're full of blood and we said then on the spot that the walls don't mean the walls of that the house it means the walls of the shema and he brings it right over here I took it from here why how do you know that if it's full of blood Scottish is in good let's prove that it forcefully let our blood but can we - really a lesser off when that's like that's the question it trying to prove that pupils and Simchat that the Vista brings the the spurting blood the Sprint of the blood is in the beginning also in the beginning y can be the chair of the other less is the one that says that it welcomes out forcefully that's a riot at the annals of life varnish more closely based in session II know that we're only referring to the walls of the biscuits and not the walls of the house now Raschi points out and says beautiful the reason we're napping brings this Shmuel to explain what what we're talking about why so portraits right because if we are talking about the walls of the house that it's very simple to see the next morning when the animal sprayed out its blood because if the blood is on the wall on the top part of the wall then I know that holds graded out all the way the beginning of the skipper and in the middle the walls and who knows if something bottom of the wall that it just came out naturally conda's would not fences look small says we don't look at the wall of the house we look at the wall of the neck the wall the neck there's no way in the next morning to see how the blood came out right exactly for the truth that slowly so I have no indication from the neck how the blood came out of one the block you know as long as there's blood fine but aquaponic that group of the ragga house the next morning Araya I look at this animal I look and I see oh it has blood all over its neck maybe that blood came all the way from beginning of the street though oh maybe they come out in the beginning and beginning the shmita is good that's is right again we're trying to decide here which I understand when does an animal move when is an animal move its tail what is an animal spreads blood each sheet done whatever the sheet that is but that's called pupils that's a sign of light is it although in the beginning of the schita or all the weight the end of Keita for afters people how cruel thing that's in the beginning excuses or not because if I can bring a ride from the next morning and the blood is all over the animals net the next morning I don't know it was the begin you see the net there's no video all I see is blood did it happen in the beginning of kids are having that done this kiddo perhaps it happened in the beginning of keeper and it's still Araya that it was pupils so you see that the beginning of streets are is enough and that's why he extensions Rashi that it's the walls of the neck and after walls of the house because the walls I'll still be able to bring the red the next morning whether the beginning of the skids or the energy the depending on how high the blood is on the wall who commit as vivid as an Amish from oil and here he sticks it in cost of education you know it's referred to the walls of the neck yeah I'm Josh Lyman the Pulaski the shop here it all makes sense if I could prove P R coos I get through life vitality of life from the beginning of keeper that's great Eliana's mr. Chito but then you have to prove it from all the way and the sceeto later zoom over khillski bazinga how could I prove from looking at the neck of the animal that it has won out of that does that happen at the end of the or maybe they have in the beginning of skin tone and the animal should be mara Gilmore and easy look daddy what did bring me Araya from spraying a blood so what we're talking about mooing maybe spring and blood is the stronger indication and even if it happened at the beginning of the sheets off then everybody with a minute that's considered free put my shanking moving and moving at the tail has to happen at the end of kita maybe maybe blood is a much stronger indicator Navarro me I did make places to say that blood is stronger than anything else opposite good look from that without the animal wanting to just come spring gap but the moon sound Emily morning says it come down bring out because of rapid life because I heart go to animal make the decisions to make decision to flip their he's doing it but this animal died the moment recourse keeps off no the worst thing we turn up the more thing if the animal died a moment before Caesar yeah the blood won't come out for sweet that's what thing one thing has no blood pressure it has nothing like the hearts like you think you could open a barrel how does it comment it come out for just where it's coming up coarsely cuz there's blood pressure it has a heart beating it has something going on it made this to say that blood is a stronger indicator than the other similar that we had what's not red laser I may die in simcha the Lawson die means it's enough meaning it's a spy person and not a stronger singing the Gemara still not arrived maybe what he meant to say calm during him leo bottom-feeder up on because reveal the answers smack in the middle of the mission between river Gamliel and rabona removal is the one that says you need two indications you need a YA guna rectum a hard-on that said you need to keep one or the other and rebel eyes is the sandwich in the middle he says it's enough to have blood so meaning it's enough it's less than then then welcome Leo but more than have fun over a vino only some about talking [Music] so some of us think I tore me up she bought and boarded bar above Rome listen to this name the father of the son of Abu Rome in other words who's the father of the son of abu room he he he himself a pilgrim he's the father his name was Abu Rome he's the father of the son of abu room says Rashi because nobody knew who our Woodrum was everybody knew parable room the son of the was was the main guy they call the father desirable Varela what about room over there a bottom er there is his spraying of blood more is more to Simmons and in a hand or foot was not but a harmonium and shitty practice all the other gorillas now add is a lotion of homeroom rabona a strike Pandey what are they talking about Elain either become Leo into talking honorable uses you need a handle afloat even shipping it to me by leg it's less they're saying Romeo says I need to a hand and a foot come home saying no all you need is one hand or one foot I don't need to VOD L cheat all our dividends it lets the one that says you need blood as a sign and they're saying add you need the other my god it means more my mother says you need blood now blood is considered more of a Simmons than a hand in a hand then the lotion add is no good add means no blood is not enough I need at least a hand at least means more lads that is number two in the mention the first one go home and say they need you meet what spiracles what's the sign of like one hand one foot you need to think Conger Glazer says no I need blood okay go home say what do you need one hand now what is one hand less than blood or more than blood if it's less than blood then what does add mean the word add is no good that means I need blood is not enough I need to add a foot I need more than blood so meaning one foot is is more of a sim in the blood so what are you telling me that that blood is more of a 'cimmanon ofum the word add is no that's the point is Mars the word on everything fly the end approach oh no no that desperate is not a shot just a you need both no I mean I need something as strong as a bull the indication is via phone I sing way add a dissolution opponents chosen one they still one poor cannot be more cover than two feet one foot can be more common than blood it's not enough what you said I needed me more if it's like you're saying them since they at the club and of course it should say I drop on my people to homeroom associate so rod ignores everything we just proved he says no here close means all the way after schita o morado all the men I mean the law the Sanyo sword this is the boy [Music] three times a year at least five this five new multimeter they're all geese macula mudan but the reason why this is a read this first of all gonna be talking about a lot but I couldn't do read after ends I have to do it a little different it's the same there's a pipe the finally mother Mary what's a burst we move basically the positive telling us that this is what you can bring as a carbon at these these are the essential ingredients of a carbon sharp but esta a sheep oh yeah kiyah bullet has to be born there's the famous keyboard it has to be born in not caesarean boy your Sheila Seon has to be at least seven days old before you share this tack I see Mike it can't be an orphan so says the Gemara oh you can say Bradley client what I learned from the Sheep it can't be off scream of a combination of a mother sheep and a father goat boy or a goat what does that mean Pratt the means but over here the parents are one person they never had offspring that's a little weird looking it looks like a goat it looks like a sheep but if the parents are both goats to them yeah you have you check mail go it looks like a sheep and walks like a sheep and it makes sounds like a sheep it's possible for a cart long travel indeed mother it's kilo she give all a here's the key we got to remember this word kita boleh proudly into their garage what does kibo tell that this animal has to be born naturally any time you remove the animal from from its mother unnaturally he has open the stomach not natural if it's born a second after then who dies even naturally so to speak if you pulled it out it's not natural it has to be pushed out naturally from the mother okay she bets your name Thrasymachus is mine the analyzer being at least seven days old Cassie Maureen it has to be under its mother Pratley oh sorry it has to be under its mother for one second not for seven days for one second in other words the mother has to be alive while the animals alive in this world if it's a orphan we cannot bring it up Roma how do we say that life is mother's that's the lion makes especially you to the mothers of the mother can be alive I'm willing to be the County Council animals coming out it was the middle of coming out normally in the mothers died during childbirth and then they grabbed its head and they yanked it out this little c-section the animal never had a mother the mothers died before the birth but it wasn't a c-section yesterday the cow look 3/4 dead it was in SU tennis I don't know maybe all cows look like that when the givers although I did see cows giving birth to have a place in Chicago is they have thousands of cows and whenever you go this is a cow giving birth to everything it did not look like that this cow looked completely out of it and the choice them in-game said these are from people took it would that's what I said there's no box usually you have to be careful you have to you can't stand next to a cow when you're shopping at allmovie teto till the person Gary this is mr. tennis this is the whole thing you were looking it was it looked like it was mr. kindness it looked like it was on its last breath and they said hoist hoist chef chef they didn't say it but that's nothing man and they took a negative and then you see some guy going and ripping the stomach open and pulled out two babies I'm saying I think I think they don't give birth like that this was lying on its side like completely adamant right they can sitting here and didn't it then just swim like this it did from the bent position to the straight position so that's uh that's good for bei Mikasa that's enough and then we're good video but don't open it up if you're if you're nothing so people know some people no no no to death the skeeters and stuff on this I know you not happy those no no I'm not no it was in this direction sorry it's right over here I was looking over here okay you won't see it anyways it's somewhat sad with no but let me go hop said tomorrow hi he also make me dummy now his robe is right we're talking about the beginning of means up or the end of school no there's a top rider avoiding so we have to put our heads here together I also make you know Elena theme that day he may bother me so if the mother gave birth to this animal and then she died loyal on paper today so what the third says it can't be a normal how long can to be an orphan right playing like that eighty year old guys anomaly awesome obviously we don't expect the mother to look forever when you're shutting this carbon so if the mother is really alive way past the birth L of the may solve all the other things so has to be that boy died during childbirth and the birth happen right after that can be either Mickey ball now that that's that's Judas question that that that's that's already in the Kiev olive why because anything that's born after death even it looks natural but it's not natural because the animal didn't push it out it wasn't from the animal you needed human intervention whatever it is City Cavallo it's not considered born naturally that's already too serious Elif she saw is that parish Lamesa busy perish the - it has to be that it happened at the same time as the animals born the mother died and raschi points out here that that makes a lot of sense in the word Papa mo talked us is like a collie pin like ad instead of the mother as the mother expired the boss shemish bizarre fashion one came in one came out birth and died there's no kind now here comes Rob is right he I'm just gonna be English being on keys to the safe later if you're telling me that when the tourist says it has to be alive it has to be alive at the end yes has to show signs of life at the end that makes sense handled in scroll the movie that's why I need a special possible type I seem like we might why because I wouldn't be able to learn out him in volley hello yeah I'm just leaving a few super-safe later but if I'm saying that when the third says it has to be alive it doesn't have to be all the way at the end as long as that's during or at before la Malay we keep all in Africa I don't need a special thing that the governor from Kiev Ollie was key in valets when did Kibo had happened a moment before before before the bird before them she gave birth and then she died then then it's considered then I can learn out that it had a mother while so while the mother was like why do I need time I see money tapasya might only makes sense if defeat the animal has to be alive after after death so to speak it has to be alive one moment after that I need a special part it doesn't seem like but if if light is a moment before that's already excluded from Kings bonus the boss says that when is born it has to have a mother in mother so male I don't need a special cause I gotta see more come see what I always have to say that the moment afterwards one split moment after birth it still needs to be alive because one moments before any excluding key evolving and the male was so gonna get there our second this is a tough thing to understand in our view also when the animal does Pecos and I need to need to show signs of life it has to be a moment after the schita not in the beginning of chemo but by slinky though which is a moment after because a lot sometimes the like somebody's the mother is completely alive like humans we do c-section yeah did you bag off and the mother goes home and I were speaking the disabled over for carbon nothing with death sometimes it's already something's the license is dead we have this is in not always is a dip or AA pill the sake home s Mesa but I love it like this Bryce Bahama doctor should push the yonder below zero sulo this is exactly like in our mission that our Bahama doctor that just extends its hand from bent to straight is fossil the men murmuring beyond that's only the fore leg of a Borrego the hind leg bank rush to the lake a softball thankfully for such a row so here writes and says that if you have the hind leg moving it doesn't matter what direction that's enough of a sign that is alive maybe because it's a much bigger Lin so takes more power the med Varma marimba taco I have a big ass or baby yeah thing be regular even the poor like given the front legs been pasta even just extending it by a big animal but a large animal extending the leg they punch like pop up in Buffalo Pashto share oh boy and a bird a people they rip rip hello boy even it can just ruffle the feather so in this case it was no voice or just move this table I raise the period as the Gemara mathematical hootenanny in all this we can infer from our mission and rations to the star mission so that offers like our business so what we macaws why I wouldn't say now image the Baby Jogger brush the other laser Abdullah by a small animal but extended its leg from a bent position so straight position it's possible say no excise nefesh that's our mission so we could be Medaille combat yeah in Greg and Lloyd that's deaf go by the poor leg but the back leg is considered a cinema the Aqua in gasoline and we can also infer from the fact of the Mishna says we're talking about baby Dhaka on your sheet but a cab it would be a similar so Melo what did rubber add Robert added seems like almost nothing says Mario right he only added the last last part or if it's through the leg the lights not originally talking about a bird so bird as long as it moves its feather that's enough transmission we have a local we learnt numbers are that if you shaft an animal for a Vedas ro the shape it goes and chef's table for that desire that's hundreds impossible that's no good now ash I think I need to come in but what have you shifted for a gun don't work shut up it is our dog doesn't she know that Brown animal a second here vividly as an Faisal that just says no wife Azula it comes with a position he says that the owner has the right to make his his animal of a disorder of wild of June shuffle usually but that's also big problem how could happen a owner have Ivana's animal what about a day something this would have claimed those people give out owner half eagle they are sooo gear yes according to these Mandana yes owner can have a mash of on his own animal even as though he's not doing that either Oh Meredith yes sir I finish up the left leg above him even says rash if the guys solve the entire animal to the Jew and he left himself make us tired papi chulo sulla he only loved himself a small part of the of the diaphragm of part of the deliverer that's it it's possible why just um probably a mother to sorrow I have to assume what is that yeah but they translate his diaphragm the the layer above the liver may be computed la vidas or already I see Kappa primaried varam conjugating says listen no no it doesn't work what you saying whom at the mocking sham of Shopify salesmen in the base time big doors where I could have a Machado I can do people in a collarless hello after I made it all goes by the Cayenne only the claims arrived in a shovel walking shame I shall be sellers but by a human animal starmon animal at home that the mush of it doesn't work and the motors can explain why it doesn't work or than me doesn't work we just said it does work I can make it and Tabitha Zara that took more is gonna dress and indeed should not a short day so certainly the owner should not have power to do anything says the gomorrah honeyton o ye however the first 210 I am in our mission are without a common remilia's there they hold this blue there Billy as ever ever you see this on your ability I see schemata shot by the fabulous they obviously have to hold that the owners do have power over this animal and they can make people even though they're not the Claudine me also got what my plugs in between the kind of common rivers they both hold that the owner has the power over the animal but the my Plagueis is according to this part himino-san agama so very shy Mina de+ in Illinois we have to hear specifically from the guy that he wants to do have a dessert and we don't hear from him that it's a bizarre there's no reason to believe that selfies are some apps it was only talking hobbies or I got me not realizing solve our vocabulary in all of the fashion even though we don't hear him to go anything stomach shaves double using clapping lie with his daughter Mina so we have a voice in the ratio with another boy usually in ten strategies or kotfe intense Robin's aura even the sound of camera hauls he has the right to make his own carve on his own animal of a desert even though he's nothing to keep them has nothing to do with the person before in history though has to do even a personal machine though but certainly the also the owner could do it why not that's what the town of camera that's all ball so really the main marker goods in our mission of holes like judo he says no I graduated Akashi even though he has carbonyl Democrats avoid this means doesn't getting sense this guy Rubin is doing sheets of Shimon is having my shopping Evans who else is much over a fete history though another shot is they can already be a mediator possibly shifting he thinks themselves dish pizza yeah I don't want to get into because I had a little bit of news but instead of the long steep done he'll think Marcel there's a purpose in building she thought it's a sign that he's still alive identity look it's a five hours into that I don't know that works exactly okay I mean you know I mean making your whole animal of a desert that could be a problem oh he's part of that stump with amazing weight because he was deliver what do you didn't rob a desert before this started lahars no Bennett doesn't start if we know that he did that were not gonna stop it is are we can that I don't know of course yeah there's no pores right over there because if you said in the forums then they wouldn't be Mulligan's in a common rule is they would all agree that's everything all right it doesn't say that according to do it but if we assume that in this there was even possible world yeah finish I mean with a possibly even if we heard that ain't matter we sat economists over communism Akashi deserve it enemy leukemia optical I do we say this all men to be something does or do we say this everywhere what's his name boy Alpena I don't learn English I agree with you that a guy could make his or the owner can make his carbon oh I'll be bizarro bingo bingo basta revelry and I'm a mega Phoenix cosmic name cause you realize it says yes but I could extend that even outside of me something goes Worcester of using am a matter and then the 30 to come along a few with name Navi even inside of you something does it doesn't work the owner cannot make it people what kinda cheffing them Akash you deserve it Laurie I'm you know have a wonderful shoppers what time is she about to Chavez Ravine [Music]