CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 62 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

Here [music] [screaming] we go. How do you do forget? How do you do? What's the process? So, I'll show you in a second. We have a little bit of a video. Very to show the whole thing. We know the imm like the skirt steak, the the kidneys, the fats. So you take that, you put it on the hand. Boom. And the the the breast and the the thigh go on top of that. And anytime there's bread like by the you put it on top of all the way on top. Sorry. Where do you where do you see this thing with the bread on top? Where do you get idea? You find it by the Okay. There's a ple here. You take the and you put it where on top of everything. So just like we find by the million we do this so too in the rest of the now going back to the original thing that the the the are on top of the where do you see this we have a contradiction in the on the one hand it says where do you put the on the top you'll be the problem is it says says the fat goes on top the is on top of the he brings it from the let's just see the for a second. So, right next to them is Bea. There's an area in the outline over here with all the rings in the in the floor. That's where you you uh today they have this uh box that cost a couple hundred,000, grabs the animal, flips it over, and it can't move, and it extends the neck. But in those days, it was a hard thing. You have to knock the animal down and grab its neck in one of these rings. But next to the rings, you'll see the the granite tables, the marble tables and different uh places that you know surfaces that you could cut up the animal. So you bring the imam from there and then check this out. It's very k number one. [music] That's the blue. And on top he puts the tail. Now he takes it and he gives it the clay number two. So what happens? Oh, when he [music] when he flips it over, the come on the bottom and the on topic. All right. Now, when he gives it to the guy that's going to do the it go, it it flips over and he does And this is super important to see this the end of it says the as you go into the the are on top of the the video that we just saw was the opposite of on top. So says there's there's a step missing from the video. Karina, check it out. Now, now I'm going to show you the full thing. Sorry, I I I cut it like this. So, you'll just have to appear the on the bottom. Last one in. [music] First one out. That's part number two. Now, the is up top. And the are on top. Oh, they do. But you [music] forgot there's a play number three. And when they flip it over, I don't know how you say life, but the kids are now on the top. [music] Good. Total and says good morningelcome to have a lot of people doing the mitzvah like by you know at least the lites. All right. So we're going to see like this. There are four possibilities where to put the bread. What are the possibilities? Let's think about it. On top. What else? On the bottom. >> What else? On the side. >> The side. Where's the fourth place? >> Fourth place. Our boys. You're not going to believe it. >> Over here. >> Like this. So, we have fouras here. Where do you put the bread? would mean this. It means that this is on top of this. It's on top of the bread. That's what it means. Okay. The says you put the sheep on top of the bread. No, [clears throat] this goes on top. The bread is on top. No. So what do we do here? It seems like the bread's on top of the sheep. A lot of words to say the same thing. The problem is now we have a it's like it's like even it's evened out. It's it's a contradiction. I don't know which one is on top. I see in other places that the bread is on top. Where do we see the bread's on top for the second time? We saw the before. The bread was on top. So, we're going to go bread on top. No, no, no, no, no. The bread is not on top. The sheep are on top. So, why does it say two sheep? [clears throat] If you recall, we're talking about we had a whole sug and we spoke a lot about these other that come together with the we focus a lot on the but look over here. What's missing from the right side? The right side. If you weren't here on Friday, what's missing? What? We have seven sheep on the bottom. We have a bull. What's missing? What carbonas are missing here? The snake. Vasimalum Josh. No, it's a trick because you see two sheep, but you don't realize they're two rams. Those are not two sheep. So what's missing are the famous two sheep. So what he's saying is what's the lion the two sheep meaning the bread the everything's on the two sheep and not those other carbonas not the seven only the two get but not the seven people say that is from that. What he does is he puts it literally like this. Now, what's the problem with this? Well, it's a little loud. The problem is it's kind of gross. How you going to eat that? There's a guy, oh, why why does he say this? Look, if I put the bread right over here. So I have the bread is on top of this leg right over here. But also I have the leg on top of the bread. So I have on top of the and I have on top of the says the author of the king. You're not going to give a king bread that that was laying in that area. Now to put it on top is also okay that we could uh so he is a fourth. We had already a on top. We have a shita on the bottom. We have a over here and now he says on the side. Say side. Ask where do you come with next to you need on top of not next to it says the word means next to not on top you thought it means on top I'll bring you two right the we all know if I asked everybody here in this room we all know the where does the the of the go everybody knows this where does it go on top of of the breads or next to the breads? >> That's one sheet and that's what we uh that's what we typically talk about. It's next to it says put on top of we go with it's next to it's not on top. Who told you? Maybe be just read it the regular normal way. Al means on top. Where's the paras? The paras is a curtain. This week's parachute. That's what he was saying. Rabbi Schwarz, he's trying to he almost said that. Where's the paroas? The is not on top of the look at the we see the iron very clearly here. This is the with the crew of him on top. I don't see a paras on top of it. I see a paras next to it. So over here means next to. So too it means next to not only is super easy. It's a a three minute. What's this up and down business I'm I'm showing. Why am I doing this? I'm doing this to the one who who's in charge of all sides of the world. Over here is not wind. is sides. >> Directions. Thank you. And according to Rashi, not here, it means in all four directions. That's why we do all four directions when we shake. That's later on. You're you're trying to make a statement. We're doing this for the He's in charge of said You go in all directions to stop the bad. This is winds, the bad winds. But to stop whatever the the things that come from different places. Sometimes it's winds. Sometimes it's metal. The point is that it stop these things. The bad the bad winds. That's why we do all directions. We'll have more this year because the lul is similar to the line. >> I did. I missed the line. You're right. I missed a very important line. the the the things that are not are the piranas meaning the the when you to do to do the if you don't do nuva you didn't do you still you still carbon you don't have to bring another carbon but that side thing the called it that helps our life that's gets rid of the piranas the mitzvah is the the the leftover of the mitzvah the side point of the mitzvah the main part of the mitzvah is the carbon the waving is it's like of an answer what's the main thing but the going like this in all directions that's the side point the side point bad or bad does anybody have an English art scroll here this of all directions up and down we do the same thing by He would go up and down with the he would show and he would say there should be an arrow in the eye of the sultan. Says it's not a very good idea to start over because you're going to provoke him. You're going to cause him to to to you don't tell the s I got you. You don't do that to the s. things. It could be, you know, he he provoked him, but the Gmorra in Vas says, and they want to say that he was actually trying to to to make friends with the Sultan this same gave a say and the Sultan there was and the Sultan was so excited by his that that he went and he and he kissed his feet. He's like friends with the Sultan. And also in Kadushian Gumar brings that there was a a sevenheaded snake here. I'll show you the picture from then. This is a sevenheaded shade and they they didn't know what to do. So they called Ravaka and Ravaka he did um every time he bowed one of the heads fell off. So I asked Yoshi to redo it tonight. So I didn't see it yet. I think this is it here. He put it in. I said, you know, you already you already have it. Let's see what AI could do. And there's like just in a few minutes. Boom. All right. When you What's the You guys remember? We have to remember this. What is it? The two the two sheep that we bring on they they require after after the And you do it complete whole like this completely. This guy's dead. You do as is, not parts of him. Not the entire thing. You don't do the whole thing. Just the that's it. And they also very very simple concept just scary words but the idea is very simple means I'm going to learn the concept of tanufa from from you. Now I could stop or I could continue. I already learned the concept of and I'm going to learn that I also have to do the entire animal. Or I could say no, I'm going to learn the concept of and then I make up my own the side are not so important. I say oh just the that's the top line over here means I'm going to learn everything. I'm going to once I learn let me learn the whole thing all the side of as well. So over there it's also it's it's the entire animal by us also or no stop. So what does it say? Very very simple. I already explained this whole we'll just read it inside. I want I'm going to learn all the I'm going to learn the main thing of plus I'm going to continue on and learn those side things. I'm going to learn from an individual that requires after. So that's number one, the main and then I'm I'm going to continue learning by individual it it's only certain parts of the animal, not the entire thing. So too it's only you stop short. You learn the main then you stop. We require the of the community just like the of the individual. In other words, but you stop and you say it's only the entire thing. No, no, no. There's no argument in that. Everybody holds you learn all that time. However says you do the entire thing because we are going to learn from the what do you do because that's the only thing that the gets as a gift you want to do the entire thing because that's what the entire thing is the you stop short there's a there's a that say the talks by it says it's also the okay so I want to remind was super simple we have three types of carbonas here and three alas each carbon only gets two out of the three alas so on top we have the he gets the look at the top the gets two al the blue circle and the green circle what's the blue circle that you do. You lean on it while it's alive. Well, obviously. And when it's alive, you lift the animal as it's alive. What is it missing? The red circle. What's a red circle when it's so just easy to remember. Green is go. Red is stop. Red is bad. Green is good. So, when it's alive is green when it's dead, it's dead. It's gone. It's red. Okay. Let's take over here. Shay. of individual has blue and red. What is it missing? That you don't do when the animal's alive is the green circle and the red circle. What is it missing? The blue circle. So what the gumar is going to do here is going to do the same exact kav three times and say the same exact answer. Kav is very simple. Let's say we just what did we just speak about the uh the sham. So it has green and red. What's missing the blue? Oh, if it has the green certainly should have the blue. No, no, no. There's a puzzle that says it doesn't have the blue. Okay, great. And then we take the next one. If it has the blue and the red, it certainly should have the green. No. Okay, it has. Let's see inside. Let's see how long this takes us. There's three carbon. And there's three when it's alive. It's dead, green, and red. And each one has two. And a third thing it doesn't have. This is what it is. Sorry. These are the three brothers and it doesn't have we already this. I'm just reading it. Now it's first. Let's talk about the sham is blue and red. What is it missing? That you don't do. You don't lift it when it's alive. It's missing the green. as it should have the green also. It should you should have to lift it when it's alive. Why? If you compare the the yuck to the to the what's the missing? Look over here. The tur has green and red. It's missing blue. You don't do. So if the they don't have the blue, they're missing the blue, but yet they have the green. So individual you have to do it has the blue certainly should have the green it should have when it's alive and the says no you can't do it because there's a word in the tells you you can't do that does not get when it's alive [clears throat] the same exact just we're changing the circles How come it is that the the community meaning on you don't do at all? They're missing the blue circle. They should do it because of now he's doing the reverse. The individual doesn't have the green circle. Doesn't do the when it's alive. If it has the green certainly should have the blue or so the answer is slightly different. We know from our from tradition we know that there's only two community carbonas that require and that is the on third question the top guy that has a blue and a green circle what is he missing the red circle doesn't have when it's when the animal's said the the does not require when it's alive the green yet it has the red. So, how come? Okay, we have a seal. We have a five people are they bring one carbon. Who does the one person does the for everybody else? and a woman and the does for the woman. If you were to send your carbon from don't don't close cuz this is a video does it for him. Here it goes. >> This is where we part ways. I have a business meeting I can't cancel just to sacrifice you in the mikdash. I'm sure you'll manage. Good luck. >> Yi Shakar. It's not our full-time guy. is our weekend guy. [music] There's going to be people. >> David, we really want to close the deal with you. You seem like a very serious man. >> Hello. Who is this? The Cohen, your corban has arrived. Oh, I missed him. He's gotten so big. I'm going to do the tonfa with it for you and want us to take a selfie. >> Yes. Come on. Tahal to raise it. Lower it. Lean it forward. Bring it back. Come on. [laughter] >> Anyways, selfieing the I'm not a big fan, but that's what we had. Raoai have a wonderful week for coming. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor atmop.com.