CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 90 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] We're holding by Omar Raveno eight lines from the bottom [snorts] rails. So we had a guy we have a guy that does the videos for us. This is a murim the the certain parts of the animal even on and kachum. So let's let's see if we have the list here of kachum. No not today. Okay you know there's um asham maybe you have >> no no listen do me a favor. Hold on a second. We're finding it in seconds. That's some of the kicum you have to take [clears throat] from the kajimum. Not some from the kalum. You take a murim am a murim and the kidneys the the skirt steak and some of the fat you put it on. Now what happens if now the the im we know turn into kachum even though it's kachum which is a lesser degree of than kachimas etc the isum but part of it becomes kach when you put it on the when you do. So what happens is it went it left the B mikdash before you were able to do what's poss so what happened some of the left mdash pleat we learned in the Mishna that mser comes before the bird messer the an animal every 10 animals you have to give it a red dot but it's an An animal comes it always comes before a bird. We'll see today actually there are cases that not really. So the Misha says there's two reasons why it's uh it comes before the the bird. First of all this and has meaning of two things the blood and the imm. So the obvious question is when you're reading it should ask but doesn't a bird also have blood you have to sprinkle the blood of a bird on the there's no by a bird but there is blood what the what the is the is trying to say is that there's there's something in common between the blood and theim of course there's blood by a bird but there's a regarding that that comes from blood. The blood obviously is before. So even we're talking about before this and nevertheless it's considered the of the are considered before this and just like when the blood leaves the mdash there's something called it left that's it it's possible you can't put it back on the that's the rail Oh, no. Did I skip? Yeah. Now I have five lines from the bottom. This is similar but very different. Over here we're talking about the stakes. The boser of not the immat where? Inim somewhere. So, boys, this is a good time to make sure your phones are off. I know that it's different time of the day, but it's a good time to check your phone. think because we're talking about the Ber that went outside of the BD before says it's why is it anyway you're allowed to take it outside of the B mikdash and eat it so you took it out a little early jump the gun before the says yes you're going to take it out but wait have patience first then you take it out it's only because this is a steak that you're going to lawyer everybody's going to agree that it's possible like said there's no don't argue in something else they should argue in aim no they're not arguing anymore because once you take outside they become just like it's possible it's not a good why it's possible that the you ask me a good how come argue on steaks. They don't argue. You want to show how much holds that even a nice piece of steak that came off the carpet that you're allowed to eat and you're allowed to eat in your house. He holds that it's still puzzle. But let's say that this is not that's our case. You have that left before you had a chance to do it says there's no meaning it's it's not there's no it lost it it's finished there's no there's no noise or no why because there's no in order if you guys remember in order to do pigle you have to have [clears throat] the done. You have to have you have to have no no. Why? Because this you're going to do later is going to be good. It went out but it came back into the holds that it's possible just because it left the says no it didn't become possible since it didn't become possible that's why the still everybody's going to agree that the works if you brought it back in the mdash over here It's outside. And that's why when you have something that's not in the proper place inside, does it have an effect on whatever is outside? Is when it's outside when it came inside. Huh? Oh, that's a different story that you remember the two breads that we bring on together with the schlam. So the schwam and the two breads are not they're not the same. This is bread. This is a bunch of carbs and this is protein. They're two different things. So they're not the same. And therefore the is not going to affect the the bread. But they more that come straight out of the same animal and that they'll also argue when it's outside. Okay, nice easy. Now that we saw I'll remind you uh where where did I put it? H oh here this one. Remember this part where the the bird was upset waiting so long for the last one. Okay. Ma is always last. Why has to [snorts] go? Let's see this one. What do we have here? No, not yet. Adabo says Oh, that's what's going I don't My buttons weren't here. I can use them. Wonder what's going on here. When a person decides to give something to the he didn't do anything just comes to she wants to give a flower. Huh? Oh, sorry. One of these days my head is right now. There's the bird has to bring but the bloodb of a bird is better than a next the sinner somebody who swore falsely is before the of anava. Why? Because comes first. But the has more things with it. And we said already, we established that it comes with more stuff. You have to do oil and the frankincense oil. No, at the end of the day comes first. Here we had this game. We don't have to play it now, but you can just see what Yoshi worked till 2:30 in the morning. What comes first? Comes first. And now next. Okay, fine. Great. What's What's the is a woman whose husband warned her not to have with another man. She didn't listen. So now he suspects her. So he brings her to viscess. One of the things is she has to bring a min to see whether or not she was mis that she brings is it for a sin that she did? Huh? >> What is it for? >> Clear up the very clear. Very good. Right. the or neither of them are first sin. Maybe it's the one because it goes together with oil and frankincense, but maybe comes to see if she sinned or not. So it has some sort of connection to and therefore her comes before the has a choice. Should I bring this? Should I bring this? The one that has something to do with comes before I prove it to you. It says that the of the sinner comes before the of you can refer only that comes before. The reason why the person who was whatever sin he did he has to bring how come he comes before because not because it's because it's a sin. This also is coming because of a sin a suspected sinsh. So we don't have a zoo. Oh, so it says there's like a riddle. It says this one comes before this one. We don't know what this one is and we don't want this one. Says one clue we have. There's one that comes from barley. What is that? >> Saita. It's a low lower type of >> It's animal food. Exactly. Animal food. Husband. What else comes from not something else? So, okay. So we know that on the left side the comes from but what comes with from it says that comes before the so we know that we have is the second one second her is going to be the last but what comes first it could either be which is or it could be that we don't know says oh it's referring to the top one is going to come before and what's a classic answer it's referring to the second one you know from here but the says wait a minute you think I didn't think about that I knew you're going to tell me no it's referring to the but it's be so partial why do you have to tell me typically comes to forgive a sin and forgiving a sin that we already established and Anything that comes to forgive sin comes first like comes before what does come before is not so what do you want to tell so it's not the battle one it's the top then [snorts] why would I have to tell you that comes before comes with oil of course it comes first yeah you're right you have this this reason that it's it has more it the other one it comes But at the end of the day, we don't know. It could be one or the other. And we don't know. Oh, you did this. Sorry. Which one is fine? The bird comes before the bird. How do I know this? You have two birds. A woman comes, she gave birth, she brings two birds. The katas, they come together from from one person. Which one do you Which one do you put on his behalf first? Which one are you first or first the referring to the carbon means typically person who would have to bring a carbon you'd have to bring a sheep what's this I don't know what this is of a new chart let's see no I don't think so it's not here. Okay. You know what I is, right? We had it the other day. Person's wealthy, he brings a a sheep. If he's poor, he brings a bird. When it comes to a woman, she would bring a bird instead of one bird she has to bring. Okay. So, she brings a bird instead of her carbon. So, but over here, if he's wealthy, he brings the if he's super super poor, he brings flower. Or if he's in between, he brings birds. Now what happens? This person is supposed to bring an animal. Instead of bringing an animal, instead of bringing he brings two birds, you hear this one, he brings two birds instead of that. One is a one is if it comes to tell us that the should go first. It says in the second one should be I know I had took him. So maybe they they disappear some this is coming to tell us that as we'll see in a second is going to do like a a review that the comes before [snorts] comes before. If they come together if a person has to bring two birds instead of one the should come first. It's even if you have two birds, the comes first that even works in a the animal comes first before the animal. And listen to this. If you have an animal and a bird, the bird is the and the animal is the bird comes first. Remember that. We're going to talk about it for a minute. Again, this is a big usually animals come before birds, but not if the animal is and the bird is a in that case the the bird comes before the and now the we learn from that we have two birds. One is what is comes first that we had yesterday all the way in the top. We had a limo that if you have two animals, one is one is comes first and now we have another thing. And from the fact that we see in the beginning that if you have two birds, two birds the comes before and we learn from there the is extra. We learn from there that is before also in a case where when you have you have a woman who gave birth and she brings that she can't get out of even if she's poor she has to bring the and she brings comes before There's a way to remember it a little bit. Why is it that when a person has to bring an animal but he can't afford it? He brings two birds, one katus, one. Shouldn't he just bring one bird and finish the bird instead of animal? Why does he bring and what does the have to do with anything? is because when you bring a katus animal part of it goes on and part of it the gets to eat. But if you have a bird the eats it there's nothing that goes in. So therefore we bring two birds one is goes completely and one is a it could help us understand a little bit of what this far what's going on behind the scenes here. So says tomorrow When you get rid of the katus animal and say you bring two birds then the katus bird is first. Why? Because you're getting rid of a katus animal. So he's bring the bird first. Doesn't make sense to bring the bird first. No going to say like three spars here since the birds are instead of the so what makes sense the should go before. The birds are instead of the so the bird should be first. This is a second reason since it comes for a sin. This is like a third reason. And and anytime that two come instead of one Okay. So rabb says no not a good kasha. You're asking me that you see over here that the bird comes before the katas bird and we just said the opposite that the katus comes first. So this is no this part that we just read that the bird comes before the katus bird is only how you read it but it doesn't really mean it always comes before the bird the before the gumar is just explaining why it says in theory that the bird comes like it mentions the bird first not that it's supposed to be first bird comes first like we said you bring me a kashi here because it seems like the the bird is first no it's just in the reading of it and we have to explain why it's the Tyra said it like that. We don't know exactly what it's talking about, but it says that the the bulls come before the the rams and the rams come before sheep and the sheep come before the sire which is and the so it says my so now you see you see I have it over here but I don't have time to look for it here I think it's over here Good. You see that the comes before the aren't we talking about? We're not talking about we're talking about that everything is so you can't bring me right from here. What comes first? It's all and explains that obeys Why do the bulls come first? Because they have a lot of a lot of wine. The same reason why. Why? Because they have a lot of the the sheep have a lot of fat on the tail. We remember Yeah. The kind made a mistake in he has to bring a special bull. No, no, no. Yeah. Yeah. That's what it is. When say you could eat a certain type of let's say they make a mistake, they bring a a different type of bull. And if made a mistake with they also bring a bor and over here you have the comes before the comes before the so we have a problem here you see the comes before but why didn't you learn from the first part you have that comes for yeah meaning I'm talking about when it's two like you have a a bull and a goat you see that the which is a bull comes before the the goat says okay good over there it's something special they say the reason it's only here. It's a one time thing because the word is missing and that's why it loses its superiority comes before it says without I have another reason why here it's a one time thing. It says like this. So, so it should be now that you said that the word means just like so and it's different than the rest of the you could answer the same thing by by the top of the we're talking about the bulls of over there it also says so that's why the is first you don't have to say that the whole thing is whatever we answer there no the comes before is because even though it's but it says in the paras Great. Now we have a very interesting question and with that we're going to finish. Let me ask you what comes first or comes before me comes before a bird and a katas bird comes before ana comes before messer and messer comes before. So what do you do? comes before that we said a miser comes before a and a comes before. So you got to stick a problem. You get dizzy. What do you mean? So what do you do? If you should if you bring the bird first the law comes first. Because an animal comes before a bird and should be first before me and the should be should go first. We just established that the bird comes before the said. So you have a problem here. Let's let's show this again. This is what you do. The ma should come before the the can't go first because it's together with the they come together, right? They're they're a package deal. They came together and the cannot the always goes before. You cannot break that rule. Two has to go before three. You can't do three before two. Can't put before. But what you could do is one could go before two. Why? because one is an animal. Animals go before birds just happens to be that when you have the bird then then it's an exception to the rule. So they're done. So we can't deal with them. But you you can do one before two. That's what they said in they said that they said the truth is they're saying that you can't you can't put me first. Why? Because what's this? What's so special about me? The miserma is a beah. And a bea goes before a bird. Guess what? is also bea has that that specialness. It's it's special [clears throat] just what it has a problem that the the bird is with it. But let's take let's take the two of them together and rise above the micer. So let's see rash inside is like this is more than so is better has a high it's a higher than it's all toe we have a special that says that the bird comes You're telling me because it's an animal. So what is also an animal has that also it's not is not greater than also is a is greater than therefore says the gor what do we do like this you make the first because the two of them rise higher than the micer the big special thing that miser has I lost also has and is more important than messer. So oil has to go before messer and kus goes before. So therefore is one bird is one is two is three. Have a wonderful night have a good and we'll see you tomorrow. [music] [singing] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor at mdy.com.