Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 68 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning ra welcome to all the guest Rabbi from Indianapolis that I know what's your name Rick Rick Bentley Rick Bentley Ruben Bentley How Could You Forget a Bentley wow from Indianapolis you're probably the only Bentley in Indianapolis if you know what I'm talking about over there it's only Fords Bo say we have with us a tremendous guest Ellie delinski for coming bner dear belly since having joined MD y my habits have changed my habits have changed among my newly acquired daily activities and he just says that is said how the B says how the whole thing the whole Dr put it in the thing sorry cannot align as beautifully Yoshi thanks for the Tor you spread for enriching my life Isner we have a picture of Michael chessel together with fishell in Florida typical Michael chessel and we have rabai a very very long email from the big famous M Michael con I don't know if you guys remember but Michael con a safer I'll show you safer as soon as we're done with this email um in honor of my father's I want to share the story you said that people regret not pulling out the perfect line like when by the go by go by and as when he asked why why don't you have a beard the first time my father came to I believe his father was the M tells I don't know it doesn't say but something like that if you years ago three four years ago he was a big big part of the shear he still is I see I I'll remind here's the safer his famous famous safer G it's a full full safer that he wrote about me even even an onov could appreciate a safer like this written about him gido the ultimate guide for how to harness your inner Bala bestselling author look in the mirror you're going to love it Elis stansky there's a lot of good jokes in here the truth is that this is AER he just he did the outside but it's a beautiful safer nevertheless I anybody that comes into my office this is the first thing they pick up and they look through the whole Leaf there's good stuff here okay so anyways so Michael Cohen writes like this that his father went Toki and they spoke about um cloning and said to Sham I didn't know there's such to in America he then called my father the mass of America kids said then they went to another G and the other G said so his father was all excited that gave him such a so he started telling him the whole shre the sug of cloning and the the god looked at him and he said cloning is aesome so before his could even appreciate the tension in the room my father rorted what about the par of was quiet whatever that means exactly sin but anyways he said like this he has a story that tops my poor Authority story his wife came home from New York City uh and then basically she left her phone in the car and then he called up the phone and the guy picks up and goes what up brother he was confused he said bro if you want your phone it'll be 50 bucks in cash he hung up he realized that his phone was stolen and then he called back he says look I have my calendar all my contacts I'll give you $100 in cash if there's no scratches on the phone he loved it he said meet me at 110 at 110 10 and my hat in 10 minutes deal but wait how will I recognize these said I'm wearing a Raiders jersey gray sweatpants thanks for helping me with my phone one problem in New Jersey kid say called the 24th pre preing and they let he let them know that there's a guy that stole his wife's phone he's on the corner of one t Manhattan in 10 minutes he's wearing a gray sweatpants and a rid Jersey so the guy ran to the to the corner all excited to get 100 bucks and basically uh there was a b the kid said they rest him and he got his phone back for free he thinks that's a better story than mine we had there was there's no violence there's no that doesn't even come close anyway the K is sponsored by Anonymous from Lakewood for for theity of the seven of them that come from supporting is on Zoom you can look over there you'll see them over [Music] there how about men the learner is he on oh that guy looks new is he new no not really yesterday ah yeah with his father his father behind okay great from Brooklyn huh I like to get up cozy sitting back learning I just read this morning 2,400 injured soldiers injured doesn't mean stitches injured means injured 2,445 in critical condition I don't know if you heard I don't know if it's true I hope it's not true but supposedly yesterday almost 10 got killed it's not out but that's that's the rumor I don't know so the is not good should pick it up in learning and memory of for the from Anonymous in Manchester joined this year the beginning of we missed this yesterday missed from yesterday they had a kidney transplant yesterday oh yesterday just yesterday talking about a kidney transplant one one of them is a big both sadik one of them gave up their kidney and I saw a picture of Yo Elan our famous the Yi Elan from Lakewood who donated his kidney a few months ago with the recipient the or sorry another another donor two donors somebody sent me a picture the procedure went well tremendous and by Michael Cohen the one and only the M of the safer in honor of my dear father re yob elzar's yard stas St who is having surgery today the of theth anous for his child his daughter and healthy baby here we go we're holding and we're speaking about is a terrible thing to give up so according to ra y works and we're going to try to ask a ra ask the says that it doesn't make sense that my re would say something like that on its own as a question probably my re was sleeping he was about to fall asleep that what that if there's two gun of him somebody stole an object and somebody stole from the ghav aov so according to R the second ghav has to pay to the first ghav the first ghav acquired it so much so that it became his and if somebody steals it from the ghav he has to pay the ghav a penalty double five lines down it says in the famous about but it says those two words together heed it or he sold it that's when you're four or five just like when you an animal it can never go back to being alive I said there's a I saw this with my own eyes where they Sheed a cow in a in one of those boxes and it's such a fast process they shed a second later they turn over the box it's all uh hydraulic it flips over it opens up and the animal just falls down into like a pit and bleeds out this cow jumped up on all four and started running and there were people everywhere and they have guns and they start shooting and it was running and jumping and and and people flying this way that way crazy and then it like obviously I don't know if it died from the or died from from bullets it was crazy but usually once something is it's it doesn't come back so let's understand what these words mean these are very important words so too when you sell something it has to be a complete M and not what and not a fake M now there's two types of now the understands now there's a fake M and a real M meaning if the owner gave up on it then it's a real M then it's a real sale if the owner did not give up on it then it's not so what's going on here but the gar just to point out do a little the is going to say well real M and not real M has nothing to do with the owner like we're thinking now that it makes a difference whether the owner gave up or didn't give up and if he gave up it's a real M didn't give up it's not a no no no no real m not a real means did I sell it forever or did I sell it for 30 days if I sell something for 30 days what is that really is that a what is that called that's a rental that's why that's the Mas the but now we're understanding we're in our in this space where makes a difference if the owner gave up or not when did this happen if the owner didn't give up this is called without I I sold it I gave it to another person it's another possession but there's no giving up over here doesn't work give back to the owner the original owner gave up if you RA are correct that after years it's yours 100% the GH of becomes a new owner why in the world would the thief have to pay four or five this is a given that if becomes the owners as much as we don't like this but that's the if it becomes the ghives it's his 100% so then once he does something with it he Sheed his own animal why should he pay a penalty it's his yeah it came to him in in the wrong way and he has to pay for it 100% he's going to have to pay for it but why does he have to pay a penalty it's his Hally it's his says you understood it wrong as we're going to see again we're going to do Kar today a bunch of times a bunch of things one of them is this line that what it means that it's not a good m means he sold it for 30 days that's why it's not a good M nothing to do with the owner the original owner giving up or not giving up we don't care about the original owner even if the original owner didn't give up it's a good M when it comes to the Ghana but why is it not considered a good M because he he sold it for 30 days when he sell something for 30 days that's not a m that's more of a of a rental that's a lease not a not a okay here's the here's a br it's very simple we have three cases and they're all talking about as you see there's a a really really skinny GH of he's GH of two and that's just a skinny guy GH of one okay so there's two GH of G of one stole it initially GH of two stole it afterwards so there's three possibilities possibility number one all the way to the right is that the ghav two stole from ghav one that's a very simple case ghav one stole it it's still he's still using it whatever G of want is G of says I learned a of Potter whatever that means we didn't even get to such a concept he has it he steals it from the goov okay and that is ghav number one has to pay the owner double because he's a ghav ghav number two doesn't have to pay ghav number one he just has to pay the he doesn't he doesn't pay a a fine he just pays the the carrot the second case is a little different second case is the G of number one stole it and there's two options either which would be the third case the middle case is where the the first GH of goes ahead and sells it let's say I I threw in that little guy with the Rob I didn't have it yesterday I wanted a second guy but Yoshi wasn't around so I put it in myself and I didn't want to mess up the drugs I made him really small so excuse me a little guy with the robe God of number one sells you see it's in a cage it says sold I don't know if you could zoom in on it you guys up there you able to Dave the middle case it says sold he sells the Sheep in a cage he did a great job sells it to not to the G of number two sells it to the guy in the RO this as soon as he sells it how much is he four he's not allowed to sell GH of two comes along and steals it from the guy in the robe from the guy in the robe so guy number two has to pay kful so we have to understand why he has to pay careful was the here there no us that's that's what the is going to discuss basically we're going to be discussing mainly the middle case third case is very simple as you know one of my pet peeves is when people take things here in Isel they come they come to KES they walk out of you see a guy walking out of The KES with two giant plates of cake and cookies what are you doing uh I'm bringing it to my brothers and my mother yeah but it's not appropriate you're taking a little bit much no no no no the the B is not not it doesn't care a whole cake with the ver Mitzvah thing with the and he's taking it home okay so a guy did worse than that to me he came to my uh barbecue he's sitting here in the room I don't care if he's Mish I have no idea what it is he came to my barbecue and I had meat from Chicago I was giving siroy and a m beautiful steaks from Chicago he decided he took raw meat raw meat he took home he didn't want to eat it then he wanted to do his own barbecue when when he wanted to and he thought that was okay I'll never do it [Laughter] again anyway so that's G I'm not the guy then it was three years before he five years before you this is we talking about eight years ago I don't do I haven't done bar in my house in a long time research I don't know what it was research oh him he has a meat store since then you pay me back a thousand times over [Music] so and meat I'm talking about fine so this guy G of number one steals a sheep God of number one she the Sheep when he she it the moment he she it he's four times G of number two right before G of number one does a barbecue he takes his meat he steals the meat how much does he have to pay back just the Karen let's see all these three cases inside m like the wide line that's the easiest case A guy stole it and a second G of came and stole from the first guy the first guy has to pay obviously he stole it he only pays let's go back here Karen why does he only pay Karen because the p says you only pay Karen to the original to to the owner so he doesn't have to pay the GH of twice if the second case the original ghav steals it and he sells it to the guy in the robe so the guy in the robe did he acquire this animal yes why called shin and then a second ghav steals it from the guy in the robe so there's a a ghav that came to the RO and says Rabbi give me a br for my perosa he says what do you do I'm I'm sorry I can't I can't give bras for for G it's not it's not appropriate so but Rabbi please say it doesn't make sense why would I give you a br that you should steal and Rob people he says no no no give me a br that anybody that had a that he should be robbed it should be done through [Laughter] me so in case number two that the guy stole it from the guy in the robe he has to pay careful to the guy in the robe why because the guy in the robe acquired it with the shin the first guy that stole it he has to pay four times because he sold it it's a didn't selling if you don't sell you don't pay four you only pay two third case he stole ited it so immediately or hey I just in this in this chart it doesn't say anything about hey just because there's no room to put another letter well call D to make it easy talking about a sheep not a not a c and then some stole his meat after doesn't pay the question is if the let me ask you a question I ask you a question G of number one did he acquire this Animal by Shing it absolutely there's no greater sh than Shing if I take a piece of wood and make it into cheer it becomes the ghav so how come ghav number two doesn't have to pay ghav number one on it's not my question it's the G's question so it doesn't matter you whatever you steal you have to pay kful and the now Hally the owner is the ghav this is the first GH so ghav number two came and took his meat so G number two has to pay to G number one says so we're going to prove a question against RAV what RAV holds again y acquire he acquires things with the Y so let's look at the second case he the first gy of stole it sold it to the guy in the robe a guy comes and steals from the guy from The Robe the first guy has to pay for why because he sold it and the second one has to pay to the owner to the guy in the robe when this if the original not the guy in the robe we don't even have a picture of the guy the original owner if he did not have he did not despair Kel then why does the second guy that stole it from the first GH of or from from the guy in the robe why does he have to pay kful who's the real owner right now the real owner is not even in this picture the real owner is the original original owner the guy that g of number one stole it from he's still the owner why he never gave up so if he never gave up why is GH of number two paying the guy in the robe sh this is just moving it to somebody else domain without anybody giving up is there anybody in the world well we said maybe from these is there anybody that holds that just moving an animal to somebody else's domain the guy is C like that without any you need two things like T said there's that little on the last line says there's no such a thing there's nobody that holds that that that sh you need in conjunction with SH in conjunction with SH you need but you need two things you definitely need the guy the original original owner to give up oh but you so then why in the world did the guy why does the guy have to pay for again in the middle case we're talking about the middle case the middle case G of number one steals it is it his or not his raboy say is it his or not his well if we're talking about that there was Yos like we just proved that the guy gave up then it's his and when he sells it it was his thing that he sold so why does he have to pay four according to Rav that says that y makes it yours 100% so then you shouldn't have to pay four the middle case why is he paying four El he didn't nobody gave up if nobody gave up why why does the second guy have to pay kful it's a here we have to say we're for not because it's owned by another guy why is he paying double to somebody that's not even in the picture the guy in the robe if there was no y the guy in the robe doesn't exist he bought something could I buy your gamar over there with all your beautiful things from him could he sell to me absolutely not so why am I paying him I'm paying him kful who am I paying cable to you're the original owner give it back give back to to whoever it belongs to but you're not paying a penalty to something that didn't happen el el was you gave up it's not your gamar anymore you gave up oh you gave up and it's not your gamar so then why is GH of number one paying four times you can jump on two kasas either G of number two shouldn't pay kful oh but you're saying he gave up somebody gave up so there is kful so if somebody gave up then G of number one shouldn't pay four times because from Who Original yeah the guy gave up already the guy gave up no then G of number two shouldn't pay there's no you why is G of number two paying because there's G an originala and then without without no only works with that's what we said needs it doesn't work without there things I'm taking your object here I took your thing I put it over here oh you need that you give up plus it's over here thear is goingon to answer a very simple answer there's a way to dance on that the guy the original owner did not give up initially that's why God of number one has to pay four he gave up at a later stage and it makes a lot of sense you know when he gave up when GH of number one sold it g of number one is his next door neighbor so he thought oh I'll get it back from him now once he goes into the market sells in the street he doesn't know to who then he gave up oh you gave up now you have to pay careful I ask you another question before we get to the answer let's go to case number one if there's a GH who stole it from the first the first guy that stole it has to pay why because he's a g and the second guy doesn't have to pay only car we just established that we're talking about and if according to works perfectly why does the second GH of not have to pay the first GH of it's the first GH is 100% so we have a says do you really believe that this Bry the way it is is is is good this BR has a big flaw on it and once we answer the flaw then all your questions go away why because let's look at the last case look at the last case a guy steals something he it the second it becomes his but he has to pay four because he Sheed somebody else's animal but what happens after he becomes his and somebody steals his meat right before he makes a barbecue that makes a lot of sense the second guy doesn't have to pay to the first G of that doesn't make sense the first GH who it he he changed the actual animal it was a live animal now it's a dead animal so that's called changing something changing something should make it yours it should be the GH of is 100% so the second GH of should pay the first GH of kful why does he not pay says therefore obviously everything's before you now if everything's before you that answers all the questions on RAV why because the big question on RAV is if it's after y it should be become his 100% And it's a riot that that it doesn't work well we're talking about before y That's why doesn't become his 100% just switch the to the middle and the middle to the then say this okay and we'll go to the next no I'm just kidding there's a beautiful chart here look look what happens if you look at this chart we're going to take the middle piece where it says number two in the middle and where it says number two at the end if we switch those we just had a major cash says why all the way to the left number two pays Karen you should pay kful why he stole meat that's about to go on the barbecue that is owned 100% by GH of number one then GH of number two should pay kful not Karen the answer is he does pay K there's a little bit of a problem here we mixed up the second case with the Third so if we take the you see myy you're not seeing if you take the Karen from case number three and put on case number two and you take the kful from case number two and put on case number three everything works out you do this boom that's R terrets so it goes like this now we see it inside let's take the the last case and make it the second case say this the second case the middle [Music] case so the first guy is g to pay four oh now makes sense you ask me why does the say guy pay kful there's no he doesn't he only pays Kar he doesn't [Music] pay because there's no years over here and just moving it to somebody else's domain doesn't do anything but the third case when he it so now he but it became the yeah of course the second GH has to pay the first GH of because it's the first GH of why so the bottom line is no question on WRA from here because we're not even talking about us we're talking about before us okay yeah a little bit more hper what was the question the question is if was if why does he pay four it says why is he paying four there's no use that's why if there's no use he has to pay four okay so doesn't like this business what are you going to change it take something from the middle put it at the end the end put in the middle he goes back let's go back what happened huh what are you talking about yeah the question was from the middle case why is the middle case pay yeah don't switch it the last case where he no it didn't go back oh you're asking me how come the second GH of in the in the in the third case the second GH of why does he not pay kful why does he pay K he should pay kful he stole from the first GH of the answer is because it goes according to that you can never acquire it by making changes like we learned by the you take uh olives you make to oil that doesn't change anything it stays the owners over here also so what are you telling me rep says no there is says there's no we're not talking about there's no and there's no question around but if you tell me that there is y over here then we go back to the [Music] problem you're telling me this so why does he have to pay four if if the guy gave up so it's yours so then why you have to pay four also in the Raa why does the second guy have to pay Karen it's yours the second guy should pay kful okay so we have a problem oh so this is the the answer we mentioned before we're talking about before you again so if we're talking about this whole Bri we're talking about before the guy gave up no question the whole the whole point of asking a question ra is if you have a situation where you see that somebody gave up and it doesn't become his that's question around we're not talking about we're talking about situation there's no years that was two stages initially in in in the middle case initially the owner the original original owner he did not give up he thought he's going to get it back from his neighbor GH of number one so GH of number one has to pay four times why cuz it was never his there's no giving up so he pays for but once G of number one so sold it then the original original owner gave up it was stage two in giving up then he did give up oh since he gave up G of number two has to pay kful to the guy in the robe the guy that bought it the guy in the robe he's cing it with sash explains why would you say that only in the second case that the the guys has to pay kful and not in the first case or see that you need and you need two things no that's not true works on its own it works the only way in the world I could come up how do I explain that two G of him gun of number one g of number two have to pay special penalties how how do it how's it possible either one pays either the first guy pays special penalties or the second guy pays special penalties either there's a y and if this's Yos the second guy should pay penalty if there's no y the first guy should pay penalty not the second how do you how do you have a situation where two people two G of pay penalties kful and and the answer is in the special case where in the beginning there was no Y and later on there was y all right say can wake up now there's a new don't be if you slept for more than 30 minutes there you could watch nugas in the back I'm not talking to you Lauren there was only five minutes I'm paying attention don't worry about it check this out this [Music] beautiful Dr E is thinking about it you're thinking about it h H okay we have three sheas here when you sell something the good news is is only for another two weeks don't don't despair no y no it's that's it we're done with the heart so with the cloud cloud this three when you sell something again I saw there's a little bit of confusion it's an interesting G of steals something he only has to pay twice if he does something severe like selling that item after he steals it then we impose on him another penalty called which actually includes the Cel as we'll see soon when exactly did he sell it before the original owner gave up or after the original owner gave up so we have a threeway a very simple what says before what says after and what says both okay it's that simple if you sell the GH sells the item before the original owner gave up it's beautiful says you have to pay four you don't have to pay four says sell it doesn't doesn't say when doesn't say how if the guy sold it he's four does the to mention that the original owner gave up no he sold it doesn't matter says why because it's only after the original gave up has to be a real sale you can't make a make believe sale what kind of sale is this if the original owner didn't give up it's still the original owners just like that there's a something happened there so too when you sell it it has to happen after something happen how do I know this why I'll give you the reason of the why why is there a concept of four or five because you did over and over first you stole it now you you did on your head you went and you it you and you sold it there's a beautiful I wish and I hope it's true he says this that it says in all the that if you do to roll in in snow and you have to do 5,000 T and whatever all the you know the scary stuff and that's only if a person does one AA one time but if a person does an AA over and over then you then all the stuff that the say doesn't apply and he explains when you do you have to be whatever when you do that over and over the actual fact that you're controlling yourself not to do it again even though it became rooted in you styish that itself is so powerful and so hard on a human being that that itself is the ton should be right says the gor so when did this happen if the owner the original owner didn't give up what kind of sale is this you didn't redo an a it never even happened didn't even start the original own didn't give up it has to be that the original owner gave up no it's not true has nothing to do with the owner giving up not giving up let's say there's no use you repeated a bad act you stole then you went ahead and you sold it that's repeating your act that that itself causes you to pay for the task says that when a person Steals and he denies it he denies the fact that he stole he ask why do you I didn't steal oh we'll give you a penalty kful then you go and you double up and you sell it so we double up your penalty instead of two now you pay four because you lied again so asked Freeman what about why is there five how did the five come in that's in four okay we have to get there to that Su and the difference between taking the sheep on your back and being embarrassed again we have when exactly is the sale taking place before the original owner gave up or after the original owner gave up or both just like the the doesn't come Backes if it happened before giving up why does it go back give it back to the owner happened after the owner gave up we had before that we're not talking about a regular the owner think about it they give up not give up no that's not what we're talking about we're talking about a sale that wasn't a good sale why cuz sold for 30 days selling for 30 days is considered a rental not a sale says I have another his name is that you only are four times if the original gave up why every time you steal something the owner gives up right away why and then what do you have you have y say Rashi and then now you have two things if he gave you have once you have and then you change domains you have two things and therefore you and he proves it says if you sold or the animal you have to pay four five what so now look at the chart for a second says every has to have and that's why you so which she does he hold like the middle that you do you sell you sell after this okay very good so what force maybe there's no it has to have us it has to have something it has to be a serious sale you can't sell something that's not not yours says and and if there's no then then it's a fake sale it's not a real sale says what's re's proof that every single theft has years with it maybe in this case the reason why he pay four is because we heard with our own ears that the guy said but maybe there's no right maybe maybe a typical G there's no use I don't know it can't be because it has to be similar to you could you could steal and millisecond without hearing any not why makes it becomes yours since they're similar they go together word after word so then without hearing that the guy it also works but without hearing that there's no has to be immediately every time something's stolen the guy unbelievable when you steal a human being the Torah says if you steal a human being and that's Thea by the way in also stealing human being not stealing an item when you steal a human being if you steal him and sell him then you if you don't sell him so says what oh that's exactly what we're trying to talk when when you steal a human being is or not says Rashi listen to this we're talking about the the the hostages terrible situation three months already in captivity did they give up on themselves says there's no there's absolutely no giving up a human being never gives up on himself he always has hope that he'll be released he'll be he'll be um what's the word rescued I heard that yesterday was failed rescue soldiers got killed in that also but he has hope he'll be rescued so what's his R there's a lady who walks into to the to the silver store with a crying baby feeding the baby this battle okay fine she says I want to see a beautiful your nicest man Nic man she looks oh it's very nice can I show it to my husband outside he's in the car sure she leaves the stroller with the baby and she leaves outside problem is she never comes back turns out that she stole Somebody's Baby from the store next door all this she walked in pretending that she had a baby and the baby's crying this that and because she left her baby there so they let her take them in outside so said that's this is in our day it's not but she kidnapped a human being even though it was for 20 minutes whatever it was it's kidnapping so besides to steal but okay fine says the so what's trying to prove look rash just said there's no giving up on a human being you sold a human being but he never gave up on himself so here's a situation where I'm selling somebody without him giving up and it's not even a sale you can't sell another human being doesn't work but it's considered a sale so in our case also I sold something that's not really yours but I'm selling it there is such a thing is selling something that's not yours even though there's no still says you see that is of the opinion if we go back to this list he holds like RAV that even before there's a but what about does also hold like on the bottom we know for a fact that he said before like like like kidnapping it's before but what does he hold also after [Music] use even so in other words yes even so he like both before and after is like on top just before you once there it becomes yours and if you sell it after it becomes yours you don't have to pay four which we saw this far a number of times let me ask you a question oh here's the case there's three steps here he steals a sheep he says oh I'm a bigadic I'm not such a GH of sometimes I steal and I take it for myself but sometimes I steal I'm Robin Hood I give it to the B ra and then he Slaughters it which is whatever does he have to pay four or not the answer is no he doesn't pay four why because he didn't he didn't she a human being's animal he Sheed aem's animal how did he have the right to be magd who is it his to be what happened there very important rash here we must see this Rashi inside says rash says in the you have to take from your in order to pay for listen to this you are listen to this if you're not paying you don't pay four and five why you could only pay either four or five not three or four once you take off you remove the you hear this so the four and five actually contains within it C once you remove the C now becomes three and four there is no such thing as paying three and four so the whole thing flies out how do this happen if the original owner didn't give up how did I how did I sanctify how do I make an animal of has to be your animal in order to make must be that happened after years oh so look at this case there's a there's aak over here there's a hides but it's only because of that that's why you don't have to pay hides that's why you don't have to pay four five what if he didn't make this animal he would have to pay four this is like a question this is a question that asking if you hold the makes it yours why would he have to pay four or five look what happened look it over here the the who is magit over here the ghav but if we go this way over here it's the owner made ites when after it was stolen okay does that work how could the owner makes something KES when it's not in his possession it's in the GH of's house if something stolen the G can't make it and the owner can it's not the G not his possession he holds like beautiful thing the fourth year of grapes what do you do it has of it's like not not it's like what you take the fruit you bring to if it's too much for you then you take the the fruit you transfer it into money the money becomes what if a guy comes a ghav like like y see Wild's story where he took some orange off a Orchard it wasn't his God of com oh beautiful grapes takes two grapes and eats them he's now over not only is he stealing but he's eating out in not in what does a do he says I know people take them but there's a problem they're going to be eating here's money here's a pile of money everything they take after they take it it's going to go on this money it's going to be but they already took it so how how how do you have the right to do that when they already when it was stolen it's in the possession of the ghav the answer is you they hold the hold that you could do it after it's in the possession of the G so you could make something he even though it's not in your possession says why are they called because he does this still a hate nobody knows that he's doing this the GH doesn't know that he did it he doesn't scream oh GH GH and he doesn't scream look what a I am oh I'm helping all these people that steal from me he does it under the table where nobody knows we have to go Vitter should you know what we have to stop over here in middle of a sug unfortunately let's see what's tomorrow wow you know what let's do two more lines you could leave ask the if why does the goov have to pay kful the owner made his animal hegdish so whose animal is it it's the owner's animal which became heish through the owner okay so the GH is walking around with it but the GH doesn't have to pay careful for that says look what happened over here oops first he stole it then he went to bzden and bz said you have to pay then comes the owner and makes it hegdish the made a verdict and they said you have to pay my then who cares if he made it look at this even if you take off the heish part he should be poter why the guy the G went anded it but after he was you don't have to pay four for that why well he's not a g now he turns into a gin once him and they know who he is and he went and he and he and heed it now five three more lines and you can start from hear me but if they just say they don't make they don't say a verdict they just say you have to give but I don't understand exactly you have to understand exactly what it means it's not a ver written we think they have to to give it looks like we're going we're going to give the tomorrow but you're going to have to give it in that case you do have to pay four five since there was no ver no still in a narrow case we're talking about in a case where he said and therefore when he he does have to pay for five rabai have a wonderful day [Music] sh [Music] fore