Daf Yomi Chulin Daf 14 by R’ Eli Stefansky

turn on Yom Kippur what is he high of chorus I have a peach described enough charge it does its share of incredible finish the even though what he's doing is a hundred percent also he's naive Mesa but his cars on Shabbos esky EV regular Mesa be they autumn fish pitas kosher choices and all the return disgust we we learned that if you are mu murdered over a honeymoon with the Shabbos then you your your sweet is no good so there's all sorts of to Samir all sorts of your shyness omar opponent is very very nicely actually but we have other things to go into so we'll continue on or ahuna door - hereby ravish me the route so Rab says all over here now I don't want to scare you but it's um what we're about to say Rav says Allah huh he says like this I sir about Himalayan mo simple Allah what the Mishnah means that you're letting eat the meat meaning only a message service you have to wait at the master Chavez venosum Cavalry oh that may marry beauty so step three is that step one is the Mishnah the me discussion step two is Rav says you can only enormous job step three is who decided who who's the author of the salah ha it's your buda now the fact that it the Gemara says its review though that that's what we're gonna discuss today which Rebbe who them they don't say who wears this review them its review the summer you find it in shafts it's basically like a riddle we're gonna have to go through shafts and find this review though on step number one that which were the first review that it is there's there's like seven eight steps a little bit of a husband just how to cop they're very simple steps these are the steps and we're gonna go over the steps they're very easy so again the mission that says some of these local Shabbos the chef's on Shabbos is meters car show homes Rav Rav says only a multi-service say the calvarium that goes a contributor which will be Buddha I'm Arab Abba rubaba says he gets it the first try review though the honey thank you Hamza Kouri medieval oh this girl's going to be who the in the Halawa of a corner on Shabbos right we all know something that looked so on maybe this cat Sabina schmagges it's really cool yo mo if if something is mucked so before shower and Shabbos comes in it smokes it for the whole day haha no so what is a ho no this is not Makati honest and even if maybe hey mamasan available in your club if you have gourds some sort of food that's not attached to the ground on Chavez you like to cut it off for your animal we're not gonna go into that I love how that's a local maybe tear : Chavez this is the love that we want the best kind of a low laugh near Clovis an animal drops that on Shabbos you're allowed to take the animal cut it up and give it to the dogs now this animal before Shabbos what was it it was alive not really meant for dogs so when Chavez came in this wasn't food for dogs review' the owner in lejos and avail america bows a surah why because the live animal is not Rory for a dog so Mela it is mocked so as jobs comes in and therefore you can't feed it to the dog if you should end up in a MOOC on Alma keeping the low eat handmade model Asura so come surviving cells you see from review Hooda that's something that snap appeared from before Shabbos he can't use it on Chavez ah hanami Keevan delay each time at mall since we're talking about an animal that was shut down on Chavez since this animal wasn't meant to eat on Shabbos why wasn't invented on Chavez says because all animals are legado there for breeding purposes only they're not to eat eating comes all the way at the end of its life but as is as you look at an animal it's not for food you could eat it but it's not for food it's designated for Lagado so Melo that's why I'm Shabbos it smoked so if you shefte did it smoked so you have to wait until mutt say Shabbos over there bio was the Katori so that's a different problem so they're trying to discuss that problem if it was a hundred percent for food it seems like it would be okay because - the problem that it's not shifted that's not an issue because in his mind he designated for food suits food it's just a logic problem it's missing like a technical how to get there but in his mind that's what the Duran Duran's will say ok so economically it clematis only I by you or me dummy so fi tells Robin hobb oh that's not a good review though now just as a side thing this is a very interesting run in Medora is they get to all of shots but it comes up it makes a lot of sense in our Soviet the rhineland arm says a lot of times the Gemara goes through different things like an hour so you're gonna go through many different steps all the way into tomorrow's that would review so we know the answer we know what the answer is the reason why we go through all these steps is just to bring up the new saga McGann so if you come familiar with we're talking about true MA we're gonna talk about MOOC so we're talking about knowing lad whatever it is all today we're gonna go through half a shafts why because the Gomera wants us to be familiar with all these concepts we know what the answer is but that's the Darracq of the Gemara so oh man I value me dummy I don't think it could be because of Hana Hossam mica or a-movin the Mucca McLovin over there when the animal dropped dead on Shabbos to begin with when Chavez came in it was designated for human consumption then when it died without Chiquita you try to flip the designation because you can't eat it because it died on its own without pizza so he said you know what let me just give it to the dogs so you can't do that you can't change the designations in Chavez how come it Cartman la dama hash the moon la Dom but over here since it was designated for human consumption to begin with when Chavez came in so it just continued into that designation on Chavez and what's the problem review the would admit that it's okay that's not Mook 2's the Gemara why miss iris Bahama bhai Allah keloid Mendez Bam oh hey allagadda luminous it's not true it's not designated for human consumption it's designated for breeding breeding is a different designation hockey for hey mother of you to be on time hey Keyshia Tina so now the Gemara ask the question if you say that n animals only for breeding then how in the world does review the whole that you a lot of shuffling animal anthem everybody holds that you could shift an animal you want them as long as you eat the animal yontiff but how can you shut the animal if it's smoked so it's not designated for eating it's designated for breeding so review that has a problem according to you you switch the designation if you said specifically okay okay but now now you're being Mikado something that you you would have to designate you have to make a whole thing beforehand nobody ever says that I'm no did he grab any animal you checked it says mahram or my lawyer or Metis laughs Sheila but Metis llegado an animal has two designations to it it could either go to the right for food or could go for breeding now it depends on what you decide and what is that called in gumar language Brera retroactive your thought right through actively designator we have two designations it can't be both it has to be one of the other who decides you decide but it goes retroactive as Shabbos came in when if you shoved it on Chavez that means six hours ago when and when Chavez came in you ready decided and that it's it's for food and if you don't checked it then then it's uh we don't know what it is so then you have to come on to the concept of Brailler that's only good if you hold Brera if you don't know the Braille Rho which the mortgage is gonna say prove the review that doesn't hold then you don't have this concert then what then next step number seven and the whole thing falls apart so let's see it inside and I'm going to show you the charge just to make it a little bit more visual oh my lawyer or medicine a kilobyte mezcla God oh it has two designations misrata who the lucky limits if you shafted then retroactively Lee it became designated for food boy dish motto but if you didn't shafted who rode the gondola Metis then the opposite then it becomes retro actively you decided that was for breathing and not for food and then ignore says vilette's later of you the Braille review the doesn't all gray row therefore rib abbas shot in the Mishnah falls away how so here this is how this is how it looks visually the Mishna says has shot a mischievous caution Rav says the mission is talking about only a matzo Shabbos says the Gemara that goes according to review that's step number three step number four means this is Roboto he says which review though the review that says that if you don't prepare it before Shabbos it saucer and you have to say step number five that our animal is for breeding and therefore you have to prepare it because if it's for food you don't have to prepare it's already prepared what about yontiff then we have to say step number six that is for breeding and for food but that's only if you say yes Brera then I could choose between ligado and Chiquita but if I don't have the inch Braille row then how this review this say you could shift on chopped onion if I can't shut that yontiff and if I can check that you'll neva viously if I could chop that yontiff obviously hope it's not muck so if it's not most of them our Mishnah only if you hold that it smoked so then our mission would say you have to wait on Tamotsu shop is because it's mucked up but if you don't hope that it smokes it because you hold Embraer see all this no matter if there's no mucked up then it can't then our Mishnah is not a proud ok you don't have to wait to master chavez why does down wish to say if the way doesn't matzo javis so cannot be this review that says that smoke so that you have to have up on yeah but yeah but you see from young till you see from if you hold in order to shut that yontiff and there's books up again if you hold the smoke stand to shut down Yount if you would have to say is brave I would have to be able to designate retro actively review that doesn't hold to be a sprayer because that's what we're gonna get to in the next two lines you hold a braver if Embraer how do you shut that young turn the only explanation I could have is how do you shut that you on this because it's not mocha so if it's not mucked up on young tips then it's not books on Chavez and it's not books on Chavez then are now in our mission of why can't you meet it on Chavez what do you have to wait them out to showers we wanted to say the reason why I have to wait the most shots cause it's book to a poor interview though but if it smokes it then you can't eat anion t'v the only way can eat on Yalta visit eh brayer videos a breeze you can't it's it's a catchment it's a it's a seven step legend that's why I put it out in paper I don't know if this helps if it doesn't help then look it up into whatsapp I already sent it on the what's up by the way amazing thing happened last night garrison ben-moshe spent over three hours with me teaching me how to do some of this stuff and graphics and then when I was done I went home what this is but then no he taught me this stuff we're gonna get there for this guy but then I was done then I went home and I had a technical difficulty so you came over to my house after the three literally three hours from 6:00 to 9:15 I'll call upon him and he came over like it though I don't know 11:30 12:00 so you should cry at her Gershon was photogra no charts many more something like says the game are over last layer view the brayer we know the review that doesn't hold it the concept that you could you could do something today and we decide that retroactive really that's what happened that's what that's what he meant me not alone how do I know now the cars gonna take two tries try number one is not going to go try on try number two we're gonna get it he'll a minute Ali Ali karaoke I may be an acoustic if somebody buys wine from a koozie who sees the guy that we were discussing whether or not the Gary MSG arises they became Gary we're gonna say according to Mohammed that the true game the real game room and therefore what what you buy for them the produce you buy for them is higher batula miser they don't really take from some extras unlike an Emirates mr it takes true mud doesn't really do myself aku's he doesn't do anything but it's a Jew so you have to be careful when you buy produce from so what do you do if you buy wine oh so here's another chart because again we're just going through shots these are famous things but just to be more familiar and make it mom as part of us when you have produce if you buy if you buy a hundred liters of something the first step is you have to take true Magdala that is approximately two percent it could be one percent it could be four percent web-browsing two percent now what are you left with let's say 98 percent from the 98 percent you take my sorry showing that's 10 percent which goes to the lady I just put in a little over here that it really comes out to nine point eight percent because you stole two percent for the claim ten percent goes to the lady from that 10 percent that's the last that the lady himself takes ten percent of what you gave him gives it to the client that's only 1 percent of the total of the begin of what you start out with but it's 10% of what the lady got fine step number two is my sister shiny my so shiny is a year one two four five you give yourself ten percent but you have to bring it to your salon and if you if it's too heavy for you you could redeem it the coins bring the coin series lime you eat it yourself in Arusha life that's nicer shaving years three and six is my surrani also 10% basically what you're giving here is 20% of your produce to other places that's where we get the concept of whiteness not my sirs it's better to give 20% of your income to darker that's what they used to do in those days so we have true mercury law my series showing my sister shiny and true miss my sir we're not going to be discussing today but that's the trauma that the lady who gets 10% of your produce he also has to give 10% of it the 10% to the coil which is 1% what because it's some produce and not on money that's how it goes some produce on animals you don't have to give 20% you give 10% this is different things different things require different amounts so now the problem is you're buying wine from the scusi and it's arab Shabbos you don't have time to do all this separation stuff you don't have the calum let's say you don't have you don't have what it takes this Raschi some two minutes before skia what do you do you need to drink the wine what you do is you designate in your head you say I'm giving 1 1 2 & 3 I'm giving right now my head from this it's in here it's in my barrel it's on the bottom somewhere whatever is left over that's the 10% that I meant to give meanwhile I'm gonna drink from the barrel I'm drinking drinking I I just drink my sir I just drink room up yes Brera retro actively I know and I understand that whatever was left in the bottom of the battle that was a 10% I designated but that you have to come on to retroactive that I have to come on to the tabret row okay so if review that says you can't do that that would be their view the holds you can't do brave Embraer there's no retroactive halli Galli I may be in a coup same manner he says themselves new game shiny Oh said he took a hundred lugan so to look in this is right over the top number one to Loog in harem trauma i saw her my series join ten Mugen go to my serrations not really ten it's nine point eight tee shot my sister shiny and nine which is 10% what he's left over with goes to my sir shiny now there's just a hollow quick I love to hear what yeah that says T show you some entertaining you keep going just like just like the original is is 98 you'd love to be 98 so you keep on going down in steps I know we had that chili I'm pretty sure look it says before is your teacher miser Janey yeah who make all this choice in Mia however when a customized her SHANY since he has a very easy way out he could take his whatever he's hive in Mycenae and designator put it on money he that he has to do right away he can't he can't say it's left in the barrel Vivian mayor maybe who the receivership in Iran so what do we see there be who they're one of the three last time at annoying say that it's also you can't do breaker you can't designate it in the barrel and say I'll do it I monster javis says look Amaro that has nothing to do with the H Bray row now if you dial him the base awesome get the penny time Oh over there it says before us what the reason is Homer Larry Maher yeah time right there should be a book I know it but in such a sit well my Freya they told him the reason is I'm scared that I'll spill out and if you break if it breaks it comes out that everything you drank all through Shabbos was traveled because it only works if you actually give it at the end you can't it's not a trick you might you have to give it to the client the trick is only what are you gonna give to the client that I'll say retro actively it was that part that was left over but but remain says has nothing to do with Bray room it's not that of course everybody holds us Brea I could designate it in the bottom of the barrel I'm just worried he's gonna tip over over shop it's gonna fall in the floor and everything you drink beforehand was Tavo Marla Hanley cashews bogus is remain worried about it if it breaks it breaks it's not gonna break what are you so worried about it's not gonna the barrel is not gonna pop a cup our team has on them do it braver so where do you see the review that doesn't all the brayer lob the Tony Iommi is the name of a Holcomb says really the Toni Egger review though you might know I didn't look up how many unchaste review the oiler ain't or the master stayed warm careful oh yeah maybe I should here is a beautiful suger of home we all know that on Chavez you know that a walk past the city you know I walk mm Amma so what do you do if you want to walk more than 2,000 AMA you do something called Arab women you take a roll you take some bread and you put it this is the end of the city this house I want to go I'm allowed to go to each direction of the city mm Alma without doing anything now if I take a roll and put it over here basically what I'm saying is that my house just became where the rollers so I extended another mm arm in that direction what do I have total 4000 amo here's the trick if I do that I can only get 4000 amo if I do that then all of a sudden I can't go anywhere on this side I can't even go two steps I don't have the mm armor anymore the 2000 Amman that I have on this side just I put it over here I get 2,000 I'm on each side of the city I take the $2,000 from the West and I put it on the East and now I could go to $4,000 okay what happens if a guy is Rebbe is coming I bet Africa took this cartoon even though it's very anti-semitic with the nose the whole thing even though he's touching his secretary in Ontario as long as if you touch the safe at IRA that whole sugah they'll bury you that whatever aquaponic it's Tom ate the who so this is the first rabbit that came up on cartoon cartoon rabbi now what happens is this guy wants to go to his Rebbe he hears his Rebbe is coming in from out of town Raschi points out that the Rebbe has a trick since he's a traveler he has a 4000 I'm a trick what he does is he says I'm standing right over here I can make that even those 4,000 hours away because I know that there's a tree 2,000 hours away from me that's my house and from there I got another $2,000 fine now if he knows that his rep is coming he just doesn't know from what direction this is rebbe reb is coming he's very like come from this side or is where I come from this side so he does to a rooms one here one here you cannot have two Arabs on Chavez you could only have one house you can't live in two different places so as anymore is gonna say it's not really over here we're not gonna use Brea he's gonna decide which one of the Arabs he wants to use okay thinking explain it's not bravery yet because the the rabbi that rabbi came before Shabbos he just didn't know he didn't know no that's not very wrong that's just finding out he's finding out what she knows before Shabbos even started cuz the rabbi showed up before showers the issue is when you have two separate ways you see the two different cartoons the two different guys and they're both coming in on Chavez and he wants to decide on Chavez which Rebbe he's gonna go listen to okay that's Brera he has to decided Shabbos which one of the two a rooms was the area of area of Shabbes and which one is nothing that's a real bro so now let's sit inside thank goodness for Raschi because the camera didn't say a word the Martin assumes you know this sucio Baba says the Gemara ain't or Damascus Mackay middle of a saga you know the master ash native archaic odd you cannot make to a Reuben together it's one or the other one area with other airline bharatham Lim Israa a river the misra if the Holcomb came from the east then the the loaf of bread upin the East that's the earth let my raw baby came from the West it rubella my growth then as there was in the West the evil kind of look on Lloyd but to have to a Ruth no good valve in a ball and the Gomorrah asked the question and I cheated and I told you that internationally Connolly condyloid they Braille row what's the difference if two rabbis come you can't do both because there's no Braille row miss rottenmeier of Nami embraer even if only rabbi came and you set up to a rooms because you don't know from which direction it should be the same exact ha laka booka fireball of America no nuclear bomb so revealing explains is a difference but if there's one wrong when one roof comes that story what happened was the rock came in Travis you just didn't know where he came from so you ever shop is you already decided which which air of to use you just didn't know that you'd made that decision that decision happened by itself mashenka if this to Robottom that came on Chavez you made the decision on Stratos that's Brera and the camera says review who the says review the Omer an automatic native um careful you have me who does the one that says there's no bravery you can't decide on Chavez which Arab to use so fine that's where we're gonna stick with we're gonna stick with review the holds Embraer if review the holds Embraer then our young test how could you eat how can you shift an animal an animal is designated for eating and for breeding so I had you to make the decision obviously review the halls there's no books on yontiff if there's no MOOCs are yontiff that I could eat a shepherd animal on campus as well and then Melo who is the one which review the said I can't eat a chef that animal on Chavez after way through Moses Shabbos says the Gemara this is the second channel second try hello avi serve review who the de Calum this review de another lock in shops is none says in the mission : Kayla money told me Shabbos ray in me told him all vessels that you could carry on Chavez let's say you have a a bowl that your letter K lighter touch on Chavez it's not Mook to a bowl right cuz it you put food in it's not book to shave rare meat all him if the ball broke on Shabbos you're allowed to use the broken pieces ruble VAD she Ison in Malacca it has to be that they can do some sort of malaga malaga means some sort of lava in other words shivering i rave all the has his memory harvest the broken parts of a bowl you can use it to cover the opening apparel shivery schoolers the high seas vampire path and broken pieces of glass to cover a battle a smaller opening now just as a ANILCA Shabbos if I find a broken piece of glass in the in the street is the book turn a Mook to one hundred percent it's book - it's like eponymous rarest rarest and Vaughn whatever they are pieces of just a stone unless you you you know Afghan a a stone is Manish Gupta unless the designated before right so a Stalin is woke to a broken piece of a bowl is Mukti here comes a big finish the Kimura says if it started out as a ball on Shabbos so it doesn't lose its sham Klee because I can use it for a silly little thing such as covering a battle that's only because it was a Cleon Chavez but if it wasn't a clearance as you just found the street obviously the same piece of glass the same size that could cover your cleat that's not it doesn't take it away from Oh Stood Still Moksa fine says review dollar bid or email no it's not good enough to do a small melaka like closing a battle of evacuation man a man laughed on it has to have the same designation that it had before Shabbos shivery arreva lots of little comic book the the broken parts of a bowl you have to be able to put in it some sort of like like like oatmeal or something that's that's that's heavy that's not gonna because if it's if it's if it's more liquidy to fall out as a small piece shira's hookahs yeah a harder thing if she Reese was lots of mm jamming and broken pieces of glass from a battle what is a battle do it contains liquids so this also has to contain liquid may a militant in may maloha Harris Loy CC review the holes it has to have the same Aloha Almo key evenly intimate malai from Aloha as Siri it has to be the same a local mayor of Shabbos holonomic even by us in our mission er that he shafted an animal keeping late come at Wallace Errol since it wasn't designated for the same exact melaka then it's no-go to contribute and that's why you have to wait until mati Shabbos MLA Emily I buy me dummy Xhosa me leave as - Eric Lee what's the what's the comparison over there it started out as one designation as a real CLE and now you're looking at a broken clay by Avellino levels comes up by and says no over there the problem is not mocked so over the other problem is nyla it was completely born on Chavez something that was created on Chavez this is Mook so different type of MOOCs in MOOCs on island so we're there it started out as a a giant CLE now you're talking about a fraction of a cliff different type of CLE yeah nobody it right because it's different it's a completely different clay look we'll see we're gonna go into that exactly what you're discussing haha Macario claw will have a saw if you look it started out as food an animal's food and ended up as food Oh Clawd the infra so this is food that's broken off for example if you have a giant loaf of bread and you broke off a piece of the bread so it's not know that it's just a smaller part of the of the larger sum so when you have an animal that's food and now you chef Danny eating it it's the same animals just a different form before before the food was walking around and now the food is not walking around but it's still food right what's the local because you can't see this Lagado because then you wouldn't be able to get it on yontiff now at this point we have to assume that it's for reading also this is the it's designated for food otherwise how do you eat any under what yes Brea umbrella only feeding fine so you have to say only for a Armenian Leila Buda Dom are you close if Reza Shah Pahlavi this this is the point I was saying to you that you're gonna see a little bit this might answer your asking where do we see this concept that food that breaks off and it's similar to the original foods no no it's not in soy cotton is a pair of slides in my Maskin right it's a tie right saw to squeeze fruit on Chavez with me automats one but if the juice came out on its own I saw it it's also why because you might come to squeeze juice on Chavez if I let you drink it you'll you'll you'll do it like a pillow and that's a proud review I'm air in Laughlin if the food is made to eat let's say you have some sort of pomegranate that it's made to eat higher hmm motor why because I don't want juice I hate Jews I want to eat a solid food the fact that the liquid came out of it is not to my liking and therefore I'm not worried that this guy's gonna go and squeeze it like a pillow in the Maskin but if the fruit is designated for for Jews like a grape highlight mm ah sir I mean male aw it's all sir so what do you see over here that food that changes its designations even even if it changes from solid to liquid it's all sir and because it's that douses that designation it's within the designation Jews is part of food even though the this thing was food the mice at the end of the day the Jews is part of the food it's a frat it's broken food it looks like this it looks like a grape but right so so a biased question was though don't tell me don't bring me arrived from over there from the shivery Calum of mochas oh then I can't use it according to view though over there it's a different clean but over here it's the same and the mela he would hold that if you shift an animal on Shabbos you couldn't eat the meat so I don't have a good source of review though it's not the review though that says no light because no light this animal was designated for food before shops and I should be able to be able to eat I should be able to eat it on jobs itself if you since the Kumari yeah another attempt Levite myeloma reviewed Amish Moya Moya how you review the haha man be Sally's they seem that I know him [Music] most people what do they do with olives and grapes 99% of people squeeze them or ninety percent whatever it is squeeze them so even if you don't squeeze it even if you don't want it for for juice it doesn't matter who I should that maybe you squeeze it how much even ischemic I mow your diet a hulking out so it's awesome email source or genomic you delete the comma your I've died a so maybe this guy we have to be concerned if you're gonna allow him to eat the meat on Chavez maybe this guy's gonna go and shut the animal Chavez just like I'm worried that maybe he's gonna squeeze a grape on Shabbos because some people squeeze great some Shabbos so maybe this person if you allow them to eat the meat he's gonna shut the animal Chavez and maybe that's why it's also steeped the meat on Chavez you have to wait the monsters Chavez says the game Aram where's that sheath just for a second says the game Aram [Music] media who timer elderly Rav if you look all the way beginning of the sucio the mission says that his chaplain Chavez is caution says Rav who's lose the whole guy that started who's the one that started all sugah rev says Rav it's only about two shops says the Gemara the whole Sookie goes according to rap Honma rap colloquy review that Fela besides a sign of him Rab is Morgan what you just said Rav holds that a basket of grapes if you don't want it for for for the juice you're like it's not awesome for you it's motor there's no knowing that hello ever up she's breather IVD so now this is a third attempt which review who that is it now it holds that if you shift an animal on Shabbos your lie to eat the meat but not on Chavez you have to wait the monster Chavez who is it review who does in a row seeing is to review the Gannon Chavez of candles the Samuel without to win their Kaddish evolution what's in there we're referring to this thing right over here this is a candle made out of Harris yeah not like what we have today now what happens is if you use this a lot it becomes disgusting it's oily it's black it's full of it's no good so this is mooks Maximus meals basically it's good for one thing one purpose it gives light once you're done with light you can't touch this hundred some book - so really bad mood sir look sir - meals without Donaire kadosh avalon ocean so if it's brand-new never used out of the box so I could what could I do it then it's a bow I'll put my a my fruit in it but if it's your Shawn it schmuck so very ready who though soma Mela so the same thing would apply to an animal since I see that something has zero use is MOOC so so an animal also zero use it's a vermin a high there's no use it smoked so there's a lot of people that have pets it was this child I love huh if you let her touch a pet I didn't go into it but I know that the latter bottom hole that it's also the mission Brewer says you know I had a dog in Chaves it has zero use what use does it provide it's not food it's not it's nothing what is it what yeah really those little poodles and running around each other whatever satyr okay I'm not going into I'm just saying just remember there's such a concept of a live animal has no use it smoked if it has Houston has use if it's your pillow if your guard dog whatever it is then I guess there's something if it makes you feel good I don't know if that's a Lima that's what you're saying but uh but just the dog that makes you feel all fuzzy I don't know if that's the that's together abuse says the kymaro Amy - honestly really mooks here Mac - meows oh so well again so if you say that something smokes overcomes meals it has no use Pez the use of you touchin Shabbos so this animal that came into Chavez's every minute hi it had zero use now that you created a new use for it it's still möchten that's why would be the says word until matzo Chavez says the Gemara aim at the Chavez like the review the books I'm at most meals this is a difference between marketers over there by the candle its MOOCs and Maximus mousse it's disgusting what's the arts forward we pungent it's a paw what oh yeah and then it's just release very pungent here with the time lady the mooks amethyst meals so it's managed disgusting Maxima has served me shamelessly so this this animal that's maximum ACMA's everyman a high that's math my sister it's a completely different insert although it's pretty disgusting take a bite out of it out of a live animal fine but is it different is this man and how do I know to make a distinction between the two issuer miss Tyra video a mare calm a Royce after spoken dialogue calm aromatic has me totally nuts bananas wegobyebye shambo's all candles of metal meaning do not miss your ladder you lie to move them because the nut meals but if you if you litter on Shabbos that's most in my class sister because I it was lit it had a hand and errand so they turned it went from from a cleat Amukamara sister says the Gemara the dilma shiny wholesome do doc Olivia time when a person lights a candle on Shabbos with his hands he's pushing it off he's saying I'm not using this on Shabbos so that would be different than an animal just grazing around in your backyard that you didn't physically push it away and say I'm not using this when you think it can he lighted you're physically pushing it away from you not only in your mind don't you want to use it in Chaves but also every shop is you're pushing away saying I'm not using this book so so now we have to come up with a hoop shot that's tomorrow staff whose distributor that says that you have to eat can to meet a month of Shabbos have a great day