Daf Yomi Chullin Daf 12 by R' Eli Stefansky

[music] [singing] >> GOOD MORNING BOYS. >> [screaming] >> LIVE. FROM MARRAKECH, MOROCCO. Somebody asking, what am I wearing here? So. I'll show you a little video. Before. First of all, reminder to say shalom. Like to show you this video. This might explain part of it. Here we go. >> [music] >> What what are you watching over here? >> [music] >> And I've stopped watching. >> [singing] [music] >> Oh, so we [music] took this voice advice. We got the mark list. That's That's the right thing we got here. I ripped my pants by the way. No, on my knee. Oh. So basically the monkey drew some blood and dirtied my shirt. So that's it. And for the rest of the trip I have to wear this shirt. Yeah. Now what about the jacket? It's a different story. Okay, so we here it's about I want to say maybe 1:00 in the morning for us in Israel. What time is it now here? Right Right Right around 1:00 in the morning. So the one was a little tired. So we got to get a little enthusiastic over here. We got to get a stick of shalom. Oh, we got They're gone. The players. You have Let me Let me just spin this camera around for a second. Everybody can see shalom aleichem. It's a nice crowd here. Mom is Mom is beautiful in Morocco. The valley. Okay. Um You We saw a little bit of Yousef. We'll see We'll more of him later. I want to read this email. And the reason why I want to read it is because a lot of times people they judge other people. And they judge other people by the cover. We have over here three great brothers. Mom is great. Listen to their email. Hunter, Shawn, and Spencer, right? And we have two Briskers. Two guys from Brisk that came that month of Shavuos. And if you were to bump into the Zeitlin brothers, the long hair, you say, "Okay, they're hockey players. Nothing more than that." Now, listen to this email. I think it's very very important to hear this. As you've seen in the sponsors over the past week, me and my very close friend Ethan Zelig have been doing Daf Yomi for 500 days over seven Masechtos. First of all, I want to thank Ethan because even though he's not a hockey player with crazy hair, he's the only reason that those kids ever come to MDY. When I joined MDY in Sanhedrin, I kept doing the cardinal sin of Daf Yomi. I fell back and tried catching up. I never fell back more than five days and ended up finishing Masechta with Daf Yomi in Makos. I was better Oh, sorry. Daf Yomi. In Makos, I was better, but still missed days here and there. At my middle school, we were able to get Listen to this. 14 kids to finish Makos with MDY at our Siyum. And And with MDY at our Siyum, Ethan mentioned how he's not missed a day. I've never told him this, but the day Shavuos that base, I promised myself I'll do the Daf every day physically possible. This past week, I've learned my 500 Daf, but I've also went days without missing a single Daf Yomi. That day daf yomi. >> [cough] >> And I never understood what it's about what what it's not about the daf, it's about the yomi really meant. Because yes, the yomi is what makes it special. You're learning the daf tomorrow. But now I understand because the yomi is what makes me feel like I'm obligated to stay up no matter how late to learn some Torah. Whether it's 1:00 a.m. daf in camp, nothing but the daf post bar mitzvah. Yeah, so this is unbelievable. He says it in one word. But I think what he means is that after his own bar mitzvah, when he danced night away and had to give a speech and he's exhausted, he sat there and he did the daf afterwards. The yomi is what makes a 14-year-old stay up after seder because he physically cannot go day without the daf after the seder. Pesach night at 1:00 in the morning, he physically cannot go a day without the daf. 14-year-old. The yomi is the bus ride to school, the bike rides to mincha, the dinner and the daf and doing the dishes. The reason it's not about the daf, it's about the yomi is because when you commit to the yomi, you become the yomi. And once you are the yomi, you'll always have the daf. Because the only explanation of 14-year-old who can't sit in class for 30 minutes and hates doing his homework learning whether in arshkal video and now the official edition of the Yasha's with official. The official MDY Shas for over 45 minutes. I don't want to single the official out at the dinner, but I mean Myers, yes. 1:00 a.m. people. It's no, it's going to be like that and then all layla. Yeah. But Remeyer, everybody knows Remeyer and what he's done and what he's doing and uh you should call him. He's just getting better. This tomorrow is getting better and better and I have a major chappie here and I got to talk to you. It's going to be good about it. No, it's not going to cost you any money. >> [laughter] >> Do you have your money? Whether or not it's going to No, no, no, it's not it's not No, I'll tell you what it is. I'm adding I think I want to do pictures in every single daf. We're going to stick out. We're going to have charts and pictures. We're going to hire a schmucky guy just for that. It's going to be good about it. And on the visual edition of the Yishai's for over 45 minutes every single day for a year without fail is that Listen to this and this is it. I am the Oimy. Thanks so much for allowing me to become this, Hunter Zaitlin. Look Now now look at this picture again. Now look. Halevai Halevai everybody in this picture without pointing out who. Halevai they could say that they learned 365 days straight and that they learned 500 daf of Gemara. With the hair, without the hair, with the white yarmulke and the black this kippah, that kippah, it doesn't make a difference. We're all learning Torah and that's that's the key over here. bring more and more of a Yid into Torah. Reb Boaz I Spheres Olam is the first half of Maran Rabbeinu Luria. For the kedushas Maran Rabbeinu Luria as well as for And the official edition of the Yishai's Re- Re- Myer, get over here. I I I got to get rid of you in the picture over here. I don't know you you Get over here. Get over here. The official edition of the Yishai's the Maseches Zevachim Yevamos Perek by the Benedict family. Yashar koach, Myer. Yashar koach. Who's the Reb cup? >> [laughter] >> What is this? I don't know. Talking about a Reb cup, I don't know what this is. Okay. Daf Yud Beis by anonymous fats l'chvod Rabbeinu for all of Klal Yisrael. Next. Oh, the mesecta. They'll sell They'll sell Sheer sponsors mesecta. Sheer's mesecta. Something like that. Okay, we have to figure out a better lotion maybe. David Solomon dedicated in memory of Aubrey Murray, Reb Shmuel Boruch ben Reb Chaim Tzvi ben Reb Dovid Zecharya ben Reb Boruch. The Paley family foundation in gratitude to the consortium and the alliance and all they do to support MDY anonymous. The cheetah man who's in the room here. Asaf, don't look around. You know who he is. Asaf, don't look around. They're going to hop what it is. Asaf, you got me and thank you to Chief Benny. We had a sticker safari today in Marrakech. We had monkeys, we had snakes. They had a sheep. They had a sheep They had a sheep. What else? We had We had horses. Binyamin and Danielle Ros- not Daniella, Danielle. She's here with us on this trip together. Where's Binyamin? Danielle, right? Why don't you say something? Nobody wants to correct me. Binyamin, get over here. Binyamin, say hello. He says no. Brias v'simcha. Monthly sponsors Ari and Simon l'refuah shleimah of Aubrey Murray, Boruch ben Miriam, Binyamin and Danielle Rosenfeld parnassah b'shefa. Weekly sponsors Moishe and Ruchie Markovich Markovich proudly supporting the Daf Yomi in Spanish l'refuah shleimah. Harav Yaakov ben Lulu l'iluy nishmas Reb Yisrael ben Amiel alav hashalom. L'iluy nishmas Harav Chaim Gedaliah ben Yeshua alav hashalom. Moishe Nachum in honor of David Sutton F20 for his commitment to the Daf and everything he does. Sorry. >> [laughter] >> F20 is one of our greatest leaders. Really? Get over here. Get over here. I'll see you. Get over here. Come on. This big stuff. Big stuff. Come. Come. Come. Come. Come. WE'RE DOING THE WHOLE WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT? One minute. I think you should read it time out. You should read it. In honor of David Sutton. David? Yeah. In honor of David Sutton F20 for his commitment to the Duff for a very long time and for everything that he does. He gives himself up to class one. We also We also have a motion. Yeah. I know. I know. Yeah. All right. Malachi. All right. It's good. All right. What a trip. The boys say what a close. Next year Dylan's going to have FOMO. You never know. You never know who's going to be here, who's who you're going to miss. The Ben Shushan brothers is unbelievable. Anonymous. All Yossi Klein. Yossi Klein arranged it all. It's good. All the stuff. Anonymous. The scores for Schliemann and my brother are undergoing heart surgery today. Schliemann for Schliemann everybody together. For Schliemann. Praise the Schliemann you all know whose kid this is and you should have a for Schliemann. Amen. The HYK Ventures in this in this course for success of all of our clients. The Yummy and Daniel Rosenfeld and Nosa is the co-sponsor. MDY kids get over here. MDY kids sponsor monthly Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann. And MDY Coffee Corner month Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann. MDY Art. Month for Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann Schliemann. The thing is I don't have a clock. I don't know what's going on. It's just 33 minutes. How How much How long are we into this? >> [snorts] >> Okay. Yeah, I know. Dylan is Dylan is tired. Hey. you weren't If you weren't tired before the meal tonight, seven courses later, from duck to sweet breads, if you ate that and you didn't know what it was, I'm just telling you it's somebody's brain. And then we had It's not a knish, it wasn't chicken Kiev, it's called a pastel. Kids are chicken Kiev with some blurs. >> [laughter] >> That's a schmuck of a potato. You schmuck of the chicken filled with potato. Yeah, call it whatever you want. I saw that that that that same exact chicken for years in Midwest Conference Center in Chicago. >> [laughter] >> We're We're doing dub you'd base. Ah. Ah. It's mighty. So, listen, we're going to have a We have a great a great dub here. Omar Nachman Omar Rab. So, here's the question. I'm going to throw out a question and you tell me what you think. If somebody is doing a knife practice on a wall, he's trying to hit the the bull's eye on the wall, and he throws a knife at the wall, and as he's throwing the knife at the wall, a cow walks by and has his neck shechted. Is that a good shechita or not? Because he obviously did not mean to shecht anything. He was trying to do dart practice, knife practice. What does the alum say? Good shechita or not good shechita? You say no, you say good. Ah, that's That's a very I think I Very good. Very good. So, that's one of the interesting cases that we're going to see. Says the Gemara, I do want to show you something that has slightly to do with the with the Gamorah later. Oh, it's not in here. Oh, it did. It is in here. Okay, maybe should I show it or not show it? That's my shala. Should I show it now? I'll show later. Okay. Omar of Nachman Rava Shmuel Shochet If you witness the shchita And this is my choyon could happen here in Marrakech, you know. You You could possibly see a shchita suddenly and you don't know who the shochet is. Imra mitchela at if you if you saw the entire shchita from beginning to end muta lachum shchitaso then you're permitted to eat from his shchita. What's the concern? The concern is that the guy doesn't know halacha. He's going to do a drisa, which is very common, meaning he's going to put downward pressure or upward pressure, depending what position he's in, but he's not going to do a back and forth slice. You're allowed to You're allowed to eat from the shchita. Why? Cuz you saw that he was okay. V'im lav, if you didn't you didn't witness the whole thing, osur lachum shchitaso. Ask the Gamorah what's the case. If the other the Gamorah, if you know for a fact this guy knows halacha, lo amur then you don't need to watch him. That's what we saw. Eidei b'sur a person is believed to say that he himself did the shchita. It says I believe that was the possuk, something like that, to the point where the possuk says you do shchita you eat. V'ei the other the Gamorah, if you know for a fact that he's not a talmid chacham, he doesn't know halachos shchita, of course you need to watch him from beginning to end. V'ela perhaps there's a third option. D'lo yada Gamorah You have no clue. You're in Marrakech. You see a guy that claims to be Jewish doing shchita. You don't know if he's good or not. So what's the tzad? So So let's say you don't know. So why should it be okay not to watch him? Cuz the Gamorah says leima there's a svara to say roim at shchita mumchim head. We have a road. There's a road that tells me the most people that deal with Shkreli Tom You're not going to mess around with Shkreli Tom if you don't know what you're doing. Most guys are average person that has nothing that doesn't know anything about Shkreli is not going to shock. It's a road. So we go with the road. We just had also yesterday what do you know road. This is for sure road the less come on. I mean you can't count how many people know Shkreli don't know Shkreli deal with Shkreli not deal with Shkreli. Oh we have a road. I don't know what I'm saying that should have worked. You like Tanya are you sure you're going to go to school to be shocked? You found a chicken shocked it in the in the market place. Mom Mom kiss from a sham who just in the shock. Unbelievable. I show him Shkreli saying Shkreli the whole month of Shkreli. So this is the road you tell your guy. I wish oh my back. Listen they should really show a video of my my back. It might just I they said listen you have nothing to worry about. There's a lot of there's a lot of a lot of security and even if you don't know about it they're there. I happen to be on the last wagon. How many wagons do we have? 14 wagons I was in the last last one. carriages two horses and a carriage there's about two people for two people in each one. I had four I had the source to be with a couple. And as right before we're going to go this guy tall dude with a black suit looked impressive jumps onto the carriage. Okay so I hopped that he's part of the security. But then it took me 5 10 minutes to realize that there's a motorcycle with two guys with guns with us the entire time. And when we stopped, they stopped. Every time And and then when there was a little bit of an issue with traffic, they zoomed ahead and they stopped traffic. Then they came back to being in the back. That's how it was. Then we get into the marketplace. All of a sudden, this guy that's in the front of of my wagon is standing next to me. I look at him, he looks at me. So I I wasn't sure, so I start walking to the right, so he walks to the right. I walk backwards, he walks backwards. So then I start running. She start running. She would have They told him, "Don't leave this guy for a second." So they didn't leave him. The entire was just a little embarrassing and uh but it was interesting. It was interesting. I have to say it was interesting. My wife didn't want to have anything with it and that's why she was she was not there with me the entire time. But it was very it's very cool. So that's the shuk. But they were there the whole time walkie-talkies and coordinating. Masha'allah. Two guys came over to us and said, "Free flat Palestine." So the guy that was with me walked over to them. He said something to them and they started running like rats. Full speed, but they didn't stop. They kept on going. And I I was just I was just impressed the entire time. Anybody try to sell us anything, perfume, this, they disappeared. We don't know what happened. A lot of dead dead guys in the shuk. They neutralized them. So anyways, so at least for that it was good. >> [snorts] >> Biter. So, Oy, shalom aleichem shalom aleichem shalom aleichem shalom aleichem. So this is very interesting. You tell your best friend, Reuben, "Go ahead and do me a favor. I'm having a party tonight. Shecht an animal for me." You come home, you come home and you find a shechted animal on your counter top. Now, you're not sure who shechted it. So I thought it happens. Guys The guys in the Hebrew shuk they looked at me like I was crazy. So, I'm just going to say for the English guys, maybe they'll appreciate it more. Does it ever happen to anybody here? I don't know. It happens to me all the time. Uh for example, let's say I want I want my son to bring me a cup of water. I think to myself, this guy needs kosher. So, I'm going to give him exactly what he would have gained. So, I say, "Yoyel, give me some uh give me some water." A minute later, my wife shows up with a cup of water. Like, "What are you doing?" Like, "I don't I'm not really thirsty. I want this kid to to get some of the hava." That's what it seems like over here. I I tell this guy, "Do me a favor. Go shuck something for me." A minute later, it's shucked, but somebody else like why who asked you? I didn't ask you, I asked him. But, you know, the guy wanted to to help out, so he shucked it. Maybe that's what happened. I didn't see this. So, let's see there's something Shalom Aleichem, Reb Chaim. Where is your garbage? It's over there. >> [snorts] >> It's a nice clean house, but in the garbage can, oh, this is mamzer sugia. You think this is off? This is the sugia right here. So, we're going to see like this. There's actually three three possibilities. You find a dead cow in a heap of garbage in middle of the Marrakech market. What does that tell us? The chareira. What is that? Kosher or not kosher? Very not kosher. An aveila. You find a dead animal in your house, on the kitchen table or you find a dead animal in your garbage can. So, if it's on your kitchen table, what does that tell me? It's kosher. It's good. What if you find a dead animal in your garbage can? That's the That's the shaila. That's the machlokes really. [clears throat] So, let's see inside. >> [snorts] >> Cuz cuz he shochet, you find it in your house, it's great. Machlokes because we have a raiv. Who shocheted it? I don't know. Is it Ruvein that I told him to shochet it? It's another guy, but most people that shochet are mumchin. So, therefore, why don't we say in our case, if I don't know whether this guy is knows halacha or not, I'm in in Marrakech and I see some Yid shocheting an animal. We have a raiv. If he's shocheting an animal, he knows what he's doing. So, why don't we say the same raiv? Says the Gemara, in our case, lay down the other lay gomer. We're talking about a situation where a guy knows for a fact that this person shocheting has no clue. Doesn't know halacha. We can go in the shochet come on chotzei mashabeh. There's two simanim you have to shochet. And he shocheted one out of the two, and I saw that he did a great job. But then it happened to me. Today I was sniffing those those spices, and all of a sudden I had a sneeze. You're unconscious for a moment over there. You like You have no idea where sneeze, and then you you turn around, and the second siman is already shocheted. Now what? The chiyur it should be okay. No. No good. Now the same over the high shafir achana mi shafir. Look, he did a great job on the first siman, so the second siman as well. Beginner's luck. The reason why you did well on the first one is it happens. But on the second semen have to be concerned maybe he paused, maybe he applied some pressure unnecessary downward pressure instead of just nice a nice slice. By me of Dimi by yourself mirror of nothing. Here's a interesting quiz question. Those who didn't hear this year earlier. What nothing you know would there be a halacha between a shita knife that's super long or short? What would be the nothing you know halacha? >> [sighs and gasps] >> Interesting. No, I see no one knows the answer. No one knows the answer. Toma? No, you're saying it's a that's a second you're saying the long second from that sugar over there that be careful of Toma. No, I'm saying a different different thing. Whether or not you have to go back and forth. There's an interesting halacha. The halacha you have to go forwards and backwards provided it's a short knife. But if it's a long knife then one one long motion. Okay, that will that's coming up. By me Dimi by yourself mirror of nothing. By the way, we have a very short on base. What? Yeah, it's always short. No, it's always short to do but Oh. Do that one? Okay, I got it. By me of Dimi by yourself mirror of nothing. Of Dimi by yourself mirror of nothing. I tell Momish what we just discussed as if we didn't discuss it. I tell my best friend go ahead do me a favor, shuck me an animal. Balaha and I, the balabice who sent my friend to shuck, I come home and I want to shuck and I find an animal that's shucked. Now, what's the law? All my life is you you could you could have relied on that it's a good shita. I don't know say what you're trying. Now they want to say what is the difference between this case that I just said, that I tell somebody to shuck, and at the end I find something shucked, but I have no idea who shucked it. Is the guy I told him to shuck or somebody else? To where similar case. I tell somebody go, I have 100 fruit on my in my dining room. Do me a favor, take two of them, put on the side for the client, take another 9.8, put on the side for the lady, then take another 10 and put on the side for my shiny. Leave me 80 on the side, basically. 20 over here, 80 over there. Round it up. You come home and you find perfect piles, 80 and 20. What happened? It's possible that the guy that I told him to do it, Jamie, what are you wearing over there? Get over here. You'll make me feel comfortable. Come, come, come. Shalom aleichem, Jamie. I would talk in Moroccan. Well, actually no. We have the Are you guys actually Moroccan? Yeah, they are. >> [laughter] >> Now now he's here Moroccan, give him Moroccan kiss. Here he goes. There we go. Reb [snorts] Isaac, we'll smooth later. All my lay. Listen to this. You walk into your house, you ask somebody, "Hey Mark, Mark Ashkenazi, could you please take trumah for my fruit? I want to have a good meal tonight. He said, "Sure." I come back home and sure enough, everything is perfect. There's a pile of 80 on this side, there's a pile of 20 on this side. You look at it and he says, "Yeah." But I'm not sure if he did it. Maybe somebody else did it. What's a halakha? Can't eat from it. I don't know who did it. But maybe I don't know who did it. I told him to do it. But maybe somebody overheard and he did it. And then what's the problem? We're going [snorts] to learn a mode of halakha. This is a very big problem when it comes to trumah. Very, very big problem. Says the Gemara, first of all, let's let's get to the question. Mon of shakh. I have a problem, dilemma. Ekhah zokheh she'eilah zeh shnei chushai. If I could rely on Mark to do what I asked him to do and he says he's going to do it, so he's going to do it. Af ilu trumah nami, then I should rely that he did it for the trumah, then I should be able to eat the fruit. Ve'einkha zokheh she'eilah zeh shnei chushai. But if we I don't have such a chazakah, af ilu shkhinah nami lo. So then how could I rely on Mark that he did the shkhitah for me? Why is shkhitah any different than trumah? On shkhitah I believe him or I don't believe. I trust that he did what I asked him to do and trumah I don't trust it. O my lady, this is a beautiful, beautiful lesson. Vekhi teikhol alah kurah demilkha. You know what? If you want me to answer you, you have to pay me big time. So pay me big time. Or eat eat a ton of salt and then you'll you'll be sharp enough to understand. So raboisai, this is we had such an watching this video that we watched it three times in a row and every time we laughed again. To explain it, you have to know the classic Mindy Auerbach who's imitating his great rosh yeshivah, Zev Feldman Baruchah. Baruch Mordechai Ezrachi. Here goes. Mendy, where are you? Let's hear a gushmak al nu. MENDY! AL NU! I LOVE IT. [laughter] JUST THAT I LOVE. YEAH, I GOT TO WATCH THAT AGAIN. >> were you? Let's hear Gushmak Elunu. MAY SAY. ELUNU. HE DOES IT WITH THE THE PAUSE. OKAY. Now that you know that, my boy say, we we dug this up. We dug it up. There's one No one No one has this video besides MDY of Reb Boruch Mordechai himself telling a bochur, "If you want to hear me say Elunu, pay up." Elunu. >> [laughter] >> It's smiting. Smiting in the belt. Who comes up with this stuff? Why? >> [laughter] >> What was this guy What was Shmuel thinking that day when he made this thing? Nachman Nachman Nachman. Look at him. It smells real. It's him. It'd be much better with his yarmulke, no? L'chayim tegel kura d'nucha. It's a whole kura d'milcha. Elunu. >> [laughter] >> But he doesn't bang. Oh, when my Had he done this? Okay, anyway. Ah, it smells like this like this today. So, what do you want to do? Oh, so he asked him a question. He says, "What's the difference between shchita and trumah?" He says, "You know what? If you pay me, I'll tell you." Then what? Lo ilu min We don't rely on Mark. Mark said he's going to do it. He forgot. But Shita is different cuz let's say somebody else the betting did it, okay? But why would he do it if he doesn't know he's doing? Nobody touches a Shita knife and checks animals that no one. But we have a good rove that tells us that anybody who's doing Shita knows what he's doing. He knows the laws. But Truma here, oh, this is the punchline. Once you hear this, you'll understand everything. Truma, let's say Benny did it. But Benny doesn't have the right to do it. You can't be a nice guy when it comes to Truma. Truma, you have to be asked to do. You can't just do it for somebody. That's considered doing Truma without the permission of the owner even though you tried to do something good for him. Ain't Truma say Truma, it doesn't work. It works by Shita but not by a Says the Gamara, don't tell me I forgot to to show this. No, no, no, here we go. Okay. Lema says the Gamara Lema Shita Mon and tonight. Maybe this whole concept that we're discussing that there's a rove that anybody that touches a knife knows what he's doing is actually a This I know. A person his his goats, his chickens went missing. What happened? What happened? A guy stole them. I love this story because it There's a lot of emus to it. It's emus to the story but there's a lot Reb Chaim Brisker was asked by his talmidim if they could eat by a meal that's being prepared by the head of the the thieves, the head ganef in in Brisk over there. So he said, "Call him over. I want to speak to him first before we could pass him." So he called him over. He said, "Listen, do you do you steal?" He comes from a firm background, this kind of "Do you steal in jobs?" He said, "I've had a lot of fair opportunities to steal in jobs." "What about Yom Kippur?" "Yeah." Let's say let's say you find a pig. Will you steal? "Yes, we steal pigs also." He said "Do you eat pig?" He said, "Mr. Sugar, no. No, I don't eat pig." He says, "What what do you mean you don't eat pig? But be makhalel Shabbos and Yom Kippur is worse than eating pig. You know that?" He says, "Don't mix the Rav shouldn't mix up the two things. One is business. The other is this. The business business I do I do Business is business. Parnassah is parnassah. But but chazis chazis shomayim I don't touch chazis." So he said maybe he said I'm pretty sure he said that you could eat from this guy's seudah. This is big. Tzaddik stole a bunch of goats, but he shochted them. He's a he's a tzaddik. He shochted he put on the side. Reb Yehudah says, "This is you can't eat from it." Reb Chanina ben Reb Yehoshua ben Reb Yosi says matter. So let's remember. It's hard to remember. Reb Yosi says Reb Yehudah says ossur. Reb Chanina We don't need to remember the whole name. Reb Chanina ben Reb Yehoshua ben Reb Yosi says muttar. Omar Rebbi He says, "Rebbi, listen. Reb Yehudah ben Reb Yosi says ossur I like what Reb Yehudah is saying that it's ossur to eat when he finds it in the garbage can. But Reb Chanina In those days you know that it was unbelievable. The the the closest I ever got is the one I went to You know what I'm talking about. When you go into Mea Shearim after the when they do the fires over there, so they won't they won't clear the garbage for a few days. No Reb Yehudah. Piles of piles. And they punished them. "You want to burn burn here. We're not going to take the garbage." Because they burned the garbage cans whatever. I was once there. It's unbelievable. Like a garbage strike. I think in New York they had a one. No? That's it. In in the olden days, that's it was everywhere. We There's no disposal, so you used to There's a pile in the middle of the city. A big pile. Nobody. She says, "I agree with Reb Yehudah when you find it in the garbage, it's awesome." That means it's an availa. But then Reb Reb Hanina and Reb Shimon bar Yochai agree that says it's muttar when it comes to a matter of a base. We're going to see later on the Gemara says the Rebbes not determining who the halacha is like. "Oh, I like him. I like him." All Rebbes doing is says that everybody agrees to these These are pashta things that Reb Yehudah is going to agree in all situations that it's muttar it's assur like this and it's muttar like that. And Reb Hanina is going to They're argue They're going to argue in the middle case. My love. Or my saba lo chayer, the Gemara wants to say that this machlokes like this of the roiv that we have a roiv that people that deal with shchita, they know what they're doing, is actually a machlokes between Reb Yehudah Reb Hanina. There's no force to say that. The kuli alma Reb Hanina says it's shchita mumkin. No, you can say everybody agrees that if you're dealing with shchita, you know what you're doing, you know the halacha. And nobody argues in the house the shari if you find a shechted animal on your kitchen table and you in your in your kitchen period, it's good. It's kosher. And the ashpos bashuk, the kuli alma lo pleig d'asra. Here we have a little video here. Another litzonus. Oh, we saw some of these cats today in the shuk. They're some some of the weirdest cats. Yeah, yeah, not Now, has anybody been to the neighbor and Sukkot they know exactly what this device is? That means Is this thing on the table, right? It wouldn't move. It wouldn't move this calf. >> [crying] [snorts] >> Okay, so he threw the navela If you have a navela, you throw it into the ash fish of a sugar. Everybody agrees that that's treif. All the navelas Keep playing but ash fall sugar by is as you advise. So, I wanted to be a more of a sugar by. I think you would you would agree to me. The more of a sugar by but you live in Eretz Yisrael, so you could appreciate also the second part. Those who didn't, I don't know. One of the kind of that based on garbage, you can figure out who a person is. You You tell me a little bit about your garbage behavior and I can tell you who you are. There's There's the husband. Yeah, my love, this is not for you to listen. There's a husband that comes and the garbage is up to the top. What does he do? He puts another thing on top. He tries to push it in. It doesn't close and he walks away. Not my problem. You know what I'm talking about? No, whatever. I'm going to the next part. Not the part that you that you belong in. There's the guy that he comes to the garbage. Mom, it's full. He puts his foot in it. He He crunches down. He gives another 6 in and then and then there's the guy that he sees it's still full. He pulls it out. He got a nice string. He puts a nice bag in. These are the three types of husbands. In this room, we have all three types. I used to be one of each of them. I graduated. >> [laughter] >> But then in Eretz Yisrael, there's another There's another together. There's another thing. There's the guy that takes his garbage bag out. He lives in a big building. He lives on the fifth floor. And he has that drip. The drip from his apartment all the way down to the garbage can. Over here we have four guitarums. Four guitarums. We have the guy that takes his shower shoe and makes a mix out of it and goes right there. You have the guy that takes his sponge and stick out and mops the sponge up from top to bottom. You have a guy, this is the worst. This is this guy now mops. He He cleans it up one one floor below where he lives. So nobody knows that it came out of his dira. And they have a guy that says, "Listen, I pay that a bite. It's not my problem. This Let somebody else deal with it." So from these things you can tell exactly who and where you're holding in life. Yeah? Masking? Kimat? You in Australia have no idea what I'm talking about. >> [laughter] >> You have what I'm saying? Like, "Woo!" You have to live in Arizona? You didn't do the what? What, after you were married? For how long? But you did the garbage thing down the down the steps? Well, you lived like in a big house? There's no garbage. There's no garbage. I don't want to That gives me trauma, actually. One of my kids the stick of the find. Let's call him the find. I'm not going to say which one. So like, you have to take the garbage out. He's like, "I'm not taking the garbage out." So dude, yeah, you got to take the garbage out. If you don't take the garbage out, it's not going to be good. Nothing in the garbage out. We lived on the second floor then in Zavitav. >> [laughter] >> He says, "Okay, I'll take the garbage out." He threw it out the window. It exploded on the floor. He goes, "You're happy now?" And then he lived for 2 years by Zalman Auerbach. I'm going to say which one which one of my kids that was. Where's He was by the Okay. Just a stick of the find. He's a great kid. >> [laughter] >> Threw it off the second floor. Yeah. Zog die Gemara. >> [snorts] >> So, Omar matter. Oh, no, no, no. I think I skipped a little bit here. Uh we can go back a little bit. I don't know where. But basically I'm going to leave the shower with the latest, right? Okay, that we did. Keep playing. Oh, here's the but I should have a bite. If you find something in the house, I got to go back to this. This is a pretty nice. You guys didn't appreciate it when you saw it. You remember what's going on. Now we can see. The guy maybe could Could you speed it up a little bit here? Let's start from over here. I could. Where is your garbage? It's over there. Oh. Keep playing with the latest. If you find it in this garbage in in your house. >> [screaming] >> MY SOUL MOSTLY LAUGHING at the blessing but I should advise. Yeah, listen. It's it's not a normal thing to put a dead carcass in your garbage can at home cuz it really smells bad. So, that's the latest here. Some say, "Yes, it's normal." My soul and all the most of the most of the advice. Most people take it outside to the to the local dump and not dump it in their house. So, may luck if you find it in your garbage at home, obviously it's kosher. Omar matter Omar Rebbi. So, now we're just going to finish up what We already discussed this Rebbi and we explained it, but we'll do it inside. Omar Rebbi near him the Rebbi who asked I love Rebbi who does this also. We find it in the garbage. My husband, what does it mean? So, listen to this dude. It's It's good to listen. Pay attention over here. Where is it also? My husband, you know what you should be shook. It can't be the one outside. How is the everyone in the room here when I asked them in the beginning, you find the dead animal in the local What is it called when they throw dumps not dumps dumpster? Local landfill. In the local landfill, it's the choir trace. Everybody agrees to that. So, what does it mean you found it in the ashville? Can't mean the local dumpster, the local landfill. And I have to shoot the basket for advice. It's talking about the garbage in your house. And on that review this says what? Also. I must say for so I have a contradiction because in the I could do the exact opposite deal. But they were Rebbe says, I like Rebbe when I find it in the house. My advice, what does it mean house? You know my advice my mission, I found it on the kitchen table. I have to declare the shower. Everybody agrees if you find it on the kitchen table, it's motor. And I have to shoot the basket for advice. It must be in the in the garbage can in your house. What we saw this guy finding. And on that Rebbe says it's motor. And Rebbe says it's also it's contradiction because Rebbe says, I like Rebbe who says it's also. I like Rebbe who says it's motor. So, the Rebbe and the Rebbe for that the Rebbe says, no. That you base in base. Near and dear Rebbe, the Rebbe didn't come to to say I hold like this one or like that one. That's not That wasn't his point. His point was that everybody agrees to certain parameters here. Rebbe I'm sorry. Rebbe likes what Rebbe said. What Rebbe said that it's also. What we talking about the local dump. That even Rebbe agrees that it's also. So, Rebbe Rebbe He only argued on the on the house one. And then the near him the opposite. In other words, everybody is in agreement that if you find it on your kitchen table, it's and everybody's in agreement they find it in the show. Rebbe wasn't making Oh, I hold like him and over here and I hold like He always saying that everybody holds that. Rebbe Huda and Hanina don't even argue when it comes to the local dump that it's a 100% trade. And if it's on your kitchen table, it's 100% muter. The whole like this was in your kitchen garbage. That's where the says. Okay. Next again, the few days on the base sponsored by a dark global specialist in international financial services by Chaim Milrod. Unfortunately, we were saying Refuah Shleimah and now we have to say L'ilui Nishmas Imi Morasi Fradel bas Chana Leah Shalom. Um yeah, okay. We just switched that, okay? Quick switch. We'll switch it back. Chaim should have a Nechama his whole family and she should be a Meilitz Yosher for your family and of all of Klal Yisrael. So, the coin cannot do shchita cuz they might ruin it. So, the imagine that he actually like that. He doesn't say maybe they ruined the future. You cannot give your simple animal you're not nothing to do with kosher. You can't give it to a shochet who doesn't who don't have daas. Man tan of the the loy be in of the shchita. Who's the tanna who says that you don't need to have kavana when you do shchita? In other words, you do shchita if you did it properly, you didn't do anything, you didn't do she here, you didn't do you didn't do all this bad stuff. So, it's a good even though you didn't you didn't mean you didn't mean to do it. So, there's a fascinating that I found today. The says that if a person likes to sing, he cannot be a That's what he says. Why? Because he's constantly singing, he's not paying attention enough. He's always singing to himself, he's humming, he's thinking about his and this and that. Now, he's not he's not going to make a good Yes, he has to concentrate. He says if you're you're talking about you're talking about a Jew. He should he should try to cut down on his singing. He goes into the whole thing he wants to be You hear this? You know about this law? It's interesting. So, who's the tower? I guess it's like it's whether or not you need a lot. So, here's a crazy situation. Oh, my Robin city. So, Robin city. Here's a case. A guy is taking knife practice. He's throwing knives, he's practicing with that What is it called? It's like Not darts. The the the Chinese art form, they take knives and they throw it at the axes, knives, whatever it is, at the bull's eye. Huh? The Chinese Chinese stars, exactly. Huh? Say whatever. What? >> [laughter] >> What? No, it's it's just the funniest thing in the world that everybody is just throwing out. >> [laughter] >> Words that Yeah, no, it's the Chinese people that throw. Yeah. >> [laughter] >> Yes, sir. I like this. Listen, everybody knows that I could speak a perfect Hebrew. I speak a perfect English. So, why do I never know words? Spanish. Just to get them involved. >> Yeah, yes. They feel good about themselves. They say such stuff and I'm like, "Yeah, yeah, okay. At least you're not sleeping." A little bit more? Okay. I'm looking at myself in the screen. It looks weird. Should I just redo the share? Yeah, let's do it. No, not at all. Not at all. It's not as weird as Yeah, compared to what you looked with the with the the Wow, look at you. >> [snorts] >> Okay, we're almost done here, everybody. So, how much how long are we into this year? 51 52 minutes. Okay. We're almost done. One speed is so hard. >> [laughter] >> Listen, hey, hold on. No, no, no filter. The boy said, "Check this out." This is based on Yousef today. He was He gave us a drasha on the bus. I'll actually play the whole drasha. It's a mighty good drasha, what he said. This is me giving out gemaras to local Muslims. So, hold on. Here's Yousef. Maybe you Maybe you want to hear Yousef. Listen to this. English English. MYD >> [laughter] >> You love it. Anyways, so that's the new ad Yousef. All right, so to the gemara. So, here, check this out. It's a crazy story. The guy is throwing a knife through the air and I'm going to ask the Ham, there's an animal walking by. Masha Adam and it gets its neck as they go and shut it. The exactly the most of the this is why cuz you don't need you don't have to have Kabbalah. You don't have to have Shimon. Who told me law? Rebbie Shimon himself says it and explains how law could be an awesome. The law could is you don't need to have Kabbalah. You threw it, you didn't mean to kill an animal. There's certainly no Shimon cuz it went There's no reason cuz there's no downward pressure. Maybe maybe there's a Gemara on the knife so you'll check it out afterwards. Ask the Gemara but you have to go back and forth. So, look what the Gemara says. It's one of those Gemaras that makes you wow. But I think like all those Gemaras, some of them like like I don't understand. How's it possible? The point is we're talking about a theoretical thing that maybe never happened, never will happen. But I logically would that be a good Shimon or not? Let's say it happened. Let's say on the let's say Shimon and I know exactly what I have is thinking about what Sugya exactly. I know exactly what he's thinking about. It's not similar to that. No, but the guy made a box and a a whole diagram. No no no, we're going to go by it. We're not going to explain. Obviously if you made a box it's a good Sugya but is it possible? I don't know. That's not the point. The point is theoretically what does the Halakha say in the case where a guy throws a knife and it hits the wall, bounces and it slices the the the the animal's neck, bounces off the wall and comes back and slices it again. Is that considered is that a good Shimon of there's zero carbon? Says Rashi that you don't have to say such a crazy situation where it bounced off the wall, came back. All you need to say is he threw a very long knife. Because as long as there's two two necks you have a neck plus another neck, then it's okay. Then it's a good you only have to go forward. You don't have to go forwards and backwards. One more small sugi here. So I want you to take a pencil if you have one. And write over here that the word machshava doesn't mean a thought. It means to speak it out. If a small child tells you what he meant to do, can we rely on that or not? No no martial. If he's shocheting an oila and he says I shocheted this oila, he tells you I shocheted lishma. Could I rely on him? So R' Akiva has a as a great kasha on him. He says, "Listen. Why you why did you mention machshava? Do you not know that there's a meforesh mishna that talks about ma'aseh? And since the mishna over there talks about ma'aseh, the mishna also talks about machshava and we have an answer for your question. With the b'alei ma'aseh, how can you ask me about a a full-fledged action? The what? Why didn't you ask me? The reason is very simple. Because it's a meforesh mishna. So you didn't ask me a a meforesh mishna. This not yesh lo ma'aseh. A kid has a ma'aseh. Machshava nami lo it ba'alei. So if so, in that same mishna tells you what the halacha is with dibur and then I know the answer. So why why are you asking me the question? It's a meforesh mishna. What's the case? This not yesh lo ma'aseh machshava uh sorry, this not in lo machshava. They a a kid's machshava or dibur doesn't count for anything. This not. A line a line if you have an acorn very minor pomegranate or egg guys or not shachak kokum kinoy guys that the kids took and hollowed out a let's say pomegranate or they hollowed out of nut. Lom be ma'afer in order to fill it up with dirt. Or they should keen on the cover they use it as a one of those old time scales. So, they needed a a second part. So, they they hollowed out a fruit. Why do they hollow it out? To make it a cleat. Oh, they made it a cleat to mayan. Why? Maybe they should have That's a That's a something physical. Mom, this monkey got me good. Look at this. Right over here. Over here. I better put on some uh antibiotics. Yeah, I have. Mom should get prepared. They don't want to shove it. No, I bought new sport just in case I get a stick or cut. >> [laughter] >> Rabies. >> [laughter] [laughter] >> Is that That's going to be what? Kobe's going to make that the the thumbnail. >> [laughter] >> I might have gotten rabies or I don't know if I might shove a grape and look at me bite like I don't have a question on dibor. He come and bite like I might shove it in the case of the muscle. What happens when his thought is understood through his action without talking, without talking? In other words, he going to have a kind of a measure of itself in Shabbat here the classic case. We know that carbon is the most of carbonus, especially kochi kochi have to be done in the northern part of that Zara, meaning if your misbech is that line, has to be above that line, not below the misbech, which is darum. And this kid goes and takes an animal and pulls them. You heard your name being called? They'll tell you later. No, [clears throat] not that part. I said one of my kids lived by him for a long time. Oh, he's out of it. So, if a kid pulls an animal from the dump to the south, then obviously he knows what he's doing. Obviously he's trying to shut the animal Let's say in Iowa, lishma, in the right place. So, that was my question. My question was something that's not in the Mishnah. It's something in between. It's not a full-fledged maaseh, and it's not a devar. It's a maaseh that tells me what his machshava is. Hold on. Oh, hold on. Yes, there's a video. Thank you. Shkoyach. A very good video of the knife. >> [music] >> Raco 2026. Those are the knives they sell there. >> [music] [music] >> Adonai, Elokeinu Melech ha'olam. >> [music and singing] >> And it's all right boys AND GIRLS. >> [laughter] >> VERY GOOD. HAVE A wonderful day, a wonderful evening. Merit the source of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a share today. Sponsor.com or sponsor at MdyDaf.com.