CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 52 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. All right. So, let's let's jump into this thing here. Yeah. Here we go. Ready? What is the is the base of the I think by the red. You see the red? You should not do the over there. But by the green you could maybe that's what the P is who told you the P is coming to talk about perhaps it's just the Z has to be by the green area. Wherever there's a base cuz not the entire has a base there's a base then we do wherever there isn't no say doesn't say the base of the carbon what's comes to tell us that all the carbonas every single one has to do the uh the over there says wait a minute it's not true. You're telling me that the word is extra. No. So it goes like this. This beautiful over here. You can see it. This is the right. So I think that you could put the blood. We know that you have to put the blood on the green area. You have to pour. What if you put it on the red? Are you no that's what the comes to says there's one area on the you're not allowed to put it on the area closest to the floor I don't know if it's what the reason is maybe because it's no not so hush if it's next to the floor but it's supposed to be on the green area and Tyus points out green and above meaning of course you could put on a wall but not the bottom wall the top wall everything above the green He's telling you I have to be on the top on the roof of the on the horizontal part of the not the vertical ly. Why do I need a for the the roof the leftover blood of it doesn't really do much. It doesn't create a forgiveness yet you must put it on top on on the roof part of the certainly the beginning part of the the initial parts of the uh of the of the carbon which give of course you need the gaga and then comes and says the same exact thing. The only difference between andal are two words that seem redundant. They're almost the same. So basically the same the same is gonna ask what's the difference between them? Same same. Oh there's noap. But then he sticks in and they don't come to give it does come for same. That's what we had yesterday just means that the must go on the but what is the difference between they said the exact same thing plus or minus this word but also says it comes from he just adds so what's the difference okay we came to the conclusion that you have to put the on the buttons if you don't put the onb you have to redo it again very interesting though what does mean up until now what does mean to you what does mak mean think about it for a second it's and then what do you do if it's >> it doesn't work >> it doesn't work and then what >> do what end. >> Did the guy get a kapar? >> No kaparo. That's m rash says over here he gets a kaparo. It makes it makes sense. Think about let's think now. Let's break it down. He did the four zerikas on the misbay. You got a kapar. Didn't get a kapar. The second you do the last zero. Boom. It's over. You got a kapar. So now what? Now I have to take the blood and pour the rest the leftover on the mak and it's makave. Not that it undo your kaparo. You had a kaparo. You had a kaparo. So what's mak that you have to shut another animal and and do another but the kapara happened says oh says listen is not don't worry about it you don't have to check another carbon so the is something completely different when you shook the bird there's not enough blood in a bird to pour into a vessel and and and and capture it and then pour it from there. So what do you do first you have to do depends what kind of bird we said between and let me see if I can find it here. Oh this is he takes it and he like a ball you have to toss it toward you're not hitting them as bad with the actual bird something like that. Okay. That's then this mitsu. This is mitsu. You get a good squeeze on the actually. We have another one. Let's do the other one here. This cuz this is more for us. I don't think there's that much blood, but okay. You give it a a good squeeze. is that that thing. What if you what if there's not enough blood in the in the bird to give it a whether or not the last bloods of the bird are so we have like it says by the pariah the par of the god he doesn't Why does it say needs blood on the I have a So this is f to me it's fascinating. I don't care if you guys don't think so. I think it's fascinating. You don't touch him. If the Torah says something twice it makes it you have to do it says add it became twice once in the second time that's two 1 plus one equals two as says not that he's trying to say why do I need a in addition the I have two. If you don't have to go and do it, you still need a Here's another fascinating thing. You read it, it doesn't make sense. The you don't have to bring the diamond. Of course, you have to. So, why is why does say you don't have to? The answer is because he doesn't have to bring a carbon. He shouldn't do a his is not is not necessary. If he sins, yes, you're right. You must bring it inside. But he doesn't have to sin. He doesn't have to make mistakes. But you have to bring every single year you have to bring. That's a must. Who doesn't have to sin yet? that he has to put his blood on the the the you do it year after year and you must bring the blood inside and certainly you need the here one once again this is slightly different not the same as before what he says you don't have to bring the blood into the doesn't go into what goes into things So certainly the the when you [clears throat] have to bring the blood into the certainly you should need the if the you don't need the you need the even though you don't go into certainly when you go into you should need the now now we understand what 's question is I think why is there because they have two sources one is a one is in other words once I do all this I'm done I'm finished the comes afterwards what comes afterwards is not is not like We have before we learned from side we have the he doesn't bring his carbon into the No over here is what? [clears throat] Yeah. This is the doesn't go but it goes to certainly should require the once again. So it's twice. So it's so like like a mitzvah you should take this and pour it. So says it's like it's it becomes like a mitzvah but it's not okay. So we have you see like that. So now I'm just going to go back because said oh what's the the on something completely unrelated whether or not you have to you don't have what to squeeze out of the bird on the on the or not actually holds that if you don't have enough blood to give a what that if you don't have, you don't have. What are you going to do if you don't have? I I did I went like this. I did this. So there's nothing inside. Nothing inside. The the is not it's not the end of the world. Says no. You're right. It comes from whether or not you have to give it or not. It's it's here. It says it's not all my does hold that is if you don't do it you have to do it again for the here also I'm going to give you a little bit of a maybe you didn't this one when you're just reading what's the who does he gets to eat the the carbon so Let's say Rabbi Schoberg does she gets the carbon. What about Donnie Fine? Does he get the carbon? >> Yes. >> Why the doesn't mean literally the the does it the do it that are able to do this they get to eat it. Just the question is I just wanted to throw it out. So what does mean? Why does it say it says the one who does it? You can't mess up the the you know here's the line. If you put the blood above the red line where it really belongs below the red line. You do it above instead of below or below instead of above. You messed up. It's what what do you put above the red line remembers? What else? Where did you get this from? [clears throat] If you have to do four makes an interesting the is to put four mat on four he's supposed to be on four for let's say four and you only did one you only did one it's good so me the wants to make a little bit of a jump and if you're supposed to put on tap and you put on the bat no you're also good you're supposed to do four you did one it's Good. So if you're supposed to do on top, you did on bottom. What's the difference? You're supposed to put on four parts of the put on one. You're supposed to put on this part of the you put it over here. Similar. So I have says, "No, you're not have no blood that he's supposed to put on the bottom." So Rashi says, "What's the blood that he's put on the bottom? Why? Why? Because that's what it says in the talks about blood on the bottom by by the bird by the bird. You did it up above the red line. You don't get the same thing. If you're supposed to put on tap, it's supposed to put on tap. You can make a distinction between the upper bloods and the lower bloods. the lower bloods that you did above they don't belong on the top. They never go on the top. That's why but the upper bloods remember we had a similar and this drove me crazy on the plane because I thought I gave wrong in that sa why I'll remind you tell me what you say but the bloods that you go on the top they go to the bottom. So you remember we had that enough what was the what did I say then why do they go on the bottom >> it drips down >> and I look in Rash and Rash says no you put the on the bottom >> like whoa maybe I said wrong there but no until I found it over there that's the it dripped out over here we're talking about the whole the leftover you know even when you do inner bloods in You still have to pour the blood. Where do you pour? You don't pour it in the There's only one place to pour the blood and that's outside. And if you do if you put it to begin with to start out with outside there's no and the same thing should be with no you can't bring. You know why? because the inner blood that they they don't have um like a a kapara from [snorts] the back. So it's really like a ka the the is much more why if you miss one one um you miss one hah it's all over but they they have a ka there's a that's how I learned it there's a little bit of a koola here and if so therefore it makes sense If you put it below the the line, it's why I need you can't you can't switch it around. If it belongs up, you put it up. You put it down, you're not there's no compar what do you mean that the inner doesn't give it a So you see that is So according to what you're saying I have the inner but it comes outside you have to bring it outside afterwards nevertheless even though eventually it's going to come outside but if you started the you do it outside there's no so certainly when you put blood and there's no no reason to bring it below the red line. If you put blood where eventually it's going to go, which is outside, eventually you have to do outside and you start out the you do it outside, it's no good. So if you put blood where it eventually doesn't go, of course it's not good. So we have to switch it around. We're not talking about You're right. We would have a good ray here that is but we're not talking about what we're talking about is you have to switch and and say the is from here this is the of that's what he's trying to say remember we had inside inside means the just one short here hopefully we get there before and actually we had this whoever did remembers Is this it says two words he finished which I don't know how to translate exactly he'll get a kapar if he did the kaparus if kilo once he did the he finished he finished he's finished his job in other words what happens afterwards the is not so important he did his he did And if he didn't do that, he didn't finish. That's according to you. It should said why why shouldn't we say if he finished, he got a kapara. Not if he did, he finished. If he finished, he got a kapara. It fits better into the words. But basically, they're saying the same exact thing. It's just what word you say first again says if he did he finished and he's saying if he finished then he gets but isn't it that the same thing if he coming to say that you have to do all the matis but that's what said if you do all the matis you get a so what's the difference between them if there's a difference or not no No, no, no. They say the exact same thing. The question is, how do you want to read the puzzle? You want to read it or they're saying the same exact thing? No, there's definitely a real if you didn't do the on do you get a or not? It's we have between whether or not there's at all here we have a forum said that one of them somebody holds that oh according to that person that says in other words holds one of these holds that is maybe you bring one you have to from wherever let's say the blood spilled so you bring another par and you start from Because if you think about it, means leftover of something. So you got a and then you have leftover >> and you continue from that point on also agrees that somebody says that. So they're both saying the same thing yet they're arguing whether what do we do here? There is a says so what are we going to do? Yes, there's a T that says that surika in our that we just brought down between. We still don't know who says what it's say that there's a somewhere who holds that but we don't have a riot whether they're talking about and rais have a wonderful day. >> [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.