Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
welcome to the sukko
so it's decided last night
that
this morning is the final breakfast and
beijing hashem tonight hashanah rabbah
at 10 p.m
we're going to get together again in the
sukkah but not tomorrow morning
who's saying shir
is uh yet to be determined
i don't think i'll have time to prepare
i'm not going on a trip with the trip
that's right come here mr fetter say it
again
shit's going to be tonight not tomorrow
morning
before i get to the sponsors
i want to say thank you first
to all the sponsors starting with uh
mayor planca
leon welcher
we had benty novak
i think jonathan stevansky is doing
something i don't know he wanted in the
morning i don't know if he'll do tonight
we'll see but we'll say jonathan's
defense we'll put him on the on the spot
raiser hashem
stefanski
at the grill
mordechai seltzer
with the setup and everything else
a bunch of kids what's the name of that
kid with the pace parrots what's what's
his name
akiva
akiba
his father's the robe of karla bach
unbelievable worker
um thank you tamati last night
sponsoring the pizza together with natan
koshnut and avi factor all that
expensive wine
and then we have simon jacobs with all
the castell
24 bottles of castell unbelievable
who else do we have
and everybody else that helped out i'm
sure i'm missing a bunch of guys
you show aaron price of course
comes early in the morning
set up the iced coffee
so you should have to everybody
the pirates of haiti
in honor of david's latin f200
akiva salkowitz f
94.
shalom rand in the house
that's right you see the i don't know
f202
202 an official eight minute dive
committee
david ziskind in memory of our
dear mother caleb assaframusha
ha levy on her 18th yard side also an
opportunity to pay tribute to the
inspiring
and in
emphatical the fatigable rib ellie how
do you say it
no in the fatigable no way
why does he have to trip up the
puniventure
terrible
in the fatigable
no
again
yeah
oh indefatigable i'm not fatiguable
his supportive family and self-esteem
thank you mark bergson in honor of my
daughter shashana miriam's ninth
birthday even i would love you very
proud of you
mendi greenblatt and shamshi
if you don't know shamshi
now let me first say this before this
was the grandfather the yeoman bin
shamshin allah said is today
shamshi
if you don't know him
and you could spell his name you never
heard how to spell his name you got a
freaking mario right now on the spot
anybody schluff rock
schlofrock s z
l a
f
r o k
yesterday i said i don't i have no idea
what i said this is laff rock it's last
brock it comes out every now and the
frog what's wrong with you no he said in
a beautiful night he says you're not the
only one he said
okay
he needs a shiny hashem quickly i mean
in the spelling not so much the same all
right
we have people from america on wow
very belly ab misses your live shoe room
in chicago very much a b was that kid a
10 11 year old who tripped me up during
shari asked me a beautiful cache and i
didn't have an answer but he's excited
to be able to learn with me and my
father picture attached and now parker
shame his uncle justin mendelsburg
signed up for free gamora shauna too i'm
sure you also would love a bad
basketball caruso shot with you next
time you're in town i think i'm done
with basketball also abby told me he
sent you an email a while back that was
the first time that ever sent in his
life
so resend it again bazel sham will read
it not sure any other mdy member can
claim that distinction good might sami
joseph here we go
three generations in the sukkah here's a
b big bucket on this kid
next
we have pictures from sukkas around the
world this has been ben schwartz is sook
in the five towns
jay davidson bodner ellie
the what do i call him the
[Music]
the the the the what lobster slimy klein
the
token lubavitcher ben schwartz
and akiva ziegler all right here the
gansu islam so beautiful and this is
inside benchwatch
here's mo landi sokka look at this
sucker boy
and of course
we have
on a pressman sukkah
yes it's real agony please see attached
if it came out beautiful i can show my
picture while i'm reading
thank you for saving us some money on
our circus decorations here i also
brought one over to jay spector's katina
carson type for introducing me to the
sheer bronchus def darwin
we have here with us rabbi
marty cornfeld who's with us from
bronchus daf bays
to that earlier
unbelievable it's a big zak rock is that
base
he's broken up dollar and of course we
all get about our sugar family picture
well whoa you haven't heard from me
personally in a while but we're still
almost certain that the homoshare will
initiate shortly as we're near parish is
beratious hope to see you soon now hold
on press
min
and finally we have here from ika lager
breakfast in the sook with the rebelli
rebellion portland oregon
rabbi rafi shenk is a new recruit to the
daffodil mishear here you go
beautiful i don't can anybody see over
there it's this little
sun is shining
90 weeks i don't know what the
significance of that is david 100 weeks
you tell me by 100.
please keep my name anonymous i started
up with that with broca's here's another
bronchus guy
i made it all the way through to the
gimmel in shabbos
i lost the
after falling behind and i kept on
trying started myself but never made it
through
been through a divorce
second marriage
the base of baza fell out the night
before my mother-in-law was nifter and i
made a blinder did i miss another day in
his house for the first time i don't
look at the daf as hard and being hard
anymore
he brought the schmuckness back to me
and i just really want to say
as required to you and everyone else who
makes the dive so readily available and
easy with you as making sure i've never
been there too strong 36 years in my 36
years and i wish i could come just to be
there for experience this year for just
one day see you guys have it good you're
here you live here
there's a guy that lives across the
street watches every day and hasn't been
here yet hasn't been the live share yet
literally across the street
i'm calling you out
who is that
[Laughter]
one of my filmmaking room
uh this question i learned to be
religious early bastard
and real thank you for bringing terry
back to my life
i'm not gonna say his name
i have to read this because it's
negative yesterday you always get mixed
you always get excited in the gemara
where learning is related to the parasha
and koi hell is today there's a pasuk
and it says perk test pesky bays
talking about catching birds and fish
she says oh that has everything to do
with
him
which basically translates that when men
are caught up in a moment of disaster
whatever they may be it falls upon them
like a fish caught in a fatal net or
like a bird sees in a snare we've been
learning and bait's all about trapping
but we never saw it from the vantage
point as man being the victim it takes
coachellas to make us realize that we're
all running around trying to avoid being
trapped whether from a spiritual or
physical snare cahell's gives us advice
in the last possible to avoid the snare
as solid kimiro westminster
dan kaufmann
ah and one more to get yesterday i
learned that the dog is as
because we see by the way
i was at a minion yesterday rabbi
peasant sun red
i've never said
clear and fast it's almost impossible to
read with him that's how fast it is
and there's only one thing that's more
hush of them reading that quickly is to
catch a mistake and fix him
before he's in the next peric
that's me
can't read literally i i can read it
maybe twenty percent as fast as uh
that was just be unbelievable but what
i'm trying to say is i didn't hear a
word he said like nobody understood the
word he said he read it here's the ice
design
i should have came to you you read it
fast and we can understand i learned a
shot that a dog is asked because we see
a dog is never afraid of anything and
this is very true the reason why i'm
reading this is this from aaron sittner
we have a little tiny dog
that any cat in the street can kill it
in a second yet any person that comes to
the house he barks and barks and barks
he's oz that's the shot beautiful shot
yeah
even if an animal much bigger than is
near the dog will try and be tough and
bark absolutely miss okay raboissai
we're starting a brand new mishna brando
sugya and it's a tsugyo
we're going to make it very very simple
says the heilig mishna
sponsored by official reformer
every
first born animal
[Music]
which is a zakhar is a bahar
abhar
and bakar is even in our days
and if you eat a bakar
even an hour a day it's high of chorus
you know about that just last night
after the the whole kumzi situation
which was really beautiful
so this is
that i just called him out the other day
he's not part of the sheer but he heard
the singing he came up and he says i
heard you mentioned that i have a goat
and i walk my goat in the street you
made me into the town's fool he tells me
i just said what you do you walk in the
street with it
i
i just said that you walk anyways i
don't think i mentioned his name but he
wasn't that upset but he went into the
he said i had a very good kasha
he is his goat a bachara or not he had a
good reason to believe because he had he
bought a mother
and twins and he says usually the the
mother gives birth to a male and a
female that's how it usually goes
and
is it her first litter
is one of them
but what you do today is you have to get
a guy involved in the whole situation
otherwise you have a probable heart
so
we're talking about a bahar a firstborn
which already has developed a mum
the way it works is in order for you to
decide whether or not it's a mum you
have to bring the professional guy in
you have to be the pro the mum
he decides whether or not halal it's a
mom now if it has a mum
then
the kind gets to eat it if not
those of them is bare
subhash
this
fell in to a pit review the eye mirror
yeah red mum kavira found the gevaldo
picture
of a cow
fell into a pit and here you have a
monkey going down now i don't know why
he's going down let's pretend he's going
down to check to see if there's a mum
here he is going down put a bag over his
head
i guess it's kind of dangerous to be in
the same pit with the animal that just
got stuck there
yes
now
if
this animal has a mom
and he decides this mumka decides it's a
real mom so now the animal is no longer
muktsa
i could go ahead and checked it
which happened yesterday as we said
you could
take the animal out of the pit and check
it
we're going to see that these words
might mean something different than
we're thinking right now in love what
that doesn't have a mom
describes it as something slightly
different
if
you didn't notice that it has a mom
before yant
this is not considered in other words
you can't even use it with the evid
why there's a two reasons in rashi one
is that it looks as if you're fixing
something
you can't just
go ahead and
decide that this is
ready to eat or you can't decide today
that it has a moon because it's like
doing a din tara i'm going to learn
later on
in the lamins i think islam with
yeah that you're not going to do a din
on yante you know how to judge somebody
so you can't judge this animal you can't
say oh this animal is obama
somebody yesterday i don't even know
their name and he told me in the name of
somebody else
here in ramada chemist and i'm just
gonna was that you
you told me no
i forgot it was but anyway it was cute
so i'm gonna say it over the coved
yantef usually they don't see these kind
of tires but since it's a local torah
i'll stick in my own twist if you want
to remember
that rib shimin is the one that's
mahmeer
and rabihuda is the one that's makeup
because typically rip shimon is mako
when it comes to mukta
and over here is the reverse shipment is
is
michael he says you could
you could remember by who else was in a
pit
and who put him in the pit
shimon
and who took him out of the pit yehuda
so mellow that's why
torah okay the cover yanta
but you can remember it what
somebody said
somebody liked it okay great
and therefore shimon who started the
whole thing with the pit he put his
voice out she has to be mako here
are you what
where is levy freeman
[Music]
judah david
the michael mcphee
judah david is not in the waldorf i'll
tell you that right now
what is the macholicus now rashi points
out right away obviously the macholicus
cannot be a question do we hold the
moksa do we not hold him
right because then it would have to be
reversed rip shipment does not hold the
moksa
does all the much
movement
could you is
perhaps says could you judge a mum
on maybe that's
that's
why why do you have to give me a story
that uh an animal fell into a pit just
straight out macholicus could you see
could you judge
a defect on yontif is that considered
judging or not nothing to do with the
pit
says you might well that's not a great
question but
no the reason why perhaps that is
democracy
but i want to tell you the idea of a
bahar
i want to tell you because
we yidden are very careful about the
pain of an animal
and tsar behind is a big thing so
perhaps in order to save the animal even
though it's awesome for us to save maybe
we could do some trickery
velasque we'll do a trick i will bring
him out that what we'll say oh i think
that's a real mum we'll pull him out and
then oh sorry oh it wasn't such a big
moment
kirby yeshua
so yeshua says
by the story of oysters
a mother and its calf
are not allowed to be shocked at one day
so if the mother and the calf fell into
a pit the best picture i was able to
find couldn't find the cow found this
one we'll have to do
two elephants in a pit
uh elephants are not kosher
don't ask him these people are passing
everything here it says this they go
so what do you do
so he has a trick ruby sure
you say i want to eat the baby elephant
i like veal
so you take the baby out and they say no
no i made a mistake i don't want to feel
today today i want regular and then you
take out the mother so that's the trick
you pretend that it's okay he trick
so mela sensory says you can do trickery
perhaps you can do trickery also when it
comes to our case also there's one cow
make a trick pretend that you that you
know that's a moon cavua it's a
permanent mom and therefore
some for some reason it's all okay
commerce malone and that's why the
mission talks about a bar to say that we
don't do trickery
if that's the case that the whole
problem so what's the what's the main
kudu here what what's the main idea
whether or not you could take an animal
out of the pit
so it's not even about
now
the main thing is whether or not you
could take it out
so says
what happened was
yeah there's two allah the mission is
talking about whether or not you could
give the animal could could you judge a
mum that's question number one
the other thing is what happened was
when a person goes ahead
and takes the animal out
sorry
he already took out the animal soccer
camino let's
he was over
that guy that likes to be over things
so perhaps
we should allow him to continue doing
what he wants to do and check the
commercial
so what are we talking about here
talking about that this animal doesn't
have a mum you pulled him out with with
no reason says rashi and i had to have i
mean he should be able to shock him ask
him what are you talking about so now we
just have to qualify what's going on
here it doesn't make any sense
you're not a chef a bar that
first what happened was
says anymore this is a story this animal
had a temporary moon before yonto but
hashtag like
and now it became permanent about the
same of the deity because this guy is
hoping and wishing in his mind that the
moon will get worse and then you should
be able to eat it otherwise you won't be
able to eat it
venezuela so that's the shiloh maybe we
had to have amino you should allow it
comashmallow not so again so when the
mission says
you see the top line in the in the in
our omer over here vimlav in other words
if you went ahead and you pulled out the
animal when you weren't supposed to
in the beginning we thought it means it
doesn't have a moon now we're saying it
does have a moon
even though it has a moon
you're not allowed to commercial
why not
because
either
two reasons rashi gives either it's
moksa mahmus is sir
you're never you aren't allowed to use
it to begin with so now just because the
god of moon doesn't it doesn't help me
or because you pulled this animal out
when you weren't allowed to illegally
will give you a canas
okay
[Music]
we're talking about says says rashi that
these tanoim
nasi
reby the one who wrote the mishnah
doesn't hold the muktsa why
over here there's no mukti because
he had a mind to eat this animal the
entire time so there's no muktsu
has no moom
shin of a bar
fell into the bar so according to
rebuttal there's no moksa why is it no
because he had a mind to eat this thing
he was hoping that something's going to
happen
what does mean if
there's no mum
so i'm sorry imlav means even if there
is a mum
now there's a canas
oh
rashi
[Music]
i like the other shot okay
vim love
even if it has a mom otherwise vim life
doesn't make so much sense
even if it has a mom you give him a
kinase fine um
we're not going to check it out you know
how to bring
we we we decide what's hiray amro so
rashi goes in here to say that rib
shimmering barium
was the rebbe of all of these was the
rebbe of rebbi
rashbee
was rebbe's rebbe so array omro we
already said in the previous generation
moving beyonce
you're not gonna go bring a mumha in
there can't bring the professionals in
okay todd
so now our boys here we have we have
a bracelet that tells us three things
very very simple
and this chart is going to make it even
simpler
here
if there's a mum before yantev blue
in this case blue is not green it's not
100 good and it's not red it's not 100
and bad it's in between it's pariv
so i did a check with a red mark what
does that mean be the evident
so it says if
the mum developed before jantav you now
that i checked this animal on yantev
why
i'm saying why if you do check it it's
okay with the evid
because all you're missing is a tiny
piece
you have the mum the animal's already a
goner it's a it's a baa mom you need the
right the rabbi to say ah give this
temple
yeah
person dies and you need a death
certificate okay but the person is not
going to live if you don't he's dead you
just need a temple fine so it's a little
bit of a
a little bit of a hazard in
in a tikkun
but you're not fixing something what was
the whole problem the whole problem was
that you're fixing something
you're not fixing it 100 you're fixing
it only five percent 10 and that if you
you shouldn't do it but if you went
ahead and you're over and you brought a
rub in or
you could still you could eat that
so that's aloha number one in blue
now we turn the page
on
look at this red
what's red if the mum was created on
yontif
that now you're fixing it completely
when yandev came in you couldn't eat the
animal at all zero
zero percent
what happened on yantev it got a
terrible mum it's not going to survive
this it's a mom that now it allows you
to eat the animal without having a
yantif
so even the avid you can't eat it so you
see it's red 100 red mum bianca
now let's do this puppet
very very simple
what happens if an animal was born
on yontif with a mum
so ignore this is very very simple
a third case we have a case that the the
mum happened there are evie a case that
the animal was born before you have to
but the moon occurred on this in the
third case that he's born with a bomb
now the difference is that uh a bihar
is born a bahar you have to be born of a
heart i'll show you valid here
where is the pasok
it's here somewhere
oh
kuala because
it has to be born and if it's born maybe
with the moment we decided to move we'll
see
so let's see what happens
mars is a very very simple
svara over here if this green case
was in fact a blue
in other words only the evide not 100
mutter then the bryson should say it
together over here in the blue
the there should be a section of bitly
avid in the bryce's should say if
there's a mum that happened araviantov
or
if it was born with a moam
a check with a red it's a power if it's
in between if you ever then you can eat
it
the fact that the bryson brings it all
the way at the end of the raiso that
tells me that's it's a category on its
own there's three categories in the
bracelet there's a category blue
category red and that has to be a
category green hundred percent motor not
about the oven 100 butter if an animal
is born with a mom
yeah
i just don't understand
not
the cups for stopped
too much wine maybe
i just i i really think that
every share should have charts because i
don't know how to explain it and how
people could understand without a chart
that's okay
you think it's not that difficult
yeah yeah
please join us at helen.8.com
sponsored
by natan
this close for my children iri kalav and
israel jakob benvoro they were both here
in the circle last night it should be
both should both do well energy strong
says the gemara
this case right over here
it was born with the mum it's mohan
meaning it was designated you go ahead
and eat it
now if the oil wasn't like into the
pizza last night
then this would be a joke this question
who was rabba bharavula who is ravuna's
rebbe
you didn't eat pizza
so yesterday we just learned yesterday
that ravuna
so the same person doras rabb the son
doras rabba baraboona
noilaru umaimoy
me vakrum
now we get a little bit more of a
picture if we were just to remember this
for the whole shot rav nachman who is
also a talmud of rav and yesterday he
had a conversation with rabbit
also
abba tani
over here it seems from rashi that abba
means my father
some says
says abba means
your father
refuna tony imam arabic
meaning that it's only in the heavens
if he was over now you can't do it if
you want to do it if you were over
alvera whatever you were over you didn't
listen
and you went ahead and you checked it
mover what does that mean that it's not
green
it's
more like the blue it's uh the heaven
what am i
here comes that sparrow that we went
over before and now it's going to be the
second time inside
all right bye people say the rabbit
bro i think rabbit
is right why medictonic plus above you
see there are three parts in the braiser
blue red and green
noiled by mo merviantev the first part
is if the moment occurred before yontev
a may vacuum i should be yantiff you
cannot check it on your octave that's
only the katrina delay how do you have a
chapter dummy but if you go ahead and
you do it okay
if the moon developed
if the animal was born before you
but his mom
was developed
red you can't do anything
and then it says
so then why does it say a third category
because the third category is different
than the first two
how could it be different it's not about
the evid and it's not us so what is it
if the animal is born with a mom on your
teeth
you go ahead and we tell you go ahead
and check it
out
we have a
problem shy came along and has a
different bryson
and look how beautiful this chart is
going to be bank
division
oh look at this
same chart rabbi's eye but two reds
instead of a blue on top there are two
reds
what forces us to say that this is green
because there's a red and a blue
but if they're both red
we're not forced to say this is green
we're not forced to say it's
we could say that this is what but the
avid we have another category you're
asking me a question why didn't you put
this
this case together with the top one
because it's very different
but look at this if the two top cases
are red they're both 100 percent also
there's nobody evident here
so then this the third case
could be different than the first cases
but you're not forced to say that it's
now you can say it's different how it's
only with the evidence yeah
valdic how do you do this without charts
i don't know
so beautiful
huh it's off the charts
shop
you got to take that out you'll see
i hope i didn't pick it up
you're not come on
since
this guy is not of the evide
they're both uh sir whether you have a
mum before you aunt whether the moon
happens both of us are so the the next
case the third case could be a different
case it's a case of
the heaven you're not forced to say that
the third case is
over here you are forced why because you
have two cases before it one is
the aved and one is usur so the third
case has to be different in it how the
only other way to be different is to say
great
says
with the evidence also to use
velocity
so beautiful i don't have to say
anything what'd i do with this bryce uh
this brightest system before ish
different than this bryce it's a steroid
is the top case blue or red which one is
it it's a contradiction
it says gemara tell you what happened
over here
the reason why you think it's blue and
it's
only brought in on shas once it happens
to be on our daf
and he gets confused has a pretty weak
memory
and when he repeats his prices he messes
up
he messed up a sticker
that's it
that's the answer it's not blue he
thought that this case isn't with the
evid in fact this case is red
and if this case is red this case could
be about the evid you see oh i don't
know if i pointed it out
yes you're right it's a green box
because i didn't have patience to change
it but the check is has a red line
through it it's a be the evident okay
so the immortal
whatever you do don't go speaking to the
guy from the next chair and say well the
bluetooth and the green green and red
blue against red he's not gonna know
what you're talking about but you guys
you understand that you understand okay
fine
um
anytime the mom
is not
recognizable before your auntie
agrees to this why would she waste his
time telling your behavior
whenever behood admits to this
what happened was there's a mom just you
didn't show it to the yet
he didn't decide whether it's a
permanent or temporary mo
miyaz but it says
even if the mum was there before it's
not considered
again means what
it's us
that's
and it's from the mission like that
he's sticking
of course it's not hilar zakin it's uh
it's an america many many a thousand in
the year later rav hill
yes
if
the typical case rashi says there's many
many cases but a very easy case to
understand
are raisins
you have grapes which are edible
obviously they're not mukto
once you put them up on the roof here's
a rooftop and you put the grapes down i
noticed there's a net here underneath
with stones i guess when they become
raisins all you need to do is lift up
the net and you gather you don't have to
sit there and shovel it okay
so
what happens is that there's three
stages here stages the grapes are edible
then the grapes you put them in the sun
they start spoiling and rotting so you
can't eat them and then they become they
become raisins and you can eat them
what happens if during shabbos they were
not edible for a moment
for two hours you couldn't eat them so
the mukta they're disgusting
you don't want to touch them
does that mook so less for the entire
shabbos or do we say
that once
that period goes away they become edible
now you're allowed to eat them again
so let's read it yes
meaning
would mean a little bit different than
how we would read it with the simple
shot
and it stays for the whole shabbos not
for a half a shot it's like it reads but
yea
since this mukta for a minute does it
remain for the whole shops
or perhaps yes it's muksa for those two
hours when it's not edible
but it doesn't remain for the whole
shops
so the mother just qualifies
if these raisins were edible when chavez
came in now right the famous concept
if something is muktsa during
verasmushes when shabbos comes in for
that moment it remains moksha for the
whole shabbos
so
wonders what's going on here what's the
case just tell me simple shot
if these raisins were edible then of
course you could eat a doll shabbos
what's the problem
if they weren't edible
so they were muktsa for a split moment
and if they're mocked for a split moment
then the
that's the story
they were good let's say they're good
raisins as shabbos came in so you would
think that they're not moksha but then
it rained
and they swelled up and they're not
edible anymore disgusting
wet raisins
disgusting and then that and that
happened on shabbos so things because
for two three hours
when when it's wet and swollen and not
edible it should remain mooked for the
whole entire shabbos that's the shia la
mai omalei
yesh
mukta
once it becomes mukta for those two
hours during shabbos the muktsu remains
for the rest of the shabbos yes
i apologize for all those guys that came
from your slime and a lot of them
the whole table over there a bunch of
guys from new york
places it's one of those daphne that's a
real study we got to take this dab
serious no time for stories and jokes
yeah
at least for me
what
one story
the story on the train robots have the
story on the train
what time does they have to do with
suckers
nachman seltzer wants to get up here and
say the story about the train he talks
about it all the time i refuse to say it
he says it's the best story he wants to
get up here and say the story he's going
to get up here and say the story i don't
care
okay
the story goes back oh no
sure no problem
okay he didn't see the story so yeah how
does he know it i'm a cabba i'm a
[Music]
somebody tell me why he thinks this is a
great story okay it's a great story
you'll hear what in a second
the valley was on his way upstairs
coming back to shiva two in the morning
anyway how old are you
uh probably 18 17 17 years old
two in the morning on a train like i'm
saying
suddenly the door of the car he's by
himself the only guy on the car to see
her up on the seat across from him and
suddenly the door opens up and then
walks six guys
african-american cover six guys walk in
like this they're walking like this they
walk in
and they see him
and they surround him
and they're looking at him it's two in
the morning he's by himself
and look at him they stop and they look
at him
he doesn't miss the beat he's speeder up
and he looks at them this is why this is
a great story he says
which one of you wants to die first
and off they go
they just walk out of the train and
that's why i say it's a great story
did anybody i think that was a good
story now you know why i didn't say it
i didn't say it and share
i said in too i said it
i myself said it
nachman
we said it and you were there
there's no way you weren't there
so anyway so the blue and the green and
the blue is the cathedral with the avid
aceve
i'm hacking no we're not going back to
the blue in the green aceved
that's cash
everybody agrees that if
we have to go back to this chart
where's everything oh it's over here
thank you
we learned
that if it's born with the mum it's
considered designated
named
so we're talking again so we're going
back
how does this fit in
because we had a question whether or not
there's a mukti chavez if something is
muktza for a moment you can't eat these
grapes for whatever reason
let's say another example is let's say
you during shabbos
uh the cleaning lady takes
the the leicester and puts it on your uh
on a chair right the question that we
had in the hotel but it happened on
chapters you didn't do it the cleaning
lady did it so now it became a business
of our officer are you allowed to move
that chair she you said yelled at her
what are you doing she moved it away but
for a moment that cheer became muscle if
the chair is ushered for a moment
does it remain awesome for the whole
shops or not so the bar says let's bring
arrive from our story over here now what
if an animal is born with a defect
it's considered designated why
name a
the famous concept of benpekua it's
could i to see these pictures again even
though we just had it i don't know a
week ago
what incredible picture
of
uh
this was taken from
an animal from the stomach of an animal
but here here's another one this is a
river from icefish
this was from a video how do you see the
substitute yeah okay here if you look
closely these are the feet of the animal
that's this is the story i was talking
about yesterday she was dying the mother
and here are the two babies twin ben
pekuas
if you check the mother and you see on
the video they shut the mother
and then they
tear out these babies the babies don't
need chito bambika that's the lava
bamboo
says the gemara this bahar
didn't need didn't need shrita it was
mother when it was in the mother's
stomach
but once it was born italy
it became a what when it was born a
bahar
a bakar becomes a bahar
a sheriff when it is born
through three stages stomach motor
borne us
around motor motor motor
comes and says that it oh it has a mum
but until the khakim came until you
called him up well it's
until you dialed your kosher phone and
yantev and told him to come right away
emergency we have an animal that's abhar
i want to eat it and he comes and says
yes it has a moment and then you're
allowed to eat it but for those two
hours until he showed up
it was awesome
and the kumar says israeli we say that
it's mother so what do you see that's
something that became an oscar for a few
hours doesn't remain awesome for the
rest of the yantef limar wants to bring
a touchdown from this case to mukta
no there's no such thing it was oscar
oscar and it only becomes motor from
that moment on that the hakam says it's
motor it's not igloo muslim afraid that
the moon was a moment no that's not how
it works
says
every time you have suffocating yeah
what happened was the no there was never
a moment of history why was there never
a moment of visser because as the baby
was born the rough said oh look at it it
has a terrible defect it's user it's
multitate so never had a moment of
israel of eating that's the case
now we've got a freebie over here some
people say learn it a little differently
hey
that what
that if it's muktsa for a moment it
doesn't last for the shabbos let him say
like same exact sugya but instead of
asking a question it's now it's become
zariah because now we're saying
we're saying it's not
oh and i have a riot to you
if everybody agrees that if this animal
was born this bar is born and it has a
mom that you're allowed to eat it
it's a benpekua in the stomach you're
allowed to eat it without chito
and it's not a bahar why is it
because it wasn't born if you rip it out
of the mother's stomach after shrita you
could eat a bakar
italy then it was
then it was born italy became awesome
then third third step is
true
oh so you see all right to you
that if it's muktsa for a moment and
then you're making mother it doesn't
remain muktsa for the whole yanta
omar abayo not a good ray of the
temperature of suffocating
awesome same exact suggyo they no
there's no moment of
yes sir because the dayanam sat there as
it was mutter in the stomach
as it's coming out of the stomach mutter
because the rob said it's motor on this
path before he was born
here he's in the middle of eating grapes
rashi says he's the middle of eating
it's the biggest riot that he wants all
these grapes it's not much he's in the
middle of eating them
when anaerobic
voices have left over graves
and he brought them up to his rooftop
wherever that picture was you know what
it looks like here
it's rooftop
it's hard to come by these pictures this
is a rooftop
put grapes on the roof
to make raisins
or he took fig's voice over helen and he
had leftover valentine's glasses and
gregory's the famous grueger's what's a
gregaris
it's a dried fig
loya
you cannot eat from them until
unless unless you designate
that raisin before yant
peaches
a quince
ube comedy payrolls anything you want to
dry out hey dummy
says let's qualify either
if they're edible you don't have to
designate why either
again going back to the venezuelans
if this is edible by banishmoshes you
don't need to designate it you you don't
sit and designate every piece of food in
your refrigerator if it's edible it's
edible it'll
if you don't know about it you don't
know so what if you don't know lima says
you don't need to know if your food is
edible if it's available even if you
don't know about it it's not muktu
and allah says
it was
like we said before it was available to
eat then it got pushed off the rain came
so you didn't you couldn't eat it and
then it became edible again the amber
say
it doesn't stay for the whole day
la mula's
why do you have to designate it it's
already edible
so what are you going to tell me what it
does stay with the whole day chasm
mojave
so what if you designate it you can't
designate this rash you can't designate
stones you can't say i want to eat
stones for breakfast and i'm designating
stones for eating it doesn't work so you
cannot designate
unripe
raisins you can't a raisin that's not
edible is like a stone says rashii you
can't be mass minute you can't designate
it
it's borderline
borderline ma i have a i have a
i have a corny joke
borderline smacking is so good we're
finishing it up
there was a guy
who was about to cross the border and he
got pulled over by a cop
cop tells him let's see if i remember it
so it's just a joke there's nothing else
going on the cop tells him you know i've
been following you for 30 minutes
and you don't even have a single
infraction
i've never seen anything like it
i
on behalf of the police department
giving you 500 as a gift
she says wow 500 bucks wow that's going
to go towards my uh driver licensing
thing i don't have a license yet
so his wife says
be quiet
don't listen to him he always talks to
when he's drunk
because and the joke keeps on going on
and on and the mother-in-law said oh i
know we're gonna have trouble with the
stolen car and then they pulled out a
thing we kissed the hose off okay
next
yeah there's no
no that's the end of the story i'm not
joking oh you know the joke okay fine
it's an old one
but we don't say those lashings
you know what editing you caused me oh
yeah boy
you'll save yeah
not me i i've never touched these videos
asmin
if he designated gulliver so in other
words a borderline
this is food that's somewhat edible some
people eat it some people don't they get
injured
so if asman if he designated it
you're asking why does it help to
designate because he's showing that he
he likes his borderline kind of food
golodaity loyasmen but if he didn't
designate it loy golly dieting should we
continue a minute what time is it
we have tonight but tonight we have a
daf also
how much
okay we'll do two minutes
oh my really
okay we'll stop right here ah good
morning everybody you're squatting from
coming in we'll stop smacking middles so
that's not more than our casper
you