Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
morning
Bo here's a guy putting a video together
for mdy but you have to listen to the
first three seconds unbelievable listen
carefully okay here goes some
[Music]
volume wow you he
that
[Music]
okay wow this is from Gaza yeah to Gaza
to Gaza
G say this is the story that we said
yesterday what's the guy's name again he
comes here all the time he was
learning father yakob L comes does death
this is pre this is just a thank you
video to Donnie
F so like you can see this is the helmet
that we had till now you can see it's
dancing on my head you can see the
difference on everyone how it looks the
amazing helmets that you gave us so I
want to thank MIT opportunity group for
the amazing donation and Donny fine for
helping us getting the very good
tactical helmets that will help us in
our missions thank you very very
much he's binging his helmet little did
he know that just a few days later
that's the helmet that with that helmet
he got a massive gash how many stitches
did he have a lot you don't want to see
I saw the picture yeah it's very bad
massive gash maybe this this this long
many many stitches and danif with his he
does was it called Mitzvah
opportunities he has opportunities he
does different he gets people braces
pays People's rent and giv the
opportunity people jump in there and
give him money it's galic here he is
very very familiar face he comes around
all the time here he is holding the da
is this after no this is a little while
ago this is before oh so he's part of
the sh beforehand years ago oh this
picture is four years ago ah
unbelievable he's not the guy that does
magic right no that's a different guy
using it h reelly I'm only 12 years old
but I enjoy your she so much so much
that I started doing the nearly every
single day aring and as my son is
learning this peraga is enjoying doing
some by
watching since the shabat that still my
bones I started K from br
and it makes my day and life even better
by finding an extra half hour my day to
learn and teach my class every day
something I love you Hebrew sh by
getting in another language checking
out we got to jump in we're gonna we
have a lot to complished today so
huh oh I have to show that picture of
bar foran what you
[Laughter]
saying this just that day that I'm
holding already by
the sponsors at 718 first time in
history there's a problem all right the
sponsor for the unity
of come from
supporting brain intact unleash your
full
potential success in all my
Endeavors I don't see any oh what's your
name from wow welcome come
off here's a question for
the a guy was
upset at his competition that was
selling Fabrics so he
took meat nice fresh meat went into the
store pretended that he's purchasing
something and he hid the meat within the
Fabrics of course uh a week later
there's a tremendous stench and uh
there's nothing you could do about it he
took apart everything and he found this
meat which ruined most of his uh
upholsteries and fabrics what kind of
damage is that are
you I'm talking about a smell is a re
considered a damage it's not
heiker
huh but it's not it didn't happened
today the smell wasn't there today was
something that developed over a period
of time so that's one of the things
we're going to see
today we're holding like uh I don't know
15 lines from the bottom
of we had RAV said a very interesting
that if you put fruit in front of an
animal even if it's
[Music]
poison this is that an animal should not
eat should control itself who told the
animal to eat somebody else's fruit
raes was mind-boggled by the statement
he said must be that RAV which was his
rebi and we know RAV is a t was po as
the first Moira must be that he was
about to do off he said it he was going
in and out of Consciousness he didn't
really say such a straight out and he
proves it he proves that he was wrong
thear says it's not such a great
proof ra stays with his thing
that so we're holding here
by perhaps we could prove that RAV is
wrong a woman goes in to grind her
weat she walks into the mill without
permission starts
grinding the owner has a guard dog and
the guard dog eats up all the wheat
Potter of course the owner is Potter
and if the animal was damaged by the
weat maybe the animal slipped on it ate
it whatever you chat you want to
learn but according to why don't we
invoke who told the animal to eat the
wheat it's not her
fault so he say to this great
cas so if you look at the chart over
here so basically it's identical to our
mishna so you're asking raish you're
asking us a question from
a the words are identical so you didn't
gain
anything we already
explained as RAB Gan said yday means
slip not eat okay so Imus over here also
means the dog slipped on it didn't eat
it eating a dog should control himself
slipping something else he put something
slippery on the floor for
that yeah but okay what's the you're
bring me something that's word for word
from our mishna to our mishna and you're
asking me a question okay we already
established that our mission is talking
about slipping so this PR is
also there is one big difference look at
the wording they're almost like
identical it's a
story and then look at the
green they're identical green to Green
then you go to the
red the bottom one but in the M
says if you want to
bees could be a whole new thing the
first sentence is in green that the
animal at
it if the animal was damag with it
meaning it slipped on it but by the
woman it doesn't say so it it means the
pases means first it says the animal ate
after the animal ate and it was damag
not not in it with it that it slipped on
it hus finished there was he what what
what makes a lot of sense hezek means
from the statement earlier that the
animal ated and there was this damage if
you add the one word b now could say
maybe it means slipped the Hees was
caused with
it okay so that one word made us think
that it's a little difference talking
about and now that you you want to say
it goes like
gra no the the is like R would say that
both are talking about that the animal
slipped but no difference it's talking
about the
same
you bring your animal into somebody
else's domain and the animal eats over
there ate a lot of wheat vit and he got
a terrible stomach disease and animal
dies
po had permission then the owner of the
the damage that was caused
to why is
the animal should know don't eat that
much don't don't eat yourself till you
get sick actually just remembered I I
saw that there's such a thing that the
cows and animals they could overeat and
they they just die you have to control
them don't ask me a question from a
place that's talking about with
permission over there since the owner of
the domain allowed the animal to come
in that's what we discussed the other
day he accept upon himself
full says the interesting I asked Yoshi
we ran out of time it would have been an
interesting uh
Cartoon even if a cow takes the you know
goes up to The Gallows and puts the the
the the the Noose around his neck you
have to prevent everything no matter
what make sure this cow doesn't over Etc
but when you
go then of
course okay so we had again what's the
what's the here say that when you allow
somebody to come into your Dom you for
instance I'm not again I'm not saying
that this is the but just to make it
more relevant you allow somebody to do
long-term parking
by oh which remind me I heard a
beautiful V from aari is that his name
unbelievable speaker from Manhattan he
was at my uh far beautiful beautiful we
have to get him for the shabbaton
everything everything that he said
was what no no no from he's in the east
side he
is huh Rabbi the saff synagogue saff
synagogue man he was on he said he was
on the plane and he saw a guy with
Korea so he went over them he said
listen when you go to the airport
there's long-term parking and short-term
parking Mia is around the corner here
Mia look what's going on M is around the
corner you're going to bury your father
in short-term parking you'll see him in
a few in a few days don't worry about it
I I thought it was very nice it was a
beautiful thing it's a
nice maybe you're a little scared
shortterm parking it's good okay guy
does long-term parking he's there for a
month what kind of do you have on his
vehicle say when you give somebody to
park in your driveway automatically
without saying a word you become a sh
rebi says no you have to specify I am a
Sher if he doesn't specify
not
when this individual accepts upon
himself to be a whether he said it like
re whether it happened automatically
like did he say I'm going to prevent my
own children and my own animals from
damaging your
vehicle I'm taking that no one in the
neighborhood is going to ride his bike
next to your car and scratch
it so here we have a nice
little chart that Yoshi
did what's going on here is not to get
confused there's three people involved
three owners owner number one is Ruan he
owns this
whole Here Comes owner number two Mr
shim and he places down fruit he owns
the fruit comes own owner number three a
guy that owns an animal and he eats the
fruit okay so there's a guy that owns a
property a guy that owns the fruit a guy
that owns the
bull said as they were learning I guess
in those days it was called today we
split it up into
Bas they're
learning he's learning
the the guy in the blue suit he puts
down the
fruit this is exactly our question this
is the the child riding a bike scratches
the car with a handlebar why because
this is a sh that walks in owned by
another guy not the owner of the mru
rather Mr Ley has a bull and it comes in
from another
place so the owner of the bull
is and if he had permission to to bring
his Bull in
there I'm sorry if if if the if the guy
had permission to bring his fruit in
there
[Music]
what's a simple explanation
who talking about the owner of the
property if it was done without
permission he's Potter it was done with
permission the owner of the property is
on the fruit ah another bull ate it okay
so go to the owner of the bull and grab
money from him later
on so we have a r here here's the owner
of the he gave permission to shim to put
his fruit down now comes
an how do you say it exterior some other
external thing you external damage from
a
bull it's not his bull it's some other
guy's bull it's Le's Bull and we're
saying so you see that if a kid rides
his bike pass the car and scratches the
car you the owner of the driveway
is that's not the way to learn
it we're talking about the owner of dox
so if the guy the owner of the fruit had
permission to put the fruit there then
the owner of the ax is if not he's po as
the obviously we went through this why
did I say the is that's the owner of the
because I understood that a campy that
is the owner of the bull
why who cares if the guy put his fruit
in there with permission without
permission your bull came and ate it
your bull is you have nothing to do with
this your bu came from outside and ate
somebody's fruit and what difference
does it make if you had permission to
put the fruit there it's none of your
business if shim had R just from ru to
put his fruit in ru's you're Mr Ley take
care of your bull make sure your bull
doesn't eat my
fruit so don't forget
this we're talking about the damage of
shen when an animal causes damage
through benefiting from the damage
through eating through scratching its
back it must be must be in
[Music]
the
so if Ruben gave permission to shim to
put his
fruit so shim all of a sudden becomes
the owner of
Ru when Ru gives him permission to place
his fruit down so Hally he acquires that
space that he put his fruit down so now
when ley's bull comes in there and eats
shim's fruit it's from shim's property
oh now you have to pay
sh just throwing on this chart here if
anybody wants to see some of the that we
learned however if shim came in there
without permission put down his
fruit
now yes it's in the of Ru but Ru never
gave permission so it's
considered or in other words it's
not it's not in the domain of that who
was damaged
so fine
next it just means that once you have
obviously Ruben is the owner of the if I
let you be
my I let right I give you to come into
my
place I didn't I didn't sell it to you I
didn't rent it to
you but that was that was a discussion
we had yesterday the day before that
when I put something down do have what
kind of we're actually going to talk
about it now we're going to go into that
what kind of do I have when I come into
your property you give
me similar cases
here you bring in your bull into
somebody else's
property again this is almost identical
to what we just said just a slightly
different case and therefore the shackle
of attire is going to be almost
identical before we said you put fruit
in shim came brought brought fruit in
now shim came and brought a bull in and
another bull the same story as before
another bull Ley bull comes from a
different place and cause
damage if he did it with
permission again the same
exact means that the owner of the of the
is poter but if he gave to the bull to
come in and another bull damaged him
you're
why the owner of the the owner wow
there's a seat right for you right here
[Music]
here standing off Guy brought in over a
thousand people to learn
phenomenal
[Music]
so so why the owner of the was
M Ma on himself I I let you bring your
bull in come here come
[Music]
come for coming
[Music]
wow the
famous if you're knew year if you're not
okay I just saw your cartoon what D was
it like gim or something I forgot where
it was where you're standing in front of
that TR
inel it was a whole long one yeah okay
fine fine okay we have a again that a
external damage came inside
the you the owner of the says the the
same we had a second
ago the owner that that that caused the
damage
he's what difference does it make if
there was permission for the first sh to
be there or not both of them the owner
should
be right right your your your bow
damaged my my my bow who cares if if the
first guy had permission or
not we're doing a little what we learned
before is the one that says that yes
there's a difference between a time and
a m but that's
only in when it comes to when your bull
enters my property and causes damage in
my property you have to pay the full
[Music]
amount so therefore once again if you
have permission to be there then it
turns into your for
this pay the full amount but if you
brought your bull into Ruben's domain
without
permission that's the
typical so rash oh it says Potter so
rash right away says Potter just means
you don't pay full NE you pay means you
pull you pay the full amount
okay is a good thing you know notied
that
says I got to show you this beautiful
video that was done just for
the um I had a nause specifically from
when the woman finds out I noticed her
left foot is tapping she's like nervous
upset here there's a few there's nuances
here take a look at this
Misa she's needing dough obviously she's
baking
bread
we had a problem with the
[Music]
sound get
Herer yeah doesn't have a beer was the
had a beard he lost his beard
all what happened
there of the owner the owner the owner
gave permission to this woman to bake
bread and he had a pet goat we had a guy
here and he comes to DAV every day very
of person Burman he didn't want to get
his kids a dog so when I moved to the
neighbor like what in the world I see a
guy walking the street with a goat a
leash and a goat Mish he says oh they
don't make a big mess you don't have to
clean up after them the the is small
it's a go it's a ker animal you remember
this
okay so I don't know if he's n with me
saying it but anyways it's good so the
guy had a look you seen the gar people
had pet
goats the goat came and ate the woman's
D does she have the responsibility to
make sure that other people shouldn't
other animals other PE things shouldn't
eat her dough the animal ate the dough
and went fight
lost his life now I don't know exactly
how it works I'm not a doctor I was
theorizing yesterday that perhaps it's
from the alcohol in the dough the
fermentation killed it some guy said no
maybe it blocked all the uh it's a
Malaga so it stores it and comes up from
one stomach KS into some blockage
whatever theat is it dies it's not good
some certain things are not what certain
things are not good for so let's see
inside
huh
oh it ate the key in the
[Laughter]
door she had permission to go into this
house to bake
bread the goat came the owner of the
house is goat ate the D he became ill
Miss and he dies so the
says said you have to pay for the for
the goat asked
the
we just learned this the continuation
the you tell an animal who told you to
eat yourself to death who told you to
eat do that's not you eat grass says
the I'll say this biter as a thing I
didn't I'm taking things out and putting
things in here the in the we say on P
night a lot of people
say and then
so I think
it's I think this might be the first
time I'm quoting him I think a lot of
people
say he makes if the cat ate the goat so
the cat is the bad guy so then the dog
is the good guy so then the the the
stick is the bad guy and he make all a
sudden you go all the way back
to he did the wrong thing he killed the
is the good guy she says no you're
making the wrong the the cat is bad it
ate the goat but the dog had no right to
get involved why the dog get involved
he's bad oh and then from there on it
goes the stick is good is good
okay oh sorry I think I
scry somebody should do a check here to
see if the word Amry is special to
bakama I don't remember it so often
every five
minutes
said in the case
of he didn't have didn't have permission
to come in
there didn't accept upon himself to
watch
it over here the woman had permission to
come
in but the point is it's on a woman it
says on the side she accepted upon
herself since she had permission to come
in she accept her upon herself to to
make sure that there shouldn't be any
damage theor is gonna explain why this
case is a little
different how come in the case when you
have permission to go I'm sorry you
don't have permission to go into the
mill and and the dog ate all your wheat
and we said over
there because was
per seems like if she had permission to
go and grind her weat over there she
would be
Potter from the from the damage that
happen to the
animal makes a distinction when
you make dough you have to roll up your
sleeves rolling up your sleeves
says she's
revealing her arms and to reveal arms
is not so the guy that owns the house
and gave permission he has to walk out
of the house he can't look at the
N but when you're grinding wheat you
don't need to roll up your
sleeves the owner doesn't have to remove
himself so the owner is still there so
the owner should watch his own goat or
or
dog but when it comes to making
bread
she must roll up her sleeves she doesn't
want to get dirty from the
D the owner of the he removes himself
from the place oh once he moves away
from there then it's obvious to
everybody that's
there she herself must watch everything
that's going on including to make sure
that the guy's goat doesn't eat the
dough who else is going to watch the
goat if he he must remove himself from
the room I just want to show the I'm not
a big uh
or I don't pound this but if people want
to see a source so this
is he makes a distinction very
interesting he
says when it comes to a face of a woman
or her hands depends on the minut of the
place the
feet
or so talking about from the toes to the
knee that all depends on what the Min is
in your place that you
live because he sees this all the time
no
here in a place that they do cover from
the knee down then she cannot reveal a
here's the big
but but from her elbow up and from her
knee above her
knee even if everybody in that City goes
with many skirts or whatever it
is like those who are
pro the is that from the knee above and
from the elbow and above it's user in
any case whether that's the Min or not
the Min to reveal that's what the M
says uh and the famous story from
LA we had a but I think it'sa she was a
Mira woman who the prince in moraco
wanted to marry her and she refused so
she said okay off with your head we're
going to tie you to the tail of a horse
and drag you through the the streets and
she said okay what's your last request
my last request is they take a needle
with a string with a thread and you
sew my dress to my body so I'm not
revealed after my death it doesn't
doesn't get pulled off by the horse or
whatever there shouldn't be a problem
with
says here is a guy that a damager he
brings his animal to somebody else's
property without
permission and the animal goes crazy and
makes all these digs
holes so of course the owner of the the
damaging bull has to
pay now this is very very
interesting take out your pencil because
it doesn't make any sense the if
somebody falls into the pit oh who told
you P to me it wasn't so P I'm not
such okay don't you know what scratch it
do not take out your 10 pencil don't
write in the G you don't understand
it's a shame that the AR scho puts it in
there and what what's the name of the
gar over there put in because so pit you
don't even need
it now here is
the says that a human being created a
pit not a bar that was created by
animal now the say B it's possible that
an animal digs a pit and it's considered
the human being dug it why even
he should have filled it he didn't fill
it up as if you yourself dug it
says you bring a dog into my you bring a
bull into my and he bites and he does
damage to the
b or the owner tripped over him he
didn't realize there's a dog in his
house and he tripped on it at
night but if the bull just sat himself
down like in this picture
as makes no sense what because he sat
down in the middle of the the dining
room that's why he should be difference
if he's standing or
sitting we have to say what does it mean
he sat
down he relieved
himself and the owners clothing got
dirty by the G the g b so now the G
become a b like the famous prank in
America they take some dog excrements
they put it in a paper bag they light it
on fire put it by the guy's door and
they ring the guy's belt the guy opens
up the door you never saw this prank
opens up the door and he sees this thing
on fire so he tries to extinguish it
with his feet and he gets galum all over
his shoes and his pants whatever so
now that is hezek from
galum and this is considered a bar and a
bar is poter from damage caused to
somebody's shoes and somebody's
clothing so let's see Rashi for a second
because it's a very very rashash
says and you're not allowed to answer
this because you answered yesterday so
Rashi says that it didn't happen as the
animal relieved itself it happened a
minute later what's the difference what
is it called when an animal relieves
himself and and a piece of the exan hits
a person's shoe what is that
called everybody said they're all right
they're all right the oil is holding
unbelievable I'm very no seriously spoil
like 10 people scream out ah they saw
last
night
wow anything the owner
owns like the excrement he owns it at
that point
like his camel fell down he didn't pick
it
up that's your
bar even though the camel
caus right that's amazing because the
Torah says that when a camel creates a
bar it's not your bar over here it's
different because the camel is
yours so rash is making distinction when
your camel digs a bar T says you Potter
but when your camel is a bar then you're
when you have then you're when your
animal creates something that's not
yours and makes a hole in the ground
that's not yours that's when the says
you're Potter you
hear
why that's
different because the digging is not his
but uh but is yours
fine
say is the one that says that every time
you slip on a ban peel or whatever
that's considered a
bar says that you
must
what oh what did I
say says You must release your
ownership so now if you're not MF let's
see if is holding cup besides those who
listen to yest today if you're not MF
according to ra according to over here
you have a situation that it causes
damage but it's not a bar so what is
it sh it's a sh
Michael no but a sh what's the
difference between a sh and a bar what's
the difference between a and a bar so
it's called a because a bar
is and
a no even admit in this case who wants
the excrements they
are yeah when I was in America there's a
whole could people from the from the
North and the South could they come into
my house without permission some people
have the key they have the combination
let them sleep in my house without even
asking me
why the whole we
learned I come home from America and
without not the guy hears the door
opening you see right away he he lays
down on the floor and I trip over him
and I break my leg what's
the tripped on him the guy obviously is
and if I step on his back I C I break
his back he shouldn't have been
there wait a
minute it's because you didn't know it
was a
surprise you saw the guy in there
with then you have no right to damage
the guy you could ask him nicely to
leave and if he doesn't want to leave
then we have to deal with it you can
take him out forcefully go to the court
whatever but you don't have a right to
break the guys
back you have to get the guy out of
there you don't have the right to break
his
head and this goes very well
with if two people are walking down the
street with permission or two people are
walking down the street without
permission how do you walk down the
street without perion says rash they're
both running so last night I was asking
what about somebody who who's walking
while they're texting in our they make
it relevant is that considered with
permission it happens it happened to me
at least 3 four times here in this
neighborhood where a person didn't even
look that they're crossing the street
they're like this m is and they walk
slow very annoying like come on I gotta
go somewhere no no no no no like that so
Benny sent me last night check this out
that it's AER it's
considered not only that you get a
ticket here in Israel if you walk across
the street while you Tex you get a
ticket nobody ever got one nobody ever
got one but it's
legally cop is himself on his phone he's
not going to see the guy
right
huh that that that's we spoke about that
also
e if the two people were like carrying
something whatever it got into the one
each guy poked the other guy's eye out
that's hez the other person I'm just
explain what the
means they slipped on each
other it's two cases that they both did
the same thing they were both walking
nicely or they both running not
nicely like an hour case one was the
owner of the house one had no business
being in the house the Potter the guy
when he didn't know that he's there and
he stepped on his back and broke his
back
he's I'm
sorry says the oh I'll say this real
quickly cuz liked it there was a guy
that I knew very well when I was growing
up his name was y Ros he
had every every year he' come back to
America he had y from a different place
he he's a heavy heavy smoker to to the
point he was once in the hospital I went
to visit him there and he was smoking in
the ICU and the nurse literally hit him
I saw the nurse hit him he had another
guy sneaking cigarettes and it was
disaster smok the I they said you know
he could blow up this Hospital K so one
was I was walking with him in Kensington
at night on dip Avenue and two gun I'm
not gonna say what are walking towards
us and I don't know if he never saw it
or he just had this fear like you've
never seen so he start acting like a dog
he gets an all
four like Y what are you doing he goes
he tells me I'm pretending I'm a m and
if I'm M they're not going to do
anything to
me that was so he tells me that one
time at night
in this uh this G comes into their house
at night they see they notice this guy
looking around so so he gets out of his
bed he turns on the lights he says why
you doing it in the dark let's look
together there's nothing
here okay
fine this bull fell into a pit oh we
have a
gal drawing here from Yoshi here's a pit
and comes the
bull and falls in look what happens to
the
water it's like slow motion the water
turns colors so says
the the guy that owns the bull
is if it happened immediately that the
bull was a dirty Bull and it got cleaned
off in the water water all the mud went
into the water now you ruin the guys's
water if it happened after the time
after a long time
not the himself is considered a
pit and the water is a
CLE happens after a bit of time then
it's a CLE the water is a CLE it shows
you over here water is a CLE that got
ruined by a
bar Rashi says when when a CLE gets
ruined that's the
pot according to okay it doesn't matter
the the you have a you have a bar the
anything that you slip on you are it's
considered a bar and that's
it according to ra you have to make the
bull which is the bar here which normal
person is going to take a $2,000 Bull
and
be is what he
said when the the the he ruined the
water from himself on the
spot when the animal died in the pit and
it takes two three days until the animal
starts smelling up that's
considered in other words the animal
came
in beautiful with with with the odorant
the whole thing smelled galic later on
it developed an issue and and it had a
smell so M you could say also the same
case with a guy who left a pack of of
fresh uh chicken he took a a trim Andra
and he left the chicken in the back seat
over shabas and the it ruined the guy's
car and the guy had to go to the this
clean it out it it when he left it there
it was fresh meat afterwards in the
store whatever it is it developed the
smell it's pass I'm just again not a r
and cuz a guy in the sent me something
and I I I want to argue with him I think
he understood it wrong I got to argue
with him when it comes to cigarette
smoke or a guy throwing up in somebody's
car which happened to me also I lent my
car to somebody gave it back to me and I
I couldn't go into the car said what
happened he I cleaned it well I said no
you didn't then did you had to go three
days in a row and clean it
out when
you when you didn't have to do that he
says I'll take care of it what do you
upet at the guy don't worry I'll do it
my RAB he loves it he loves he gets to
drive a free in a in a minivan for free
what do you mean he didn't have to pay
me okay anyway I didn't let him he takes
it he does it once in a while he fills
up the gas I'm serious he likes to do
stuff he likes to do he's doing to both
of us anyway
so I'm saying that cigarette smoke is on
the spot you smoke in a rented car you
damage on the
spot on purpose no no purpose no it's
not because I'm saying the smell is here
I'm just
making oh that's something else so what
no
I'm saying between a smell that comes
out later and and smoke that's right
that's it I'll go ask
him fish oh yeah the kitchen still
smells kitchen still smells unbelievable
unbelievable so one minute when comes in
ask him to take care of the
[Music]
kitchen we have a
minute have a minute to finish this it's
not a big
deal oh so it said in the mishna if a
father is somewhere on the bottom of the
pit and comes a bull and falls on top of
him you have to pay ker the famous
question we know that ker is only a
payment that's paid when a when a bull
does it three times you pay the value of
the person but this the first
time this guy is bull he jumps on people
in the pits Falls in them he's a killer
he kills people so he should have killed
him right away so Rashi I just want to
point out this Rashi real quickly Rashi
says we already had this question we had
this Su what happens when a bull kills
somebody three times you pay ker but the
question is on the first time that the
animal killed somebody you have to kill
him any animal that kills you have to
kill him so how did he even get the
three times we
had that he he he killed three he hurt
three people they put them in the
hospital and then they all died so he he
he was able to do it three times or he
killed the person ran away killed the
person ran away or who's or they know
the B they don't know The Shard says
Rashi those are
all over there where a bull kills
another bull over here he fell into a
pit so there's no AR he couldn't run
away he's in a pit so B go and grab
him there's no that he did it three
times as soon he does it once we grab
him as
the how do he have ever get the
three here's this here it is did it
here's the father working to fix the pit
on the bottom comes the bull he sees a
bunch of grass he's eating there and as
he's eating boom so every time it's he
doesn't mean to to hit the guy I guess
he's not smart enough to learn from his
mistakes but that's not is That's So a
bull kills unintentionally he's
not
we have a situation but
not the question is and this is another
that we have to remember in bakama we
learned that if you kill a bull you pay
ker you don't kill a bull you don't pay
ker what's shot over here you're not
killing him because it was unintentional
yet the gar says you have to pay ker the
answer
is remember this this is Shen Shen is
different we're talking about Karen you
need a kill a bull in order to pay ker
over here he's eating grass so he he
damaged during Shen during Shen you pay
ker even if you don't
kill I know I I I I I I I heard I hear
what you're saying as I was saying it I
was thinking that
also he's asking that it wasn't he
didn't eat the person he was eating
grass and then he he fell
afterwards you're right it is the first
time this animal did it and we're not
talking about the regular we're talking
about
50% there is such a thing according
to no it's the first time he did it and
not half he's gonna pay the full
why he PS the full
am so on the first time he's going to
pay the full amount because it happened
in the domain of
the according to it was his it has to be
his so makes a lot sense it was his
father his son they had permission to be
there why do you have to emphasize that
it was his father any human being that a
both
you I think if you don't mind let's try
to do this so it's super super simple
it's a lot a lot of words but super
simple I think we do it in three minutes
and it goes like I'll just tell it to
you
it's a classic that from the it says it
says in the I give you to come into my
to my domain but you have to watch your
Shar he says straight out you have to
watch so what's parv if he doesn't say
anything then you're and from the sa Mas
the exact same opposite I say I'll watch
you Mas if it's you poter okay so we
have between the and the
classic
we got to go through quickly a lot of
words saying this very simple
thing is that automatically if you let
somebody come into your you take
responsibility you have to specify
it come into you have to watch
it so since you have to watch your own
animal if it cause damage if it got
damaged your
PO bring your thing in and I will watch
it spe I'll watch it every person could
infer from here that if he didn't
specify it would be the opposite of what
is you have full responsibility if you
said so but if you didn't say so you
don't have responsibility that's Mas
like rebi they have to say
so because you said something if you
didn't say
anything
so what you gonna do with exact
opposite because he said so
specific that's why
you're but if he didn't say
anything without saying anything you're
not
yourself what you have the beginning
goes
like
broken right it's a problem
[Music]
because in the time of the that
everything had a rhyme so the first the
first part of the the BR says you watch
your own thing so in the safe it says
I'll watch it it doesn't mean I have to
watch it it's even if he doesn't say
anything you're to watch it like say it
happens
automatically so goes he says the
opposite goes like rebi they have to say
specifically
and he re that
says have to pay the full
amount if he tells him you watch your
own bull I'm not giving you anything in
my by me telling you you watch your own
bull you have no no to my domain you can
bring him in but I'm not giving it to
you therefore it turns into in my
domain you should pay the whole
thing it didn't say anything
then I give you to come into my once I
give you to
come become that kind of an is what you
asking
before over here so if it's then what
it's like
in and
that's have a wonderful
[Music]
day