Daf Yomi Chagigah Daf 19 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning first thing i want to remind them about the amazing serum love coming see them and all different tsumin around the world go to mdyceum.com to register to all of them but i really encourage loyal since it's an ace the borders are completely open you don't need vaccinations just come in and there are many many people that already have flights reserved we're accommodating people for shabbos if you want to stay by somebody's house you could say by somebody's house if you want to your own place your own place we have the option for meals we have options for trips soothe us together on chabas fellas together and then of course the big seam of mata chavez so come one come all really really highly encourage it there's a lot of you get to meet all these people you hear from from the emails the miranda kash's of the world the uncle phil's who else leon welcher from south africa the the kale the kale woody chewing the kale twins are gonna be there i have no idea woody's gonna be there will come um let's do the uh sponsors first let's see how much time we have left we're running late on sponsor on time here uh the parents of haidesh for the kylo is mr anonymous is dedicated by the kesley and davis families before slamming for miriam esteban divira paris haider says rosenfeld in memory of my dear friend judah again jonathan davidov a member of bikhor davidov ben paneer amazing having aliyah reforest mindo shrilly sponsoring lily nishmas my grandmother sarah vitul bass avram yitzhak we have here okay mrs weisman says my husband yasi started learning through sheer when you started megillah it was all shmuley tranq who posted on his whatsapp status about a free gummara raboisei again we're starting yvonne soon we're gonna have let me give you a little bit of a hint most of the characters and the cartoons are well known members of the shir including a bunch of bald guys from the sheer who are going to be the brothers of ivamus we're very much looking forward even the women are very funny and very sneez so it's going to be very exciting my husband has not learned in years due to the fact he's extremely busy taking care of our special needs on effie please have effie in mind this is hospital frame simcha ben schepsi rahul rahul mckitzer who's written hospital and rehab and night after night but nevertheless he's learning torah my husband is a different person thanks to you and everyone who knows us and attends this year knows what a special person y'all sees hashem should give him the kayak to continue giving the sheer and bringing light into so many homes thank you again for everything you're always feeling at home with toro s wiseman letter from fifth grade this is fifth review next time we could have a chance to make a see them on a small massachusetts will be in september 2025 so i challenge them and offer them a night out and i supper we should all be so proud that there are eight boys that are still doing the different messages you never know what the boys are really capable of doing just a little push sometimes leave a curveball and they jump to it thank you parents for helping and continue with us have a great shabbos um i don't know it just says letter from a fifth grade reviews hmm that's another two okay should we jump into it it's a good idea no since you said it's a good idea i want to read just this one from noah i'm goodman i joined that for myself my cotton really enjoying the consistent learning i entered law school after years of yeshiva 30 years ago and have not been able to learn daily until now professional cousin oh what he's saying is we had us here is it a he says it goes either way it's based on my real against the torah i'm also right there right there okay fine no i'm good in toronto um by the way i got a number of emails yesterday because i did the thing with alexa and i told y'all safe to take out that word so people what was that word it didn't sound good it didn't look good it was not a dirty word it was just not appropriate for the sheer the the beginning of that word is freak okay if that's what you want to know but it's not people thought of something else and they're making a come on the right well it wasn't it wasn't a dirty word but okay it was extremely funny at the time oh did i read this one no we have to read this theory a highmarine cast learns that yeah me every day with mdy learns on his own filing this year since he's not in any framework he considers you his rash of shiva he follows your movements tells everyone what he's happening in mdy he's looking forward to the scene next week i would love to join the one in london here he is okay so let's do a quick quick hazard on what we learned yesterday because we flew through almond based today by the way is also a very easy death but new musa game and tom and tahira but very very geshmaku stuff we got waves we got apples falling into the microwave by mistake all sorts of great stuff we have like this our mission said this is just pikitzer so if you don't understand what it says here it's normal the mission says that you you're required to wash your hands any anytime you eat hulin which is just regular fruit and the mysore cheney fruit my chinese fruit is part of truma semicircus if you have fruit you give two percent to the cayenne 10 to the levy and ten percent in green to yourself you have to eat in yerushalayim etc so that fruit has a certain condition to it it's a little bit we'll see a little bit more than same as hula macho at the end of the day it's a little bit more than hulan you have to wash your hands says but the problem is that the mission in bigquery says you do not have to wash your hands for my sushini then we bring a braiser that says that according to you have to wash your hands for maestro cheney so that solves the my sushini problem our mishnah goes according to the reminder shiny you have to wash your hands they'll go like this but what do we do with hulan we still don't have amanda omar that says that you have to wash your hands for hulin so the mishnah the mother says well aramis is talking about eating and when you eat you have to wash your hands maybe the lord says but everybody agrees that even eating there's no machlok is between eating and that's where we got to yesterday that our mission is talking about eating bread eating bread since it's we're trying to train people the koihana they should wash their hands and time with this everybody even these regular have to wash your hands when eating bread bread is the sign of a pseudo that's how we eat so aaron mishna is talking about eating bread chamomile is strong that's the end of the soup now we're holding tatara butter five lines from the bottom of it if you wash your hands then scaven you have kavanagh that they should become tar you're the tyrus yeah that's the thought loya's cabin you just washed your hands let's say you shook somebody's hand and show and you're concerned about covet you come home you start washing your hands you don't have kavanagh kavanaugh you're the mayors you don't get it to hire from them the same thing if you dunk your hands in a mikvah in a scavenge if you have come on other tires let's go tomates khan limeizer when it's meisser meister is if we go back let's see if i can find it here the chart that i had yesterday here this is how the mission of the mission brings these five things so hulen is the least kadaish and the most it could have is a shaney in other words if an apple of hulen touches something else it doesn't doesn't uh transmit tum at all it itself is not more than a shiny it can't it cannot be more than a shaney but my sushini says the gemara is stronger than hulen and therefore myself cheney you would require washing your hands and cooling not okay islam as a vert once we're here khulen when you're in in my melody so when you're learning torah as as a beginner the khulan you're not you don't need cavanaugh come in maybe you don't understand everything maybe you know 100 maybe it's for different reasons you don't need kavanaugh um oh here we're going to go into a beautiful sugya how do you know that when it comes to cooling you don't need to have when it comes to cooling you don't need tarvana regular food you washed your hands by mistake you had kavanaugh to wash your hands for germs you put it on the sink you went like this you what you did whatever you need to do you put into a mikvah you're yaita you could eat you could eat whole no problem without having khabar and snack how do i know gao shin is approximately four years ago when we're still in the other building we were sitting and we had a small kabura maybe 10 guys and a fellow showed up from los angeles david and he called himself david agal because he's a surfer and he said that he's on a surfing trip uh i forgot where maybe like costa rica or something or not curacao one of those no no no that's where he lives but anyways some fireplace and he wanted some tyra in his life so he went on the internet and he found the shirt we just then we had 30 guys on youtube and he came to say some alaikum he's here and ever since then that's almost four years ago he hasn't missed the day he's in constant contact with us he sends us to arizona et cetera et cetera come david agal david the wave so here's david agall he's standing here it's all about waves by him is it's uh is his messages waves he has a surfboard here and there's trolls he's going nobody knows what where california is a pretty large place anyways he said i didn't say you just said it laughing he doesn't they don't they don't pick up anything they don't inform him they only hear you say it again three yeah what did we say where malibu california okay great anyways this guy's david not hagal somebody else he has trailers the whole deal and a wave shoots out of the water he's on the sand he's on the ground now this wave is detached you see it's detached from the ocean and the wave contains 40 saw the amount of water that's required for emika the allah is if you have a mikvah you need ashburin you need water that's not moving can't be zoichlin can be moving water ocean is different ocean oceans like a mayan you could have moving water not a problem and the fact is that you have 40 saw and it came from the force of the ocean so even though it's moving it's perfectly fine guy's standing mining his own business and a wave hits him in the head it's detached from the ocean to hire him so the higher it seems that he had no intent he had no idea what was going on this this thing hit him mitaram on the spot it hits the kali the police certainly didn't have intent tahar so what do you see tanya adam do me the caleb they're both in the same sentence a human being a path both are ma kayla and so just like obviously this cli right over here doesn't have das intent not intent wanted the wave to hit him he has no idea just standing there minding his own business with the chumps whatever comes this wave and hits the person also he has no intent and he's tar so you see you don't need you don't have to have kavanaugh when comes at least maybe he's sitting and waiting for the wave to hit him for a large enough forty saw wave to hit him do me adam mma law just like he has intent so to the klee has intent how's it cle have intent because the bar calvano he the owner of the klee is having havana that the wave is going to come and hit it what's wrong with that who told you that this case of the wave that's knit lash is a case of no kavanaugh maybe it's the case of cavanaugh and therefore i don't have a right to happen bro well if he has kavanaugh's what's the big deal what's the fiduce soccer rain water that comes down down a mountain let's see if i have a picture i i was in the middle of making one i don't know if i printed it yeah here hi it's raining this is not a river this is just water coming down a mountain 40 sub water that is not good for mick for why because it's zyklon it's moving it's not an ocean it's not a mayan it's rain water rain water has to be stationary it has to be in a mikvah without movement you know if a mikvah has like a a crack or something and the the water is moving it's no good it's becomes zyklon you can't have moving mikvah mikva not that it can't go like this but the water can't go out they can't go in it has to be stationary it's a mikvah that's the word victor it means it's it's it's gathered so this is no good for a mikvah so if somebody stood right over here in the bottom and got a 40 saw rainfall of water on his head he's not he's not he's not tar but it's similar to this case here's a guy standing and he got 40 salt water what's the difference so people are going to get confused so maybe i think that in the case of the gal that's a big hit okay this is you are tara from a wave even though you're not tar from rain inami nigsa russian autu keeping oh so what's going on there this is the rush this is the head of the wave the head of the wave is kosher for twila but this part right over here the the yarmulke the keeper the center is not kosher if you take a pot and toss it up into the ear and it hits this area right over here no good this is okay because you're on the ground so it's as if it's muhammad to the character and great but a flying fl not object a flying body of water oh a flying body of water is not a good maintenance it's not a culture makeup even if it has our bombs up it's mid-ear mid-ear is no good this is keeping no good this is good so i think that russia is also not good zera because you might say that this is good to keep up bottom line is i don't have a right from this case because this case could be a case of kavanaugh you're asking me what's the big i just gave you two great conditions don't get confused with rain water don't get confused with the mid-ear part it's it's caution um delay might be let me keep it and who told you that you cannot be taivo caleb or yourself let's say you jump up 10 feet into the wave in mid-air you're not you're so you're not you're not talk design yeah i'm at villain it says before the price so you cannot be totally mid-air oh so i'll give you another i um that you don't have to have kavanaugh for hulen when you're title if you wash your hands by mistake or somebody forced you to your mother washed your hands for you you didn't want to you're you it's you have an apple that falls into a mikvah right you go like your table caleb and you know the sometimes it falls on your head it goes to the bottom so you go grab it the guy forgot that his hands are tummy he had no intent to beat with his hands his intent was to grab the apple the other tyres his hand becomes tart so once we're here we can't demonstrate here we go it's not uh yeah mandy hold this please here's an apple this apple is tahr here's the dead mouse carrots touches the apple what happens to apple nothing star the only way this apple can become tommy is here hold it high over here and i want to put the water on the apple oh now it's now it's had water on it now that i touched the apple with the share it's the apple becomes tummy what if the apples outside and it rained on the apple or some other guy whatever somebody poured water one of the mashems it's not after water wanted to mash him nothing i have to have intent says the gemara my hands become tahar by reaching for the apple because i don't have to have kavanagh over here you see you don't have to have kavanaugh i had no intent to make my hands tar i wanted just to grab the apple but by doing so i put my hands in a mikvah they become tar without intent you see here the idea your hands become tar without intent for hula it doesn't count that it's so full of water and it sat in the bottom of the mixer for 25 minutes that's not water that i intended to put on the apple that's water it slipped out of my hand and went into the mikvah listen to this what if i have an apple on the bottom of the mikvah and i say i said listen i want to go into the mikvah and grab the apple so i can make my hands tahar two for one let me at least i need to make my head start i'm gonna go once my hands are in there i'll grab whatever on the bottom so obviously you're the hyrus you don't even have to have kavanagh your hands are tart but over here big payroll the fruit become as if i wanted the water since i want the water for my hands so that water becomes water that i want and it goes on the pre as well basically rabbit nachman in it's i explained it a little bit like that i'm explaining rashi that the if i want the water for something else then the water becomes water that i want even for the preview and i didn't have intended to go in the pre i wanted that water or something else okay it's hard to understand rashi as is why did i want the water on the fruit who said i wanted the water on my hand ace very person has intent to go into the mikvah only so you should be able to eat so now his body is good for coolant oscillomycer meisser is the next level up he cannot eat my sir now why because his kavanaugh is for something else it says like it says that he had kavanaugh for kulin isn't that a problem with what we're saying now we're saying you don't have to have kavanaugh even if you fall into mikvah by mistake you become tar why so why does mission say that he had kavanaugh for hulen says outside of course you don't need to have kavanaugh the kiddush is even if i did have carvana it doesn't work only to appoint my cavanagh i don't have that i don't have to come on at all if i'm sleeping and i fall off my bed into mikvah because i said hulu it stops at holland and it doesn't go any further i'm not tar for maestro shiny that's a huge quidditch it's as if he wasn't table at all oh this is a big fascia it says here judah says if he was total and he had zero carvana it doesn't work even for hulen so you see you have to have cavanaugh my life it says it even doesn't work it does work for kulin it doesn't work for icer it's interesting twice it says a big criticism that it's possible that if a person had zero cavanaugh it would work for micer it's just because they had kevana just for cooling that it prevents him from going being comfortable zero carvana might be better i would think might be better than a a small carvana of only hula because it's a general kavanagh i'm going into the make for well zero kavanaugh so work even for myself but if i'm having it for a lower level of hula then it doesn't work huh yeah no so the havamin haven't himself went out started looking searching it went on you know uh barry line whatever he started looking into what's going on here desanya and he looked and he found mamesh it wasn't it's me for surprise that if a person is typical and he has no intent at all it works for hulen mamashaw sugya that for hulan you don't have to have intent for everything else you have to have for for my sashini for truma of course and kochim and certainly sir au revolution we're learning not hard stuff but it's hard no on my ribs a guy goes into the mikvah thinking to himself i'm going to the mikveh for what for tahara he knows what he's doing he's going in for tahara like we go to the mig for today we're going to make do we have any intent what we're going for no we we have a general intent we're going into to be retired the body not hulin not what get the news to get the news in the midfield you got the news but but for kulin after my shiny you're not thinking anything so listen to this unbelievable he comes out of the mikvah well texas says in big parentheses well he's still wet he still has mikvah water on him so now he can decide why he went to the mikvah not 16 hours later a minute later he's dripping wet he can still say well i wanted to make it for my sushini not for truma oh no i went for truma not for not for kochum i went for kachim not for katos he can decide what he wants to do and if he says he's a shaytan he says i only went for khulan he's stuck at hulu level he cannot eat my sushi by the way it's very interesting when is a person tahar when it goes to the mikpo when he goes into the mikvah or when he comes out of the mikvah comes out of the mikvah when he's in the midfield he's not tar yet he's in the water says gary anybody else chemical guys in the back how you guys doing not you hillel here for four years hi you wasting me hi well it's been a few days taco okay if you're talking with the shares you're not tom you're not tar no total shares via you're not tar you're really not okay but anyways the the case of missional holds not everybody who's like this kind of mission holds like these guys said when you come out of the mikvah so i have a big uh a shiloh a riddle a guy's in the mikvah there's exactly 40 saw his title comes a guy takes a pale worth of water out of the mikvah and now he's a 39.5 saw is the guy tar because he didn't come out of the mikvah is he tar oh you hear what he said when you take the pail of water out of the mikvah that's coming out of the mikvah the mikvah came out of him so that's coming out of the mikvah okay just uh horror why not says the gemara again although max against him would call bachelorette saw he could be toyable he could decide what he wants basically macy they regular mine a guy is a flamingo he has one leg in the mikvah one out okay on the steps one design one is that are they right you can they duff it is going to get on the table and show us hooks like the dover cow max since he's still one foot in the mikvah he can decide what he wants to be tired for so let's say he went in leslie went in he went in for hulen he could decide i want to go i want to be tar even for truma allah wants his always feed her out shubhani maxum my love andy oh so it seems like not even for hulen you have to have cavani if he is one leg in the mikvah and he already established what he is he went in thinking i'm going in for hulen but his leg is still in the mikvah now he can still change switch your mind now i want to go up in my drink i want to go to the room i want to go to kachin [Music] but once he got out of the mikvah emily so what's the cash the cash is unreal but lazarus says that once you leave the mikvah you can decide what you want but over here it seems like you can't decide what you want so mark says you're right if you decide it already what you want and your one foot is in the midfield then you could redo it allah but once you come out of the make for him rebels is right if he's a blank slate and he comes out of the mikvah and he's still wet according to christmas he can decide what he wants but if he is not a blank slate he went into the mikvah with thinking i'm going in for hulu and he came out of the mikvah he's still wet he cannot switch his mind you're here rip also doesn't give you a free-for-all once you're out of me you do whatever you want as long as you're wet if i went in as hulen and i came out and i'm dripping wet i can't change because i decided what i want to be it's only if i forgot to decide where i want to be and i'm wet i'm standing by the makeful i could decide i want to be whatever i want montano who is the tana that that says that when one leg is in the water you can decide what you are um let's remember it buddha says it's and it goes only according to this vision a person goes into mikvah which is exactly for the savior you know that each person that comes out of the mikveh is going to take water with him so the second guy doesn't have 40 saw yet right the second guy that goes into mikvah is going to be a little bit less than 40 saw what's that the shiny doesn't the second guy going in doesn't have what he saw or how could that be you don't have 40 sun in mikvah how could we view the whole that it's okay we learned in aravind a concept called good ah you take this edge in sukkah and you can do such a thing you you vision this wall going down completely review this says i envision all the water on the guy's head as if it went down into the mikvah we're gonna see soon says it's a bird lush and it doesn't literally mean oh the water went down it means since it's going to come down water always travels downwards so it's as if it's in the mikvah and it's not a lot of good ah okay yeah you with the baldness okay we'll get to union vomit don't worry about it is like the guy's ainan says rashi you know ain't a person who loses a loved one in order for him to eat katrina has to go to the he didn't do anything he didn't go to the lavalier or nothing you have to go to the mikvah but that's only ahuman but we are called this trick of pretending that the water drips off the body into the makeful only works in the rabona vanilla rib dust that that's that's what dust is saying that in it it goes according to your yehuda not according to rambo diary that the water that's on the first guy drifts back into the mix very good it's good for the second guy who played is wrong because it does said it only goes according to review though we're saying that goes according to everybody okay according to review that i go downwards i say good ah remember aches means downwards do i say the concept of good what's good going upwards so this is from aravind from the call halashan book an amazing book we had over 700 pictures for everyone here you have a wall that separates two homes and the concept is good asic we pretend that this wall goes upwards and separates the roof okay it's an invisible wall you see how they did invisible beautiful how they did it good asset do i go upwards the question is do i say good asic here as well now what listen to this unbelievable question i couldn't help but i couldn't have when i was a kid i don't know about you guys i lived in for rockaway we live in certain neighborhoods and the minute then was i'm not joking people had massive afros massive and it was cool to have one of these stuck in your hair i'm not sure everybody was walking around with a comb it's called a pick and this is how i would walk around now this is a little bit more what yeah everybody they go the cut yeah it's coming back now stickle what i could give me a fork you'll see i have steel one over there so this is the shield i mean the the the scener that we're talking about is a very small fork it's this but very small much smaller but it's the same idea what if a person sticks a fork in his hair and he's standing on a step of a mikvah do i say that the water of the mikvah travels upwards you just use that machine and say the water goes downwards so say the water goes upwards it's the same allah basically but according to the khasanesh this question makes beautiful sense because if in fact it was similar there is no difference between up and down in allah if you go down you go up but the quran says it's not literally goes down it's i'm telling you that eventually since the water is going to go downwards and to drip into the mikvah it's as if it's in the mikvah well that only applies the logic only applies with gravity downwards it doesn't go upwards that's the commercial question that's why you might have a question does it work or not work we gotta go we only have four minutes from the base okay we'll talk afterwards says good morning do i say good afternoon this is a really good ah last night do i say good up upwards or not or demo good ah it's like perhaps he says both is uh sorry good ah is slayer of you the good asset leslie he doesn't hold the video demographic is like check this out beautiful picture three water holes one this guy has 20's on it not a good makeful this guy is perfect make for 40 saw this lower one is also 20 saw can i be toyable on this one and this one is the question what's the question because they're connected with sort of a fall like a little river going from one to another says lotion mayor my friend not rebbe mayer mayor that's how he called him matt bilbel i could be title in the upper one why because it's connected to the middle guy what about the battle one a thousand percent even coach king i could even go upwards what do you see a good assignment i could go upwards boston but you i'm asking you so and what does that have to do with review though because review is saying mayor my friend said and he doesn't argue so obviously review the halls it's also good he's just bringing his friend botania but that's not true i know for a factor of you the argument may or may not be the oymer mayor hoya like that i can't argue with you there's nothing to do about that you're right rebeca says you don't say good asak says you do say good asak but godakas they hold it's okay sponsored in honor by moishi horn in honor of chewie woody and the kale twins sponsored by mushi i say they should come to the seam because they don't come to see we're going to think they're fake they don't exist they should all come to the seam well tickets are nothing now i mean now they might get expensive because we're buying them out if you get in there it's going to be unbelievable sponsored by michigan's burskie in honor of brian and talia edgar says the gemara if a person goes into the mikvah thinking that he's going for hulen he's only good to eat cool and he cannot eat meister cheney says gamora where is that somewhere around there we had uh here we go [Applause] you see that even though in the mishnah we said in the mishnah khulin the most it could be is the shaney nice or shiny the most could be cheney but you see the mishna it goes in order you see that if somebody's tar fakhulen he's not tar from my sushini what does that tell me that cool and am i so shiny are different emma melo if i go into the mikvah for one i'm not good for the other i mean if i go for hula and i'm not good for mexican if i go for my chain i am good for hula because hulan is less than my shame aim is safer so that's the ratio what about the seven big the amharic midris laprusham we're talking about gotham again madras is too much mattress if a zob zavanida sit touch clothing they become tommy becoming like avatar a person who's a parish what's a parish he eats his hulin bittahara he's very immaculate on his huland that he shouldn't have any kind of tuma so it says that if you touch clothing of an amarette since he has no clue and his wife has no clue so maybe she sat on it maybe he uses up he sat on it so the parish this guy is makbit on tara altar sakaidesh for kulin he cannot eat anymore he's atomic big day prusian and a beggar of a guy that's a very immaculate oh you see he's he's a makhmir guy he's only mahmoud for what he does midris is considered mamesh tuma for somebody like a cayenne who eats truma which is a higher level now osana mayer look what's going on here look what it says here in the mission that says if you have clothing and you're making altars it's no good for truma and if you're truman don't mention my sushini no look in the mission you'll see skipped it what does that tell me the meister shane and hulen are equal the reason why it's skipped is because there's no need to talk about it it's in the same category as schooling well that's different than what we just said a second ago we said the ratio of the mishna says that one is under the other it goes hulen then my sushini then truma and now you're telling me that hula and my society are on the same level that's impossible to say that the ratio goes one way and the saving goes another way so sometimes when it's impossible we have no other choice and we say okay we're stuck say ask mario rachel you're about to save your mayor in register our bottom is safer and mayor okay we have no choice however all he does is i don't know if i made one basically he he just inserts it right over here he has he does have five it's not four it's five levels you look at the mishnah he has a different mission the different years it's called tara sakai there's prusian one two three four five yes five and mma law everything works out well should we go a few lines more it's kind of late now i really want to go to the next sugiyo what yeah let's go okay omar of mori shimami no if a person is so careful about the way he treats his hulan he's very very careful he wants to impress his family he wants to impress upon them that they should treat caution with respect he doesn't know when they're going to bump into kachin so all food that comes into this house he says you know what this is like the highest level culture how do i treat that food that food is not kochum he didn't get it off an animal he didn't get it off the mizbaya he bought it in the mccullet it's a regular apple where is it here this does this have any dishes zero in my mind this is cuddlish like a carbon what is it how close is it now what could i in my mind when i decide something's college to what level of gdusha is it in other words if i take this later is it a sleeshi is it a ravi it could only usually go up to shiny but in my mind could go to sleeshi you could go to ravi so says gemara from our mission you see yes i treated mamas like kachim even ashley she's metameth yeah if a shlishi a third level very very low level of gaducia touches my hulan apple will become tame we're usually not why because in my mind it's kacha how do i know it middle boohoo look this should have been right over here before kaidos there should be another category called altar sakaidesh category number three if a person decides that this school in apple is khadash it has a gedusha more than truma less than kaidish but since it doesn't say it obviously it's equal to kaidish hold on a second time out i took this apple i said this apple it's regular coolant everybody can eat it everything is in my mind this apple is kocham i'll prove to you that this apple is kochi why because if it's not kachin what is it it must be one level less than kachem well then how come it's not in the mishnah should say al tara sakaides if somebody's mocked been on apples of khulin then it's not kaidos but it should be a category for this in the mishnah why is there no category you know why there's no category because it's equal and identical to kudish itself i decided this kulin should be kaidesh it is kaidish it's one that's why it's not in the mishnah it's not in light blue because i don't need it what's in my gonna ask who told you maybe this apple is like truma and that's why it's not in the mishnah that's it this is obvious question him before shaman omar that says that if i decide that this kulin apple is kurdish kardashian it's nothing it's like hulen that's why it's not a category in the mishnah and now okay there's another mandalorian that says rebellion it's not going to hurry it's the second level but certainly who told you that this has hedusha like duchamp and i'll prove it to you from the mission that it is called this like like like kaching how element safa what does it say in the safer we don't have to know the first part but the second part is now this one you ever the effect is yesterday he ate everything apples that are hull and he ate them like they're kachin his handkerchief was for the next level meaning that it had kedusha of kochim it's hulen but of kochim and that's our then if a person has intent to make a simple apple that which is hulen it is do we have to repeat this tomorrow okay we don't have to says medley sorry you