Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Daf Yomi Bechoros Daf 28 by R' Eli Stefansky
1,859 views
Thanks for learning with us! - Good Morning - MDYsponsor.com - 27B - 28A - 28B - Have A Wonderful Shabbos Support the Shiur: MDYsponsor.com Where to Watch & Listen Find us on your favorite platform: https://mdydaf.com/learn#platforms US: 605-562-0066 Israel: 055-DAF-YOMI (055-323-9664) UK: 03-333-661-463 Belgium: 0480-201-272 #DafYomi #EliStefansky #Bechoros #MDY
Chapters
Featuring:Daf Yomi
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Good morning.
So, we are we have over here a brand new
location in
byashan.
>> So in the most northern part of
Lunashan, we're opening up our 46th or
47th.
>> Oh, that's actually
>> we went down.
>> Oh, they took three and they put them
together. Okay. But anyways, we were
just discussing here in the before she
started. How do we get more satellite
locations in America for brahas thinking
about brahas and maybe the idea was to
change the time of the year and if
anybody has any kind of suggestion I
want to hear it cuz now we're starting
to work in that kind of stuff. Here it
is in
we have with us two tremendous guests.
We have a bunch of guests but two I want
to talk about. We have Doe Farcus from
Australia,
the famous Doof Farcus, the Kazen over
there in Melbourne. Y Melbourne. And
with them, we have a very, very big
surprise guest. His brother.
Now, why is it a big surprise? Because
doing the D with us almost entire shas
and he lives here in. And this is his
first time here in the Bush.
>> We're not going to say anything. It's a
cuz it's like a I'm it's like a I'm
super happy that he's here and super
interested. How come he wasn't there
until now? But anyway, I'm very very
excited.
>> Thank you.
>> Thanks for being M from where did you
start? All the way in
>> Bro.
Oh, the two of you together.
>> You're both on the cruise.
>> Wow. Wait a minute. So maybe this is a
whole farce. Really? It's you and you
just tried to slap your brother in the
cruise. Prove it. Prove it.
>> He's got videos. I got a bit you you
quoted me in one of your
>> really
I quot you that what
>> and I gave it over in my
>> Yeah,
>> it was beautiful. He shouldn't be
jealous to just of the car.
>> Oh, yeah. The old
>> and then you said in the sh Oh, this guy
in Tel Aiv said that I told you said it
beautifully. So,
So, I want to tell you something. I just
noticed something I've never seen
before. You know, in stadiums, people
raise up stuff to like show, "Hey, it's
my birthday."
>> A guy right behind you just raised up
something. I'm not making this up. He
raised up something. He said, "Hi,
Edison. I'm here." So, you want to show
it? What do you got?
>> Raise it up. Don't give it now. Raise it
up.
But you know what? Since you did it,
since you did it, I got to tell you
something. Listen to this boy. He did a
bigass with us. Big big on the bottom of
these chairs. Wa! Mine fell off already.
But he bought from some online place. We
couldn't figure out. There's so much
noise in the He figured it out. Here,
let me just get a regular chair.
Regular people
>> here. These guys. And this saved the
day. And he goes, "Just yesterday I saw
a picture of him putting them on." I
didn't know who it was until yesterday
from yesterday. Figured out that it's
him. These these rubber things. You got
to tell cheermarket.com that these are
available.
>> But oh, so anyways, it all comes
together.
>> It's fine. Okay. So, please don't raise
things. This is not a stadium over here
and I'm not going to sign it. This is
not a sport thing. This is a shar. This
is a shar. Hi, mom. I'm here.
>> My voice said, "Listen, a 1,000 Listen
to
the This This donor didn't realize that
it's going to What happened?
It might wake some people up here. I
just get up. Let's see you do it.
Dr. Epstein, you're supposed to be part
of the wave, not watching it on the
screen. Let's fine. Anyway,
this this thing is incredible. One donor
one donor already is in it for 1,43
sets.
>> It's going to cost him way over
$150,000.
>> I tried it. Sold out.
>> It says sold out, but I think I don't
know. We have to ask. We have to sold
out here in this row. Cuz over here we
have like 200 sets or something and
that's all they have in in stock or
whatever. But in America it's going out.
Let me show you how it looks in Yosi
Klein's in in our headquarters coming to
pick up all
>> has already the labels.
So many orders going out. It's crazy.
And they're waiting for stickers that's
going to be printed right now. And this
palette is going out.
>> Make your own MDY edition. It cost us
$10 million to save $1,000.
>> Here they go with the whole there.
Instead of doing plumbing, these are all
plumbers, right? He takes his plumbers
off the job and he says,
"All right, because we started late
there's a very long a very long email
from this from this ber. He's 20 years
old. He's a sat.
He's um he's paralyzed in his entire
body. But he could uh he communicates
with his eyes and he writes letters and
stuff. He wrote me a email but I can't
read it right now. It's very long. Him
and his and his rebi he says that it's
him and he watches it a few times a day.
But let me just real quickly I want to
show you this email.
Dear belly, you changed my life is a
phrase heard nearly daily in this year
and it never gets old. Not shak
something shak shake shak okay
>> right shak shak your shir has turned
people into better husbands parents I've
been part of this is the first time I
received the email like this it's very
interesting email I've been part of MD
since I'm proud member of you have
changed my life club in a rather unique
way you mentioned this year some time
ago that fining rules that messer isn't
only about giving money to this duck it
also refers to time we must donate a
portion of our day to share Torah with
others inspired by this and by watching
you live it out daily. I carved out a
portrait of my day to set out to write a
safer something I never would have
dreamed of without your as a
contribution to the safer dives into one
of the most perplexing and baffling eras
of one that you mentioned in there are
numerous instances which seemingly
misquer
but apparently their version of the
wasn't identical to ours you pointed
this out and called it super interesting
very bothersome and unbelievable
dess and also daf
Lammed Xan B MDY time 53 minutes in and
25 minutes in. This leads the
foundational question which the sat
explores are the words and letters of
identical to those given by Miru. The
answer will amaze most people and
reveals a dramatic backstory of how the
Tyra's text survived thousands of years
of gullless leading to deep appreciation
of the Tyra we possess rebell humble
though you won't admit it
but the MD is well aware of the many
nine months later consider the safer the
latest one its birth is fully credited
to your inspiration impact your Here's a
safe for everybody's sight it's
unbelievable
do you have who's where is he our the
guy that publishes from Z. What's his
name? Don Don Cornbl. Yeah.
>> Wow.
>> Here. Big safer.
>> Wow.
>> Inspired by the share.
>> Incredible.
>> First time.
>> Beautiful.
>> Uh, Rebelli, please accept the this copy
of Ara, your child, your child as a gift
of appreciation.
Very my children have been so influenced
by your enthusiasm, your gifts for
making learning and that she has
incredible visuals that they've
completed many with you. In particular,
my son Yol now 13 has been learning the
D with you every single day since we met
since we met see more than 3 years ago.
The I have of this is even more special
than the safer and my son influencing
recruiters also while rebell have
keeping and elevating one day at a time
>> shak.
Oh,
>> you have a gift.
>> A gift.
Now is a good time to give the gift.
Thank you.
>> Liquor liquor chocolate.
So is it it's good and it's also from
Kristier? No, this keeps the white
>> think it and you think you're in
Krister.
>> Ah
does this keep the mice away. What's
this ghoul over here?
>> I wanted to thank you. I served in
September 7.
>> Where?
>> Oh wow.
>> Yeah.
>> And tried to take me
and you get it back.
>> Wow.
Yeah, thank you.
Appreciate it.
Wow,
they make it over there. What's the
story? It's just called
>> Had founded the expensive liquor store.
Appreciate it.
>> Um, here's here's Shet. Here's Shet with
his shaket. He's going to kill me for
butchering. Shak shacking his name.
>> Wow. Bell Works.
>> Oh, Bell. Yeah, that's Bell Works. Join
the nightly share base. What is this?
>> Oh. Oh. Oh.
>> Oh, this is Miami.
>> This next
Miami.
>> And here we go.
>> It looks like David's son over here.
I'm showing you everything together. Oh,
>> guest speaker Rabbi Avi Bourbon. Uncle
Phil receptive review in the Gimar
forum. Remember Uncle Phil did a whole
thing in Yuma
Rosenberg says the Hajin lead was his
father. Ah, I wasn't even aware of this.
Tell me afterwards. 2 and a2 years ago
when I started doing the dot
um I was
very inspired
watch
>> okay yeah we got a oh it's 7:40 already
okay let's go
>> if anybody wants more than400 people
signed up who would believe it's look
mish like uh like the initiative
somebody had an idea and it went out of
control. It went a above and beyond our
wildest imaginations.
And uh I spoke to the donor yesterday
and he said he's more than happy. He
thought it's going to be a couple
hundred but now it's 1,400. Hashem gave
him money for a reason. Hashem is the
kids are a whole thing and he's very
happy to do this
is sponsored by Nathan Kamyk per honor
rebellion. May the name of the white
people in honor of my father
Miriam something like that dedicated
memory of
the spons
found Foundation gratitude to Yasi Kle
Marinazi and Benny Rdnik for all you do
for MDY plenty of money gratitude all
MDY
of anonymous
in honor of the family.
the Spanish
in honor of the Yhen
Benish
mayor 10-year-old boy from Nif
I don't know what can we do what how can
we be better that kids don't light fires
in the middle of the street they act
with a little bit more safety and
caution. What do we do? We got to do
something. It can't can't continue like
this. Nathan Kamyki LLP afraid of
simbas.
You got to open up an organization to
awareness to parents. Helmets on
corkinets. They're going literally 70
mph without helmets on these little
flimsy things that I know's son fell off
of it and he's a married guy
>> and he needed surgery
>> wearing a helmet.
>> Safety. Safety. There there's like we're
we're 10 years behind America, maybe 20.
Who lights fires in the middle of a
neighborhood? Why? What's
freedom? Nothing. OBM on our fourth yard
site followers anonymous
in honor of MDY.com/y
sponsors
and our kids too.
We're trying to figure out how do we
know that
is eaten within its birthday year. How
do we know that? Sarah says because it
says in the P sh it's his year. It goes
from the day of his birth to till his
birthday. That's where you have to eat
him.
The problem is the ve some are gurus
rebi but in the yeshiva rav they kind of
argue rav himself and they say that that
that only comes to teach us the concept
that you can eat a bar for two days and
a night there's there like and not we'll
see like not like that it's one day and
one night
I'm not exactly sure where we stopped
off yesterday
So another
fine that it's the year of the
if the are using the for two days and a
night they take away the pik from rav to
learn that of two days in a night. Rav
is using that P to tell us that it has
to be the year in within his year, not
the calendar year, the Bkar's year. From
the day he's born, he has a year. So how
does Rav know this for two days in a
night?
It's a we say it's similar to
you get to eat for two days in a night.
So is two days and a night.
How come the learns
the teachers? How come they can't learn
out from where Raph just learned? You
learn it. You compare it to the answer
is you can't compare it to according to
listen I'm comparing to a different
carbon. Who told you which carbon to
compare it to? If you had two options to
compare this and what you could eat the
for one day in a night or two days in a
night, which one would you go for?
>> Two.
>> Why two? I would go for one.
Grab whatever you can. The minimum. You
don't go for the maximum.
There's things there's rules in the what
you do. If you have two options, two or
one, you go with the one. That's the
more solid way to go. So, you go with
the you only eat for one day and one
night.
You're right. You should only go for
one. But it says gives you a little
extra, a little more. One more day. Gets
one more day.
There's a tremendous here. Why is it
tremendous?
We never found anything similar to this
in the entire what that you're supposed
to give something to to but if it's no
good you give it to the
we don't have anything like that. If it
if it doesn't have a you give it to the
k get if it has a you still give it to
the ken. We don't have anything like
that. Usually if it has a you sell it
you do you start over you give the a
says
plural
stays to teach us that you get extra day
and the fact that the gets a because it
says you should get two types. The guy
gets two types. Either a healthy
unblenmished animal or a blemished
animal.
And this is the end of the
is not referring to two different types
of animals a blemish and unblenmished.
It's referring to all the carbonas in
all the in plural. It's not just your
private one. It's all that's what it's
going to say.
I want to make a confession here. It's
an embarrassing confession but it'll be
a toll for the tabor I spoke about
pushed push pushed before bacious
and um unfortunately I fell in bacius d
bay I fell
I did I had the and this and the
learning wasn't so good and certainly
the the first thing that went was the
but I'm strong as ever I'm holding my
shishi already I'm good I did half the
parish in so I want to tell if you
didn't start yet or you fell in batious
join me I'm starting in and I wrote down
in my that I missed half the par and I
hope to make it up before before next
year maybe this week I'll have time I
don't know but I'm starting in so I'm
reminding if you didn't start mikro you
could always start it doesn't have to be
complete It's like daffi. If you fall,
you fall. All right. That's my That's my
piece. It's embarrassing. I'm pushing
everybody tell you to do it. And I
myself fell. Okay.
>> Correct.
is a big
boy
is a big
no no
says in the Mishna.
Now let me show you the because it's
very interesting. This is the Mishna.
If this animal developed a m in its
first year,
he's permitted to keep it for 12 months.
There could be a comma there or there
could be a period there. It could be the
end of the phrase and then there's a
brand new phrase in our Mishna. There's
no parenthesis. the bar line where I got
this from puts parenthesis and he takes
it from the the B or someone on the side
over there. I see in the gimbal. There's
a gimmel here. They take it out. Now,
they take it out based on what we're
about to read now and learn. Now, is
there a new statement
that
if the blemish occurred after 12 months
you get 30 days? What's the 30 days? is
the 30 days if the blemish happened
after 12 months or perhaps it's one long
statement and that is when a blemish
occurs we give you a freebie we give you
30 days regardless if it's a middle of
the year after the year you always get
30 days an extra period of 30 days and
the Gar is going to explain why why
should you get a freebie why should you
get extra 30 days the answer is because
sometimes there's no cayenne around
we had a few days here last week no
cayenne very it's it's sad Americans
come their guests here and no co you say
the same you know they they get all
Americans get all excited even during
the week they bring their kid they they
put the kid under the towers you know
it's a whole thing the first time I ever
saw this shabas I saw two bak in
children bring smoozing like it's the
first time in my life I ever saw it but
uh some you don't have a kite you don't
have a kite
so
you don't want the in in those days no
refrigeration no freezer you animal the
clock starts ticking. You have a few
hours, that's it. A day, two days, and
then it it goes bad. You have to salt it
and it's not the same. So that's the
what did the mean?
If the blemish developed within its
first year of life, so you get to keep
it up to its birthday.
And it's one long statement and
therefore you get extra 30 days.
If it was developed
maybe it's two statements. So if it was
developed within the first year you get
up until this birthday. If it was
developed after the year then you we add
another 30 days.
illustration.
So then the question is what does means
either
the the
when did the mum occur or means the 30
days is the words mean you get an extra
day 30 days or does it mean the mum
developed after 30 days? It's a way to
learn this whole statement. Is it one
long statement or two statements?
If you have a unblenmished firstborn in
our days where there's no
and there was no reason to bring it to
the because it had no blemish.
You got to keep it. You keep on keeping
it two three years
once it develops a blemish.
Depends when the blemish happened. If
the blemish happened in its first year,
you keep it for 12 months.
And after
the year, you can't even keep it for a
minute, an hour.
So that the
doesn't lose out over here.
You're permitted to keep it for 30 days.
You see that even and this this
statement is going the Gar doesn't know
in a second the is going to ask but the
Gar understands for now that this
statement is going even if the m
occurred within the first year you get
30 days after the year is over. You get
an extra 30 days and you might right
away ask. Let's see. He did a whole
thing so might as well show it. Hold on.
That's cute. If here if you have a m
within the year, e copy your solution.
Let's say the m happened within the the
first year. So you get to keep it just
until the end of the year.
But if the if it occurred after the
year, then you get 30 days. Okay? And
then the gar says, what does it mean? Do
you get 30 days within the first year or
only after the year?
So over here it said we just this is
what we just learned that what that if
the the m occurred after the year is
over you don't even get one minute 1
hour
but
we did give you 30 days. Why says
maybe it should be a little larger.
the meat will go bad.
But the Gumar says, but I don't
understand it's still we still didn't
explain is the 30 days referring to
within if it happened the first year or
if the happened afterwards
that we didn't explain. So now for that
we have another thing. Hold on.
Did the m occur
after the year or the occur before? When
do you get the 30 days? When's the do
you always get the 30 days or not?
Even though there's no
>> Yeah, that's what that's what he was
referring to. I guess that's what you're
trying to
>> moment of so
like on this chart his mom developed 15
days before the end of the year. The end
of the year I just I because I just told
this to somebody and it just hit my
head. I I bought we had a Toyota Sienna
in Chicago. So I bought an extended
warranty.
Extended warranty. I don't know what it
is. Another two years or something. The
day after the extended warranty was
over,
the first sliding door broke
the motor and that cost a few thousand
dollars to repair. And then two weeks
later, the second one mish the day after
I can't you can't even anyway. So over
here the m when did the mamish the last
minute of the year. So if it happens
within the year you get you start the
clock starts ticking from that moment
like over here in this picture. So you
get all the way to 15 days into the next
year. What do you see from here? You
don't get 30 days. You don't get a 30
day uh no matter what 30 days into the
next year. I if it would happen
um 29 days before the end of the year,
you would get one day in the next year.
If it would happen one day before the
end of the year, you get 29 into the new
year. But you never get a 30-day. It's
not a freebie.
You only get 15 days in the next year in
this particular case. But you see from
here that the 30 days is not a given
day. You just get it for freezer.
So now we're going to see two ribbons.
This is a right to one. The what?
The clock starts ticking from the moment
he gets a so 15 days before the end of
the year. He has 15 days in this year,
15 days in the next year. You don't get
30 full days in the next year.
But there's that says the exact
opposite.
He gets 30 days according to the next
year in the following year.
No matter what,
even if the the the mum happened two two
months before the end of the year, his
birthday, two months before his
birthday, when his birthday comes, he
gets another 30 days.
Seems like two years. You go into the
second year. You don't give him a full
year.
We see brings down for if a tree was
planted 30 days before, it's considered
a full year. It's its first year of our
you start counting. Oh, comes it's
another year.
You're 30 days into the next year.
So now we're going to just ask the
question that we just said.
If he developed a blemish 15 days before
the end of the year, we give him those
15 days till the end of the year plus 15
days. But we don't give him 30 days like
just said
you don't give him a fresh 30 days.
It's a bomb. Great brand new suga.
So what happens? You have a newborn or
firstborn. You give it to the kite. The
kite we said you have to you have to
bring it up for 30 days, 50 days,
whatever you have to do. And then you
give it to the kite.
What if it developed a m? So if it
didn't develop a m, the kind has to
bring to the to the b mikdash and then
eat the parts that he could eat, etc. If
it developed a m, it's much better for
the k. He doesn't have to go all the way
from where he lives all the way to it's
who knows a 30-day trip in those days on
a camel on a donkey and shleing a little
goat with him. You can shift in his
backyard and eat it. So obviously every
k wants to have a m wants to make sure
it has a m and then you know that's
create a m etc. But what does this guy
do?
He does and then he asks questions later
first he
then he brings the the dead animal to
says can you please check this out for
me is this a m or not
and he shows the after the animal's dead
the m listen a m is a the rabbit can see
it's missing a leg so of course it's who
cares that it
seems like a kas we're punishing him. He
didn't go to the rabbi. Boom. Aer. So
what's the concern? We're going to sing
in the gimbar. What's the problem?
If you're not a professional and you
tell the the
go ahead or the go ahead and you tell
the it's good. You're allowed to right
now. You don't have to bring this is a
terrible terrible blemish. You're not a
doctor. You're not a vet. What are you
doing?
cover. We have to bury it like a regular
that dies.
This is must pay from his pocket.
>> Oh,
it's much more than that.
>> No, no, we're going to see. No,
>> discuss it.
says the
yeah I'm going to show the video later
when we're talking about a cataract
that's very very problematic we know
cataract is the the the easiest of all
the m but it's a very very big problem
why because when an animal is dying in
the throws how do you say the thrones
throws of death
>> I don't know what happens some vessels
some blood vessels burst in his eye. If
he started out with a small cataract,
the rabbi would say it's not a big deal.
It's not a mum because he's dying and
he's suffering and goes crazy. His eye,
you know, you could look at it, look at
the eyes, they go like this. You know,
it'll burst. It'll grow. The cataract
will grow.
So, that's a big problem.
Can't say, "Oh, I saw look look at this
cataract right now." Take him to to
optometrist and they'll look at the at
the animal eye. They'll see there's a
cataract. Oh, so it was a good No, it
grew double after it died as it was
dying
because they changed.
The whole concern is a real M in the
body. Let's say a severed limb that
didn't happen after it died. That's
obvious. You see it's all healed and
everything
since cataracts is such a problem. So if
somebody's not mb and he does his own
without a professional
he this animal based on his own we're
going to punish him and give him a why
because he'll come to do the same thing
with cataracts
it's interesting brings down over here
that usually is like your mayor but in
this case is not like because it's and
in we don't pass like mayor
says there's no concern over here.
There's no reason. Everybody knows
that uh that is different. Cataracts are
different.
An animal afterwards you show after
after he dies he show the to
professional
because eyes change. Now it's known that
the eyes are the the window to the soul
so to speak. You look in somebody's
eyes, you see that he has he has you
look in a person you see he's like he's
half dead. So the over here says that
the eyes could change. How could the
eyes change? You see a guy that his eyes
are
garnished and then his eyes are like lit
up
cuz he started doing the dab.
But in a guy has a separate leg. It's
not it's not it's not changing one iota
after death.
It doesn't matter what kind of cataracts
or regular in the body
because they all change. What are you
talking about?
If a guy if this if this this animal has
one leg missing it's not going to change
for the worse the better
because there is one m that changes
called a cataract and therefore all m
suffer because of that one m called a
cataract because we cannot rely on what
you saw before the death of the animal
in a cataract and therefore in all mso
I can prove from our mission.
It says
he says he doesn't say because it
changes it or doesn't change. He says
because you didn't go there. That's a
punishment. That's a
not because
it actually changed and it's different.
No, it's a
Nathan
Freda Nathan OBM. I remember saying this
OBM's mother on a fourth yard
global expert in international financial
services.
Thank you. Steven Schwarz parents
million J Schwarz. I should really
should have shown this earlier. Here we
go. This is our production. We did it a
while ago, but it's layer. You got to
see this. Look at the ostriches. The
different female and male all the way
over.
Heat
up here.
I would Gambler.
When Rome says that cataracts could
change. Does he mean that 100% of
cataracts change after death or during
death
or is it like 50/50?
What's the difference
to say that the witnesses are lying?
If 100% of the cataracts change the fact
that they're coming now and saying that,
oh, this is what they saw before it
died, it's a lie because every cataract
changes.
But if sometimes it changes, sometimes
it doesn't.
We can rely on them. Here's the video.
Boom.
They can walk through gates in this
video easily.
Why didn't you show me before?
>> It was exactly like this.
So if every single one changes then
there if not we could rely on them.
They're not lying. It doesn't mean that
they deliberately lie. Just they they
don't know.
Let me show you a case of cataracts that
change after death.
Why is he showing it to him? Because
some do, some don't. I want to show you
a case that does.
uh a layman has no business mixing in
two things that have to do with
veterinarians.
He's he's passing Allah on Amum
and because of him the owner the the the
the went ahead and she this animal and
we say he can't use it anymore. He has
to bury it. So he caused him a great
damage
because he opened his mouth and he mixed
into something he shouldn't have. He
should have told him go to the pro. I
don't even know if it's the RV. We said
he could go to a pro, right? I guess he
could go. I I'm not passing it.
>> The person who knows
>> person knows in that thing.
>> That's right. You don't have people who
don't know.
>> So he doesn't know. Is that a hint?
>> It's clear.
>> Who knows?
>> Person knows.
>> Those who But we don't know who knows.
That's the problem. We have to ask
somebody who knows. Who knows? We don't
know who knows. Who knows?
>> Those who don't know. Yeah.
>> Okay. The the people that didn't watch
the weren't here before the show have no
idea what we're talking about.
So this guy that doesn't know is going
to have to pay from his own pocket.
This is goes like the says that even if
there's a a real blemish you see he's
missing a leg the animal's missing a leg
and you without going to pro you got to
bury it you can't but he has a real mom
no regardless
says no
everybody agrees when it comes to
cataracts that you can't rely on
anything or the or the owner and
therefore you have to bury it
now
it says this unprofessional guy he has
to pay. How much does he have to pay?
Only 25% for a small animal
half for the large animal. Why half of
the large animal? Because if he really
has if this animal really had a serious
blemish, he just messed him up. He he
caused the cayenne to bury an animal
that any m would have said this is a
real blemish. And if he had a real
blemish, the guy would have eaten it.
Now you open your mouth, you advised
him, you shouldn't have advised him. And
now because of you, he has to bury a
perfectly good animal that he could have
eaten. So that's 100% damage. But on the
flip side, what if they would have gone
to a would have said, "No, no, no. You
can't chef now. Can't shel." So what do
you do? Wait for 5 years, 10 years, and
then the animal's going to drop dead and
you won't be able to eat him anyway.
there's a good chance that he didn't
cause any damage. So that's a 50/50.
That's a m and a multip. So you only pay
50%. So that we got to 50%. But why 25%.
Because the the smaller animal
is very small damage. So only 25%. What
does that mean? So says
a cow cost $2,000. You have to pay him
half of that. That's $1,000. A sheep
only cost $500. So he paid 25% of
that.$125. Where's What's the
I don't get it. $25 is not a You're just
going to give him off. Let him pay 250.
Why 125? Why a quarter of the value?
Since it's very difficult to bring up a
smaller animal also to bring him in, you
have to go outside to raise an animal.
You have to go to fire. The kids of the
cen has a lot a lot of t bringing up
this thing. It's not a great gift for
him. He has to take this goat and go all
the way out there and come back. So at
the end of the day, you didn't cause the
kind that much damage you and a smaller
animal cause him less than you think it
is because every day has to be bothered
by it. So now he doesn't have to be
bothered. So take that off the price. So
only 25%. Says the Mishna. I think for
me this is a tremendous kiss from
Hashem. Why? Because last shabas I was
in a hotel in your shabas. I said over
this story not knowing that within a
week we're going to be learning aes
and he said that somebody that's
and he says somebody that is potter
this is the case that happened to me on
chabas somebody what happened. I was in
charge of the alcohol. So, I brought the
wine and everything and I brought
liquor. I didn't have this liquor, but
we had some liquor. And
I I right before the meal, I opened up
the bottles to ear them out.
And one of the waiters, who's a non-Jew,
I I don't even know how he did it
because I was in stores where the the
cash register is an Arab and they won't
touch your wine. They say, "I can't do
it." You know, somebody else has to.
They now not even touch the battle.
>> Yeah. An Arab won't touch a bottle of
wine. It's like a duster for them. It's
like it's like a It's like a smartphone.
>> The Arab moved it literally. He went
like this.
Put it over there. It was open. So
there's a person there, a very person.
He says, he tells this son comes running
over. I'm talking to this person. Son
comes running. The waiter, the waiter,
just move the battle. He says, "Throw it
out right now." I said, "Whoa, time.
It's my battle. You're not throwing
anything out." He says, "I don't care if
it's your battle. It's We're throwing it
out right now. It's going to cause that.
Let's talk this out." What do you do? He
moved it from here to here. He didn't
pour it. You don't know what you're
talking about. It's You moved it. It's
open. Get it out. So then my son-in-law
comes around and my son-in-law asked me,
Mary Jacob, he says, "What are you
talking about? You didn't pour it." He
says, "I'll drink it. I'll drink it.
That's exactly why I'm pouring it out. I
don't want you to drink it. He tells the
song, "Pour it out." And the son runs to
the stink, pours out the whole bottle.
Now, you have to understand that he's
invited to my right. So, I like this
guy. Now, I don't like him anymore,
but I like him. And after is over, I
looked in the and I saw that he's wrong.
He's 100% wrong. Mom is wrong. Now, this
guy knows well, very well. People ask
him sh the whole thing. So he just made
a little boo boo over here that it's
it's if you move it with your finger or
pouring here's the
mom she talks about this case I'm I'm
I'm baffled by the people that are and
they ruin other people's
money monetary value
touching the
cloud How? Certainly not on somebody
else's bottle of wine. An expensive one.
Barashem. Literally, I I would have I
would have been in jail right now had he
touched my spilled out my $800 bottle
Castell. That would have been all over.
Game over. Bar. That one I took to my
table. Imagine. Oh, you got the Castell.
I would have gone crazy.
Fine.
He says it moves. It moves.
Sh back book. It's inside the battle.
Calli
if you didn't touch it with your finger.
It's m look it up.
>> Tell him.
>> I I tried to call him yesterday to ask
him what he's I don't know. He's he's a
big on. He's a big on.
>> Was he uh how much money he take any
money from him, but I want to call up
his son.
>> Tell his son. I want to mess with him a
little bit. You know, like say you owe
me for the and then tell him. But it's
really I went to I asked for a bottomir.
The son doesn't owe me. Even though the
son is 18, 19 years old, the son doesn't
owe me. The father owes because the
father pass.
>> No, the father it's it's you don't say
in this case all thing anyways. But what
the pel is that it happened this week
and it's a
mishna
team. It was worth the story. I don't
care how much the battle was. It was
worth the story.
>> That's why he
>> Yeah, maybe. Yeah.
Beautiful.
What happened? Happ happened here.
>> Thank you so much.
Your turn, buddy. Uh, I I'll be right
back.
Shalom. Kaboo. Can I ask a question? Of
course. That's what we're here for.
>> Do we need to smear blood on the
doorpost on Pesar?
>> Yes, you should smear blood on the
doorpost.
>> Thank you so much, Kabhar.
>> What do I do? I forgot to settle my
kidneys and now it's after the zombie.
is after this mom very serious shy you
grab it twice close it up close then
push it down the toilet immediately
close
>> what are you doing I forgot to sell my
kidneys so I'm flushing them
>> kidneys you don't have to flush them you
can just eat them
>> smell
>> what are you talking about the roof said
I didn't have to flush my
We need to pay for the Grand Dream. Who
doesn't check it?
>> What now?
>> Oh, maybe that's the guy from Supply
Dubai. You know, it's not
>> broken window. You have to pay 1,500
check to fix the window.
They make they make mistakes. That's the
all right
but if he's a professional from the best
he doesn't have to pay says
mayor
what happened there he didn't do
anything with his hands he told a guy he
has to pay he didn't do he didn't do it
he didn't do a there's a missing just
with his mouth he passing the wrong
he did do he did do something wrong. He
took the money from him and gave it to
him.
He told somebody that doesn't have to
pay somebody that really shouldn't have
to pay and he made him pay.
So, but it's bod what's meaning if the
RV takes the money from the guy that's
potter and gives it to the guy to the
other guy
he he shouldn't have to pay but he takes
the money out of him and makes him pay
that's he took the money
but what's the case where he said that
somebody that is potter how did What
happened with his hands? How did he do?
If he just said the words,
he didn't do anything physical.
The the malva, the lender had, how do
you say mashkin in English?
>> Collateral. He had collateral. And he
took the collateral away from him with
his hand. He grabbed the watch as a
collateral and gave it back to the to
the borrower. That's the physical
damage.
How do you take something that's and
make it
and that's literally what that person at
the did he wanted to prove make a point.
He wanted to say you can never use this
again. So in our case, he poured the
bottle of wine down the drain or over
here, he takes a sher and he makes
something that's makes tears to how do
you make something that
he mixed them up together?
Should we just do this quickly?
There was a cow that did not have a womb
that this is called a he's head off. He
shot it in the head. He killed it
without a and fed it to the dogs.
They said, "Wait a minute. It doesn't
have a womb. That's not a traifep."
>> Yeah.
comes from Alexandria.
>> We don't they they they come without a
womb and they live they live long years.
You see that it's not uh I didn't show
this video. This is a famous this is the
famous story of the it goes to the gar
before that for behemoth dhaka because
it's very hard to bring up a behemoth
daka. So you only get uh a quarter of
the thing here.
Aba, it's too crowded.
>> Maybe the Rav could advise.
>> Buy a goat.
Aba, the ox didn't bother anyone. Bring
him back in.
>> It's not helping
by a goat.
Finally.
So much room in here.
>> Buy a goat.
>> Yeah.
>> Who's my assistant?
>> No, it's from hundreds of years ago.
Thousand years ago.
>> Yeah.
>> Oh,
the famous saying,
you just lost the donkey. You're going
to have to pay with your own money. Now,
it's interesting because the retirement
was very, very wealthy. And it could be
>> tell your friend to put down the wine.
But it's interesting because sometime
maybe maybe the is he could have paid
him cash easy. He was very wealthy says
but he he had to sell his his beloved
car. He had to sell the and and pay with
the to make it to make a to say oh I
made a mistake. I'm not going to forget
this mistake again.
You're a professional.
Shalom. You don't have to pay. Goes into
it. Have a good Have a wonderful day.
Shab
>> at 9:00.
Merry close of spreading Torah
throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir
today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at
mdy.com.