CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 44 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. >> Wow. Wow. Okay. So, there's a rashi here. We start off with a rash holding like 10 lines from the top of the top. So, Rashi says it's a little bit missing over here. This is referring to. So the B starts and says I think that you would be only for why the whole concept of pigle is said in the p about and from there we have to go to the rest of the rest of the now I would think that you'd only bring something that's similar to so remember these words put it in your brain for a second what what's exactly is going to say okay so I would think that only applies to and one other something that's similar to only something that's so similar that's eaten for two days and a night so that would exclude and and even a taid which is kum we said it's a a culture calendar you only eat for one day. You remember the sim because you have to eat the breads quickly so that everybody comes you invite everybody. Okay. So here's the says means what? This is the idea of pigle. What are you eating on the third day? You're only allowed to eat it for two days and one night it says so the whole idea of pigle is in this passing over here it says pigle all the way in the bottom well two lines from the bottom but because it says from the meat meaning it has it has leftovers anything that has okay now so that that includes a lot of kurbanas but it doesn't include I see from this also that you could do this in green it says of what's extra word you come to include how do you know you could do pigle even on the birds and if you bring flour and oil whatever you're bringing over there you could do pigle what's pigle you're thinking that you're going to be eating it you're going to after the lot of time in 2 three days from now another question so it's an interesting but how do I know I can do pigle on the oil so very important going do a little bit of a it says anything that you make to me anything so that includes oil Whatever mean that's by uh okay so let me just show it to you because it's it's an interesting lot that so we have three things here we have we have no left overnight and we have pigle soar says like this we saw the and but it says also the word it says so now we can make a connection between and which also it also says in purple by and it says by the word all the way in the bottom. So together we have this from it says by it says benro it's missing over here to really say byro should pop out that it's a sorry no no we're not even holding there yet this idea of pigle no pigle pigle by but it says we learn from to from pigle so basically I'm learning pigle from where from where am I? Oh, okay. Now here. So it says [clears throat] it says no. So we're not we're not learning jump to another. I'm confusing two dam over here. We have the same exact. So right now from tum we learned the idea that allas are included. And here you learn the word and the word. Let me just put it on the screen for a second. And I'm just saying it's a little interesting how the says it but it's it's very clear. Pigle you learn from you learn from. You want me to order those? Huh? new ones I forgot already. Okay, so fine. That's how we know is called why is the putle in the parl when at the end of the day we just said every single car is included including including including the oil of the says humans eat from it the eat from it everybody gets to enjoy it and there's a matter for each one >> or you could just pay what you like goes on and that allows you to put the meat on the that allows the humans to eat it. So now we're just going to go easy stuff. We already had this in the Mishna the you have a m even has a m what's the matter of the blood that you sprinkle on allows you to put the animal on top of the all of it and the height of this animal goes to the you have a bird which also completely goes it's you give it a little is what allows you put it Without that you cannot put on which eat it completely it's something it's blood all these guys where were they totally different bunch of them the parel the paracip or the They're all in. They all go into the all the blood is applied in the don't matter. You could be of the immac where where where do you burn theim? >> You can't be you can't do it there in the there's nowhere to do it. That little is only victorious. No, we put it on the Oh, so but what's not included is we said these are all this is like the kamita. Why not? Because there's nothing past it. That is the matter. It's like the blood of an animal. There's nothing that that comes to to allow that. That's also the last step. The matter together with the and the entire goes up to Hashem. So there's no matter we have to remember this because this is important. I'm going to take out there's no pigle. There's no on it by itself because that there's no matter to it. What this is important there is no because we're going to talk about it soon and on blood says wait a minute where do you the whole about go and where do you perform the outside of the in the of It has to be something that's on the outer part. So he says I am excluding everything. This entire chart is not in the pigle thing. All these guys the this is all inside inside the Now then we're going to see something that explains even the inside you can only do pigle in certain situations. Here's very interesting. We're going to see a shita soon. This guy inside this Let's Let's grab the but are on the outside. And where's the >> on the outside? >> Outside of the So what if you in the So what if you do during the thinking about you're going to put the on in two weeks from now. That's not because it's not inside. It has to be inside the things that you do inside like the sprinkling of the blood. >> Interesting. says I pointed out before about 15 20 lines up it says something that's similar to has pigle without any we used this whole before just to remind we learned from the word from it includes but there's one thing that's like I don't need any what is that one thing myar is very similar to I don't need a what do you mean you don't need a posing but how did you want to learn it it's the simplest type of le it's not a li it's like I I see this over here let's apply it to here also but that you could just knock off in a millisecond how any schlugs it up it's not strong like a heckish like like a I give a What? You have to lean on it with your body weight. You have to rewind. So we have a new just for today. The puts his hand underneath the hand of the and they go in all directions. This is where we learned Lula from. This is the thigh and the breast. So they say, "Oh, you do this by by don't do it." says about your right. This is actually a it's not like you think just a logic because that you can throw off as we saw before the here look the first it's a double what's it includes something else called that is peel so now the is going to do something it's only one line and anyway here in uh MDY we don't get traumatized by clu but take a look at this let's go through the the idea of clu for a second when the t is very generalized and doesn't give you anything specific it says anything you eat anything you eat so it could be a to it could be a kas you even need a k it could be anything so that's a cl and when you have a prat right after a cl it closes it down it shuts it down completely so it was very generalized and then poof no schlamim only. So now you're stuck with slum. But if you put another cl after the prat, you have a cl. So it's very very generalized, very specific, very generalized. So it it opens it up again. It's not completely open and it's not completely closed. It's somewhere in between. It's like it's a lot of stuff that are similar to schlam. The problem is what do you see over here? What's the problem? >> Over here it's clu. Now what do you do? Is it is it a is it a are we shutting down the clal and we don't care that two clouds are together or no it's as if you have a cloud it's just the proud is in the wrong place it should have been in between the two clouds and no you're not it says these two come right at one after another take a look at the chart for a second it's as if it happened like It's as if Yes, you're right. It does say put the PR in between. Who is the man says that you could do on the extra oil of the gole here it goes like that you could do pig on the oil the problem is I told you to remember that also there's no pigle on the blood and that could only be. And then you have the the the the classic problem. How could the race be and the mayor holds that halfle why? Because there's a matter. So it can't be had this yesterday that that there's no connection between and they they could come at different days. So obviously one has nothing to do with the other when they come together I'm talking about it can't be so must be so then we have a problem the remor is rebi and he also agrees to when it comes to oil so it's a new called so this is a tremendous that check this out something new for today look at Part of the process of the mitsra is that the kite goes takes a bunch of oil in his palm. The kite one kay pours the k into another kite's palm. He takes that oil and he does this inside a facing the over there. That's is in the right corner. He he he does seven drips of of blood of of oil and that is the matter. What the says it makes zero sense that never happened. Nobody will say that upon him right now is that the oil is what the oil itself not the blood of the asham is m this oil the oil itself is m himself mur himself like the blood is m of the blood which we never have over here the oil by me sprinkling seven times on the floor now the ken is allowed to drink this oil whatever is left over she says And it's so it it creates the the the right to do your until there's the the blood of the is sprinkled. But once the blood was sprinkled, there's no and but you're not allowed to benefit from it. Rebi says there is until you give this the seven um the seven drops of oil. But everybody agrees it's also to eat from it or until you do the seven the seven things on the right finger and the and the toe etc. Let me say this in front of you. You're going to tell me that according to Rebi, you could be meagle with the just the z of the oil and not the not it's not nothing to do with the with the blood. What's a lawyer that comes by itself? When do we bring oil by itself? Let's say the forgot his oil or he's very poor. He's one of these poor. So, he comes back next year with a with a thing of oil. It's fine. You're allowed to come [clears throat] back later. You don't have to do it the same day as the carbon. Think about it. He's bringing three carbonas. What's the third one? Three and uh plus oil. [snorts] Now you're right. So he has to go all the way back to make the whole trek back and bring his oil. So in that case, what allows the oil to to go? It's the it's the the applying of the oil. Everybody agrees that there's no pigle at that point saying in this case the oil is the head for the oil. The m of the oil is the blood of the blood. He brings the different time. The bottom line is it can't be rebi rebby never said that the oil is the oil is m itself you make pigle on the oil itself. So if it's not so you don't have a you have the is what do we do here it is this thing is different you got to you got to erase it I don't know I I just now forget I'm not even going to say it I I thought that maybe is the one that always like says don't do that don't don't don't erase maybe I'm wrong maybe it's everybody It's you know what it is and you don't have to take out and it fits right into her mayor. This is one number one is you have the comes with the the carbon and then that come with the carbon and that the the is that there's no so it's two separate and it fits right into a mayor that when it comes by itself he also admits that when the lukem comes by itself come by itself then the is not says the so we have something called there's 24 muna we're not going to talk about any of them you can look at the list and enjoy I don't even know what this list is there's 10 I don't know what this is anyway I I just grabbed it from babakama we had it over there kufud a manly how do you know about all these matis kohuna the ton ley one of the Musl is here. So here's the check this out. It's all in this. So Rashi brings that what's in this because said you're not the said you know what you are the and this is what you get. In other words, it's the idea of um What's what's the lion? The famous medish where a guy was plowing the field with his with his uh bull, his axe, and the axe fell into the pit and broke its legs and he couldn't get it out. So, he jumped into the pit to pull him out and he found a treasure. Sometimes the the the bad is the good. Not sometimes, it's always we sometimes we don't see it. Sometimes you see it on the spot when you find the the treasure right there. The here these are your math 24. So sorry. So what's what's this call? If you look I just underlined the word in the four times. All what's all the extra? All including the including the oil, the extra oil from the goes to the it has to be from the fire. that has nothing to do with the and the fire. They also get that the which allows you to eat the new crap on the second day of P. You bring the Who does it go to? This is super interesting. When the she has to bring, we saw the whole video 25 times. He put the on the corner of the who gets. Why did they get because there's a when it comes to the it's to allow you to it's nobody needed. Nobody did enough. to allow you to eat the new crab and is to to decide whether or not to to say m in English to clarify to clarify whether or not she's mis it's not a kapar at all because she's going to die that's theap it's just to see whether or not I think the doesn't get to eat it doesn't want to do with the word the rabb this comes to be the this bird gets gets to be eaten by the thing. They they they break the neck before they even do because >> it's breaking the neck. It's fine. The gets to get it. So says in the is just allowing the to continue on with his life and also to be to be cautious but not it's not they get to eat from it. What do you mean what I need? It says unfortunately that they can't get it says also the is sometimes when the becomes he has to restart his whole thing. So it's like the the it's not coming to be just like the is not coming. So too the is not coming to and the co gets very interesting. If somebody steals from a g convert and the convert dies, who's he going to return it to? A Jew, there's always a relative somewhere, but not for the convert. The tells you you give it to the and that's his thing. This is for you. Not other stuff, not other but this particular one is good for you to be a woman. So this is beautiful. This is what we spoke about. This is so simple when we're talking about the go inside the these guys right over here these four. So he says like this if it it depends because there's certain things in all four where do you can't inside so there's things that go inside things that go outside even in the inside guys. So then it's good pigle but things that are in the there's no pigle there's no pigle on these on these guys but if he's standing in that and he says I'm going to this right now in order to do the which is inside because if you're outside and your your thought is about inside not but he's standing inside he says I'm doing this with the with to do the what do you do outside but if he's standing outside and he's doing what you do outside which you do outside. So everything's outside and outside that is micro I wanted to say because never saw a rainbow there's no rainbow in his life but it's already after micro it says by by the the show it's What do you learn from has nothing to do with the inside? Everything is outside. That's where the pigle occurs. Super interesting that what that the pigle for the these part has to be for things outside done outside why do you have to tell me such a thing is not here we don't have we don't have so why do you have to tell me that is like him that's how you do super interesting it goes against everything we know listening what does that mean you should toss the whole why we I mean we We we spoke the first Mishna I mentioned the famous that he says and he made for he says is coming and nobody doesn't know anything about about and it also says if you're with we don't have a bish today we don't have so what are we doing but if you learn about the the we learn for learning whether it applies to us or not even though we don't have today you learn it and you get and he says you're right. So I said I I actually asked that question. Why do you have to tell me this? I'm telling you, have a wonderful day. I'll see you in New York. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.