Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
good
morning we have a huge crowd today in
[Music]
Chicago It's Time to Say Goodbye I am
leaving with my family BM right after
Shear we're going to the airport
catching a flight to New York and to
hang out in New York for shabas I was
invited there for the good convention
last minute I just got tickets today so
I'll be giving Shear tomorrow I don't
know if you'll be able to see the shear
before him but tomorrow at the AA
convention which is at the same hotel
where mdy did the shabbaton just a
number of weeks ago in the Aron hotel in
Connecticut so tomorrow Shear is at
2:00 M shab at
7:30
bem promises to be a beautiful
M I want to inform
the
that a tremendous thing
happened we tried it was Yi Klein's idea
to finish half of sh during the
shabbaton and I advise him it's not you
know people come want to hear speeches
they're not interested in sitting and
learning and plugging away doing 10
each but unfortunate circumstances with
bam early and kol took it upon
themselves to learn half AAS I think
it's an incredible thing how many people
are that within a few weeks of the have
a I'm not talking about I'm talking
about
sh400
D for a 2 year old I don't know if it
ever happened
so all the D Mar taken as of maybe an
hour ago y b made a last minute push and
people took they all jumped in I think
there was 65 deaths left and within an
hour or so boom all taken then should
have an alah and I'm looking forward to
seeing Robert bem so on Monday we have
tickets to go back toel Monday will be
my last day B in the United States on my
way back
to and we should hear looking forward to
sing Robert in
person and sing the
whole because I am in a rush to get to
the airport and I haven't packed of
course and I'm not exaggerating that I
only got tickets to New York just a
number of hours ago so uh we're going to
skip the emails but I do want to bring
out one very important thing a big
milestone for our very big you did and
he said I should say his name and show
this because maybe he'll be m one person
people struggle all the time with
different things everybody has a
struggle and I think uh you know if
you're not addicted to this you're
addicted to that and a lot of people are
addicted to to wasting time that's also
an addiction not being accomplishing not
not learning tired just sitting and
watching stuff and doing
things so here we have our very very
dear Goldstein very big part of the Year
want to share with you he's
sober alcohol 900 days it's a huge thing
because every day is a struggle every
day you know today's day and age with
kushim that we have and everybody goes
to KES and everybody gets little tipsy
and not everyone a lot of people get
it's a thing it's a thing of Our
Generation and to to keep away from it
for 900 days and then he writes to me
and
1,427 da with rebell and 80 of those da
is retro active clarification because he
only started with us during Co right in
the beginning of Co he had covid and he
was in his basement in bar park that's
where he found us us and since then we
became
tremendous the so keep on going she go V
and V there never look
back all right so today's she the for
the
of
worldwide
[Music]
brain intact unleash your full
potential and success in all my
Endeavors of the M
sponsor that come from
supporting here we go we are about nine
lines from the bottom
of
so we can look at the mishna the m is
on I was just looking to the side here
here's the the picture on the
screen you have a person who was
carrying some sort of jug there Rob him
and it burst open and somebody tripped
slipped on the
water so we have two cases or he got cut
with The Shard of the
barrel by the way it's your guys you're
responsible to fix mistakes to yell
something if there's an issue if I'm let
if I'm skipping some words because
nobody else is
here what's going on is that it's a
small share because I didn't know that I
have to catch a flight at 8:00 so I just
called it together real quickly and this
is what we got we have Taki again we
have
Reon I have to thank you every single
day basically that I was here he set up
the the monitors and the screens and and
all the
okay that's what we're looking for re
says that if he had intent with this
Barrel something let's we have to figure
out what he's talking about but if he
doesn't have intent he's he's only if he
has intent now let's go to the gar now
let's the
bottom says what's going on
here what does it mean that he
had you have a person imagine let's say
a guy it happens all the time guy comes
onto a plane with a napsack and he takes
off the napsack and you know he hit some
in the face but over were talking about
he takes something off
from his shoulder and as he takes it off
his shoulder it's heavyweight he trips
let's say on the sidewalk okay he trips
on this shoelaces he trips on the
sidewalk and the thing goes flying down
he wanted to put it down nicely
and it fell off his shoulder while he
tripped now we're gonna see a big
m is
tripping considered
AA negligence or not
negligent is of the opinion
that tripping you're negligent and
therefore since he tripped and he was
negligent so that's
considered he had had
intent says wait a minute doesn't make
sense
why we have right we read the Mna this
the first part of the mishna then we
have says inent not intent meaning the
who happens to
be he holds that even if is the literal
translation in Hebrew is you know melted
basically it broke into pieces he's he's
he has this Jug on his shoulder and
broke into small pieces and and fell
that's an that has he has no intent over
there whatsoever so you're telling me if
says well he has to have intent that
means that the T holds even without
intent you're
100% in
yes here have a
nice is a nice art
byov caner
so can so here he is he's holding a
picture in his hand and all he's left in
his hand is the
handle did he have intent to drop the
thing no it just fell out of his hand
so that's in that case
says you know a
person not is against his will he's
obviously he would much rather that the
pottery shouldn't break off they should
be left with a
full we have this in this week's par
also we have
din would anybody think that Dina is
going to get an A for what happened with
no she was forced so the Torah says you
have a you have a a young woman who's
engaged engaged in the time of the gar
meaning with a ring
she's and somebody was her it's not her
fault you can't do anything to her so
you see that the if if it's against your
will you're Inus and the Torah says
nothing happens to you says the
okay maybe the says you know it's
between me
and is not going to punish me he knows
that he didn't do anything
wrong it's the death penalty if goes
ahead but if it's between ruven and shim
and ruven damage shim so he can't say oh
was against my will you a lot of things
are against your will you hit my car
it's also against your will you don't
want to hit my car but somebody has to
pay for the damages and even though it's
not your fault and you know you fell
asleep I I get it you have a lot of
excuses but the bottom line is you Dam
somebody else's property maybe you
should pay even so you don't have to
pay oh here you go here's a guy that his
camel fell
down and the owner didn't get rid of him
didn't pick him up didn't didn't
what's so the fact that the camel fell
[Music]
down so let's do the Bry again two lines
from the
bottom two cases his
Barrel broke and he didn't move the the
shards and everything else to the side
his camel fell down he didn't pick him
up
say that he's I just want to tell you a
few things because we're talking about a
gumml I think it's important to know
what we're talking about so a few very
very interesting things about a gumml
first of all a camel could drink I think
it is 53 lers so think about your car
car probably doesn't have a 53 L gas
tank it could drink 53 lers in one
minute and I think it could walk like
literally 100 miles without drinking
it's very interesting do you know it has
like three sets of
eyelashes of of eyelids and two sets of
eyelashes something like that as so K
created a creature that is designed to
make it through the the
desert
so and there's many many other there's a
somebody bought a camel for $53 million
maybe it's
mid mid 53 gallons I don't know $53
Million number the point is that gave
this creature the ability to walk
through the desert it's DWIs hooves are
everything about it it's lips it has
lips that can eat Thorns it's whole body
right we know camel drink think about it
what drink now and and get away with not
eating for who knows Al
so created us also with all the tools we
had the tools to make it through life
whatever life throws at us the hot sun
from the desert no water etc etc we have
those tools so whatever sours we have
and whatever things G us the
tools now there's a few rules here says
the admit to Mayor that if a person puts
a stone or knife or and his bag
he put them on top of the
roof on the edge of the
roof and a calm wind came and pushed
them off so the
says why is
he because this is normal this is a calm
wind and you shouldn't have you
shouldn't have done that you shouldn't
have put it on the edge you know that
it's most likely it's an on a normal day
the wind is going to come and push the
down interesting how we switch language
but the point is he put some sort of
object on the
roof to dry them out you know like if
you have water in a dish and you put
food in it it's very possible that that
water that not boiled will ruin your
food well hurry up the process we had
once gar that if a person puts water on
his meat that's it you have to sell it
for really cheap so there's a whole gar
if a person prepared a wedding and then
the father died you can make the wedding
because it's going to be tremendous loss
because of the water introduction I
don't know if that's a but he had some
sort of vessel he wanted he wanted to
dry out before he pours wine into it
which could ruin the wine he wanted to
dry it out first enough enough
[Music]
and what is here I have beautiful
demonstration that Yoshi put together
this is not AI this is all this hand
done let me show
you means a wind that's not common that
he didn't have to think that there's
going to be such a wind now I want you
to pay attention to both trees the palm
tree and the fire
and the the tree on the side I like the
way that they move everything is
beautiful here there's a lot of work
that went into this the leaves are
moving if you look on top of the roof
there's a like a suitcase over
there oh I'm supposed to push the button
here hold
on so that's that now we're going to go
a little further
to
this that's that
okay
[Music]
so
basically this guy when flying in a
damaged true poter why what do you see
from here that even mayor holds that
when there's Aus it wasn't something
that you calculated you didn't think
there's going to be a tornado that day
and comes a very big wind and throws
your suitcase off the roof you're a
Potter and we said that according
to
says there's two arguments
here there's one argument when it falls
and there's an argument what happens
after it falls thear
explains there's
one at the time of the
Fall whether or not when a person trips
is he considered negligent or not
negligent May hold that when you trip on
a sidewalk you trip on anything you are
responsible you the hold that a person
that trips is not
negligent now when are you you're if you
have to break
it now there's
another and there's another okay so this
thing fell now
what this is very super
interesting could I throw a banana peel
on the floor in middle of uh a very bus
the intersection and say I am making my
banana peel hefer and if somebody falls
on it too bad on him it doesn't make
sense that you should right well we have
I know what you're thinking but that's
why we
have that he
had to break
it
Andor holds that when he just lets it Go
lets it lose he says I don't want it
anymore you're remain that's what you're
saying and
the says why why would I say this to
what forced him two two one when as it
falls one and another after it fell two
completely
different because it says in the Mish
two different things or in the
no it's actually the yeah it
says two different stories is a guy
tripping on the water or what are any
two cases a guy tripped in the water and
a guy tripped on the orange juice it's
the same idea right no it's two
different one is that a guy tripped on
he slipped on the water or he got
injured from a piece of the barrel or
the
glass same exact
thing coming to
teach before he had a chance to go ahead
and clean up the
mess I'll tell you a story was a where a
guy
comes
and he
sees a car parked like on three spots so
he's really annoyed at him it happens a
lot of times you know a sh in R and the
guy parked is a really nice car paid a
lot of money for it so he grabs two
spots on a busy
street guy got really annoyed but turns
out a simple story but it turns out that
the guy was doing a because there's a
lot of somebody dropped a bunch of like
sharp objects on the ground that could
puncture your tire like a bunch of nails
whatever glass so you parked in a way
that nobody should get
damaged fine which reminds you of
another M just heard today actually from
somebody sent me a clip interesting that
U I forgot the guy's name uh this spy
Rabbi okay so he said that a guy in a
trol comes home to his driveway and he
can't believe his eyes he's been
fighting with everybody to not park on
his driveway here guy comes a guy and
parks in his driveway so he decided
teach him a lesson he backs up his
cement truck to the car and pours a
bunch of cement on his car he's all
excited with with his thing and he runs
into the house as he runs into the house
he screams surprise it's his birthday
and they gave him the keys to this car
they just poured all the cement on
okay
whatever
F so we have two stories here either a
person slipped in the
water before he was able to do sponge
and clean it up
or or he got injured from one of the
pieces of the
glass and the guy was mate he said I
don't want this the glass
anymore after he didn't have a CH
sitting there he was lazy you know broke
a bottle of glass how many people break
a bottle of glass in the middle of the
street and they clean it up they walk
away he's Mur now what happens if
somebody gets inj that's where we
have
says
and since our we just explained that to
be two
separate we had two lines from the
bottom
of that he his Barrel broke his camel
fell down he didn't pick him up also
because the the Bryce is mimicking the
mishna so just like the mishna has two
separate cases the Bryce wanted to
repeat something
similar so the says wait a minute if
that's the case it's too stories we need
to explain how these stories worked
out we just explained beautifully if a
guy's glass let's say has a nice bottle
of wine it breaks there's two points of
the breakage as it breaks he doesn't
have a chance to pick up the mess and
somebody gets damaged or later on and
later on is a question of hefer not Hef
okay
two but how you going to explain the
second case in the bra
as two separate cases which T asks a
beautiful question who said there's two
separate cases in each maybe one case is
like in our mishna it's two separate
cases you have water which is means at
the time of The Spill and then you have
The Shard of the of the of the barrel
which is later who said
it's they didn't take the the water make
it into two cases now you want to take a
camel which is one case out of the two
and making into two cases okay
that's when it comes to camel who fell
great talking about a
camel that you were ma let's see I think
we had it over we had it already but
here this guy
yeah camel he left him there and the guy
said I don't need him anymore why I'm
going to bring for camels leave him
there middle of the street comes the guy
trips on him and breaks his knee so
now middle of the street
sayson says I don't understand why okay
but
this but if the camel
was walking normally and the camel
tripped so why is that the owner's fault
if the owner Tri you're saying okay n a
guy that trips is he a not a but when a
guy's animal trips why should the owner
be liable for a tripping
animal let me find the picture before I
show it to you here we go beautiful
picture
thisel consider a a what a pet a boar
what a camel yeah cam will that be
considered yes anything a
even a peel of banan a
pit even if up
ownership that's the exactly he had a
camel and he gave up ownership is
according
to according to
mayt but how do you have the first case
by a c says I'll tell you here's the
case check this
out beautiful now what they were walking
normally on a pathway suddenly the
pathway was full of water so the camel
couldn't see where he's going and he
tripped and he causes damage later but
whose fault is it that he tripped that's
the owner's fault when the camel is
Walking Mind and he trips on a sidewalk
great but over here the owner the master
brings him into this puddle and that's
what causes the tripping Sals actually
the owner's fault
that he went into a puddle that was in
Middle like a river that came in middle
of the pathway as what's what's the
case if this two ways to
go why did this owner bring him right
through the water he's a complete he's
negligent and if there's no other way
then he had no other option he should be
considered it's not his fault
what happened was the owner tripped fell
down now tripping is tripping your fault
or not your fault so the owner tripped
so the owner it's the owner's fault that
he tripped let's say according to and
then the camel tripped on the owner so
it is his fault as long as you hold a
tripping is your fault then the camel
tripping on you after you trip is your
fault and if you hold that you're
tripping is not a problem so you're
going to hold that the camel tripping on
you is not a problem you know
thank
you according
to that you were ma your it's talking
about that you MAF your stuff your your
broken
bottle so it's not yours anymore it's he
if it's not yours then why exactly you
had kavana you you had intent okay you
had intent that what the guy should
should you had a tent to put it down you
had a tent to what why is that intent
going to make you it's not
yours you you took away what had you say
got rid of your ownership disolved your
ownership no he didn't he didn't do
hefer to the to the to the glass he
wanted the glass he wanted to use it for
something it's a beautiful story
that there was Ora going around
collecting money in France he walks into
this wealthy guy's home he sees a
beautiful manira and all sorts of things
and the guy's you know silver CLA
whatever it's called he looks and he
sees a pile of broken
glass so he says to the owner of the
house ma what's going on here what is
this so tell
you he came from a religious background
but he decided to go off he moved to
France and he wasn't practicing religion
and he's walking the street and he sees
a religious kid a from kid crying so he
says what's what's what happened kid
says my father sent me to
buy oil for the
Mina and I tripped I fell and it broke M
fits into this story over here and I
can't come home he doesn't have money
for another battle of oil he's not going
to let me home so the guy felt really
bad he went to the store bought him a
bottle oil and says go and then later on
he starts thinking to himself look at
this kid and look at his family they
barely have money the kid is struggling
the kid said his father can't afford
another battle of oil and he spends his
money in all and started making him
think about
yish and he said you know what I want to
do tra that's what he said based on this
thing it got him going so went back to
the street and he collected all the
glass and that's his little souvenir
what is it called his um what's the word
I'm looking for um not momento uh okay
you don't have to send an email it's
fine I got the word um no no no when it
means a lot to you when when sentimental
thank you sentimental to him so he's not
going to get rid of this battle this
broken bottle of oil he has it in his
thing you know he's
a
also explains that we're talking about a
situation where the individual wanted
today we don't understand poverty we
don't understand these things we live in
a different world but in those days a
little broken glass maybe there's
something I could do with
it
so like uh you know somebody I think
somebody gave me yeah gave us uh from
the broken glass under the from my they
made some sort of design some people
want glass
okay so when says the statement only
when it falls before you have a chance
to clean it up seems like there's no
other and later
on what what do you say everybody's
gonna agree that it's can't
be says that afterwards if you try to
say that it's Hef you're going to be
so with two lights from the bottom so
you have to say theot is according to
everybody
you're that what that after it fell and
you had a chance to clean up the mess
and you don't and you're mate that's
what you were saying before makes sense
that
what what did say says when after while
it falls in other words when it fell
immediately after it fell there and you
want it to be that after it fell for a
long time sitting there there's no no no
no no there's in
everything no to say this in two
things that's exactly what said what say
say we have two over here one is when
the battle breaks right then and there
whether or
not is somebody who trips is he
considered negligent or not and then we
had completely another the guy waited 10
minutes he had the opportunity to clean
it up and he didn't and there another
could you be could I say all that broken
glass is half let somebody else deal
with
it now holding
the turning
the
wow got together it's unbelievable show
of
from
from from to anti to such a thing
everybody everybody took
D my holy nephew son of Robert
ber and J
and
unbelievable you know look at the names
you have guys you have and everything in
between top of
the we're doing
okay
[Music]
I better get home soon got to start
packing
no there's only seems like he says
there's only after it falls and the
question is could you
be but what about immediately by the
Fall is there
of that what that when you trip you're
not negligent you're Potter everybody
holds that that's that's what you're
gonna say according
to
later
says mayor says that tripping you are
negligent says there is
that in the idea
of we could use said that when a person
trips he's a meaning person
trips he went to wedding and he couldn't
do the da that's your fault you have to
take full responsibility you're P can't
say oh this and this
happened okay take it to any way you
want but it's it's a nice
lo you trip that's you're human being
you have to be
careful however argue so you're going to
say when I miss the I'm like to the okay
here when does it work you hear this
might answer some of the problems that
we have here when does it work to say my
broken glasses e only in a case where
you weren't negligent to begin with when
you tripped and the batttle went flying
out of your head because you tri your NE
in that case you could say hey I don't
want the glass anymore I'm
AF if you stop you take a bottle throw
it on the ground take a banana peel put
it on the floor and say oh it's not my
fault it's his let him deal with it I'm
after the banana peel that doesn't work
it's only when it goes flying out of
your hands from then it can
work and here we go to the
a person says that the Nez the broken
glass that's on the ground
that uh what do they call like dresser
that they put out in the middle of the
street
I'm we have the problem is we don't know
who says what so the all the way to the
bottom of the is going to try to figure
out who says what but what is
the one of the two says you cannot say
I'm being M banana
pill no it's not yours anymore the guy
slipped on a banana pill that's owned by
everybody not by
you remember we just had the says in of
after the the barrel fell and you waited
a while could you be M or not and we
said according to can is the same
right the one that says the one says
now yeah because remor spoke about even
in a case where he tried with even in he
says you can't go ahead
and maybe everybody holds that according
to there's no that everybody's G to hold
okay that if you try
to disown whatever object it is the
glass whatever after it happened
you're won't be in will
be whoever
says that what that when you m you stuff
your and this is within this is exactly
say you could be stuff
your now if you can M stuff how do you
have a bar how do have a bar the T says
this is a bar right but no it's talking
about a bar in your goes through the
whole like that back and forth we'll
have a little bit more
later I have a bar I have a
backyard I I dig a big hole and then I
say you know what I'm giving it over to
the to the
robab the one that says explain I
know I'm talking about even according to
when say that you only in this exact
case like we said before when it was
when you tripped you fell you broke the
bottle of wine that you were holding on
the way to guest on chabas and the
bottle of wine
broke then you could
be because it's not his
fault but if you broke the bottle let's
say deliberately and then you say you
know what I should I don't want to be
because somebody's going to fall here
and get caught and they're going to come
to me so I'm making it Hef that does not
work it only works when the battle went
flying out of your hands unintentionally
when you tri on a sidewalk so now who
says what
again two words can I take broken glass
in middle of the street can I take a
banana peel and say not
mine we GNA try to prove who says
what I'll prove it to you that says
he say the name
is there are two things in this world
that are not your real
property made
it you are responsible for these two
things what are the two things the first
thing he says says
this in other words you cannot be your
bar
it's it's owned by the public he says
it's
yours what's the difference if you dig a
hole in the middle
ofin let me see oh I did this one you
want to see my art it's not bad for the
first
try guys's digging in middle of
the
yeah don't look at it like this there's
20,000 people that will be watch
watching this year
later
after so
it's you like hold on let me just go
back you like the little mug and do I
put on the the truck over there like you
like with he's in a
tour but he has an Israeli flag on his
car I love it
anyway this is how he arrived here to to
to dig out the hole in middle of
Manhattan the guy's digging a hole so
what's Al it's not his it's not his
property it's hefer it's worse than
hefer it's not his what never started to
be his nevertheless says so certainly if
you're M you're right okay there's
another
thing since the Torah says from this
after
so it's not really yours you're not have
from it if you can't have from it you
can't benefit from it it's not yours but
the put it right back into your
possession in order to
be you are for having even though it's
not yours it became yours put it in
your okay great Riot by the way there's
a famous Marshall that these things
these two things I think you could take
the here as well you know in all the
says thear so perhaps you could say that
a bar andar these are the two things
that we're fighting with a bar are the
obstacles that we have in life in front
of us they're exterior obstacles there's
this there's that different things that
we have to be careful with and thear is
the the is inside of you so you have
obstacles inside your head or whatever
and they have obstacles on the outside
that's the remes over here there are two
things a bar and that are not yours
these are not these are obstacles but
the T made them yours kilo and what does
become yours becomes yours and you take
that t you fight off those
obstacles say I don't
like in fact is gonna switch it
around really say
this said the opposite this
not listen to
this if a person sees animal waste the
worst of the worst who wants to dog
waste in middle of a sidewalk a guy
decides to be a nice guy he lifts up the
dog waste the middle of a
sidewalk and
then he put it back
[Music]
down and somebody was damaged now he has
to change has to get new new shoes
[Music]
terrible you are why you made a Kenyon
it became yours you removed the obstacle
and you put the obstacle back
down there's a famous you know the
famous book go my son by something
shapir I forgot his name what's his name
know what I'm talking about go go my son
shapir I think it is you're looking it
up great
so I think it's so he says over there
that when he was in the war he
eventually made it to beckan or
something and believe it or not the most
prized possession was animal waste that
they could use it and heat themselves up
with animal waste you imagine today we
we we fight the the shampoo is not the
the
right fragrance that I wanted and I
thought about they used animal waste to
heat themselves up and get rid of
mosquitoes which chase the away and they
were all day all day looking for anim
whoever could find more anim one had a
better night okay so this guy maybe in
those days who knows and we had in the
gamar they used to make dishes out of
animal waste right we had such a
thing so he picks up a piece of
waste this is the we're trying trying to
prove it's only because he wanted to
make it his he wanted like like
like if he just wanted to move it over
he didn't want to he didn't want to
acquire
it
po why because the bar has to be in your
possession so you see that over here
holds that when you MAF your stuff your
Potter second AG he said that
ACC you know why because in this case he
lifted up the waist put it right back
down and this is fascinating this thing
right here is fascinating this is very
lumish very lumish I think if you think
about it for a minute you might come out
with a different conclusion
think about it for a
second there's a glass on the floor you
lift it up and you put it back down
who's the guy that broke the bottle or
the guy that put it down the second time
anybody person picked it up and put it
back down that's what you think person
that picked it up put it back
down here's another question you have a
pit this is a
pole
and you
remove the cover of the
paddle and put the cover back down we're
see a fascinating thing here that when
it comes to a pit in middle of the
street in middle of this there's a big
difference between putting a cover over
it or filling it up does it make a
difference to you whether the somebody
filled up the the pit completely with
with dirt or they covered it with a lock
is there a difference to me it doesn't
seem like there's a difference but there
is a major difference one we consider
the pit still here just has a
cover if you remove the cover you didn't
put the pit there the guy that dug the
pit did it but if the pit was completely
filled with racks and dirt that's
completely different then get rid of the
the pit completely let's see
inside talking about he picked up the
dong the waist and he put it right back
down
I'll give you a good mus
says it's compared to guy that found an
open pit in other words there's a bar
over here a real bar and he covered
it and then he went and he uncovered the
pit so who should
be he says this a great example there
was waste on the floor you lifted it up
you removed the bar and then you put it
back down just like a pit it was open
there's a bar in the you covered it and
then you reopened it says no there's no
comparison it's amazing to think about
the difference think this makes you
strong in and understanding and
understanding lus what is the difference
again there's a piece of waste that if
anybody comes here and steps in it gets
Dam
you remove the waste so you're the guy
that removed it you put the waste back
down so you're the one that did it
you're the one that put the waste there
you have another case you have a pit if
somebody comes they'll fall into the pit
you covered the pit now there's no more
pit now you uncover the pit now there is
a pit so you're no say very
different what's the connection what's
the
comparison
when you uncover when you cover the pit
you never get rid of the pit the pit is
still there just with a
cover and then you remove the
cover but when you remove the waste of
the animal so at the time that you
removed it there is no waste there is no
bar the Zero Bar it's not a bar with a
cover it's
zero you know what it's compared
to it mama what about a guy that found a
deep hole in the
ground he went and he filled it up with
dirt he took a tra to filled it up with
dirt but then he red
it in that case
this he removed the bar 100% And then he
brought the bar
back that Rai is a
problem
so what's
theat in this gar how come if you what's
you pick a piece of
was and somebody got damaged with
it
says you
have
says what happened was he lifted it up
let's say say this is where it was LIF
up this much not three but just this
much and then he put it right back down
so he's never
C says the
G and that's why he's po
say but otherwise if he lifted it up
this much then he removed the bar
completely by him putting it down he
created a brand new bar if you lifted it
this way it's so close to the ground as
if he didn't lift it maybe Love It
Whatever without going into that he
didn't make a kenon in it he put it
right back down it's the original guy
who put it down that's his
fault why does he have to force himself
to say that he lifted up less than
three and goes into all
thing forget about just say he lifted it
up the proper amount which is
he created a brand new pit a brand new
part by lifting it up more than three
and it's his problem now you got so why
do you have to say noav say I'll tell
you why the reason why he went into this
whole thing if whether he
had he had a problem with the wording in
the mishna he figured it out from the
M why does it say that he flipped over
the waste listening normal language
would be comes a person he lifts up the
dog waist off the sidewalk nobody uses
the lotion of oh the guy was a nice guy
went by the
sidewalk and he flipped over the waist
oh because it says flip over that that
that indicates th that he never lifted
it up the proper
amount means that it was less than three
now once I can
prove then who's the other
the one that
says
what you say I don't want this waste I
don't want this whatever it is according
to say we
Lear somebody hides glass a
thorn and somebody steps on it worse
than could be worse than Lego worse than
stepping out
Lego here's a nice
picture of a house that is surrounded
with barb wire comes somebody and by
mistake picks up his hand and gets a
terrible cut in his hand needs 25
stitches who's paying for the
damage fence on
it somebody got damaged by you are in
the
damage so you see over here I put in the
words means it's leaning out into he
doesn't have the right to put his fence
right there in
the but if it's nice and close to his
property line then you poter even even
and this is a nice over even if you use
MAF
remember because we're talking about
your
bar otherwi not a real bar
even why
are isn't it because he had a pit in his
in other words he had Barre and he was
mate he said I don't want that
anymore but he didn't he wasn't M the
bar M that whole property over
there oh you see
that even when the bar is not his even
if it's when it's not
his so you see
that you said hold
that he said all the is
the
and I'll tell you
could be that everybody
holds that when you m your stuff
you're time poter how come over here you
poter
when you have a barb wire that's with
your property line because it
says it's not normal for a person to
scratch himself on a wall and he doesn't
have to be worried that somebody's going
to scratch himself on the barb
wire did he really say this
is like
anous
learn if a
person here first of all two pictures
here is a picture of
M person says
this uh banana pill is half and he's
hoping that someone will trip on it well
and here's a picture
of he digs a
pit and some bull donkey Falls inside of
it and dies not like in this picture he
actually
died so you see that according
to hold on where were
we yeah and you said that ACC
to in
fact so oh we go back what do we say
over here when we said
this just want to
see oh we said that we wanted to say
that according to is and we said this is
it right now we're saying the
opposite okay so once we establish is
the one that says that if your MF your
hez your M your glass the banana peel
you are then obviously argues we didn't
know who said what one said this thing
one said the other one once we know said
automatic says but we have a big problem
we prove that according
to that whole that we had in name of his
like day he himself holds your Potter
this whole thing that he brought was his
rabish as we mentioned
before so there's no sh so bottom line
is says say
I'll see you tomorrow live from good
convention have a wonderful day and
we'll say real quickly to
H we say it together and quietly no I'm
kidding just not a lot of people
so
[Music]
Chicago thanks for hosting
and
B will
come and we'll see Mia
soon