CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 56 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. It doesn't help to go like this. You have to say it. So I have a question here. Which carbon do you do for zikas? For zerrius. Anybody remember? >> Huh? Four zikas boy. Which [clears throat] carbonas do you do? Two zeras that are four. >> A lot of them. >> A lot. Which carbon or carbonas do you do? Only one. >> Pes. Good. >> Anybody else? >> Meer. Okay. Good. Now have another shilah. This is this is uh to to warm up for the for the trauma cuz we're going to have a fiveminut trauma. So trauma by trauma I mean the word >> it's five minutes but I have trauma I have one question if a person ising an animal and he has a thought that he's going to eat this animal after its permitted time that's pigle. So he'sing the animal. So let's say it's a schlamim schlamim. You're allowed to eat it the day of the that entire night following the day of the and the following day. So you have day, night, day. When is it to eat that animal? As you're the owner, you want to eat it. When does it become at night? Night night time. It's no night time. Is the end of the the night. If you're allowed to eat it in the night, you can't eat it past. I'm talking about day. You're allowed to eat it day, night, day. When the day is over, it's also to eat. Whenever the day is over, so let's say a person had a thought as this as he had a thought. He's going to eat it 2 hours after. Is that pigle? He thought that he's going to eat it after he's not allowed to eat it anymore after. Is that pigle? Yes or no? If I'm asking the question obviously it's not so we're going to see a that's not until the next day why you have to wait patiently but this is such a on the bottom of here do me a favor I mean he'll give me this thing this is the this is the whole azoro this whole green square. So it says in the Gmorrah that from here from this point all the way to the top just leave it out. >> Okay, good. From here to here is 187 ammo. It's a lot. It's over 300 ft long. >> From here to here >> 135 >> 135 from here to here 135 the width. From here to here 187. So thear is saying is that this entire area is a area called Azor you could even over here over here over here all these areas you could do here you could eat if you're allowed to eat over here over here all these areas the entire 187 and the same thing would apply for the negative. So if you are tame and you walk into the Azara, even if you walk into this area or this area, you are you get kus for walking, you touch the dead rat, you walk in there, you went to walked in all these the entire year 187 by 135. So there was a who said this over in front of the was 187 by 135 heard this and he says, "Oh, you know what my father said about this?" in the 135 187 it all has so therefore you could eat the and you're permitted to in the entire area all over now if you remember what's the issue over here over here big issue the issue is that it says in the that's you could see the so if you're standing here this would be the area that you could see from from your from wherever your eyes could see. But your eyes standing over here cannot see over here. They can't see over here. They can't they certainly can't see behind the So we already answered that. We said over here there's a door on the corner and if you stand in this corner right over here you can see this direction and see that direction. What about back here? We said there's a window in the here goes through through and you could see over here. Okay. So you could you could check there and if you walk around anywhere in that you are if you are [clears throat] what does it come to exclude perhaps you're on this thickness of the wall you're in a doorway right over here you're in a window maybe that and you're not or maybe if you're on this wall on the giant wall, very wide wall, and you're eating the the carbon. You're over you be over. Or maybe you want to chef right here on the wall. There's not enough room here. You come in the in the in the in the rush of you decide, you know what? I found a nice area right over here on the wall. Maybe I can't there. But it says the windows and the width, the width of the wall. There were different rooms here. Actually, this doesn't show. I like this picture better for this here. This one. If you look over here, you have all these different rooms here. Right over here. You have the lishkas. So, you have different different rooms. These rooms for instance if you take the lishkas this one right over here that was built you could see it clearly here was built half outside of the bid half inside there's actually like a dividing line in the that's where the sat and half of it is considered half so maybe you're telling me that inside the you cannot she can't eat your carbon And if you're okay, you're not going to get because it doesn't have if they are built outside in the mundane outside of the but they're open. And they have a door opening into the B into a but notes the inside is like if it's built in the mundane outside and it's open to the to the Kesh it has like so it says that these rooms have so you should be able to eat inside here you should be able to chef inside here says no they don't of real eat in there. You're not allowed to chef in there. If you stop right over here is permitted to go in there and eat. It's impossible for to say, "Oh, you're eat." They can't do that. If it's also if it's notes, they can't they can make a they can't make a they can't say in a place that is not you're allowed to eat there. They can never do that. So how does it say over here that if you have aka a room that's built in >> but it's open to the how do you know that? That shows me that these are they are considered or kaidesh I should say. You're allowed to eat the leftovers in the And how do we know this from a this is to remember meaning in a in aesh place there's a double here it says that's double we know is so to tell me it's [snorts] a that there's these rooms over here that are also included in the kesh. They're also kaidesh. So if I were to ask you how do you know that you're allowed to eat a carbon in one of these rooms. >> [snorts] >> So if I tell you that if you walk into this room when you're tummy you don't get it's not such a ste because you don't have to but you're allowed to eat there because I can't argue with a with a with a says you're telling me it says you're allowed to eat in there what is you have to make a distinction between eating and it's strange. It doesn't make sense, but it's a pos. So, there's nothing you can do about it. When you're and you walk in there, you don't get it's not considered for for your you walk in there, it's okay, but it's still all right to eat [snorts] in there. It's still enough to eat kachum in there. So, if it's enough, you should be if and you walk in there, you should be you should get a punishment for what? No, for that I don't have a for eating kachum. I have a special. You're telling me that if your tummy, you walk into one of these rooms, you're fine. So, we actually have a little bit of a Let me see if I take a look at this. See, this is a bird's eye view of two here. Three, actually. See these rooms right over here. So, he did this. Look at it for a second. Now, if you pay attention, there's a wall, a thick wall running right through everything. But the guy in purple is completely on the other side of the wall and the on the side of that that's 100% in the mdash. The other ones are built outside of the wall. So says, "The ones that are built in the mundane, the ones in blue, light blue, they're permitted to eat over there." That's from the you cannot in there. But it says you are if you are, you walk in there. So it's not exactly what you said. says, "Why can you chef?" Think about it. Something doesn't Something doesn't rhyme over here. You cannot in these rooms. Why can't you chef in this room right over here, the blue room? Why not? Because it's outside. It doesn't have That's why if you walk in there when you're not Why? Because there's no So there's no you eat there. How can you touch him there? because that says you're allowed to eat it. You know what I could say that the reason why if you in this room right over here is because you see there's walls, there's all sorts of things. You don't see there's no direct eyesight to the to the to the entrance to the to the I could get I understand that. But what's the if your tummy you walk in there says more I'll explain to you a timeout. Can it be that you shut it right over here? Right. Right into the doorway of this room and there is a direct line of sight. What's the word I'm looking for? >> Line of sight. Direct line of sight from this area. Okay, fine. You're hiding in this corner. I get it. But when you're at the doorway, I see I see it. And if I'm over here in thiska and there's a beautiful from here to here, how come I can't check right over here and is at the entrance? So you have to say because if it's talking about a situation where you're hiding in the corner for that I don't need any limo. That's I need to be able to see the doorway. Even though you could see the doorway of the it says you still not why there's no there. So also therefore I must say that when it comes to also there's no and you're not. So what comes out when when one of these rooms is built in the mundane? So are you allowed to eat in there? Yes. You're allowed to eat in there. Why? Because it's a just if you walk in there when you tame you're not you don't get and are you allowed to there? No. What about if it's built inside the B mikdash completely like this guy right over here the purple guy? So then if you walk in there with your to you're in big trouble because it's inside of has what about see you're allowed to eat in there for sure cuz now we have a pos you're not allowed to go in there when you tell me why because inside what about in there? >> No. Why not? because you can't see that's we had the pos can't see in the wait a minute you just told me until now we were talking about the last yesterday the day before there's a concept called you have to be able to see from the doorway anywhere that you and if you can't see you can't she what about eating do we have the same concept in order to eat you cannot hide over here the guy wants to eat a sandwich in peace right behind there. He doesn't want any client bother him or whatever. Is he allowed to eat here or he has to have the the direct line of sight from a door. So says Garo, but over there we said there's direct line of sight. But but what if he goes inside over here into the one of these rooms? Oh, so we had this already the other day. Let's do it again here. The 3D view of the That doorway right over there on the angle on the corner that's a pish these doorways these doors were eight tall the problem is that this if you stand right over here or right over here this is behind the door you can't see the doorway there all the all these walls is blocking. Therefore, they made a doorway on the corner. So, if you're if your head is right here on the corner, your head has the ability to see in this direction, in this direction, and you're good. Oh, so it says that what do you need this for? So, you could see everywhere. And if you could see everywhere, you could eat. It says, it doesn't say it does say, but in addition to that, it says we said already that's why we need the doors, but it also says, so you see, you need to be able to see in order to to eat, you need to be able to see everywhere. You're right. It's a great question. Therefore, we have to make a little bit of a gear change and take out the words. You don't need to be able to see everywhere from in order to eat. You don't have to be able to see when you're eating a sandwich. You don't have to see a door opening. It says, "You have to have the door by the door." You see a doorway says, "You're right. It says it by." But that's a one-time thing in the time by the inauguration of the of the mikdash of the Mishkan. But later on in generations when you ate you didn't have to see a doorway. This is a fascinating thing. The blood of the of the carbon once hits once hits you can't sprinkle it anymore. If you can't sprinkle it anymore then the carbon is possible. You have a carbon. We know that the the main part of the is to do the sprinkling of the blood once it's all over. Why is this fascinating? There's two words here. When I first read it, I'm American. So means, what does mean? What does it mean to everybody here? You're all Americans. >> To be macros, to sacrifice. No, that's not what it means. It means to sprinkle the blood >> over here. It means to sprinkle the blood >> to bring close. It means the blood means. So we have two things here. We have the blood and we have. So the says since you have these two words and we're going to go with these two words the whole time. Means so it has to be in the same It says on the day that you do the that's the day you have to do this. You can't wait till the next day. Rashi just says a very interesting thing here. We'll do Rashi says Rashi if you remember who doesn't remember the famous video. If a even the blood goes onto the misbeh I have a bucket of blood that stayed overnight. It's almost like lush. You put your the blood in the refrigerator so it's good to go. So maybe I could take that blood in the next morning. Okay. At night you're not allowed to do but the next morning I want to do maybe I should because it saved it so to speak. It's a safe zone. says, "No, you can't you can't use it for that." Oh, so we have a here that says that the blood becomes but this that tells you that the blood becomes possible, right? By I need it for something else. What'su? Forget where it says early. We're not starting there. Where do you sh the carbon? You sh the carbon and y during the daytime where it says y one day one I'm allowed to eat it day one. I'm allowed to eat it night two and then I'm allowed to eat it day two. That's it. Day, night, day. You got to get used to this. Yeah. One and two. Arly three. You see where it says arm three all the way at the end? I would take it off. I wish I could take it off. The arly one and y three. Yoshi wanted to show the whole picture. Day, night, day, night, day, night. But you'reing in daytime. So it's really the chart should start during the day. You get one night and one day. The reason why we have early that's because that's the next that and I mentioned it in the beginning of this year where you're thinking thoughts or you're actually eating the the food the night following day two. You allow to eat it day one the day you that whole night and the following day. That's it. Day night day. So, I need a puzzle for that. Oh, now now it makes sense to me. You're allowed to eat one a day, a night, a day. That's what you're allowed to. Okay. Why the two? Remember, there's two words there. One was means blood. If just to say that you could eat it for a day, night and a day, then just say the day that you it should eat it. Why didn't you need the word which was blood? It comes to tell us that the day that you there's two words there and uh they go on the same day you have ask a very simple question the maybe the Torah is trying to say in other words what is trying to do here maybe the eating is dependent on the so you could you could do two different times you could do the day that you and you can do the zika the following day perhaps perhaps if you do the zika the day that you so you get to eat it that day. If you do the following day, so you get to eat it that day. Who says that you must do the day you if you do the day, then you could eat it today and tomorrow, you get a special bonus. You get it today like this chart. But if you do the following day, then you could only eat it the following day. You get to eat the B. Yeah. Two and three. You're right. This day night day starts at a different time. We'll start tomorrow. If that's the case, the day that that oh I'm sorry the day that you sprinkle the blood meaning even the following day then the clock starts that should say why does it say again we're using the two words together because it says in the same p as great that's the end of the day that you that's the day when the clock starts and you have a day night and day sponsored by >> the has to be done the same >> the has to be done the same day as the oh we actually have a beautiful addition today for the pigle video was done in the middle of the night here so let's go back to that chart that did give me such a you're permitted to eat one night. One day, one night, one day. What if during the Here he is. That's the What if I don't know what happened there? Here. Oh. Oh, it works. As he's shing on day one, of course, he's shifting. He's thinking in his mind he's going to make a barbecue the night after when you're not allowed to eat it anymore. Is that considered pigle? Yes. There's no reason why not. It's after the time that you let eat it. But we have a puzzle. You know why? Check. Take a look. In the original one, there was It shows that you could only burn it. Oh, that's why it had it. O, that's I shouldn't have taken it out on y 3. That's when you could burn. That's when you burn the leftovers. So the burning occurs only after the night. Oh, we're back to that. So let's see. Yeah, here we go. Galdic. Ah, it's burnt in three since you can only burn it on day three. So piggle only occurs from that point on. From the point that you can burn it, not from the point that you can't eat it anymore, which is three. It's three. It has to do with the burning. It makes sense. This is what we were all saying. Once you can't eat it, it becomes that that that thought of eating it in a time that you can't eat it that night. That makes a big goal. Now, what about eating? So, that's called that's called we're not talking about here. A thought of eating in the wrong time. just literally eating this carbon right over here. O, you should have at least saved what you did. Okay, whatever. Make him crazy. Anyway, he had not a thought to eat it on. He ate it. He literally ate it when it was past its due date. It's it's a expired meat that's called you know what we never knew about this. You're only the following morning. Even though right now you're not allowed to eat it anymore. It's night time but it's night and you can't burn it. So if you can't burn it and you ate it, you don't get for eating. What do you mean you're not allowed to eat it? Once you're not allowed to eat it and you eat it, you get cars. I have a right if there's it's it's interesting in a carbon there's three different timelines for different things everything has a different time so when the as he's doing he thinks about item one is is one time if he thinks about doing this when is we said what is puzzle the rebbit What is it? So if you think about one minute after that's we know about theim here. So here we go. She just did it. The three different the is immediately after at night. The of is the right after the morning of eating a barbecue is the following night. Once it's daytime, you can't throw the im the different things that the parts that go onto the you can't do that anymore. So, if you think about putting them on the after that time, that's if you thought about eating a making a barbecue out of your after two days in a night, meaning the second night, that's sorry. Rashi just says very interesting rash I just want to show you here he says that all here in the bottom he says it doesn't matter if it's a blood of aim or blood and are always considered which we mentioned the other day as well think about it take a how do you eat the part of is when you allow to eat it the day of the and the night until So how come how come is not the same thing should be double day night day night why stop by the day why is it also during the night you should be able to eat at a night the following the third night or this I should say the second night where's that thing here right here He did it. You should be able to eat it on the red square. Makes sense. Like a which you can only eat one day, one night and like they could eat two days. The night follows the the you're allowed to eat it for a day and the following night. So those who could eat for two days, you should be able to eat the following night as well. This is a positive says no. You can't you can't serious. So maybe you should be able to burn it right here in the red box once the day is over. Burn it immediately. Why have to why do you have to wait till the next following morning? And it makes sense. We have we have think about it. When do you burn the carbon kas? When you can't eat the katus anymore, which is when when can you eat the katus anymore? Next. >> The next morning, you eat day night. At the end of the night, which is you have to stop eating it. When when can you burn it? The next minute. So also when you stop eating it, when do you stop eating it? The next minute you should be able to burn it. Right after you can't eat it, you burn it. That extra B. You can only burn it during the day. Have a wonderful day. [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysonsor.com or sponsor at mdyop.com.