CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 47 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. We have a phenomenal daff today. Starting with Omar on the bottom of Omar. This is this is an unbelievable mindbogling. It's counterintuitive almost. I wouldn't come up with this. I wouldn't understand this on my own. Their says that if a person knows that what he's about to do he'sing he knows that this is a but he wants the for stakes for his personal uses he doesn't want he wants that is kosher but if a person didn't know it was a he grabs it in he thought it's a and it's not it's a says the that's possible you know what's going on here if he's he's doing an a he knows that it's a kos But he's making that's that's cautains caution because he knew it's a carbon. So when he shed it he knew it's a carbon. But if he didn't even know it's a carb zero and he takes it and he shs it as a but he didn't know it as a carbon. It's a massic you just for that you get zero credit for the carbon and therefore it's possible. But if you had no idea that was a you only did it for possible that's a we'll explain. How do you know that when a person does exactly this case? He doesn't know it's a carbon. He grabs this carbon and he thinks it's a and he sh it's pos or he was he was target practicing with his knife against the wall and a and a bird flew by and he shuffed the bird. Well, you don't sh the bird. Well, he did malik. Okay. So, an animal ran by and the knife struck him in the neck. or like in this case he didn't have intent to do a how do you know it's possible? So he says you have to have that it's for so says I was asking you how do you know that if you don't do it that you ruin the carbon means that you should do it with your d with your mind. You should have intent and without intent slipping on a banana peel and shing or a mundane animal that you thought is mundane but it happens to be it's it's not a it says in the thought who could who could manipulate the just the person that performs that the performs that and therefore since there's six different they have to think You have to think about what carbon, who is it for, what's the if it's etc. So forget it. Don't think about anything said don't think about anything. Says what the only person that can have a that can manipulate the thought is the what about the owner? No, he can't. So therefore, there is a that says the owner could also have there's another unbelievable. What a d today. He heard says, "I heard that the owner has the right to the owner as the ising the ising an animal. The owner was standing to the side over there. He has a thought and that thought can ruin this carbon. It makes the carbon bagel. His thought that he's going to eat this at his kid's bris in a week from now ruins the carbon. I he didn't do he didn't take action. The kind is and the brings the macro. It seems like the guy bringing the mak the owner he's doing the says there are three shittas three different sugas that are the same idea our suga that we just said this that holds that the owner can manipulate the of this animal even though he's not doing action and two more one by a an animal for a idol worshipper the of the go is going to go into the animal as for even though the Jew is not think the owner is and the third one that the owner Ru he could say that this piece of garbage this is something important and Shim somebody else is going to carry this outside in the and he's going to be because Ruben decided this is an object. These are the three different that they they have the same idea, the same concept. This person stands [snorts] on the side and has a thought and this this he does the action and it's considered a good we just spoke about that when it comes to in the md when the owner the is a thought of pigle he's going to eat it after two months it ruins the carba And what's not for a nonjew says it's a good says is possible. Why? Because says that of the owner that this animal should be for works. It enters the animal as the the whoever is and finally what does he say that's not something that's not you're not supposed to hide it. You're not supposed to keep it for safeguid something that's like disgusting and and nobody wants it. Nobody else in the world keeps something like that. If this roofing guy decides he wants to keep this empty can of soda, he decides he's keeping this this this piece of toilet paper. And then a second person came and took it outside in either from or walked it for. So this guy [snorts] This second guy was until because the first guy had these are the three things that are similar. As you see, we have the three shittas. Shittita number one on the right is our shittita, our gar that if the king and the stroll with the blue shirt because he's wearing a blue shirt standing above him and he has of that he's going to eat at a different place, a different time outside of a lot of time. You have a go with the tattoos standing over him and the it's a of and finally are all the way to the left is the that if you take it like a soda can and you decide this is of a thing. So somebody else that carries it on says the two on the left here. Look at these arrows. Beautiful. Everybody holds a verb. In other words, whether you hold that of a or soda cans is you're definitely going to hold it in the mdash. Why? If it's outside the mdash, my as owner can manipulate this item, this thing is certainly inside the mikdash as well. with her value. Now you see how the two arrows go to the right cuz everybody holds a when it comes to the owner can manipulate the the the pigle in this animal. However does not hold them. So two red arrows coming out of going to he doesn't hold that just because the guy thought about of a desire makes it of a desire. Just because the guy thought the soda can a why Maybe he only holds that in the not not outside the great now we said this the first step is that holds of hold of now the question is does hold of the center one and does the center one hold of that's the only thing that we have to do and then we got it all straight says yes holder in other words holds all three cases they can manipulate with your mind that what the holds if you if you're not watching this and you're just listening to this on Spotify or so you'll know what I'm talking about says that you can make a soda can into a can for the second person holds that you could that the guy can make the carbon or not the carbon can make it if you hold this So Rashi says here this says you should be put and the Rashi goes on to say that is similar to but similar to and therefore he says that's what he says all the way in the bottom that When it comes to a thought, you can learn from but shabas has no source. So if you hold a shabas, my thought can manipulate somebody else's action. So certainly when it comes to my thought can manipulate the action because I learned from the md but finally the center one even though it goes from doesn't hold maybe when it comes we similar. What do it says? You can't do work on shabas. You can't do a on Shabas, but that's a that you know that you're doing a but this guy when he's carrying the soda can he says this is this is not this is not a this is not a thing this is this there's nothing this this is toilet paper I'm not carrying anything he's supposed to suffer because Ruven decided that's not toilet paper that's something it goes by your mind it goes by your your work that had to do with law. It doesn't work in chabas. It only works in pigle according to where do you do the in the mikdash what is so when you're saying this what do you think to yourself what's kadashim what is that now we know we're learning Now, so we have a little bit of an understanding. Here's the famous list is a what else do we have here? The the lighter guys, you have the heavyweights, the the and you have. So I want to point out here because the Gumar is going to ask later. I just want to point out there's a header in the takes place in the northern part of the English doesn't mention here the saddam although later on in the mission it does mentionab but it's not in the header and the gumar wants to know why isn't it in the header so what is we discuss it numerous times but if you're brand new to the I love this from I want to get my money's Earth. This is the Bdosh. This is the this right over here. This light little guy right over this little part is the This is the This is where the is this the what we're talking about. I'm going to show you a much better depiction that Yoshi just to familiarize familiarize yourself with this this line right over here. There's a line that goes with the msb from side to side from this line down that's north this north of the msb south of this line north of this line. Now does it include the entire width of the that's a three-way as we said but certainly this area of the misb and it's actually depicted in another color you could see it's a darker color that entire area now let's see what yoshi did so you see the misb now and everything from the upwards is north so you says in the green area everything north of the msbak rebi adds that area but of course rebi also agrees to this area as well because it's closer to the says only the green and the purple but not the blue to understand. So when we're saying what's north of the we have a is the entire width is that okay we're doing great now I don't know if you don't like this kind of stuff don't get grossed out but I didn't I didn't show it in a long time I'll show it here why not have the and the cababala the cababala is also in the When we're talking about the bull of Yipper and the saw of Yim, the two goats, one goes, throw them off the cliff. The other one we and we have the power of Yipper. The bull of Yamiper. Remember we discussed it this the 43 dams and we're going to discuss it right now. It's a combination of the blood of the power and the blood of the So the by the way of all animals is in the of all animals I believe is in when it comes to you must sprinkle eight times the stands between the poles of the in our picture is ini so there's no poles there's no arin unfortunately that's the ev and you can see there's eight drops of blood on the right of the mda of the and eight on the left. There's the eight blood on the divided between the the bull there's eight drafts of blood from the bull and eight drops of blood from the goat total of 16. Then he goes to the this is remember palm up palm down but eight over here eight and eight so it's another 16 eight for the bull eight for the goat in the not in the so that's the total 32 then seven on top of the you can see the seven right over here seven and then in addition to Add another four. So that's another 11. Total of 43. 32 + 11 43. If you miss one, you're done. It's unbelievable. Look how beautiful this is. So now when you're saying this, you understand what's going on here. You have all these matis. You had 16 in the 16 in the on the floor. Another seven in the on top of the another four on the chronics. You valve it. What do you do with the leftover blood? You pour it into the What does that look like here? Grab these images, put them in your brain. He pours the extra blood, whatever's left over right next to those drinks. They're in the western corner. Why western corner? Here, let's take a fly over of the Mikdash and we'll see those corners. It'll be quick, but this is north. This is the north side. This is the west side. And here are the two holes right over there. Okay. But if you didn't pour the extra blood in it's not it's not a done deal. It doesn't ruin the car. There are those bulls that you completely burn. You don't put on the it's the which we discussed extensively. And the and the goats that are burned completely. Where do they burn them? We'll see in a second. These are the goats of where do you them all animals and you receive the blood in the north. How many blood sprinkles do we do? We discussed this many times only 11 seven over here like this in the Seven right over there in front of and four over here. 7 + 4 equals 11. returning with B. If you miss one of the 11, no good. Same thing that we said before. Leftover blood goes into the holes on the on the base of the even if you forgot to do it. Oh, so now let me just show you will do the sponsors. I want the to not get mixed up here. There's two things. There's something called Badash and something called two very very different things. Trumash is where the K I'll show you a video if you want. Takes the coals every single morning takes a little bit of it and puts it next to them. The Badan is outside of your it's a a mound where where where they take the all the when it piles up too high you take the co you put it out there you also burn the pum over there that's where you burn the parm. So let's see what it looks like this burn the p and here's the the extra coals right over there. What's true? Not to be. This is not what we're doing. Not this. I think there's a AI. Um, miss out. Okay. Sorry. Okay. So, this this is true mass. This is that you do over there is how come in the header of the word is not mentioned is mentioned later on in the where the is supposed to be in the in the but how come the the when it says should say doesn't say it says unbelievable because there's the the one of the three carbon that has a skin affliction for talking whatever it is he has to bring three carbon one of them is the and that the receives the blood with his hand that's why it's not mentioned in Mishna you can't say oh the the dam is in universally in the there's one that's not done with the k so I let it I left it out. What are you talking about? It is accepted in a it says in the knowable it says that the later on it says is done with the in the north says in the beginning the town of thought that the should be with the hand sh that's why he left it out of here but then he realized later on that it has to be with so explains what's going on here. What do you He thought in the beginning it should be with his hand and then later on the it says in the I think you should do with with you do you you put the blood with your finger learns that just like the takes blood from his palm and puts it on the the's ear and and thumb etc and he sprinkles it in the with his hand. So the the receiving of that dam should also be with the hand. So maybe I think I hope I didn't skip here. Let me just go back. I'll think that when you bring the blood to you should do with your hand there's a heckage between just like you do with so what I do on the one hand the says you should receive the blood with your hand on the other hand it says that you should receive with a cle so what I do compromise two one client receives the blood with a cle and the other with his hand. They both jump in there and they try to get as much blood as they can. One with the one with the hand. And what do what do they do with it? The one who received it with his hand should go to the one that received with the should I just want to show you one final video and with that we're going to we're going to finish this here. Fore! Foreign! Foreign! >> [snorts] >> in Hebrew. There'll always be somebody guilty and he's ashame and he's asham. So, it's a play on words. Have a wonderful day. [music] Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.