CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 28 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

Everybody say we're holding the by the already the category of it's a place outside of outside of the BD makes us so the entire mission is going to have this wording either the whole thing or even part of it I'm going to put the parts of the animal that go to the I'm going to do it outside insh again the same wording or even part of [Music] What carbon do you eat? Well, the column you eat maybe the carbon part of it you eat. So it must be talking about something like that you get to eat the meat. So he's thinking to himself I'm going to eat it outside of the mdos outside. If it's aim he has to think outside because you're allowed to eat the doesn't have to be the whole thing even part of it. or he thinks to himself, I'm going to eat one of the hide of the alo. It's a human eating the hide, which is a little interesting. The gar is going to discuss. Let's point it out now so we could do a little bit of khazar. If the hide on the tail has to go onto the mbayak, so what does this guy think to himself? He's eating it. He's going to make a nice bar. It's it belongs on the misbayak. The question is, could I think that I'm going to eat a barbecue on a piece that really belongs on the on the misb. I'm mixing two types of eating. There's the eating of the misb. This this tail goes on the misb and there's the eating of the barbecue. And if I think in my mind, I'm going to eat something that really belongs to the misb, but I'm going to eat it on my my barbecue tasted. Who said that's beigle? If it's the part of the animal that I'm supposed to be eating, the steaks that I'm supposed to be eating, and I think I'm going to eat it in 3 days, that's pigle. Well, let's say I let's say the the kidney is supposed to go on the misb and I think to myself, I'm going to eat the kidney at my barbecue. Who said that's pigle? I'm doing something wrong, but who said that's pie? So, that's a discussion in the also plearus. Why are all these things that we just mentioned no carus? because they're all in the category of becomes possible if you think about that thought during the one of the now we're moving over to what's as the is performing one of the let's say he's doing and he thinks himself I'm going to I'm going to sprinkle the blood on the not now not today tomorrow that's and that you get four mixes doesn't have to be all the blood. It could be part of the blood. It's the same thing as the ratio. Just the the thought is slightly different. He's thinking about outside of it's a lot of time. He says, "I'm going to eat this meat tomorrow. I'm going to eat it a little bit of it tomorrow." Over here, he's talking about eating part of here. That's what we just saw. I'm going to eat a of the hide of the ali the hide of the tail tomorrow. All those are pigle the carz since it's pigle you get carus. Let's say he thought to himself he's going to eat another part of the hide. Let's say the hide of the leg he's going to eat tomorrow. Is that pigle? No. What? It's not the only one that's that we know of right now is the hide that's very soft on the tail. And that's why it's pigle says the gimmar sabu we thought the gumar understands or alo dummy the hide of this the sheep that's the the skin on the tail is like the tail and therefore if you have to put the tail on the on the misb you have to also put the skin on the mb. So he was supposed to put it on the What did he think? Instead of saying, "I'm going to put it on this." He thought to himself, "I'm going to eat it." What's going on here? He's thinking about eating it when it's really supposed to be eaten by the so to speak. This our Mishna goes like, you could make that switch. They're interchangeable. I could think to myself, I'm going to eat something that really belongs in the let's say it's a part of the animal that the gets to eat. The gets to eat and he thinks himself he's going to put it on the tomorrow or in three days from now. That's also a way to do pigle. Ah, it's not supposed to go on the mb at all. No, he thought it okay. We learned let's say during the he thinks himself he's going to eat part of the animal that that's supposed to go on the like like these guys right over here. All these three things are supposed to go on the misb. He thought he's going to eat it in his barbecue or it's a nice steak that's not supposed to go on the and he decided he's going to put on says no you're you're able to mix those things up and it makes the animal possible it makes the carbon possible says very good so you want to say that the goes it goes like says you could interchange the two the two of the person The problem is we're going to learn tomorrow which is the continuation of our mission calls it starts out the in other words you do one of the formal with the intent to eat something that the is to eat you're doing what you're supposed to do, but it says it's only talking about something that that's the to eat. The mission doesn't discuss anything that's not the to eat and that is not that's that's the one who argues on those are the ones who argue they hold. You can't mix the two up. So what's going on here? that goes like the which probably I didn't open up. If you open up one of those is they're probably going to be together and so the the B goes like how could that be? How could be the beginning and the yes that's how it is. you're gonna have to live with it. Or we just had says that the hide the skin that's on the tail is like the tail. And he has to say, "Well, what's going on here? How could you how could you think about eating it as a barbecue when the skin is like the tail?" And the tail we all know goes on the misb this tail of the of the sheep goes on. A beautiful part of that goes on his goes on his How could you think that it's a barbecue? How could you mix the two things? Oh, like that's him. Or we could say that the the height of the of the tail is not like the tail mat. It doesn't go on the muzz. And that's why when he thinks about eating it on his barbecue, that's the proper thing that to think about because it's supposed to be on a barbecue. The height of the tail does not go into his back, where does it go? It goes in your stomach. When he thinks to himself that he's going to eat it outside the lot of time, that's what where did he get his his thought? It says the fat of the notice the fat. That's what we saw in the video. The fat of the doesn't include the skin. Oh, so comes check this out. Here's No, no, no. The skin of the tail is like a tail. Ah, the Misha says that he thought about eating it. Yeah, because we're not talking about a sheep. We're talking about a goat. Our must be talking about a goat. Now, why doesn't he say like isn't it better to say this? No, it's not better. The is going to explain why each one says what they say [Music] again. The skin of the tail is like a tail and therefore what he goes on the misb if it's a sheep just what and then you had a problem if it goes on how could he think about that he put it on his barbecue you can't mix the two there the two different eatings you're right you can't mix the two eatings only holds that we hold you can't but we're not even talking about a sheep we're talking about a goat so the just explains now that we see the thing on the screen how doesn't say like it's pretty convenient. You could mix the two thoughts of and we're talking about a sheep everything is great. You know why they don't hold like doesn't make sense to them that the is going like goes like that doesn't work. How come everybody doesn't hold like Rahuna that says oral orala what's the obvious answer cuz they don't hold that they like to say oral that the the soft skin of a tail is like a tailuna says the soft skin of a tail is not like the tail they don't like that they they like to hold that the skin of a tail is like a tail so now how come don't hold just say that the the skin of the tail is like a tail and the reason why our Mishna says that he thought about making a barbecue even though it's different than making a barbecue because the skin goes on the misb not a barbecue. The answer is that's by a sheep but our mission is not talking about a sheep. Our mission is talking about a goat. Here we have actually a picture here. Here here are the two tales. The one on the left is a goat. It has no fat as nothing. So you're not supposed to put it on at all is talking about that and that's why he thought about making a barbecue out of it and that's why it's because it's actually something you put on the barbecue. But the picture on the right is the fatty tail of a sheep that doesn't go on a barbecue that goes in the mah. That's why it doesn't fit into says we're talking about a goat. my time of the army mash. What was he coming to to say oral? He wants to tell us this idea that the skin of a of a of the the sheep's tail is like the tail we already learned when it comes to tum there's a whole says these are the skins that are like the meat when it comes to tum and it goes on to say so we already know this idea that the skin the hide is mish like the tail. We already have it. So then why is saying why is he being that we're talking about that the skin is like the tail and and it's talking about a goat. We already spoke about it. But when it comes to that's only when it comes to because it's very soft. It's not something a king eats. Doesn't matter that kings don't eat it. Great. What does say? Let's go back to our chart. Is the one that says that the skin of the tail is like the tail and therefore it should go on the but our mission is not even talking about a sheep. We're talking about a goat. So this is a key word here for this whole thing. Don't get confused. We're talking about an what's an is a carbon that one brings to as a gift sometimes, most of the time, and the entire thing goes on. You don't get anything. Nobody eats a thing. Not a nobody eats one morsel of this. And he had in mind that he's going to eat one kaz of the hide that's under the tail outside of its place. So outside of its place what's poss [Music] typical case typical case. Oh, but it says over here that the skin of the hide goes on them as they say in the name of whether it's this take a look. If you don't like these kind of pictures, don't look. This is the skin of a smaller animal like a goat or a sheep. Here it is on the right side by she sent it to me this morning. Here's the skin. These are all softer skins. If you have a soft skin of a of a calf that's uh the head on the head, it's very soft. [Music] And also included is the skin the hide that's under the tail. That's the over there. All the soft skins. This is by a female animal. The private parts that skin is also so at the end of the day we're talking about could only be a but it also if you have another carbon that has softer skin if a person thinks to himself he's going to eat this outside of its place becomes possible. But the bottom line is it says in the beginning we're talking about what about other according to says what let's go back to our chart says is not like the alia the skin is different what the only carbon in the world that you put the skin of the tail on the is what because the entire thing goes to hashem That's according to Rauna. Why? Because the skin is not like the tail. So give me another example of an of a carbon that you put the skin of the tail on the on the muzz. The skin is not like the tail. So why would you put it on the mah? Even a carbon that you put the tail on the you don't put the skin on the mah. It's not part of the it's not part of the the carbon that goes on the the Yes. Okay. So that's why it says but according to that says that the skin of the tail is like the tail. So there's many animals that you put the tail on the and that includes the skin. So then why does it say it should say all the skin goes on says that the skin and the tail are one. So once you put the tail on you put the skin on. So why do you have to say you're talking about a case that the guy thought himself he's gonna eat the skin of the outside his mouth? No, he's gonna eat the skin of let's say outside the time. Oh, because we're talking about the tail of a goat and the tail of a goat never goes on. There is you're asking all the tail goes on. No, not goats, only sheep. And we're talking about goats. You're 100% right. It should really say ze. You're right. It's a mistake. It shouldn't say the word. Let's erase and put a new word in called. It means next. So says this thing called if you has a thought that he's going to eat it outside of the allotted place the the place he's supposed to it becomes possible you don't get cars says man where did you get this from so now the is going to show us the behind the scenes yeah I could be a and I can tell you here this is the A B C D. That's at the end of today. We're going to get there. This word says this. This word says this. And don't ask any questions. But now this the behind the scenes. How do we get to it? This is the long one that we just saw. And there's one more called the short puzzle. Let's go. We have so we go back to that over here means we said everybody over here scrape out third is time three is time not a place so therefore it's referring to the word in this it's referring to thinking about doing the the outside of its loted place or eating outside the place. And then if you look at the last last line, it's from one of those two. Which one of those two? He's telling you more obvious thing. We need to understand the behind the scenes over here. Who told you? Maybe means that gets doesn't get carus says I'll tell you why gets carus because the the started out that's how the so the is very on that because that's how we started but think about it it says you get carus right by the pegle the word peel And then right away if it's you get we have another let me just show you the real quickly and then I'm going to switch to double screen here. This is the the same idea. That's the short. Now both them together you have the long one and the short one. So he says we already have the long why I need to say the again the long one is in this is in why have to repeat it days. Okay, so the first is talking about the second is talking about check this out. This is Yeah, let me show it to you again blown up. You see all I'm asking is look what it says in the next telling me he's talking about and then it says what's going on here has no doesn't have cars talking about is talking about something else is talking about I'm going to show you the picture you tell me what it is what is that No, that's a different thing. Not it's not a it's if you literally leave the meat over overnight to the next day to the day that's also to eat and you eat it you get oh so now I know that is talking about and I want to say is talking about say like this only this kind of guy gets he ate this steak that wanted to sleep overnight. And it comes to exclude the right before it that the does not get. Who told you? I'm reading the with you right here. Does it say anything about this? It says in fact is like I don't even remember. It's like way before it's before the so maybe is talking referring to you get cars. Who told you? Where'd you get it from? Maybe it's coming to say only this one gets cars which is says it makes much more sense to say gets cars. What is going on here? Because look, it says and it also says, check this out. It says, so now I have between and and it's a very interesting lim. So I must say that that is talking about so that I could tell you that is also chorus. They're both chorus. You hear what's going on here? It's interesting. How do I know that is talking about? Because otherwise how am I going to know that gets so isus and it says the same word that says byman. So now it makes a lot of sense going ask obvious question maybe talking about and it gets carus and gets cars also a good idea. So it says are very very similar. Why are they similar? If we thought about it ourselves, we'd come up with the same thing. What? What's I'm going to eat it the following day. What's pigle? I'm gonna He thinks in his mind he's going to eat it the next day. Okay. So they're both about the next day. So that's Zman. They're both similar in in terms of and also in terms of Abama that they both are bad. You could have a bad thought about Obama that I'm going to eat it outside of the lot of time. Whereas outside of the lot of place Rabai does not work in Obama. You can't have a bad thought about Obama when it comes to place because Obama is in a bad place. It's in somebody's backyard in Tom's River. So since are very similar. So it makes sense that they're both and then you learn one from the other says no it makes why don't you just say that both here we go check this out one here and that's what we did a second ago and because you have the oven now it makes sense it goes together. So as the why why would you say that? Just say that one is and one is and it has and you you compare why compare to compare to and and I have a reason to say that because guess what are very very similar in four things. MD they both occur in the minder does not occur in the minder is a physical thing you left it overnight but both in the head only partial they're both all through the avoid of the four and they both have the word in the barbe saides I learned from I learned that no's cars Because I have something called check this out the wordeshim that referring are referring to one says that's the we were talking about and it doesn't say the word here but it does say I'm sorry it says but it doesn't say right it doesn't say the word but in the first ping on the right it does say the word noiser and it says kaidesh but it doesn't say so because it says kaidesh and in the pausing where it says cars it says kaidesh kaides and kaidesh That's how I know that gets chorus. I never understood why the gar does this to save some words. But the main main word in this is the word and it's missing. It says you're supposed to know this by yourself. That's why luckily we have it over here on the screen. It says all the way at the end of the [Music] talking about And the says only gets and not the right before which is does not get chorus. Check this. Oh, look at the screen. It's going to be magic. Watch it. I did this myself. Is on the right is on the left. Who told you? Uh maybe the ping on the right is and that's the one that you get carus for cuz it matches up with they both have the word and is from the small from you don't get you don't get cars who told you to do it like that says did I skip it's much better Let's go back. Uh is the long one. Why? Because is similar to in the fact that it's and say that the is talking about Yeah. Do this. Why do is so similar to that's why the toy put it right there next to like we have it over here that the small is talking about which is right next to which is to tell us that does not get carus only what's Um only this one it's a special meat in that only gets cars and not because it's so similar to that's why the maybe that's why the made it's going to go fast we all learn it we learn all these forget the second forget the the shorter p we're learning everything out of one p similar to what we said Firstly in red double of eating why two of that that's what we know until now there's two eatings yes there's the human eating and there's the eating referring to the now in green there's two components you need the blood to think about this blood. You're going to sprinkle it on the misbehag and mispel the rest of the animal becomes pigle the rest of so you need two components you need blood and the rest of the animal and that comes to exclude as rashi three that you put the entire thing on the so there's no two components it's only one component like the of the has to be something that you have a component that you do the pigle with and the the rest of the animal the rest of the cover becomes a pigle. What do you do with the word in purple? That's how you learn. Here we go. That's what you all said in the beginning of the year. We said now is in red the beginning of the of the linear. This is a very super interesting al if a has in mind to eat this carbon outside the lot of time in six months from now and he ate the meat right now right after he had the is it is he does he get carus or not he he did and he thinks I'm going to eat this meat in a year from now and then he bites right into it is he on peagle or not that is pigle wrong not why because he didn't do zika yet you must do zero trick question Sorry. Why? How do we know this? It's from this. You need a for it. Without the you would say like you need all four. You need in other words you need to do and then it says that's in black gray. Let's say you didn't think about a thought about when to eat it. You just literally ate it on the third day. You don't go backwards. You don't reverse it and say, "Oh, this this happens to be now that says in purple." In other words, that the pagle, what what goes wrong here? The is a bad guy. He did something bad, inappropriate. So, what did he do? He caused the animal to go bad. The himself doesn't go bad. Only the carbon goes bad. Oh, let's just do one more over here. Where do I have it in red? That we learned that's a beautiful that people has to be pure. You can't think about other it has to be just just pigle. Thank you for coming. Thank you all the guests. Thank you for all the people that are involved in making this happen. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.