Daf Yomi Bava Kama Daf 32 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning RAB that was very rectic wow we're live in the five towns from the bki home thank you mi and the revon or Mrs when somebody calls my wife the revon she gets all so Mrs and Mr M bski we sit on your chairs and your father's chairs in and here we are sitting on your chairs in your house it should be you know what we'll do the AL we also at these days we do the all those who are still kidnapped and the 5,000 injured over 5,000 and all the families that are suffering so they should all have an A I do want to for warn parents that this is the beginning of the Su is a little bit uh there's a parental warning here um before we go into the sugya we'll do a couple of emails my grandfather listened to the rough she every day I remember often walking through his kitchen to see him sitting in front of an open gar with his phone prepped up next to it playing the shear remember just as often not see him his usual spot as I walk through hearing the shear playing his bedroom too week to sit with his gar but unwilling to let that cause him to miss the day love learning this conversation revived around it I don't know how many people with his favorite safer but somehow everyone even more dis relativ knew that was his the last memory I have of hearing my grandfather is two days before his t one of his nephews my first cousin was removed I comeing from s came to visit briefly before going back while I was there sitting with my grandfather kitchen I need to go through M uncomfortable I spent about 10 minutes just sitting at the top of the stairs from there I heard my grandfather tell his story I heard him say doesn't time but this was fresh audience the stories as follows was re there was rebi teaching his class about ye he asked the class okay fine it goes into the whole things I hope this will be for him I greatly appreciate the's time thank you one of barel Septimus grandkids when he was nter the this grandkid wrote in and I read the email that he asked that this Grand kid should uh sponsor a Shear for him he didn't know how to get on the computer the grandkid pushed it off and then the the grandfather was nter suddenly and the grandkid felt very bad so right after theur or the Shiva came and and so here it is I think it's their it's the yard side hope every beautifully inspiring shs good convention in Good Company when saying that I was very glad to see that good appreciates your almost as much as our every growing MD family does that they made you a highlight speaker confirming story about the from yesterday she please see AR SC biography of the you may also want when I said the story story I said I did I asked people I asked the Rab in the audience if you ever heard it and he said no so I was a little skeptical I remember reading it somewhere because I know that I read this book many times when I was younger because K is probably one of my favorite D you know from recent years because of his just the way that he was undiscovered until he was in his 50s and he wrote the famous K nobody knew it was it stands for his name but nobody knew who the author was it was just a was a popular safer and nobody knew who the author was until he came to and that wanted him to wanted the the world to know he was so they it's a very interesting story anyway so it's in this book wishing you safe trip back home to join you soon until then wishing them the white family a week Fuller so yes tomorrow is my last day here in the tri state area I'm going to make my way to ER tomorrow night I still have to discuss when the she is exactly because I think I think my flight is like 7 o' I have to be there you know takes an hour and a half to get to nework you know the whole okay so I have to figure it out and I still have to prepare Bo said this is a beautiful story in Hebrew but somebody two people sent me this email so I'd like to read this email look at this picture very carefully what you see in the picture here is here now it's on the screen is a father learning with a son theaf this son is a general in the Army and he got injured he's blind right now he had surgery on his eyes on his eyes and the father and he was sad that he's missing the da so his father is reading them and you see him concentrating you see his eyes are closed so it's a very uh this one was from SCH Kleiner and this one was from the burgers father together always uplifting side but you see this picture is far be on an ordinary Kut Gabby ker is sitting in the corter of the apology Department in the Bellon Medical Center is reading the gar to his son major Gan ker why is he reading because Ganer company commander in the 46 sixth armed regimen was injured by an anti-tank missile that hit his tank during the battles in Gaza and is recovering after surgery on his eyes from the day of s that were attacked many of us started to accumulate gaps in the told me Bruce insisted and assisted insisted on trying to find time for the da even when he just had a little free time at the end of the day in the tank he opens the gar and studies he keeps saying we have to do two Wars one war in Gaza and a second war to continue on the da me and don't give up on both fronts boy say hear this we are sitting here in America we're not in the front in Gaza we only have one thing that we could do and that's to learn and and uh after I was injured he replaced me in the position talked to his grandfather kiter how Survivor it's a whole long thing few anyway turns out the Matan Gan MP finish and that they bring Gaza ASAP ASAP his grandmother was deeply moved to hear that her grandson was also winning the battle in major Gabriel May you speedily return to learning with your own eyes beautiful all right I did I said my mother go back okay I said my mother I'm willing to uh even though I have a very weak memory go back and you'll see for for the let's go what do you [Laughter] got I do what do you want never bet in my life not even once never never bet on money in my life de the the mother of worldwide of the month sponsored from supporting so yesterday we did this mishna we'll go over briefly but I have a question for the what I did say it thank you I'm Mar asazi he's texting me he didn't say it okay so no usually I say I don't remember but when I remember I remember this it's like rear not me nice trying out my M from two minutes ago I have a I have a question for the for the and I'd like everybody to participate please if a person texts and Dr arrives and hits a pedestrian and kills that pedestrian what are they I'll give you some options here it could be something else but what are they anus Aid or shig anybody you all say ding dong check it out check out you hear thatan it's a it's a new New Concept that we're gonna be learning today it's not means what do they call an America um premeditated murder it's not premeditated this person didn't want to kill somebody wasn't there a story recently with a from girl that it's now but it's it's not a you can't say hey it's not my fault yeah is your fault you shouldn't be texting while you're driving what is it it's something in between a a sh amaz it's a it's very close to in fact there's something called there's a that is not even a get closer to an okay we're gonna get there that's one thing so just I know that we showed this twice already but just do me a favor for my sake I like this so let me see where it is here check this out if you guys understand how much work goes into this oh maybe there's we'll put some volume there hey it's great okay and I explained yesterday if you didn't see this year yesterday this is just uh the beginning and B we're going to be able to develop it to a point where we explain complicated sugas and things like that then m I watch you watch trying to prove anyway what happened there is two people had the right of way they both have the right to walk inab and therefore when they hit each other they are poter the guy that that hits the the glass he's Potter why he has a right to be there just like the other guy a right to be there as the G we're in the gar B La heart good heart of the I'm not trying to to I'm saying the EMS the bis have great hearts all those cheers all the things all the over the [Music] years a person damages his own wife with permission obviously but causes damage during relations since he had permission just like the guy walking down the street he's now if you look over here there's a I believe it or not that's the person owes his wife money why he should have been more careful can't we prove it from our own that's literally what we have over here they both have permission to be there but right so they both have says no so for that we need the over here this is the famous person is Gonna Come into a forest with his friend to chapwood and he takes a nice swing with an axe to chop the wood and the metal piece goes flying I guess they had the same axes that we have today there's a wooden handle and a metal piece you put like some you know like uh matches in there whatever you make sure it's nice and tight and eventually comes loose and it finds his friend and the friend dies from it that's called a and he has to run away in order so that he could survive to live because if not what's going to happen his relative could come and take revenge so um this is in the wrong place let me get to it I hate when this happens this is B when I get back there we don't we don't have this issue let me here check this out there's a little bit of a this is a Yoshi this is not a 3D this is more like a I don't know what you call it 1D [Music] 2D I don't know he's he's very AAL okay it's it's not even rated you don't see it's like it have just the sound okay fine great so that that's what happen so says look at this sorry they both have permission to be in this Forest but it's not owned by any individual nevertheless he's he has to go to this one that goes into the other person's so to speak like certainly you should be what do we do says when it comes to a person walking with a beam and a person walking with a jug they both have they're both equals they're both participating they're both walking they walking towards each other you understands in in this particular case different cases but in this particular case just think about what the says about Esther Esther what does that mean she wasn't a participant at all she just stood there and did did his thing yes it's it's it takes two people but she wasn't a participant over here also talking about in situation where only he was active and therefore he's doing the says why is she not considered a participant when it comes to the says the ones who do meaning even if a woman doesn't do she she's not really participating she's there still considered that she did something says even in that case they both benefit they both have and therefore just that alone causes her to get Misa but over here so over here we're talking about injuring another person and he's the one that took action he's the one active and therefore he's that's a person would be to his wife you know NE let's call for the say that's it so from here and on no more warnings so I said yesterday but I realized today I want to to me it was very bothersome what's the difference between a Ando so one is with Alf one is with a he but I realized this week in this we I got an Aliyah and the guy was a KRA I hope he doesn't listen to the share and the reason why he's about K not he's to me he's just a log carrier why because I got that LE with the K and he took the beautiful and he did I told him I said you ruined my day what kind of is this you're that's it I'm gonna start calling this guy from now and in fact my favorite um from mdy I love him dearly but on purpose he'll do the reve on the K just to get me aggravated he knows that that's it fine next huh one day of course there a day but why do you have to be that guy it's so beautiful yeah I found the I found I want I'm such you know it's beautiful I gr the hold that it's supposed to be I the or whatever stop it be like everybody else let no it's probably seriously in our show and I'm this is not something to to be repeated and don't tell anybody about this the camera no it's I feel bad that I didn't you know I used to be Vil this is a long time ago where you know show everybody screams so a millisecond before the got there I scream out everybody instead of scream they started laughing it was it's not good to do in I'm serious don't do it so now you're the the guy with the beam and you're in front oh I was going to bring a whole beam and the thing okay forget it next time do you have any toys with beams and barrels no probably go go look for it no no no until until you get it we're g be done so we have the case in the mishna where the the beam guy is going first and then he stops and the other guy knocks into him or he doesn't stop and the other guy goes too fast it's tailgating we call it tailgating today so yeah I have it over here fine you have a beam let's do the you have the beam walking first and the guy's behind if he goes too fast and acci him obviously it's the the guy that's tail gains fault if the bean guy stops short and this guy bumps into him so the beam is says the there's two cases one of them is doing something illegal unnatural or I don't know if unnatural is the right word not the right it's not the right thing in it's like a car parked in the right lane in middle of a a very six Lane Highway you don't park on the right lane you go to the side so one was literally sitting in midin and another animal is walking normally if the walking one gives the sitting one a nice kick Potter that's the one we want to talk about if the the sitting one decides to stick out its leg and give it a good kick to the one that's coming next to it and you could say that the reason why he did it want to protect himself or herself she's sitting on the floor she sees another cow about you know craw you know trying to go over she g a good kick so we have we have we do have a picture here for it so one right over here you could see the arrow pointing there's one sitting on the ground the other one steps over it and gives it a nice kick look it look it's looking back it's looking in Anger did it on purpose poter poter why because this one on the on the floor is M it's doing something so if you come and you do something different after somebody else did something different if you're an animal you're Potter if you're human being you're this is the the other way the one on the floor gave the one trying to climb over it a nice kick if the guy with the beam was first and the guy with the barrel was walking behind the one with the barrel was walking too fast bumped into the beam poter obviously we all relate to that you're driving 75 miles an hour in the left lane and of course this is that old lady likes to go 30 in the left lane why they go in the left lane I have no idea and you hit her you're you went too fast but if the person left lane makes a short stop okay so again in America that might be the maybe the insurance companies don't go with that but when you're walking with a beam and just him you shouldn't be St you shouldn't stop everybody's walking at a certain Pace you don't just [Music] stop over here the one that's on the floor so the one so over here this guy gave uh gave the one that's on the floor stopped and hit the one that was crossing over it the one that's on the floor is like a parked car we just said if you park yourself you're with a beam and you park and somebody hits you you're so this cow is like the park car and the one that stepped over and you hit it you're does anybody get the problem over here because when you're parked car you're not doing anything you're just standing still somebody hits you so the guy that's Stood Still is he shouldn't be there now we're saying that the one that was parked not only did the person not hit him but the person that was parked opened up its door and flung it out and and hit that person it's a whole different story right the animal that's on the ground kicked the the the car that's moving that's a whole different story than a car that's parked that you're if you hit it sorry the car that's parked is if somebody hits it but over here the car that's parked is also causing damage without it hitting it's it's it's it's it's kicking it's sending something out of the car says the you think you're helping not only you're not helping cash what you're doing is creating a question when he wanted to introduce the the mus movement so he was a tremendous maybe the greatest of the generation people know him as the the Mr the rabbi of mus a tremendous there were a lot of people that were against M so what they did is they sent a to go fight him and he would get up and give a whole pill pull in learning at the end you stick in the m so this said what you're saying is not true because I have a r from a different gar like this and like that so said no what you bring me a is when you ask me a question a contradiction is exactly right to what I'm saying oh and the guy tried again he kept on asking contradictions and would show him that the contradiction is actually arah was playing with him the next day the guy comes he realizes okay I'm not going to ask contradiction I'm going to bring Ras so the guy screams out he goes I have a beautiful R for the for Thea it's not a r it's contradiction to what I'm saying know what to do so he said it again he brought another rot so the guy said okay that's I'm done with that give me get me another job so that's the says here you're bring me a to what you're saying it's not a r it's actually a contradiction the what again is is everybody following me I'm saying the weird words here if you have a car that stops in middle of a highway and another car hits it the says the car that stopped on the highway is R from a cow that parked itself in middle of and as another cow's passing by it sticks out it leg and gives it a nice kick that the cows they're not the same story one one is not doing anything and he's and the other one is doing something so of course the mission is gonna say you're because the cow on the ground give gave it a kick here look at this picture didn't belong and it kicked so of course it's you can't bring a RI that if a car is parked and you hit it that the car is the car didn't do anything hold on no it was just sitting there and another cow came tripped over it and and banged its head on the floor and and died okay that's a different story says not only is it a you see this [Music] Lo you helping me not only you're not helping me bring me a this case of a cow is because it gave a nice kick but let's say it didn't kick the C stepping over but the C stepping over tripped and fell Potter would seem like poter the Mish where where the guy has a a beam and he stops still and a guy with a jug hit it you're saying even though the beam didn't do anything didn't kick so it's a stero it's not it's not a it's not a r it's a contradiction [Music] says the this beam is talking about that the guy spread across the whole you can't get by so and nevertheless you're even without doing anything over here with the cow it's sitting all the way to the side so I gave you enough room in the to go by why do you go over me so it's a TI on the count you know what we can bring a from the end of the M what if you reverse it now the guy with the barrel is first the guy with the K is walking behind him if the guy with the beam is walking too fast and breaks it he's he can't go too quick and knock it but if the guy with the barrel stops still and the beam guy hits him what's the beam guy can go around has enough room certainly can't stop the entire it's not as as you want to tell me a large beam a long beam fine but this is similar to the story you're telling me tell me that the cow's in one part of the and you can get around it okay over here also you can get around it nevertheless even though you can get around it and he hits it he's sorry Potter Potter he's Potter why why is he Potter he could get around why is this guy goes he hits him it's not such a always there's other lanes make go go around nevertheless you poter says right so this so it's a good R why because we say the same thing this cow that shouldn't be there even though it doesn't take up the whole and other cow could go around it says in our mishna it's Potter even though he has room to go around he's not to go around he can continue straight and damage that when it comes to a beam the guy's walking he's in the left lane he's walking we had this before in yes you could go over me if you're if you sit down in the middle of I'm allowed to step over you but that doesn't mean that you're allowed to kick me while I'm stepping over you that you don't have and for that you're going to be says the is Bing the same three times basically if you run and there going to be a sh when when he's running it's notas but if you run all three cases of guys running one is running and one is walking two people running where's the first one sorry I missed that two we're walking okay two cases here there here five and they damaged the guy running damaged doesn't go like he says no you not let it run run running is different it's not not not common practice to run on a sidewalk you ever see somebody in Manhattan running it's not it's not it's not how you do it he says when you're running a shabas late in right before shabas then you are why he has one exception to the rule you see a test over means that's the that only you let it run but on Tuesday if you run you're say like even on a Monday must say no the m is also onas doesn't say anything about shabas how can you say talk about shabas when the M doesn't talk about yeah because you have to be why does it say to say if one guy is running he's Potter if both are running of course the Potter that's a if one guy if one guy's minding his own business walking like a man two miles an hour down the street and S is running like a crazy guy and hits him and he's Potter so of course if two crazy guys are running they're both jogging in opposite direction they hit each other then the of course they Potter so why do you have to say second case if in the case when one is walking the guy that's running certainly two are running the reason why the two cases because talking about during the week that's what the is talking about how do I know this because of this why does have to say that's like next level you have to think I guess when they when taught the M he explained it to like that but if two people running in the week day learn a lot from this and this is how we that he agrees that if you run why what are you doing exactly what's the permission why say this is like right I I know that says what does next one some say so the first one is let's go out and greet like Rashi says like a king even though the says like a like a goes he's excited to meet his the who's a queen king queen you're going to greet chabas say you say is if you get all dressed up put on his Talus or whatever it is why says this way and Ash says this way I don't know but there's a certain here says I should have looked it up huh I any here but everybody okay so I just want to point out something we have to we have to talk about it for a second about chabas the most important y that we have is shabas the most that we have the shabas it's the highest Madre the most and it comes with the most severe punishment if you you only get you get Skil which is the highest the worst death and the reason why it's the most um what's the word um no uh uh uh uh the most neglected the reason why it's the most neglected and not not as appreciated you goas why because it happens every week so what I'm suggesting to the obviously I'm not gonna do it myself but I'm telling the to is that everybody should take upon themselves and they come and tell me people came to me the sh and said because you said this I do this and this and that like I was saying to myself well B you do it because you know I don't want to tell the guy make him feel bad but listen I get he does it I'm just telling you what to do and it doesn't mean that seriously people should everybody take upon themselves something whatever it is when I moved Isel I think about myself something I wasn't doing at the time that's is 10 years ago I without a without any excuses without anything say at the meal I never used to say say prepare something takes time time and who has time for it so I prepared and then about four years ago when my son-in-law came to the family as covered I let him save you know you know what happened that was it so yeah I have to start again but you know how it is to start again I want to start the next cycle yeah that's right I'm coming now you're right that's right and of course and of course is gonna say you gotta say you have that you say this hereen Chas everybody saying that we didn't blow for this year and that every year they say history says that when you don't blower on chabas becauseas this tragedies in CL if you look at the history of K that's it's known things but anyway I just want to say real quickly I saw yesterday at that convention they had a very emotional video I'll share with the real quickly so my my thing my idea is that everybody should take maybe maybe Lear not everybody learns this easy books now say about this that something to because shabas is the holiest y that we have but uh a beautiful thing I I I didn't if you notice I didn't say any stories about oh this kot was saved because they kept shab I'm keeping it very very P very not not to say that's I don't want to go that route but this guy they showed a video of a kid like 18 19 year old maybe 20 year old kid who went off the D and he decided what happened I forgot why but he decided that he's going to keep the r spoke to him going to keep one thing and that is not to smoke love to smoke and his friends made fun of him and this and that ker they were supposed to go he loves going to to the Rave parties and he works hard the whole week and he he likes to to blow up some steam at the parties gave a whole thing the bottom line is that he convinced his friends they're all going to to NOA and he convinced his friends that he can't go because of the smoke and because of this and that they should not go and they should stay this and the they go to Kish instead I don't remember the details I'm sorry bottom line is that all his friends were saved the kid broke down crying his his other friends that went all died he said their name this so and then after the whole video was very emotional because he's crying on the video and his father was talking his father's like the head in the area and uh then the kid came out he was there at the convention and uh he claims this kid says shabas I was saved and now I'm sh shabas completely the whole okay anyway Z the M oh yeah thank you the turning the sponsored by may my holy nephew son of Robert and Jen ear and mayor which is also so you have this guy we're not going to show it again we have the guy chopping wood and he's in a public domain and a piece of wood or even the axe itself when flying into a private property and or he was in and it damaged so was the reverse he was in his own private backyard and it slipped out of his hand and killed somebody in the [Music] street or he was in private property went private property need all three says it only say it's a little bit out of order if it only say there's a lot of people when a guy is chopping wood in R so he thinks to himself what's the worst case scenario a piece of wood will go flying into this guy's backyard nobody's there well what he's probably at work maybe should be at all fine guy standing he has no right nobody has a right in a public thoroughfare to chop wood so he started off on the wrong foot but when he started in his backyard he has all the ride in the world to do it and something happened happened so maybe I think that he's no he's has to go to very simple right if it doesn't say if it didn't say I would think that it has two things going for it why should he think that if the handle goes flying It's Gonna Hurt somebody's neighbor neighbor's never in the backyard is all the right in the world to start chopping one his backyard he doesn't have to go to you need all these cases says Ah okay I was supposed to say this before this this is the that we learned a couple times of if a cow sits down on the ground and does something then another cow comes and also does a potter it's a complicated one fine this we did already this is aagar this is interesting how it came out with the with the wording in there but okay B so if you look closely it has our SU this is yosi's doing f a guy comes in here he comes into the Carpenters work uh what are they called Workshop thank you now the carpenter knows that he's there he knows it's funny there's a little m in the wrong place behind the carpent great so he sees huh lot of he he didn't knock on the door he just walks right in but the guy sees him and a piece of wood goes flying and hits him in the head and kills him Potter what ises he Potter he's Potter from going to G but he's on Damages so if he didn't kill him he's for damages but if he had all the right to come in he said come in then he's on the four things these are the four things gonna say besides for the pay the medical L income but not for embarrassment why because embarrassment you're only when scav scav who said that yeah from West hon you brought West Hamstead here that means what so you're not going to goingon to see rabie cron Omar this is what we call the first there's actually a chart let me see if I can find it real quickly oh this is a okay fine I'm looking at like for the first time because it came in late let me show you real quickly if you want to see all you're going to be looking at is the where it says and it goes down like the it's the center box the center colored box okay so basically what's that this one yeah you guys the center I'm also talking to a few other people that going to be watching later but fine was say now sorry on the second case what is he on the second case that's what I explained the second ago the four things notus and according to this he's Potter from going to Gus again what happened he's working on his shop guy knocks on the door come in he comes in he continues working a piece of wood goes flying and kills him or hurts him really badly but if he kills him he doesn't have to go to GS why not why not why not isn't that called the so the says over here he doesn't have to go to go it's not similar to Forest they both have the same amount of permission to come in but this guy came into his so yes he had R to come in but he came into my domain I'm the B here I'm not gonna go to GS because you doesn't like this so let's remember this that what that according to this before we get to ra ra says a different the exact opposite but according to this which is hard to understand a little bit but I guess that's uh that doesn't make sense hard a little bit okay it's hard to understand I guess if somebody comes into your domain he comes into your house and you kill him by mistake you don't go to gas okay makes no sense if in a forest where each one went in by themselves not then it says if you went into your friend's domain and he and you have to go to if I allow him to come in like now I'm even worse off I'm I'm more of a mazed so to speak I knew you're here you're in my house and I killed you by mistake I should go to go should say he killed by mistake says ra you misunderstood P Gus means literally he doesn't go to Gus because Gus doesn't help him he's so bad off that you can't even go to GS a guy that kills somebody purpose does he go to Gus no and there's no a him and you can't kill him does he go to Gus no because gas is there to help people that did things by mistake he didn't do by mistake this is called what oh it's called and doesn't help says okay so that aners the question that we had before if a person I'm not a r again I'm just throwing this out there I might be wrong but something similar guys is texting and driving not paying a lot of attention to the road and you're in a vehicle that's a killing machine people die every single day so you might be something called you didn't intend to kill but you're you're not you're not a ma you're not a maybe now I have a question for according to this that the guy was very negligent he's a carpenter and he he told the guy to come into his shop and he didn't stop working and one of the tools hit the guy and killed him and R says he doesn't go to Gus now is a guy that why do he run to go it's one of the reasons he run to go is because otherwise the the relatives will come and Avenge the the death and they could kill him you're allowed to kill him so I'm asking the what about case where he's not allowed to go to Gus G doesn't work for him he stays at home could the come and kill him everybody says no yes who says yes he says yes just to be different and you're right I also thought it's you're right for saying no because it makes a lot of sense but what should be right he should have some protection but unfortunately the says that could come and take care of says talking about malus and every human being goes through a medical before they get malus he supposed to get 39 malus what if a person's really old and can't sustain the 39 so the B will look at him take his heart and this and that okay 10 comes this guy and gives him 11 and he dies on the 11th one or he gives him 40 instead of 39 and he dies on on number the guy giving Theus has to go to he killed him by mistake he is a bad guy it's not oh he's a big he should have counted well and he should have known that that extra one is gonna kill him we have a case of where the guy does go to gas that's not like what we said that you don't go to G on he made a mistake it's not he he didn't not that he gave him extra he didn't know he was going to die is that he gave him extra because he he miscounted he didn't count well he thought that happens all the time right you count the 40 but you get mixed up somewhere you take a text in the middle in the C so I thought I like that better Rashi brings it that he he kicked him under the table you know he kicked the shoe like um it happens all the time especially when I was a kid when my mother would ask the guest if they want extra dessert and then all a like one of my siblings is ma why do you kick me like like she only had a little bit left and she didn't want you know the guest to feel bad or whatever okay so he kicked him on the table money what do you mean the guy giving the malus is not counting he's just hitting say the biggest D he's the one that reads all these let's see if I have theim here you read C these are not all the C that has before the whole the whole process the dying comes and says look you didn't listen to here now we're gonna hit you one guy's there his job is to count makes sense you don't want the guy to do two jobs hit and count that's when you get mixed up the third one says H okay yes there's a guy counting but I think it's incredible the guy hitting is also responsible and that's why he's aing not a car there's a guy counting his job is to count but the person hitting shouldn't say oh I don't have to I don't have to count he's counting for me you're talking about life and death here one extra one extra WAP or zap or what what do you call it whip lash thank you lash one extra one is going to kill him so you need to count yourself also don't rely on that other guy it's unbelievable and that's a TI on him to the point where he has to go to this guy's playing Rush he takes a a brick and throws it into 13th Avenue either he's going to kill somebody or not kill somebody play and it kill somebody that's not such a this is almost amazing yeah you didn't try to kill Ru because you had no idea the ru is there you just threw it off the roof he should have thought that for a second there's a lot of people there it's gonna it might kill somebody so here again we have a case go so this is hard to understand we need a good shot here it's not talking about a guy throwing a stone it's talking about a guy that is breaking his wall so it's not so much into the he's doing it more into his own you know backyard whatever and stone goes and hits in that's why he goes to GS you should make sure that nothing can happen you know that when you break walls Stones go flying different directions no no reason to believe there somebody there it's at night should have checked he's doing it into a a pile of of of waste in garbage or Garbage D so what's going on here what type of garbage if it's a per there's a lot of people there that you know they go they use it as a restroom whatever so then again you're caraz not amaz caraz nobody's there why should he think there somebody there okay so it's in between it's special that's where people use it at night nobody uses to relieve themselves during the day but some once in a while I shouldn't say anybody once in a while somebody emergency somebody uses it and he should know that not consider nobody but don't play a big because you know that at least two three times a day somebody goes through there I don't know exactly what the she is but the is just saying it's one of in between so again we had a before with two cases what were the two cases the two cases were you have a carpenter shop and the first case is the guy went in there without permission he didn't knock on the door he walked in and the carpenter picks up his head for a second he sees a guy standing there he knew he's there but he didn't give him to come in and he died the second case is that he gave him to come in so on that whole thing says the NOA says this was on the ra now we're on the last row vertical row all the way to the left now what this is the ra you went into the Carpenters shop without permission and he died however in this case you're you still to pay the four things according to the you're not to pay the four things right if you look in the in the center column in green it says and he's from going to now remember what said said No at the end he said means he cannot but over doesn't have to go to so now now we're not going to to remember said oh it's AER to go to GS in other words GS doesn't even help this guy so we're going according to the that says in the like in the beginning of the that when it says you from means literally you don't go to gas not that you gas is not going to help you you're a good guy you don't need gas right we started off the Su like that that what you tell a car tells a guy come in he knocks on the door come in he comes inside so he has permission to be there and then he kills him by mistake he's Po from GS why because he was in his dining room he was in his shop when he comes in the shop you don't have to go to GS Rob says that doesn't make any sense not only do do you not go to G you can't go to GS it's not even going to help you you're big Russia it's am no we're not going that so if that's the case you hear this if a guy comes in with permission into your shop and you kill him by mistake and it's nothing you don't even have to go to Goos so certainly when he doesn't have permission to come into your shop he just walked into your shop and you kill him of course you don't have to go to G that's the ra man the but whoever says that you don't have to gas you don't have to go to G because you didn't have R to come into but in the where knocked he's polite and he walked in you should have turned off your machines since what time is it it's getting very late let's see where's the nap guy here's the na oh um you go into a what do they call in English blacksmith and he has some sparks flying he died from it some a piece of metal goes flying out and he dies pot says he's [Music] pot however you want to call it he's The Apprentice he was learning so because he was he supposed to be there you don't you don't go to gos ask him what just because he's an apprentice he's allowed to die you allow to kill him because the master blacksmith told him to leave and he didn't leave well if you tell somebody to leave and he doesn't leave you're allow to kill him because he thought he went out so then why you have to say he's an apprentice if he didn't know that he left he thought he left and he didn't so just say he's not in paren a regular person you tell him to leave no no sometimes he Le sometimes he doesn't he doesn't have any for RAB but this guy has special uh respect for his his teacher and therefore when he told him to leave he thought he left but he didn't and therefore he doesn't go to goge if he kills him have a wonderful day for coming and tomorrow I have no idea we got to speak toel oh let's do something we'll do an easy one for we say all together and for all those who needed were middle of a war the need it the all the injured need it and the needed now that we heard that they don't even feed them and they whipped them and hurt them and branded them with fire with the exhaust of a motorcycle the little kids imagine for