CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 110 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] GOOD MORNING or so we have a a bit of a steer here between the Bryce and the Mishna. And it seems like on the one hand on its outside of the potter according to which one is it? So yesterday we saw a gavaldic terret that there's an akamina between what we're talking about. There's two types of there's that you do. Do me a favor. You're you're over there now. Get me the uh the the we do on the every single day twice in the side the we're going to call today because compared to Thank you. compared to the it's outside. And then the other time is once a year. No, not but here it is. He takes two handfuls. We're going to talk about that. That's the sheer two handfuls. We we'll see if that's the and he puts the two handles and he's so says everybody agrees that what one is enough where's the if a is not enough when he does the amerad this that says it means literally and you shouldn't veer from it even one iota and anything less than that even a is not enough says take fill up your you is also good enough it says the word hookah we all by what does mean to us means this is it and that you can't you can't veer from it. So if the says and the says all the inside then it has to be I disagree with you comes with his own terrors here. So here says if you need says no [laughter] this is what's the of on a daily basis on this what's the shar we just said and now the she even though the says and that is the I'm going to tell you that's the says by I know it's the why because it says it's a different year. But listen to this. Since on a daily basis the shar is a kaz so I am kipper if I and what happens on a daily basis if I take that kaz and bring it outside of the bd I'm because that's the shar the shear on a daily basis is a kaz you hear men it looks like I'm losing you already the shar of the of the daily is and if I bring that outside we're talking about outside and inside the b if I bring it outside of the baz less than not. So too I am kipper if I bring out one kaz even though my shar is much larger I have to put I have to bring in but to bring outside of the mikdash the sheir is the same it's a gaz here yoshi did something like this if this helps us during during the the weekdays during the the year all 364 days of the year besides on yumipper it's so what happens is oniper he took a kaz worth of from the he took a kaz and brought that outside on the weekday a kaz the question is if you're also that's the whole thing let me ask you a question so what happens if you take out water you spoke about yin water pouring doing a on sukus take the water outside and pour it. So maybe the shear should be a also look just like the on a weekday is a and we're learning that same sharp even though the real of is a it's so maybe water also. So the is going to discuss that we said what is everybody agrees I'm telling you it's a you have to have if you take that that and bring it outside how much is this year I learned from a regular daily of what connection does have to do with the regular shear to take it outside is the same shar you need for the inside and that is if I can't learn outside from outside how am I going to learn the from My what is he talking about? [clears throat] I would think that if you bring outside less than the in other words leaz of less than a kaz of here's the key word less than three of wine less than three of water I think you should be of but the po the the point is that last thing that it says there's three L of water a little less than three L of water but we all know that three L of water whatever it is let's call it three liters there's at least one in there a lot more than a kaz how come in that case we don't say oh he brought a kaz of water like this. Wow, it's loud. I don't know why it's loud. Here we go. There's just like if you took one kaz of water and you poured it outside, you should be but yet we know that's not true. Anything less than three actually just close the door, please. Keep going. So he says, "Oh, and says, "No, sorry. Is a question." Yeah, you said it already. question says there's no difference between the the the talking about the the regular weekday just what we said how much is the shar on the weekday but over here what happened was he went and he took the shear whatever he's going to do that day and he put it So whether once you put the in a vessel does it lock it in say no it doesn't do anything the is remains no you put it in a cle so it's the that that's the shear so now you have to until you take everything out of that cle and bring Bring it outside. You're not why cuz now I just made a yes. If you bring a kaz and put it on but once I take the two press the two press and I put it in a cle the makes it and that's your sh for today. So let's say you let's say you put some of it inside but as long as you took whatever is remaining and put it outside then you're anything less now that we establish this does the establish something or not >> according to establish establishes the doesn't do anything so there's certain likel they have bring wine with the carbonas. How much wine? So, it depends how large the animal is. If it's a giant animal like a bull, you have to bring six. Look. If it's a medium animal like a ram, you bring four. And if it's a small sheep, you bring three. So, he says like this is nothing. So, if you put aside six, it didn't and you took four out of the six. Why? Because nothing. If something that the cle makes it establish now you have to bring all six outside. But over here four is enough. Why is four enough? Because four is good enough for another animal called a ram. Let's say he he put four and he pulled three outside of the because they're good for a lamb. If it's a little less than three. Why? Cuz there's no carbon that takes less than three. So if you have less than the shear, you bring it outside, you're part because it's not the >> no not a you're just sitting up. Now going back to the what? >> Yeah. It's like anything without a we said we even mentioned before that are lesson. So was that we're talking about and we have if a person takes less than the of brings it outside whether or not he's why because the shar during the year is a so maybe that she should also go into so what do they ask him asks him yes so if so let's jump to something else called water according to it's only on sukus the water one is enough to bring outside and be over. Why? Because the is so to the water is a soashm. No. What's the connection? It's not a good You're asking me water from No, we're talking about I'm comparing the weekday that we do this every day which the shear of taking outside to the which is now you made a real jump. You went all the way to water on what's the connection even though you're right both outside but it makes a lot of sense to learn from even though one is the one is the we learned in the that if you have less than the you potter simple question. What happens if you let's say you bring outside of the shear you have a all of a sudden a wind comes poof blows it away a fire consumes it now you have a half a kaz but when you stepped out of the mdish you had a full is that considered that it's missing and therefore or it's not missing Listen, the moment you step out of the it's possible anyways by just bringing it outside of the becomes possible. So, who cares what the she is? It's already possible. You're dealing with something that's possible. So, so it's possible that has a she never heard that such a thing called a shear and something that's possible. [clears throat] No, it has to be something. You can't say, "Oh, it it doesn't need a shear." Even a one little um gir. How do you see gear in >> a grain? One grain of you for something like that. No way. Fine. I I'll keep prove it to you. This is a classic says until you bring the last part of whatever you're bringing the last part of the last part of the so you see over here that if you're missing any of it you [clears throat] no even if it's outside so he says were you trying to bring a no I'm not trying to bring a from cuz okay you're Right. I'm trying to bring aording. Yes. Even according to why I heard before because it's here in front of us. Everybody agrees that if something's missing you that that's what he's saying that says that if you don't have the whole thing it's even that if you if it's missing right now it's not in front of us. And the wants to say where did it become missing outside classic not a good I can't I can't force the because maybe it went missing inside the my question is what happens if part of the the went missing outside. So once again, same question, same answer. It says if it's missing outside, so here it's even more refor. It says it's missing outside became missing outside. You started off good and came missing already. was already inside the Oh, so it says that if you have look at the last line of the Oh, I wanted to check if I said it in English. I said it in the Hebrew, but I don't know if I said it in English. Coming out. So that's says part of this meat is regular meat that you're supposed to eat as a steak and part of it is immune and he flipped it. You don't have to flip it. Says you don't need you don't need outside. You could put it on a stone. You could have it in midair. So there's no touching. There's no touching and flipping. It's simply being mid outside of the md. That's what you're for. Rav says that it's both part of the same animal. So this is this is meat. It can't make it when it's the same item. >> Says the Ah, you have a that you didn't take the you didn't stick the didn't stick his hand in and take the three fingers worth of flour. So like that you can't put on the on the on [clears throat] and you took this and you put it outside on outside potter. Why you potter? because it doesn't have the kam. It's not a good. What if you did take a kam and there was [clears throat] a leak in your house and you needed that vessel. So you put the kam right back. What what do you do with the kamita? There's a big bowl. You take the kamita out. You put it in a small bowl. The kam went back into the bowl. boats. Now over here, you shouldn't really bring it on, but if you did, the guy that brought the so you bring that same exact item outside. Now, if you go back to this picture, okay, so he took the small bowl and put in the large bowl. The large bowl is the so it should become so it's as if you're putting into the whatever is left in the bowl is mut to bring outside. You're allowed to be that or whatever. Burn it on. You're not It's not the large bowl should be the small bowl. You're right. Theoretically, the small becomes in the large and we're going to view it as of a not as the on. We have a problem though. There's a Okay. So, we have a concept that if somebody brings a guy with a a giant shack, a giant hand brings a kima, it's like 4 pounds worth of kamita and a little guy brings a kima. So, the the the small one and the large one is bottle. No, it's not bleak. They don't become bottled to one another. >> Yeah, I hear whoever for whatever it is, you know, he's you don't say, "Oh, the little guys it goes. It's part of the larger guys." So, the large bowl is not. So now we know when you do a regular mah, you bring a min. So you have to take a kit. You know what? Let's show it. Why not? We saw it yesterday. Show it again just to because it's very important to remember. Oh, what's this? This is the new one. I want to show the the Levina part. Levina. Oh, here's the lavina. That's the levina. Okay. Now the lev you have to put onto the and the you have to put on the muzz. So there's really two things you have to put in in order for a person to eat the leftover. You have to put you have to put two things in. What are what are they called? That's two. When we throw the blood of the carbon on the that's one that blood allows you to eat the carbon. But when it comes to there's two things. So now you have you can understand now we're going to have some questions. What if you do one out of the two? What happens? He only did one out of the two outside is always consistent. They have to put everything on them. So if it's [clears throat] two things you have to put a boat according to everybody even according to if you put one inside the mdash one outside that is consistent to what we said up until now even mentioned earlier if there's 20 you put 10 inside 10 outside according to you don't have to put everything outside you just have to finish whatever you have left over you have to put outside and those two things are the and they're full of frankincense. And here he does a zoom in. He can zoom in, zoom out. Now we're talking about these two. Every shabas we have to burn these in order to eat the he only brought one of them outside. Same question. You have to be both. But if your macro one inside and one outside because at the end of the day everything went some inside some outside the how you say in English blacksmith. What happened was you have to bring a a kit. You have to bring a kamita and also the levina the fragrances. It's two different things. While he's bringing the kamitz, he's thinking to himself, I want to eat half the half of the cuz you have two things that are that are allowing you to eat. So maybe each one takes 50%. The gimmar is asking now which 50%. Which 50%. Okay, eat 50. Go ahead. Eat 50% of this flour. You're going to start taking each uh grain of of what are you going to do? So says very positive. You hold yeshra retroactively I can decide this is the half that I that was on you could do that as you hear it's a question as much as the matter how much is a matter 50% because I also have to do and is another 50%. So what the question is maybe this will help you. Do we have the same in whereas a girl who's engaged but she's a naira? She's 12 and she makes a nether who has to be made for the nether >> both husband and and and father. What if one of them is mafur? So did it weaken up the nether or it actually took off 50% of the nether? Does each one have a 50% share in the Nether? A full 50 and so he got rid of 50 and the other one has to get rid of the other 50%. Let's say she made a Nether for two days. I'm just throwing it out. So the father got rid of one day. Now the husband has to be m the second day or no each day becomes a little weaker but it's still there in theory over here uses over there to make it guys. Same idea becomes weak says what are you talking about says that in order to make when it comes to you have to think the thought of pigle what's pigle I'm going to eat this in two weeks from now but I have to think that thought at both both by the and also by the sorry I could do piggle on one of the too. So if I do pagle on a kim, it's good. Mr. Mr. Shi, so I was m I knocked off half according to mayor. But according to I can't do unless I do both. This I just thought when I was reading it because the question was so we have to say that the question but wait a minute it's not a good question he holds like so is the one that says so we're going to go according to that say right in our do So since if you just do a so do we view the as 50% a whole 50% and the a whole 50%. So if you do one so you knocked out 50%. So you could eat half of this carbon it makes it weaker says what's mix sometimes not sometimes you all remember this cuz we're at what carbon do you have to apply blood on all four corners everybody together. So what if you only did one corner outside? So this is fascinating. This whole idea of says it's only onus. You can't do the but it seems like outside remember after you do you have the leftover of the blood. If you that outside you are agrees by blood that what by if you do one outside you're why each z is an independent entity yes you have to do four but each one each one is 100% that one I'll prove it to you we're talking about that we do side. Boom. He knocks over the whole blood. It's all spilled on the floor. Now, what do you do? What do you do? Anybody remember? You another one >> and you continue where you where you where you are. So, what does that mean? That means that whatever you did already is good. Each one is individual. He says in the name of is talking about in his going [snorts] to see at the end everybody else is to spill the water to to pour water on them on is in the says a lot of people wonder what is sometimes it says And why is plural? Because the is actually referring to the water also. If it's in the so the water should be just like the wine and just like wine you need three. water should be should have to bring three log seems to say that you don't need three log even if you spill less than that another question [clears throat] just like wine is all year round if you bring oil you have to bring wine so too if you spill you pour not spill pour water on your in your house outside of all year round but we saw the mission he said only on sukus says there's three things that are that 30 days before you're not a plow anymore. 30 days before but if there's 10 small little guys little saplings planted something like this then you're permitted otherwise they'll die. Okay, one that you bring in there like today if we if Yoshi did this it would be a whole mat this it would be shaking people be moving but these are they used to walk around everybody agrees came from it's not a so the question is just is it three log or is there's no she at all but at the end of the day it's to have a wonderful day at 8:30. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today mdysonsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.