CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 115 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning rap boy. We are holding dofal. You have a mitzy and one of the one of the carbonas brings is an asham. So, here goes. This is the wrap. It's awesome. It's like a hot sauce. >> So, taking it from the B. supposed to go in the mid and they going to outside. Now it's one thing if he burnt it as an asham. It's another thing if he thought in his mind that it's an what is it called when he thinks in his mind that it's an even though it has a necklace that says asham that's called so again there's two things going on here. First of all, he took it outside of the mdash and also he was so we saw we have yesterday we learned we'll just read the two lines here on the bottom of because that's basically who we're discussing today. So it says like this had been m this asham for an asham outside that's the Mishna that he's potter why is he potter because the mits jumped the gun the mits came early again it's means it's not the right time for him to come he still has the saras in his hand you saw maybe that's that's the giveaway He he went to the K. The K says, "No, no, no. You still have." So he goes and he brings a carbon that's that's before the time before the time if had brought this carbon inside what would happen nothing. He's not nothing. So therefore if you bring it outside on top of Abama he's not but what happens if he changes his mind changes his mind says this is not ash this is so now he change it's a and now you continue bringing it inside the bdash if it was inside the md you continue bringing it oh so if you do that same thing outside of the mdash now you just everything is in the head it's all has to do with what's in your mind so if the thought in his brain that it's not it's now he made it himself not okay perhaps I have a to this idea that if you switch like this like this coin right here is switching his in his brain from a look it says on the sign if you look closely it says asham right over here it's an asham it was a necklace that went around his thing he even had a cigar he's smoking says the what if somebody shed this asham outside of it was a couple things going on this it's it's too early and it's switched to saw one sheet whether it gets an essay or not learned this the famous that we discussed a lot do I have it I don't even know if I put it in here yeah here that the Mishna brings that this is the source that it has to be something has to be a source. It has to be something that you could bring into the maybe an this should come to exclude anah that the owner didn't have like we're talking now this this not time for let's talk about this simpler a woman gives birth right when could you bring a carbon depends If she gave birth to a male boy, then she's she brings the carbonis on the 40th day. If not, she brings on the 80th day. So on day 20, she decided to jump the gun and bring a carbon. What is that called with the she brought oil on day 20? That's it's early that the owner, the woman is is bringing it early. Not not that the carbon is early. Sometimes the carbon is early. How's that? It's too young. The bird is too young. The whatever it is the theyed the mother that day. So you can't check the the offspring. No, no, no. The owner says all these extra words in the hair here. Why do you need all these words? What difference? So it comes to to include all these things but it doesn't mention anything about if if you if you brought a that's it says that's a what's missing is what are we talking what tell me the exact case if it's talking about that's one of the we're like talking about three different components One of them is is it the right time and not the right time. So let's let's line it up. If it's the right time, it's good then what's the difference between ash and there shouldn't be any difference. Why does the price talk about also is okay? We're talking about it's early. Now if it's early this this there this there's another thing going on. Was it or not? the guy did whoever do you think that it's a or you think it's something else if you if you think that this asham which is early and you think that it's a it's garbage it's nothing so for bringing for for outside it's it's early and then you thought the right thing oh what that when it's early and You think that it's not it's that you're not I'm sorry that you are. He says you are. So says no we're going to go back the what? It's it's the right time to bring it. So what do you ask me? It's the right time. So what's the difference between and talk about a talk about also? Why do you mention ash? No. because it goes according to that there's a heckage between that what that if you do I think we learned it in the first Mishna let's look it out I don't remember it is in it's not in the actual Mishna >> we learned it in those let's see the first Mishna first so I should I should know this the Cesar. There's no difference between ash and they both smoke. Yeah, they both come for a Yeah, but you can't just say they both he has he has a it's a heckish just like a if you do the what's the first in if you if you take a orb and you flip the designation on them you can take them and throw them into the garbage says I have a third one the name is oh so there's no question over here what was your question how come it doesn't talk about you mention they're the same by mentioning one you mentioned So let me ask you a question then why do you mention mention and you'll know from it the answer is very simple I want to tell you the bigger I'm telling you the one that's not so known only from I know if I tell you is no good is everybody knows the first of by the way it's the first of when it talks about this The starts the same way. So I'm telling you the the I'm telling you the thing that I learned out from which is what was your question. How come it mentions and it doesn't mention it's the same thing. It mentions because it's mentions means great again trying to bring a if you outside of the migd and it's also it's early and according to at least those who argue says what's I don't think we had it unless I know that Yoshi threw this in. I didn't show because I don't remember reading it. Maybe he read it and I I missed it. Thea means >> we did have it. So he's read I I remember I didn't >> What's the here? That if a animal was less than a week old, you can't bring it as a car. They're making a birthday party cuz now it's ready to go on his hair. It's like bulb. Good. That's a possible. I don't know. Maybe. Whoa. Here it goes. I think that if somebody brings in a early what's early he brought was the this animal 6 days old didn't wait until late was six days old or maybe the owner again something's it's too early for the for the for the whatever if you cannot bring this animal today why because it's six days old or because you're still a if you this outside how come it doesn't mention anything about over here it only mentions what are we talking about we're talking about he did the right thing he he thought that it's a because he messed it up he did it too early that what he thought that this ash is and you continue bringing it. No, we're talking about he didn't have the right intent. He thought that the was something else was asking why it doesn't mention because it already mentions. Why did I mention not? It's the same thing but the backwards. I rather say the source the and then you'll figure out on your own cuz if you know what holds you hold it and are the same. So I mention one from there you know it's so basically it's the same exact price that we just read just the gumar says he doesn't know the lemon before we said like uh five lines from the top we said right four lines from the top I showed you the causing them. So now we're repeating the same thing I think to exclude that the owner is not ready to bring it yet. So over here it says what you think to exclude. No, he's if he brings in and I I I remember they brought a he brought a I don't remember what the was I'll tell you what the is I'll remind you what do you see it must be the does this whole it must be that we're talking about what case our case that what it's and because if it's not and it doesn't make any sense Yeah, if it was and it would be and it must be that we're talking about our case that it's too early and and that's exactly the this is what the started off when it's too early and that's my room what's the question you already answered it goes like it's the same thing that okay the whole that whole we already spoke about it we already answer your question we have another contradiction says know if you thinking that it's not anah like we saw we start off the you have a guy that's supposed to bring asham but it's too early for and he's outside of the mikdash and he thought about it's three things you really have to keep track over on three different things. It's outside of the migdash. That's a given because that's the whole for the last few daff the whole parrot. We're talking about a guy stepping outside. It happens to be too early because he has on his hand. It's still on his hand. So it's too early for him to bring his car and he made a flip instead of thinking that it's a with a green hat. He thought it's an Of course it's not a good. So you have to redo. You have to rebrand. you have to pay another 500 bucks and get another carbon. What if the the guy is is a is a he's you know he's still a he's not it's not time for him to bring the carbon there's a problem with the animal itself. Why? Because ash could only be in the first year. The language is not like us. We say he's 2 years old. Two years old by us means he finished the second year. two years old in the Gimar language means he started his second year. It's day 367, 366 on on his, you know, it's into the into the second year. No good for says. >> Oh, so we have a contradiction here. What do we do? Says when is it possible? On the one hand, it's possible. So, which one is it? If you do it with the thought, it's going to be an because it's not the time. This is no here. You take a you take a you think to yourself, it's an now you made it kosher. The last line we had on the bottom, how's it possible? You do the wrong thing and it's good. You do the right thing, it's bad. Yeah, we find that by says there's a contradiction between the it says outside in our is and the says so again we have a contradiction the same idea when it's you do the right thing becomes possible if you not you don't do the right thing is whatever it is outside is thinking that it's a then it becomes at the end of the day is the one that says the says was talking about at least that when you sh it in the right time yeah the whole is talking about and now over here we're saying that we're talking about not what happened was he he put he had two for yeah we spoke about that you take to he brought two we had the also a few days ago he put a backup let's call it a backup just in case one goes he has another one and what did he do he jumps the gun and shucks one guy outside of the b mikdash now since that guy is available to be right now that's why says Because he's anah. What did he gain? What we gained is since there's two of them. If there's one, you know why you're over here? Because one of them is an it's not the it's a that you one of these ashams is like an why? Because it's the extra. It's a backup. If you have a one of the issues that has the five. So you you send it off to land. Now you just without any automatically it flips to remember the said, "Oh, you should do the same thing over there." The says, "What are you talking about? One is in a cave, one is a but works perfectly is a great it says in the if somebody takes meat that's edible for human consumption it's steaks that come off the it's steaks that come off the and you bring it outside of the you put it on nothing happened. You're not you don't get cars for that. This is not a carbon. This is meat that's edible to humans. Yeah, just from going through the list, all these meats from the leftover of the which is basically barley and the two breads, the two loaves of bread that you bring on the 12 breads that we bring every on the and the leftover of a we're almost there. almost starting a new for all those that are looking for excuses not to start today because new they only need. Somebody asked him today when's the new said this coming week. You ready? Yeah. Yeah, I'll be there. How do you know that if you do all this outside similar to goes up on top of the of course something that goes onto but leftover doesn't go on doesn't go all these things do not go on what about if you pour the oil on top of Oh I really should show you this. This is good. It's good to to know this. How many times do you pour oil on a We didn't get into it at all. Three times. Three times in a regular mah. That was a by the way, confusing. We'll preface it over here. you know Yoshi's thing that he goes like this and then a bunch of flower comes pouring out for five minutes and everybody says oh it's that fake thumb thing that that's in a but a normal he's going into very tough stuff he's he's doing this into flour that has oil not stem oil on the bottom of the clay flour on top of that another time oil mix it up then another time oil dough so you're going into dough So, how do you know that? If you do, you pour oil. Here you see bo. Let's see. We have bo over here. Yeah. Here we go. Bo basically mixing it up. We're going to have it in sheer bo I showed you is the mixing it up. So, let's see if we have pois. I don't remember. I think yeah, I think we do. Pis is breaking it up into four. I don't see it here. Here. Oh, this is nice to show. Why not? This is a mikava. You have to do bring flour, oil. Now, the thing on the left is a little exaggerated. We know the vine is not that large, smaller pieces, but okay, it doesn't matter. You get the idea. There's three components, three ingredients. And salting the carbon, you take the the meat of a carbon and you go like this, back forth like a we saw you do on the southwest corner. is setting up the the you have to say this talking about outside, right? We're talking about everything outside. So I guess he grabbed the whole outside of the they took it from the put it outside and started putting everything on the shelves putting the the wicks together and doing and and receiving the blood outside. How do you know? Just like the the putting it on the is the last last thing like also putting the of that's the last final thing that you do. There's a whole bunch of in the in the the as we saw but putting it on in that's the final one. So it must be something that's at the end. Anything that's in the middle of that va bal uh yik b all these things pouring oil mixing it these are all in the middle in the center center doesn't count that for that you don't get cars next says in the that until the mishk was erected after then was mut and also the was done with the bkar was done with the now we s we saw this we're going to see the in a second let me just show you where the is over here the understands that the did it what's little kids the younger kids no refer to a one-time deal we'll see one time or until the did it the gives some hope to the then I was thinking to He said that and I remember hearing this in from and I never saw it but somebody sent me that >> come back >> that that will do that I don't know how it works with and this maybe everybody is maybe you that are notar you are so how does it work exactly everybody's doing he was reading this one that we have on the screen said that after there's no no more it went all to the so he wanted to ask him a bomb from our Mishna that says the Bkar went all the way to the Mishk but he he was about to to to attack him from our Mishna and then he realized he could do two for one sham You heard another mistake says that goes on this you don't have to remove the hide. You don't have to skin it. Put it on with the skin. So he says why should I ask him a question from our Mishna went all the way to the Mishk. No I'm going to get much more for my money. I'm going to bring him a and in the bry it's unbelievable. It's big over here. Yeah. He has a cash from the mission. Then he realizes he said something else and I have another source that's going to get him on two things. Two different completely he got him from a two questions. Question number one is it says over here actually it says that the went all the way to the so that's question number one. Question number two is everybody could could bring a carb and even a woman. I'm sorry. No, no, no. Every animal I believe it means every type of animal. You could bring a giraffe. You could bring a bea. You could bring a certainly they brought chickens. And this is a big in a cave. That's a even in a cave. Why? Because in a second you'll see that I could bring a uh an animal to cast don't bring any lions don't bring anything that's only now everything was so the problem over here is not a problem but the is that is only now and over there it says even great and listen to this so that's question number two it says over here that they used the skin animals in the midbar >> and you said that there's no need to so I got you on two questions and this is a even in our days Trump could bring a carbon on bring a giraffe the that go to they have to They have to be they have to be zoo that's referring to the that they were doing the so warns them you don't come close to you also like regular don't don't come close to to to the to the mountain it's referring to the not they did the all the way to the did the go all the way to the or Yeah. What's the question? The did it but maybe it was all the way only to not to the Mishkan. It's it's a it's a it's a question of nine months. It's a 9 month from Matanra till Mishkan about 9 months. I think it was sir that hinted to that with with my close ones in other words close ones are going to die here when when you when you when you build a mishk now what's interesting is thought because talking about himself about thought I'm going to build a mishk I'm going to die that He didn't tell him exactly what. Now it makes a lot of sense that meaning but if we're doing so what does it mean going to die that day it's going to become in my honor So the hint was that two of the ones that I I honor, they're going to die. What he's talking about until died. That the ones that I honor, these are holy people. As soon as realized that his sons are known to the in other words this special to him he was quiet he was he got a lot of reward for being quiet what he's quiet he didn't say a thing toem oh what does it Even though he kills from you even he get some of them die and you're quiet. There's a time to be quiet as a time to speak up. What does that mean? Sometimes you are quiet. get a lot of reward for not um questioning's sometimes you must go out there and scream. Look how beautiful this is. Hashem did a great thing for me. I have a baby. You make a kid. You know that you get for the reverse also is awesome. the what does you know they go so the the the whole world is fearful and everybody is elated become I don't know if elated is the right word they become they they go up in the da the bottom line is the bottom line do you do you remove the height from did they remove the height of the in the midbar or So it's in fact that what gave a general overview of the and he gave the details later on nine months later in seems like a contradiction what's going on is repeating what happened over there who gave a very general not the all the details. So one of the details that was missing by is the het that you have to skin it that he didn't say he said you put a carbon exactly how you do it that came later on so there's no until that point no no everything was given at all the details everything so removing the hide was something they did all the way back then so it's not a question that goes according to that they took off the hide it goes over there. The third time have a wonderful day. I'll see you from the other side. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.