Daf Yomi Beitzah Daf 31 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] in the official eight minute navigating committee anonymous sponsor for forest lamer for binyamin ben rahul benny giddleson who's having a stick of pain in the hospital from kidney stones but look at this i have a picture of him what's more important is what it says on the wall in the hospital room they ask you like this what's your name you write down they write down for you what matters most to me no here it is family and mdy i thought it says family mdy it does but he writes in and what matters most to me is family and then he's stuck in the end i was more excited because it said family md why okay that's what a guy is in the hospital and he's thinking about the mdy mishpochah very nice foolish lame-o um i just started two days before beta love the daf with the clever charts aids this is the way everyone should learn i call it daf lame that people mess up over sukkas i actually lost track and out of either abundance of liquor or the other word i don't know what it is i wound up a daft head decided to review the daf rather than take a chance of skipping he ended up adapting i once had it happened to me and i was giving in chicago i came prepared with the wrong duff like a daffodil it's disaster you look at the good boy like what's going on here no they knew that they knew that they knew what after not everybody knows after i learned the wrong person go like the gra arami cooperman mdy members and shkolin and i don't have a screen over there screen's off oh we are another mice at the gas station in england the islam lives in the gas station you know there's no gas in england so this is the second story i'm loving your daf ever since i joined the beginning of sukkah amazing happened tonight in london as you may know the uk has experienced a petrol a few short fuel shortage which has meant many petrol stations have closed and those are open have long hues tonight matsuyante if i set out to find an open petrol station i had missed that on two days of yadav she recording it was a great opportunity to catch up unless the shirt is driving the bedroom using cute five first two petrol station closed third one only had a 10 minute cue but when i got to the palm it was card only and i couldn't pay with my phone i called my wife and she suggested that i there's another jewish person to queue maybe i could borrow his credit card well i looked up and there was another firm jew on the petrol four court who i sort of recognized but didn't know very well he's more than happy to lend me his credit card to pay for the petrol when i gave him back his card i want to swap phone numbers with him so i could do a bank transfer however it was very hectic she asked me for my name i said alan garber he said i know you are you just joined the mdy london whatsapp group i have your number and i'll message you my bank details p.s a big issue i can thank you to fellow md wire laser jacobson who is the hero at the petrol pump warm wishes rabbi garber now their children got engaged yeah what's this oh yeah does it get together in this get-together today matsushabas you read this east 27th street it's on the corner of avenue m light refreshments will be served if you say light nobody shows up it'll be sushi there's going to be me let's see 400 people show up all right boss [Music] aha okay this is for oh where's early today oh listen to this one this is a great one this is justin ivory while catching up on death i heard one of your participants referring to a story about the train in the in a derisive manner i'm being much in the strongest manner to that individual i say i don't think it's to you some guy made hoisik of the myself he didn't believe it so much you don't believe it even though you may be rebelli's best friend and even though among the sheer participants there's a lot of ribbing and givenchy it is issa noira to be my vasa talmud you have to ask me about them i wasn't i didn't hear anything and then i have no idea listen i myself have zero doubt about the authenticity of the story and i myself experienced nearly the same story here we go and much worse three different times over the years but that's not the point somebody must have said is the meister kim atoyo and when you say you got to get up here and ask me let's go who is it really do it avi get over here i played it down they're really twelve guys now here's the hello okay listen justin ivory this is this is the this is the sheer without these kimchi rivets there would be no shirts it's a field it's part of the thing there's no design there's no anything here right now you know who did it i i don't know nothing happened though the guy that did nothing okay here we go daf lambda alef you all know what taflamer alpha means we are 30 days into mercedes-benz which is somewhat of a canyon of a of a good habit for those who started themselves bladezone the official mission is sponsored by official reforce lima for brainerd basiante devorah i saw i didn't print it uh actually a video that archul sent me yesterday of the gemaras that are being sent out and it's unbelievable the you know you open up the first page is all about official it's dedication they printed it in the gemara it's pretty cool all right and i told him that and then we have a sticker that goes like sean malek him to mdy i said why are you putting a sticker looks like an afterthought it should be part of the oh yeah right okay arie morrison says the official mishna mivim 18 min so we're talking about yantef and you have wood that's detached from the tree and we want to know whether this wood is mooked or not so depending if you designated it for your oven so there are a number of things here you could have wood that's in the open in the field and just scattered and the opposite side would be you have wood that's put it together in a pile in a secure place so here's your secure place here's scattered wood and here's a pile so if you have these two these two uh conditions you have it's in a secure carafe and it's in a pile there's no there's no question that it's not moxo you designated it says review that says that if it's not in a secure place but it's gathered it's in a pile or a mccarth if it's in a secure place but it's scattered all around you have one of the two conditions that's enough call here oh it needs to be oh sorry um what's considered an enclosed area of yehuda review that says that it must be close to the city close to the city the roshan and the rashford iran they say close to the city means 70 almond two thirds that we had already an air of in that amount so here's a blow up you only did this this is the city and we're going to be using this so remember this picture this is a picture of some ear from the blue line to the red line is 70 i'm approximately 140 feet let's say 145 feet from the blue anything within the 145 feet is close to the city what's even further than that the trump a 2000 arm is out of the city so that's the that's the next the next cheetah we're going to see exactly what the is no no no no no uh yeah i see what you're saying i don't think so i think it's from the end we never this is just the um what is it called the uh the who no okay whatever we always had the 70 and two-thirds as a there was a number in uh an air event fine that's some basically in other words this this this fence is locked it's really secure so that also illustrates that it's designated wood he put it aside it's it's secure he locked it up poisajas so the los angeles is a lock so we're going to use the lock as the pisajas we are going to use this picture as some of as close to the city it's a little bit confusing if you're reading the words here what is your bic saying do you need two things you need one thing is it is it the key that makes a difference it what is it even if you go far out now i don't like the way yoni did it so i redid it a little bit because he's looking from the kharfaf vantage point and he's saying rabioisi says here all the way out here it almost looks like rabiut is saying a longer distance according to yoni but he's just looking he's pointing where the kaifa is i'm going from here you're in the city review this says you only have this amount right over here 100 uh 70 amma and rabioisi says you have 2 000 i'm all the way here all the way the kharfaf is located much further away that's also considered ignore these lines over here for a second oh yeah we're going to see in a second the kimono is going to go through everything right there's no mention of being locked according to our video at all omar reviews that you need two conditions and that's not in the mishnah you need one and two you need muhunasim you need them piled up and also within the enclosed area but what about aramis it says in our mission it says it doesn't have to have two conditions one out of the two it could be enclosed even scattered like you only depicted over here it says mario right the mishna goes according to one cheat though but we don't really hold like our mishnah obviously if you have two conditions or you're missing two conditions typically you know happens all the time doesn't discuss at all but we're trying to get to kahama by understanding revelation allah we know what i'm saying allah azza learns in bashar al-amsilla that is is on one of the two conditions and hold no you need two conditions according to the basilo so so according to basil you need two conditions according to and that's that's the though but our mishnah goes like rip shrimp in a lazar that there's no the according to the cell you don't need two conditions one one condition is enough and that's that's rip shimmy our missions are shin bin allah fine argument so our mission goes like we don't pass it like that omarova so that's that omarova ali khan valley if you have a pile of leaves stamina just thought this was cool do you have a pile of leaves no it's a problem maybe he's not from i don't know it's a one time fine ally caught a valley funnel there's better pictures people flying off the roof landing on these things leaves what happens to leaves you can't really control them so even though they're gathered a big wind comes and blows them away so you don't have das on these leaves so even if they remain there on yantev they're not your leaves you didn't you didn't think about them so they're mukta they're still mukta something that you think that's going to be there on youtube you secured it you put it in a fence it's not going anywhere great but a bunch of leaves you have no control over them so even if they're controlled for some reason i don't know like they pile them up in america they don't really move around that much you come two weeks later it's the same pile for the most part well whatever big win comes blows them away kevin de madlows if a big win comes they'll scatter so they have as if they are scattered even though they're not scattered vasurum you can't use them unless you put a nice tarp on it you put something heavy on it shop your dummy okay now you show they control it it's not going anywhere great okay now let's see this for a second before we go into the sugiya very okay in the mission we have review though and rabio so the gemara says what is the macholicus maybe review the holds that you need two things it needs to be close to the city plus you need a lot even though as you said it doesn't mention lock and ruby i see you see from the lost interview i see ryan see eimeir this is a very cool sogya because although at the end rashi the way rashi sees this line in the mishnah because he used these words and not different words the first part the second part so the fact that he doesn't say lock doesn't mean anything now because rabiose is responding to him and it says kosher christmas you need a key even if it's far away so maybe you'd also meant that you need a key but it has to be close so that's not akasha it doesn't say lock the bottom line is perhaps this is the shiloh the gimbal is asking now is the israel reviewed the though that you need two things a combination of being close within 70 ammo and a lock and ruby icy argues that he says it's one or the other it could be either one that's one large larger number two is the red that review the holds it needs to be close you don't need a lock that's the passion so you don't need a lock but it needs to be close and if it's far in the lock doesn't help me it needs to be close and riboyce says there's only one condition they both say there's one condition review who this condition is it needs to be close if you always see this condition it needs to have a lock i don't care how far it is as long as it's in the chrome 2000 am it has a lock it's good it's just one or the other uh sorry this or this review that says rabbi says and you know the gemara answers they take a little bit of the red and a little bit of the blue ribbiosis says review this says it needs to be close and rebiose says like the first lotion in the havamine of the first lotion that it's one or the other that's the masculine of the gemara okay so we're not going like any one lotion completely we're taking a little bit of the second lash and a little bit of the first lashing now let's see it inside what's going on here what's this lushen so i have the lush in here if just in case you don't want to look in the mishnah but split into two pieces if you use even if it's far sort of um you need two conditions it has to be review that says you need both and allah it doesn't have to be close like you say review though but in other words it's one or the other i could go close without a lock or i could go far with the lock it's one or the other or de marquis or perhaps the second lotion the red says there's one condition one condition only it needs to be closed thus review the ic lame meyer yes you're right there's only one condition but it's a different condition from the condition is you need a lock so i don't care where it is you don't need it's not one or the other it's one you must have a lot even if you're close you have to have a lock if you're far you have to have a lock you always have to have a lock not like over here that's one or the other close without a lock or fire with a lock over here it's always with a lock you need to have a lock a lock shows that you designated it you want the wood you want to use it on your in other words the mercy says you must have a lock even if you're close to the city review that doesn't say that over here he's more mahmoud suddenly in dislotion before he's more mako over here he's saying even close to the city which rebuked that says you don't need a lock which was the passage of the like he mentioned doesn't mention anything about a lock but he says no you always need a lock even further away it works even closer you must have it tashma says from the fact derby icy says and then the rashi says it shouldn't have continued from shabbos if ribioisi holds that this is the icker that it's a lock so just say something that's it it's the lock i have one condition you need a lock then why does your bicy continue and say the why does he need the green thing why does he need this part just say whenever you have a lock it's good a feeler will tell you from shabbos hold on over here you see now one more thing raj is beautiful over here so rashi says rashi says nice try rashi says everybody's trying to bring back guys that were here a week ago he's been doing it first of all he's always done says what is rib you think about it what is your you see responding if ruby huda is talking about a lock also stereois he has no business answering him culture should just add one step he should just say green i'm arguing with you on one thing even if it's further away why does he repeat and say oh it has a lock review that says it has a lock obviously review that says it doesn't need a lock says rashi it's beautiful so you really from all the words you learn something from the fact that rib yoshi continues on and says that means that he says that the lock is not the accur and from the fact that even says the lock means that rib yehuda was not talking about allah because everybody which was before the ic is the one mentioned first in the mishnah if this is talking about a case where there's a lock and he's next to the city so there would be rabies say not only next to the city but also further away from the city why does it repeat oh you need a lock we're already talking about it has a lock and obviously everybody's not talking about a lock really there's one condition so that's the mascara one condition has to be close no lock and on ribosi says either or either close or with a lock and that's enough even if it's far away with a lock or close without a lock no questions uh don't trip me up now yeah no it's beautiful it's surrounded yeah yeah car 5 is surrounded with a locker without a lock it's different uh a typical guy does not walk into somebody else's car but to get the bad guys out then you put a lock on you have areas that are i have in chicago the old kool-aid factory if anybody wants to buy it it's for sale it's 11 acres in south side chicago the cool effect the original kool-aid factor is on that property so yeah nobody wants to buy it's not worth anything i had to put a fence around because i got tickets every month thousands of dollars because the grass is this and people would just dump all their stuff there so you put a fence there now it's not locked you just move the thing and the truck climbs and all once in a while every week some higher uh comes takes their all their whole load and dumps it on the property there's no lock you can't lock it because it's it's very large 11 acres how you gonna lock it you just put the fences and they they move it so it's locked and unlocked for the most part normal people so we got rid of most of the trash you see there's two things now it's fenced without a lock so 90 of the people don't bother with it somebody wants to save has a whole truckload and costs 500 to dump they move it it's hard to move they move put the truck in and go away that's without a lot and this is luck it's more secure you could also break that too but it's different in diaries okay he wants to close the borders doesn't matter that's what it is akiba likes that look at that all the way from up there he's laughing away those of you who didn't hear he says like trump invited him he's not taking sides you're saying one wants it closed open borders close borders okay you could use one or the other you could go far away from the city within 2000 ammo with a lock or you go close to the city without a lock says the mishnah sponsored by official reforce limo avromyosis you need some firewood so here's yoni where was he the home stuff i just forgot to use him it's unbelievable like a guy there's other people that have mishnahs beautiful i call them up can i use no yoni is like absolutely no problem i want to spread torah i mean this is what he does for a living it's unbelievable i'm not going to say who said no there's only a few other very nice ones out there and they work i understand them i don't know why people give me resource i call them up the guy the guy from uh that drew just lifter uh aravind chavez uh pirushkai your sky archer gave me resource for most of their stuff okay anyway all the guys that watch this year might not buy his mishnahs because the thing is the pictures already online and i don't know what he's going to lose whatever the question is it's it's copyrighted it's very hard it's very you know you get whatever anyway here's your beams on your house and he has beams here's beams in the house this beams in a pile and there's a broken beam here's the broken beam so it says aim a vacuum you can't break the wood you can't chop it up let me not carrots with lemon accuracy in this birobian if the beam broke onion what is that called miguel you didn't have a mind to you this beam you just want to use it now because you're broken now you don't have too late during during management you have no no intent to use it now that's the type of wood you can use what kind of tool could you use a and not with us with a saw willow be maggle and not with a sickle so you can't take this i don't know how this is gonna this seems like something that just cuts wheat okay whatever you have smaller pieces of wood you chop it with the sickle elbow coughing what's equipment so we're going to see in the gemara we learned crevices this um cleaver okay this is a cleaver all right zogding tomorrow so now we're turning to death alamed aleph almond base what [Music] high expectations you have those no no excuses okay vladimir's racial oh and now the aflame and alfonso is sponsored please join us sponsored by natan kushner kashmir first class for my children i call ev and jacob and the vora that should do well energy strolling have you entirely missed us and you're shamai yeah with the official no yeah with the official i think so says russia in the vacuum club in the race that says you know in chapter one do we do we skip some words there no so in the ratio it says [Music] and then it says but you shouldn't use an accident either now what's going on here even it seems like from the mishnah even if the world is there from aravyantiv so rashi explains the gemara that the gemara understood that the problem now is turkey over exerting yourself on yonder so there's no difference when the word became available if the word became available at every onetive you're still exerting yourself right who cares so where do you have a situation where you could cut wood on yantif you can't use it this and that but you could use a coiphens you can use a cleaver when the wood is smoke the the wood is the tyre this is what it's meant to say we're taking that back we're not talking about tirica now we're talking about mukta and there's a big difference when the wood became available if the wood was available before yantev there's no mokutsu and then if there's no milk to how do you chop it up with a cleaver and now with the with an x and the other stuff amen vacuum in a savor yeah but there's a lot of theorizing that we allow it's not it's not a concern but their cloud is not a concern we thought it was it's not what about baking what about cooking what about kneading i don't know what it's all it's all fish so you have a pile of wood like right over here this i could take away what is that oh a pile of wood well i'm an acquaintance why again because it smoked it was a mukta if it's in a pile we already learned it's like the cedar remember the cedar wood and the the male the female cedar kiss it's yeah lumber today's is is more valuable than gold right two by four is ten dollars or something and in israel it's twenty dollars it's crazier that's that part of the sukkah that i added to my house was i want to say like uh fifteen hundred dollars in lumber and it's not even that big it's crazy this we didn't discuss this is what's missing from the mission this is what you needed to understand by yourself every kid in haiti in those days when they were nice knew that this is what's going on there's two parts of the mishnah there's wood the mission is talking about mukta this wood that you have from yantev it was developed on yonder because it broke on yontif and then you have wood that broke before yomthev and it's available that wood that's not mukto and you're allowed to chop it up in the vacuum labor character let me make it let me give you a little graphics you can't use an axe a sickle and a saw you could only use a cleaver freebie now hey maybe i can make some aluminum savor will she'll curate below in a question you can't take wood from a pile that's valuable lumber well that question is moving and not from a piece of wood that broke on yanta viewer it's not valuable why because it's moksa migos wasn't available it wasn't available but let me carry them you can't use an x or avocado something like this is how i understood it that this isn't a cable it's wide this is a zohar it's narrower this you use to chop down a tree and this you use to cut down pieces of wood says rashi you want smaller pieces of wood you use this this looks like the decal this looks like like a tirkha like working during the weekday this is less of an issue this is no different this piece right over here is no different than this same kind of design same blade so what's the difference that it's on it's on the back side of an axe it's still the same idea of a coefficient you're a lot easier covers you allow to use the the zucker of an x this is more very simple no you're using an axe anjantif who cares that there's a motor cli on the x right you'd have a problem understanding you shouldn't use the handle yeah you can't use the handle of x because you're using x so yeah it's the back it's on the back part of the x but it's still an x people see you chopping with the back of the x they'll think you're using an x a yantef and that doesn't look good now the same animated i think since you're not going to use this part the front part so you know he's the back come asheville on that's allowed even though it's the same blade size as the kuipers as they claim we can last la safa rashi just says that the difference in the size is where they lived what tool was available to who did they have this double-edged axe or not or a barrier let me show same thing comes out you're allowed to use the narrower side not the the wider side sheet of olive of course you know how to use the wider side it's like an axe there's nothing between this and the paradigm similar in size now the same anime cardinal avocados a little bit of a character safari since this is allowed maybe this is allowed if it's just a designated cliche so to speak an axe okay the whole thing is awesome but since i'm already allowed to use the cli in a certain way they'll just allow they'll allow me to use the any way i want commercial on you're not allowed to use like that okay now a little bit of a shiloh why are we allowed to open doors in the house on shabbos windows it should be awesome to open and close things even let's say a faucet is a big problem how can you stop water from coming in you're turning your phosphorus character so that's what the mission is basically discussing no no i'm not talking about that not talking about the water going down i'm talking about moving a house which is also you know how to pick up a house and move it let's say you could how can you move parts of the house the window window's part of the carca it's part of the house yeah being a mysterio yeah mysterio you're you're breaking it in a way it's attached but still moving it moved out of the at a position now it doesn't keep the water in before it kept the water and now it doesn't it's broken why is that not broken you have to call a plumber now oh you know how to plummet you know how to turn it great but you for that moment you broke it yes it's attached by your so you let uh you allowed to move a house uh sideways like if it's on on one of the one of these four stilts move it this way you allowed to do that on chavez no it's mukta it's it's been mysterious allowed to open the door so that's what we're discussing yeah that's what we're discussing why why is it so the official mishnah span survival you have a house that's full of fruit yeah i printed it as i'll show you you only need a picture of equifax it's the the other side of the axe that you're allowed to use you're not allowed to use by issue moly pay rips you have a storage room full of fruit viniferas and some of the stones fell out this is the next case where he removes the stones but it's the same picture i don't want to print it twice the stones either fell out so rather than him breaking it's enclosed he can't get to the fruit he sealed it up nicely put stones everywhere that was opening grab the fruit from that opening mayor oymer now very interesting rash here very interesting needs a little bit of a hesbur rashi says that the reason why the fruit is not mukta is because the only answer to get to it is the rabbanam so mela doesn't make them fruit mukto that's what he says the reason why it's only the rabbana we're going to see the mario because we're not talking about bricks that don't have cement so that it needs has been right are you maxed it from your dash you're not maximum that's it's only is there a button he figures he could get to it because it's only yantiff and it's it's uh fish so maybe that's the shop says go ahead break the bricks and get in there asking allah you're breaking a tent you're breaking opinion and this binyan the character being a vestiria bakarta you're not allowed to break something that's attached to the ground umbrella by avira delivering we're talking about bricks without cement and mma law you're not really breaking them down is that all is that okay you have leftover bricks from from the building site you're allowed to carry them in chavez why because you use them as a cheer charging but if you pile them up nicely what does that show if you pile them up then you want to use it again to build vale then for sure you put it aside it's already making some kiss the whole thing it smokes so in our mission it should also be mukta when a person builds this device right over here this is no worse than a pile of bricks this is even better than a pile of bricks this is already a designed building so about it should be mokuto you're not going to sit on these bricks you use it already for a building bring your mysterio bakarika or there beyonce you're right we're only talking about yantef and yanta zakhon nefesh we're [Music] are you allowed to rip open a bag on shabbos to get to it i mean there's certain things oh no sorry okay same exact words you could break the brakes um we'll finish it tomorrow hashem 9 30 monthly shabbos by the way are you going to be here dr mayor planco you're going to be here you swear or not if that helen rabinowitz is leading back to toronto mayors what okay 9 30 mr chavez if you have it has to be 9 30. the deuteronomist is 9 30. maybe we'll bring somebody else inside you have something that's carica tied down rashi says a cave door a well door i couldn't find anything like that online the little that i looked a door any door mohamed character you're permitted to undo the knot now that's a problem on chavez to make it not an anduino you're allowed to why because this is the way we use it that's the way we use it we undo the knot we nod it we this is how we lock the door we constantly open and close the mainland's motor that's why you're allowed to lock the door in your house that's why all these things available they're very interested in shiloh by the way stamina is thinking about this why are you allowed to close a soda bottle you're closing a click so the answer is because you're that's the norm and you're going to be opening up soon to get the drink out but what if you have a bottle empty bottle a two liter bottle of coke and you put the cap on and it goes to the to the trash site and it stays there for 500 years isn't that proud now i just close something loyal basically the only reason why this mother is because it's meant to be undone it's just throwing it out there they discuss it i think i don't know for sure i think but you're not you're not allowed to unravel the the the rope you're not going to cut the rope because yeshtira bakarika now since this is karaka you're breaking the character this rope is part of the character should be caleb but if it's attached to a like this stop so you have something tied to kali um you're permitted to undo the whole robe to to undo the knot to undo the rope i have a wonderful shabbos mustard shop is 9 30 hashem we might have issues with the cameras because gary won't beer but bazel hashem 9 30. you