CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 27 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

We saw the Mishna. The Mishna says that if you put the blood on the wrong part of the misbeh I told him to take the misbeh whatever you guys know what it looks like. There's a red line in the middle of the the goes above the red line. All the other animals go below the red line. If you mix it up, you put the the blood on the top instead of the bottom. If you put the blood on the bottom instead of the top ple. So we're going to see we have a we started off with here holds that if you put the blood in the wrong spot on the mak it's still good. You put it on the on the top on top of the red line. It's like as if you put it on the bottom. It's perfect for whatap only for everything else. No good. In other words, the meat is no good. You can't eat it. You can't put it on the etc. And we're going to see is basically saying the same thing as the one who argues and it's literally at the end of it's literally the same. the one who argues he says putting it on the bottom instead of the top no good and therefore the owner does not have a kapara going back to that's where we're at. So and says at the end that apostle was the one that applied the blood and the said maybe it should be and that's where we finished off there's no soar says we're holding by 2 4 6 8 10 lines from the bottom why is it only by weab is also a problem if we're talking about somebody who's apostle if the guy let's is could actually have the wrong intent. Who could have the wrong intent for and and all the other things that are that we're going to talk about in a second. There's three things that could be a bad only somebody that could do that not a puzzle. It can't be let's says Rashi it has to be that doesn't have any has all the stones are perfect says like we're not talking about before when I said in the beginning of the we're not talking about we're talking about versus says we're not don't okay take out the word we're talking you're right we're talking about all the way in the beginning And now a could perform the could perform. Therefore what what's the fear? Since they can perform the therefore they could have a bad intent. They could ruin it with their intent. Other things they can't because they can't do they can't do So they can't ruin you're right in other they can't ruin it but in the they could you tell me that during that we learned these guys these guys that are for during they could have as says that apostle cannot ruin it with his pass from Israel cannot have if the Israel decides to to walk the the blood to the he can't have a bad he can't ruin his listen to this if a person had a thought in his mind as he's performing the he says himself you know what I want to mess around there a little bit I want to take this blood instead of putting it below the red line I want to put it above the red line is Is that avo? No. Why? It's not not one of the three things we just discussed. He didn't think to in his mind that he's going to do this in three days. He didn't think his mind he's going to eat it in 3 days. And he also didn't think he's going to eat it outside of your he also didn't think it's for another owner. All he thought about is that it's going to be above the red line. That's not and therefore that is if you thought about it right away it's you all remember we learned when we're learning about pigle today actually maybe it's tomorrow mixing up the b yeah yeah tomorrow at the end of the d the the second half of the year is all about pigle and how do we know it and what the but one of the one of the we discussed and everybody body remembers this is that pigle has to be a pure of pagle. In other words, it's one of these things. The isser is only if you think about it as pigle and you don't think about another something that ruins that the the carbon m we just said if a person had a thought that the blood is going to be given underneath the red line not above the red line or vice versa it doesn't do anything doesn't ruin it. So now he has another thought. O he realizes it doesn't work. He has another thought that he's going to eat this carb. Is it a good pigle or not a good pigle? The answer is it's a very good pigle. Why? Because the first thought that he had is zero. If the first thought would count, then you can't have a of pigle. Pigle has to be pure. It has to be mish the purest form of is without any disturbances. So this is not to consider a disturbance. Nothing doesn't do anything. Kasher. So, and if he thinks to himself he's gonna eat it outside of the lime or he's going to put it on outside the lad time which is also a type of a form of eating pigle it's a perfect pigle because his first of putting it above the line means nothing of cars and therefore you get cars for that the pos. Now once you have a that ruins it. So the following day now the people's no good anymore. Why? Because the original is good. Now the ask wait a minute. If you tell me like here on the chart holds that putting the blood below the red line instead of above the red line is good in a way it's partially good. Why is it partially good? It's good for the kapor of the owner. It's not good that you you can't eat the meat. So it accomplish something. If it accomplishes something, he thought in his mind he's going to put the blood above the red line. Why is that not considered piglear says? We basically answered the question because it only it's only a partial it only works partially his mava his his sorry his his uh putting above the red line and above doesn't work to allow the the meat to go on the misbeh so me doesn't bring to a situation of people how do you know this says You only get carus when the pigle caused it that you can't eat it. The pigle didn't cause it to not be the the fact that he put it above the red line and below the red line. That's what caused it. If that's the case, so why is it possible at all? You're right. It shouldn't this it shouldn't be shouldn't be possible. But now there's something new. There's a new that we didn't know about until now. It's called when the person decides the decides that he's not going to put the blood. There's a that he's going to put the blood in three days from now. That's here's another I'm going to put in the refrigerator. I'm never going to put it on the That's also a bad that makes it possible. It's not, but it makes it possible. It's called So what do we have till now? We have that in our Mishna where it says that if somebody decided that he's going to put the blood above the red line instead of below the red line. It's possible but only that you can't put the meat on the m you can't eat it. But it actually does work in a way this carbon that the owner that brought the carbon gets kapari. He doesn't have to bring another carbon. We're going to see that basically says the same exact thing. The only difference is is how translates the Mishna. how he explains the Mishna where says the word means no halfple not for the not forapish learns differently he says no you're right that when you put the blood you apply the blood below the red line instead of above the red line or above the red line below instead of below the red line it's a good it's a good it's Not in its right place is like the right place regarding theap just so when it says ple it means mameish the entire Mishna means he's ple it doesn't get a kap and and you can't put the meat on the m completely normal like you and I would read it puzzle it means ple comes with no no it doesn't mish mean ple it only means 50% ple but the other 50% is kash says I don't like to me means everything. I agree with everything you're saying. All the that you said are correct. Just how do you explain the Mishna is incorrect? You see on the chart they both have a check, a green check. They both hold the same thing. The Mishna, the reason why the entire thing is puzzle because the coin had a bad thought. Not only did it put did he put the blood in the wrong place, he also had a bad makava of pigle whatever it is where typically if he just put it in the wrong place you're right he would have he would have a kapara cuz he didn't have a it was in other words means his mind was silent he didn't have any anything going on in his mind he just put in the wrong place but in the wrong place the b getsap so over there it's a it's a similar mission to ours but over there it's discussing you go back and do a kaparo. So it says he thought about putting the blood instead of down above the red line instead of above. So now since says the same exact thing as so we're just going to ask the same questions that we asked on all the way it's goes like great and finally now we're on the opposing team now this is argues first of all he says if you put the blood in the wrong blow oh we what do I don't even need this Yoshi did this I didn't use it on Friday here we He put the the blood of the above the red line. He put the blood of the below the red line the Mishna and everything all the the steer that we had. Everything is talking about a case where the did not have any other intent. He put the blood in the wrong place like we just saw without something else going on in his mind. If you put the blood in the wrong place no good. So, how come we said that the the guy could go back and redo the blood cuz there's actually more blood coming out of the neck of the animal. There's damage. We I don't know if you remember, we we said it quickly then we learned there's the blood of the skin that doesn't that's no good for and there's damatis. That's the blood that comes out after the dam. We we're trying to get the damage the blood that the nama comes out with. We're going to see I might have different colorations to it. But over here there's more blood. So go redo it. What's the problem? And our Mishna our talking about there's no other blood. No other blood. There's nothing you can do about it. It says in the Mishna that if you put the blood in the wrong place it's possible but you don't get carnish. What's going on according to he had the wrong thought. Remember our is talking about he had the wrong not only did he put it below the red line above the red line. He also thought himself about that's so that now now makes sense it's not but according to that he didn't have he did we said he there's no thoughts going on so why would I even think that he has to get if there's no thoughts going on good question let's just talk about for a second It also says there's no over here. There's no if you did have a thought just a question. He put in the wrong place. No good. So what happened? There was a there was a cabala in the vessel and what did he do? He poured the blood. Instead of putting it below the red line, he put it above the red line. So we we all know what happens if you have blood inside the clichus. You're about to do and you trip. You fall and all the blood falls on the floor. What do you do? You sponge it up. Tinko it and you put it back in the thing and then you go v. So let's say you put it on a wall. You put it on this wall. Scrape it off the wall and go. You put it above the red line instead of below the red line. According to zero. So just scrape it off the wall and continue. What's the problem? says a very uh convenient answer because he yells that you're not allowed to gather it. If it falls on the floor, you're over like that. If it's supposed to go above and you put it above, in other words, you put it in the right place, but you did it with your left hand or you had a bad. Let's say let's let's say he's talking about it with the left hand. Here's the says you're not you're not you're not to gather it. But if he put it in the wrong place in his says even though he holds is it's like not not in the right place but nevertheless you're not you're not allowed to gather it. He says you should gather it. And now our we have to say he's talking about that to gather it. That's why you don't have a issue. Everybody agrees that if it's supposed you put the blood in the wrong place, you should not gather it. And certainly if it was supposed to go above and you put it below eventually the the blood drifts down the the the top goes to the bottom. So there's no reason for you to redo it because eventually anyways it's going to end up on the bottom. So if you put on the bottom okay so he's supposed to put on the top but it reaches the bottom. If you put it directly in the bottom such a if you're supposed to put it over here inside the and by mistake that's a you can get confused you know you used to doing on this all year round one day a year you go over here a couple times you put it over here so he made a mistake you're supposed to put the blood on this and said he went inside that was that's really sneaky he used it as an excuse to go put in. Okay, so we're over here says you got to gather because there's zero zero. You know what? At the end of the day, you put an on. You're right. They look very different. One is made out of stones, one is made out of gold, one is huge. You need a ramp to get up. The other one is only like uh 4t tall or something. Okay, but at the end of the day, put on his back. We have the Here we go. Means justice he this one. What did I learn? This comes to exclude three things. There's a concept once you put something on a it doesn't come off. We're going to see says everything doesn't matter what. But the first mandar says says besides three things. If at night you take it off and if the blood spilled and that's the the part that we're looking for the blood that spilled on the floor take it off. And if you took it outside of the here if we have the we might as well just look at the chart for a second here. If you took it out from here, he went over here or over here. No, no, I can't. Let's go back to the other one here. If you go out, go outside this way, it's all over. You if it comes on the Let's read this. The the word means the what's it goes up to heaven. You put the whole thing on them. You burn everything. Nothing. You don't eat a one ounce of this animal. Everything goes to how do you know the three things we just learned and meat that was left over the raw you know overnight when you can't eat anymore went outside and a person or the the meat is that we discussed that with the intent let's say did or the the blood All these are going to be in the video as as part of the rep. And and blood that goes above and he put it below. Blood that goes inside the he put it outside. Here's the first mission of that if it goes on top of them. It doesn't come off. Now, we're not talking anymore about the carbon. We're talking about the word means to go up. If it went up on top of this, what about an animal that was done to it? Or somebody did a somebody designated this animal for and a sheep that was given to for services cannot be brought as a carbon and if somebody sold or traded a dog for a sheeplo is an animal that that has two different you know the goat and a sheep had a had a offspring va He can't be a carbon. Why did you say that? But let's say the the animal cannot cannot be uh why what's the what's the what's the logic that this list you take off this list you don't think about it this whole the list that you don't take off is because they were good carbonas what happened you put the blood in the wrong place everything but it was a good carbon but the other list they had no business coming to There was they were before they got to the mdash. But we just learned from all this from this whole video and everything blood that was supposed to go above and went below and there was no argument from this position is because we have to say that the absorbed it so to speak and and made it good. You see from here at the end of the day we're going back to the to the question I supposed could you could you gather it off the floor or not and the answer is according to no you can't rebel we're just going to do this small and we are at the Mishna and that's it for tonight how we're doing with time what happened if you put something we're talking about the the outer but even the inner if you put on something there by mistake it's you don't you don't take it off we we learned that if it's supposed to be inside you put it outside or outside you put it inside it's okay I think okay that's the blood things that have to do with the carbon but flower that you went like this and We wanted to put some flour on the There's never a situation where you put flour on the blood. Yes, once in a while, but not flour that doesn't have the ability is not in the par doesn't have the ability to it does. If you put this on the inside, you got to take it off immediately. It's the outer misbeh. That's the one that has the power to to take things that are not supposed to be there and and and say it's okay. But the the inner one doesn't have the powers. No, what we're going to say is we weren't talking about the inner, we're talking about the outer misb. If this goes onto the outer misb, the regular misb take it off because the outer misbeh does not have the power to be mad things only things that belong there doesn't belong on that. Where does belong rabbis say? right over there. It's called the opposite than what we said in the inner one is so powerful. It could actually be things that have no business being there at all. What's the difference between the inner one and the outer one? Let me just show you this video before you jump up and run. This is the what is it made out of? A bunch of cement. A bunch of different things. This is just the cyber 79 just uh so you get an idea. But look at this one. This one is made out of gold. The whole thing. Okay. So that has a lot more powers. Thank you so much for coming. [Music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysonsor.com or sponsor at mdyop.com.