CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 80 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] >> Good morning Rabbi voice I Do you need to smash me or is it Mordecai? The voice I was holding on death. I ain't tell some of the base. Three lines from the bottom. And through my mind I learned that we had three cases where there are two titles involved. A title is when something good happens to your person gets out of jail. He's able to go over the ocean, the midbar, the desert. As a force layman he brings a title with 40 breads. What happens if you end up with two titles? Do you have to bring in this situation two two breads? In other words, two times 40. What are the situations? Situation number one is or out of order or without order, the title had offspring. So you have two titles now in front of you. Which just says you don't have to bring more bread. The other one is you did a tomorrow. We have sheep number one and sheep number two. This was the original. Sheep number one was the original. And then you saw sheep number two, you liked it more, you said I want this sheep number two to be instead of sheep number one. That's a tomorrow. That's awesome. Now so now you have two sheep. How many breads do you bring? So it says in the Mishnah you only bring one set of breads, 40 breads. What if sheep number one got lost? And you brought you found you brought sheep number two instead of sheep number one. And by before you even had a chance to check this sheep number one shows up. So now you have the option [music] of giving the bread checking the yellow one. Thank you awesome. Have the option of bringing the yellow one checking the yellow one and bring the bread to the yellow one or you have the option to do it with the smaller one. Why? Because both of them are in front of you. If both of them are in front of you, you can do whatever you want. I call upon him to do more like this. Shall I rub honey in the machine of Rubuchan? So they said in the name of Rubuchan, the Shano, when does the Mishnah mean that you don't have to bring a second pair of bread? El Achik Paro, when you check the number one and now you have number two. So you don't have to bring bread for the second one. Aval Fini Caparo, Tunam Lechem. But before the Caparo you need to bring bread for both. Now what are we talking about exactly? Aviva Rab Amram so as Rab Amram Machai, what is he talking I want to remind the island there's two types of a title. You can have this the the Nidava. Nidava means I'm talking about one particular one. I said Haray Zu, this particular one. That's the one I'm bringing. If this one dies, gets lost, whatever it is, I don't have to replace it because I said Zu. But if I make a Neder, not a Nidava, I talk about myself and I say I at least the fancy I'm going to bring leather. That's what we say Neder. A title. So it doesn't matter if this one gets lost, I have to bring another one. But it's a big enough Kamina. Why? Because if I made a Nidava as it was going to say in a second, so now my is Dafka on this one, Zu. So if I bring another one number two has nothing to do with number one. It's as if I decided on my own to bring two Nidavas. Okay? So on both of them I have to bring bread. Why wouldn't I have to bring bread? I lay my Khalifa Choyda last night on the Amud. What am I talking about? That I brought my my title got lost. But what kind of title? The title they said it's on me. I have a it's a it's on me. I love the Caparo and I know you love the Caparo and I know. On both of these cases we learned that what? Like we saw over here that if both of them are standing in front of him Let's see if I can do it real quick. He's standing in front. And we're over here. Oh, right over there. At this point when both of them are standing in front of him he could pick and choose. He could say I want the bread to go with the yellow. I could I want the bread to go with the white. I love the Caparo and I know. And if it's after I already got my Caparo, I used I I checked the yellow, then white does not get bread. I love the payment of if we must be talking about I love Achalife Choydas Nidava. He said Haray Zu. He pointed to one and he said this particular one. Bain the snake Caparo, Bain Achik Caparo, Tunam Lechem. Why? Both of them are going to need bread. Mar the Choydas Zu. It's literally that he he decided to bring two titles. I call upon him. So it doesn't matter if you bring one or two. If you bring two, the second one has nothing to do with the first one. The first one is my if it gets lost, I don't have to bring a second one. Why do I bring a second one? Because I'm I'm giving a class type to Rubuchan. So both of them require bread. I love Choydas Nidava. So must be talking about the offspring, the other case in the Mishnah. Not the case where one got lost, but rather where the mother had offspring. I love Choydas Nidava. Here, let's see this one. There's the offspring of a Nidava. I love Vlad Choydas Nidava. So there's the Choydas Nidava and there's the Choydas Nidava. So we're talking about the the Choydas that's a Nidava. He said I want this one. So Bain the snake Caparo, Bain Achik Caparo, Ain Tunam Lechem. So the you see on the bottom over here, there's no bread in the basket. Why? Before Caparo because it's moist of the Choyda here. This is just the leftover from the mother. It's not its own thing. It's it's under the the mother. And therefore the bread that goes with the mother is enough. You don't have to bring bread for the offspring. So I love Vlad Choydas Choyva. The next case. That you are to bring I I like the wheels on the stroller. They're made out of the matzah, the challah that you bring with the Choyda. The Vlad Choydas Choyva. So the snake Caparo Tunam Lechem. If I must bring it, it's I said Haray Alai. So before the Caparo I can use the offspring and therefore I have to bring bread. Achik Caparo Ain Tunam Lechem. Here, let's just press this button right over here. See, before the Caparo we require bread, but after the Caparo it does not require bread. Like a marshmallow wants to be kissed here. Because of Rubuchan Adam is Caparo by Sheva Kedish that I'm permitted to to receive a Caparo through the offspring of the original. That's Rubuchan. Because of Rubuchan Adam is Caparo by Sheva Kedish. I can receive and that's why the the offspring is in the in the challah in the bread. Aviva Nami Aviva Aviva went through the whole Sugya and he came up with the same Svara. It were Nami. Now we're going to going to do a review of what we just learned. So here it is in pictures. Khalifa Choydas Nidava. If mine my Choydas ran away, got lost and I brought a replacement but it's a Nidava. In other words, I said this particular one is what I'm bringing. So Bain the snake Caparo, Bain Achik Caparo, it doesn't matter if it's a Nidava, which is the one on the right, you always have to bring bread that we said. Bain the snake Caparo, Bain Achik Caparo, Tunam Lechem. Why? Mar the Choydas Zu. That we already established that the second one is not necessary for you to bring. Why? Because your whole you accepted upon yourself only the original one. And the second one is completely extra. It's a it's a second one. It's as if I brought two separate titles. Three titles. A person can bring five titles. But in each and every one that he brings has to bring bread. Mar the Choydas Zu. What about Vlad Choydas Nidava? But if the Nidava had a offspring. Bain the snake Caparo, Bain Achik Caparo, Ain Tunam Lechem. Why doesn't it need bread? Why is it a title? It's the offspring. It's the the the the outcome of the original title which that had bread. So the offspring doesn't need bread. However, if it's Vlad Choydas Choyva. But if you you said you said upon yourself Haray Alai Choyda, I'm bringing a title. And it had offspring. So if you used it, the snake Caparo, Tunam Lechem. If if it's Choyva, you said Haray Alai, which is the one on the left. The snake Caparo, Tunam Lechem, Achik Caparo, Ain Tunam Lechem. Once I got the the the Caparo, I don't need bread. Okay. New Sugya Rab boys say. Omar Shmuel. So Shmuel What are we? Like 12 lines from the top? Two, four, six, eight, 10, 12, 13 lines from the top. Omar Shmuel. Call She Choydas Mesa, the Choyda Ain Tunam Lechem. He says two Halachas here. He starts off saying two Halachas. The Mishnah is going to say that then he only said one. Which is the first line. What are his two two Halachas? If in the same situation you have a Chatos that must die. There's five times the Chatos that must die. Five situations. To remember it, it's Vitimna. We'll go through them one by one real quickly. That same situation in a Choyda then don't bring bread with the Choyda. If the Chatos must die, so if it's a toy doll, don't bring bread. Which hottest must die? The offspring of a hottest must die. You can't There's nothing to do with it. Because a hottest only comes for forgiveness for a Nevada. If the hottest had offspring, what are you going to do with the You can't use it. That's it. It was designated for the I did last week. I can't bring it for this week. So that that hottest must go in the room and die. Tomorrow's hottest, if you say this B is instead of A, so the B has to die. What's the next one? If right before the person was able to bring his hottest to be something that she died, that's it. Fourth one is hottest if the owner already had a forgiveness because it got lost, the original got lost and he brought a second one. And the fifth one is hottest if the hottest became went into the second year of its life. So that one doesn't really apply to toy doll because toy doll could be older. But if these cases happened to a toy doll, in other words, toy doll had offspring, you did a tomorrow to the toy doll, the owner died, whatever, then you bring the toy doll as is without bread. That's what says without bread. Number two that he says is hottest royal. If the hottest must graze to be following them, which is what we call land, you send it to a special place that you do all sorts of sports to break its bone. Once it breaks its bones, it becomes a a bone. And then you could redeem it. If that's the case, the same case happened with the toy doll. If a hottest would have to go to land, then by the toy doll, the same case, it would require the bread. This is the one we did yesterday, so super easy. Says the You should bring the toy doll as a carbon. How do you know that if he designated a toy doll and it got lost and you designated a second one instead of the first one? The video that we showed. How do you both of them are standing in front of you? How do you know I could be back here either or? I'm going to bring the bread with it. Whichever one you want. Perhaps both of them need bread. I'm going to give it a new one. Singular. Bread goes to one of them. We all have a big problem. You told me that in such a case, we all have a hottest royal. In such a case, if you have the two in front of you, there's actually three cases. We'll go through them real quickly. But just pause now for a second. You have two in front of you. So you you shut one and the second one goes out to graze. You don't kill it. When do you kill it? In the other case, where you designated one, it got lost, you bought a second one, and you shut the second one, and then the first one the first one comes back. Then you must kill the first one. But when both of them it showed up before you had a chance to shut the second one, now you have two options in front of you, then you let it graze according to this man doll. This man The names of the But I am going to do this. Both of them in front of you. This is the new toy dolls. The rabbit. But we don't pass it like a rabbit. Pass it like a A hottest Mesa. You don't kill the the second one. Buy them. Only if you found the first one after you already shut the second one. But if both of them are in front of you, should I buy them? Royal. Oh, and if it's royal, we said let's look again in what says. What's his lotion? Call if in the case where the hottest grazes, that's the case we just said. The toy doll You would have to bring bread for the toy doll. But says you don't bring bread in such a case. What do I do? So what holds like the owner I would No, no, no, no, no, there's another man doll. We we brought. Ready holds like not like a that if you find the second one, you find the original. We'll do it again here with this. This was the original. You put this aside for a hottest. It it got lost. So you bought number two. And then number one shows up. Now you have two of them in front of you. What do you do? Ready holds that you shut the one, either one, but the other one must die. Oh. The other one must die. Then this bread That's why says in that case there's no bread. Hello, now what is the case? You say goes like ready. The what? When you have two of them in front of you, you shut one, the other one must die. So what's the case of grazing? Where in the world does he graze? So there is a case. The If the Oh. Let's go through the three cases. Case number one is you set this aside as a hottest. It got lost. You brought You bought another one. Now, case number one is this guy came back. So you have two in front of you. Case number two is this guy did not come back. You shut this guy. And then this guy comes back. That's a case That's a classic case where this guy must die. According to everybody, this guy must die. There's a third case. That from day one I brought two for bonus to be something to do with this. I only have to bring one hottest, but I brought two and I said one of them is in a house. If something happens to one, I'll have a second one. Oh, in a case like that, according to ready, you're not going to You're not going to kill him. You're not going to kill the second one because you brought both of them on condition that I'm going to use one. Here is the right. So you can use one or two. That's That's a case where you send it to land. You let it go graze in the following them. Because you brought both of them as a race. Let's go tomorrow into the land. But here's a case where by the hottest it goes grazes. What's that going to be in again? Call if by the hottest it grazes. I'm just I'm just going I'm going 13 lines in the top. The toy doll In that case, the toy doll would require bread. No, but we're just saying that according to it doesn't require bread. Well, that we toy doll ain't going to let him. There's a problem a contradiction to all of us. Silent rule. So we must say all of us should be really. We all must hold that what The hottest Mesa. There's no ifs, ands, and buts. This The five hottest always die in all situations. Even in the situation where I bought two as a and I brought them to be something to do with this. If you're going to shut number one, number two must die. If you shut number two, number one must die. Oh. I, what about the second part of the royal? Now, there's also such thing as grazing. Cuz in all cases, every hottest must die. So which hottest is going to go graze? There is no such thing. You're right. According to they never graze. I says that if it grazes, it it requires bread. He never He never said that. Call the toy doll He only said one line. If the hottest must die, there's no bread. He never spoke about a situation where it grazes. What we said earlier. The owner All of them are hottest. This is the one that says you can have with the lot of the And he says no way. There's no There's no bread for the because why? Because by the hottest in such a situation, the lot of the hottest according to must die. That's That's one of the five hottest that must die. So the same situation by toy doll, there'll be no bread. If you have a offspring of a toy doll, there's no bread. He says there is bread. And comes along there's no bread. The lie. Okay. The boy said another thing. All my apple. If a person says this toy doll bread, this is the toy doll this is the bread. What if the bread got lost? It's not a big deal. Go buy more bread. Of the toy doll, but what if the animal got lost and you made me toy doll errors? You can't bring another toy doll to go together with this bread. It's forbidden. Why? Because the animal not the bread. The toy doll. The The The bread goes for the toy doll not the toy doll for the bread. There's the The bread is the bread. The like to say on this. They say toy doll that you're supposed to eat. You heard this word. You're supposed to eat in order to dive in well. You're not supposed to dive in in order to eat. So we have two of them. Oh. 27 minutes and we're turning bay and bay is a record for young people. You need toy doll. Two of them. If a person sets aside money and he says this money is for a toy doll. Think about it. If he says this money is for a toy doll, could he buy the toyda breads with that money? So the Gemara yes, if he has leftover money, first he buys the toyda, if he has leftover money, he can buy the bread. But if a person sets aside money, says this money is for the toyda breads, he cannot buy toyda with it because toyda is not included in breads. Bread is included in the toyda, that's what he just said. The iker is the toyda. So the breads come after, they come because of it. Maybe by a ham lachem, if you have leftover venitoise we have change, you can buy with a bread. But what if he put aside money and he said le lachmi toyda, this is only for the bread, venitoise we have leftover money, hey, maybe venitoise is not permitted to buy the actual carbon with it. Why? By dima. Eilema, eilema mishum d'Rav Kahana, perhaps it's because of Rav Kahana, Rav Kahana d'nai lachmi toyda shani ikri toyda. How do you know that the breads of a toyda are called a toyda? Shnei mar ve ikri l'zeh, ha toyda l'chales. It says it in a funny way, ha toyda l'chales, that the the the the toyda is called bread. Matzah is. Yochid chinami, okay, so the toyda is called chales, chales is called toyda. Yeah, but lachmi ikri toyda, toyda ikri lachem. The bread goes follows the toyda, so it's called a toyda, but the animal is never called a bread. The bread is called a toyda, but the the the animal is not called bread. Okay. So now we have a sugia of the the world's biggest shlamazel. V'amar Rava, heifrish todah v'avad. He set aside a todah and ran away. And he so he went and he bought a second one. What happened? V'avadah, and it also ran away. V'chazar v'heifrish acheres acheres. He's not the biggest shlamazel, he has stories that are even better than this. Okay, so now what happens? V'nimtzu shnayhem shnayim she has all three animals in front of him. V'arishlash t'mimim zeh, now all three of them are there. This sugia mamesh passed over here, that he he lost his todah, bought another one, lost that again, bought another one. Okay. And as mazel would have it, all three show up. So here they are, right here, all three. So now we're sugia, right? The yellow one, thank you Hashem, one is the number one. He would that was the that was the original. Let's push the button here, look what happens. He has a kaparah, in other words, he shechts number one. What's number two? Number two was instead of number one. What's number three? Number three was instead of number two. So number two for sure doesn't get bread. Why? Because number one had bread. And number one number two is instead of number one, so the bread was taken care of through number one. But what about number three? Number three is far removed from number one. Number three has no connection to number one. So number three shecht, but you have to bring breads for number three. What if you shecht number three? Number one is far removed from number three, so you would have to bring breads for number one. But not number two. What if you shecht number two? One and three are connected to two. So both one and three would not need breads. Let's see inside. This guy brought us shnayim shnayim in the turn of lachem here. You see? Empty basket, no bread. Shlishis turn of lachem. Three doesn't need bread because three has nothing to do with one. This guy brought us shlishis, what if we do the opposite? Here we do kaparah with number three. Here we go. Where is it? New. Boom. Bread everywhere. So number three had a kaparah, so this bread he brought bread. Shniya ein lo todah lachem. Number two doesn't get a bread. And number one does get bread because one has nothing to do with three. V'shniya ein lo todah lachem. B'emtza is what? Here's another case. The middle one you shechted and you brought breads together with the middle one. Ah, so the middle one took care of one and three, the middle one is connected to them both. B'emtza is shnayim ein lo todah lachem, one and three don't need bread. Abaye says no, Abaye omer v'Abaye omer v'Abaye omer m'han shnayim ein lo todah lachem. It doesn't matter because two comes because two was instead of one, and three is instead of two, so in essence three is instead of one. They're connected, they're all connected. Three is for two and two is for one, so three is instead of one also. So am ein lo what? It doesn't matter which one you use, even if you if you do a kaparah with number one, you would you not have to bring bread for number three. Kulhu chalifin had d'dinihu, each one is instead of the other one. Omer Reb Zeira, v'chein dini chatos. Reb boy says mamesh easy easy stuff. Mamesh the whole daf, everything is easy. The same exact halacha would apply with the chatos. The what? If you have two chatos and you shecht one, what do you do with the second one? It has to die. So what if you brought one, it got lost, so you bought a second one. The second one got lost, they brought a third one. So if you shecht number one, number two must die. But number three doesn't die because number three has nothing to do with one. So what do you do with it? It has to graze. If you shecht number three, three and one have no connection, so one must graze, but two must die. What if you shecht the middle one? Both of them must die. Let's see the chart. Here you did the thing, great. New. Ah, three chatos. If you shecht the number one, you did a kaparah with number one, so number two must go into the keeper and die. And number three grazes. It's all on a four. Love the fact he has knees and everything. Same applies if you if you shecht the number three, so number two dies, number one grazes. What if you shecht number two? Both must die. Because they're all connected, one and three are connected to two. Inside Reb Zeira, v'chein dini chatos, same halacha applies to chatos. Heifrish chatos v'avadah, you set aside a chatos and it got lost, v'avadah, v'avadah, and you set aside another one. Instead of it it got lost, v'heifrish acheres acheres, and then you set a third one. V'nimtzu shnayhem shnayim she have all three in front of you. V'arishlash t'mimim dies. All three are here standing. This guy brought us shnayim shnayim. If you got a kaparah with the first one, shniya tomos, the second one must die because the second one is instead of the first one. Shlishis which has no connection, the third one has no connection to the first one, teira, it should graze. This guy brought us shlishis, the same thing with the reverse. Got a kaparah on the third one, shniya tomos, the second one which is instead of the third one, I mean the third one is instead of the second one, so am ein lo tomos, the second one must die. V'rishon teira, the first one must graze. >> [snorts] >> This guy brought us b'emtza, and if you do a kaparah with the second the middle one, shnayim ein lo tomos, one and three must die. As the toyda, he comes along again and says listen, it doesn't matter. Three and one are connected. Why is there a three here? Because there's a two. And why is there a two? Because of the one. So one and three are connected. Therefore, if you shecht one, even number three must die. Kulhu chalifin d'dinihu. As the Gemara in my v'chein, why I have to tell another case of chatos when it's actually the same thing? M'al the same mahasam with the ikla mima maran v'toyda tzu. By the toyda there's a concept of saying I want to give more shecht to the Ribono shel Olam, so I'm bringing more toyda, great. Al achas d'rachamim v'chatos tzu, it's also for you to bring more chatos, you only bring a chatos when you're doing an aveira. Eilu v'eilu, maybe they're not connected. They are connected. Mashma l'on that they're both the same, toyda and chatos are all the same. Tanya Reb Chiya. So now we have a Reb Chiya that says something and it's interesting. The Gemara is going to try 15 times, 15 different ways to see if we we have a eitza for Reb Chiya. And that's going to go all the way to tomorrow on daf kuf alef amud alef, which is actually today, I'm going to give it today, all the way to the bottom kuf alef amud alef. So basically to a whole amud and a half over here. What's the case? Simple simple case. Toyda sh'nis'ara b'tmurah umaysa achas min Reb boy says here we go. A guy brings number one toyda. Then he goes ahead and he makes a tmurah. What's a tmurah? He says I want this to be instead of this. He likes this guy more, he he thinks it's nicer for the Ribono shel Olam to have number two. That's this is the right, it's called tmurah. One one of them is a is a tmurah. Number two is a tmurah. Now he he he got mixed up. He doesn't remember and it got mixed up. So now I have numbers on these, but we don't know the numbers. They all look the same, they're all mixed up, we don't know. One of them got lost. Boom. So I'm left with number one, great. I don't know if this guy is a kosher guy or this guy is the original guy. Is this guy a tmurah or not? What's the difference? Tmurah, no bread. No bread with the tmurah. I have to shecht it, but no bread. If this is the original, this is my real toyda because I came on a plane from America to Eretz Yisrael and I want to bring the Ribono shel Olam a toyda because I I crossed the ocean and the desert and everything, and you hold like the shita like 95% of Klal Yisrael that who make gomel, so you would bring one of these. At least the Chofetz Chaim doesn't. That's his problem. So you would bring two two of these and and a carbon. Toyda sh'nis'ara b'tmurah umaysa achas min, one of them died, chaveirta ein lo takanah, you don't know what to do with it. You can't you can't bring it as a carbon. Why? Eich inavin, what should you do? Na give lachem b'hadar, if you're going to bring the bread with this guy number one, perhaps it's not a real toyda, how are you going to bring bread with it? Na give lachem b'hadar d'ilma tmurah lo na give lachem b'hadar. If you're not going to bring the bread with it, d'ilma toyda lo na give lachem b'hadar. How can you bring this without bread? Says the Gemara, let's just understand the question, then we'll try to solve it. Solve it in 15 different ways. Eich inavin, eilu amar lai, if he said I accept upon myself, so that's different. Why? L'sagi d'mei'si, then you're going to if you accept upon yourself a total, then you must buy another total. So you're going to buy another total in the store and then what's the Oh, I have to be magnanimous. I have to be magnanimous. I forgot the very important thing. If one of them died, this is this is problem. What if both of them are in front of us? One is a tomorrow, one is not and they got mixed up. What do I do? Very, very simple. I bring the bread, but I make a condition. If number two is my real one, the original one, then the bread goes to number two. And if number one is the original one, then the bread goes to number one. That solves all issues. I don't have any issue. Cuz I could bring the bread and one of them is going to get the bread on the condition. But what happened was one of them died. So but but I said I accepted upon myself a total, so I'm going to have to memorized bring another one. I bring another one. Then I do a condition. I say, if the the the this is the original number one is the original, so the bread is going to go with the original. If number one is a tomorrow and I can't bring a bread to it, so the one the second one that I bought is going to be a new total and this is the bread of the new total. You don't have a life. So can't be that I accepted upon myself let's say you bring another animal and you should bring bread and he shall say, if the first one is tomorrow, so the second one is an is an original total and that's my bread. Number two is my original. But if the first one is the real total, this is its bread. The heart and number two, the second one that I bought is just a rise. Just as a backup. So the tomorrow okay, you're right. The whole question is problem is let's see he didn't say I really like. He said this this should be my total, then it got mixed up. Then I don't have to buy another one. There is no reason for such a situation. I don't have You asked me you should go to the store and buy another one. I don't have to. And if I don't have to, I can't. One is on the other. I can't use the second one instead of the first one. There's no reason. Simon, this is I think the longest Simon and Shas. Just to remember you have to be a genius. Simon, we move the meters a lot. Made them say, in front of Rebbe, in other words, Levy said in front of Rebbe, let's see he should bring bread and he should say, he have the kind of total he all of them all. He love it all. He love it. All right, so we got this guy in front of us. We don't know is this guy a tomorrow which does not require bread or this guy is the original total and it requires bread. Bring bread and say tonight. If this is the original give all the here's two breads 40 breads, great. And if this guy is not the original, this guy is tomorrow. Okay, so the bread will go back to the store. So the more you can't do that. Why? It's also for you to bring coolin into if if it's not if this is a tomorrow then this comes out of this bread is not total bread. This is just regular angel bread. Angel. Berman. You're not allowed to bring Berman bread into the base of migdos. Another question. The lazy behavior so bring another one. And say he have the kind of tomorrow he all of them all. Okay, so this is the problem one. Number one is the problem one. Bring a number two and bring bread and say like this. If number one is a piece of tomorrow, then I'm going to use number two. So I have a great total and bread. Total with bread. He have the kind of total he But if this is the total, all of them all. The heart of Islam. I'm going to bring number two as a Islam. Wow. So I have a question for the island. Think about this for a second. Tomorrow we don't say miserable the side. Why don't we say miserable the side? Because on Pesach you're not allowed to bring a total. Why can you bring a total? The whole we don't say miserable the side. Why not? You're not allowed to bring a total on Pesach because part of the total is comments. You can't bring comments on Pesach. So why not Pesach? Because part of the day you can't eat comments. You can only eat comments in the morning. And from this man you're not allowed to eat comments. So I'm lessening the time of me eating the carbon total. Even though I could finish it. I'm not allowed to do that. I'm not allowed to bring a carbon knowing that I'm going to be able to eat it less time than necessary. Oh, knowing that now we can understand why I can't make number two a Islam. If this is not a total to be Islam. Well, a total you can only eat for one day. A Islam you can eat for two days. But now I'm going to have to be just in case that this is actually a total. I don't know if this is a total or not. I I brought it as a as a condition. It could be a total. It could be a Islam. But on the side that it's a total you can only eat it for one day. So even if it's a Islam I have to be and only eat it for one day instead of two. That's also because I'm lessening the time that I'm allowed to eat it. You have the kind of total he Sorry. I'm a Levy. No. Michelle I'm a Levy also Rebbe tells Levy Michelle to come and might be all of them all. Because he's lessening the time that you're allowed to eat the Islam. I'm a Levy and the Rebbe. I had a good shot. I think it's a good shot in middle shear before. It came to me. I hope it's right and not I'm a rat. It's Over here the more says Levy tells Rebbe. Says Rashi didn't Levy tell Rebbe before? We said the made them is Levy who told Rebbe. Oh, says Rashi because Levy was talking privately to Rebbe. Asks Levy to Rebbe the lazy behavior you should bring an animal and bread and you should say he have the kind of tomorrow he If this guy number one is the tomorrow which is nothing, all of them all. So number two will be the total. And all of them all this is the bread. We have the kind of total he but if number one is the original total, so what am I going to do with the number two? All of them all the bread goes with number one. The heart of them all is the total. This should be the leftover of the total. All of them all Rebbe didn't like this at all. Came and do my knee. She don't mind because I love this lotion. I used it many times. Came and do my knee. She don't mind. I I it seems to me that this guy is brainless. He doesn't have a brain. Brainless. I like it too much. Sometimes I use it on my kids. Not good. I go like this to some of my kids. Not going to hollow. Came and do my knee. She don't mind. It seems like it's hollow. There's no brain in it. How could you say such a silly thing? The human efficient resource. Can you uh uh a leftover animal if it's leftover if it's leftover you have no choice but to bring it and say this is the leftover. Uh either it's a good total or it's a leftover. You can't do that. So first of all, it occurred to me in the other shear and it could be this I don't know. It seems so simple. Then maybe that's why Rashi points out that it's Levy in front of Rebbe that was private. That's what Rashi says. It was private. And the mail law it makes sense now. What's the lotion? Levy. Rashi's pointing out that it was private because he embarrassed him. He wouldn't do it in front of other people. He yelled at him but in private. And then [snorts] we'll just do one more here. He also he says that 80 into an office unbelievable. He should bring an animal and bread and he shall say, where's my bread? Oh, brings this bread. If this one the original number one is a tomorrow, so then this guy all all of them all. Great. So number two is the total and the bread. He have the kind of total he but if number one is the actual total all of them all. This is the bread. The heart What about number two? What about tomorrow? This should be in the exactly like it. It should be tomorrow of it. What's the problem? He just did it. It's the reason. All of them all I need money. No way. I bought my car you're going to tell him to to get 40 miles and it should be kosher. No way. You don't tell a guy to do something like that. Why should he do to make something tomorrow? Not a good idea. So for the rest of the ideas we're going to have to do the next shear. Have a wonderful Merit the source of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shear today. mdy.sponsor.com or [email protected].