Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 51 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] Tower lustrous is that a good word guest parents who sponsored tonight's Mala the pizza and the fries if you're listening live you can still come by there's a bunch of Pies in the back over [Music] there Alex Gilden I just wanted to say I'm enjoying all the new views on the camera including the fact that on a daily basis I can now see the color of your socks very exciting stop don't even try aha your style is even more a little more interesting than I thought interesting whenever I look for the tie now it's got to have the Ellie stansky look otherwise it's just a regular tie see if this on a serious note I've always appreciated and continue to appreciate your care for clly mdy is truly a Crosscut of all's colors from Modern to Etc they only continue to breed and may we be to see rebuilt this year Alex Gilden dear belly I must thank you for the freeor that you sent me the day before I was going to Camp your good yum Rosen knocked on the door and hand me a gor the camp I did a few dve and now I'm right into it for me it's summer holidays and I thought is the way to go I love this song byz okay one of my friends who knows I'm a Rey fan pointed out to me on your very famous quote it's not about the D it's about the Y don't know what he's talking about but okay he sent the picture you should another boy in my class thinks you're Mugo I'm still trying to brainwash him the reason I'm thinking this is that one time I showed him the video see him and he saw you laying on a table I told him that has changed so many families lives including mine my dream is for you to come to Australia and give I was just very excited that in Australia they also use that Lo thank [Music] you the sponsor for the unity of that come from supporting my little five-year-old sister on her 25th yard Side by her brother price my son AA b n g u i gu iig iig on tonight M I don't know what that is but a big all right we're on the bottom of we are 50 days into so here's the shil I was surprised based on the question the fact I'm just asking the question if you were here yesterday don't even try to answer it if somebody dug a pit that's 10 it can kill an animal 10 comes another person along and digs another that's who's first guy or the second guy or both or none huh did I show that thing in Manchester I had it in my but did you show it it was it was there in the I put it in my sheets all right guys from Manchester wiiz matus the guy that I didn't change his life here's the guy here he goes he's calling his wife [Music] over y That's right thank you for putting this together II you should know it was in my um the PowerPoint to show during sh for some reason I skipped over it I don't know what happened yeah you saw it shsi saw it okayy said here we go uh all the way on the bottom so we learned the other day that according to if a bull falls into to a ditch irrigation ditch that's exactly one arm by one arm he gets trapped there he F he falls in so the guy the owner thinks oh it's a great idea now he's trapped he can't move let so said the animals trfe why because we learned something called if an animal Falls perhaps his bones are fed something inside happened so the the way to to he says says all you need to do is wait 24 hours or you let him walk whatever there's ways to figure it out but you went ahead you're you you acted too quickly without asking a of you're going to lose your money but what is he saying he's saying that in since this animal it's possible that it has that creates what a Traer meaning the animal is going to die cuz if he wasn't a TR wouldn't be a problem so what if an animal has a broken bone you to you to eat the problem is maybe there's an internal injury and maybe he's a TR so you see that even though he only fell one Amo one Amo equals six you could still get an internal injury from six and you were saying the whole time that you need is the if the bar was less than 10 the last you see that you pot so you see why you pot because there's no there's no concern that you're going to get a big this's big impact from six there's no Impact says now remember according to Rav you need he you need you need that the ear isn't good so the reason this goes according to R the reason why if it falls into a bar that's listen is because there's no bad ear now when you mention bad ear it's to mention thatan who's the one that said I said I think all the way in the beginning ofama Maybe even the first D says that and we see soon today's d as well the people should learn about nin about hez because hezek is a so he says that if a person goes to let's say and it leaves the front door open he's he's being for in a way because you're letting all the hot air in the the in the winter all the air conditioning we have today you're letting it out think about it before you open up a window in a in a m kades or any place stop like the sensitivity to think about what are you causing here interesting as the if there's know if this the the the thing is the reason why you put is because there's not a lack of bad air there's good air so how come if this animal falls into a lower ditch that's not if he why because I don't know why you said there's no the ear is good so what's the problem you're right the ear is not bad enough to kill an animal but bad enough to damage an animal so what are we trying to prove can an animal die with less than 10 says it could you see even though thisal only fell into one he said strafe oh we have a nice so here we have a guy that's uh in prisoner clothes it's interesting I got to say I got to tell the this person asked me not to read the email so I'm not going to read the email but I will say that a certain person wrote me an email says it's not nice the way with this the the artist is depicting women the pregnant woman why does she have to have such large ears I'm serious real email the ears are too large I'm looking this is a guy has the same large ears it was who was a potato head I don't think he depicted anything he just showed a Potato Head people have to complain about everything we were we depicted a woman with large ears okay so here's a person that's condemned to death and they're about to throw him off this little uh skila base so how tall does it have to be has to be six amas plus his height a person is about three amas three amas is approximately six feet so a total of what 18 feet from his head from the top of his head because he's going to be be falling on his head falls on his head he will die so which is sixs plus his three you have three floors three times three I love this like when when I read it I just laugh to myself says why do you need that height put him on a table like right here that's about 10 and throw him off the table on his head and that will be skila the guy's going to die according to what you just told me that if an animal fell off six he could die so then why do you have to go to such a three to to 12as or six amas plus three amas just knock them off a table okay you say six and but even according to you 10 also kills so so then go to 10 10 the cashes put him on a six put him on a chair throw him off a cheer okay so a chair is too low and according to you a table is good enough enough so put him off the table what do you gain and this again if you were here there's a kid that got this he claims he never heard this and he got on his own it's it's a what is the easiest the easiest one H you know 13-year-old got it I'm a 13-year-old right over here this is the easiest one we have to treat even somebody that's condemned to death even though he has he did something that's and he was warned by Adam not to do it and you still have to treat him with with respect like you would want to be treated what is the best way to die you have to give him the quick death and the quick death means off a higher platform it's interesting that the rambam says I was at somebody's house eating a meal a couple weeks ago I don't remember I'm just going to throw out a couple weeks so nobody CLS who it is and I was talking about a guy that's completely off and the he's uh and I said one word and the one of the guys in the house jumped he says what are you doing start giving you have to know no it is fine the ra says that there's no mitvah to love somebody that's over in public and that you are you tell him don't do it and he doesn't listen there's Noah there's aah to hate him MIT to hate him he says so what's going on over here if there a mitah to hate somebody like that this this person just went and he over something with with and everything and he wasn't so maybe thead is that once he's in this position that he's about to die so they tell him you have to do V and everything so maybe at that point he's already he's the cha Etc just I'm not a r again but maybe he shouldn't yell at people if you talk about a guy and he was warned is that there's no there's no is now I'm going to get from all these emails and this you told me told me is that good or that's bad okay but I don't think these are the you wanted me to say the want me to say the okay it's interesting that the SAT says that what they say about the bov and his that he used to be M he would like say no you didn't do such a he never did that he would D for that they should do CH but he would never tell a rush in his face oh you're a good guy hem loves you and this kind of stuff okay I'll come on him so says the G if that's the case that we have to put him we have to dump him off a high platform should die quick have much better idea put him in a here M's here anybody want to buy a plane he's selling his plane but before this is I hope you're buying like a Cirrus or something schmack that jet or something but no is a great idea you take this convict you bring him on the plane and you tell him there's a parachute on his on his back say you want to go for your last jump before he jumps and by the way there's no as he push him out you you know 10,000 foot fall he's going to die instantly that's not that's not no that's not good why because his his limbs are going to Splatter everywhere and that's not nice that's not so don't exaggerate over here this also I I started saying this joke this is a joke from from a kid but all the kids in in the Israelis they know this joke the Americans don't know these kind of jokes what is the difference between a guy that jumps off a one-story building and a 10 story building you say guy that's right who said that that's Israeli you have know Israeli all Israelis know this the the guy that jumps over one story goes It goes like this boom ah and the guy that jumps off 10 stories ah boom okay fine I didn't say oh so let's go back to this it says in the about so it says like this first of all you have a house this a house that's house and this D you cause death you're falling from a house to the not vice versa not from to the house whoever is talking I don't know who you are I'm not going to look up there and down there it's just it's disturbing so says like this not that you fall from to here I think we have to go this way oh if theim is taller than the house he fell from to Potter cause that's not your obligation you don't have to put a Maka you hear G we have to put a Mak one of these days it's not our it's not your the city has to put a fence there whoever is in charge of the road that's not your problem what is your problem but if you do this you're from a house you fell from your obligation you have to make sure that people don't fall off your property why because the p says now but if a person could die less than 10 you be obligated to put a even less than if the the fall is less than 10 P attention theah says to be house and if the house is not then it's not a house now if you if you're measuring a house from the outside of the house and you telling me that it's a t house it's very possible that with the this is not a real picture cuz we want to show really here my picture might have been better no it's also not the house it's better if he fell off the house the question is like this you have a house that's T tall off the roof to the floor is T but wait a minute the roof takes up room there's Rafters the shingles the drywall all this stuff so inside the house maybe you have uh six left it's not a house inside has to be 10 it's not a house why is that called a house you're right he drilled underneath he got he he made the house with inside outside it's tent with the roof but inside he dug deeper into the ground than he has inside the house he does have 10 told me Mish recently that in the old city his cousin was drilling to get a little bit more into the room he wanted to they said it figured okay these the walls in the old city are very very thick so he told the kaban take off half the wall we have will spread out so the guy's drilling drilling Al a knock on the door the cops are there yeah he said there's a sh around the corner down the block underneath that somebody is trying to steal the sa there's a drill bit in the AR KES and we think it's coming from your house he didn't even know there's a he said it's called or something something like that so he says okay there a drill bit Ines so no didn't touch so he said okay what I'm going to do is I'm gonna go down to leave the part going to drill this di or whatever it was downwards so they start drill building they're going down down down all of a sudden one of the bricks Falls and like keeps on going they go in there they look and they see there's a tunnel they're on a tunnel this tunnel like a water kind of shaft that goes all the way to the what I say it's called the Cordova Cordova whatever that is he said this by the huh cardo the cardo the cardo that's right the cardo this whole thing like hundreds and hundreds of feet underneath this house this everything's built on top of everything it's gavic over there okay so do not do don't try if you live in The Old City at least don't go downwards so as oh if you could do this trick a normal person probably you know even if you're very short you probably want to live in less than at least 10 right so then why do you need a house that from the outside is 10 you got have a house that's from the outside four and you dug very deep you got you got 10 within in the house it's still considered a house and you still be in a says okay says that water animal that fell into becomes a when you look at the animal from its stomach down from it belly down you have at least four right a horse that's standing up his legs are at least four probably 10 or more but let's give it four yeah so then you have from its stomach to the floor this animal fell into was so total which is yeah one four plus 6 is 10 so this animal said is TR you're right that the actual ditch is only six but the animal is at least four tall so it fell in it fell from like the when Once its head fell or whatever fell it hit it was 10 falles say they need yeah according to that we're talking about according to ra you need ear but Accord bad but according to the animal dies from the from the impact so six is enough because the animal is at least four say so we have a picture here this is take a look in other words it's it's not standing up tall it's its head is right there let's say this bar is six so how much did the animal fall six if it's standing up straight if fell 10 because the legs are at least four says says the oh sto okay fine I was just going to say that the rner says in terms of doing things that are dangerous I don't know if this is the right place to say it but okay just put it over here things that are dangerous and uh like he talks about driving and we spoke about it because this uh there's a a Friday that somebody got killed in bar Park somebody ran a red light in bar Park and then the cops went and they looked at all the videos uh in bar Park and so that I forgot how many 15 people went through red lights or something Arab shs doing a rush so he talks about it he just says it's to know he says that there's no when it comes to these things it's what's common sense and the law is to protect Society it's not a oh you have to obey the law because it's have to obey the law because otherwise being a ma and you to make sure not to go through red light he talks whole fine just thought throw it in there why because we're talking aboutus we're talking about this so fine if you have a bar that's own by two people oh do we have a sponsor yeah sponsored the the the pit is own by two people the first guy walked by and he didn't cover it and the second guy came and he didn't cover it so Rashi brings right away we're see in the gar that it's a very special case it's not that the first guy went by and didn't cover it and then the second went by and didn't cover it because if that's the case the would be who's the first guy saw number one he owns his bar he noticed that his bar is not covered and he keeps on walking comes short of number two sees the bar is not covered and keeps on walking who's huh you say two both first one good second one we have we have we have first one second one and both the is both the both the both were negligent the first one was negligent he saw that's not covered so how come over here the mishna says that the second one is because thear is going to talk about a situation where the first one gave over the rain so to speak he said you're responsible now okay you're responsible oh if he said that and they did either they gave him the the cover whatever it is then he's I just need to understand the situation how is it possible in this world to have a bar that's owned by two people it's impossible says the if you hold that a is possible to be okay then I understand the the land was owned by by both of them the pit is owned by both of them like we said in the other Mish and they disown their own they said anybody can walk there but they kept on to the bar remember is the one that holds that a bar how's it possible so let's go through all the the all the ways it's possible so they don't possible if they sent guy to dig the ditch for them they told him you are go ahead and dig out a bar it's also to do something that's not VAR for somebody else and if you do it it doesn't go it doesn't go after the two people that sent you you yourself are liable it's also to beik the property of the public yeah so you don't have to go into it but I I was very upset on Friday somebody sent out a video they're looking for two guys two FR people that walked into one of the lobbies in this neighborhood with a hammer and broke the the screen hell shouldn't be a screen in this Lobby okay that's already private property I'm talking about even public property some people believe you let a garbage cans you allow to destroy public whatever it is they go I'm saying it's AER this iser to to destroy public property okay the says it here most people learn that's that's the of destroying public property going to him and to destroy that yeah to go back to to says that people are very Mo learning M which is a lot of the like and all and even which is if you wear but to go and to damage somebody's property that's so maybe people should be moreid on learning that okay okay this guy dug five and this guy dug five so when the second guy dug the the final five of the bar then the first guys out of it okay so we're going to see literally in three lines but the gar doesn't even say what it is we going to see that there's between that if somebody dug a nine and another person came along and added the final 10th now it's a killing bar it's a killer so according to Reby you're a you become a partner only for and according to the second guy is always even on so according to rebi only there's only basically one CH in one case hez hezek when it comes to damages you could be a partner with somebody why because the guy that dug nine he could damage the guy that dug 10 he just added to the damage okay so they both sh him in damage but to kill an animal you need 10 so you're not a partner with anybody you that dug the 10 you're the only one liable Accord even you're not a partner so as if you're talking about re and that one case of damage Mish okay there's a case where somebody one partner dug nine the the second partner dug 10 the 10th now they're Partners but according to rebbi himself there's no partnership when it comes to death of an animal and according to certainly there's no partnership the second guy is the only guy that's so then what's the situation tell me how do you how do you have a bar in middle of that two people own it we have a picture a fixed picture from Friday and they are they're holding on oh they're holding on to I got this from AI nobody helped me but on Friday the said that you could see the string through the hand it wasn't now Yi fixed it up basically the the bar let's say was nine and the two of them pulled out the final together so now you have a bar this is interesting sh of the water how water works okay that that's that's today's Su we'll get to it it might not be the most accurate picture it's huh what's aul is like um no no no no this is this is a stone a is like it's like a stone material like one of the no is is a piece of not earth like no like I I believe it's like like a ring like a ring that's what do the AR say it's a part of the part of the dirt that you take out huh a clump of dirt to me means a round thing like the the bar is made out of a bunch of round and he pulled out the last one over here he pulled out they pulled out a stone they made it oh I see there's a nice video coming out maybe shut that off for a second I need to see what this is I have no idea what this is okay we could show it hold on we could show it this is M okay you ready first first time I'm seeing this so here's one guy oh is yeah it is for there one guy took water and he left the other guy behind that's what thear is gonna say it's not bad so the second guy he's the guy that's because I don't know exactly what happened over there something okay so it's not it's not exactly accurate to what says but okay we get the idea says oh so again so how do you have in a bar they both pulled out the last Stone together in say one dug a pit that's nine and the other one came and made it re says there's a partnership only Forin and not for the death of an animal an animal is only the second guy we this why have to say that you dug a pit even if you open up the pit you're person dog after another person the second person got it to 10 by him doing the 10 he got rid of the first guy completely he took the entire responsibility upon himself I love how thear does that thear understands that you remember what we learned at least yesterday now if you're Ina you learned it six months ago but if you're in you learned it yesterday and you should really remember it but we still don't remember it that what we said that that it could be the guy that opens it he didn't do a m really the guy that K maybe maybe if he dug completely maybe he has to fill it up in order not to be that's why you need those two fine says what I they skipped only a few lines they had the same from yesterday here we see it on the thing so means one person is who the second guy is whether it's NE whether it's second guy is always the says to exclude it's not it can't be to be was one person what does he do with is we learned if the bull himself digs a pit here you have both of them here two is is and what he's going to do with the second one so again what do we have from the two one is that a person and not a sh if a sh digs a bar his owner is not and also the second one that two people that dug a bar two people are only one is fine because you're talking about talking about it says so to match it it says also it could have you're right it could have said fine but it just matches say very good so learn that only is one person is if there two partners but which partner maybe the guy that dug nine he did most of it he did 90% of the damage how do you know how do know that's the the last guy it says that the guy that pays the one that caused that but you can't learn from there why because I already used these three words if a person has a that he made it or even a and it got a so you you redeem it now that red redeemed Bull Falls into somebody's pit why it has to be yours completely since you weren't able to give it over to your dog you can't feed it to the dog it still has a little bit dou to it sort of so it's not 100% yours not 100% yours you don't get paid if it falls into a pit but you still need those words you can learn two things from here because it's obvious we're talking about the guy that did the final t we're not talking about the guy that that did n the guy that did 10 because his death over here so obviously he's the guy that the p is talking about about oh we're not there here now it's going to be the answer very good what was the question as a guy that that dug a pit 10 for him until now until now we're learning nine and 10 that's not that's we don't have an answer yet now we're going to learn 10 and 20 10 and 11 in other words that's 10 comes another guy and adds one to it who a guy dug a another guy added 10 more each and every one of them is because the first guy was the second guy just added they're all Partners so that answers the thing whoever said two people are both are is right there's a pit that's 10 Deep could kill an animal comes a guy and this is let's say yeah comes a guy this is a m a first class M he goes and he he he puts a little lime on it he Smooths it out real nicely then takes paint and he makes nice drawing says rash in the m is a place that's not his there no nothing the city's going to come soon and fill it up he decided now it's a good time to draw in middle of Rob him underground so he's why is the second guy because he made the bar more narrow narrower and a narrower bar has less oxygen bad ear kills the animal oh so isn't that similar to our case where a guy dug 10 and another guy dug 20 over here a guy dug a pit and he made it even narrower so both of them should be why is only one of them oh I don't have it what's the sponsor again oh sponsored by Jonathan stansky to remind that it's the end of the year and we have a SI 46 so you can get your on your taxes it's a great idea and Jonathan's fancy the minute he heard it he jumped out of his seat went to that Nar plus which is still intact the some guys are running around the city breaking them that you can't do anything but douche on it and uh ours is intact so maybe oh so maybe in order to answer the the question is say that we have this bar that is two different people that made it narrower one one made it narrow than the other so what then in we said that according to re n and 10 a n and according to so maybe he'll also wants to say say no it's only one guy that's that's why this with the Sid over here only one guy [Music] only one person is the last guy when you talking about nine and 10 so the the guy that did the 10th he's the one that's responsible but in our case it's already he just went deeper he made it 20 so it's a it's a deadly pit to begin with then the second guy didn't add death he just added depth I just came out on the spot number in that case maybe will agree that both are Partners to the death of the animal ask the first guy made a it's already and the second guy that came and made it narrower it's already wasn't over there was very wide so couldn't kill an animal from the bad ear oh the second guy came along and he added bad ear that's very similar to a n pit that the second one added the T making a Misa pit over here we have a wide pit that doesn't cause death and he made it narrow that cause death same thing in other words according to [Music] this that you say that both is great so why how do you explain the Sid one that the last gu no there was no B ear there at all not even to damage anybody fine and according to that says anyway there's a problem with so says r talking about he put some mattress on the bottom over there interesting sh it's in the reverse until now we said you saw the picture of the two pulling out a stone from the bottom of the pit and they made a 10 that's from the bottom what if you have a nine pit and he goes and adds a I'm going to call it a this round thing all the way around made it now so what's the Shiloh why is it why should it be different okay now he made a 10 pit according to both them according to only the second guy is what's the difference okay that's a typical case that a guy made it a guy went from 9 to 10 and according to ra the second gu to the second guy when you dig out you added another you added bad ear to the bottom I know you're thinking over here about this hav it's like making you crazy how does it work right I know I know how you're thinking but on top when you added a on top you didn't have bad ear you had a good ear that's where the good ear is on the top kamash no by you adding another on top where it's good you created bad ear all in the bottom on the bottom it's really bad ear a guy dug a Nine Pit the second guy came around this is going to shock you maybe second guy comes around and adds another now it's a deadly pit and then he does chuva and throws the dirt back in what happened perhaps when he added or when he time out he took out the thing and he put the thing back in no no no no look in the says he made it 10 and he added he made it nine why he the he did he did says maybe by him making it 10 then the first guy that did nine is gone we don't look at him anymore perhaps now he became the balabas of the bar the fact that he did chuva doesn't help or no maybe he just brought it back to this the the the the situation that it was before he started digging before he started digging was nine he brought it back to nine now ruen who [Music] dug we have a beautiful picture here oh here we go there's a bar the total depth of this bar is eight but out of the eight there's two of water so any water that you have you have to times it by two so two equals four so four + 6 right because you had eight the total depth is eight there's only six of ear two of water two of water are equal four so four plus 6 equals 10 so says that's a case of a bar that kills my the way we calculated is each of water it's two of Earth of of of no of no Earth okay so two of water equals four plus the six above it so when you have eight eight cavity of the bar and two of the eight are water that's considered 10 ask the check this out what about oh what about no no what's going on here let me go let me do it manually here we go okay what about nine of a pit a pit that's exactly n deep but one the last is water so you have seven no that this is not over is not good let's see okay this is hold on a second let's just read it let's see what happens here there nine and one is water so that one of water equals two and total you have eight there's only eight of ear one of Water 2 plus eight he wrote seven it has to be an eight okay there's a mistake here y I hope the next one he did okay where it says seven it should say eight okay do we say the same calculation or perhaps this's very little water so very little water doesn't really Killa let's see this one I hope he did better over here I think so but why is it not moving oh yes that's better Bara the total depth of this pit is seven but the three water 3 * 2 is six plus the four on top is 10 maybe it's not deep enough basically the question is do we take this this formula of of the eight and do we do it in different in different ways a guy finds a pit and he makes it wider what's this I don't know what this one is these are all this came after oh I guess this is it here we go oh this is nice I like this you have a pit that's 10 by 10 by 10 I think that's what this is for here and he made it wider he made it 11 let me just make sure he did it the right way yes if you look on the right side it's not moving he made it why to the left okay what do you mean what's the problem he did he did a favor to the bar now there's more oxygen in there it's less of a killer if an animal is coming from the left and he's walking he's going to get to this uh bar a little quicker maybe that's what tripped him up he was used to having a bar that's only 10 and he would walk around today Suddenly It's wider he fell in and let's check it out if the animal died from lack of oxygen then then the opposite he shouldn't be because he added oxygen over here but if you look at the uh at the report from the uh the veterinary coroner he says there a brain hemorrhage something so you know that he died from from the fall not from the lack of oxygen so he's because he made it happen earlier no let's just check it out depends if he came from the right or the left in this exact case if he came from the right side of this picture then he's Potter why because he didn't add to the right side he added to the left sorry if he came from the left then he's if he came from the right he added oxygen so he should be if you have a bar that's exactly the width is the same as the height let me just say simple if it's exactly the height of the and the width the height of the bar is exactly the same of the width what's in other words if the width of the bar is greater than the height of the bar then there's a lot of oxygen in there if the width of the bar is narrower than the height of the bar then everybody agrees there's a lack of oxygen the question is is exactly [Music] what's if it's exactly it's no good it'll kill it won't kill the is if the death is more than the will first guy comes along and doesn't cover the pit when is the first guy poter so you look rash over here says that what we know for facts says they must have used this bar if you're just going to read it simp the as the M says it that one guy saw his own pit didn't cover the second guy came says Rashi both of them are because the first guy also is negligent by walking by his own bar and not covering so what point is the first guy [Music] Potter when the guy just lets the other guy go by he like like we saw in this video that he was drawing water and then he left him over there he says okay now it's your turn it's not enough just to leave him there he has to give him the cover the menal the menal he gives him the menal the manal a guy is drawing water from a well and then his friend says leave the the pale and everything I want to I also want water one is as long as he puts the pale down then it's the other guys's responsibility he has to give him the cover of the well oh so this is very very interesting what's the what's the what's the the is going to a place that you never dream of it's about retroactive clarification unbelievable when you say yes so if you have two partners that own a well well together they own all the water together if you say this retroactive clarification so every time ruin takes a cup of water it's 100% his and every time shim takes a cup of water retroactively we collect clarify that that's the cup of water that was his to begin with if you say am that means that every drop of water is a mixture of Ruben and shim you can never divide it oh so therefore I need to protect my water and you have to watch your water you have to watch your part of the bar and I have to watch my part of the bar that's if you say yes we're divided here if a then you become says rash you're actually I'm watching your stuff so if I'm watching your stuff you got to make a break over here yeah it's a little interesting I know so each one is filling up his own thing so now in order unless if if I give you over the the cover of the pit now I am transferring I have to watch everything at all times you have to watch everything at all times by me giving you the cover of the pit now you have to watch it but no we all own everything together so now it's my responsibility right now to watch your stuff I have to watch yours because in every cup of water and every part of the well there's a little bit of you a little bit of me so I'm watching your stuff that's what the gamar says interesting similar thing you have two partners that got into a big fight and they hate each other say I'll never benefit from you and you'll never benefit from me I certainly so they can't even go into their own real estate not true they could go in and each one takes a part why if you hold I could retroactively clarify what I own what you own so I went into my part you went into your part no each and every inch of the real estate is owned by both of us and therefore you can never get in there it's interesting we're going to have this we're going to have it two more times tomorrow it's repetitive but if I sell a well to my friend once I give him the cover of the well there a as the very simple what's the case if I bought with cash so I bought with cash I don't need a cover if I'm treating it as real estate and I'm going to sit there and show everybody mind and do whatever I need to do forget about the cover yeah you're right I want to buy but you need the owner to say you there's a need to hear those words from the seller but if the seller didn't say those words all he did is he gave over the cover it's as if he said specifically go have a wonderful evening have a wonderful week tomorrow bem at 7:15