CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 37 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning. Raoai was starting a brand new perk per bi question little bit of a riddle talking about pigle. We're not going to talk a lot about it only for a few moments. Again, if somebody has a thought that he's going to eat this carbon, as he's shingling the carbon, he's going to eat this carbon in a week from now at his kid's bris. Let's say that's pigle. As he's doing one of the zikasadam, the first one on the first corner, he thinks himself he's going to eat this carbon in a week from now. At the same moment, he thinks that he's also going to eat it outside of the amdash at the bris. That's twoas. You cannot have two thoughts in piggle. So it's there's no curse in that piggle. He thought outside the latter time, outside the latter place. It kind of negates one another. It negates the severity of the pickle. So I have a question for you. What if when he's spraying the blood on one corner, he thought to himself, I'm going to eat this at my kid's bris. So that's that's a good pickle. Then he does another corner because he has to do at least two corners, four corners, whatever the carbon is. He does another over there. He thinks to himself I am going to do is that as if he did two and therefore there's no severe severe pickle or the pigle got in and what he did later he thought about the the mim outside of the muk that doesn't negate it. How do you how do you think how does it work? It's within this. Oh, it's number one. Corner number two. >> Because the first is enough to not be. >> Oh, get spilled after. >> So, it depends on how many zikas you have to do. >> At the end of the day, we're going to see according to all you have to do is one. So, if you only have to do one and the rest is just for the mitzvah. So then the fact that you had another thought on Zika number two that shouldn't do anything to Zika number one because Zika number one that's it it's over by Zika number one that so he got the pig was the beautiful a of pigle then he tried to put another in it number two it's it's already too late so let's see the oh are you able to get me that over I'd love it. I forgot to get it before she just slightly careful with it. We have the outer misbeh which we're about to to bring up over here. This outer misb is inside the and that's where most of the carbonas go. So any that is applied to that outside keeper. Thank you so much. Here one on one corner. That's it. He got the kapara. However, when it comes to say, you need at least two. You need two. You need two. One, two, or one and two. Needs four. He's saying when it comes to to the you need two to be simple all one is enough so comes out if he didn't have any bad intent during the first he wasn't thinking that I'm going to eat it by my son's bris I'm going to do his re I'm going to eat it outside of its place but then at the second the second he thought the bad thought of I'm going to eat it at my son's bris keeper it's too late the sec the the second zika is already after your yita you're on one zika so the fact that you did another zika and during that zika you had a bad intent of eating it in a week from now it doesn't ruin it because it's already over I'm doing it because the says you should do four zikas but I was y the kapar And if I stopped right there, I would be one. So the fact that I continued, I'm just doing it better and that's it. [Music] What if he had the the a bad intent during the first one and the second one he threw in another thought of outside the allowed place not not inside the mdash or inside I'm going to eat it in I did the wrong thought at the first the fact that I had a second thought at a second it's too late. The second is not is not it's not essential. It's not and if it's not essential not then another thought there doesn't do anything says the Mishna. So let's see the one more time. This technology is only going to get better. This is the beginning stages of it. We're going into the here and this is the this is the otherwise known as every day the does the on this twice a day this is inside the remember when you pour the blood on this >> what else is if the make a mistake in or they tell people to dodara inside those are all essential. How do we call it? What's the famous thing? >> Right. Doesn't matter. It's fine. It's fine. It doesn't say. Doesn't say here. It does say the ones that are given on the not but it doesn't matter. It's the idea over there. is over there. You need every single one of the or the the applying of the blood is super essential. Therefore, if he put all the blood where he's supposed to, let's say he's supposed to put four on the on these corner, let's just say, and he missed and and the final one he had the wrong the wrong thought. You cannot have the thought of on one out of the four. You would have to do the on all four. Why? Sounds super complicated, but it's not. Half you cannot do pigle on a half of the in order to be m in order for this carbon to work to get to get the job done to get the kapara m it's the same idea to to have theap the carbon work you have to put it on four corners. Let's say let's just fire even sake. You have to put on four. You did three. It's not enough. In order for you to dole, you have to have the thought dur during all four. It's not enough to have the thought dur during a m on one corner. If you if you only thought about this during one of the applications of the damus, it's not a real piggle. Yes, it makes a puzzle, but there's no carus involved. So now we have an easy suggest the entire over here and more. How do you know that one application of blood on the this not not this guy? This one right over here. That's enough. How do I know the blood of your carbon should be spilled? It doesn't say four one time. This is a typical carbonas. You're supposed to put four applications. There's one, two, three, and four. And one of them would be and Rashi always says I took this from Rashi. Okay, here's the says three words. You should spill the blood of the carbon. We just said, what do we learn from it? That one one out of the four, one out of the two, depending on the carbon, one is enough. The Gumar is going to ask, "Wait a minute. I already used up these three words for this." What What do you do with the leftover blood? You have a whole vessel of blood. And you went like this. But then on the bottom, you always have those the last, you know, 10% on the bottom. What do you do? We learn from this. You spill it onto the base of the I'll show you a video of it. We have showed most of it, but we changed it a little bit. So what do I do with the how do I learn? So this is going to be the question. We're going back to the question. How do I learn the top thing in red when I'm already using it for that the goes in the so he holds something else. He learned from somewhere else. But there's another limo we learn from that pouring it directly onto the even though you're supposed to throw it from a distance with force. It's okay to go over the and pour it like this. I need a puzzle for that. It's very different to pour it onto and to do his takes care of that. He doesn't hold like that. He holds that it's not it's not okay to pour. You got to only throw. Okay. I learned from here that the pes need a I don't even know you need only from that. So again going back why do I how can I learn the is not saying oh as if I I didn't learn anything out of this it's fresh to teach me that one is enough but I I need it for at least one of these three things so that's today's or a lot of it most of and a little bit let's see as how could I learn from that one application of of The dam is enough. I need to pos something else. How do I know here? Check this out. The leftover blood. What do you do with the leftover blood? You take it and you spill it onto the base of this bath. We changed it a little bit. We last time we had it pouring directly into the into the hole. No, ne next to it. It will go in eventually. How do you know that's what you do with the leftover? In other words, it's it's a sort of an it's not you don't pour it into the sewer system into the you pour it onto the it's it's an essential part of of the carbon. Oh, so I used up the says no you didn't use it up. He he learns this idea that you pour the onbi. [Music] Look at this. We're talking about there's a bird. You take it and you put the blood on the wall of the misbath. Now, how do you do it with a bird? It's not like you uh it's pouring out of its neck and you're grabbing it in a cup. It's going to be like two drops of blood. What's here? Check out the P again. One more time. It says and then a second later it says it could just we could ignore the word. But the word is not important because it already says I already know we're talking about the blood. What's the extra word? What carbon requires four? So I think that only you pour the blood on the on the base of how do I know other from this interesting from the like the furthest carbon. It's a it's a bird. It's not even a That what he's not learning it from this idea they have to pour the blood on the inside. He's learning it from the bird is extra. It's available for me to learn that one is enough. So another now we're talking about this one is there's a difference between I'll show you here the video. Let's not the video. Um this one beautiful. Here's two people doing similar but different. The guy on the right is doing his. He's at a distance to them and he's throwing it with force. Things splatter all over the place and that's the idea. You want the blood to get everywhere to go down. And this is directly putting it on the ton of there's certain let's say we're going to talk about and a carbon pes they bring together the carbon you have to pour it the you have to throw it how do you know that if you're supposed to throw it like the you poured it onto his be. So in other words is a little bit better than it's possible that is included in that if you pour it directly but not the opposite. So once again the question is I already used up these three words to teach me that if I pour it onto the wall instead of throwing it I'm so does he have these three words available to teach him that one application of the dam is enough for allas because he holds that it's not true pouring on the wall is not good how do I know that holds thisan Let me just explain for a second. I I skipped here. What's this? There's a there's an idea that you're supposed to say you should eat the when you're full. Now, if you have a a small sheep that the entire car is taking a piece of kaz of that, you're not going to be full from it. So, what do you do in addition to that carbon pes? You bring a carbon and you eat the lamb chops and you get full and then when you're full from that you go to the to the one and you eat your so that's called there's another one called we're not discussing soal you make a so he says over here what if it's like you know the shabasuda you make and then you don't make a a mus on the kul and on the ch or whatever you make one if you make says it's one of you don't have to make a let's say I don't know exactly how it works but yeah it is backwards but let's say you forgot I don't know exactly the whole thing but if you made a so says it goes in one direction in other words is saying that the the pes are similar because you could be the with the so it's in the same category of a you have to pour and you have to throw the blood but if you pour the blood for the it's so the brah will be mighty also it's within the same category but if you do the reverse you say ah on something they have to throw the blood on the it's not mighty it's not the same as the pes because if you throw the blood of the pes you're So if I make the I'm not on the they're two separate types of carbonas. You cannot confuse the two and one doesn't work for the other. In other words, he's saying that spilling the blood on the MSB does not patter the you're not if you spill the blood of the carbon on the wall of the you have to do a for therefore you have to make a for and a for two separate types of you cannot confuse the two. So over here we have who holds that what do I learn from this we said that it's who holds that is not like so is not used for that but according to this is very important here look look at this chart for a second what's questions I already used it up for the third thing on this list that what is when who holds that that is for is taken for the third thing on this list argues on that says I don't learn that because it's possible it's not is available and I'm learning from the top thing on the list that in a second is going to learn another thing from which is this right over here. Soar's I'm just explaining the Gimmar's question in the future cuz we're holding here. So it's going to be much easier to understand says how can you resp here here we're starting now is coming to teach us that one application of blood. Oh, let's see the POS for a second. Tell me how you understand this. Simple Hebrew is a type of a the firstborn animal goes to the and it goes different types of so what are we talking about here? What carbon are we talking about? We're talking about aar. Do you see any other carbon in this? No, I don't see >> but the says yes. According that this puzzle might be talking about other stuff the pa says that all this plural. Why is it so plural? What what is that? Why? Why? Why? >> This is simple Hebrew. >> Three of them. Three types of animals. Very good. From here I learn that you have to apply the blood and the this is also a riddle. What is unique about a carbon about micer and a carbon pes? There's something super unique about these two things that other carbonas don't have. Super interesting. There's only two things in the world. Micer and Pes. Think about it. Let's do it together. >> Who eats the micer? >> Who eats micer? >> The bum. >> The bum takes it. It's like micer sheny. You take it to your slimy. You eat it. It's like your own fruit. You give 10% to yourself. Give me micer to yourself. How much does the coin get from the smicer animal? >> No. >> Zero. >> When you bring a carbon p of the bdash, how much does the coin get at your carbon pes? zero. These are the only two things that you bring to the to the this. What about a carbon? It goes completely on the the does get something >> he gets the the skin. So there's only two things in the world that the gets zero. He's working like all a million his hand is killing him. zero time from this that I just learned a bunch of things and I I I pushed them off according to this. So once again the final thing on the list that you need I learned. So it's not available for says no The says plural. He doesn't learn from is available to learn your beginning of the enough to do one because he's learning from the words which we saw before. We can see it again here. these two words [Music] made because it's plural in other words of the of the carbon not the K7 so that's what that's why I said I wanted to say the question there so it's it's easier to understand learned the purple the second to the bottom because he learns that from so he learned how could you learn you're right fine we have what said did he learn for the second to last or the last thing on this list [Music] now if according according to this one man the what that I'm learning from the last thing on the list in other words the second thing from the bottom is possible in other words he would agree to in that case so it comes out that there's no difference between a they're both one doesn't work for the other they're both so how If one doesn't work for the other does not work for Zika and Zika does not work for soi they're individuals so why would one be might see the other why does hold they can make a and according to one okay if it's too confusing according to the says we have to tell so according to one is so why is it that you can make a and so says because comes because of the it comes the doesn't come of the the if you say that this entire is talking about it's not talking about all these Three animals a go to the basic pes but if this is also talking about two different types of animals called messer and pes and we just had a riddle that tells us that what there's two coronets in the world that you bring the coin gets zero out of it and they're both how do you tell me that it goes to the coin it's for the owner says what is means that in the it doesn't matter even a that the balm if you have a firstborn and he has a broken leg you give it to the coen the only difference is what's the difference if you have a balm or not a balm If it's a not a balum, bring ring it as a carbon. The kite gets to eat it afterwards. If it's a balm, then the kite eats it as is. That's why we're always careful that the k shouldn't go and, you know, poke a hole through its ear on purpose cuz then it gets to eat the whole thing. It doesn't have to bring it to the mdash. Typically speaking, I would think that a bar goes to when it's complete without a how do I know that even that has a goes to the that's why it says there's no other poss maybe could connect to that that we know that typically speaking when a an animal has a mum what do you You p it all these animals that go to Kev's land. What do you do afterwards? You redeem it and you take the money and you use it for the it's something different unique. You don't do a learn this. Okay. realize it says that this we saw is not it seems like it's only talking about but it's talking about also so that's why it says you should not redeem it cra we know what is when a person sees he has he designated an animal and he says I don't want this animal to be myer I want the other animal to be instead of this this firstborn should be instead of this firstborn however he doesn't so you don't bring it to the as a carbon this is not the second one the one that's instead of in other words you cannot redeem it you send it to land and let it and you let it befall and the owner gets it the gets it the in the micer case the owner gets it. I heard both. I heard that you could bring it as a carbon and I also heard the oppositeely. In other words, I know for a fact that sometimes the carbon he cannot you cannot bring as a carbon the but not how do I know this concept this that is like they don't put it on the the micer This is to to learn out of here famous you know when you hit it with the red ink. So the word also says here Why does it say the word should think of in other words the of the when you say this should be instead of the you do bring it as a but when as a after if this happened after I would think that before you also bring so here we have it you do not bring if it's a you don't bring it as aim only after do you bring it as aim So, let's just go back here for a millisecond. We know this inside out, but let's just do it again. The bottom three different braces. What do you learn from D? You're supposed to take the leftover and pour it on the So, if that's what you learn, how do you learn the top? Let's say you learn the bottom that that needs from where from so it's not available. So how do I know the top that I learned from? How do they know the top? They still have different that they learn from says Rashi that one is enough that requires usually four and now is one. So that's good enough. They took me seriously though. Where does Bish get their idea that you need two zeras? Not one. It says in the car. Where is this? [Music] Here it says three times the word car without a V. Now without you could read it. which is one but it says plural. What is that called? That's called this mus. The way you read it and the way it was given us. [Music] So if the way we read it plural each one equals 2 * 3 is six. Haresh the the idea the the issue not the idea is that we have only four corners. You can't do more than four zikas. There's only four corners on a square. So four teaches us that's the mitzvah. Then the Torah repeated another two and there's a concept only in in I should say here in you see that when the Torah repeats itself for a second time it means you must do it that way. The Torah repeat itself on two because four is for the actual mitzvah. That's what you should do. And another two to get to six. Those are you must do two. One of these three has a VV. But if you look in the we have a little bit of a problem. There's no VV. The VVE went missing somewhere in history. It doesn't mean that what we have is wrong or this is how we have it. We have it without a VV. But he still has that that's only two plus which is another two a total of four. So you have four there's four corners. He says no. So all of them is not MKV but one of them is Makave. Maybe two should be Mak. No. Maybe none should be Makave also. No because it's impossible. You you have to do is an essential part. But there's no reason to say that it's two. So minimum is one. The Torah says do four applications. One of them is who told you that one of them is is essential. There's no over here. It's impossible that there'll be just a a without anything. Oh wow. It's late. I want to tell you a story here. Raboi. Have a wonderful day. [Music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.