Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 29 by R' Eli Stefansky

Great. Good morning. See off of a song. It goes a lot better. Ah, >> David's back. Dave Bell. >> Here you see Shimmy Shuax from Antworp who's a fantastic musician had a small break during a wedding and look what he's doing not to miss the D. It's amazing tremendous was at the wedding of his daughter who got married last night. spoke at the seam even though he's not invited to speak come to see him made a point to come and visit for a few minutes to show and to show how he's as leaders like this like that without you we would not see that that so in your best regards Linhard I like this a lot I just joined them I must say that it's truly very much though I learn every day. I really I never really had a regular schedule for learning being with a busy schedule traveling all over the world finding additional time to learn that always a challenge. Check this out. A person puts up a what's your name? >> From person puts up a sign in China. In China and he gets this guy to learn Tyra. The other week I was in China and I saw an MDY poster in the spar of Shankai. I said to myself, why not try it? So when I found out that was about to start, I took it by myself as a famous go just do it. I haven't missed the D since and when traveling I make sure to download the shar in advance so I can watch or listen to it on the way during the flight. Of course I do also join the live share via Zoom whenever possible. Thank you for making this year so interesting for getting people excited about learning the D every day. May bless you. in good health to continue teaching the daff for many years to come. Linhard attaches a picture my my colleagues took of me watching you during one of my many flights. Here he is. >> Okay, I'll try to remember. >> This one uh he's on Zoom right now. He's on Zoom right now. Say, take a look. I don't know. Could you put him on Zoom? Let's see if Gary could uh work the magic. >> This one. This one was was hard to read. >> Huh? You can't. >> No video. >> Oh, his video is not on. But you see his name is >> Oh. Oh, no. Ms. You saw it in in China. It's like it sounds like Wow. Okay. Thank you for joining us. I enjoy this year very much and I've been learning since and I also feel like I can't this guy he can't sit idle and not point this out was promised a helicopter ride if he does becious over a year and a half ago now what's so difficult he says ah I feel bad for this person it's very difficult for me when so much time out of yes are taken up with trips and talking about them safari Morocco the Alps All this time and money spent on personal enjoyment when there's an unfulfilled promise. Mish hurts in this guy. >> I feel consortium. >> I don't know. I think he hijacked the name cuz if he's the consortium >> then we don't want the consortium. >> Sincerely a consortium. This is one of the people I was speaking about yesterday. It hurts. It's hard. It's hard to deal with. Dear belly, many say why should I be the one to worry about putting status videos on my phone. Let the other guy do it. Today after putting status on my phone since the dorm 57 it paid off. Louis Fman the owner of J2 pizza in Lakewood tells me due to status he's watching this year. He sends you warm regards. So guys, let's get status going official edition by Aron Corda in honor of Shashana Bati Alum the entire David Salomon we have to make a distinction between the official shas and the I don't know how to do it exactly maybe somebody could come up One is the mayor official >> official edition >> David Solomon in dedicated memory of the sponsored by the palic family foundation in gratitude to consortium >> in gratitude to the consortium and the alliance and all they do to support mdy anonymous and thank you to chief benny anonymous for complete refor for basel monthly sponsors and Danielle Rosenfeld. >> So now we know the consortium is 83. >> I don't know who it is. >> Very simple. The consortium always pays money to put their ads on. The consortium >> I it sounds like you know something we don't know. Anonymous for sorry the Spanish year sponsors wishing them the wife continue family continues and anonymous we had a a pretty good meeting yesterday doing the same thing that the Spanish people are doing do it in French >> so see how that works there's more French speakers than Spanish speakers in the world that's what they anonymous Robert Early Preston Harris Group recruitment make money from the shear and give back to the shar I didn't see the email yet I don't know what he's talking about hk ventures in this for success of all our clients Danielle Rosenfeld that's a sponsor of the month mdy kids sponsor monthly art 8 minutes into this year. Can't believe it. Anybody want to about anything for four minutes? Boy, we have a very exciting daff. >> The real consortium says Mark Ashkenazi. The real consortium capitalizes the C always. >> Okay, so now we know that guy hijacked the name. Everybody said, "Check this out. Today we're going to be learning about a lot of different suggest today is if something is exactly 50% do we can count it as a ro or not exactly 50%. And then Gar the Gar takes that back and says only by carbon pes we have something similar to that. Also in the Mishna we mentioned the concept of ro that has to be the majority of one of the sim 51% but it says it twice. So why does it say it twice? And the Gar goes on a very lengthy discussion. We know why it says it twice. One is one is but that the first one is the second one is a whole long discussion. And finally we have a very interesting sug when you do we consider the entire process part of the every cut of the knife or it's the final cut. So giving you the heads up. So, we're going to start this and the Gar regrets it right away. I mean, it takes a couple minutes, but the Gar is going to take it back because you're going to be shocked when you hear like 10 shack a bomb. If you 50% of the ka or 50% of the veh by a bird, that's enough. 50% is like we c we'll count it we'll consider it the majority good a bunch of questions on that this makes more sense to us no the if the says 50 so it's what do you mean 50% you need 51% so will explain this he didn't tell him how much you should check. He told him how much he shouldn't leave. Do not leave 51% unchecked. Meaning if you 50% that's okay. You should 51% just to break it up a little bit. You know, we just started there was a a where >> he felt like he he wasn't there was too much resting on his shoulders, you know, like there's all these and is it kosher not kosher? So he decided to become a reb. So somebody said what are you doing? He says you know too much. He says listen it's better if you animals than she kids. Oh So here's a the obvious question from the Mishna yesterday. It says that a half a sim by a bird is possible. One and a half sim by a possle. Why you need of each simmon? You need a of the it says but according to it that says 50% is like 51%. Why is it apostle? Why does the mission say it's possible? 50% is counted as 51%. That's exactly what Raf says 50 is like 51%. Says no R. We could answer this. It's not you. We're trying to put him in a corner and force him into a checkmate. No, it's not a checkmate. I could get my way out of this. I could say the Mishna means that 50% is user like that. If it's take takes away all the of the and came and said it's not it's don't eat it, but it's not. But if it's literally not a good like we would hold that it's only 50% then it doesn't remove the tomb at all. Why is it why do say don't do it? Cuz how could you be so exact 50% maybe you won't even get to maybe did 49%. So they said stay away from 50 do 51%. Okay another another try at knocking this. Oh, so this is how by let's say you have a piece of earth where you have an oven. How do you how do you take away the tuma from an oven? >> The only way to do is break it. And the only type of break is if the break is less than half because if the break if you have a large piece that's 50% or more then it's considered an oven. You can make you could you could maybe bake something in that oven. What happens if a guy breaks it and there's two pieces 5050? Exactly 50%. So says it's impossible. That's exactly what the Gumar says. And what if it is possible? What if it is? You're a lawyer. What if it is possible? What if I have a CNC machine that cuts exactly exactly? Oh, maybe Yseph vermin could I was looking for the word. >> Oh, there's a there's a word in variance maybe. I forgot what the word is when they cut parts for for uh for missiles and for spaceships. Tolerance. Tal who said tolerance. Yeah, that's the word I was looking for. The tolerance like the the a hundth, a thousandth of a of an inch, a millionth of an inch. The tolerance. Oh, a lot of it goes in ppm parts per million. >> Parts per million. That's in the tolerance. Tolerance is parts per million. Okay. But in that the word I was looking for is tolerance. Correct. Thank you. Thank you. What if you broke a earn piece and it's exactly 50/50? Did you remove the tomb or not? It happens to be that in this room. I guarantee you there's nobody here that could break a mat in the little sader like I do. I'm 50/50 every year. Ask my kids. You all have this mishagas. >> Sit there.50. It's >> not supposed to be 50/50. >> What should I do if it always happens? What should I do? I don't even try and it happens. I'm that good. >> Hand. What machine? Who eats machine mats at the I'm talking about hand mats around from Satmer? It's as is like this. You go click and you has they're like this for have to say there which one is it the right or the left? Oh there's a somebody once said that if you have to measure which one is larger then it's not larger. If you're coming on it's not then it's not large. Okay. So I don't want to hear your emails that you're better than me in it. You're not better. I was just kidding. They right away said it was it was a bad year. Oh, it's impossible. A lot of times says the it's impossible to do something 50/50. It's always going to be 49.99999 and the other one is going to be 50. It doesn't but you're never going to get it exact. And that's why we can't consider either one of them less than a less than a half. Sam but let's say you have a tolerance machine of a million 10 million per per for what ppm it's mashma it would be my but according to rav 50% on the dot equals 50% on the ra equals 51%. So each piece when you look at each piece okay it's exactly exactly 50%. Exactly 50% it's 51%. And therefore they shouldn't be is a beautiful here. It's impossible to view each half as 51%. Cuz that's a contradiction. You can't have two halves that are 51% cuz that equals 102%. That's impossible. When you have two contradictory things in front of you, you can't say, "Oh, they both equal 51%." So when it comes to one cle, you can't say that. Where could you say it in? Inita, where the says the half, I don't care about the other half. The other half is not. If I'm going to view both halves of this pipe, half is cut and half is not, then you have a problem. This is 51% and this half is 51%. So you have 102% of a pipe. But the Torah doesn't say look at this left part this the half that I'm not shafting. The Torah says only look at the half that I'm shafting says Rash. I focus on one half and that one half is 50%. And it's considered 51% according to Rav again the Gar wants to say that Rav holds that when it comes to if a person did 50%. It's good enough. It's as if he did 51%. The literally it's as if he has arrive. Oh, so let's do this about pet because I think it's very important that remembers this I saw yesterday struggled in both even though I was promised by that everybody's going to know it because he he made a whole big deal out of it. Now what if a person she the breathing pipe the trachea hecks 49% of it goes home takes a 6-hour nap on all sorts of but that's not the point. And he wakes up from his nap and he continues sheing and he goes through the trachea completely and he goes into the into the veh also. Is it a good or not good? Is it a kosher or a tra? >> Yes. >> What if he did 50%. If he did 50%. >> And he went to sleep. >> So the the the question is on 50%. According to Rav what you're telling me according to Rav 50% equals 51%. So if she's 50% he just made a traa he just did 51% and he went to sleep what is that called after he started a realita cuz he did 51% if he did less than 51% so he nicked he made a hole in the in in the animal's trachea it's not it's not the end of the world the animal could live it's not a traa but if he did 51% and then he went to sleep that's called shah and that should be tra yet we say The last words on Bh did 50% of the breathing pipe of the trachea and he waited around for 2 minutes or he took a 6-hour nap whichever one but he paused and then he then and then he later on he finished it up. But if you tell me 50% is considered 51% he tal he did that he he made a tra now I just want to show you what she is for a second we had a terrible incident here in the shir and this is uh this is what they're showing now some individual a British individual barab scream out v screamed outre screamed outre screamed out the Ver I'm not going to I don't want to remind it was a terrible incident and I had to make a mah. So over here we have a bird a British bird doing something terrible. Okay, we're going to we're going to be mad. Listen, we're going to do chuva for this person for this individual. But what does shi mean? Shia means don't wait. And if you wait, you have to say v. Okay, here we go. This is not how you say fighter. This is how you say fighter. >> Ver. >> So that's Shahi. Wow, >> that's a that's a very interesting way to learn how to say >> I don't I don't even know if you could say it like that. The end. What do you do over there? >> Wow. Yeah. Shim, it's many years of practice. >> Okay. You think we're talking about an animal here? Guy decided to pretend that he's noted and he got on a radio station and he's going to like give it to the, you know, one of the politicians. So he gets on he says, "Yeah, what's your name?" Where would he live? And say somewhere, you know, whatever. Nagda, I don't know what. Yeah. No, what do you have to say? He says this guy if he's ah okay. Okay, fine. Blew his cover in the first second he started speaking. So you tell Israeli, I don't think they know what that word means. Do they? No, not mish. So he says very simple a bird all you have to is one simmon if you only check the 50%. You decide what you want to call it. If you think 50% is enough like rav like the rav great so you could take a nap now. Why can't he take a nap? You alreadyed this bird. It's alreadyed. And if 50% is only 50%, it's not 51%. You didn't do anything. We're not talking about a we're talking about a bird which only needs one. Okay. So again, one more try to knock this rav out that what Rav says and rav. It's a good thing. The 5050 if 50% is considered 51%. A good you started doing you notice that his trachea is already severed by 50%. And all you did you took a knife and you checked it 1% a trachea that 51%. It's a good but according to your that 50% is considered 51%. You started off with an animal that has a cut 51%. Shani no maybe I could say when it comes to the toa I need to be able to see with my own eyes is one thing 50% is considered 51%. But when I when I look at a a traa I need to see with my own eyes. I don't have to use a magnifying glass to see whether or not I did a if there's a roy of tra. I need to be able to see with my eyes. what you're saying doesn't make sense. So I have a simple according to you. We have situations like this. Remember everybody when it comes to the esophagus the vet the eating pipe over there you don't need a ro of anything. One tiny hole makes a trafe. So when it comes to traa a small pinhole could also make it tra. But when it comes to the breathing tube that you need a all of a sudden when you need 51% all of a sudden you need to be able to see it. So I'm going to tell you but that to begin with a pinnol never works. You always need a so certainly it doesn't make sense. Your your logic doesn't doesn't work here. If in a place where a tra could be even yet when a certain tra you need a you need to be able to see the so something that always needs a re like always needs 51%. So certainly you should have to see with your own eyes. So now the says you're right. This whole let's toss away not toss away this it never happened. There's no such thing that 50% is considered 51%. Nobody holds that. There's one place in the Tory that 50% is like a it's not a we'll consider it like a what's that place it's this week's parish how does become half so the says the ni died and people went to today we can understand it let's say rabad was lifter so all the go to the lva half of kai go So they're all taught me half stay at home. I happen to go I think there's a lot of Ashkanaz and they were just saying I don't know exactly how it happens. 50/50. Well, it's exactly 50/50. Now what's what's the and it's an interesting because it's not it wasn't it wasn't given right away to it's after complained. He said what should we do if we're says dash these words. So not when everybody brings carbon but in a month later treat it you get your own begged for it. when you beg for something. So, so changed it. Hashem said, "Okay, fine. I'll give you something called now this is the famous which was said about carbon pes. What does that mean that if 51% of then you could brings the carbon peso they could go to the the m to so what happens if it's 50/50? We said you need a on this comes ra and says 50% is enough to bring when when that when that when that 50% is we'll treat it like but not says no you need 51%. And what's not that I view 50% as 51%. was my time at the say twice is 50% is considered a not so much a as a it's not a it's a and when you have it then you do it then they can do so if you have 50/50 let's go back just for a second just to finish that off 50/50 the 50% that's tahar they should the 50% that's says that I don't treat the 50% as it's so what happens they have to wait till the next month that whole 50% has to wait a whole month just a super interesting of the Rambam he says how you going to count all of Israel how do you know what a is he says it's but I don't think they're passing like him you base it on who came to the mikdash somebody asked a good Why would a Tommy person come to be mdash? Whoever came to >> she >> fomo. No, he says fomo. Why would if you're coming and you can't sh Why would you come to show up? Should they count you? Okay, whatever. What's your name? >> From where? >> Baltimore. No, you there once in a while. >> You don't even know. That's that's even a bigger problem. We got it. Okay. Thank you for coming. Who else is a guest? >> Mayor. >> Oh, Jonathan Stfansky. Pointing at other people. Mayor, who's mayor. Mayor, what's your name? >> Mayor >> from Welcome. Welcome. >> Oh, yeah. This is the guy. I saw you a bunch of time. What's What's your name? >> From >> Moaza from Monty. Shalom. >> Location. >> From what? >> My one location where half of our attendees are from New Square within a mile. >> Really? Wow. >> What? You have a location? Uh, what kind of location? What is that? >> Satellite. >> Mameshi one location. I got to be on top of this. >> But most of the people from New Square >> half I'm assuming I just read I just read this week the article about the square in what was it? I don't remember. And it said it was supposed to be they filed it as new but the mish like when you the the Jews came into Ellis Island they changed it new square what's so they new square it's new square regards to over there new yeah >> I got it I got it okay it's not even on me here Gary thank you oh you're good boy in new square or my on keep on coming there. If you if you're never there, show up. Give them okay. I just asked yesterday, what's the the first location in Israel? He said just last night as we have 33 locations. Some of these locations have 30 people a night. Don't you guys >> one should post on status. Okay, give up. >> Monty one. Okay, now we know my one. I like it. >> Three brothers. >> Yakovkitz is our uncle. >> Rebakovitzkowitz. >> Yeah. >> My fourth brother is not. >> He's hiding. Why is he hiding over there? That's my spot over there. You know that? >> I also hide over there. >> And where's the third brother? >> No, there's five of us. >> Brother is making his first >> Mazda. Okay, >> that's why tell them we usually don't give such ear time, but the brothers Okay. All right. Simpler over here. Check out this Mishna. It might be looking confusing but it's not. I just took the Mishna I put it over here. There's a sishna. All you need to see is the red words. It says in the beginning of the Mishna 51% of one sim is like the whole thing all you need is the famous. So then why in the world does it repeat itself in the and say all you need is a it says the idea of two times in the gamar is going to say that the first part the rat is talking about regular animals that you at home you place is considered the whole thing the bottom part is talking about the b mikdash I would think that a b mikdash is different than kulen okay and then we have a long suga maybe five different am that come along and say I could prove to you that the ra is talking about and the safe is talking about and not reverse very important to the gar to figure that out think about it are you able to figure it out it's it's like a riddle which part is talking about and which part is talking about that's the trick over here so let's see inside we already why does it say at the when I already said in the ratio the same thing says Omar these are the names so I guess there's six the reason is because the or the one of them is and one of them is a simple which is and then the gar does the reverse of the You know when you just we know that the main part of that is the number one thing of I need a lot of blood. I need blood. So therefore I have to do sorry when it comes to I don't need it's enough to have a I don't need more because I don't need blood but when it comes to I need the blood. Notice the says it's enough maybe maybe I need 100%. And now the is going to do it slightly different. Now we're doing 51%. I need 51%. Why? Because I need the blood. I'm going from 51% to 50. Before I went from 51% to to 100%. And now I'm saying I'm starting from a lower point. I'm saying only maybe you need a 51%. But I maybe I don't even need a by. Why? Because I don't need the blood. Maybe 50% is enough. That's why I need two parts of the one is one is now the says you think okay so what's the difference a whole big to-d do out of this which one is and which one is beautiful take a look what it says the first words a bird you don't a bird you do malika Ah >> it's >> if it's but if it's not it makes a lot of sense is referring to not outside of no so but let's look at the it doesn't say it doesn't say anything about so addresses that sorry let me just go back So you're saying okay so by the way it says the word instead of look it says look at the I just highlighted the word at the bottom and the save it says then it says The is going on the word but you can't say that in the because the word bird goes on the okay that's the first word in the over there it's there a bigger question why it doesn't say okay that's one now we go to the next how do I know that the racial is It says now we know in there two birds that doesn't work with so you tell me this the end is it says all in the safe it says also says more Oh my that's not a cash in the one it says means every single one of the you should check the but in the you can't say that it says it's not talking about the over there it's talking about one but the list you're right it should really say if you want to be proper it should have said a little better but I couldn't say that why but there's two types of birds and one bird is called All you have to do is therefore it doesn't work. I'll prove to you that the rach says you have to shaft the jugular you say you don't have to chef if we're just talking about mundane regular like nowadays you don't have to you don't have to cut the jugular great am I it doesn't make any sense shouldn't argue that they should say yes you have to cut the jugular why the whole idea is to get more blood. So, why not cut the jugular? I want to show you a video. Tell me what you hold. If you didn't see this, uh, Gamar yesterday, if you didn't see this at all, you can answer. I want to know if what this guy is about to do, is it good or not. Oh my god. Kosher or not kosher? >> Not kosher. >> Not kosher. Here's the person that was at the shar last night and he said the wrong answer. Okay, good. I like that. >> Not kosher. The answer is >> hello. >> No, this one. In order to know this when you have to see the it's kosher outside it's not kosher in the mikdash you cannot check two kbanas together but you could check 25 beah it's a great new system they should line them all up and will come with a very long knife one one swoop it's all great >> oh there's a knife >> no that's only after that's fine. >> Oh, you mean if if he shuffed the whole thing? >> No, that's fine. The next >> We're not going into the details that he's chopped off the whole head. Not the It's the point. And that they're all standing without a head. Okay. I have a lot of couches in this video. >> Give them a heads up. >> Sorry. Sorry. I'm >> You should We're doing well. We're doing well. Once in a while there's a slip. I'm I'm slips I'll prove to you that the talking about now in order to understand the well you just need to see this chart and everything makes sense. I just added to the right below the this idea this video that we just saw is the Mishna in one from now. In other words, it's a continuation. In our GMAR, it's two separate Mishna. It happens to be one Mishna. Now, it says over there that in the B mikdash, you can't two heads and one sha. So, it must be it's a continuation of the saf is talking about the mikdash and and the says, "Oh, and if you two animals and watch out, it's no good." But if the safe is talking about in your backyard, then the Mishna wouldn't continue and say, "Oh, you're not two animals." Cuz you're allowed to have two animals with one knife in your backyard. >> You look You look like you're not with me. >> Okay, great. So, you like in Texas >> for real? >> Welcome back. Welcome back. No, I I just thought I didn't explain it. says it says two heads, but it's only after the fact you shouldn't do if safer the purple is talking about. Now I go to yellow and I continue with kachum is good. >> Yeah. But listen at home is 100% good for number one don't have two holding on to one knife one person you it's really a combination of two words because he holds we go by the way it's written So it's okay. But if the is actually talking then the continuation doesn't work well because now all of a sudden you have a continuation that's not accurate. It says it's only it works even in the first place. Okay. And finally, finally one more. One more to prove that the is and the safe is talking about the kitchen. Nobody argues. Everybody agrees that the racial is here. Let's just go back here in this thing. He says it says he just repeats the question. So why does the mission repeat itself twice? They bring him to I love this lion. It's like a new lion to us. It's a lot of yuma comes another k steps in and finishes it off. Why does another kind step in and finish it off? Because the has to grab from London. I I saw you, but you're like not even a guest anymore. So yeah, >> it's like dove. They come every two months over here. >> What are you doing here? Why are you here? >> MDY. >> Well, what a MDY. >> Beautiful. Send him. Send him regards. the cog needs to do. So he starts the drops the knife or passes it on to someone grabs the blood and another guy finishes off the I would think and he did he did so it's enough what if the it seems like you need another kind to finish off the job that's why I have the second that's why let's go to the easier one hold on it's easier to see it over here that's why I have the safer that says to tell me that it's enough for the to do even That's enough. I don't need the second guy to do to finish off the job. It should be possible if you don't do it. I don't need the second person. So why in the world is he there? Wait a minute. But now you have someone else performing the has to perform all the Nobody could step in here. Maybe there's a little bit of absolute. Why? Because he didn't cause all the blood to come out or whatever. But that's why I need the mission to tell me that he didn't do anything at all. Nothing wrong with what the go and letting somebody else finish. But since there's no nothing, so then why in the world do I need another kind to finish off the job? In order to get all the blood out, I make sure I get another K there to do it. But there's no no nothing turning of the D by D global specialist in international financial services. Here's the here's a question. Think about this question for a second. Somebody started sheing a sheep outside the B mikdash. outside in he starts the process starts cutting and he finishes as he walks in the B mdish he's in the B he finishes where did he this animal >> huh >> he started he did slice number one in Bamesh slice number two in the B mikdash >> yeah Yeah, he's slapping him. Please don't answer if you learn to soy. Ah, >> I don't Yeah. Yeah, that's that's that's right. No. What do you say, Gary? >> It's considered at the end. Why? So, that's exactly the question. Does the start and end? And it's one longita. It's all a process and therefore it comes out and or no we go by the last last second the last slice and the last slice happened in in a good place. So I don't care where you started it. >> The last slice of the >> Yeah, of course. Yeah. Here we go. as he's there's a little timer over there. So there and the the other clock only went at the last second. Okay, you want to see it again? This one? Look at the two clocks. One doesn't move. The one on the bottom doesn't move only at the end. And one it's a gauge. Sorry, gauge. I should call it a gauge. Uh, miles per hour. Okay. So, so we have he says in the name of we had a when does the when you pay rent is it at the end? Does he work the whole the whole throughout different in the same idea he says no is only at the tail end of the at the tail end of the no the entire process is part of the and the explain what is if number one performed everybody agrees that the did the second sim this is possible the the Yehudi. He performed a a he cut the trachea and he made it he he rendered it tra right away. By the time the Jew got there, it was already because the is not valid. I don't know if you could zoom in, Gary, into that on that shelf over there. There's there's a red line on the divides in half. And are you able to zoom in? >> Yeah. >> Or or Shabi, give it to me and show me >> Yeah. Let's see. Prove. >> Oh, just give it to me. >> Okay. Here's the red line. Is the red line. He perform all below the red line. performed above the red line. Another another difference between and is that we mentioned before you only have to do malik on one simila two. So what if he did he was trying to do malik on a bird and he did one simmon below the red line which is in the wrong place but it's actually the place of the soar says and you're trying to say that it's one long process but in this case everybody's going to agree it's no good did one or did one simmon below the red line Why? It's as if you below the red line. So where is it over here? If he one simmon outside of the mdash and one inside since holds that starts all the way in the beginning and ends all the way at the end. So comes out that wants him outside. for outside but according to it's only the end part and the end part wasn't was inside the master didn't say that what you just said who's the master didn't say what you just said do the same exact if you one simmon below the red line and one above the red line. You told me that it's 100% as if the is below the red line. So if you one simmon outside with a bird and one simmon inside mikdash. So it's the outside ofdash. So by you able to by you're able to differentiate and say oh the first is considered and you did it below the red line. Oh so the first sim is considered he did it. So that's outside. So what's the and where where do we have a differentiation between? Oh, we have a video that if a person and then he got somehow into the real quickly. Here we have it. He started at the then he brings this nonmoving sheep all the way to some mdash and he's able to skateboard up the stairs and then he does the rest. Oh that in this case this particular case that's He started the outside of he finished it inside according to where did the start in the beginning of a skateboard ride and therefore it's as if she did outside and cars for that but according to in the name of what is his name it's only the end part so the so he did great he brought bought this animal half into the rest. He's not anything. Oh, it's because we're going through different of and and learning these over and over. And today we're going to add a little bit when you listen to this and this is that we never spoke about we barely spoke with a paradum is to make people tar people that are they went to the only way for them to become tar and that's why we have a problem today with we don't know you take the part when you burn it you take the ashes you mix it with water you sprinkle it on the person two times and it becomes tar is a very fascinating if a is sheing a paradum and while he's shuffling paraduma he text messages his wife the paraduma is apostle you have to go pay another $4 million and buy another paradum if you do anything while you're doing performing the paraduma no good now I also have to show you this because going to say haha and usually haha by paraduma means sprinkling of the water in this case it's not the sprinkling of the water it's the sprinkling of the blood one of the processes in the paraduma is the kind of take blood and throw it sprinkle it towards the bid. Here we go. It's a This is an addition for today. They see a paradum beautiful red. Today they the the for there's no paradumas left anymore in the world. They all grew black hair whatever no more. They bring up these children that never see tum in their life and they put them on door so they don't extend their hands beyond the door. He does grabs the blood and he tosses it towards the B mikdash. That's what when the now is going to say it means this. Now while he's doing this he does something else. He checks his phone. He slices a watermelon. It doesn't matter what. Then he washes his finger on the part of the fine. Whatever he does, he passes. In other words, the entire process of the paradum from the beginning, from the all the way to throwing the blood to burning the whole thing, you could ruin the paradum. We all know, we learned in that the paradum has a di what is it called? >> Dimetrically. Yeah. Okay. Whatever the fancy word is. >> On the one on the one hand, it makes people that are A paradox. Oh, paradox. It's a paradox. >> The kayen who sprinkles the water on the person who's he becomes. The person that's becomes the person that's becomes. So very simple. Anybody involved in the so their their clothing becomes you have to literally take you ever heard of such a thing you take your clothing and put it in a mikvah dunk it in a mikvah to make it tar they obviously also have to go in the mikvah they have to become the rashi brings the gourd so we're doing gourd there's a restaurant in Chicago that has crazy amount the gourds. So as he'sing he also cuts a gourd. No good. So if the happened whileing we just showed what is what's he did while let's think about it for a second. Was this paradum a real parad at any point of its life? No. Why? Because you messed up on the first second of paraduma when you did it, you messed up. So does the performing the avoid in this paradum does it become? No. Why? Because there's never but you take it to the next step. We saw in the video when when does a come 5 minutes later after you grab the blood then you take the blood and you sprinkle it. So there was a parad for 5 minutes. It just what just the guy who sprinkled it. He cut a watermelon while he's sprinkling it. So he ruined it at that point. So anybody that dealt with this until that point became just ask a simple thing. Why don't we talk about let's say a guy was doing for 5 minutes back and forth or he paused it whatever he went on a skateboard a whole. So you have the person who's because he was doing on a paradum. You have a person who's doing a paradum in minute number five who's not because that's when he messed up. That's when he cut a gourd. So he's not in the itself. It's a very long process and the whole thing is considered aita. So let's let's split the there's a person who becomes Tommy from a from a paradum in theita and there's a person who's not in the what's the obvious answer to that that once you mess up at minute number five that minute number one never happened it's one you messed up the whole was messed up this part of the room was never so let's see inside should be if there was up in the he cut a watermelon while he was shing. So depends let's let's distinguish between before the watermelon after the watermelon anybody that dealt with the before the watermelon comes but after the watermelon and we're going to finish off with this is he talking about it's no good when a person performs a like that at the end that becomes puzzle he chopped the watermelon then the entire wasn't good. There's no two parts of that. It's one no good. Have a wonderful day, a good shabas at 10:02. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.