CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 60 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. Welcome. Welcome to all the guests. We had yesterday the size of and different things. We're continue with that. So, here we go. This is says 5 by five. If the is 5x5 that leaves us one tiny amma in the center that you could be macro on. Why? Because you have to get rid of you can't you can't be m where the horns are and you can't be mac in the amma below the horns because that's where the walks around. So basically you're left with one tiny square in the middle and on that square a thousand in one day argues here here's it says in it says in it says interesting but it's a serious because we're going to see that everybody agrees that Does exist that you start measuring something like this. You take the center point and you come off the center and from there you say five. So yeah the T says five but it really means from the center. Why do I say such a thing? Cuz I see somewhere else the same idea. You're not going from side to side and that would be five 5 by five. You're going to the center from the side to the center. From the side to the center and that gives us a 10x10 mak. So if it's a 10 x 10 mbak now you must remove I don't know if we did that already. We did it yesterday. must remove the outer amma because there's a horn on every corner. You must remove one inner one, but that goes all the way around like right away. So therefore, it takes off two from each side. So we're left with six. If you take off four, 2 + 2 is 4. 10 - 4 is 6. So now have you have a 6x 6 square where you can do kurbanus on 6 * 6 36 36 is had a a 400 m. So in a 400 m you get 1136s in there. So if mob was able to be macar on one square th00and kurbanas so 11 * a th00and is 11,000 carbanas. So therefore we have a problem you cannot be micro 142,000 on this 10 x 10 says so let me just show you we have actually four in here between and according to that the wasn't large enough. So, we had to be we had to be madish the entire a you have a misb in the middle but it's not it's not large enough. So, I have to be able to to be mac and and burn up these carbonas all over the floor. So you had to be m according to mdish according to I didn't have to be makdish the entire it's a massive I don't have to be madar why it all fits on that one that small little 5x5 mb with one that's enough it has a superpower it's a super fire it's not a regular fire it can consume 142,000 carbon it's not a problem we just saw according to is 10 x 10 according to is 5x5 another we're going to get into right How tall was the according to it's 3 + 1 you go to the top plus one what's the one the chronos it's so a total of four according to it's n + one is 10 and then we have another that we're also going to talk about this is also very interesting how tall were the curtains actually the walls of the mishk in the midbar how tall were they were they five or 15 the pik says five just the gar says it doesn't make sense What people that are walking outside could look over and see inside five they're not gonna see inside but if if the standing on top of a tall they could see him it's not proper to see him doing so says that's what we're talking about now how do you know that you measure something from the center says we have it in another place also it says referring to is 14 uh 12 from the center from the center. Maybe it's only 12 x 12. Who told you 24 by 24? It has four quarters. So by us also that's the five doesn't mean five. Five means 10 because you're measuring to the center. Yeah. Now is not a joke gave to me. You can't mess around [clears throat] with it. So what what does he do with we learned they go to the center? What does he do with it? So is going to learn the for the width of the he's learning it for the height of the outer is three is literally was three tall very shorts like this shortb it's wide and short and is tall and uh not that wide it's only five narrow So he has a different he learns from he doesn't learn he says it says by the and it says by it says right is you see by the pi the height is double the width. So if we have a five that we already say is five double that is 10 tall I have a big problem with what you're telling me if you tell me it's 10 tall approximately 20 ft tall the height of the curtains are five. So let's remember that the Tory says that the curtains are five. How are we going to get out of that? Where's that picture? If you say this, okay, I say it's three tall and I have a five tall wall. No, but according to you, it's something like this. It's a five armor wall and he's standing 10. He's way above everybody. So anybody walking around in the midbar could see inside and see what he's doing. It's not proper. Doesn't have it. doesn't have the respect that it needs. You're right. That wouldn't be good. He admits to that. That's not good. [clears throat] However, says Rashi, it only makes sense that the the curtain the the clim that go all the way around the the Mishk they are at least 10 the size the height of of the or the so wait a minute we have a problem here it says it's 15 not five the walls so why does the say five so if you take a What is this? Oh, this is so Oh, it's actually taller. It's 15 ammo, but it mentions five ammo. The Tory says five. You saw before I told you to remember the P like seven lines from the bottom. It says it's five. So, what do we do? So, it goes like this. Take a look. This is the carave. It's like a decorative lattice mesh that goes around the We're not even talking about that. We're talking about the one above it, the from the and above. Sorry, what am I saying? Let's see. Sorry. Hold on a second. No, no, forget this. It means that from the from the top of the misb the this one right over here. This this one. No, let's go. Where's the one that it goes up? Or maybe it was this. I think it was this one. Yeah. Oh. So again, how tall is this curtain? 15. How tall is his be? >> 10. >> 10. So 10 from above the 10 to the top of the curtain is five. That's why the Torah says five. >> You get a five above the highest spot in the in the So why does it say according to why does it say that the is only three? It's five. It's 10. Why? Why three? again rebut says is three says it says in the three it's three says is 10 so why is the call it three then we have to go to this picture right over here it's referring to three above the here the itself one armor in other words three from the bottom for where the mikbar starts midw itself is one this >> lattice. >> No, not the lattice. >> The ledge. >> The ledge. The I don't know what [clears throat] >> what is it called? >> The rim. Some sort of rim. Ledge. It's not a ledge that you can stand on. >> I get that. >> Protrusion >> plus two. Three. That's why the says why would why do we start from there? I'm not exactly sure. And then the just repeats everything that we said before goes by the width. He uses the [clears throat] rav to say that we start from the center and therefore it's 5 from the center to the edge. So it's really 10 by 10. And learns the rao rav to tell me that the height of the is 10. If according to how tall is three. Yeah, it's three. How tall is the the curtain around the mak around the mishkone? Five. So the difference is only two ammo. Two ammo is let's say four feet. A co is taller than two feet. 4T standing on top of his bay doing that vo so it doesn't really cover him what does it covers maybe his headure his head is I mean his body besides his head different world the comes up to here let's say so all this is is exposed is that everybody sees the head and he's moving around over You can't see what he's doing here. Something like this. You see him, but you don't see the animal. You don't see what he's doing. According to me took the entire the whole floor and was why it's not enough room under to be back all these [clears throat] why according to was you don't have to say he was the floor so that this on the floor when you put down the when build that the ofenu was small. What does it mean? According to even the new misb was small you tell me had built a large muzzbah because was too small but is also too small. Cannot do 142,000. The most he can do is 11,000. That's why you build a new one because it's small. Yours is also small. He's saying is no, the new one is small. And Rashi points out that the new one that made even though it's made out of stones, it's called also. So it could fit in the new one is too small to be of 142. That's why they had to be the floor says what's over here. This whole thing between not this whole thing but part of it very very simple. Here we go. What you see on the bottom right you see the misbeh of mobenu the outer misb it doesn't look like our our outer misb looks like right right next to it. So anyway was more of a cle as we're going to see but it was the outer misb that's why it looks like what we what we do today for the in the new mikdash the outer mbah look like that as So anyways the is do you learn the outerb from outbu from that's therefore I go to a larger area just like was 12 from the center but it's really 24 so ours is five from the center it's really 10 10 by 10 or says no I rather learn the I rather learn from I don't want to learn from so says I don't want to learn from the inner take a look at the left corner both of those are certainly the everybody knows the inner one is a cle the inner misb is is a small little thing you can lift it up anybody could lift it up and move it so too is the giant moenu it was movable look it even has those rods that people jump in there and pick it up and move anytime they had to break down the Let me show you this. I thought it was very cool. This video they had to break down the uh the Mish gun here. the pose on the side is very very interesting and we don't and he doesn't he doesn't want to learn the cle from the stationary. So if you recall all the way in the bottom, four lines from the bottom where the were five lines says I'll remind you there's says if you move the misbeh when it comes is you need the actual it's not going to help you is one dam is another says and if you look at four lines from the bottom it says my where do we find this so we've been searching for this all the way to today and here we are a death later that's the we're talking about after this whole sugio comes and says listen to sprinkle The blood has to be only on the I remind you we had the pes when there's millions of carbonas there's blood everywhere till their knees and we had this Venice thing the Venice situation but anyway so they they put these stages in the blood so that you could walk around not on the blood. The word says that according to Yehuda, they would fill up one one clean one of blood and bring it to the math and pour it. Why? Because just in case somebody that brought a carbon pace, one of the millions of people, the K might have dropped his whole cle into the onto the ground and wasn't able to do. So, we'll do one zika for everybody. We're assuming that there's some molecule of his blood everywhere and when I take one cle full of blood I'm going to take one drop of his and I'll do one final on the so what do you see from that you see that the misbeak in order to do this you have to do it on otherwise asking just do this why he needs just pour it on wherever you are according to there's everywhere entire So just pour it where you are. He would fill up one vessel of blood and pour it on his because if one of the bloods of the entire blood fell his able to eat it because if there's no he can't eat it. If it's true there would be the whole that entire has you need you can't just it can't fall out of the coin's hand you need like you need you need you need an action you need to pour the blood says okay you're right good good you need the so if it fell out of his hand it's not enough that's why we take one vessel full of blood says pour it right here on the spot. Yeah, you're right. You could technically speaking, you take the blood, pour it right here on the floor. It has glues on the floor, but you want to do the just to remind what uh when you have a mah is made out of flour and sometimes different things, oil, whatever. So the car first goes and takes a kamita kamita. He takes literally three finger worth of of flour with his pinky. He makes it smooth with his thumb and he takes that and he puts that on the rest left over. So theam get to eat in the in the in the b mdash but only if the is whole if the misb has a defect they have to [clears throat] make a repair can't eat. You eat the matzah by the you don't have to eat it by the can anywhere is referring to the type of that you have you have to have a that's full that's whole that's great for what about how do I know the same thing applies to say that if you can't eat the same look it says doesn't only apply to it also applies to so how do I know that requires require says I can learn now from this. So unfortunately we don't have the three scan here. All three things that the three scan said we have one this is one of the three things. So now we're not going to show the whole we're not going to show any of this. I'm just going to show the so you remember is you give 10% of your produce to yourself. In other words, you bring 10% of your produce to your shal and you eat in your just do you have to be tar or you can be t when you eat it? You have to be tar. You have to be tar your milk is if you eat it when you're bring it to your if you want you could change it into money could sell it redeem it into money. Bring the money up to your slime and buy stuff in your slime. What about today? as tomorrow if you have today could you bring it to your and eat it I'm learning from both of them you have to bring up to your need in order to bring a you need a to bring your firstborn animal you need a migdash so too when it comes to You need a mdash. So today we don't have mdash. You don't bring your toile. You know why you need a mdash? You have to take the the parts that belong to the put on. You have to do. So of course you need a mdash says oh so now we're introducing something new is the first fruit of the you bring to the mdash and obviously don't have any they don't have inards and they don't have blood you bring it as is says oh what's is you take the fruit take a Look, it says, right? What does it mean? You take it. That's what the You put it down. Where do you place it down? So, what kind of riot? What do you bring me a riot from? I have a you see in the same it says so there's a heckish in the same brings the same so I learn one thing from the other need but I have two things look I have burim and bkar those two learn my from if I can't learn my sashi from one because this one is different because I have uh I have imm so learn from bikurim oh is different because I have I have to put it down on the floor okay so make a combination you don't have to put down on the floor you don't have to you don't have in blood but the two of them together tell me you need a bd so two you need a mikd The bottom line is though that's that we could continue over here. Why not? There's a concept in shas very very simple concept the that the B mikdash has and the has does it last forever or perhaps once goes into g the leaves with them it's a big shad leaves love. Why can't you just bring the you have a firstborn animal bring you to the to the to the mdash? Question when you bring it to mdash, do you need to build him as or even without him? >> No, not for >> not for says you need a misb. So according to Tyus, he shouldn't be able to the carbon like people like want want to do. I guess there's other I don't know I'm familiar with Tus right here. Tyus says you need so why can you bring up but if you hold this today so then you should have asked a question on why you ask me a question on on today. You could say there's no condition today. The problem is we have a specific case where the blood and everything was done for the before the now we have the meat to deal with. And now we have a heck between the meat and the blood of [snorts] the meat of the blood. The meat of the and the blood of the we know that the blood definitely needs. So too the meat and then take a look very very simple looks something like this we have the blood of akar that teaches us with the heesh to the bkar's meat that what you need is and now once I have the meat I have a he to the mi that you need then if you have a misb it's great so what's the problem with this It's haggish to hesish. So what's the answer? >> Thatish to is only what's not in this in this in this picture. But does that work if that's the outcome? Sometimes you say, "Oh, if it's you could do, but that's the the guy all the way to the right. If he's he could teach in a but not not the the one that's learned." So says you can't do says the of the wheat is in other words is you bring the stuff up you're eating it yourself that's if you hold that the one that's learned the one all the way to the left is that works great but if if you need that should be all the way to the right not only in the left and over here on the right the d and the ber are how do you do a haggage from both blood take a look I'll zoom in either the blood is of the meat is of the so it's one animal it's one one carbon so it's considered one it's not even a he was going to we're running out of time I had a nice video that I'll just show you tomorrow have a wonderful day >> [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.