CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 48 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. You know what? It's I think it's morning. Good morning. So, that's the uh the northern part, remember? Okay, we're going to go through it. as I don't understand the whole that teaches us is um we can jump right into this one. It's really nice. The bottom north it doesn't say in the beginning of the mishna starts talking about the different bulls that go into the et says a very interesting thing. How do we know they derived it from so they love it. It's their their so to speak says very nice but there's other the was from the regular not the goes into the says a regular where do you put the blood in not inside the not inside the so that's why it's a combination of two things is more important than why because they came up with the but within the categories the one that goes into the that's the the one they like even more there's a second reason says sorry says where does it say north on the northern part of Benbuck. Interesting because theim the order of the it starts talks about Ben and then it talks about sheep and then it says the north has to do with sheep not with the bull. So how do you know this is the connects the two it adds from the first thing the first that we learned and we're going to learn the top one from the bottom one says that's according to the that you learn the top from the bottom but if you don't hold that what do you do this I'll prove it to you so we're going to go on a tangent a little bit we're still try to find out how how do you know that the is in the north and and other carbon is in the north but for a moment we're going to go off this similar to comes from an there's anal means a certain ash we know that he did a for instance if a person um used a property of the bdash deliberately. He used it knowing that he's using so he has to he has to bring asham. Now asham comes for something like like he's not sure if he ate or not. In the case of a suffic then you bring but what if a person as a suffic if he used this two he's not sure if if the one he used was the one or not if he brings a for says he should bring means Oh, where did I see it? Yoshi did a tali here. Right over here. Take take a look at this guy. He's hanging from a hanger. Love it. There's the question is do you learn the from the tackling says or the tackling from the bottom one from the upper one do you have to bring a carbon or not the bottom one says he doesn't know like a suffic will connect it to the they have to bring asham made them know there's no ri from here maybe we're talking about everybody holds that of course you learn top to bottom bottom to top by the time we have what's called this shva between here let's look at the for a second here. It says by us by by the and it says by when it comes to when do you bring a only on something that if you did it deliberately you get this but on a on using something you never get you don't get carus if you use it deliberately you But it's not called. But when we're talking about, it's something that is one thing. It's only so he says I'm going to learn that I'm going to take out something that has we know is a carbon that that that has a slide. If you're wealthy, you bring this one. If you're less wealthy, you bring that one. If [snorts] you're super poor, you bring the other one. I'm not going to learn from a half a thing. I can't learn half that what certain you bring and and that comes for something that has a a slide then I don't bring no once I'm learning I learn all what's but also admits to that concept that you can't say I have says So there's another. So yes, but the stops. So what do we do? We have on the one hand we have on the other hand we have to to to learn one positive from the other. the that's to learn sha two words that are similar. That's another way to learn. And now they they're fighting against each other. Who wins? Say that the wins. Both of them. By the way, if if you take a hish by itself or by itself, it's literally as if the said it. They're very very strong. But the question is when they there's a conflict between the two, which one wins? Everybody's going to admit that the has more power. And what's going on here? Ah, you have a between. You're right. We do have a I'm going to use it for something completely different. I'm going to tell you how much money you need to spend on your carbon in order to be [snorts] I would think it doesn't make any sense that when you when you do an you you you're not sure you did a you have to spend more money that if you're sure than you did a regular you don't have to spend a certain amount of money it could be even a danko there's no there's no minimum amount So the the is also nothing that you need to spend two. Oh they have to spend at least two for the carbon. This is the the thera of all that all need whether or not did we learn the word does it mean could I learn to the rest of the rest of this category all say for a certain thing and if you don't hold that you're learning so where does he learn That what you have to spend two you're learning from they have to spend two for the in there's different say some don't somebody has a who is designated to an and she's only a half It's a whole complicated thing. She's only a half she was released 50%. So she's and somebody had relations with her. So that somebody's says he learned another says okay next seven lines from the bottom we just spoke about needs the north. They need the northern part of but how do you know? You just spoke about how you know you should in the same place you where do you the north the word is extra. So we learn from there and how do you know that when you receive the blood also in the north it says you should take how do you know that the person receiving has to be standing there maybe could be standing outside such as here he's standing outside the green line receive how do you know that's possible The word is we take the VV and the lament and we flip the lammed and the VV and we do he shall take and at the end of the those are the last words B today I don't hold of this I don't hold you take a a lid and above and I flip it and I make two words out of Okay. So, the Torah says he should do it. It's the preferable way. Lack of an how do you know? If you don't do it, it's not a because we have another P. It says by he shall and then we're going to use this word extensively on let me see where it is right over here it says what am I going to do with this word it's a meal only but suffen This carbon the head of the brings he brings it in the you bring them in the same place as so why is why did the specify it should be in the north to tell you and double it up. Here's your it's not it's not a it's not a nice thing to do. You must do it this way. Maybe perhaps it's not coming to say that all must be done in saying the specifically the is very special. It must be done in the north and nobody else. No, we're going to learn from the original. It's called when I see it over here, I'm going to apply it to everything else to teach us that needs to be done. Okay, so we established that the Nazi because double and we have all the in one puzzle and we have the comes off his own. So it's but what about everything else? That's the he's special. But where do we have the double by all the to say that if you don't do it in the north it's possible says tell you why because it says by the sheep it says in the you should do it in the north but it also says again a double by the why does it say by a goat and by a sheep why double we have the concept and that teaches us all every single I'm going learn from the kisbah. I'm going to learn from the sheep. It says I don't need it. It's extra. I have it by the goat. I have by the goat. I don't need by the sheep. So, one of these is coming to tell us all need the north. If that's the case, then what? I need the you're right. I need for something else. There's something called came and he brought a mat to the and all the other as well. So anytime you bring a mat that's not for it's not for forgiveness. So maybe you would need by him also you don't need I'm going to ask you a riddle. What carbon do not require the northern part of the azara? We just learned something that comes for for what else is going to tell us. It's a great thing because imagine if it was only in the north. There's not enough room there for millions of people. So now at least they can spread around all over the [clears throat] who did not say that we're talking about he puts his hand on the head of the goat. It's telling us that even the has to do says no there's no is coming to say something completely different that goat needs according to the he says you need so I would think that you also need to do it in the northern part of that's why I have No, you don't need to do it in the in the northern part of mascul but accord says there's no there's no I would never think that you have to do the original thing was if you have to do you have to do but if you don't have to do so you don't have to do so according to that you don't have to do why would I think you have to do Am I ambi I don't understand at the end of the day the Torah never said to do said do why how would I make a jump from the Torah says do a specific action in the in the north doesn't say anything about the the says do in the north okay didn't say that the the the shouldn't do shouldn't doesn't have to do the I would say but there's a tells me everything all have to be in the same place and be done in the same way if that's the case then why does the have to say that a ni has to do just learn from everything else the answer is you know why you know why the has to say by because ni is a one time thing it's a one generation thing back in the day by But today, but but when the Torah says the the rest of the rest of it's not for it's for it's future generations. I can't learn from future generations. That's why the say oh if the had to say it by because it's not in future generations. So too when it comes to the north also not only the but also the northern part of the by the north I I cannot learn from everybody else. So what does the what does the come at the end of the day? Why do they need comes to say that the animal has to be in the north but not the actual person performing the you tell me you need for the show? There's another that tells me that here it's another I know that the person has to stand in the in the and he has to receive the blood in the impost and if he stood in the green behind the green line it would be possible. So think also same thing. Okay. But at the end of the day what do I need for? I learned from this I'm learning it. What are you telling me? I need to tell me that the doesn't have to be there. The could be outside of the green line. We even had the whole case with the long knife. That's something else. But the could be says I don't need for that. I'm learn I learned from so the question remains what do I do with here the can be standing behind the red behind the green line the animals in the green line but the is outside of the green line. You know what I do with to teach me that when I a bird a bird is different than an animal. I would think I would have that you have to only in the north. Why? because I have a when it comes to a bird the Torah never said I'm sorry when it comes to a sheep the Torah never said that we know a even a woman anybody could a sheep yet it's very important to do it in the northern part of the so when it comes to a bird where the Torah said only a could could do malik to a bird so of course it should be done in That's why I need says wait a minute why would I say such a thing you know when you need to do it with a knife it's telling us that a carbon pel does not need to be in the north I would think that a carbon has to from where there's no specific time. You can bring it anytime, but you have to do it in the north. You can only do on the 14th of certainly you should have to do it in the north. That's what I need. Finally, I need to tell me do not need a in the north. But wait a minute. You know what? Our law is different. It goes okay. I learned from what I'm going to learn from that doesn't have a special time and most of it is most of it goes up to Hashem. A little part is eaten by the and it needs it needs the north. So certainly I'll tell you why you can't learn from because is different. Let's remember this because we're going to just put it all in in a second has the ability to forgive on a very harsh a of so let's learn from Asham does not is not for is special is in the category of where is not here let's see the categories again is on the right side not on the left is on the left. Let's leave that there for a second. So what is this line? Very very gishmak. Take a look over here. We want to learn. [laughter] I didn't even realize how gishmach these little guys are. If you look at carbon, he's eating mazis by the sedar is being burned on top of a fire. Let's learn from what say you remember and and certainly no I can't learn from because it's completely goes to Hashem. So the said let's learn from so what what do you say it has it has for what the is doing here is meaning let's take all them together and let's learn pes out of them each one has a has a has a pro and a each one is not but could be for okay so now I'm going to introduce Oh, let's learn from Asham. But the problem with is oh that's a big problem because all of these guys are kach. Take a look and are all kachum and therefore I cannot learn out from them at the end of the day. What do I do with you know what I do with let's go back. We I said before the Gumar is talking not me. I said before that I can learn from Isa that it's coming to exclude that the person performing the doesn't have to stand in the in the north. He could be outside of the green. But you ask me, well, I already learned that from another from the No, you didn't understand wasn't learning that the the could stand in learning that you should not receive the blood in the north. remember and that's what the Gur says. No, he doesn't learn. He doesn't take the lament and flip it with the V and then and make a out of it. That's an interesting limo that he doesn't learn. Wish me luck. Have a wonderful day or whatever it is Shabas. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or [music] sponsor atmop.com.