Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 62 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning first we'll start off with theim meni Ma [Applause] even though we had a wedding last night he's here to learn to ma CL is sadden to hear the passing the great M Solomon who n and I put in try to put in a a nice clip where he talks the 10th uh C Global he speaks beautifully about I know people that started the D because of his speech at thatum so I don't know if we'll be able to throw it in if you also throw in a clip or something tonight if we want to make a resolution it is to make a resolution that our homes will be filled not only the sh that we learn with a sh in public will bring the learning of we prepare a and we'll revise a we'll learn with our children we'll find moments to fill our homes with for all of us two emails I would like to thank you for the amazing shim I love it very much and I've been from the day I bought my smartphone I have a few Heroes additions on some of the stuff you recently mentioned now I have a feeling that a lot of this email is not is not 100% EMS don't read it no this the story you said about the man that went over to help a lady goes that when he saw it his wife he asked are you on your way home there's the story with the the guy wanted to do he saw a woman shlepping heavy packages and then he noticed it's his wife he goes over say you in the way home she said yeah can you please take home my towels bag also and off he went you said that that story there sha asking for a ride home I heard a different version I also I yeah it's a famous One Thea slipped on the snow so he shouted to his can please help us to get up so T answered you can help each other get up you recently mentioned about the danger of letting the children watch I can say that children are addicted watching your belly as this is the only thing that my filter lets through I hope this is okay and they'll not beg tomorrow for Uncle Mo I know they won't because you're much better wow wishing you all the best PS I don't really reside in mon but thought I'll have a higher chance of to read you my email because it's your favorite place now I was that maybe his name is not really mayor Feldman because it's spelled m i r so I know they call you at least we should make it our next fine deell I'm here four years I started learning four years ago when I was wondering whether to start the D all my R and friends all said don't do it one of basically they G different reasons they not pass shabas the kiter he's at a wedding decid he's going to start right away on January 5th of kiter now he basically didn't even miss a single d uh blah blah blah blah blah the most I fell behind was One D since broken and all the people told me he did not start a shot one thing for sure that that changed my life Anonymous PS we met around three four times I'm very good friend very very the sponsored for the unity of that come from supporting for your Relentless commitment where's that piece of paper you're supposed to give me in memory you don't have to get up you can pass it over it's fine memory of my great grandfather Mo no that can't be who is today it says M so I'm assuming it's m who is today ah okay so we'll do it for two what does it say here [Music] in honor of the ofen andik in Baltimore in memory of on his e site by Anonymous in honor of and the marriage of his son they to bring you and Mr he thanks you maybe it's Leon 9-year-old girl getting heart transplant that Peril is in rehab all right I have a question for you the spored again oh the arst sponsored Beautiful by who anous Anonymous for easy child for his daughter and healthy baby easy child birth for his daughter and healthy baby what happens after the birth and after the baby is mom is healthy what do we say then we'll have to figure it out you really okay here's the question I want you to think about it because I at the yesterday I was asking a bunch of people and I got different answers very interesting a guy shows friend a old dilapidated stal that he found in the Mikvah he says he he paid for it 100 bucks so St 100 bucks so his friend's like very nice very nice he turns around pulls out a match and like he always had a TI it to burn a stral $100 you thought a stal cost $2,000 here's a $100 stral for 100 bucks it's worth it he burns the stal to crisp it turns out Bo say check this out this is this is a true story The the stral of kki was sold for $1.8 million you can imagine what it looked like it came from rash it's old trial this guy this guy that bought it didn't want you know his friends to to know how much it cost he said it's 100 bucks the guy went and destroyed a $2 million stal $1.8 million stal the question is let's say that's the value I'm not going to go into detail oh he overpaid let's say let's say it was a an antique car he told his friend it's worth a 100 bucks it's actually worth $2 million plus and his friend burnt it to crisp how much is the friend $100 because that's what the owner told him it's worth or he has to pay him the real value of $ 1.8 million for kki sh1 $100 some say 10000 doeses anybody say 1.8 anybody I would go through sh I go through rendi learns a say the answer is 1.8 it doesn't matter how much the guy told you you have no right burning his stral you're you do it as much as it hurts and but if you think if you pause for a second you think about it is it a t why is it a t t because it's hidden the price is hidden it's hidden in the how much there's no there's no that's yeah yeah yeah that's why I said I'm not getting into the details oh you what he saying I don't I don't understand the but okay but he's saying he's saying good he's saying that was sold in an auction and auction has a certain value but I'm saying even without that there are certain things that have value and people don't know about okay what's what's your name Glenn Beck black black from London South Africa Johannesburg another one ah you're from the you came in for the wedding no sh beautiful okay welcome welcome boa here we are let me ask you the same question though does the same thing apply if you tell somebody watch my stral it's only cost 100 bucks watch it 100 bucks nak listen to this question I know you I hear I hear yeah here's the same exact question but slightly different I I let I say could you please watch my sh I just bought it for 100 bucks please watch it and then you put it on the window sill and somebody grabs it somebody steals it how much are you 100 bucks or 1.8 million so the answer is 1.8 it cost him 1.8 he told the Sher let's say he told him it's only $100 he didn't want to scare him he said it's 100 bucks so the guy go goes he's slightly NE negligent he puts it by the window open window puts it by the window somebody comes by grabs it so the answer is in that case he's only high of 100 bucks why because he's a Sher and he only accepted upon himself a sh of 100 bucks so let's see it in the here we're getting to it right now we're holding three lines from the bottom of we have the situation of the goddes you have a box as you can see here full of gold and he goes and he lights the godish on fire so we have a if there's gold you pay gold you only pay the value of the wheat or The Barley but here's the it's a kicker we mentioned yesterday you see that one by one box in there that one by one box it's not that you don't have to pay for that volume of wheat you have to pay as if that one by one box was wheat okay so you pay a buck instead of $110,000 we had yesterday this is referring to a case where you started the fire in your own backyard and it traveled to your to your next door neighbor but if you went into your friend's backyard and deliberately started a fire over there you must pay everything although yesterday we learned that according to ra you don't pay everything things that are the D to put inside the bail of hay you have to pay but things that not you don't have to pay things like like money people don't usually bury money in a bail of so even if you went according to even if you went inside there into your friend's backyard and you lit it I'm fine your because is be again things remember like the Yoke of the cow that you typically hide inside the that you're not not not a not the wallet you allow your friend to come into your yard and put down his bail of and his friend not only he took advantage not only did he put a a bail of hay but he also put his cash in there even who says that typically you have to pay for t on for hidden stuff over here you don't have to pay why because the owner allows you to come in and put a bail of hay he didn't allow you to come in and put a bail of hay plus a plier and and this and that not he only accepted upon himself to watch to make sure the on the B was for the he and not for Caleb so now we're GNA have four cases and all four cas cases have the same outcome you pay the smaller amount so one case at a time I allow the person to come in and put in expensive wheat he goes and he puts in inexpensive less expensive less expensive barley and I wasn't careful I wasn't doing my job to watch his what I thought was but really ended up being so a pile of is 100 bucks a pile of barley is50 bucks so his 50 bucks got destroyed stolen how much do I have to pay him 50 I only I told him he could put in 100 but he didn't put in 100 so I only have to pay what he put in which is 50 one more case S I gave him permission to put in 50 bucks but he put in $100 worth of stuff and I was negligent and it got stolen s we have to pay him 50 bucks CU they only gave him permission to come in with 50 here we have a nice picture for this it's a pile of wheat the guy goes and wants to pretend he doesn't want people to steal it so what does he do he takes a box of barley and he covers the top covers the top I don't know why I think I said the story and nobody cared about the story I say it again when I was a kid inra we got upset at somebody whatever we in a little bit of a fight so we we came with the devis the plan on chabas to dig a hole in one of these men mountains that we used to play on like a dirt Mountain we dug a hole on before and we filled it up with Sid like this white Plaster and then we sprinkle a little bit of dirt on top and then we let you know one of us not not me pull the guy's ear or something and then we ran and we ran like above this thing and the guy ran after us and he fell into this pit onab his whole suit was full of white the whole thing so sometimes you you cover the top with something else and it looks as if as if it's something else so over here it's un on the spot I get marks for the stories and the jokes it's beautiful cannot write this story in my book he had a pile of Wheat and the guy covered it with barley or the opposite it was a pile of barley and he pretended it was expensive it was made so is only pay for the barley either the guy thought it's barley because it was covered with barley so that's all he took upon himself to watch or it really is barley and that's all he has to pay is barley so but kid the bottom line is he always pay the the lesser of the two here we go this is the story he gives a woman a bar of gold or some jewelry gold he says you see this white stuff this is not white gold this is called Silver if she damages it with her hands of even though she doesn't know what it is if she goes and she damages it the same story with the stral she the guy thought that was the Lesser it was 100 bucks and he destroyed it over here also he gave her this ring and he says this is a it's made out of silver he lighted her but it's really gold she has to pay for the gold why he tells her my who told you who asked you you have no permission to damage my stuff that's user to do and the fact that you thought it's this and not that that's your problem but if she was just a Sher and she was negligent since she only accepted upon herself the Lesser value of of silver so since she's negligent she only pays silver she tells him I accept it by myself to watch something that silver to watch something that's made out of gold I never accepted upon myself and therefore yes I was negligent but I was only negligent because I thought it was silver and that's all I have to pay you say this based on ra ra is in he comes and he he he said okay we knew this from from the now we learned it a minute ago if he was fooled there was a pile of wheat which is expensive and it was covered with one layer of barley or the opposite was a pile of barley and he do a very small layer of Wheat and and he's a sh he's trying to watch this and he looks at the pile he says oh this is a pile of barley because there's a small layer of barley he thought that that's what he accepted upon himself he only has to pay that amount I don't need to come to Raa I know this about the strl and about the the antique sports car and the story of a golden ring that was told to the woman that it's silver I see it from this that if I see something in front of me I see a pile of barley because that's what I think it is but really it's a pile of wheat which is much more valuable I only have to pay for the pile of barley because that's all why because I was only accepting it by myself to watch barley so here to our case with the with the gold and the silver I never accepted by myself to watch gold as him to do anything so it's even worse it's even worse yeah and okay but you agree you agree you agree that if you're a sh you have to pay if you do it she destroys the gold ring she has to pay the value of the gold ring you agree yeah okay so then sh most certainly correct okay so it's even better correct okay it's worse so you're saying that I'm right I'm I'm not only right I'm very very very right okay I love being very very very right that's going to influence the level of right you're right I would not bring a RI from the shal to the watching but one from the other you could okay fine the first he says I heard this from in theud that what there's no Tom there's no if somebody Burns a bail of hay and inside there's valuables you do have to pay I heard something and I don't remember what I heard famous contemporary what you don't remember he says that the is if somebody steals something and then we we catch him but we don't know exactly what he stole we don't know so we could force him to swear we say I'm sorry we force the one that the object was stolen from the Nigel he says he stole a million dollars we don't know we know that this guy stole it's lost now so a million dollars seems a little EXA swear I swear it's a million dollar and the GH has to pay him a million dollars so I said the story a while ago I'm not going to say with any it was in a story in a restaurant in Los Angeles really every single part of it is we left a certain restaurant in Los Angeles and my wife as we get into the car my wife says oh I left my my purse in the restaurant go back to the restaurant and the purse is gone so I go I said who's the owner speak to the owner I said you know we were here three minutes ago and the person's gone he says what do you want me to do he I can't do anything about it it's God it's gone I said what do you mean we can do you have cameras everywhere let's see who took it no you can't do that it's the camera's not working is that all I said listen you have the cameras go why can't you help me out he said no I said look yeah if you don't go look at the cameras I'm going to do something here that you're not going to like so you didn't trust me so I got onto a chair you didn't believe me so I got into the cheer I said ladies and gentlemen so everybody stop said there's a thief here there's a guy some he's stealing stuff from people he stop stop stop stop stop stop stop I look I look okay he goes up to his office I'm telling every part of it he used to be a little c not today I'm not I wouldn't do something like that he goes to his office he comes right back down two minutes later he says I saw something weird on the camera you're right the the lady that cleaned your table right after she cleaned the table she took the garbage outside so let's look outside so he takes one of his guys there a big dumpster he jumps into the dumpster and he's looking and he can't find anything I said no you're going to look again kids are finally he finds a bag within a bag my wife's purse was in there so he takes out the purse and we we go through to see that everything is there sure enough everything was there besides the cash so they make a little meeting they make a little meeting the woman that cleaned the table that stole the purse the guy that jumped into the dumpster and they make a little meeting they huddle they come back okay okay listen she says she claims she didn't she never she didn't steal a purse but she knows that you think she did and you're going to go to the police and going to deport her and the whole thing she doesn't want to make a big deal out of it so you say how much was in the purse and she'll pay you now I know that I gave my wife a 100 bucks that morning and she spent $8 so we had $92 so I look at her with a straight face I said there's $150 in the purse so she says no no no no no seriously so when something is stolen why is it a g something is stolen something is stolen can ask my wife she was my wife would not lie I would but my wife not for a good story maybe I hear in the story I even lied I'm even saying a story Li okay now there's a there's a there's a part to the end of the story so I told my brothers story he lives in Los Angeles the following week he go his wife goes to the supermarket and over there they help you out and they put your groceries in the car she turns around and her purse is gone so she goes back home she goes inside this that they give her a whole thing so she goes back home so my brother comes to the store he says where's my wife's purse look at the this and the guy gives him this whole Spiel he can't this that they try to protect him because they need these workers so my brother remember what his older brother did he gets up on a chair he starts screaming ladies and gentlemen there's theves here there's still guys stop stop stop and he gave him the purse he gave him the purse he went to the back and he got the purse back M so you could try it you could say at least the fans said you stand on the chair you scream you make a big if you didn't learn anything today at least you learned this not okay Z so it's called Tak n what's Tak Nal we don't know how much is stolen we can't trust the thief so we trust the guy that was stolen how much and I I believe the saying other things in the so that it's all within reason if there's a guy we know that for a living he he makes $20,000 a year he can't say that the guy stole half a million dollars from him you know it's all within okay one of the most hated things in CL Isel a guy that that goes and tattles on somebody goes to the authorities CS him a monetary loss now I want to go to Bez and say this guy called up the authorities on me and because of him I lost XYZ uh $20,000 there's something called not to get all excited it's very similar to grma according to rash the same exact thing similar the point is you cannot take somebody to bzen because they made a phone call to the authorities and the authorities came down and because of that they they made you close down your shop and they made you tear down your house it was just a phone call I didn't tear down your house I called the authorities and the authorities did it that's G me so if you cannot sue somebody over that you can't go to bz for that because it wasn't direct so guy that's I can't do anything about it let take care of it but the question will be according to the other I could take somebody toir damage so the question is could I swearing Bez then that the damage was $20,000 that's how much it cost me to to renovate and this and that yes it was illegal and the guy had a snitch on me and because of him I lost all that whatever the case is Hally that it's considered a mo okay take I don't know now since it's a monetary take we have a moiser who caused me $10,000 damage can I sue him how much how much do I get it's a t but what do I do now means I wait for Mia wait for but I need my money today so some trying to say by a that happens to be with M 50% exactly don't know exactly so what do you do 50/50 some say yeah and some say no that's too bad exactly I'm saying I'm telling you in talk about it we pass like what's I don't know I don't know I have a great Yoshi put it together beautiful picture here the guy kicks a safe into the river look what happened to his toe it's not as a but now obviously it's not as safe and when it means safe it means more like a cash box he threw it into the river now he sues the guy that kicked it and he says I had $100,000 in there he says okay what should we do what do we do in this case that if you torch a mansion to pay everything inside if you swear that this is what you had inside we have that today with insurance companies they don't know what was stolen they have to like there's a lot of trust going on and they I had this much jewelry this much silver you have to bring receipts but you don't have receipts for everything so what do you do you swear and you take because why the Mish says this this is normal for people to have nice things in their house if I said I had $100,000 in the that's normal to have $100,000 in a cash box but over here he's saying it's like you know one of those registers in a store you typically don't have jewels in there you have a lot of cash you're coming from the store in those days they didn't have the buttons and everything but they had a a cash box this is where I take my change from so I'm saying no I had a I had a diamond in there do people put diamonds in these boxes or not I don't know the person says I had a silver a silver cup gra I thought that I we're going to have a beautiful guest today uh aitz so I just happened to bring this but it's here anyway so he's not here he's here in somewhere I was hoping he was gonna come today to this year he gave me this as a gift now if I say I had this in my house it's a nice piece not everybody has this so it depends if you're we can trust you yeah by the way yesterday the I did with a guy the famous that helped us out tremendously at the shabat and a woman came in there with six not so good-looking Beckers you know like yellowish stuff so I start putting in she no no no no no no no what are you doing these are gold 100% gold pure gold she had six beers this size pure gold so I I I sent a message to Y I said do you remember that story am I making it up he says yeah I was there with you and yeah fine at the wedding men's M's brother is from Chicago you didn't tell me that by the way I good friends with him the engagement you would have know okay I'm done with the story okay so anyways so his Ari Cohen's son-in-law comes over to me says have regards from SCH Zach the guy from the you did you once did CM in this that Zach he says you got your first job from him like I I was just talking about him here here's the WhatsApp message that we're talking about Z and the the place anyway o this is worth a little less now okay says the gamar so I say I had a beautiful silver cup in the house that he torched we look he's a wealthy guy make sense he's a person that people trust and other people and trust him with expensive silver today everybody has a right then you could just swear and take but he's not that kind of guy so each person depending on his situation here we go here 's a golin a golin somebody that comes in mid day in in broad daylight and steals from you here's aams hamson if you see in his left hand he has cash uh the guy that's being held up in the ear has a gold watch behind his back and he he says listen you give me the gold watch and here I'll beat you up here's a bunch of cash says gives cash for what he steals doesn't give cash he doesn't pay he gives M call if you hang somebody and torture him until he says or until he sells it to you it's considered a sale so why do you call himam he's not a ghav now he might be a very bad guy for doing this and the ra says he's and all the will yell at you you don't you don't do that you don't force somebody to sell you something but he's not a ghav Don't Call Him A ghav Don't Call Him A which is part of if a guy says I agree to sell great then it's a sale then he's a then then it's a regular sale but the guy doesn't say there's a you you'll come up with your own conclusions at the end there's a guy that was a diamond dealer and he bought a bunch of diamonds he gets on the train and he's going somewhere fire back in the day and he notices that there's a guy that followed him the street as he was buying the diamonds he followed him onto the train and sure enough the guy comes off the train with him so they come to the to the inn and the owner of the in says sorry I only have one room left so one roof so there's no choice they have to share room in middle of the night the ghav gets up and starts searching through all the stuff and he can't come up with any any of the diamonds so in the morning he says listen I got to tell you the truth I'm a GH of I've done this trick a thousand times I have a deal with the owner of the in he has a lot of rooms that are available but when he sees me he says no rooms available he puts me in the room with the other guy and uh in the middle of the night I get up and I go through everything I find it every time tell me where did you hide these diamonds you got to tell me so the guy says you know where I hid the diamonds I hid them in your pocket cuz that's a place that I know you're not going to search what's the most of hos school I have no clue sometimes we'll make one up sometimes the Yeshua comes from the least expected Place sometimes you know that kid of yours the most kid he's the one that brings you the most you know sometimes the the the deal that you thought is the worst deal in the world that's the one that brings you the most yeah in my real estate also the one that the one deal that I thought was the worst deal I I bought it it's my most says the you come up with your own thing gates gates a spark which came from a hammer and caused Great damage it it created a fire that's your responsibility it's your it's your m whatever you want to call it we had to twice a camel that was full of fla he went in a in a public thorough and he overloaded the camel so the flax went into a store and in the store there was a candle there was a a fire it lit up in fire then the camel continues to walk and burns down a house the owner of the camel is why negligent but the store owner put the candle outside and then the camel came by and lit up on fire and burned down a house then the owner of the store is it's just a reminder for the I know a lot of people themselves that after they're going on a serious diet after all those so because you didn't accept you you were on diet for half a day here's a good time remind I know it's after Kana [Music] Kan that's one this is the second one supposedly there's a better version today and here's this is ours that was the first one was official shout out to Ned and you didn't put in the hour one Gary you didn't get it okay put pretend it's pretend it's in it's in and this that's ours I don't see the difference but okay it's only n n seconds says in the name of you can see from the you see there's a over that means that's there's aah to put your Mana below like that high below this okay I don't know exactly something like this a couple feet high a to put it low right doesn't go below 10 in this world but they say he does like you put it below he goes below he goes to the put the Min below where he's at because if it would be okay to put above then why does say that yesterday it was also the same time that the F35 went by F16 no he said F35 he he knows about these things warning oh five minute warning for she exactly why that if you could put it above 10 so put it above 10 why are you putting it below 10 and then you say oh it's not my fault it's you should have put it high enough to to avoid the camel and its Rider from hitting it and burning things down see no not a good RI now the Riff and other they say that we stay with with Ra's V that ra says you see from here that you should put a Mana below 10 why cuz otherwise why would review the say that it's okay to put your Mana in the street put it really high where it avoids the C the fact that thear says now that's a that's a classic style of thear to say you don't have you don't have solid proof I could go this way I could go that way I could say something else but at the end of the day R really felt that that's the so therefore they passing like that you should put your man below which I do have to mention that the whole point of n why why could you put it outside right I forgot to say this because you're supposed to put it outside of the store he has the right to put outside the store because ofum it's better to put outside so I mentioned this I was in Chicago was like I guess I was in Chicago still and uh Mar askanazi and Uncle Phil and a bunch of people they sent me the following day because I said this in share I said I'm it might be from the only people in Chicago that lighted outside when I used to live so they sent me a glass box and a mana and oil they figured I don't have time to this and at the end I didn't use it unfortunately or fortunately I was here says no maybe is you could put it above what's your what's your claim so then why should you be po around you should put it he's doing we didn't want him to go in other words we we don't have to trouble him to go above it's let him let him go below and if there's a fire it's not his fault if you put your candles above 20 which a lot of us do because we live in apartment buildings it's not good they say today might be different you're also facing other people that are that height so we have a couple pictures from the famous in in Su one of the reasons you can't have a Suka that's over 20 hour which is appra 40 feet because then you won't remember that you're in a Suka you won't see the so also when it comes to you have a is when you have an Alleyway between the between different Courtyards so you're not allowed to walk in the alleyway because you might come to walk into the public street but if you put a beam across the alleyway that'll remind you that you're in an Alleyway and you won't carry into the into the street so what if you put your really high above 20 it's possible so too by there an interesting thing look into this because I I really want to know if this is true but claims that there was a missile that hit a sh and they want to know if you should leave the the the Missile hit wall to remind people of the nest that it was it happened two minutes after the last missp walked out of the sh and uh he talks that maybe when it comes to you should have a nice sh you should have a broken wall they left all the bullet holes after Massacre they left it in the you can see it now really the full ofet the says on this week's this week's he says how come didn't that he shouldn't be how come didn't take away his his uh his speech impediment because M wanted to remember why it happened it happened because of a that hasem did to him that he took the coal instead of the gold so he want to remember that for the rest of his life there sometimes that you you leave a Ness out there I know for myself and somebody came over to me after last night's Che and said same thing with me I want to say this when I used to see the word maruba I used to get really nervous like like wow scary stuff it's easy it's it's just like a it's a self-made trauma kind of thing right you ask him to me listen to this it's easy when it comes to G when a person steals something you have to pay two times the amount if you're a golin you do it at night you don't pay two times the amount but there's something called above not only you have to pay twice the amount sometimes you have to pay four and five but only when you steal a sheep you pay four times the amount if you sell it or Slaughter it you you kill it you sh if you steal a cow you have to pay five times the amount and the difference is they say the says because when you steal a sheep you're embarrassed you because you had to carry the Sheep it's smaller this guy walks on his own so he have to pay more it's a special by a cow and a sheep and that's it says the mishna you should know that when you pay there's something extra that doesn't happen when you pay four times and five times when you steal something you can steal a bike a computer gold silver you have to pay double it doesn't have to have life but four and five is only by two items a bull and a sheep now if you steal from a you don't have to pay I had a whole argue with my I found I said that you're not a ghav if you steal from a GH you're not a ghav he had no right to take it it's not even in the it's not in the property of the guy that was stolen from and it's definitely not the ghav he said no it became the Ghana the whole thing and the agrees to me and everybody El ages but you don't pay if you steal from from aov certainly you don't have to pay four and five if you steal from a and then you it or sell it now let me ask you a question we learned if you are a you're watching some else's sheep and you have a big T for land chops so you decide to steal it comes the guy the owner says give me back my sheep he say you know what it was stolen you're so doesn't have to pay if it was stolen then we find out you're you stole it how much you have to pay you have to pay kful because since you want to steal it you did a tin you have to pay question for the you have to pay what about if you went ahead and you shed it for lamp chobs do you have to pay four huh nobody knows you say yes is the same thing same thing okay so that's what we're talking about right now you why didn't why the M say another difference between the two payment and the four payment that what when it comes to K by that lies and says it was stolen oh here he gives him this says and was really stolen and the GH was found he pays so certainly as well you claim that it was stolen as you see this uh chart that claims all the way in the left top corner he claims that was stolen his Potter but if we find out there was was actually not stolen that you try to steal yourself so this actually is uh Yoshi as a young daughter I guess it runs in the family and she did this for us says where's the par he says Ah I don't know M was stolen and then you see the the cow picking its head out so that's the the Sher The Watcher claims that it was stolen so what does the PK say so before we get to the P it only so I have a great difference when he claims that it was stolen we find out that it wasn't stolen he pays twice but if we if he actually went ahead and and and Sheed it or sold it he doesn't pay four and five so it's a big difference here's a case that you pay twice but you don't pay four and five this is a great this is a great RI that there's no difference between K and 45 went ahead and he it it or he sold it and therefore it's not in the mishna because it's exactly the same just like would pay twice he also has to pay four five if he went ahead and he sold it and that's how he some say is a little weaker let's say that it's fine but says you're saying as if the mishna is giving us a whole list of all the differences here's there's only one difference no all the M says there's more there's something different about Kel than four and five I'm not giving you the whole list of there's other things in the list that I'm not going to bring down now I know people get very nervous when it comes to Cloud PR Cloud but not in an hour she everybody knows Cloud PR cloud and if you don't know this the Yi guy that comes around there he looked at me after she he says this the first time in my life I understood cloud cloud because it's so simple take a look what Yoshi did unbelievable here's a GH of it says on a sticker I'm not a daffer okay he's aov so when the tah says let me just show you before I do this let me show you real quickly thees what do you sh says the end sh you pay on what I called in red on everything anything you steal on computers and bikes also and then all the T says in purple only on four things three animals and and clothing and then the says on everything so that's what we call a cloud everything very specific aatt only these four things and then another CL so the rule is when you have a cloud cloud the second cloud comes to say it's everything but it has to be similar in some way to the four items so what are those four items they're not similar cuz one is a suit and the other three are a donkey a bull and a sheep so let's see in the pickup truck the Torah says you to pay double for every item in the world even a carbon with a stal even a star even a chicken a slave on the top everything then it says so we just limited to only four items everything else went out of the pickup truck but then we say CL so now it comes to include more stuff like a chicken but not a not him not a slave and that's it that's the whole Cloud brother CL let's see for now how do you know they have to pay on everything I'm sorry how do you know they you pay for something that lives and that's worth money the it's an exclusion comes to what's the has the AR call it to Cloud what is CL in AR generalization specification when you have this then it has to be similar to the to the four things that were listed you could lift it you could move it it itself has intrinsic value unlike AAR a document that doesn't have value it just says so and so owes me I've called so what come what does it come to exclude land you can't lift it and slaves because there's aage between a and a slave and also documents that say that people owe you money even though you LIF it they don't have intrinsic value and it comes to exclude a carbon why from your friend not from we had this Bo we should know this means that if you touch something that's you yourself become Tom so just like a bull a sheep and the donkey you touch the dead body you become has to be you said it has to be similar let's go all the way s his life so maybe it comes to exclude if I steal a chicken I don't have to pay two chickens says that's impossible to say that one of the four things is clothing and clothing doesn't become Tom it doesn't become it itself is not t yet it becomes Tom it itself doesn't give off T we're talking about livestock maybe within the the live things but a chicken is live so maybe I could exclude a chicken that what hold on I skipped something we're talking about live things because yes you're right one of the things is clothing but don't forget it says four words so based on the other three words that talk about animals let's say it's should be exactly like those animals that are matama birds are not Mama only if you koser bird only if you put it in your mouth so maybe let's exclude theor asks let's exclude kful from chickens and birds Rai have a wonderful [Music] day [Music] for that