Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 95 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning ra Bo live from Miami got stop stop stop got that's how it [Music] goes the way who's your friendi a big O here this is close to I wish I could turn the camera around wow unbelievable Yesa no it's Nota most of the guys are local even have twin twin brother sign he didn't even sign up his own brother I'm here for tremendous Sim it's one of the biggest for me um my this is the first theany anle with the name stefansky my daughter has two kids but they're not the St this something special and you know it's myar is a very very talented guy as you all know it's a huge huge Sim it's a it's a new page it's a new Leaf in his life in our life so I couldn't help but come I sat in the middle seat in coach and it was worth every every every minute it was was Mish was a m was was to be here um very interesting I'll show you this uh email that I got today but before that let me just because I don't want to jump back and forth I don't have the same abilities I have in the B meas I'm just going to read this one de AI my husband has been doing the daily doing the da since he wakes up at 500 am to do the D reell before going to chakras and then going to work by the way I have to tell you like this right now it's 4 in the morning for me and since I came got here it's Miami this morning here in Miami I've given two shum D two DS and this is my third one so this is what we do when we travel we don't sleep we give da you know why because you got to do the da and there's people that count on it and they just roll and this the the one I started for some reason I I started to to do it in Hebrew also so I had to do make up Hebrew and uh my eyes are like closing right now because it's 4 in the morning but who cares we got to do the da that's how it works he wakes up at 5:00 a.m. to do the da the rebell before going to sh and then going to work he then with my brother-in-law at night using the wonderful visuals from mdy if he misses in morning he always makes it up even if he's in the car I Shep so much Nas waking up to my husband learning and even more Nas when our one-year-old daughter wakes up and joins him sorry I didn't put the video on she sent the video here I'm so happy he was he has found MD and enjoys learning with the Rebellion he's always eagerly try get others to join as well so grateful to mdy and reell for bringing this amazing opportunity to my husband and all of Cl sincerely CS beautiful dear belly thank you for your wonderful share true story relevant to today's D I can't find it now but I remember reading an article about Israeli B Chua inat area who been a prolific burglar as we coming about Chua he stood up in the in the major synagogues inat on ch's morning I believe and announced that he had been a burglar if someone's house had been robbed they should come to him and he would compensate them I don't know when every whether he consulted learn the before making this public offer but many people were impressed with this action nonetheless reportedly became a rabbi nine months later of course and ran a small Yesa other for other ex-criminals who also became and nine months later who have become religious you ever come across that end his BT please let me know as a criminologist I want to interview him one day called noris Buffalo New York this is better than the entire email Buffalo New York always I want to tell you something I walk into the hospital this morning walk into the hospital and there is a doctor holding so I yell out to him hey you do the D I thought I got another recruit he says I give the D so I didn't ask him I said could I take a picture of you I said it's very inspiring to see a doctor in America going to work holding gamar nothing else this is how he look holding is gamar like that I took a picture of him and I did not ask him to send me email but he sent me an email very interesting de Rebellion MD unbeliev story just happened I was walking into Mount s Medical Center in Miami Beach morning where work as a gastrologist whatever something like that whatever gast now you know you know what I'm talking about I usually don't bring it with me to the office but this morning I'm on call and I came straight from SCH I walked in and didn't notice I passed right by rebell and his wife all of a sudden I hear from behind you do the D I turned around said what are you doing here he told me just to ride for the birth of the new grandchild I told him yes I give the D for my in Hollywood he was so excited to hear that that he actually passed through security the security guard said I'm sorry sir you can't go through without speaking to me first B said I'm sorry I just got so excited he's holding the book he then said I have to take a picture so he took a picture of me my scrubs holding my gor he said this is amazing I wish went on my way around the this story is amazing because it shows the incredible power that the D has to unite Jews all over the world it also shows the even with the bir grandchild rebell is so Overjoyed about another I was just trying to get another customer I just went to let re I just want to let rebell know that one of the B ntz listens to him every single day and joined him in Stanford Connecticut there also number there also a number of in Hollywood Florida that regular participant this the greatest on the baby to be sincerely Dr Jonathan Mazer Hollywood Florida anybody know him yeah of course I really wish I had a you know what let's take a picture from here I'll take a picture try to put it on tomorrow because this is really nice maybe do a panoramic no go over here everybody way nice oh oh that guy right over there what happened to Mendy he left already oh men's in there okay good let's see if it came out oh very nice beautiful have to remember to put it in what else do we have here that's it so the coil of the week is sponsored for the week becom the of the day baby stanski wow very nice thank you Joe Sharp is sponsored for the unity of our fathers father and the Art of the month is sponsored by Anonymous of the for easy child birth for his daughter and a healthy baby am as that email mentioned it didn't go through the clearly but this is your first time to I think there an amazing that not a lot of people know that is that if somebody is a robber he's a burglar like that guy inat got up and announced I owe a lot of people money please let me know I owe money to says rebi in the time of re they said if somebody steals from a lot of people somebody lends a lot of money with interest and you pay him back and he wants to do chuva and he comes and he pays back that money do not accept it from him so it seemed like a guy likes to steal cars that's that's what he does for business he steals your car and then he shows up at your driveway he says Hey I want to give you back the car you say no no no I learned I'm not supposed to take it back keep it you want to do TR keep it it's a nice loss some people have Maserati some people have other cars yeah Jeeps M yeah 50 30 th 100 th who knows with all the extra pipes and this it's unbelievable we have the two the two heads of different divisions here in Miami sitting next to each other it's only here only all right so we learned that it's amazing aov comes and says I want to pay you back say no no I'm not accepting why because he wanted to do Chua wanted to be easy for him to do trua but we have a question it says in the BR they do accept the money from aov so what do we do so one simple way out of it is to say that this Tak was in the time of rebi at the end of the T and the BR that says you do accept money from a it was hundreds of years before a different generation of t Okay interesting he's actually brought down a guy wanted to do CH he was already 70 years old he came to Rob he says what should I do I owe Myer I never gave my money and some say it's to give to give what do I do he said I owe $250,000 he made a calculation he owes DOA $250,000 what should he do I see all you guys are rolling your eyes this that way I'm y whatever you all give it to mdy you'll be okay I'm seeing like Mak in your head no you're just trying to figure out how much money he earned whole life no maybe was I don't know so they they passing that that since he used up all the money so it's already anyway you ask your local Rabbi what to do but there such questions the guy who wants to do cha like like I mentioned many times s in his famous book Incredible he he writes about what's his name again the guy from incred what's his name wace Wallace what Wallace he when he did Chua he made a whole list of people he stole from including a bar that he took some glasses from and including a place that he took some bricks from and and each one was a story took him many years to to return he feels that he went through the entire list but he that's part of the story how he went to the city hall and he found the guy's address and he went and he this and that until people gave money that people should be M people do Chua why not so says like this we're holding two lines from the B oh so this helps us B all the way in the bottom last line if a person has your car and he stole your car yes take it from him says that's not what re was talking about re's talking about it's gone it's it's it's long gone he ate the oranges all in in the orchard he he drove by and he saw some nice oranges was hungry he stopped the car took five oranges it's gone it's in the stomach 30 years ago so says that's when re said don't take five oranges from him let him go therefore if that's the case if the re is only when it's gone then I could say that the Bry that says that you take the money they're both talking about the everything is talking about after re top of so very simple you're asking me it says the Bri you should take it from the GH of yeah because he still has it he's driving my car watch take my car back when when rebi said you shouldn't take it from him because the car is gone it was 30 years ago I don't know what he did with the car he sold it he crashed it it's not here anymore so leave him alone as thear but that amazing story that we yesterday what the story that a man comes to his wife and says I want to do truva I plan on giving back every Dam sto so she said Reika you emptiness you piece of nothing you if you're going to start giving back things the people you're not going to have a GLE you're not going to have an naate so I said yesterday there's a SCH in New York that has a reel of rope of GLE rope and if you forget your GLE you call me snip snip so guys send me a picture here it is shiners that's right who said yeah here it is here it is the whole roll of GLE rope or whatever you want to call it black string and the scissors that's tied with a GLE rope and this Pell underneath you could wash your hands before after before so you know not time of the whole thing and you can diab so she said what are you going to return your G now it's if it's visible it's it's alive it's still there he's wearing it yes return the belt that you stole so okay we have to be a little bit he talking about I want to repay everybody with money like I'm gonna pay money I don't have the the belt I'm gonna I know I stole the belt I'm going to pay with money you telling me in a case where it's right there in front of you said you have to return ites the famous case of mish here's Mish so Mish here goes this guy sees a nice beam in somebody else's house and he does what every good GH of does removes the beam and he brings it into his own home now if you're M him to take it out like he just did what could happen is a very big loss will happen this is back in the day when Yoshi was inexperienced I see this is like this is Kinder spill already but anyways his house will fall down but at the end of the day this beam is right there in front of the very every body a beam that's built into a fancy house you don't have to give it back you just give money you don't give money you don't you don't have to return it why because you want people to do Chua so you do give money sorry you give money you don't take be out of the house that's a special dispensation why because the whole house will fall down we're not a person to knock down his house in order to give back one beam so made as if it's God now remember if it's gone completely what do we say rebi says you don't have to give it back at all but this case is very different we have a very interesting case everybody say have a case if it's here you stole a cell phone it's here give it back it's gone don't give it back we have a middle case we have a case where the beam is here you don't give it back we have to give back cash it's different either you don't give back anything no cash no phone give back phone in this case you give back the cash of the phone okay so it's three different cases why because it's here so if it's here you have to give it back but we don't want you to give it back because you're gonna break down your house okay so give cash nice picture we have here of a guy that stole a sheep and he sheared the wool after he stole it oh this is here's a a guy that has a cow he stole a cow and she gave birth it says on the bed my husband is a mdy daer is a daer okay looking for missing cow get the idea she gave birth after he stole the cow very interesting this is this is an interesting where did come up with this that what that he has to pay even for the Vlad the calf that was born after the Geva you have to pay for wool that occurred after the Geva why where where did he get it from the answer is I'm going to cheat and I'll tell you the answer is the reason why he has to pay everything is because it's a canas it doesn't make sense logically the the these are improvements that happened to the GH of after he stole it so why should he have to pay okay we have two Shas that seem very similar R says that it gives back the actual animal and the difference you have to pay the difference let me see if I could come up with it without no not this one oh this is better so it goes like this let's say a pregnant cow is 130 a non-pregnant cow all the way on the left is 100 a calf is worth 50 so the 50 the G of gets to keep the 100 he has to pay because he stole a 100 but he stole he stole a pregnant cow and now she's not pregnant anymore she gives back the 100 but he has to pay the difference between a pregnant cow and a non- pregant cow which is $30 so he gets to keep the baby the Vlad but he has to pay the $30 for that you assess it with money so was that what it seems like he's saying the same thing as is gonna explain the difference I already told you the answer but the asked the question might why does REM say you have to pay the full value the full $50 of this calf it doesn't make sense he stole a pregnant cow so he should pay $130 why is he paying is it that holds that a difference when you make something change when we make a big change in a piece of stolen good nothing happened in other words it Remains the owners from beginning to end and whatever happened happen so this cow gave birth cow gave birth who who's whose gain is it the original owners you can't you the G didn't become yours ever maybe that's the and since it never became the ghav so this C that was pregnant gave birth so who should the who should the gain go to the original owner perhaps No in fact the ghav it did become the goov why because there's a major change here went from a big pregnant animal to a non- pregant animal who there is a there a famous saying in Tom we don't want somebody that doesn't have a to gain what happened he stole a animal is worth 130 two days later the animal gave birth he makes a $50 gain from the baby just has to pay $30 difference he basically has to give $130 to the original owner and he gets to keep $20 so being a GH of paid offer him we don't want GH of him to make money so the Air Force is remain give him you have to pay $150 not $130 there shouldn't be any game for the Gham beautiful beautiful what if the animal started off was worth th000 and now the animal is worth 500 if you say that it never left the owner the original owner's domain so this G of could take a $500 animal even though it's worth $1,000 and just put it right back in his backyard and he's done what if he say that we just trying to punish him so that's not a punishment if you just if you could take a 500 if you made the animal go from a thousand to 500 you made it lose value and you put it right back in that's not a punishment a person steals an animal and he leaves it by him for 20 years animal is worthless now it's old animal he takes a 20-y old slave and when the slave is 90 years old he goes and returns it he has to pay the value of the slave of the animal the day it was stolen in other words what does that tell me it tells me that the moment he stole it it became his because the the the slave went down to Value we know we lose brain cells from the age of 20 on right cells in general all our cells are dying slowly there's a famous Marsh that says says bring your brother where is he not the not the traitor brother the other brother that's that's right that's right that's right that's right I know you're right you're right sorry don't worry anybody can leave whenever they want you don't have to apologize that you came by the way I appreciate I tell people when they some people come the last two minutes of the share that's also some people come for the first two minutes of the sh as long it's not just email little says a guy walks into the bar with a wallet full of cash and he starts buying drinks and he's getting more and more suar wasted whatever you want to call it com sh and he's having a great time and he looks at his wallet and less and less money and then he and he fin looks in there he like and he says this's one cupet that's what he says in the in uh what was this says this and he and he and people are looking at him they can't believe the guy's there it's 4 in the morning already and he's just spending and spending and he has almost nothing left what is he gonna do he has there one bill left what is the guy do last bill he buys a drink the guys are in the bar the they can't believe it they're they're making fun of him says we're all that guy in the bar we're born with a whole life in front of us and we we enjoy it we're laughing H I did this and I did that I'm 20 years old and he says he says you're 20 years old and you really you think you have all that money left you have all those not true look at it your W is now half only and then it's a quarter and you're down to the your last year your last week and you're still trying to enjoy life instead of being smart about it that's what he says so this EV that became old is worthless now so in this part later on we're gonna see R's changes but right now REM makes a distinction between a slave and a cow he says you could say take the slave I'm not paying you what it was worth 20 years ago I'm paying you what it was worth a 90y old slave today take it here it's yours here you thought the slave is gone here it is when it comes to a cow you have to pay what it was worth 20 years go not what it's worth today but if in fact your mayor holds that the a change doesn't make a difference at all it's always the owners no matter how many years go by a change doesn't create a new ownership so the original owner is the owner and if the slave is 90 and if the animal anal 35 whatever the the age of animals are before they pass on you just give it right back to the owner so then why does he make a differ a distinction between a slave and an animal an animal also even if the animal is on its last leg s to speak you just take the animal put it right back in the guy's domain and say I gave it back to you here this is what I stole from you what do you see from you see in fact that a change makes a difference that's why he can't give him back the animal oh so maybe could say that was talking to not according to me I hold that a change doesn't change ownership and even by an animal should go right back to the owner but I'm talking to you you R hold you say that it changes that a change does affect ownership I want to make a distinction say between a slave and a cow because we know in the whole that a slave is exactly like K the way you buy a piece of land that's how you buy a slave there different so just like you can't steal a piece of real estate you can't steal a Slave that's not true you're right typically speaking a slave is like K but physically it's not K I can lift up a slave and put him in a box and steal him I think that's what they're saying in this case a slave is like m not always I don't think R saying always when it comes to stealing it's like a like a piece of metal when it comes to K and other things it's like this Bo if he goes to a shop and he says take this wool and change change the color from white to Red he goes and he makes it black sh make this black and he makes it red this is a Yoshi special so first of all this is what is right you take white wool you make it red but check this out we die your Frack there's a guy walking in walks in there I need my Frack died black [Music] please with a red frog so we're gonna see that this guy's a Israeli Rashi says that um that there are people that make this mistake you don't see it so much in America it's not that common anymore and I see it all the time it's very common you go right Michael you probably went to a store said listen I want to buy this black faucet and they'll say no no no no no Black's not good for you you should take silver right they give you advice you know what I'm talking about and sometimes you tell your contractor happened to me I had a fire this guy I'm I was very sad I tell him build this wall over here he says no you don't want it over there I said trust me I've been building for a long time longer than you I need the wall over a because if it rains I need to have access behind the wall it's no problem I go to America I come back the walls where I'm serious mdy offices now the wall is up against another wall I'm like what if it's going to rain trust me trust me and then the first rain water's pouring in and I have no way to get to the other side of the wall anyway they like to give advice over there so so Rashi says unsolicited right yeah no if you ask a guy hey what do you think is is better is that so in America they're so like anti that so they won't even give you that advice I don't know each one has their own I'm asking what do you like better they won't tell you responsibility I don't I don't it depends this that you go to restaurant could you give me no no it's all good all the food is good no tell me what okay fine sometimes you push them they tell you [Music] there's I miss him this is this one is a little different so he tells the um just uh okay I don't even know if I should say it they say it about him it's not true it can't be true like by he got up and he said oh was and now it's only me and whatever one other one I don't know if he it can't be that he said it imp B but if you know what they'll deny it for sure but anyway they say it about because that you know he had a certain style so anyways ask him ask him he'll laugh at you see no way no wouldn't say something like that ask him about this story this this one is better he makes an announcement he says said this she CL coming up I'm gonna be wearing a Frack olive color olive color Frack oh the whole be SM just full jam-pack to the gills theive color frack and the door opens up he shows up with his black frack and gives the shear CL a single person could leave so after this sh went over and said said I of color Frack he said what you never saw a black Al Olive in your life okay anyways I guess you're allowed to be going for for some ask him about this one then once once once he says yes on this one ask him about the other one I don't know like something like that okay he tells the guy we'll see Rashi inside on base he tells the guy I wanted black he gives him a red one you right is better for you red is better I don't I don't think a Frack should be black beard but I'm cheating a little bit it's not m is talking about when he when he gives him Wool Wool that's white is only worth $100 a school and he made it red now it's worth 150 yes it's the wrong color but it's worth more considers him like a ghav so ghav if a ghav would do this let's say a g of steals a white spool of of of of wool and then he changes it to Red so's he improved it so what what happens he has to give back $100 worth of white wool and he keeps the profit that's what a GH does so doesn't have to give the yeah what the black and and red yeah yeah yeah yeah we're going to see that's what I'm saying I'm explaining he says I know better I I know what color you need that's what he says did it that's what it is what yeah but I'm saying when you're not around you didn't have a chance you didn't have a choice even you told him this he writes the order down yeah yeah I'll do black sure sure you come back he gives you Red there not such a good one but anyways the tired the guy this guy tells his wife come come come come to the window I want to show you what I got you I got you a birthday gift she comes to her she says you see that red that red that red Lamborghini over there yeah that's the exact color of the sweater I got you now if May holds that when you make a change in the object nothing happens it Remains the guy just got the joke so at the end of the day since he made a change since since change is nothing according toor it doesn't matter if you change it so he took white he made it red who gained the owner gained not you not the G so you should have given him everything why is he why is he keeping $50 profit so you see that in fact May throughout chh holds that when you make a change to something it becomes that person's object the owner of the dying store he gets to keep the whole spool of red wool he just has to pay for the original price the 100 the 50 keeps himself okay so we asked originally is it aass why when it is why is it when a person steals was a cow and the cow gave birth REM says pay back the cow with the baby the answer is because it's AAS not because he in fact told that a sh doesn't do anything sh does something it becomes yours but we also have to punish aov when it comes to the die Factory we're not going to punish the guy didn't he wasn't uh amaz it he thought he knows better it's called the sh some say that wasn't our question whether or not it's a or may or hold that a is K but over here it's not because himself flipped it around mayor remember before we said there's a distinction between a slave and a cow now ra says no according to Mayor There's no distinction they're both the same that you pay from the moment that you stole it meaning that she is when you steal something and you make a change in it it's yours therefore you pay only from the time that it was stolen you don't pay what it's worth today are the ones that make say slaves you say so of course is the one that holds that the change is a change that's why slave cow you stole with the with the wool a special so what is the question this the question oh just a completely different question when is there a when do I penalize the guy in all cases or only so means something that's not typically when you buy something from somebody there's a sh so I could come after that property on all real estate if I you owe me money I could come after your property I buy something from you I come after the property but there are five cases where you can't come after property can only come after property that I own not property I sold to understand this you have to go back to the [Music] story a guy comes and he says I want to rent your apartment how much is it the guy gives him a price real story she says you know what I want to live there for three years I want to give you three years in advance rent right now three years in V so guy says wow three years in vest great he gives him the three years in advance and he never moves in what does he do he puts a sign somewhere I have an apartment for sale and he goes ahead and he sells this guy's apartment with a a a crooked lawyer he was able to sell the guy the guy's apartment the guy that owned the apartment never found out why because he had three years he couldn't care less about the apartment never heard from the guy everything's quiet three years later he wakes up he says oh I haven't heard from my guy let me go I can't reach him so he goes knocks on the door some different person opens up the door yeah can I help you what do you mean can I help you it's my what I bought no a whole fight unfortunately the people that bought the house had to move out they they bought a stolen property they had to move out so the question that we're talking about right here is what about all the improvements these people made in the apartment when you buy a brand new apartment a ro it doesn't come with air conditioning it doesn't come with bars in the windows it doesn't come painted or nothing so they invested a lot of money in the apartment the actual apartment they have to give back what about the air conditioning what about this comes out to tens of thousands of dollars right Vel basic stuff it doesn't come with I I rented apartment from mendi once it's not it's notar meni so he gave me the keys and I didn't have a chance to go into the apartment so I go there at night I go turn on all the lights nothing can't see anything I thought maybe it's the breaker I go to the breaker box everything's work bring a flashlight all the B bulbs are gone the renter took every single bul bu out because they're worth money it's my bulbs I'm not going to leave bulbs in there not men's fault the guy that rented before me from meny that's what happened anyway so that's the mice over here what about the produce that comes off and the the of the pis in other words see a second let's say these people let's say the people that rent that bought the house from the GH of they rented it out so that's of pis now there's profits to the fruit so that we for the air conditioners and all that we can't go after real estate that was sold we can go after the actual person if he has any money in his account the GH of this uh this thief whatever you want to call him con artist Etc but you can't go after the con con artist property in order to pay for the air conditioners and the bars and whatever you else to put into this property no the life fixtures even in America you have to write it down and every con says dishwasher but it's normal here to leave your dishwasher in the refrigerator and this over there you Su you leave refrigerator I'm not even talking about the refrigerator they take plastic things off the seal like little things like it's going to cost me $100 just this what do you just leave it there no so so a person accepts upon himself to uh support his stepdaughter a person owes money it doesn't have it doesn't say in the in the document that that that you can go after the real estate typically a woman goes after the uh the husbands or the she goes after property but it doesn't say the but we already said the from we'll get to it so this is actually a oh this is mus and that is if you see in a document that typically has a warranty what do you call how do you say in English um gu not a guarantee but okay there's a lean a lean call more like a lean a lean on a property a typical Cuba has a lean on your property so if you don't see it there you should just know it was a mistake from the cyer he forgot it but remor says no it's not a mistake it's on purpose and there's all who says it and one of the cases is the air conditioners and the bars what's the cas stole pie of Real Estate that's not the case he sold something that's not his and that person that bought it improved it when when he collects he has to collect from the principle he takes from Real Estate and the rest improvements he cannot take from Real Estate he takes from whatever he could take from Real Estate but as long as it comes from the con artist property that he owns currently not something he sold why because people that buy from him don't know exactly that there's improvements not they know part of the story but they don't know all of it explains because the owner of the property comes he comes and he takes the whole apartment back with the air conditioners says aren't we talking about a case of a you're asking me is there a class when it comes to somebody that that's a he doesn't know so isn't this a case of a guy that's a he doesn't know that know the over here steal not nevertheless REM holds that you come and take the improvements also gave the guy a big even when he was says no we're talking about a case of amazing that the guy knew that he knows that he can't steal property nevertheless he took the chance he bought it from off aana and he improved it and therefore there's aass why because it was amazing we still don't know whether gets a oh sponsored by thank you by Greg Haber for the succcess and the return of all the and our hostages for back to the story with the red Frack he brought his thing in his W to be died red and the guy died in black only he only has to pay for the original and he doesn't have to pay for the profits that he put into it the up the what's the word whatever improve but if it's true this guy let's call him a says rash see rash three lines down he's considered a why there's many people there are many people that don't know that if a person tells you to do something with his object that you know let to change it a lot of people don't know this unbelievable so yeah exactly this is the rash for Israelis but he says a lot of people it's a certain mentality I believe they do it because they have a lot of over there people care over there they do I want I want talk about later if you hold that you should also give a person that did so this guy that owns the die Factory should get he should have to he shouldn't get any gain here at all he should have to pay the Improvement to the owner of the wall and not keep it for himself mayor did not give a that somebody did it by mistake and the guy that only the die Factory is a mistake and that's why he didn't penalize him we saw the two and we said that the is explain we have two that when there's an improvement that's on the animal after he stole it here the animal's full of wool he didn't Shear it off yet it's on the animal the animal let's say is pregnant so it became pregnant while it was in The gh's Possession so there we have the holds give it back to the original owner you didn't take it off there's no change even though the wool is still on top of the animal you cannot the GH of can keep it for himself very interesting certainly if it's not connected to the animal but even if it's on the animal it's considered the original owners no logically speaking look the guy stole it it's already in his possession it had improved in the gh's domain give it to the GH so what is the sh typically if I take your animal to watch you pay me to watch and I improve your animal in my domain it got pregnant it whatever it has more wool so there's a norm in the world some places they give that guy that watching the animal they give him a third sometimes give 25% sometimes it's 50% but there's a there's a certain there's a scale depends on the place says no the the since the guy stole it it goes 100% to the Ghana it's only how much the Gin gets but he definitely gets something this is the case we had already if he stole a cow and it got pregnant by him and it gave birth maybe we didn't have this this happened by him it be became full of wool when it was still by the gun of this is a serious change so he only has to pay what it was worth when he stole it so if it gave birth then it says right that's what it says it gave birth that's why I go to the what if it in your birth it seems like that if it stayed pregnant then the original owner gets it said we have when it's still pregnant right now that according to that the the animal's pregnant so give back the whole animal to the original owner so this fits in perfect to says everybody agrees that if the animal's pregnant right now it goes to the G the question is how much according to the entire thing goes to the GH according toim a part of it goes to the Gaz so it's neither of them says will answer that even if it didn't give you making a deal it says if it gave birth then it goes to the what's the case here um go if it gave birth it got pregnant by him and gave birth by him so he keeps the the Vlad so so why is it talking about a case that he gave birth it goes to the Gin in all cases whether it gave birth whether it didn't give birth even if it's pregnant right now the the the prophet the Improvement goes to the G you ask me a question why did it say only case that it gave birth oh the obvious the the typical answer we wanted to to official gave me a great word there's a word um to be symmetrical but not that's not the word he used but just that the the mishna should the words should match up the ra the so that's why we used the same word but it also means when it's not what AR no no much fancier word that they don't have they have you know typical official word that nobody knows besides the three people that read the dictionary whatever what says that the golin gets a third half like rep explain that it goes based on what city you live in says when by we asked the question we're almost done oh good 52 minutes according to that says that when the animal improves by the Goslin he gets a least a third a quarter a half now what does he get does he get cash or he gets a part of the animal or bus he's a real partner we could we could resolve the question from they says three people that we do an assessment and we give them cash so the answer is going to be we don't give him part of the animal we give him cash we know that a first born gets two parts so let's say there's two brothers the older one gets two thirds the younger one gets a third so what happens if the property improves so we know this is I'll tell you what it is you'll tell me what how you say it in in in the of the any Improvement that happens after the father's death the B doesn't get two3 he only gets 5050 with his brother he doesn't get two parts what is that called very good now that there was an improvement there the wants to take two thirds no he pays off his brother he gives him back the money that he deserves he doesn't get two-thirds of the Improvement he only gets two-thirds of the original whatever the father left over but the improvements later on he has to pay back his brother in cash you see over here that you pay back when you have a problem like this you don't you don't make the person a partner in the actual you just pay him off with money have a wonderful day tomorrow the same exact time at nine o'clock and I'm gonna try to do a sheare I don't know if we're g to do a live though for in Hebrew um not yet sure what time but thank you very much for coming out bring a friend put on your status