Daf Yomi Bava Basra Daf 87 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good [Laughter] [Music] morning you know what I I'll do myself we did this I was a little bit Kus I don't know why came out weird but here it is [Music] morning this is uh my son went on a TI yesterday and uh he's the one in the center number 23 they usually don't wear that to youi I'm just uh as a trip these kids as soon as they get a chance the second they get a chance here they are this is them doing good morning rabai L style okay y fredman Joel fredman so somebody recommended and I think it's a great idea actually uh to make an app or when we have our app when it comes out B very soon there should be like a a place over there where you click in and you say you did the da in that place where you are so add another destination to mdy travel app learning in Vietnam Vietnam can't have a day without learning thank you gab says Joel fredman I love when I call you ever call A B Ag and Joel Freedman picks up or Abraham bovitz picks up no but they have this Abraham bovitz ab ab bovitz what's up what are the like we don't know the there's no you can't see from the name not Joel fredman some gu somewhere is learning in Vietnam okay I know exactly what Joel Freedman looks like in my mind at least yeah exactly what ah he has the baseball caps he can't tell right El Emanuel we think we we thank for the to continue learning the da reminding us that every page is important hi rebell on Wednesday you read an email from Yosi Kelner Anonymous with an idea to do a group Kazar after the she for the last few months I've been doing Kar with every day after watching the she and it really adds to the clarity and satisfaction that I get from my learning taking on yusi kellner's idea the same thing could be done in mdy RBS right after the 10:00 there could be in both languages that could trigger the same initiative in other places sh80 um this is more in Hebrew oh shim freedland is in and he learns everybody knows uh I have an interesting class this year a little um what's the word m it's um challenging thank you and it would really help them if I could use the pictures from the shear so yes you could definitely use the pictures there's a there's a there's a school Ines that uses our pictures but they work really hard to take out the mdy logo from it it won't show anything that has MD on it so that I on no MD Y is MD y once in a while he can mention us so maybe one of the fathers they maybe they're anti so don't use it if you're anti here's the question of the day I have we have a little time now for the initiative from Heritage Foundation I can't tell you how many times RAB Rothchild drove in to bees count how many many times yph did he drive in here came from he came special from Kar you he was [Music] here didn't F so here's the question um M Yehuda are Partners in a construction company firm and they're supposed to be building my dream house m is a pleasure to work with but Yehuda drives me nuts he's always arguing nitpicking like crazy with him everything takes ages because he insists on irrelevant details I just I can't take it anymore I've decided to take my business elsewhere M will be devastated that I'm leaving and I really want to maintain my friendship with him I want to tell him that his partner is just too stressful to work with can I tell MTI that I'm leaving because of his partner Yehuda a no it will cause a rift between M and Yehuda yes Dove can tell MTI why he's leaving so that MTI will not be upset with him yes do can tell M so that M will tell you who to stop being so difficult with other customers in other words c c c everybody saying c not at all so he's saying that the answer is it depends if this is interesting if those decid to switch companies and is just telling M so that M won't be angry with him if his to is just to keep the friendship it's not a and it's forbidden why is that not a I don't know but do is still a customer who's just considering leaving the company because ofation with Yuda then he could tell M look at rule three of but before telling M should approach yud explain to him that some of the things he's doing are causing him to consider leaving this is because one of the rules of T is that one must first approach the subject you hear this one must first approach the subject before discussing the matter with someone else in the of Z the sponsors the of the month is sponsored bys huh he's back I just noticed is sponsored for the sa and speed return of all the hostages speed return speed return of that's also spons by and and also another sponsor matching donation for the for all that come from supporting should give you all the BR you know what they are I know what they are no I don't know all them I know some of them for that last day fellow mdy members wife she should have a learning and in the month so I had the pleasure of meeting this individual this individual happens to be a very uh I would say looking person like a black Hatter very serious kind of guy a guy that that learns a lot and he's part of our she for for belly does not cheat this $5,000 and the whole MD staff to continue to make so enjoyable for so many sponsoring the art of the month Rabbi so we're holding on all the way in the bottom two lines from the bottom to remind we we had two cases that are very very similar there's only like a word or two difference between the two them and that is if a person is selling one c a certain amount of of produce flour let's say and he says straight out that's normal right I'm selling you this whole huh tomorrow we're halfway through Basra I also remind the that if you come on M you'll be I can't promise we'll have any left over you'll be in one of these unbelievable um full year a full year uh bookmark the only thing we asked them to reprint because it doesn't mention but it does mention in here the shabbaton it's on here somewhere the third day into Sanhedrin which is you know because we're doing so this there's also another one that um the thei from England made we had that also but I don't have them anymore where's the hes oh here it is we have a we have competition here you go both ways what this is the haris yeah but this doesn't have the whole year okay but it's it has other stuff what this is the whole year maybe he has then I would push this and I'm just okay fine this the har one page this page not okay wow same size here are the two cases you see the two cases a person says straight out like we do today I'm selling you a whole core for x amount of money so when you start filling up here take a look at the measuring cup nothing happens until the entire cup is full when the whole cup is full then it's a sale but if a person sticks in that's normal but he explains each saw is a sell cuz a c has 30 so he's breaking it up and into 30 parts so there's 30 different K going on here so if we do this one each little saw is an individual Kenyon as it happens the buyer acquires it one one saw at a time no so once once he acquires it nobody can go back you can go back on the rest but not on what you already put into the CLE in the first case you go back on entire amount all the way to that once it hits the top boom it's over so now the gar is going to ask something happens if it breaks no yeah if it breaks then the uh the owner it's the owner's respons the seller's responsibility G to ask a few questions here very interesting stuff today s very simple I'll tell to you in hour terms you know like a p it's very hard to get a cleaning lady so you you makeup it's very hard every day you found the cleaning lady right now right before suus you find the cleaning lady you make a deal with her you say listen PES time in a half a year from now I want to hire you how much do you want so typically a cleaning lady here in is about 60 70 shekele an hour she says you know I'll do it for 30 shekele an hour if you give me all the money up front give me 3,000 shek right now I'll work for 30 shekele an hour so give her 3,000 shek now she gets to use the money for a half a year and half a year from now she comes and she works P when everybody's charging not 70 they charge a 100 she's she's charging 30 shek an hour so the says it's a problem of ribus why because she's taking all the money in advance and she's waiting with the money she's she's keeping the money for 6 months and then she's giving you a discount she give something cheaper that's M says the is going to say at the then it's not so because she has the right to decide how much it takes per hour but it looks like ribbers everybody in the neighborhood is taking 100 chel an hour it looks me again everybody in the neighborh takes 100 chel an hour she's taking 30 why because you gave her a loan you gave her a loan oh you still I thought you paid her everything you paid her no you did you paid her everything but in six months in advance so she has a loan she has a loan for six months now she took the 3,000 shekele bought a car for six months she has your money why why is she giving you a cheap price cuz she borrowed money from you no the 3,000 sheo that's that's her right it's a loan you're giving her the money in advance okay yeah listen listen listen what is Rivers rivus what is rivus ribus means I give you a th000 you give me back 1,100 I gave you 3,000 shekel and I'm giving you cheap labor in six months from now everybody's getting a 100 shekel an hour paid right then from the beginning correct cheap lab but to labor here's the money I everything now the money for okay hold on let's maybe maybe it will come clear as we go on yeah says says the gamar now I just want to show you real quickly this is this is PES time right this is PES it's called I just gave you an example of P there's something in the time of the gar called G we saw that that during the when they reap the wheat that's when they need all hands on deck they need everybody ra would send all his go work because you get a tremendous amount of money you get four times the amount literally four times the amount so he told all B all married guys go work make four times the amount now you have some cash now you can learn the whole year this is what Guardian looks like the noises the annoying ones will stop in a second this is Thea don't go that no there all they get a little bit of a headache if they went that fast now this Zyra throwing it up winno this the whole process you need a lot of people for this so the demand for workers is really high people pay a lot of money this is a pure stuff that after a few hours of work they get like two pounds of the stuff gal working four guys after whole day 18 people exactly okay this is the process of Gin Gin Demands a lot of money oh they even that's amazing okay now let's see inside this is the story of the cleaning lady I hire a worker to work in the the highest demand season I give him one dinner which is 25% of the going rate of a s but during thein season he could demand a full sell four times the amount if becomes Al loone I'm giving I'm paying him today the the the 3,000 so he should work for me later by the GU for a cheaper amount he's not permitted to use the money because that's a loan and what's the CL and [Music] ribb if you you're waiting with the money the you're paying for waiting with the money you're giving extra because I got your money I will give you something later what am I giving you later I'm giving you cheap labor instead of charging four times the amount I'm charging you 25% this is just how do you get out of this problem if I CH if I do the same thing for PES I'm going to give you I'm going to work for a quarter of the price but I'm going to start today suus I'm going to be your cleaning lady today today suus I'm starting today at 25% that's my wage 25% and I'll work through PES at the 25% wage if I start today it's not a problem of rib the is going to explain everything I if he started today here we have it if he you see on the right side there's a little there's a little coin that's what they decided he's going to work for the small coin during the Gan time on the left in ER everybody gets four times the amount so if he started working on the left it's AER if you started working on the right when it's really cheaper to work then and that's when they decide to work then it's m if he started working in this in this place it's now as the gar on R remember R ra say that if a person says straight out I'm selling 30 30 measurements and each measurement I'm taking from you one saw so as we go along as he fills up the the measuring device there's a kenon another kenon another kenon as thear isn't our case of this cleaning lady the same thing every day is another measurement every day is another kenon you have to you have to view every day as its own entity she worked one day she gets paid for that day worked another day another day so it may last the when you gave her all the money in advance to work through PES so what if she started today on sukus and she's going to work every day every day it's his own thing so why did she get all the money through PES it's still a she's still taking a loan if it was one job to work from suus to PES and she got all the money today in advance for one job she started the job and she got all the money okay but if every day is its own entity just like we said by a measuring cup every every time a s goes into the cup stop there's a Kenyon stop there's another K so stop at day one that you wor and that's it so why did you give her all the money in advance that's rib say much better here just to compare the two things the wants to compare that every saw is its own entity is very similar to starting to work in Nissan and taking all the money in advance but every day is its own its own entity every day it's its own entity and it should be also to benefit from that loan from all the money in advance why do you say that if I contract to work for a quarter of the price a dinner instead of a sell for every day even though I go through the period it's he why is he taking all the money in advance why is this working the ging guy he works in a very high demand job but he's taking very little money the reason is cuz you gave him a loan you gave him all the money in advance isn't that a problem says ra unbelievable and this explains also you really think a person is not allowed to take a small amount of money for his work a human being could take whatever he wants per hour you can't decide what a human being should take says the rashbam beautiful here's the rashbam uh the ram is yeah the it's like where it says right where it says gamar after it says Mish then it says Gar so to the to the right of that it says like this and if you want you can look on the screen says the the the the the payment that you pay a person for his work there is no ribus on that why it's the way of a worker to to rent himself out even for nothing when a person is starving and he has nothing at home so he'll work for a dollar an hour also he's allowed to do that you can't say oh it's say no you ripped him off no that's what he's masing to work for whatever he considers that it pays for him at that point he'll do it if he's a lawyer that makes $1,000 an hour he won't work for a nickel less than $1,000 an hour if he doesn't have food to put in his mouth and he's literally starving so work for a nickel also whatever he could get can't if your kids are starving they're starving he's going to go to work what can't be zero you got to pay something it could be zero also time out abam ask know fix all these guys they work for zero for mdy you could work for zero Z person could decide I am donating my time what's the problem that point no what do you mean no z z so they won't be alone I'm talking about in a in a in a time that a guy decided I'm working for a dollar an hour here's $1,000 for th000 hours says ra a person is permitted to do that there is no Ribbit on a person's so what is the problem what is the problem [Music] so um no I just want to pause here for a second because at the end of the day we'll get to the gamar but this is important because happened yesterday the end of the day a person's hour is worth as much as he decides it's worth so if a person says there are people say listen I need to come to the she I need to come to da today but you're going to lose $1,000 he says so what I need to come so he just made a a hour of learning is worth $1,000 to he just told for me an hour of learning is at least $1,000 just yesterday unfortunate thing happened no but I pointed out I had a little screaming match here in the k i I asked the guy where you going he says I have to go pick up my kid I said why because if you come this it's five shek I said you're joking right he says no five shekels I said so you just made all your learning worth five shekele you just said that learning five shekel five shekel is more important than the learning that's what you just said you just you just decided right here we're learning the Su and you're telling me so now hold on what what oh he didn't say that correct correct I was about to do there if the and what happened was I took out 200 Che from said here I know you're struggling with money here this is for all the five shekels in the future five shekels so he stayed he stayed exra 25 minutes so I I I spoke to him I said is the going to end upset no they like there's a lot of people they make a little extra money like that you're right if it was a problem of Midas you're 100% right if it's a problem of money you just decide these guys struggle five shek means a lot to them but I said you just you just lessened all your tire to five shek that's what you just did it's unfortunate I don't want to be in that position you're right I'm just throwing it out but forget the bad part the good part the people there's a guy that came two nights ago to the Hebrew Sher came over he says I'm he comes every night with his son he says I just gave up a private yesai Rebo concert in my friend's backyard with a swimming pool to come to this year we we for forgo we forget for for for when not a word that I know how to say we gave up we gave up this is better in panovich we never said we for went for went for goat I would say no no that sounds I'm marat's dick I I knew that you don't say it like that the okay listen why you guys said for go for when you listen to these guys okay these two guys what for when okay yeah yeah okay right there we're not learning English here in this class this class you like okay so the says similar moal to what we said the other day it says galdi he says that a guy was very wealthy and he lost all his money so somebody asked him why why are you working as a garbage man he says a garbage man I'm starving he says yeah but why garbage man he says because I'm starving I'm starving I have to eat something what do what else should I do so says when when you're starving you have very little T mitz in your life so then you have to everything you have to so even if like people tell me is it considered learning I mean uh one and a half speed in my car in tra yeah if you if you're starving you have no whatever you is the ultimate learning in the world of sitting down and harving over no but at least for not because it's not the best that's why you're not going to eat you got to whatever you okay so says like this H I know guy that had a ticket back to Israel that he was going to miss giving she and he bought a brand new ticket you don't got like that I don't remember the story but could be it's a story really [Music] wow that tiet for went that ticket get over here say the story out loud he was willing to forg willing to forgo that's too many words too many words you should write in okay so also me also what a person can't take less money than he's worth he needs it right now so therefore we still have to understand why is there two cases if you're allowed to take money up front and you're allowed to take whatever you want but only if you start today at Su time but if you do the same thing in P time it's AES you're allow to take what however much money you want you just said says when you're not starting to work right away then it looks it looks like like the the M that I had over there the I love that M but we're not going to say it again it looks like yeah I was in a I was in a hotel with that that was struggling let's call them struggling they came with what's his name Frank Frank a whole Frank a whole group of them I actually met up with some of them recently and uh they said what are you doing I'm going toia we're going to there's a there's a thiser Pizza my kids love pizza so oh very interesting so we go with them and they were struggling with the whole we got there and uh I see them looking back forth and then they walked away said is what happened he said we can't do it we can't pull the trigger I said why not because it looks like so I said but didn't you eat the other day no no no this is different this looks like we're not doing it it looks like this this looks like pizza we can't do it anyways looks so I heard AA from Jacobs I it blew my mind and there's a suff to it why said that a couple he's trying to get to the Su you're going to get to the m you're going to get to the Su chill out you're going to get you're going to get you're going to understand everything perfect but you have to hear the Su you have to hear this mice you're G love it a couple comes to to and says our son took off his and shavas we don't know what to do so why says your son took off his your son is M shavas do you mean he took off theal so so he said yeah yeah yeah nobody knows about is like he showed up without a so i s over this story to a huge and he says of course the parents are right what do you mean if you do you could do cha you'll probably do but to take off your like that him like do you understand what you saying and we went back and forth he he didn't understand what I said I didn't understand what he was saying I hear the Sensitivity I hear I hear he's still going to Sho I don't know no he's going for the kides he's going for the kdes anyway I said the story over to to to to Mayor kenig see he had a kid in his house for for for a while he says the mother M the mother called him up he says my my kid I don't know what to do he he he took off that that the rim around his yamako he's going with yam like stefansky like a sheit so so he told her he says uh I have news for you but uh your son doesn't really keep shabas doesn't wear filling so she said yeah yeah yeah that's POS it but nobody sees it the same thing you told me nobody knows about it okay so over here it looks it look now you understand this meny it looks like rivus when it looks like ribus when it looks like har you can't do it it's not ribbers it's not ribus why is it not rivus because there's no rivers on a person's salary on a person's wages but when it looks bad I give you a loan of 3,000 today so that you work for me in six months from now for cheap it looks like ribus so it looks like ribus is aome but when it doesn't look like Ribbit when you start working right away today [Music] says says in the that if you're selling fla sell you 50 acres of flax if you rip out of the ground three pieces of flax you acquired all the fla as what because you took two pieces out of the ground that makes a king let's say I sell you 10 of these screens over here you lift one of these up you kind of the rest no you have to you have to make it K you have to acquire everything go improve the car anywhere even a small amount so you went and you cleaned up three stocks worth two inches worth of the car is on top I think is also saying that although my argued with me he says argues with this so I like going to go with t in this case I always go with but it's at top of the page it's easy to find I want you to make say it's like making now it's lent to you it's rented to you lent to you now the entire 50 acres becomes yours so now because it's all yours you make a Ken on everything [Music] says if I sell you wine or oil your friend and went up in price down in price the measuring cup if somebody can bring me paper towels CU I bring it's a little dirty here what I'm about to do it's not it's not going to get you guys dirty okay I might as well just use the the measuring cup right now cuz we used it yesterday you know what let me just I'll put on my gloves because it's I don't want to get all oily you'll understand the whole Su perfectly before sh just do this maybe okay this is a measuring cup so it says in the gamar that if went up in price didn't if it's not full until the top so this goes to cell up to here he starts filling filling filling up yeah we could do it right now why not it's not you go like this up uhuh I'm the seller it's still mine but once it's all the way up to the top amount then it goes oh it's two cups exactly now it goes to the buyer that's not why I brought this thing here show in a [Music] second if the middle man was there the how do you call the middle man in English the the not the the broker the broker if he was there now the broker is not acting as an agent for anybody he's doing his own business he's a middleman he likes to take a cut in the middle so if the barrel breaks then the middleman the broker he takes the loss oh says the that you have to give him three that's what I want to show you check this out it's beautiful stuff I'm gon to I'm the seller and you're the buyer you you gave me this CLE so I'm going to pour all this now you gotta it's very very quick when it stops coming out of the CLE you know when you go to the gas station you fill up your tank and then you have to like put the three drops in some people stay there for 6 minutes cuz they want to get the last drop and they squeeze the pipe a little bit that's what we're doing over here with oil no no people do it because they don't want the car to get dirty not because it's stingy no not here watch this it's going to happen quickly I'm pouring this in pouring this in pour pour pour pour pour pour pour here one two three that's it how much oil do have left in here hardly anything now wait if you wait the longer you wait the more oil is going to fill into this check this out I'm going to go sideways here it's starting to fill up you could see you see we'll wait here for two seconds and you'll see how much oil I have as the as the seller I have to fill your thing up and then three drops one two three boom but you bought all of this you paid for two cups but guess what you see how much oil hair now it's very significant there's a guy in the shear last night guy with a long beard came over to me after the she he says we grew up in when we had a thing of oil like that my mother would put it upside down for an entire day she would wait there an entire day for every single last last drop that's how they grew up told me Danos that they had toothpast toothpaste yeah this m Big M I have a sister I have a sister oh she has tremendous Talent tremendous then afterwards you buy these devices that you can roll it on the roll you know I have a cleaning lady I have those toothpastes that you know stand upwards they don't she for some reason figures that it's right side down so she flips it over now when you're at the end I'm trying to get to Shear one last toothbrush thing and I have to wait why do you have to flip it over you see it every day this way she has to flip it over that way I'm a got to fire her but I need her for p anyway say last night middle of hold on we got to move meny needs to learn [Music] Theo means literally check this out you put it sideways Hino you put it size Matas here I could do I have the thing I forgot what's oh here we go her K I did a whole I devised the way that I'll still have sticky tape on the kinus this is called if you want to know what this amount that's left there now it's getting more you see this it's that belongs to who to the seller the is going to explain to us because it comes out of use in other words the the buyer has no interest in waiting around for 5 minutes until everything comes to the bottom and then you'll repour it he want to get out of there a guy that does this for a living what he's going to sit there for five minutes Every Time Boom he doesn't have to do three tip so let me just show you real quickly we just had the Raa says that the the seller has to give three tip and the sa says you poter the said he said I could tell after yipper he looked at all I can I know exactly what each person D for and what answered him knew anybody want to try me nobody everybody was scared one guy says yeah rabbit tried me so he says okay you you have a store you sell stuff and you like to learn but the problem is that customers come in every five minutes and they disturb your learning so you as all my customers should come in one shot I can learn normal wow how do you know what did say said nine no I want you to to be oid me the way you're supposed to be oid I'm not going to give you everything you're gonna you're going to learn with your little problems in between with the little things so I made this easy for everybody the seems to be not difficult just to to hold Cup this AA Thea says the the seller has to give two drops is that what re says look check this out is re going on the ra but three drops says you don't have to give any drops or no we just learned that A store owner doesn't have to give three drops is gonna be M says no only on a shabas you don't have to give three drops but on Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday you do have to give three drops okay so this is just a little kazara preview and by the way here in we're more than the mishna because over here if you have your store open two hours before shabas they'll revoke your he over here it says you know all the way shabas people used to have this store is open so the ask a simple question who owns this measuring cup you're going to tell me it's the purchasers measuring cup actually the buyer it's this is his measuring cup and the seller is putting stuff into his measuring cup why should it be the sellers every little bit that goes into the to the cup should be the buyers we learned it you're going to tell me that it's really the sellers so then the question is even if it's the sellers and I filled it up two cups how did it just become the buyers so what if I feel it's in the sell's vessel and I feel up what KY was he it's still the of the of the seller it's owned by here remember we had a middle man the the broker he's lending his vessel see it has his picture in it so the same thing that we said the other day when two people borrow one CLE from one person so depends who needs it at that point in the beginning the seller needs it so as long as he's filling it up here it belongs there he's filling it up it belongs to the m as soon as it fills up boom it jumps to the can't be a middleman's says in the end if there was a middleman only in the sa does the introduce a middleman that if the the barrel broke then it goes to the middle man is not talking about a middle man says we're talking about that he just lent his CLE he wasn't around but in the sa it's talking about this case that we see on the screen the middleman was actually present so if he's present he takes full responsibility of what goes in his CLE he's trying to make all the money he can so then he's responsible for everything that's there but if he just lent to Cle then what because then he doesn't release he doesn't relinquish his CLE it's his he's there I'm waiting for my it's his CLE but when he's not there he gives it to them okay very very simple question let's pretend that this whole CLE was full of true Trum Hees and I'm giving I go to the C I pour the same thing I did to the seller to the buyer this C own by a buyer Pretend This C is own by a Cen I got C I have a whole measuring cup full of oil I want to give you as a gift as a truma gift he says okay I fill it up I do three drops but look how much is left now whose oil is this whose oil is this it's the cion truma it's truma the whole thing was truma how to become come mine so if you if you agree to me that this oil is the it's true it's so how in the world are the whatever is left over if this is not a k Why is it now the the sellers not the buyers you just admitted to me that it's the other guy the guy that that deserves it bumped into does anybody know that said that we just learned showed him here go to he's a says I heard you have some issues let me he he tells him that when you when you put the CLE on a side like this sideways whatever is left over is the sellers but 3 minutes more than enough B ra it says that if you do that it's Trum forgot to tell the isra is a very important so I'm going to tell to you now before I forget even if this is truma the stuff on the bottom if I pour this in here and right away I fill up my CLE again that's good then I don't have an issue with truma because the stuff is all over the CLE it didn't gather on the bottom but if I wait and I have this on the bottom now it's legit now I have a problem now it's truma says you use it right away not over here you're right it should be the buyers the reason why here let's see now now let's see together how much actually fell to the bottom this is this is a serious amount especially if you lived in 70 60 years ago okay so says the you're right it should be the buyers the reason it's the sellers is because the buyer gives up on it he doesn't want to wait around for five minutes he gives it as a gift to the seller but when it comes to you can't is not being here it's aem's so what hm doesn't want to wait around five minutes that's becomes yours it's still K still heish says the now these words make a lot of sense we already did it let's do it again the r on top says red that the seller has to give three drops to the buyer and the saus says that but a guy that does this professionally for a living he doesn't have to give three drops R comes and says but you Potter so was he referring to the ratio where it says that this when I sell privately to you I have to give three drops but under shabas I don't have to give so that's a COA or he's saying that even a store owner who does this professionally must give three drops throughout the whole week the only time that he's Potter is on a Friday afternoon and very very interesting I got to tell you this the wants to bring a r from here unbelievable again how one gar could have could could be a riot to something completely abstract shabas morning you take a mug you wash it out in the sink you have a bunch of cold water in your mug then you go to the n and you fill up your cup you're over on Bish cooking up the water that's in your mug oh so he says he wants to bring a ride from here that if you go like this to your mug three times you barely have any water in there it's m because we see over here that whatever is left over in the mug is insignificant says the what you're talking about it's insignificant because he's he's to the guy because of but not because it's [Music] insignificant I I just not I'm not sticking around for five minutes to wait for that insignificant amount of water so water is less than oil I get it the whole thing I'm just throwing it out that has to do with here what truma exactly truma it's a problem soab shabas is also problem truma it stays truma it is truma so shabas it should also stay chabas what truma stayed everything in this vessel is 100% truma you're not allow to use it you're saying even in the case that he filled it up with his own stuff then not then not if you fill with his own stuff but over here as he filling up the water you're talking about after you fill it up with water as you pouring in the hot water which was later it's already time for okay I'll prove it to you the it seems like was referring to let's go back to this chart was referring to the sa that we're talking about shabas the the so he's actually being where the the mishna says that a owner could doesn't have he could get away with giving the three drops that's only on a shabas because we're talking about says the Mish this is really going to make people go crazy this this this if I ask you not a single person in this room will agree with this mishna unless he sees the gar and is like the somebody sends his young child to the it happens here in every day to buy some oil he gives him a larger denomination it's worth two so the owner says okay you you give me a CLE he fills it up with oil gives him the change he gives him one is back a whole CLE is worth one one iser the kid comes with two he gives him back one change now we're broke on the way got destroyed who's responsible so the mishna says what y you saw the Hebrew she you learned the mishna there's no way logically speaking doesn't make any sense I sent my kid to buy something so I'm responsible for everything that happens to the kid on the way home give it to the kid oh I shouldn't have G to the kid and your kid that goes to the mall across the street from your house and and then the battle breaks who's I wouldn't send ah you wouldn't send him but you do send him you do send all the time eggs everything I know what you do don't tell me stories he lost it he broke it everything went the famous story that Happ I said this a long time ago say again two brothers weren't talking to each other for 50 years when the when one of the brothers is 88 years old they decid to make some peace and uh it turns out like this it turns out that one of the brothers was trying to make peace 50 years earlier in and he sent his brother shus and he sent it with his son the son was a little kid the son trips the whole sh the cakes that the the mother made everything falls into the street the street had full of cow dung and horse dung whatever you know the times you line so you have all this soya and everything wrapped around the cake the kid takes everything he's really embarrassed he takes all the cake puts it back in wraps it up and delivers the brother who's in a fight he opens up the they sent me cake with cow dun so he goes to his porch he lived in gim goes to his porch in men's apartment he takes a full shovel worth of pigeon poop puts it in a plate wraps it up nicely sends it back to the brother so now you have a fight for 50 years how do we know the story because the the son who was 60 years old at the time he didn't care to tell the Father the m 60 years earlier 50 years earlier he scared because he Tri they didn't want to tell his parents now he tell the parents so they f for 50 years for no reason just remind me here kid trips falls breaks the whole thing says the T this is the the owner like said like said like said because he shouldn't have sented with him the says like us like most of us besides y that you sent the kid there you took responsibility yourself and agree that if the the guy took the the the vessel here the vessel and he measured it and he gave it then the storekeeper is from the actual vessel says the I can understand the far what's going on when I send my kid to the store what I'm trying to do is you you're the store you see a y old that could barely walk straight and he comes he says fill this up with oil you know he's going to trip so what the father want to do is fill it up with oil put it on the side I'll send the later with a taxi I'll figure out how to get to you but don't send it back with a kid you know better than that you the no the father took the took the chance says the father by giving a very breakable item to the son and tells him walk to the store M he's mate so so why should the store owner be on the on the C we're talking about that the father not the store owner the father is a seller of these of these battles and the store owner said oh interesting you want to sell this to me and he takes it looks looks at it oh once he takes it in his hand to to check it out now he's responsible for it two more lines says so we have so what the arguing in if if if he looks at it he or not doesn't make any sense no no no when you buy oil the guy's selling you the oil he's selling you the vessel and everything so the father was never MAF to begin with it started the it started its Journey from the from the store okay this piece of glass is the same thing as oil so say who's responsible on the oil the storekeeper who's responsible for the glass the storekeeper and flip says no who's responsible for the oil the child the father and who's responsible for the glass the father it's the same it's just it's another item that he's buying from the store he's buying two items oil and a glass and either according to the store own according to the father at 9:30 notar have a wonderful day aab