Daf Yomi Bava Metzia Daf 80 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] I go rebid we're going to in L of emails we're gonna do the daff today I just want to show you a quick uh picture they asked me to speak of this place a few times I went there couldn't believe it it's like right down the block in me me shal um they have this uh K there what is it called again shiy Shifty or something pel whatever they do have to there on Thursday night it's gaka Place very very I didn't that this neighborhood so gak over there anyway somebody's looking for a great place to live it's more like Israeli Israeli they all speak English but more Israeli American all right we're going straight into the sponsors the only the little rush is because it's mavas and it's late and that there's another Shear coming up right afterwards at a quarter two so it doesn't give us a whole lot of time the anous for the safe and Speedy return of all the hostages you probably heard they rescued three baddies on Friday they rescued another BD on shabas or maybe it's the same time kids are four baddies there's only six of them ABA Renard my grandfather mayor sha Renard on his y [Music] site sh memory 36 y but who's MOA who's in ranana now we had him all right [Music] Rossman on his 10th yard Side by his family his alfeld great man a great families on amand my father Mo David Ben mois it said Ah that's how you read it okay we'll do it again my father moav moid Ben Mo no that can't be oh I know benev probably Mor jeski Mo Mor Jes and my brother shim Danel Ben should do it Simon jki were n on the same day 25 years apart do we have this last year we had I think we had something if not this one we had something similar because it's very familiar they n on the same day Father and Son 25 years [Music] apart we are holding and here's the question of the DAT what it's not a joke what weighs more a ton of feathers or a ton of metal what's the answer wrong wrong see the gar that you might be wrong says the I don't ask easy questions says the a person rents a cow the way it used to be you rent a cow you rent a machine lro to plow you rent something like this and you need two people to um to work the machine as such one guy is in charge the blade in front see that blade one guy is in charge of steering the Sheep the the Bulls the owner of the plow makes a deal with him you can only use it in the mountain which is harder shom which is harder on the blade more likely to get ruined he went to an easier place and the blade broke there so what's the he had permission to go Offroad and he drove on a regular nice highway so the is if the knife breaks Potter because he had the right to even do worse than that and did less what if he only had to go in the valley and he went and he plowed in the mountain which is harder on the blade then the rent would be instead of doing something really hard and dangerous for the animal he went and he only used the animal that he rented for wheat to thresh the wheat Potter it was damaged there say setting off people's series only yours Riv fall I mean but if he had R to do the easier one and he used the animal on a slippery surface like uh you have these two driver guys who is responsible yeah right after I'm driving with my mother-in-law in Brooklyn and my wife both in the car and actually I took a really sharp turn and my mother-in-law who's very small she went flying from the left side of the car she hit her head not what are you laughing she hit her head in the door anyways from there on she's screaming from the back be careful of this my wife is saying be careful of that you're going to hit this guy that guy and I I didn't I'm not the safest driver I was never accused so I I stopped the car I said listen you have to decide who's driving you mother-in-law or you the wife you have to make the decision here that's what happens when we have two people over here two people are driving this thing after mine after mine only after the you do things like that so who's responsible the guy directing the car the guy on the blade who is it the guy with the handles all the way in the back he's the guy that's he's directing the animal it's the guy the want that that that that's controlling the blade he has to pay soash here what's the gar is asking if they didn't CH like in other words the whole question of the gamar is if he was if they were told to go in the valley and they went in the valley and he he it's not his workers he rented a plow it comes with two workers so the asks which one of the workers is responsible the guy in the front the guy in the back and what if they did what if they did uh change they were told to go in the valley they went on top say at the end of the day the they want to please their their um their boss so they have a that's why the Govern didn't asking about that they want to please the boss whatever the boss says the boss always says customer comes first customer comes first we're talking about an America not this whole didn't happen customer comes first and therefore the guy says go in the go in a mountain when the boss said go in the valley you listen to the customer you do whatever said it just reminded me the story it's not so n here but I don't know if I said the story and if I did not very often I was in JFK I was waiting outside over there you know like you wait for people by the sidewalk where all the cars come by and they take passengers all of a sudden you hear like this screeching of the tires and this guy starts hitting this car that car he jumps onto the sidewalk between People hits all the wagons with the suitcases and plows right into a beam like a terrorist attack everybody starts running and screaming I was I was probably 19 years old then or something like that so I'm the only M that I run to the car every like don't run don't run I run to the car and what do I see I see a older from guy with a beard in complete shock he's just standing there looking straight ahead ask him he's okay this that his son comes out what happened was this guy this younger guy Parks double parked to Triple park the car you you know like you do in Kennedy you can't get up to so he tells his father who doesn't have a license sit over here and pretend you're the driver okay so cop comes they see a driver cop comes and tells him hey move your car now he was in alwiz this guy so cop talking to him and telling him order he didn't he didn't ask any questions he puts it in Drive pushes the gas hits a bunch of cars until he got stuck in the thing so the only reason I thought about is because you don't ask any cashes the guy says you you told not to but the customer says you do you go V that wasn't okay for it's good enough close so the guy in charge of the knife he has to pay if it's a place that's a lot of stones huh I didn't miss that then we can go for the video I'm asking I usually lose on those if it's a place with a lot of stones then they're both responsible they both pay a sh ask but let let the boss prove which one did it why should they both pay okay I love this one you buy a car okay you buy a car the guy tells you listen transmission is gone brakes are no good uh what else do we have air conditioning is garbage now it's the middle of the winter so you check brakes look fine everything just galic so you don't even bother looking at the transmission but the mice the trans transmission is no good so he hides it under all these lies he tells you four things that are no good three of them are good one of not listen it's a biter here we have a from from bakama we have all these uh why not we did it then it's one of these it uses Ken the Gores boom or I'm just thinking this kid he was he he sees a dog at the bus stop so he asked the guy he says does his dog bite she says no my dog doesn't bite so she goes and he he Pets the dog and the dog bites his hand she what you said your dog doesn't bite he says my dog doesn't bite it's not my dog be no gun's fine with that ashy gun's fine you guys know you guys make it up you have who that okay so we got all things he put all together he only had one moment puts it all together all the he lied why because you see there's no other M so you realize that's also not okay so you lied to him you fooled him he didn't look at the transmission because he looked at the brakes they're great the air condition is great everything's great so transmission is also stck and then in fact transmission is no good so but if you say transmission is no good you say transmission is no good plus it has another problem you don't say what the other problem is so the focus is on transmission go check the transmission also learned something similar servant to your friend your friend epilepsy everything she only has one little problem she's let's say she's deaf she's not M you look at her she's mmal so guy pulls over somebody doing 180 he pulls him over he says where's your license I don't have a license you have a Social Security no I don't have social what do you have I don't have anything so he calls the the sergeant comes down he says uh license he pulls out his license what's social he tells him social what so you didn't how when the guy asked he says oh and then you believe everything that guy says pretty soon he's going to say I was doing yeah but I will tell you another says like this so the same basically if he throws in a bunch of M he lies about a bunch and there's one in there you don't get the you say specifically she's de but she has another M then he should look into that deafness what if in fact she did have the four five M he described we say in that situation the guy's like I couldn't I can't I didn't believe that what he said is true he's hacking he's lying how I'm trying to buy and she he's telling me all the moment of this person I told you about my mother-in-law this I didn't even think it just came up when my father's trying to sell his house in ravia I was there present she's telling the future buyer all the C of the house you don't want to buy this house you know if your grandchild falls down the stairs Dead all these stairs are made out of stone it's like m no and then the leaks the leaks it turns out she didn't want to sell the house whatever and she was right because that house is M all right fine if she does have all those that's not considered he was open just cuz you thought he's lying doesn't mean anything says that no the is that I would think that since you said so many like that why should he what what else should he do you're asking when he's he's being too honest you can't be too honest but yeah you're right it's the same thing says T that if you say a bunch of M you say this girl has all these M and then it turns out that she only has one out of all those so so it's you're lying there was a sh told this guy guy was in for many years nothing so the sh says I have this girl she has this Milo this Milo this Milo all the mil in the world only one problem 10 minutes a year she's crazy think he says sounds like why not so could you read it she says yeah I'm G to have to wait though for those 10 minutes is that to marry you you have to be in a mishna state all right today is m is going well so we're going to go back there but this is a real a true no this is it's not it's not funny but it's more like for Israelis it's not it's not so much in English so I'm not going to tell you the myself says the Mish no no no it's [Music] not it's a true story there's there's even a little mus which I'm not going to tell you figure it out yourself there's a b who was probably the worst B in Yesa and you know the day came and the father calls up the Riva and he starts asking about this B Anda is so annoyed at this guy you know he got the license and he did all the things he shouldn't have done all the trips so he says he says in Hebrew so the father he hears okay fine and uh This Guy's daughter gets engaged to this guy so the up the at the V and he says you asked me for information and I told you so what happened exactly he said I figured that you know if he's a perfect bck and the only thing wrong with him is his call his voice then uh I might as well so I said I won't have a son-in-law that has a good voice no okay says the mishna it's not it wasn't it wasn't as funny as much as it was true it's true and when it's meant to be it's meant to [Music] be so go something like this whoa no this is not a good picture this is a mistake okay I should have looked this over beforehand um no good yeah no no no no the have to be smaller in this case okay no he switched the okay it's supposed to be another number instead of 15 s say 14 okay what what happen weigh much less than so if I rent the donkey and they say we had this picture on Friday it was better on Friday but he tried to change it I don't know what he he added stuff and then let's see hold on oh oh like that I get it okay this is not good this is good in other words in order for to weigh the same amount as the it has to be a much larger package much larger bag he didn't listen he was he was told he could only bring wheat which is heavier and he brought means that if he added three in other words he added to the so now it's larger is so comes out like this you you see the donkey on the right it weighs 15 it it it's 15 saw to have it's really weight it's not I don't like this the the to get the same amount it since it weighs much less so it's larger but the weight on the donkey is the same so is is that you're why because you just did something so that's what I asked what what weighs more a ton of feathers or a ton of metal in this case a ton of barley weighs more than a ton of wheat why it doesn't weigh more obviously it doesn't weigh more but it's wider it's wi harder to carry go carry uh something the size of a semi-trailer truck that only weighs 100 lb it's it's impossible it's going to start going this way that way you're going to hit so therefore it killed this donkey so he stipulated you can only bring why the bu the bulk ruins it as much as the weight does so we're G have what it means exactly what if it weighs less but has a lot of bulk are you on that also more bulk less weight or maybe it means it's the same weight just more bulk is an amount you said you're going to bring one L and you brought so but you didn't add anything so that's good you brought barley it's a smaller package it's good it's lighter sorry it's the same amount lighter like we spoke before if you add to it then we're going to see a little bit more how much do you add the general rule here in the whole is that if you add 130th more than what it's capable of carrying if it's a human being if it's an animal if it's a ship whatever it is whatever that amount is you say the the gross weight of the elevator is x amount and you add a 13th then you and you break it AB holds oh I think there's another one here that the bulk look at the bulk here for a second the bul is like weight so the actual size of the thing kills it not the weight of it so if you have 15 so which equals 90 C you add three C it's 130th you we don't need know numbers the point is 13th kills the animal here we go says if you have 15 and you add three kills it okay [Music] so R says let's see here R says you need to equal the amount of weight so to get to the amount of weight you have to put six on because that's the difference between a whole saw which is six c not three C like AB says rather you have to get to the weight r a whole it's the weight that kills the animal not the not the bulk so not the volume so m in order for to kill the animal you have to equal the weight the only way to equal the weight is to add six Cav then you have the same weight and you have a little bit more bulk bof the animal dies yeah understood we have to do okay one more time according to all you need to do is add bulk if you have the same volume and you add a little bit of three C to that volume to the bulk it's going to die R says bulk alone and that's what our logic will probably tell us that bulk alone can't kill a donkey it has to be the same weight plus bulk then it kills it so how do you get the same weight in you have to add six in order for the to equal the same amount of weight as the you have to add six and then it kills it and then once you have the extra bulk on top of the weight that's what kills it not we learned in our that he was H to bring or he rented this animal to bring and he brought what if he added something to it what did he add three like like it says three not six like know you didn't understand what if you did exactly what the guy told you to do in other words you rented an animal to carry wheat and that's what you carried how much extra do you add to the donkey to kill the donkey and you're if that's the case you did exactly what you rented the animal to do how much do you overload that animal and then if you did what you're supposed to do and you added Le is 15 and you brought 16 you rented an animal to bring a Le of of wheat which is 15 and you brought instead you brought 16 of barley I don't know if he did it H oh yeah you did okay we'll get there in a second so now another saw of equals how much C anybody remember one saw is six so it says here that if you rented an animal to bring 15 of wheat and you brought 16 of barley in other words you added six c not three if you added six like if you only added three like what's G to do with this again the basic is what kills the animal three C or six C over here it says that if you rent an animal for 15 saw and you put 16 saw of barley on it then you're that extra saw is six not [Music] three so for this we have to see this gal there's something called something called T and something called typically speaking we do T okay today we're going to be talking about and when I sell you a certain amount I round out the round out the top says AO what happened was he erased M he took off the top he leveled it out so it's very very simple if you level it out then 16 m equals 15 and a half it should say 15 and a half to okay so we have to tell Yoshi are you able to change it so where it says 15 put 15.5 how much is 15 Point what really oh you did okay good let's see in other words AB says three more 15 and a half is three a half of a Cav a half of a saw I mean is three so therefore 16 why why does it say that he instead of bring 15 wheat he brought 16 because of 16 and that ex those extra equal three not six extra oh okay we're done with this if you didn't get this it's fine we're moving on of bigger cup Consulting with into our lives says if a person is a carrier okay he's a water carrier let's say and you go over to him and you add another C to his weight he will collapse you have a a boat so ad I think is what was it a s sorry and if you have a a a large ship then to knock it out you add you add a c let's you have a a cruise ship so that it's all basically 130th more so so if it has 90 could hold 90 so in order to knock it out you have to add three cor 130 for every 30 c one why is it that you're if you knock out a human being that's carrying water and you add the you know a c of water to this water thing and he falls down if he really can't carry it let him knock it off his shoulder let him just throw it down as soon as he put the water in poof he fell to the ground he didn't have time to not to to undo it to to take the load off his shoulder says no we're talking about money he's carrying your water from point A to point B if you add another C he says no no no that's that's not what I'm I wasn't hired to do that I was hard to to do x amount and you just put on more the reason why he didn't knock off his napsack or the waters because he thought he's getting weak he didn't realize somebody tricked him and put more water on there if you add one C and knocks out Theo that means it's 13th more that means it could carry how much 30 One Core knocks it out that means it could carry 30 C I don't care exactly if you're buying you're purchasing a Spina tell guy I want a Spina it doesn't mean a robo it means something that could carry 30 cor and if you could only carry 25 he fooled you and you give him back the money says sponsored in recognition of myself and all the ofd you give his suit into the tailor and it takes him a week during that week There's A Fire somebody comes steals it what's the has you're paying him to do the work on your suit he's a we'll see if that's the reason or whatever but the point is he's he's not a you're right you didn't pay him to watch it you pay him to do the job comes so if the tayor calls you up it happens it's happened here to me sure they call you up your thing is ready ready come pick it up from that moment on come pick it up and and give me money bring money with you he flips the tailor flips into and he would be part from that point on from I tell you you watch my thing and I watch your thing so I'm getting benefit because you're watching my thing you're getting benefit because whatever I'm watching your thing you're watching my thing we each get benefit from each other so that flips us into a I I ask you could you please watch my car I put it down over here in front of me then it becomes if I say give me a million dollars you say okay but give me collateral I give you the collateral so collateral is is a gold bar so on that gold bar you become if I lent you money so the lender is a on the gold bar if he lent him fruit and in L of the fruit he gave him a gold bar as collateral then he turns into sh because I'm getting better fruit afterwards I get I get better fruit could spoil I don't want the fruit I don't know that it's better but right now in the state that it is it could spoil I'll get better I'll get good fruit later so that turns me into if a poor person gives me a collateral I'm allowed to take the collateral and rent it out and take the money and deduct it from the loan I gave the poor person why I'm doing the poor person a favor says the mishna doesn't go like the Mish says what somebody that's a a Craftsman somebody that's a tailor he turns into the problem is that the doesn't talk about a renter the talks about but not a renter so what we have what is where does he fall in is he like sounds like right or perhaps so this this renter is like a like like the guy like the tailor and according to should be this Taylor guy is not like the renter why because the fact that he is using him over everybody else that gives him special an oh feels good about himself so he becomes I was thinking to myself was reading it I think it's later on the actually you don't go to the competition I owe you I owe you each one each and every one of you you become I become a sh away for you guys I'm responsible something happens to you guys what agree yeah e can go anywhere you want you come here he gives me it's what right I know don't even say that because I want to ask you a question later okay not it's not later okay next year tomorrow morning don't ruin it I heard exactly what you said and you're right not ask the same you could say by a renter I have something to rent and I like you I let you rent it and I didn't give it to anybody [Music] else okay forget that the gives the Tor a little bit extra how that makes him Mak doesn't also mean in a case maybe gives a little extra gives to the to the renter a little bit of a of a break in the price so maybe that makes the renter when the tailor holds on to your suit how come he's not so worried that you're going to pay him you never ask for money in advance why because you have the suit so having the suit gives him that that step on you that extra step that that's worth money to him and that makes him a in the suit I want your suit I like your suit because now you're gonna pay me I don't have to run after you what was your problem problem was that our mishna doesn't fit with REM why because that's the problem there's no name in the mishna and we want our mishna to fit in with MNA but holds that is and it comes from that so you know what you do just push this button right over and changes it a and now the whole thing is understood according to is actually fits right did we say all the words have a wonderful evening a wonderful week a wonderful life I spoke about you everything's galic we'll have to talk later