Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 19 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning Rabbosai. Live from Bet Shemesh, my house. I caught some sort of stomach stomach bug. So I have fever and I'm weak. And the stomach thing we're not going to go into. So I figured it's better that I give Shiur here in my home. Yesterday last night's Shiur in Hebrew I did not give, I skipped. So I owe a Hebrew Shiur. I did I was basically in bed all day. So today this is about the Daf. It's about the Yomi I mean. It's about the Yomi. It's about the Yomi. I am going to make mistakes more than usual. And that's why you are here to correct me. Rabbosai today is Shlosh Siyamei Aggavla. It's also one year, exactly one year before the Siyum Hashas. Special special day. Reminding the oilam to say Sefiras HaOmer Hayom shiva v'arba'im yom sheim shisha shavuos v'chamisha yomim baOmer or lo Omer. This tzaddik was one of the three singers. Duvid Feder. This is an incredible recording. This is amazing. You what? Give Shiur in Hebrew and then we found out that the internet wasn't good and nothing worked. And until we got the internet working until this then I had to redo the whole Shiur in Hebrew, the whole Shiur in English. And Baruch Hashem Be'ezras Hashem we should learn for everybody. And the oilam had another >> Duvid, that kind of laugh that's Mark Ashkenazi that you're talking about. I at least give a I get a lot of coverage. He didn't go to the spa. >> Mark Ashkenazi is actually on the Wow, you can see here what's going on here. It's a beautiful Okay. Now, check this out. Uh Uh he has talent. Listen to his words how they flow in a Hasidic style with a lot of heart and a lot of um I don't know, I'd say like uh Uh whatever the word is. Okay. What's the word? You say. You don't know the word cuz you were schmoozing. Poetic? Poetic. >> Situational awareness? Yeah. Here. Here, poetic. Oh, you bet. Let me do this. Hold on. Check this out. Good morning, MDY family. I just wanted to share something. Uh I know maybe it's not my place. It just came to sing, but in English they say, "I got stuff for you." They take them out. Um I was the outsider of this group. And what I what I saw on this week was mind-blowing for me. It feels very strong points that I took along. And it was very inspiring. First of all, the unity between everyone. Everybody comes from their background. And while this whole week I wasn't able to tell [clears throat] how much money each of you have in your bank account or what you do for a living. You just kind of left everything behind. You just came with your heart and your soul and just spent beautiful time together. And was really inspiring for me. It was really beautiful. Everybody cared about everybody. And that was one very strong point for me. Another one was the dedication. The dedication for Toyota and the dedication for this beautiful MDY the quality of organization or whatever you want to call it, but the way everybody puts in their whole heart and soul in it and it >> [clears throat] >> and nothing stays in the way. Like it was Shabbat that I I saw Eli giving the last year a few minutes before the moment like I came after preparing myself for Shabbat and I was already like I know after singing before the moment I just go put away my mixer stuff and I go down there and then I see there Eli sitting and recording his last year because one of the recordings whatever something was didn't work. That was such inspiration for me. And I saw these kind of moments the whole time. Also, the vulnerability. Same as the showers when everybody shared such showers by the sea. This was just was amazing to watch. So, yeah. Also, like in the morning, I don't remember his name, but one of the made a siyum. And I don't know why, but [clears throat] I'm the outsider and I felt so happy for him. I felt so It was It was It was a moment and I felt it the whole time. Like, I felt like a part of this beautiful family, this beautiful organization. So, I just want to express myself that First of all, thanks thanks for having me. It was a true honor and a pleasure and a to be part of such a beautiful meeting avoda. And also, another very very strong point that I took along and I think it's going to stay with me for a long time is this bringing together the Torah together with life. Meaning that the way he brings it into our world in 2016 to our life. And it's not something that is so far. No, it's a part of us. We can enjoy life. We can have a good time, but at the same time, we can learn and we can we can bring in the Torah in our lives. That was huge for me. So, thank you everyone. Toda raba. And yeah, I really appreciate it. Thank you. Okay, so we really hope that Duvid Feder jumps on the bandwagon one of these days and joins us for the daf. Father was in the shiur, apparently. Tell us what's going on. Ah. Yeah, yeah. I think his father, right? Although, so I was just miffed for a moment a few months ago cuz his father was doing the daf. Yeah. Okay. We could pretty much jump in, I think. Let me just see. Let me just read this cuz I I set up a sponsorship for this person. Dear Rebbi, today marks exactly a year since I started doing the daf from D.Y. Last year on Chol HaMoed, his wife had a daughter who was born with extremely complex heart condition. She needed open heart surgery and the world-renowned children's hospital that we were in was refusing to do surgery saying that there was less than a 10% chance she would make it out of the hospital alive. Everyone was davening for her. We asked for a second opinion from a different hospital. We were warned there's little chance that it would give us a different answer. That night I sat next to my daughter's bed crying to Hashem. And I made a couple of kabbalahs. One of them was that if my daughter has surgery and comes out alive, I would start doing the daf. I was inspired by one of my cousins sponsoring the daf as a for her. The The day we heard from the other hospital. They said would take her and operate on her. Surgery was on Rosh Chodesh Iyar and a month later she was allowed home. The day we got home it said on the daf was Shavuos taf kuf ches. At the beginning of the shiur Rebbi played Golden Dove video. Look it up if you don't remember. My daughter is my golden dove and the daf is my golden dove. It kept me going through the struggles of the past year. I didn't miss a day. Even the day my daughter had her second open heart surgery and the day when she had a cath lab procedure done and every other stressful day this year was not complete without doing the daf. Now my daughter Bassie Bas Yala Esther is doing really well baruch Hashem. Although she still needs another surgery in a few years but im yirtzeh Hashem will keep performing real Hashem will keep performing miracles for her in the zechus of all the Torah and tefillah done for her refuah shleimah. Thank you Rebbi for your incredible shiur for changing our life. Your talmid Yehuda Zev Stepansky, London from MDY Bais Menachem Stack Boys. There was another um video actually but I didn't put it in. I was like I have to remember to put it in. I got a video of somebody had twins also. He said that he wanted to call his twin uh the girl MDY because he believes that that's why she's alive today. Mamish I got it on the same day. Chavala I didn't put it in. Okay, maybe we maybe the editors will put it in. Um The calm alien baby. He said he can't. He said he wanted to but >> [laughter] >> Alien baby. >> [laughter] >> Very nice alien. >> [clears throat] >> Uh no only one of them was a nice like nigla. One of them had a had You could say you could give everybody the ice, the kosher ice that we brought from America. This American it comes from America this ice. Ah it's kishlak. Okay. Let's jump into it Rebboise. Sefiras HaOmer Rebbi Mordechai Ben Rivka Shlita quick duches Mordechai Rebbi Yisrael Ben Leah Esther Refuah Shleimah. Official edition MDY Shas Maseches Zevachim Shlav Perek The Benedict Family Daf Yud Tes Kivi Nussbaum and honor of our children Hannah, Yaakov and Mimi. Dedicated in memory of small the Posick family foundation in gratitude of consortium and the alliance and all they do to support MDY. Anonymous and thank you to Chief Benny. This this cheetah man gave me a beautiful katoris with a very ravish Oh, here it is. It's on my table. I'm prepared but yeah, it happened to be here. Show you maybe I hope it doesn't have doesn't have his name in it. With the maktaris. And a beautiful ksav inside. Very very nice ksav. Shkoyach He also had the thing he poured his heart one of the top speeches. A lot of top speeches. Very hard. People ask me, "What was your favorite speech?" There was a lot a lot very hard to Okay, shkoyach the cheetah man. I'll explain to you the man a different time. I saw the guy thank you to Chief Benny. She sponsors Ari Simon as a monthly sponsor of my brother Benny Miriam. Yoni Daniel Rosenfeld How's he doing? He's getting better? Starting the process of prosthetic. Oh, it's a home. Weekly sponsors Moshe Markovich probably supporting the Spanish Yaakov and Lulu. Shmuel Dear, mazel tov Yaakov Schreiber and your seal for you and for Bas Weekly sponsors Howard Wimmer My and in honor of Bernie who got me to MDY two years ago this week. Anonymous Mazel tov Poliyavich, one of the biggest investors in Jewish education worldwide. The Yael Foundation team for the merit of Uri and Yael Poliyavich and their children, Benjamin and Matt. Anonymous for the merit of shidduch for Sara Golda bas Rifka. This actually could be a a really good fit, MDY with the Yael Foundation if we could cuz we really um do a lot for children. There's many, many thousands of children around the world that watch this year and benefit from the AI, etc. Weekly sponsors anonymous for refuah shleimah for Avraham Yishaya ben Slava Devorah and Rebbe Ruchama ben Yehuda's and Aviva Mostovsky, Nachman ben Nosson Mostovsky on his 50th yahrtzeit Gimmel Sivan. Daily sponsors Kenovation's LLC in honor of the consortium Elias and the syndicate Asher v'hatov lach. What? Just the play on words. I don't get it. >> all these organizations. It sounds like a convention of the mob. Anonymous for the merit of refuah shleimah u'meherah l'Rifka Sara bas Chaya Dvora who was having surgery May 19th refuah shleimah. Kyle sponsors month HYK Ventures LLC in the zechus for success of all our clients and Binyamin Daniel Rosenfeld brachah u'parnasah. MDY Kids sponsors Kenovation's LLC in the zechus of Akiva Simcha ben Feiga Rifka Yehudis bas Chaya Chaya. Month refuah shleimah Yonasan Eitan ben Moshe Aryeh brachah amen. Refuah shleimah Mordechai ben Esther amen. Refuah shleimah Daniel Zev ben Aryeh Esther amen. Reb Boaz side, we are holding on daf Yud Ches amud beis. Reb Shimon Lakish achshar b'chuda d'keiva. Let's see what we have here. >> [cough and clears throat] >> Oops. You see that? >> [snorts and clears throat] >> Let me do it again. The purple line is the chuda d'keiva. And I'll take I'll try to do the uh uh I'm a little nervous because I don't have a lot of room here and it could drip on my Gamara. Let's see. It's not the smartest thing. Okay. Who did the kiva would mean all the way over here. So, shrita typically is done today is done over here. Over here. This is the bas gdola. This is the final ring. This is the shipuya kiva. This is the Adam's apple right over here. This shpitz. This is the shipua. It goes downwards. This is the choid. Meaning this is the end of the kiva. So, Resh Lakish you could do shrita all the way over here. As you see in the chart, let's do the chart. You see? It's not such a clear picture on the screen. Okay. But who did the kiva? Corey Ali Rebbi Yochanan, Rebbi Yochanan says Resh Lakish giso giso. Giso is a lotion of gas. Too much. Your maxim, what are you talking about? So, Rebbi Yochanan is going to say Let's see. I don't know why this is not working. It's not working. Oh. Rebbi Yochanan. Rebbi Yochanan says you got to move the purple line to the Yeah, what's the called? Yeah, I know, but what's it called in our sugi over here? No, choid is the end. No. Um let's see. Maybe We have it over here. Oh yeah, kiva. It's called he calls it a koiva. Okay, fine. A call pardon him you could see over here the shitas. You have a shlogish that says you go all the way to the end of the koiva. Says Rebbe Akiva on you exaggerated. The Ritva says a beautiful thing here. Rebbe Yochanan and Rebbe Shlogish were brother-in-laws. So he made a play on words. He says giso giso. You exaggerated my my brother-in-law. Like it's a new way to call your brother-in-law. Gis gas. You're a gis gas. Your brother-in-law is gas. Amar Rabbah b'shmi d'Rabbah, paga b'chitei treifa. Okay, this is going to be difficult. I'm going [clears throat] to try. Okay, maybe take Do me a favor, take my Gemara away for a second. Okay, good. Thank you. This right over here, you could see there's a flap that covers [snorts] this thing. It's a flap. So I'm going to open it up. I'm looking for the chitei. Oh, here it is. Here's the chitei. You see these guys? Hold on. Wow. Basically the chitei are the I have them. Here they are. These two guys, perfect. They look like wheat. These are the You know, I'll show you guys. These this right over here. This guy is a wheat and a wheat. Um that's what we call the um No, what what you sing with? No, vocal cords. Here, now you got a beautiful shot of it. Beautiful. Look at that. These guys, mamesh Okay, fine. Gemara, please. I need a Gemara to learn. Wow. Thank you so much. Now, the [snorts] voice side of the day is at the end of the choir. Let's see if we see it over here. Yeah, well. There's somewhat over here. It's in this area by me. It'll be in this area. Let's see what we got. Here. You could see over here in this picture. You see the heathens? Those these guys, the the funny looking shape things. It depends from what area if you look at it from the front like I showed you it looks one way. If you look at it from the back it looks another way. Okay. So he says like this. Or I mean I put up a heat a treif. If you bump into the to the vocal chords, you already went too far. You buy low. We have to understand what he means. In Hebrew, I'll give you a muscle in Hebrew it's called pagash. Pagash auto. What does pagash mean? I I met him, but does it mean I actually touched him? Not really. I bumped into him. You say in English also bumped into him. So I bumped into him doesn't mean he physically touched him. He bumped into him or he bumped into him like he ran in front of him. So that's the question over here. Pagash nagabem, did he actually touch him? He bumped into him literally. To save you got By the way, Avi sent me something. And I started reading it and I couldn't believe it. It's my the name Joselowski. And you wrote me that the Hamas did a protest in front of a show. And said her name and then I couldn't I didn't I had an emergency cuz of my stomach and I just dropped my phone and I ran. And [clears throat] no, but that that's my first cousin. Shira Joselowski it said. You even said her maiden name. I don't at the Shabbat home on our table, Joselowitsky, my aunt, Joselowitsky. That's my aunt. No, it says no one was going on in America. Hamas are doing protests and garnished. Harassing people as they go into shul. Or maybe men men means that you don't have to go all the way over. You don't have to go into You didn't touch it, it's still treif cuz you got to it. You're in the wrong area. What? It's only a kasha according to R' Shloka's cuz it'll be a problem. No. You overdid it. Right, right. So, we're going to see there's many different shitas here. Pretty much it depends if the knife had situational awareness. You can't You can't overuse the situational awareness. They overused it in that word. Stick with this thing. Okay. Over there, obviously that the knife hit him and he died, so it actually touched him. Or it went up to it but didn't touch it. You can see you can go by my halacha here. That the malachim came, it doesn't mean they touched him. They they they they met him. So, R' Papa says that if you cut the chittin, you cut the vocal cords, but you you leave a little bit of them, then it's kosher. Meaning, you didn't go past the vocal cords, you're in the vocal cord area, it's kosher. This is who? R' Pappi. So, let's let's go back over here. R' Pappi? Yeah. Oh, [clears throat] no, cuz R' Pappi we had before pog of a chittin treif. So, that's R' Pappi. Let me see what it looks like. R' Pappi. So, over here you could see that he's machmir. His His purple line is more to the cut, you know, to the to the right. He He He want He wants you to avoid the chittin completely, R' Pappi. And Mar bar Rav Ash says you can go a little bit a little bit onto the heat them. It my arm of a little bit of a rubbish here with heat and share it. Omar I may my bear bear Mar Yenu call have a community carrier of here brother of Ravi I was in front of a real normally share with heat and share it. If you cut the vocal cords the heat they and at least you you you have some left over towards the head. There's two you have the the kind of the vessel going to the body and you have the the side going to the head. So if you have a little bit going to the head you didn't the the opposite the left is to the head. The left is to the head. Possible everything that says possible is towards the head towards the eyes of the animal. Closer the the closer to the lungs and whatever that's closer. As long as you leave a little bit of the vocal cords the heat they on either side so you cut them in half so to speak then you're okay. I'm going to let her have a vanilla of Ashi I'm going to let her have a sham in Missouri equal my suit to the last one. My suit to came to our place with Dora share with heat and share it. Okay, so another sheet that says that even if you shaft in the heat they it's okay. My bear of Ashi Omar Poga the heat they share it. Over here it must mean Poga means you didn't touch it. You went up to the heat they it's closer. Share cuz here it says before it's share with heat they try for. If you cut it even one little bit it's completely treif. So I have over here we have a sheet that that touching cutting the the heat they it's treif. So it's going to have you test me now with the because I may shoot you quite well a matter share it. The sheep we call it over it's closer. In other words will I matter? So let me see what we have here. You have when you see that that that apex that that guy that where it says koiva ulimata meaning towards the the corner towards the body towards the right from let's see if I could zoom in on it from this blue arrow that says koiva going this direction is okay that's ulimata towards the body towards the trachea the things with the rings everything from the blue to the thing in the rings is good v'aino dishy b'chitei and that means that you you from the you could see from the blue the blue arrow where it says koiva if you shut it over there you cut into the chitei turn an angle and that's okay because you left some chitei on the left side of it and you're okay rab Nachman actually mishipui koiva ulimata >> [clears throat] >> so the shipui is actually even further to the left shipui as we see over here ma t'lumdin How could someone understand it if he doesn't have a There's pictures they have pictures No a different maggid shiur yesterday said that if you really want to understand sugia you should watch a shiur that has diagrams Did he put out No way Did he put out a QR A different maggid shiur you mean Rabbi Dovid Didi? No No it's surely surely No you just said Surely he said that He but he but he didn't say a name of who you should go to to watch the shiur obviously He put out a QR Are you serious That's interesting Okay He has a presentation you can watch I highly recommend that but the bottom line is Okay You made the cut It's going to be a first. Talk to you tomorrow. Let's just show this. Why not? Even this part, even cutting into here is okay. This is this is the shipui. Even cutting over here is okay. We have a big problem because they hold that the shita must be done in the basak doila. Thank you. Right over here. This is the basak doila. Which it is I spoke to to Rav Iceberg. She said today obviously we chef right over here. We don't chef in between. We just chef. He's like it's impossible to know. He says it's very hard to understand Rashi. All the margin Rashi says I'll tell you the mitzias that the the thickness of the skin of the bull it's impossible to to to feel rings. How can you be a novice? This is in a chicken may lie here. But in an animal, how do you get to the thing? The basak doila I don't see it here. You know, we don't have it, but you know, maybe this, you know, this red over here. It's right after all these rings comes the basak doila. If you cut right in between It's kosher shibukashia. Yeah. Mhm. Maybe maybe you just And then he says he he had a good kasha. He says that if you do it, but I forgot the loshon. Um like a izmel or I forgot what the loshon, but basically if you cut like this, it's a kosher shita. He says how's it possible? You just cut through a bunch of rings. Rashi says it has to be getsur. Oh, sorry. >> could use a laser to Like you today could do with the CT scans. Like you you see you do. I'm a lay. I know. Like you look you done a like you look you done a. So they say it's like lotion of plain almond. You look you look at the schmuck a book. You look at the book. Like barrel and schmearl. I don't I don't know who you look at this. I don't know who you look at this. I know schmear that. Now let's get this away from my nose. Um I know schmear that. Now I know I just know Bryson. I love this. I couldn't prepare so well yesterday. There's a lot of freebies. There's a lot of names today. You have to buy the only schmear lady. So again the matter is towards the body. So this is like you know what I mean. From schmear the matter is all kosher. From And on this let's let's just show it on the screen for a second. Schmear the matter. Anything from the schmear boy from that downward slide and towards the body towards all the rings is all kosher. The only schmear lady. So this is the only one also on the screen. You see on the screen? There's a green line. Perfect. And all of a sudden he made a left turn. And he does the red somewhere else past the dollar. That according to the bottom is treif. The only schmear the bottom schmear you see you do. Why? Because you basically says as long as you do the right in the right place which he did over here. You can see what you should do here. There's a lot of lines but you can see there's the halfway point and there's the third point. The the blue lines in this thing are all thirds. So he did 2/3. Yeah? See these lines? The green goes through the top two lines, thirds, and then afterwards it goes the last third is red. But that What? No, that's only according to R' B' Yosi b' Rebbi Yehuda in the Mishna. There's no in according to everybody else. That's That's the sugia. And that's the sugia. We're going to see that idea in the Mishna. He says it in the Mishna. He says and they argue on him on it. They say there's no You got to do everything. Sorry. It goes in three steps. If you do everything past the it goes in three steps. If you do everything past the it goes in three steps. If you do everything past the it goes in three steps. If you do everything past the it goes in three steps. If you do everything past the it goes in three steps. Let me just go back over here. Here. You know what? We did a thing. Perfect. This is perfect. I see you forgot to take that out. According to if you do a little bit you do 2/3 in the good area and 1/3 in the bad area puzzle. Completely puzzle. According to if you did 2/3 in the good area and 1/3 in the bad area is kosher. According to this would be puzzle according to everybody on top even according to you though. Why? Because he did it. past the it goes in three steps. You see the green the green the green line going straight down? Where is it? It's not in the That's already in the That's already in a different area. Completely puzzle according to So, basically there's three steps here. You have the that says you have to have the total total in the You have that says as long as you do 2/3 in the 1/3 in the in the wrong area is okay. And then you have that says everything in the wrong area is okay. It's not the wrong area for me. I say the Kaiva is also part of the Shrita. It's all good. Says the Gamara that Rabon Shimon bar Yochai says the Shrita of Rabon Shimon bar Yochai is good. Shrita Rabon Shimon bar Yochai is more make all than the Tana Kama. Rabon Shimon bar Yochai is more make all than Rabon Shimon bar Yochai. So what's the big difference they tell me here? Now the same Rabon Shimon bar Yochai and Rabon Akiva Eiger. Maybe Rabon Shimon bar Yochai was only referring to the Tana Kama when he said it's kosher. In other words, I hold that if you didn't do the whole thing in the Tabasac Dila it's kosher. Not that you could go all the way to the left into the Kaiva. Why? Because it makes a lot more sense. He comes right after Hachamin. He's actually referring to Hachamin L'Chaim. So then he'd say the same as Rabon Shimon. Exactly, yeah. Yeah. Okay, but that we had already five times before today. There's a lot of Shitas that are saying the same things. I hear. It bothered me a little also. Why is Rabon Shimon doing Rabon Akiva Eiger? Because he is actually going in the wrong Rabon Akiva Eiger. Rabon Akiva Eiger. Maybe maybe he is going under Rabon. Imkain the Lema by the way. So the Lashon should have been different. Hey the Lacha on what we just said. Says the Gamara, Rabon Shimon bar Yochai and Rabon Akiva Eiger that are above the Tabasac Dila. In other words, to the left of the Tabasac Dila is all good. Yeah, the Kaiva we can say because in fact Rabon Nachman holds like Rabon Shimon bar Yochai. So we're going to go like Rabon Nachman like Rabon Shimon bar Yochai. Like Rabon Shimon bar Yochai. Okay. So now we have a long Sugya here that basically says a very uh simple thing that kind of repeats itself a lot. Omar Rabon Omar Rabon Shimon bar Yochai, Machloikes Shochet Shnei Shlishi and Eigrim Shlishi. If you did, let's just do this here right over here. The Machloikes is in this area that he did two thirds in the Tabasac Dila but one third was in the wrong wrong area. Are we good? The Rabon Akiva Eiger holds the Shrita being in the Tabasac Dila. say no you need 100% in the very we have the of the whole over here and 2/3 is enough. Take a look at this. You could see that he's going the opposite direction. He started from the bottom the red area. He started out with the red. He started out in the wrong place but then he finished up with 2/3 in the right place. So as we're going to see there's there's an importance according to some men to women where does that where does the animals in the leave? Maybe the is that he he dies I forgot what they call it the the leaves in the right area. He did 1/3 in the bad area. He didn't he's not going to die from that. Then he then he goes and he makes a right turn and he starts shifting in the right area. At a certain point he dies. No say died in a good in a good area. What's the problem? Or no? You got to the whole part the whole the whole thing has to be in the right area. I have to finish. I think there should be like more arrows on this thing cuz I think I see I see you guys a little confused. You see the arrow on top of the green? That's the direction of the should be more arrows maybe on the bottom of the red also showing he started from the bottom in the wrong area. Red red red red then he went then he continued the going green. I don't know if you could do that. No. He did it from the bottom. Yeah, why not? Cuz the animal's in the wrong place. That is it has to be started from the top and he just did it in the wrong area at the top. No, [clears throat] could do it. You could do it. Yeah, you could pull it. You could pull to the side. Says the Gemara. You're saying You're saying that he started from the cave on the top? I went down that way. That way and then went into the right here. Right here. Make more sense that way. Okay. We can do that also. And then it would it would actually be easier to understand the thing. He started by the cave and did 1/3 and then went down into the right here. Okay. >> [clears throat] [snorts] >> You flipped it? No, you just move it over. You just move it over. Let's see. No, no, you can't do it. There's no possible way when the life of this animal came out being in the right area. He didn't have a right way. He did 1/3 and then it died. 1/3 The first third was in a bad place. The second third when he died was in a good place, but he only had 1/3 in a good place. Let's see that. Maybe the case is when he started bad and went good. There did I have a kind of problem. So, the that tells us that if there's a little tiny hole in the head the animal is dead. But if the corner is halfway cut like this this animal is not treif at all. Not treif. Now you go into that slit. I guess. You know what? Because it's like a spring. It like it goes back. It goes Maybe. Wow. Memories. >> [snorts] >> Yeah. So Don't you think maybe I have rabies? It's not that bad. If if that's what rabies is, not that bad. It's just such a good >> [laughter] >> So I was always nice to begin with. It's very Wow. Remind me it's not doing well time-wise. How much time are we? I'm 45 minutes. I'm just going to use this even though it's going to smell a little bit. Ma? Is it going to the guy I have to use it for the Hebrew though? Yeah, give me this knife. Let's do it. Why not? We're going to if the animal Wow, it's not so It's not sharp. >> [laughter] >> This would be kosher by sight. Why? Cuz it's halfway done. Okay, but it's a little bit more than half. So I guess to to start it off is the problem. Once it goes, the mama slices through. So if that was like Oh. So now listen to this. Mordec What's Mordec? Because now all you need to do is come in there with a knife and cut a little bit more. So, let's say let's just say here here. Let's do it again for the for the thing. Let's say you found an animal like this and you can go in and you go boom, a little bit more. You're going to say it's why? Because you killed it. Beforehand, he was he was in a tray and now you just went like this and you you killed the animal. So, your your your amount made it Yeah. So, the Gamara >> [clears throat] >> Um I have no idea where I am. What's the connection? Over there, you went and you you cut more of that corner like I just showed you that's in the place of so it's great. But over here you're using it's like cutting his brain a little bit and then cutting a little of his corner and say, "Oh, look he died together with me puncturing his brain." It's no connection. One one is a head grandma in a place that's not good for and then I continued into a place of how could I connect the two? But what if you the opposite? You did a great two thirds and then you went and you you went off you you veered to the left and you went into the into the area that you shouldn't. Why is the shera? It makes a lot of sense cuz you did two thirds of a good that's what I was saying before. What's the problem? If you shut it most of the of the semen and then you went away it's as if you shut the entire thing. Maybe it's only going according to who in the mission says I can go with a right. Maybe argued and it's only that says okay. I understand. So, every time in the Torah that every time in the Gamara in Shas, when we talk about Rebbe, it only goes according to Rebbe Yehuda. Amar lei, "I know Rebbe Shimon Amino." No, in Hilchos Shchita, the Shammai would be playing because we see there are both an argument really see Rebbe Yehuda in the Mishna. So, maybe anytime that it mentions a Rebbe and that it's okay, it's going according to Shitas Rebbe Shimon Rebbe Yehuda, but Hakham argue. Listen to this. Now we have a real freebie. It's just going to reverse the the the names. Amar lei, let's see how long this freebie is. Amar lei, Amar Amar Rebbe I'm going to say, "You don't bring me right from there." What kind of the the the what I just did live, that's the whole thing was in the corner. But before you want to go outside of the Makom Shchita and come back in, that's different. But if you did a good Shchita and then you went out, it's according to everybody it's kosher. That now Rebbe Shimon Kamayu, cuz we learned that if you walk away in middle after you did a Rebbe, it's okay. Mar Zutra Rebbe Chisda, so it's Rebbe Chisda over here. Now it just switches around on Chisda. Ma name Ma? Which one? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Thank you, yeah. I almost forgot this. Check this out. Uh did we do this? No. No, no. No, no, it's not the slide. Which one? Which one slide do you want to see? >> [clears throat] >> No, I don't have I don't have slides. Uh you put in number 36 after you run away in middle? Cool. Okay. Um Mar Shimon Rebbe Chisda, Amar lei Amar lei Rebbe Yehuda Amar lei Rebbe Yehuda, maybe only one Shita. How do you know it's cool Alma? Maybe it's only Rebbe Yehuda that holds right. So, Rebbe Rebbe Yehuda maybe it's only him. Amar lei Rebbe Yehuda Rebbe Yehuda Amar lei Amar lei Rebbe Yehuda Amar lei what? Every single Rebbe in the world is Rebbe Yehuda. Amar lei, I know Rebbe Shimon Amino. Amar lei, I'm talking in Hilchos Shchita. The Shammai would be playing. because we see the mission that they argue. Okay, new so yeah, so that was nice. That was like seven lines. Here it says it says it says Here it says it says oh This is that the slide. Oh, so very did it well like you. Because there's one extra arrow at the bottom. No, he started from the top in the wrong spot. Comes back, makes a right turn, goes into the right direction. And and then he goes out again. I don't know I don't know I don't know. He says in the name of and this is important to remember. He says in the name of this question. I don't know I don't know. I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know. I don't know I don't know I don't know. Where did the guy die? In the good spot. He did one third no good, one third good. So in the third that's good on the right, that's when the animal died and that's good. I don't know I don't know I don't know. That's not good. Why? Because I need it's not enough that he dies there. I need the right of the in a good place. It's not it's not important where he dies. It's important that you have a right in the right place. I don't know I don't know I don't know. So now the reverse take a look. So now the reverse take a look. Like this. He he started off in the right spot in the goes off to the wrong spot. Then comes back in the right spot. I I'll say thank you to for really for really for sending some people to the to watch the to see this the charts. I don't know if I'll have time to Okay. Can I give you a hug? No, he told me once that 100% that he got people because of the sheer that because of what we push. We push the different advertisements and stuff. So obviously people are going to eventually end up by him and they'll say, "Okay, I don't like this type of shur. I'll go to him." So, anyway. So, now he's paying back. Payback. That's right. They ask Rav Huna and he says it's treif. Why? Because the neshama went out in the wrong spot. You look over here in this Let's Can we see it? I I didn't make sure that Before it was showing it on the screen. Okay. Over here, he started good, went no good, ended up good. Where did the animal die, Rebbi Yishmael, in this in this case? In the no good. In the middle. In the no good. What? It doesn't go by the It doesn't go by the neshama. It doesn't matter. We don't care about the neshama. What are you You're You're You're looking at the malach hamoves. You did a shchita. You did a shchita that's roiv kosher. I don't care where he dies. Shmuel bar Yehuda ikpad. Rav Yehuda heard this and he's very upset. Amar, "Tarifna umachsher. By the by by this case Yeah. Let's just How come it doesn't move? Wow. Okay. I don't know what's going on here. Let me go over here. Maybe this one is better. This mic's not working. Oh. Okay. He says, "In this case where you start off bad, you went to a good shchita, and you went back Tarifna, I say it's treif. And over there you say it's kosher. And now in this one the the reverse one where I say it's kosher, you're saying it's treif. What's going on here?" U'makhsher na tarif. And you say it's kosher when I say it's treif. Amar Rav Huna, "Shapi kamikpad." So, Rav says he's right for being upset at me. >> [snorts] >> He heard it from Rav. He's saying it from Rav. I made it up myself. I use my own logic. This case that you see on the screen, Rav was in a good spot. You see there's a lot of green, very little red. So it should be good. Then came master this law like I might saw. By the hegrim shaka the hegrim, oh man what no all one second. What? By this case when you went in the wrong in the wrong if you if you're going to say that he has to take everything back, so he's going to have to take this back also. Where did the animal die when he was in the right spot into the day law? So how can I make an after kiss by grandma going after kiss so too? In other words, he's saying I agree with your logic. Not this one, but this one where the animal die and that's what I was saying. He's dying in the wrong spot and should be bad. Oh, let's do the sponsors. Turning the dub a dub global specialist international financial service for the little show. >> [snorts] [laughter] >> We'll get there. We'll get there one day when I when we when we use it in sheer I'll tell them the crazy story. But then says the tomorrow I got to buy many things for the mall. So they asked him, what happens if he did this? No? Let me just make sure. Shaw actually, yeah. Good shita, bad good mouth. I'm going to love I don't know but I mean you mean isn't that exactly shita I see you can master shita. If you do a shita looks like a W. It looks like a a comb, kosher. There's a lot of there's the famous joke I'll just say there's a shiva bakker. Change it from a timon to a shiva bakker whatever but they he goes he says I need to buy a new comb. He says why do I need to buy a new comb? He says cuz one of the teeth broke. It's not so big deal so it's just use the rest of the comb. He says no it's the last tooth that broke. Yeah. I only had one. He's using He's using the comb with a It's one tooth broke so now it's gone. Okay. What's so funny? Yeah. It's absolutely hilarious. Oh my god. Shita I see you can master shita. So if it looks like we should No you you should have done it but I was sick I forgot to tell you. If it looks like a zigzag like this like a W a few W's then it's a kosher shita. So it says where do you see from here that that he's talking about that he went in and out of the shita? How do you know that he went from the into a place that's no good and came back? Maybe he's saying a that you do a W in the good spot of the shita that itself is kosher. I would think that's not kosher to go like this to shake like this even Imagine a regular shita today in the corner it goes like this. Why is that okay? And what's the problem that the says more than that it should be not okay because you can't really see inside. The shita shita what's the that you can do a W in the It is. But I'm saying you mean the shita is smooth for us you need a clean cut so you can look inside it the shita you pop it open look inside. If it looks like a W it looks like an accordion you can't really look inside. Everything is covering each other. You don't have a can't open it up and look inside and see there's a good chicken there. There's also a question of Rashi that said you have to be in the base. According to this it doesn't make any sense. But maybe Rashi is talking about only according to that cheetah. Okay. Okay. Right? Who knows? Maybe it's within that within that meat. In between the two boys. I don't know. Come on everyone. Simeon Bakod. You also have a baba. Let's try to get to the Mishnah. How much time are we already? You have two. I have two minutes. Less than two minutes. You also have a baba heard of Khan of Yosel Khan of committee of Yuda. Yuda is giving sheer. What? It's the video how it happened. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I forgot to show [snorts] a video. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. The question is how does a grama happen? What what what happened? So here this is more like a Pixar style video. >> [groaning] >> Ah, the grama. [laughter] Got it. That's how it happened. Now we can see. >> [clears throat] [snorts] >> Mhm. >> [laughter] >> Very good. >> [laughter] >> That's what really important in Gevoltig. So what do you want tomorrow? Let's make sure I didn't miss anything else from all our beautiful slides. I want to give a lot of thanks to the bunch of them because in the middle of the shear I felt like that was it. I had to get up and go. Take a break. We're not done yet. So they made this thing that I didn't have to use that I didn't have to use this. Wow. We're done. We're done. If I do then then we finish the shear right there. So it's going to be like this. Sorry. No. No. I was I was trying to do something here. So we have the same thing that we had a couple days ago. We have giving shear. Sitting in front of him. And behind we have a Rababa. The other guy asks Rabbi Judah. What if it's this case? Let's see. Going back to this case. Here. This case. The other boys are putting it on the screen? No. Oh. What do you want to say to say? I was going to say something. What if he did the next one? I can't believe nothing's working here. This one. Bad. Good. Bad. What's the What's that law? It's too long. Oh. I have no idea where we are. And and who's Gamora? What if there was already uh a cut in the corner? And he shocked it in there. I'm a lush good as I can share. It's okay. So listen to this this is where you have to use your head. What is the difference? What would be the after me know if there was a hole an existing hole in the trachea and you continue the hole with the knife? Or if you shocked it normally were in a place that there's no hole and then you came to where there's a hole. In other words, you only shocked it 50%. And Whether it's just a sham or not. But the season sham happened after 50%. Usually it season sham happens at 51%. Over here all you shocked is 50%. You didn't do it right. But together with the negative you have a right and then he dies. That that's what would be possible. Why is it possible? If I cut first No, no. Here let let let's say let's say let's say he when he came there was a 10% cut. And then he cut another 40% so totally have I'm sorry another 50% he cut another 50%. So total is 60% is kosher. Now what happens if he cut 50% and he gets to a 10% cut? So the heart is 50% made a whole a full sheet of cuz together with the cut that was existing we have 60%. That's different. Yeah, why? Why? Cuz his cut is brought over to the sheet of 50. Okay, but you did you season sham. You you use this 10% before you also use this 10%. You start the sheet that is already 10% existing you all you did is a 50%. So you did you didn't do a right sheet of the 50% sheet and that's okay. Cuz you're using the the existing 10% total 60. Over here you're doing 50 and then you bump into a 10%. So we have to see if there's enough coming. Okay, so let's go let's see. What's the I don't see enough amino. There's a lot of that if a guy starts to and a Jew finishes it off it's kosher. Cuz all we care is about is what you're able to do. You do your your end the guy did his things it's kosher. So if there's already a neck of and you just continue there's a 10% neck of and you do 50% so it's like the 10% the guy did and that's kosher. 50% and he bumped into a neck of not to give me a straw the guy my guy. That's as if you did 50% and the final 10% the guy did. The guy did the over here nature did the no good. I don't like what you're saying it's no good. Go home. I'm over go go. When he only 50% and the guy did another 10% so who did the guy? Over here when he bumped into the to the 10% that existed he's doing the what's the difference if he started off with 10% already existing or you bumped into 10%? He he didn't he's the one that did the he's the one that finished off the have a wonderful Merit this course of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a share today. sponsor.com or [email protected]