Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 140 by R' Eli Stefansky
1,541 views
Thanks for learning with us! - Good Morning - MDYsponsor.com - 139B - 140A - 140B - Have A Wonderful Day Support the Shiur: MDYsponsor.com Where to Watch & Listen Find us on your favorite platform: https://mdydaf.com/learn#platforms US: 605-562-0066 Israel: 055-DAF-YOMI (055-323-9664) UK: 03-333-661-463 Belgium: 0480-201-272 #DafYomi #EliStefansky #Chullin #MDY
Chapters
Featuring:Daf Yomi
Categories:Torah/Gemara
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Good morning.
>> First of all, welcome to all the guests.
We'll get to them in a minute. I want to
tell the about that we're doing
tomorrow. The Hebrew Shir is finishing
tomorrow. know the the English here is
going to be finishing on
Shabas. So we're doing something that
I'm not so into usually which is to
cover the mitzvah of the so we'll do
right after the Hebrew Shia we're going
to go next door to the push hall
everybody's invited it's sponsored by
Simon and Alex Catz
and Benny Rodnik
they went three ways and
there's other people
only one ticket per person do I know
it's only 30 shekel a ticket. Oh,
[snorts] 30 shekel a ticket, but do not
buy for
one per person kind of thing. Children
at home.
So, check this out. [music]
>> [music]
>> The MDY Gamora is a brand new initiative
where we're going to translate all of
Shas in a clear crystal way where
everybody's going to understand Shad and
going to the beautiful pictures on every
D. [music]
>> We've assembled the top-notch team of
editors, translators, copy editors in
order to make it perfect. We have an
all-star team creating it. We want to
create a gamarra that is readable and
that is like signature word gishma.
>> So our boys say
the is here. I just saw for the first
time here almost every has a picture
to explain the sug to make a mortgage.
Of course I'm picking the dap that don't
have picture. [laughter]
kids are. You'll see. And it's just
going to get more and more. Here we go.
Wow. Wow. Look at this.
>> Okay. A better quality. This is the
first time that we did everything in
house. All the
translation and editing and the pro
everything in house. So, we want to hear
what you think about the translation
versus the other one which was outside
company. The idea was always to have it
in-house completely so we have more
control and uh you know tighter on the
on the expense side.
There's a lot of look at this. Ah the
first time I'm seeing this
yala. So anybody that joins this year
gets one of these for free. Um Zman,
you're not
You want to join this here?
>> What do you mean? Like you mean like I
hear that? We could talk afterwards.
Maybe I'll give you a gimmar if
>> Yeah. Yeah.
Um Yeah. So it's a time to bring your
friend, tell them about starting a
newer.
A lot of people are inspired now to
start learning and do something.
[clears throat] um a bunch of people
just just the amount of people that
added from yesterday to today.
It [clears throat] looks like small
amounts,
but it adds up to $25,000
>> a month. Oh, no, no, a year. This is
this is the monthly, but total it's
$25,000 to MDY, which helps the machine
keep on going. These are the $52 men
neckludor
101. Abraham Fischer NJ has 180. Alex
and Rachel cats in addition to
everything else they give. Aikin 200
Schlommo Kapalovich 200 in Hebrew. Ary
Sparka three shekel.
>> But he did right his name was yesterday.
The day before he added
100, shekels Goldberg 101 Barry Moraiim
>> Brynim
Morzan Hill Abrahams where is he 200
shekel and these are
Stavnit Maurice Tam Per Shinman Schlommo
Benzaken [clears throat] Antioli
Anoli Yosip Okay so these are all 30
Arif Fleer
Garts
garts garts garts. Wow. She D Robbins
Daniel Marmmer David Rosenov Harris Fra
Hersh Ezra Salom Gdaler Gerson Winger.
How do you spell what? Vessel Velakov
is Bel Dove David. Joshua Weinberg. Josh
what? Josh David. What did I say? Joshua
Weinberg, Manakim Freeman, Morai
Rosenthal, Moisha Mazri, Moisha Michael.
Oh, NG has it already. We said Ofer
Linimal,
Robert Feiner, Yanke, Yankee, Lieovitz,
Yankee Lar, Yehuda Sternberg,
Yolinstein,
Yitzik Horn, Yseph Robbins, Yseph Barry,
all $30. It all adds up. a big maz in
the Yi Hollander had a grandson
everybody's invited to the zar the
location will not be announced
[laughter]
and Toronto
they are joining the bandwagon hold the
meet and they are doing
>> unmeat
Manchester is doing unmeat
dove har
You can't guys that for three four days
before shabs they're busy smoking their
meat and after misus hulen they see a
pizza party they go crazy oh there's a I
forgot to put it in Chicago's doing a
scene Chicago's doing a scene Mark maybe
you can put the Chicago see him in I
forgot this was cool I like this we're
not going to show it's in Hebrew I just
like where he
It's not Dave Shar from Boyside.
>> Basically, what he's saying is that we
learned today in cheer that if you don't
really do the mitzvah, you learn about
the mitzvah as if you did the mitzvah.
So if you never had opinion about
yourself cuz you're born second in the
family, all you need to do is learn.
It's as if you had aar. Yeah, you did a
pigeon.
This is very interesting. Dear Rebelli,
you can see my name in the list of MDY
monthly donors. I want to let Rebelli
know where the money is coming from. I
gave up my Disney Plus account just so I
have the extra money to give it towards
MDY.
>> What's Disney Plus account? What is it?
>> Like Amazon.
>> Oh,
>> that's what it is. So it's not the
money. He gave up also the watching.
>> Wow. He gave up his Disney Plus account
just so I have the extra money to give
towards MDY. I really appreciate all the
hard work of MDY. I want to wish the
entire team and family a happy and
healthy new year. Mayer Frankle Monty in
New York. It reminds me of your this
whole thing that we once did. Netflix.
No, that was Netflix. Here's the guy's
name. Mayor Francoyak.
Me doing the daff yesterday sitting in
New York City traffic.
What's this? Oh. Oh, Ken's Diner. OH.
OH, FLICKS. Ken's Diner. Oh, Chicago
should be proud. Rao, a very dear friend
of mine, Dr. Marty Dalber is in the
house. He's for coming. Dr. Marty
Dalber.
>> Oh, you mean you mean it's And
[laughter]
here's the real one. Raise here's the
real one.
an hour and they heard a [laughter]
they went to Ken's Diner AI in seconds.
Okay. So, is it or Ken's Diner?
>> It's so mean it's everybody's going.
Everybody say anybody can do chuva. If
Marty Der is here, he'll tell you.
He once came over to me. I'm talking
about 30 years ago. 30 years ago. He
said, "Listen, I see you have a talking
problem. I bet you you can't stop
talking in Chul for a whole year. And if
you do, I'll give you a roof to your
house." Roof. Roof is $5,000.
So, you know, you can't dear me. It's
not a good idea. [laughter]
And of course, I I beat him. I this. So,
at the end of the year, he came over to
me. He said, "Listen, but I saw you
talking once or that." I like, "No, no,
no, no, no.
>> [laughter]
>> He paid up like a tatala. No, I don't I
don't remember what happened. Did you
pay or I didn't take your money? It was
>> we'll talk later.
>> He's going to say that song. Anyways, we
could all do chuvo and uh Oh, talking.
Should I say the misa?
>> You want to say the ma? Say the m
>> I'll say the misa. I'll say the misa
because it's it's it's before him kipper
and uh we could all do better.
I came to this neighborhood and I I
happened there was an empty seat in
Schulz. I sat down. Who am I sitting
next to? I'm sitting next to
I recognize you this that a whole thing
and we had a little smoo and the next
week we smooed also during you know Beng
sort of kind of thing
couple weeks and one day we're standing
outside over here and a woman passes by
and she said to us she goes this is
disgusting the way you guys were talking
in Mil Davin it's it's uh it's terrible
I'm never coming back to this sh again
and she walked away but I want to be
Hey, this was 13 years ago.
Selzer never spoke one word in Schul
since then. Not one word during diving
ever.
>> At that time for a bunch of years. Can't
say never.
>> I don't know where you d in a different
place now. Since I know you, you took it
he took it very seriously. It it right
over here. Listen, we're not perfect,
but the point is we can all do chuva.
Everybody has a weakness in some area
and sometimes you need to be in the a
little bit and that's it. It's kadai.
It's here.
Here [laughter]
>> I don't know what that but it's
inspiration. Seriously, it's inspiration
for CL and thank you for allowing me to
say the story. No, it'll be an
inspiration. Seriously, we weren't born.
Not somebody's upset at me cuz I once
mentioned the story that 40 years ago he
didn't go to Shak. Whatever. Come on.
No.
>> Say tell him you're sorry now. Again,
tell him apologize.
>> But he it's going to embarrass him. He
wants you to say his name.
>> He does.
>> Okay. Before Yam Kipper, I'm asking Ma
from good old friend of mine, Remy
Menson, the story I said over about a
horse in in the dorm.
>> He doesn't like
>> he doesn't like the story. It's not a
story that even happened. It was made up
maybe. But the point is that I I I threw
him under the bus. He said that I woke
him up during shakers when everybody was
diving and we were in camp then and his
kids might have heard it and they might
have thought that he didn't go to
shakers that day. So I'm asking I hope
you're I hope you join the share and
have come visit us.
>> I actually started um I was talking
about that. I'll tell you something
else. There was a a video that went
around of a previous house of mine that
I used to live in and the owner of that
house was very upset at me. I said I
didn't tell the guy to to put it out
there and I didn't do but just yesterday
and I I was in the middle of leaving him
a message and I don't know I got some
guy called in. And I just realized I
never sent the message to them to ask
him. But I what I want him to know is
that somebody somebody told me yesterday
from Toronto that
was he says you know four people that
fell off the bandwagon. This is the
number he said four people they started
doing the d because of that video. They
saw where you used to live and they saw
where you gave up. They started doing
the daf because of that video. So it's
an inspiration for people. So he's him
and his wife should be for that video
coming out of the house as nobody knows
who it is in this but okay
>> what's I'm asking I need to ask you guy
I embarrass you in public and you and
you and you and you and all of you guys
I hope you get up get up a second I want
to be
you I'm you [laughter]
say loud the whole way say quickly
Now I have a new slate. I can embarrass
everybody all over again. You walk into
this room, I'm allowed to embarrass you.
>> YOU CAN'T STOP FOREVER.
>> OH, WHAT do you give me if I do? What do
you give? Huh? A roof of my house just
more.
>> You are right. I won't be able to stop.
Forget a year.
One day. Let's one day at a time it.
>> [clears throat]
>> with gratitude to Hashem for everything.
Nobody beats Kavansky's
thing. Oh,
I didn't mean
>> you you didn't you
I don't think so.
>> You don't think so? It was It was
yesterday. He We're going to get to
there today. Wow. What a kiss from
Hashem. David Sal dedicated memory of
The dedicated Dr. Nick Sabo Sheridan
dental services the family foundation
wishing the MDY family.
Chief Benny
in honor of Levy hosting
weekly sponsors Spanish sponsors
for
the family
of Yosi's bakery and borrow park
and today that's the breakfast today
beautiful breakfast
I'm on a diet and I try not to eat cake
so for bringing that cheese bapka
[laughter]
to the shear and I walked out and I I I
brought it home and it was guest and I
ate three lbs of itations
LC in honor of I'm not joking
[laughter]
this year anonymous
month Rachel cats in honor of their
beautiful children #promise kept
[laughter]
Alex, thank you.
Anonymous
looks the world. You try to give to to
to your children and you wrote their
names and everything at them. Israel got
his his air time, his 15 seconds of fame
over there with the nether and the dava.
He made up for it.
Misha Wexler in honor of Mark Matibski.
mdy.com.
We're holding
this might be in my opinion one of the
prettiest
inwives in the entire Tory.
Me and Marty Da will do this.
Oh, that's right. Tell them. Tell them.
No, Marty Zug.
>> I wasn't to say that Toro the Balori
wasn't there. Ellie had
uh standing behind me, sitting behind me
in the Torah. He's on my on my right
right calf. He's drawing out the truck.
[laughter]
I went like this on his back. I was like
doing severe this.
>> You remember what taparo was
>> because at the end he told me it's you
talk not
[laughter]
I just thought about a crazy story.
I once said it in cheer but you're
sitting here so I can't say it now.
There's a story in our where two people
they went at it from one side of the to
the other because they were talking
during ding. It's about ding
>> and one made a mah to the other one and
now their kids are married to each
other. One of them is my niece.
Don't say
>> I'm not going to say any names.
Wow. We got to learn.
You should send the way to the mother
and take the the chicks.
You think there's a mitzvah. They should
go search for the mitzvah. Like you go
for for pes before pes. You go to the
the fields for your matzah and you work
really hard.
You should go everywhere.
Go into the fields and find birds
which is
it has to happen upon you. Just you just
bumped into it.
The word can means that any type of nest
even if it only has one egg, one we're
not going to use our special thing.
We'll use it tomorrow. We'll use it
tomorrow. The thing in the kitchen.
>> Nah, fine.
Let's just use it now. Here. This is
>> Okay.
You cannot do
with
[laughter]
Okay. It's okay.
anywhere you find it.
How do you know that even on tree
on all trees
if you found it deep in the ground
already included every single place?
what I need in front of you on the way.
It's not it's not there.
It can't be something that's already
prepared.
These pigeons that come and sit in your
you make special nest for them. They
live in your attic.
They made their their they they they
made their nest in and different like
you know in the walls and the and in the
houses.
These this is interesting. This is your
chicken, your goose, your your your duck
that
ran away. They flew away and they made a
nest in the orchard where you don't have
control. Then it's not yours anymore.
Once it flies away,
what if they made a nest in your house
or these pigeons called
these are wild and you have no
connection to them. You don't control
them. They come and go as they wish.
There's no
Oh, so because if it's in your house,
then you have control. You're in you
have control. And we're going to have a
story about so anything you have control
over they'll go in your hand like this
like this kind of bird if you use kosher
you would be but
other types of birds they have zero
control they come and go then you're
potter
you have control
if you have control you potter if you
don't have control
I got to get rid of him cuz
Okay, thank you.
It has to be something that's not in
your possession.
We already learned. We start off the
you happened upon it says
we already learned that
in front of you.
You have this is interesting, right? You
bought this bird, but it rebelled. It
flew away. So once it flies away, you
lost your ownership over it. That's a So
therefore,
what if it says?
[laughter]
What if it says on on the path? What if
it's not on the path? It's in the ocean.
We need a positive for this to tell us
that the way is also in the ocean.
Oh, so here's
this is one
Get to know the Israeli trail system.
kids are mu. Now this is the next one.
This is um a nest in the water.
So Rashi says in what? How do you have
uh a nest in the water? It's stuck in a
tree. That's how he says. I don't know
exactly why. Why can't you just have a
nest? Maybe it wouldn't survive it. It's
in the tree.
If you have a nest in a tree in the
water, then
what if you found uh you do one of these
you happen to be in in the middle of the
sky so like on a plane. Oh, today we can
understand on the plane.
Oh, sorry.
How do you know? There's no that says
that the
so it says in the
so maybe
in the middle of while you're flying
around in the sky.
You're right. It's called but it's not
called
is a pathway on land or in the ocean.
The rug brings a ra from here about I
believe he says it's about uh
do you say on a plane they asked him
that was in the beginning of aviation
and he said no you see over here that
it's not considered a d it's called it's
called it's not called is no
or I don't know if you said it on one of
those two things for me makes more it's
better for me if I said it on go
back my
This is one of the most interesting shus
in all of this is one of those questions
you'll never forget. What if you found a
nest on somebody's head?
How exactly they have a nest somebody's
head? So I saw
and um I forgot who the second one is.
They talk about monks. They say there
are monks that sit for many months
without moving. They just sit and
eventually uh a bird could come even in
Tibet. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Monks in Tibet
they say hodu hodu. They say in in India
they have such a thing. They meditate
for many months at a time.
>> And
the point is whether it happened or
never happened. What is that?
>> Oh that for sure it exists. You're
asking
>> what that they sit there for months and
they just look at the sky. That I know.
But does a bird sit on their head?
>> Yeah.
>> Oh we had a little bit of this. What is
this here? This is I guess in this is
based on that cuz it's in India
says India.
[laughter]
All right. I like what the bin says
because he says he talks about this year
rash falls out on on shabas and so does
sukus he says you come rash and you
really want to blow the there's no you
come sukus and you want to be in the
first day and there's no there's no l of
she says that you a person wants to be
the mitzvah of but he doesn't have the
mitzvah so he's thinking about the
mitzvah he he he
uh contemplates the mitzvah He's
yearning for the mitzvah. By yearning
for the mitzvah and learning the of the
mitzvah, it's
it's a it's a nest in a person's head
because he wants the he wants to miss so
much.
Yeah, it works. It's good. It's cuz we
it could have said it's
comes from the
a person's head is like is like the
earth [laughter] says the famous gar.
What do we see
in the beginning of the Torah before he
was born
says it says in the
is
and at the end it says
or what does it say at the end of
he's going to live 120 years.
Oh, so this is
sponsored by our
look at this by a kamyanski in honor of
the killing of Kmeni the hum of his
generation and he did not know that it
says this in the daf. Did you know? You
didn't know what this coincidence or
what?
>> Oh,
the generation put him. We said it's one
of the most interesting dedications of a
gar ever of all time. And uh there's a
reason why. Unbelievable.
How do you see in the Tory? Because it
says all the way in Mirac
and Hmon ended up
>> dying on a tree.
There's a famous miser with the Ramban.
He had a student his name was Aar and he
went off to D Aar and he came to Ramban
and he said
>> came to him.
Onion kipper.
>> Onion kipper. Very good. Mamesh. We're
talking about arium kipper. And he told
he says, "How many a was Ian? I just
ateook a cheese." He took a pig in front
of hefted it and uh he ate it. Or
>> he took a pig, he killed it. He he
cooked it and he ate [snorts] it in
front of he said, "How many lav was?"
>> So said four. And he argued with him. He
says, "Five."
So then he tells Raan, you know, you
always said that everybody's name is
mentioned in Hazenu.
She says, where's my name in Hazen?
That's why I don't I don't believe what
you said and that's you say that's the
reason he went off.
>> Abad said to such a big why did you go
off? So he said because you said
everyone's in the I looked at the whole
I couldn't find my name. Where's my
name?
He says over here in that that week's
para this week's para [clears throat]
he says look at the third letter
you're going to be wiped off the earth
and nobody's going to know who you are
and what you are and some people they
stick in the ra from like raenu a okay
but a and for some reason this shook him
up real real Well, some people say he
the chuva he got on a boat without any
orars and he just sailed into oblivion
and nobody ever heard from him again.
>> The point is everybody's name is in the
story.
>> Who?
>> No, this isn't this story in the we
know.
>> Yeah, we don't.
It's interesting. uh he says if uh the
the nest is on a guy's head so he should
be with you can't even do
and therefore he says uh it's on a guy's
head a whole thing
says it's on a guy's head
where do we see Esther
it's also a ping this week's parish sort
of a ping about ponim but aster is the
concept when sins
takes away his his um he's not there
he's not you can't you can't see him he
hides so to speak aster that's the of
aster when sinned over there
did not reveal himself
how do you see in the murder which means
the head of is like fragrance
which is Morai
Morai
just real quick I want to say to some
what's your name
>> David Rosenberg
>> from
you
>> Ariber
>> brothers you both do the daf
>> he was at the shabati
he surprised them for the
>> in the Hebrew shabatan
>> English
>> in the English one ah
yeah Yeah. Yeah. I remember you.
[laughter]
Wow.
>> Huh?
>> You do. Was it good?
>> You going to sl your brother next time?
>> Okay.
>> Maybe. [laughter]
>> Very good. For coming.
What does it mean
that it's available to you right there
and you cannot do
we're talking we have a
finishing off
comes before the
ra before the maneus
hudus was a slave and he killed all his
masters and he became
It's not it's comes from a place called
Omra. These are birds. These are
pigeons.
I saw with my own eyes.
They're sitting there 16 rows.
The width of of a mill very thousands
tens of thousands of these pigeons.
Kiri they would just say over and over
pigeons would talk they would say my
master my master in other words pumping
up hordus my master my master now
these are pigeons pigeons don't usually
make sounds like that but what's the
idea over here the idea is that talking
about a person like who has a low
self-esteem who realizes he's really
he's born a slave
And suddenly he's a king and he doesn't
he doesn't really believe himself that
he's a king. So what does he do? He has
these birds pump up his ego.
Master, master, master.
It could be just like throwing in like a
we say on
those who go to the grion and forget
about it. But regular, normal people,
everybody besides me in this room. Well,
no, Rabbi Schwarz, he was there also.
Um you see
it's repetitive.
It's like for 15 minutes.
What is this? It's the same idea. When
you say something, even if you don't
believe it in the beginning, you say it
over and over and over and over and
over.
You tell yourself
not
it has the opposite effect when you say
that. You say hashem
kiri kiri you hear from somebody else
you eventually start believing it
girl from she jumped off the roof
>> yeah
try to marry
she jumped off
a little I think I can I think I can
>> think I can I think I can just tell
yourself over and over build your
self-esteem there's a pigeon over there
>> [clears throat]
>> refuse to say it. Master Master
Suma.
So stuma rashi stands over here show I
got to tell you kiss from not as good as
as uh as a but my daughter sent me a you
know family thing
happens to be my favorite word
she tells she tells the [laughter]
she tells her friend You're a shaita for
not saying it.
She says backi
you're know what I'm saying. I'm saying
master slave. I'm calling hordes a
slave.
The people heard it the the
took the pigeon and they killed this
pigeon for saying that this is a slave.
Sorry.
This whole story
pigeon speaking
it's just a story
says I testify that this is what
happened says
sometimes when you see something that's
so
I'm talking about you know a pigeon
talking when pigeons don't talk. So you
have to say that what you saw is real
but it's
not not necessarily
butish
it's
with with with
yes it happened but it's with words of
when there's a
bird there's no we're not going to have
you know
It says the word means kosher
when it says the word can mean also a
non-coosher bird. The word
I said it back in the day. Let's see if
we have it here.
>> Would you consider these birds that were
speaking tic
noisy
are are pigeons? [snorts]
>> No. The human being did
a kosher bird. A pigeon is a type of a
pigeon.
>> Who does the kish on them? He said you
I'm gonna make you do
can you afterwards like a girl?
>> Oh no.
>> What if a what if what if somebody did
to you if you
>> Yeah. What if somebody did kisses to
you? You become tra
no no no. Anyways here check this out.
The the says that the word is the the
second letter is going with the with the
ram. the same thing. These are the the
four things that tells you what a kosher
bird is
tear the
zepus
and so
in the word licked that it's a it's a
kosher bird.
You should not make a des
that resembles a bird. You shouldn't
fashion something that looks like a bird
called now it's referring to means a
bird. It means any bird
means you shouldn't make an eagle as
your
and in the word means
grasshoppers.
So remember this. He's going to do it
five times in a row.
The word no goes without it only means a
kosher bird. The word refers to two
things
and
we say it every morning. So it says
again and
it's a contradiction to what you said.
You said t means kosher means tummy
cough has wings means how do you say
grasshoppers in Russian? No no no no in
English
>> locus.
No the word fit in our means only kosher
is referring to I love this one.
It says
like we asked the question you'll say
the answer it's like fill in the blanks.
You say maybe means also the no it means
only
the word.
So why say it over and over five times
but now we're getting to a strong
finishing up. Oh,
on the branches there will live the
birds of the heaven. Meaning all birds.
Who lives in the heaven? Who flies
around in the sky? Even non-coo birds.
So you see the word se bird means non
birds. Says
yes they're called birds from the heaven
but they're not called birds. A regular
bird. B bird refers to only kosher
birds.
says
there's a bird that is but there's also
there's a bird that's
says no you made a good deal but not not
the right one
there's a
but there's a bird that's
what could it be what bird is that's
if you're talking about a that is
here is a
referring into birth
perhaps they're talking about the
mitzvah. So let me just show you real
quickly the mitsra the process of the
msro very important. [clears throat]
He's sitting outside of the city right
he gets two drawers these little what
are they called?
>> No.
>> Sparrow sparrow. Yeah. So two of them
one of them is you put the blood in the
water. Then you take the
and you dip the live one. This is the
live one. Dip himical blood with water.
spray on him and then you let him go.
There's one that you sh and one you you
let free. So you have two birds. So
we're talking about
the one you just what do we do with the
one he did? Nothing. You bury it. You
can't do anything with it.
Shave off all his hair, even his
eyebrows.
If it's the the one that you do and it's
telling us you can't use it. It's that
we already learned from the end of the
you should not eat from this. I already
learned the puzzle. Says, "No, no, it is
talking about the bird that you shift it
for the and it's telling you that you're
not allowed to eat it, but I already
have a that
this says
it's an you shall eat
your if you eat the bird on." This is a
positive. This is not a negative. So,
not only on a negative, you a positive.
Yeah, this is a positive shall
that means if it's not it's a it's a
bird which is not according to this.
[snorts] Yeah.
Sorry.
Yeah.
asking if so say the same exact thing
for
what you gain by saying it's talking
about go back to the tra the first the
first terrace that you had that's
talking about he said oh it's already in
the says
add to it
these are
number 12
what does it mean if learning the idea
of a good like that of a bird then
learns a tra is not a good we're talking
about
it's referring to the bird not the tra
bird
we're talking about a normal thing says
it says the two birds are alive
means they're alive in your mouth
so it says birds can refer once again
another question that A bird could refer
to a non bird
that they are whole that they're this
bird is not missing any limb.
It says that they should be
you see that birds could be
in the category. There's a bird that's
afraid
of this because says that a could live
goes through this
if you a tra live. So obviously you
can't use the word to tell me that a tra
is no good. So I need a special word for
tra
but if a a tra any animal or human being
or a bird that has a tra cannot survive
if it can't survive [clears throat] then
I don't need a special word for it. I
could learn it from the word that you
have to live.
One of the kabad um rebases
was very against people like trying to
fit their understanding of a mitzvah.
You know, the reason why we don't eat
pork is because it's not healthy. The
reason why we need tra because again not
healthy. So he when people would come to
him with the tra he would say he would
look at it and it was tra he' say
in other words it's it's a healthy but
it's a tra nothing to do that oh Hashem
is trying to save you from eating non
non-healthy animals
whether you hold that it could survive
or not I can learn from Another posing
up the whole there's a concept called a
what's a you bring a carbon not because
you did a bring a carbon because you
gave birth brings a carbon
it allows her to come to the mdash to to
to be tred to eat to eat
that's a what's a
is like a it bring to forgiveness so we
compare the two
inside the you bring these two
what you bring outside of the
again
talking again and the
is you outside of it's a to go on with
his life
if we compare the two so we should
compare compare the two.
So I learn that the bird has to be like
it can't be a tradeful. So I don't need
a for
that I cannot use for the bird. I cannot
use a bird. If you remember here just to
remind remember that uh fish was very
into san giving people $1,000 to do san.
A lot of people jumped on. So this is
irony. You have to burn the entire
thing. So if you look closely over here,
it's every This is before AI by the way.
Spent a crazy amount of money on this
video. Population 17,000 zero. If you
live, you wouldn't be living anymore.
Okay.
You can't use one of these birds from
city for
if you want to strip them off. The one
that there's two birds. one you send
away one. If it's a sending away one,
you can't send it away. Why? Because
it's a if anybody finds it, he'll be
eating or dealing with
you can't what
>> but it means that
>> but over there they said it's not a
problem. You could use the bird in that
case. [snorts]
>> The two different guys are fighting now.
It must be the second bird that we're
talking about.
What if you know this is kaparis?
Everybody knows that if you do kaparas a
big no no is like to sell to somebody
else. Pretend that you never did kaparas
to it. Double dip on one kaparis like
wow this is already full of somebody's
errors. I'm going to use it again over
here also.
One one one matsur us use this bird. Now
you're going to go here's another guy
mur sell it to him. No no no you can't
do that. Now, what are you trying to do
exactly?
You want to use it for the second bird?
This is the se the first ms you shed one
bird. Now you have a second bird. What
are you going to do with the second
[clears throat] bird? You're going to
ship it away. You're going to send it
off. But instead of sending it off,
you're going to sell it to another msra
for what? From you can't check it. It
has to be sent away for the first guy.
Obviously, you're going to let it fly
away. But before you let it fly away,
let another use it and then let it fly
away for both of you. That you're not
allowed to do
sold.
He sold to another and in return he got
a bird. Now that bird is also for you to
use.
It should have
again same thing all over trying if
using this bird to send it away.
This is going to cause a problem for
whoever finds it later on. So you can't
chip it off.
She's talking about a bird who killed
another person. It was just in the news.
What happened now? That the bird killed
a human being. How?
>> It's old news.
>> Oh, it like cut its neck or something
with it long.
>> But it was a tra wasn't a
>> Yeah. Okay. Because a bird could kill a
human being.
We had this also if the already passing
that it's you have to kill it. So of
course you can't use it for
it's before it was sentenced to death
but we know that it killed a human
being.
If you want to ship it off
you have to bring to bring to
rid yourself of the of the bad of the
evil. You want to
you gonna get bad rid of the the the
rabbing it? No, you can't shift it.
If you have a non-coosher bird sitting
on kosher eggs,
you can't have a mother who's why
we said means kosher kosher bird is
sitting on the eggs.
What's the problem if a kosher bird is
sitting on no non-coosher eggs? Says,
I'll tell you what the problem is.
says
it should be a bird they take for
yourself that you can eat and benefit
from eating it. If you can't eat it, why
can't you eat it? Because it's a trave
bird. Then it's not it's not it says in
the important this
doesn't mean those two words
the the the the little chicks the eggs
you must be able to eat. You should eat.
You can make a an omelet out of it.
It doesn't say it about the mother. It
only says it.
So it's not for your dogs. It's for you.
It says that if the if the mother is a
you have to do but if the if the chicks
are you why
you cannot do on something you can't eat
on the on the babies but on the mother
you could ask why
let's compare the mother to the to the
babies in the same
just like We already established that
you can't do on babies that are trave
babies that you can't eat not in you
want to compare the mother to the baby.
So, okay. So, but you can't eat it. You
can't eat it. Then I don't need the the
tar says.
What does means that the chicks that are
there's two ways to read it. How would
you read it without
aim?
There's a mother and there's chicks that
are
wait a minute. We just said that that if
they're
>> it's something you can't eat. If you
can't eat, you can't do
>> I know.
Huh?
>> I don't know. I didn't know that.
>> I don't know. You see later?
>> You'd see cuz you know it has a
different different shape. Remember we
had a whole suggest
pointy on the top. If it's pointy and
pointy, let's say
You didn't read it well.
It says
the mother is
if the are 100%
kosher but the mother is strafe then
hold on
anor healthcare bua global shortest
maybe
okay let's do these three lines here.
He stuck his hand into the into a nest
and he cut the the the neck of a chick
but a little bit of it. He didn't do a
full. So what's the shap?
If he left it as is. He didn't continue
the become
have to be able to eat it. We said not
something that goes to your dog
since he could finish. It's up to him to
finish the and he could. It's like a he
he has the ability to do it.
Perhaps that's considered that it's for
you. Remains in a question. Have a
wonderful day.
Meritus of spreading Torah throughout
the world. Sponsor Ashir today.
mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.