CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 6 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Wherever you are in the world live from part city, Utah. Here we go. We're holding on. What do we have yesterday? We had B. It says the word. The Gar asked why do we have to say it again? says the Gar comes to teach us that if an animal has a tra it's one of these things that the animal won't get to live according to moshas for more than 12 months it has a punctured lung a hole in the heart different things uh the the spine is severed won't survive won't survive an animal like that you're not permitted to bring as a carbon in the B mikdash ask the why do I need a pos and That's the whole today back and forth. I need the P because I can't learn from but I have aimer why not what's I can learn a very it's very very simple this if an animal that has a blemish which you're allowed to eat on chabas you're allowed to eat on the weekday but you're not allowed to put it on the misbay so certainly this guy right over here that has a hole in his stomach which you're not allowed to eat an animal that has a trao so certainly you shouldn't be able to put on the misbay Uh the guy on the right you're allowed to eat probably the left you're not allowed to be ba the guy on the left the tra certainly should be awesome love it then said what's the lion because I looked it up I can't find it here oh shaft I could not find it anywhere in chass looked it up today couldn't find it maybe you'll find Maybe it's spelled differently. The is what if I have a good answer on your so then I need a but what's the good answer? So we're going to bring all these we're going to try to bring a good answer and we're going to knock it down. Knock it down. The bottom line I have aimer. So why I need a at the end the says here that's why I need a because the is no good says you know what are you telling me you're saying logically speaking if something is for a private person to eat it certainly should be user for Hashem so to speak. How can you bring this animal to the B mdish when you yourself can't eat it at your shabas table? You can't eat it at your barbecue. It's a traa. We know that they check for holes in the heart. They won't sell it. They'll sell to you bring it to the misb. Wait a minute. I have something I have a few things here. The brings chabas something you're permitted to do for the misb. You're not allowed to do it privately. You're not to sh an animal on chabas. We allow an animal on chabas for the mdash for the misb themed you twice a day the says the I would say also it might be awesome for a private person to eat but it's who told Don't bring me a ride from Shabas because Shabas the whole idea of not being Shabas. Once in a while you allow to be Shabas. Like I was a sandic at my son's uh my grandson I should say my grandson's bris. My son had a son or my daughter-in-law had a son in Miami three weeks ago. Mamesh less than three weeks ago on Chabas Chabas. Oh so Chabas goes away. Don't bring your arriv what what do you mean shabas shabas for mil is not a private thing is a mitzvah commanded it it's not it's not you're not benefiting anything from the mil guy here yesterday I don't even know his name was his name zupnik or maybe I'm confusing with somebody else but he became vu when he was 43 years old and he described that he had had a bris meal then 43 had a get a brisk I'll tell you the reason you can't bring a ride from Shab is because that's how we do the mitzvah there's no other way to do it but bringing a carbon I could do it without bringing a tra I could bring a good healthy animal I don't need I don't need to bring a but on chabas I have to shift an animal to to get a carbon let me prove it from what's putting flax and wool together. You're not weave them together. See here, he's weaving them together. He takes the wool, makes a thread of it, and then he takes the two threads and puts them together. That what you're not allowed to wear. In fact, if somebody comes over to you in middle of B and tells you that your pants are shot, you have to remove your pants in front of the whole. There's no cover breeze when it comes to but they use where the of the belt of the no once in a while even for an individual where you could wear a flax bead and put on wool titus on the corners and that's madness and it's says the same thing we said by you're doing it for yourself the command you to wear this belt that's the way to do the mitzvah I can't bring a from it the reason why I need a to tell us that a is I can't learn This was something me personally when I was a child it caused me trauma this mad but it's so simple in fact if you if you do it on in a chart it's just like wow we have three things here actually it's two things we're going to go in a circle it's like a catch 22 we're trying to prove that something that's also to a individual ual should be for the says let's learn from Malik that what I when I kill a bird in the B mdash with my thumb with my nail so it's for the individual it's for the for the misb so what are we going to say no but the reason why it's not a good is because over there it's something special that as the kills it he makes it to the and and at the same time it comes something special so I'll bring and these are two things that we learned yesterday let me bring from blood is to the individual but here so maybe also or no but blood comes from something that's m the whole animal's Whereas the traa the whole animal is a tra what about malik. So now I'm going to pull out malik. So the combination of these two things I could learn one thing. I'm going to learn that there is a concept where something is for an individual three lines from the top. That's the top thing in this chart. That's the 3:00 on this chart. bring because the whole body of the animal is the whole the whole bird is awesome. It goes in a big circle. Each one has its own but they have one denominator. What's the common denominator? Individual is also to eat something that had and it's also for him to eat blood. But yet they're both and so and that's why I need a pos to say the is also you just have to hold when am I knocking the and therefore I'm knocking the I need a or when am I saying I have a good why do I need a possible take a look at the chart all these things. Oh no, this is the it's red. It's also to the individual. It's to the No, but all of these things the malik that's the only way to do it. The said that's the way you do it. That's the way you sprinkle the blood on my you give to eat so to speak from the blood. I take the tra and I flip it on its head as in this chart. again. We're going back. Why do I need a pic that says not this? Sorry, not this one. I'm trying to get to this one. We don't need to see it, but it's going to play in the background. Why do I need a pic when I have a that tells me that a tra should not be allowed on? Because if a bal a blemished animal is not allowed on this certainly says I'll tell you why. Let's stop it now. You got it. Your whole is from a blemished animal that we didn't have in a very long time. It's that the and the animal are equals. The animal cannot be and the ken performing a cannot be both of them. But a tra is different. A tra don't bring me any ride from a tra because a traa the tra itself can't be about but the performing could be there's no for that has a hole in his heart to perform an animal born with a ceserian will prove it to us together with the balum We'll do like a mad. We'll take the two of them in com in combination. Each one has a problem. You can't learn individually, but the two of them together, they'll help each other out. Each one that has the problem while the other one doesn't have the problem, the other one has this problem, but the first one doesn't have the problem. Boom. Together, we can learn out that what? You're telling me it's such a big milo that a and an animal both are are similar in a but guess what an animal that was born with a but what about a what about a let me ask you a who was born with a can he perform so let me prove from that what that the is to do that but the carbon grave him. You didn't make the is the guy. He's kosher like the animal that you're putting on his which is not kosher. You can't bring a ceserian born animal out of you're allowed to eat a barbecue made out of a cesarian animal but it's also you know what a firstborn animal has but not if it was born with ceserian so you see a weakness in it no what could be aar even though it has a blemish But it's also can also crave him. If he's can't do it can't do that if the animals can't be put on the kids were going again in a circle. We I didn't have time to put it in. Yoshi wasn't feeling well today. We didn't put it in. But you get the circle. Just keeps on going in a circle. Catch 22 so to speak. And it keeps on going in a circle. Each one has its own minus but they have one common denominator that individual can make a barbecue out of it and it's also now once again we have our back that should certainly since it's also for individual it certainly should be also for the so what's the question if so why do I need The reason I need since is different is different than all these things. What there's a case where a is to eat but the other ones don't have is never mut. What's the what's the case that by a tra how do you have a tra once in one time it's mad how when the k takes his thumb with the nail and cracks or severs the spine of the bird that makes the bird a traa then he continues pushing forward and he severs the con the trachea and the sophagus and that's how you kill the bird but before you kill them before you cut the simanim those the trachea and the sophagus are called siman Before you did that, you created a tra here and you're allowed to eat it. Forget the eating. You're allowed to put on for now. We know we don't know about eating yet. We know about what's the case exactly telling me that what kind is it? Also, you can put on what is there's a concept. There's no zakus in a in a bird. In other words, you cannot differentiate physically and it doesn't really matter either way. You can bring a female or a male. Another thing is there's no tamos. There's no such thing as a bird that has a blemish. There is something called that a bird is missing a wing. A bird is missing a a full limb like a leg. That's a problem. But just a blemish is not a problem. Cataract, all these blemishes not a problem. Oh, but the point is that there's a where you could eat. What is the you could eat? There's two types of birds we bring in the entire bird goes on. The whole thing goes but just like an animal you get to eat part of it. The coin gets to eat it. The bird also the coin gets to eat it. But it's a tra the coin went like this with his finger. He made it a tra. You see there's one one case of a tra that's and that's why you can't learn from everything else says but wait a minute is eating right off the m in other words the fact that the could eat it's not the hashem allowed him to eat took it for the misb now once it's ready for the misba now the coin gets to eat from it it's different it's a different way of looking at Finally again let's wrap it all up and this is the end of the I'm telling the end of the why does the have to say to tell me that you cannot bring an animal that has a hole in a heart as a ka I could learn it from logic says you cannot learn it from logic why you're going to learn from a someone that has a blemish look at this bird over here he's all banged up. You could see that he has blemishes. But a traa, we know anybody that ever went to, you have to open up the chicken, you have to open up the the the cow, you have to look at the lung, you blow it up, they blow up lungs, and then they say, "Oh, look, there's a over here. There's a white dot here." The whole It's not something that you notice most of the time cannot learn out from you're telling me that you learn from this. Let's see the P again for the 15th time. This is the P that you're learning from. They have other ones. This is the that we learned yesterday that do not do not bring a carbon from something that can't drink from. And another second, we know that when you have 10 animals, the 10th one goes to but do not include you let them out out of the pen. One, two, the 10th one, you hit it with the red dye. Didn't show it today because we have a lot of other stuff. But if one of them is a tra has a hole in the heart, he's not part of the 10. So you see you can't bring a tra when the animal's born like this but a means the first three years of a tree you're not allowed to benefit not you're not allowed to sell it use it for any sperms at all you must let it rot that's our is if you have a vineyard with grapes, you're not allowed to sew, you're not allowed to plant. According to everybody, it's wheat. But according to most, it's also other vegetables as well. And believe it or not, the learns this from this mash. In other words, and our law is they were born bad. They never had a they didn't have a moment that they were mut whereas a traa he can be a normal animal and also a nail goes into his stomach and then becomes a tra but if it was good maybe it should be kosher that's why I need the second now if I had these because it makes a difference if it became and then you made it it's no good that's like it's it's you try to make iter no But if you made it first and then only afterwards it became at the moment that you made it to nothing wrong with it you I would think that it is oh sure that's what the says the third to tell me that a is to go on the says cannot perform the interesting thing. Now when it comes we said that that corresponds the four of correspond to the four of an animal. You have you have putting it in a cle you have and you have putting it on. So too when you shut we have but guess what could be done by not cannot be done by but what's interesting in this mission to pay attention because the is going to ask it right away so I just want to point it out here from all the and there's many the picks one the sinner let's say somebody walked in the base of his why just start the all did the I'm going to show you what is in a second or somebody that whose parents or relative died that day before the burial they can't do any mitzvah if he performed the bye-bye is a person who is and went to the mikvah that day we'll show you real quickly because we're in a rush what's some stuff bunch of rats eating of them. One of them chokes to death. [sighs] [snorts] So the mouse is dead. So it made the person to this person has to go to the mikvah. Goes to the mikvah and becomes a in other words he has to wait until nightfall until it can become completely tar. Now he's red but he dumps into the water. he becomes purple if the kind is not wearing the bug that he's supposed to wear the clothing that a kind wears if he's a eight clothing if he's a four if he's is in this state of purple no let's do this yeah yeah yeah sorry so a person is he's red he goes to the mikvah now he's purple now he's But he's if he's a Z he has to wait until the following day to become completely tired. It's not enough here. The nightfall comes he's still blue. Now once he gives the he turns green he can he has to bring a carbon. Once he brings the carbon he's completely did not wash his hands and feet. He cannot perform the he's a Jew. Let's say his brothers died during the bismillah. So he didn't do one. So he do one on. So he's he's still doesn't have bris. He cannot do he's sitting down. He's standing on top of any kind of device. He's not standing directly on the floor. He cannot perform the or standing on an animal. Agab he's not an animal. He has to be directly on the floor. He's standing on his friend's feet which are like his feet. It's no it's he performed the instead of with his right hand he did it with his left handle says let's say you did it with your left hand just take everything here I have a bunch of flour take it put it back into the into the bucket and then you start over again and then you do it with your right hand with his right hand but inside the he found a stone So it's not a full kamita as we three fingers with or a piece of grain of salt or a piece of frankincense. It's possible. Why? Why is it possible? If you make too much or too little what's too much and what's too little, let me demonstrate, please. You see this part on top of my hand? That's no good. That makes it possible. Don't say, "Oh, it's more." No, no, no. With your thumb, you got to go like this. Got to knock it down. Okay. With your pink, you go like this. Now, it's nice and almost even. Now, what's it mean? Too little. And that's the problem that we have now because you have a stone in there. It's too little. Notice how my fingers go to the bottom of my palm. See that? would be like this. Your fingers are bent all the way up to each other and you have that little amount. That's no good. It has to be all the way down to your palm like that. That's the says the Why are you telling me and picking one out of all the of the sinner? Why listen? just start from all the because it applies to all the you can't have doing and you cannot have doing and all the other things says it's really in fact this is what was ting and we probably got it from here why shouldn't the sinners require oil and why because we don't want somebody who sinned to benefit. Oh, because you're a sinner, you don't have to spend extra money on the on the frankincense and on the on the It doesn't make sense. And this I realized that this who loves explaining the that's what we started with. I hope Rashi doesn't say because then I'll be a big No, he doesn't say good. [snorts] And why in fact does the not have to spend extra money? You should make him spend extra money. He sinned because I don't want his carbon to be a beautiful. I want it to be a to show, hey, you sinned. You're not bringing a fancy thing here. Let's continue with the same thing should apply to not you bring an animal because you sin. by mistake. He should bring the wine that goes together the liations. Why does it why don't you have to bring the wine? I don't want him to bring a fancy carbon is the one that says I don't want him to have a nice carbon. So if aar or all these people should be cautious why it shows that it's a weak carbon does it who cares there's no oil there's no but no cannot perform so whatever we just said in our we know mimics say the same exact We should bring as an example and you ask me why to say that it goes occur what do you see how come it's not since it says the word which includes all the it doesn't say besides it includes And since it says all includes every single in the world question remains so why in the world do we highlight says the first of we already established doesn't go like that what the first says that if you bring a thought the wrong thought instead of thinking that it's a he thought it's a or whatever he thought the owner that brought the carbon has to bring another one doesn't think that the second also doesn't go like because the first one doesn't go like doesn't go like individual If a does and it's no good, put it back into the pot. What's the problem? Ask the what do you mean? What's the problem? It says in our mission that's possible. Yeah, it's possible until he puts it back in the pot. If he puts it back in, it's kosher. So then what in the world is add the same exact same thing. Put it back in the pot and continue. That's what says put it in the pot. Says put it back in the pot. Then he didn't say different. If you see it and it's in his hand, tell him to put it back in. Problem is it got lost. Can the individual go to his house and fill it up? that you need of the to make it a you can't just go home and grab some flour from your house. So here's the very simple if the got lost a dog ate it. So can you fill it refill it from your house? But the words in the mish don't seem like it. Why? Because it should say go to your house. Go to go home and bring flour. It doesn't say that. What it should say is go home that's what it should say was not talking at all was only talking about the says so what is he saying that if with his left hand he should put it back in the bowl and restart that's what Biser says so why did Rab have to If he's going then he didn't add anything that the whole list of the and all these things we said that also you can put back in the bowl and to restart I would think that was just talking about the left hand versus the other other stuff only have two and a half minutes. Let's see what we can do in two and a half minutes. Why is the left hand when the can't hold all the stuff together and he has to also hold on to the he's allowed to use his left hand. So you see there's an exception to the rule on the left. So to you see an exception that he could do so as we said yesterday is not considered one of the four and now the is going to debate that is when you have a cannot perform the why can't perform the because it's considered and explains because it says we know everybody knows every kid knows that it says by this is exactly the way it is. We don't understand it. Sometimes you don't understand. So since the Torah said it should be like that, that's it. You can't do it any differently. I'm going to tell you that a is now there's two things. There's something called which is a very high level of like when I take an animal I say this should be an so it has the high of something lower level I donated an animal to the md the upkeep of the can sell it they can do whatever they want with it a is in the lower category says wait a minute it makes no sense what you just said you need a because it's in a lower category it was in the higher category you need a what you're telling me is even in the lower category you need a certainly in the higher category for the lower category. Certainly she needed in that. We're gonna have to stop in 40 seconds. when a looks at you don't need it's not considered but you definitely need a why can't we learn from that what that that even is allowed to perform a backyard but you can't learn maybe from we learned oh the famous I'm not going to show it But the famous video, how do you know that there's certain things that once they go on, they don't have to come off even though it's also to put on but they don't come off. And we learned from say no no we learned it from but we just used the bama as anai. Have a wonderful day. [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdyop.com.