CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 69 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Today's test by the way. But have no fear because >> the are here. Exactly. Is here. Take a look at. So anyway, call Absum. What's a pos instance? A guy that lost a parent that day. He's and he did Malika. However, it has the power. It still has enough in it. We consider it a malik to the point where this animal, this bird is not tom. So if you eat it typically you eat a kosher bird that's that's an aa and if you perform outside of it's a thea is it's an interesting one of a kind that you touch it nothing but if you put it in your your your mouth you're not an interesting question if you touch a cow that that was run over by a car you become tom if you pull it you become what if you take a piece piece of meat. Somebody takes a piece of meat of a cow that's tame and opens up your mouth with you know pliers and puts it in the back of your mouth. you become tummy. It's a only I'm going to hint only by a bird. If you take an available bird and you put in the back of your mouth, you become but if you touch it not both ways are that the fact that you touch it you don't become and the fact that you put it in the back of your mouth you do become what if a person does the malik with his left hand doesn't seem like such a bad thing you do it at night at night or you take a bird and you sh it inside it with a knife inside with a knife or at the end of the day the has enough power to remove the whether you do it inside the basement outside the basement. If you do in the toys has a power obviously. So even if you didn't you you were wrong for doita within with a chicken inside you shouldn't it still removes the toma and you should definitely not take a bird that's designated as an and take it outside and it but you did the has enough power to remove the the tomak and here goes a whole another category. Use the knife. That's not That's not That's nothing. Using a knife in the back side of the neck. That's no different than taking a gun and shooting in the back of the neck. >> Why is it called? >> Cuz he did an action of Malika. It's the same action, but it's not Malika, right? It's not. It's the same thing. It just It's trying to tell you even though it's in the back of the neck, it's in the same spot as Malika, nothing. It's a sack. It's a knife. No good. If you perform on a nonchim bird, you took a bird who wasn't designated as anything and you did a malik on him. So he did a malik of inside terrible stuff or he did a malik on a on aesh bird outside. It doesn't work. You have these birds, the there's two types of birds. We have the young pigeons and the older doves. So if they're not old enough or the the pigeons are too old, the ugly ones or its foot fell off basically or it became blind. So very interesting. So the Rashi says over here, look at Rashi. say it's missing a limb. Now missing a limb is different. We know that this very it's very hard to make a tra on a bird. But missing a limb is different. Why says and where do we have this week's there's a there's a you don't bring nobody in their right mind is going to go to king and say hey king I brought you a gift and give him a bird without a leg a blind bird. when we say that you know did you know that there's no male and female by birds there are but we don't care about it there's no such thing as has to be typically not by bird we don't check and there's no it doesn't have to be whole that's on cataracts but missing limb noon sorry means that it's wing dried out that its eye is blinded and its foot fell off. All these are not a good malika and therefore it's considered that you have an avail in front of you and you put a piece of meat of this bird in your mouth you become says the if what happened was in the the mdash regarding then even though it was the wrong thing you did it with your left hand or whatever you shouldn't have done it but it has the power to remove the tum let's say the the was in the body of the animal the body of the bird it doesn't have an eye this all these things it was too young too old then the doesn't work this is what we saw in the left hand at night at least it has enough power to remove the but when you have a a or like it means and the knife says why what's the say the left hand has some power in it we see once in a while the kayen uses once a year he uses his left hand so it's not the end of the world left hand so mayah Over here also we're going to say it's not the end of the world. And what about night? We know they throw the onto them even at night. Wait a minute. But we know that even a woman could could do in the mdash. So what's wrong with aar? Why? for the same he's saying that the the left and the night is okay because one time we we allow it. Oh, you know what? One time we allow to do says is not an you bring me a ride from says it's not even I'll tell you anything you have to do in the like that came told you the story drove four and a half hours each way right I tell you the story yes every chicken today needs a means It's not an even if it's not how come says it says in the we know that it says it's just we don't know the reasons but it's it has to be part of you know why you need a because it's for the upkeep it's like it has a similar it's not it's not it's It's a lesser called you need that makes no sense what you're saying. So that's if like the lesser of the less which is the money for the upkeep of the of the of the of the mikdash or the temple as some of you guys are going to call it the slaughter house the temple. So certainly for the Oh, we have somebody who gets saras and how do you know if it's or not? You have to go to it could be but it has to be a he looks at it he says you go go it's not considered asking why don't we learn from bama oh so we have some new bombas actually we did bama a few times but nevertheless there's bama actually here's a real bama they they claim it's a real bama they found this you know it's thousand years old thousands bama is when they had there was a certain Kufa a certain time in Klay where they didn't have the B mish you're allowed to to kbar in your backyard they found these stones they decided it's a bum it's okay it's in the museum of I don't know what here in Israel from let's learn from that what that is to when you do with a [clears throat] say if I can't learn from Obama why because there's no connection between Obama and Bama is considered like mundane like compared to the mid ask the famous video that if went outside and you brought it back in and you put it on the bay you don't take it off how do I learn it because bama is outside and it's kosher so you see I do learn things from to the mikdash says the garra remember this answer because we're going to say it twice today. I hope if we ever get there, no, I'm not learning from Obama. I'm learning from the Obama is just a great ex. It's like a it's an answer. the main the main to learn is from okay he says when does a it's good enough to get rid of the toma not like Raf says and how does he learn it from Babak but if you use a knife it's zero you made a that that makes sense no using a knife like like Betty said it's not malikica I don't know what it is. It's it's making it a traan. We learned in the all what what does all mean? All the guys that are apostle. Okay. So, not only but even who says that is not good. What does he do with the word call? What does call mean? Where does it come to to add? It's interesting. Not a type of a person, but a type of malik with the left hand. A person does with his left hand or he does it at night. Even though it's possible, no, it removes the toma. If you look at the look at the call and the Mishna goes on, it's the second line in the Mishna. So what are you telling me that the word call means? It's in the Mishna itself says you're right. It does say it in the Mishna, but first it says it in in like the word and then later on it it it um >> no I'm looking for it uh >> spans a little bit. Okay, fine. Whatever the word is says in the just to explain what this word means. is a very severe tuma. Meaning, typically speaking, if I touch a dead cow that was run over by a car, I become tom my body becomes tummy, but my clothing not by a bird. So if you touch it, you don't become at all, but if you put it in your mouth, you become tom. Not only you become tom, but your clothing becomes that's a severe tumo. So that's what it means. So over here in this comes to explain the once again the same question what does it come to to do for according to doesn't remove the now we got to go in the reverse how would he explain the opposite it says if the the the the travel wasn't in wasn't in what does it come to to to add the the if you a bird. So over here we have to remember this idea they go together you remember this idea from the video if something goes under the certain things don't come off. So if it doesn't come off that itself is like indication that there's no tuma. It's parallel enough if it goes on it doesn't come off. Doesn't come off meaning you remove the but if you do malika of a chicken outside of mdash that's mish killing it that's murder that's just that's making creating an avail. And there is says I have like it says in the that's it. That's that's what we're looking for. That's the case that we're talking about. If it removes that's what it says at the end. But we're going to say a few more in between or somebody who's puzzled like when it comes to pigle the guy thought about pigle and nicer it's left over and to even though you had a thought while you doing you thought about pigle and the real quickly if it doesn't create a piggle then if The Malik is not good at all then it can't be pigle they're how can I make pigle if I take a gun and I shoot uh a cow and I think while I'm shooting him that I'm going to eat this cow in 5 days from now is that pigle no it has to be that has to be has to be so if I do malika and I'm think oh I'm going to eat this in 5 days from now is it pigle well it depends if the malika works then it's pigle so here we're saying It must work in order for it to be and that's why saying it is good is good it makes it therefore it removes the from this bird I heard two things and I don't remember what I heard exactly what I heard I heard about is going into the going like this taking three fingers worth and making a out of And one I heard about performing one comes off the and one doesn't and I don't remember what it makes sense like you're saying that should go off stays on why [snorts] is different why because I can do by so of but but So I could do the same on in my backyard in the time of when was but if you're going to tell me no there is but if there's no then there's no birds they're they're dependent on each other if you say there's no says there's no in if there's no you don't bring a then you don't bring a bird and if you do you do bring a bird and it brings it says by since there's no vessel by obviously the guy in his backyard that has a little thing he doesn't have a golden vessel so doesn't passel but if you do have biker that's why is different But that that you could do by a bummer outside is a destroy from it says in the that if you perform the with your left hand or at night it removes the so it's interesting rashi here doesn't say this but they bring a rashad over here on the side that says we're talking about a malik that's ple talking about okay and they say that this is not the real rashi this is the real rash okay the point is okay according to the the arch scroll and the mif they both bring this as the original that I would think that if you perform a a malik that's pos they put in they put in the word pleim that's inside I think that you're that the it doesn't work and you become even your clothes become means to exclude it's only but maybe this is considered a because you performed the says we learn from tra doesn't create a anything that's so to is not matter but malik which is inside it's able to be muring what does it matter what does malik matter if you think about it you have a kosher bird what exactly does it matter it's matter a live bird that goes in the if a live bird went on it would have to come off malik allows to stand on and therefore it removes the of the mouth now means it says over here I'll bring the case of somebody who does malikum outside or somebody does malik on a non-carbon doesn't matter where he does it if what happens If you put a bird, you take a regular bird and instead of doing you use your nail in the back of its neck, you take a chicken and you put it on the so it's not it doesn't have the power in that case in fact because again I told it's connected if you they have to come off the mb then they they have they have to they don't have to come off the mb they don't have something similar. I think that and outside think no only but like that creates an I learned from the word we're going to see tomorrow also is extra word say and we there has to be they have to be symmetric if inside inside and outside have to be the same. So over here by both of them are also it doesn't matter if you have a bring a tra in English they have to be equal and that comes to exclude mundane bird inside inside the mdash and inside and outside and is going to explain what it means since they're not symmetric There's no what do you mean according we're going according to now the of a bird inside you can't say that the of the bird inside becomes tame why because outside is tar you hear if you shift a bird outside of mdash tar or tar and they have to be the same so if you do it inside of mdash it has to be tar they're not going to be equal. But when it comes to we're talking about birds, right? A bird that's both of them are puzzle. So both of them are puzzle. Why did you tell me a second ago they're not equal? They are equal. They're both puzzle. In other words, saying you must say that the is worth something. It does something. Why? Because if you take a if you an animal outside of the mish take a bird, you shove it outside. It was a bird. What's that? You outside you get carus. So how can you tell me that didn't do anything? It it worked. It worked enough to give you carus. So that means it works. So if it worked so certainly certainly it should work to remove the the the from so and it continues That's that's a great outside. What about inside? Oh, because you have to make them symmetric. They have to be the same. So if you outside if you do sorry outside the bird outside it shouldn't be why because you have to they have to be symmetric and inside it's not why outside makes more sense to learn one thing that you did wrong from another thing that you did wrong rather than learning something that you did wrong from something you did right. In other words, cotton bird that wased inside not properly. What's that? That's that's right. Like >> yeah, that's and and and if you shut it outside, that's inside. And you check the outside both of them are Now if you didn't if you didn't do oh but you cannot learn of outside from of of inside a bird that's inside that was from a bird that was outside and you don't learn something that's not a bird outside with that you that are inside which is ask real quickly you see you see you do something like that why is you did it wrong how do you know that you don't take it off but is kosher so you're learning something that's not kosher for something that's kosher how could that be and over here the say is the same exact answer you said before No, that I learned from a I'm bringing it right from a you're right it's kosher and you're learning something that's not kosher but that's just a not a real learning he's really relying on the not on the >> merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world sponsor a shir today mdysponsor.com or [music] sponsor atmop.com