Daf Yomi Beitzah Daf 20 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning [Music] today is sponsored by paris in honor of david zlatnick f200 akiva sokowitz f94 sean rand f202 ah he's in the house rip challenge though i hope you brought some meat schmoly 202 and the official eight minute dive yo me committee inaudible stefanski and my upcoming 90th day of doing the daf learning toyota consistently especially while doing while doing pre-med has been a real challenge that i've been trying to improve on and i'm really grateful to be ellie on the opportunity to be part of america's deputy seizure shaolin to the chief shusher who's that by us [Music] yeah the chief show shusher no that's not for you but in our show i'm asking a theoretical my one please join the mdy daft share you will love it and okay he's this is somebody that doesn't watch the daf so how is he going to see it okay whatever i'll show you'll love it it will keep us connected from afar from anonymous but boyce said this was uh an emotional one not so much for me there's a whole long story behind this i got part of it here thank you rebellio for bringing me to this moment in my life it might be hard for some to believe but in my 54 years on this planet i've never put up ahsoka i remember in hebrew school helping put up some decorations i've been planning this since i started learning sukkah with you but nothing prepared me for the flood of emotions that came over me today placing this on top of the first sukkah i built at my own home i have trouble connecting most of the times when i dive in and also the show but today as i placed it in place i felt the power of thousands of years of my people of the world really felt part of something so much bigger i'm going to be using this opportunity to invite some of my secular jewish friends over during the week to experience this and who knows i might even get something to join the daf i want to thank you the rest of the guys out for zoom from zoom who've been so supportive especially mark ashkenazi also no elephants were harmed in building of the sukkah jeff rosenberg jeff i don't know mark where does he live mark i see mark uh clapping on zoom mark where does he live tell tell avi where he lives oh he's over there in california he's one of david gal's boys shmuley backs i recently joined this shirt thanks to my friend of romero farkavich who posted sheets i actually learned that most days of russo but family shared with me the most amazing starters every day just wanted to point out that part of what pulls me to the sheer is your funny comment stories throughout the year obviously the share itself clarifies some points as a side note it clarifies some of the gemara but the main thing is there's some stories and singish stuff going on i may have missed the first time i i even enjoy you running through the sponsors and commentary it truly makes me feel part of something even even though we've never met i don't know if this was your objective but all caused me to learn more so thank you so much yes it was my objective next time i'm energy strong i definitely plan on trying to come to live share at least once shmuley bags saw this shivish man walking exactly like this i stopped and asked him what he was doing response watching your belly's deaf here's the sheevish man listen there's a guy in seated her so he thinks this is yeshivish he saw this yeshivish man i mean maybe he's a sheepish and he i don't know he could be he's not from ponovich i don't know what yeshiva siddhara tsushima doesn't for raqqa okay well i don't know i've been i used to down and she was for august i don't know the white sox gave it away oh oh here's a interesting one dear belly as well as making newspapers this is from yossi sanders i'm also a freelance cousin this year dominating seniors hill schulman bergman birmingham uk as you can as you can see my gemara now accompanies me onto the people together with my master i mean jacob's picture in the right already dafs with someone else but give him a shout out anyways i love an mdy as he would love you'll see sounds love mdy gemara please see us on my ride up on mdy london see him in last week's paper and finally just for you blah blah blah you see sounds manchester jewish weekly here's you'll see sound sounders now check this out a while ago i was trying to open up a special kylo i wanted to do something called call hazard shots i noticed that in a lot of shows there are people especially the khashoggi people they like to learn during because of shots which is against allah says to learn their physicians they learn so i was going to open up a special coil called carl hazorsa shots we pay special those who are over on before and we pay them but the problem was i couldn't find a rush kylo the boy said he's the rush coil he's the cousin and he has his art scroll on the beam as he's [Music] he's boring everybody else and he's learning the whole daf this is the rush carlo that i was looking for all the years here he is the bussy sounders coilovers kylo all right moving on to the more serious stuff daf today's and i want to say this raboisite this is where people fall off the bandwagon right here sukkas it's very difficult to learn and not everybody has a big party in the sukkah like we're going to have this beautiful breakfast every morning and by the way if you're part of the daf you are invited if you've been learning with us you're invited there's those who are gonna start learning with us on socas they're not invited and your children and wives are not invited if you do the daf you're invited it doesn't matter where you live and how you watch you're invited so for all those i just need to say i get i'm getting phone calls can i pay 200 shekels to come no yesterday um simon jacobs delivered two cases of castel wine you're talking about thousands of shekels worth of wine each bottle is overdoing the jackal two cases so we're gonna have wine in the morning which is the way it's meant to be on yantev and it's curious because every year we do it at this time it's the yant of kvi it's just like monster shops we have a 9 30. it's not the 7 15. oh i got to read your email you're right i forgot to print it out that's a very good one and i forgot to bring it down um what we'll have to do one of the nice the the new yorkers complain that they're going to be lost anyways what happens is people fall off the bandwagon they miss the daf here mr duff there they get the scars they get depressed it's very depressing you want to finish the homosexta the idea is don't get depressed it's all right you miss water to death even seven death just go to where we are holding whatever it is whatever it is just jump on pretend it never happened and later on you might be able to catch up if you don't it's not in the world but don't leave daffy you because you messed up on yanteff all right so now we are going into oh where is here tomorrow night should it be just right here every day in this it might soak in the morning but tomorrow night here i'm looking for more by the way mayor plancos here in the back is sponsoring uh a full breakfast one day betsy novak is spelling a full breakfast and the rest i am sponsoring all right so tomorrow night's cheer is right here in the basement typical time 9 30. there's there those who ask every single month of shabbos what time is shared that's why the same as it was last week the same as it's going to be next week 9 30 what time is she in the morning 7 15. okay and on sukis it's 10 30 we have a 10 30 cavua sukkas for the last three four years it's a beautiful atmosphere it's unbelievable okay what no in my sukkot at 10 30 and on a regular day right fine is a is a giant of actors of camaraderie everybody comes into the circle all types of people we have hasidim and litvax miss nagdim and anti-misnak them and lebavichers and we have a token cluster event and we rent a you shall me guy it's all it's unbelievable we have everybody there yes ask yeshua he drives to different places to recruit it's a whole matter with him no i don't think you could do that now they're going to cut that out and say i said okay whatever says the gemara we're holding four lines from the bottom at the words shazam it's the last words of the sugiya and all it means is that sukis is the thing that we care about is sukis in other words if a person brings or says he's going to bring in a dava one minute before sukas he must bring you that sukkas he doesn't have according to this mandaramar three of them television why am i reading it again because it's going according to this man it's that is the most important out of everything and now let's get on to the regular program says the gemara the bod says if a person brings a carbon and he stipulates that it should be a carbon it's a tita he crossed the ocean he came from america there's a strobe and he wants to say thank you that was saving his life or for bringing him here or he had a disease or he's a jail he's bringing a carbon taido you cannot use that carbon although it's a carbon taida it's and a giga is a slum so i would say okay let's use it for this but since on yontev you're again you might have to bring this red carbon here this xiaomi this shaman a voluntary but that's not what we're talking about we're talking about you must bring in as you come to the base so you cannot be yaita with your taida cheetah that's passion there is to bring a taita that says it has to be readily available to bring as a carbon can just piggyback ride kill two birds with one stone and say oh i'm gonna be right to my titan now you have a special here you have to bring a pure non-carbon related animal says the parish i'm telling you maybe i would think that if a person says specifically i want to bring a i don't have to i cross the ocean it doesn't say the torah i have to bring it but it's a it's not a possible so i want to bring my toilet but also he says as he's as he's as he's donating i want to bring a toy though but i also at the same time want to be heights on my carbon jagiga or now what happens when he does that so as soon as the words come out of his mouth i want to bring the toyota that's it then he continues to speak and he says oh and i also want to add something to the gigo no good that's what kamar is going to tell us same thing harini nazir i'm accepting by myself to be a nozzler i'm not going to drink wine i'm going to grow with my hair i'm going to be careful tomorrow moist my shiny and i'm going to use what's my sashimi the 10 of your produce that you give to yourself but you have a lot of produce so you transfer into cash and instead of buying stakes in your salary you want to buy carbonites those are the carbons that i have to bring as another mahou once you say the words i bring you that's it the nether is how once you say i'm going to be another you're another now you cannot add to it and say oh but i want to piggyback on the maester shading i want to pick it no it has to be a pure corvo says moro august so it's a personal very personal story i never really said a story i was about uh 19 20 years old i was dancing in hasano like a mashoguna and a guy comes over to me i talk to you yeah hoshmooz it's telling me about his daughter and then he says listen whoever marries my daughter i give him six million dollars six million dollars now six million dollars in those days is probably i don't know 20 30 million dollars today the house that we bought in kensington there was a hundred twenty thousand dollars today it's you know one and a half million whatever it's at least three four times right 20 27 years ago so i go home all excited to my father this guy this guy is gonna give his number one thing so my father told me he said listen if you could take the money and bring it home and put the wife in the bank that's a very good idea but since the money's in the bank and the the wife is home it doesn't make sense so oh yeah it makes my the mice a taco cigarette is probably the worst advice my father ever gave she's probably 50 years old now and and whatever the joke you said yesterday that's what she was probably also why else would the guy offer so much more okay anyway there's a guy dying on his deathbed and he said to a guy right the gemara always says arabic to guzman it's a huge number give this guy 400 zoos for my bank account le pleni valencia barty he has to marry my daughter oh started back then already omera papa airborne is shocking if i would have married that girl there would be no uh no mdy whether i would be somewhere in a place in the chavu zak was welcome to save the world [Laughter] nice he said or we would have a much bigger building omra papa [Music] just forgive me much more than that but he didn't make it at night he saw that was a great guy and he was like yeah okay omar papa i promise what happens is the guy gets his 400s if he feels like marrying you're great not not because you basically it's here the heady there's but this guy's a skimmer out so you have to be everything he says goes because you don't want him to to go crazy he said give this guy 400. stop giving 400. the next condition but he he doesn't say but he says and he should and he should marry my daughter what stop if you want to marry mary great boy though stamina reminds me this other great story that i like to say all the time but there was some rebber that did not like his son-in-law he realized like right after the haas and these guys are real he messed up in the shadow big time so he told the son or listen it was a beautiful class in the video we just saw beautiful beautiful but i noticed that under hopper when the oh what you should do is give a get and we'll just say the broncos again so the guy gave a guess they said oh stop stop that part is good now now we have to think about the bronchus so you could do you do half and then you think about the other half later first you take the 400 in cash and then if you want to marry her great if not not thai madame avalyama lindsay lay but if he reversed it he said first i'm conditioned he marries my daughter and if he marries my daughter this 400 zuz in assassin's chakrill be like natively there's a dna we shine him tysonist rush different what if in our case he says i want to bring it but also i want to bring i'm sorry i want to bring a uh yeah and i want to bring a toy though is it like the reverse in this case where mary 400 that does work you have to marry the 400. so maybe you could do a gigatoyto maybe you have to bring both you could be outside on both yes i didn't say it was a question that asked for and told him the buddha so to speak you can only be eight to one that's how you say it we don't say it as a given it was a question or you're gonna answer them okay so that is in the past again the torah with soma yoda you have to lean on the head of the animal this what kind of i love we're talking about so yesterday stamped so we can grain this in our head yesterday we spoke about these oils these four oils this is everybody coming to your slime today in those days would bring a carbon eyeless rhea and tomorrow there's going to be atomic in the base i make this which is also noila and there's a carbon muscle for circus and the passage is talking about are you less than the dava voluntary i want to give a kajabo full animal i don't want to eat any steaks i want it all together you must do [Applause] lean all your weight on the head it doesn't say it by any of the other alas okay the same thing interestingly enough was that that's fine it says but look what it says in the beginning of the puzzle again voluntary slamming so here are the three shlomim that we spoke about yesterday is if you run out of meat right shalom basar so you you bring another carbon but it's part of the xiaomi the dove i want to bring in the daw and that also says so we have two somakhs both by and not by so how do we know that by hover you have to do smith or maybe you don't honey torah says that you have to bring these karbalas to the visa that's not a voluntary oil and the illah that of allah is kamish but like the laws that we have what does kimishba mean so we must say like the laws we have by the allah and we're going to prove that it goes says no it doesn't go according to it goes according to everybody what's this big proof that goes only according to java don't learn oh as amazon is going to explain that's rashi explaining what you're going to say you cannot learn out on the government from michael una dava comes every single day in the mesa almost beside shabbat let's say but six out of seven days there's always a carbon xiaomi cheva comes in yandere special occasions so you cannot learn save xiaomi one from the other they're very different okay a smarter to be macholic now the ebay silo we saw in our mishnah right we just learned the mishnah and a few tests that what the according to basil you do smith why in the world do they say they have to do smith on a yantha like suckers because they must be learning out a a slum that you have to bring on sugars from him that you just bring voluntary and that we saw the pasta the valentine it says it talks about and then says okay they must be learning it like that and the gemara and the mascot is going to say no that's not how they learned you made a mistake if you compare basil compare a xiaomi nadava to sham mikhaila sorry dava and therefore they can learn that they're equal and they both require smith but besides different than the dava one is more frequent than the other so you cannot learn one from the other so according to there's no smith on sukis when you bring that kiyo of your xiaomi and according to me so there is so sorry or whatever this bryce is i think the big this bryce is a bishama you know why because according to basilo there's no need to bring a word kamishbat i just learned out one eyela from the other eye law just like i learned once from nadav so i learned from dava and that we saw in the first passage that this is the mephorus by aila this is so i take the chava and learn it from here why does it say that i learned that from the word kamishbot obviously it doesn't go according to be still it goes according to vishamai you shall be saying you need a special apostle says okay i made a little chart here i think i printed it you're saying that we go from the black to the green i'm learning from the dava no maybe he learned xiaomi and how do i learn allah from kamishbak in other words even basil will agree that i need the word kimishbat so this bracelet that says kimishba that i learn uh that doesn't say in the position anywhere that we have to lean on the head the prices i learned from the word kamish but maybe it goes even according to basil not be shaman maybe even basil will agree that there's no way you could learn regular slam him that's a kaiva from the davao why because one is very frequent one is not frequent um what are you telling me you can't go this way you can't learn that from that why she came to you one is freaking one is not like so then you can't go downwards you cannot learn him from my isla allah is a car being put completely on the mizbayakin you get to eat half of it or most of it this is tomorrow hello whatever the word is so i'm going to save you all the pain and aggravation very very positive if you ask me that shlomim is matsui it's very very common i'm going to tell you no asymmetry means i'm going to learn from the combination of shlom and manolo so no matter where you ask me a question from i have an answer what are you gonna what are you gonna tell me is different you cannot learn out a slum from the dava because one is very frequent well guess what isn't and you have to and you bring how do you know from kamishba you're gonna tell me our law is is burned completely under misbehave and that's why it's different xiaomi and the dover are not burned completely and you do smile the bottom line is i'm just telling you the whole rash of alpha bottom line is satellite both oila and have one thing in two things in common first of all you have to bring wine with it nusam castel second of all you have to do smirk so mella anything that you bring wine and you you'd have to do samika anything so i'm learning a combination of shlamim and oil to teach us of chiva but you don't have to do it immediately before the shrita so please do it perviantif do it 24 hours prior lean on it prepare it get it ready there's no reason to do it on youtube because you're using an animal i want to be not supposed to use an animal to do it the day before what's up sarah you need to do it immediately before fine says gemara okay so what are you telling me that you you thought i say you don't have to do smith you bring me a ruby i see that says you do have to do something guess what there's somebody else that holds like you also you don't have to smile so don't bring me away from me i see who da marcus another bic but this time it's a different reality the son of a review though i'll take it everybody agrees that you have to do smith immediately prior to this you can't do it do you do sweetheart in our mishnah an incredible story really incredible story that we can learn a lot and bring it into our lives we're talking about hillary zakin hello zakiyan was the nazi of khloe israel the greatest man alive whatever he said went listen to the story myself himself brings a little silla a male sheep why because when you bring in allah must be a male so he brings the the male sheep and he's about to perform smith on it to lean on it with all his might cover all of tamil of course the talmudim show up the the kanayim from the other side from stamina and they're there at the right time in the right place they show up and they start championing the galadar they also have their goddaughter shamai and hill and what are you doing rebbe [Music] what do you think you're doing what do you what is this for omar allahi and he tried to expose he's showing them here look it's in the caver they're not going to look but he started grabbing the tail so they should see that it's in the cave if it wasn't in the cave zachary they didn't look they believed him says rashi the bottom bottom line he was such an honor he was the goddard he could have passed on his path get out of here he didn't want to get into an argument he didn't want him to fight with him so he lied he pushed a lie and he said i'm bringing the cava i'm bringing islam two lies not one two lines it's it's it's an argument against his own and tired that's that's even worse and the the this is i think there's a tightness on him i'm not sure but you have to be it's not to say that when it comes to allah you should do it hilo was on a certain andrea he did it if i cared he held a certain way you don't say yeah yeah yeah this is right yeah maybe you do but la maisie he could have at the end of the day he could have just said guys you know what you're talking about i passed michael you know he didn't want to he didn't want to bother them he wanted to just get out of there so there's a big shield the civic has seen him says you could only do it question let's say you don't want to lend somebody money are you allowed to tell them i don't have money don't have money you allowed to do that but they have shawn she shouldn't get mad at you you can tell them i don't trust you you last time you didn't return the money to me or my neighbor told me you go around asking everybody for money you never give it back or you say i'm sorry i i i fell on hard times make up a miso you let it do that so some say you know you cannot do so because it's in the future for i see we're running late er most argue on him they bring rise from our gemara that even it didn't happen yet you're allowed to lie okay fine but you see this idea of lying who did it with avraham avinu and sarah he says brahmaviro said he's all didn't say you're old you lied international i'm fine i'll be silent that day bishamai were stronger than me and because they were bigger and stronger they decided to make that like beshama you know i don't know if you ever play basketball you play basketball on the the other team screams foul not a foul not a foul and if there's one guy from the other team that says no no no i saw and that's it checkmate there's no argument the other guy says the other talbot from the the other side says no hilo is right above and buddhism are famous a lot of stories about him a lot this is some famous one in babavasara shalom he knew that was like this he brought the better the best of the best animals and he put them says twices and higher values not in that zone you can't bring bazara they weren't they weren't they weren't a carbon yet and nazar involvement and he said call me sure to listen i'm telling you guys here take these animals do smith to my song and they decide i was like and nobody said a word we just turned to the base sponsored by the whitetail group for all those initiatives oh yeah very good point i like it a lot he won the argument they not only did he win the argument he was trying to point out that he almost lost argument he should have lost the argument because there's more than they were they were going to be covered for life couldn't change it but something happened and there was a flip within and they were able to to make that why because he wanted peace he did something for the peace i mean if you think about it it's an incredible story the power he had he was the most powerful man in claudia's role he could have been a second said you know what you're talking about get out of here but the guy would have been upset and he said what do you mean rebbi so you should shut up but he said it and he took his words and he yelled right back at him he said and he said it almost it almost rhymes like you see in a lot of fights you could you could win arguing maybe i've never tried it but usually what happens is two kids fighting at home so one kid gives a patch to the other one if the other one would just return the patch it's very possible the fight would be over we usually add like 20 percent this is instead of patching him a punch a punch you give a kick and before he chokes him out that hospital holds up but you can de-escalate it if all fights you cursed me said shut up shut up but if you use a worse and in this that's how the fights are going so you see from away for sure gemara here's the not nice lotion he said just tell him and then the fight's over what do you say you are more it's you poor honey baby it starts okay fine time try it at home try it i'm not going to try it but you guys can try it tanya i'm big into revenge at least ten twenty percent hundred fifty percent more um so now they still say listen you don't wanna buy into my shot i have a puzzle i'm showing you that i'm right but what about logic let's use logic um [Music] you know how to cook meat on chopstick and i'll do you know an animal shabbos but you're allowed to bring it on the base of me so certainly you should be able to bring it to them as baeach is svara on shabbos you know how to cook at home where you like to cook in the miz in the basement so if the atlanta cook at home certainly you should be able to bring carbonas in the base amigos don't you agree that you cannot bring a on the dava stammer a voluntary carbon chamber vasoligo but you cannot bring in the dava on yantef you agree to that nobody's arguing soon we'll see that they do argue but according to this they still say you cannot bring on the dove in you know why we hold according to this shout out in the gemara you can't bring in the dava because you can bring it tomorrow there's no need to bring it now in yantef when you're hungry at home i need a shaktaryan but on the dava bring your animal in a week from now bring it two weeks wait until you understand where the khala mayan to bring acha giga on the first deviantart video on the background so you can bring it you can bring it the entire the entire yantef there's no it's not no that's considered that it has a very very specific time very limited time it's not why if you forget to bring it then you can never bring it again so it's a big loss big loss i i want to bring it dafgo on the first day because what happens i go on a halloween trip with my family and i forget to do the daf i mean i forget to to to bring the carbon i get messed up how mighty messes everybody up right everybody going on these trips besides the aussie billiard he has to send it back home and do the videos don't be sad it's a beautiful thing i'm not either going anywhere me you'll hang out together my m i have a right from the torah that you're wrong you can only check for yourself not for hakushi not foreign so we go back to this possum the passing that we learned from um look have a little club if you have a dog rahman it's not i don't know anybody like that what if you have a fashion a dog kuflam i'm kidding because i have one the new guy doesn't have that i'm joking around he's getting nervous we have a dog that's what i'm saying okay yeah uh i almost got it yeah wow we have a cuff my brother comes to showers he goes where's the kuflam vase the whole shabbos p-i-g kovalev you won't even say the name chef anyante for your dog you can't do it fine says gemara you're not going to believe this abhishel literally if you look at it it looks identical to what we just said the same exact logic hold on because we're late same logic but it's very different that what and he says um here's akira and the time of the gemara stove and timing gemara so if it's closed the tap is completely closed in other words i'm not allowed to click on it on chavis st curious wrap up nevertheless your rebbe's stove is open who's miss back is ready for business you're allowed to bring your commitment he already bring a muslim right so far it's identical to before if your stove oven top is open and available on yante what you should have all the good meat and your rebbe's table is empty there's no carbanas doesn't make any sense what's the difference though guess what the gemara over here doesn't bring you bashami savara it doesn't say oh but you you admit that the dharmian and davis are us it doesn't say it here it's end this is the end of the story obviously i have a show holds that according to basil you're allowed to bring the dharma davis that's why bishop i never answered that before we would say mishami said look this is there's a on the dava that you agree that you cannot bring on yantev uh according to your logic you should be able to bring it but now it doesn't work because according to me still you could bring in the dawah so they don't have that argument but michael midley said then what's the difference between abhishel and the titanic the same exact same sparrow same kind of climber you could bring another and that's why bishop i never answered him and queen beyonce that even basil agree that the word hashem means everything um i'm sorry that's before myself in korean beyond if you don't you cannot bring uh the dava on youtube that's why bishop argued her boy said once again matsuyantev at 9 30 here have a great yanteff we'll see you then you