Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 49 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky
1,441 views
- Good Morning - 49A - 49B - Have a Wonderful Day! Quiz - Kahoot.MDYdaf.com -- To receive the "Nothing but the Daf" Chazarah Shiur daily via WhatsApp: https://chat.whatsapp.com/FeQFPX1eKOHF6wkOETOuTB MDY presents: "Nothing but the Daf", R’ Eli Stefansky’s MDY (Mercaz Daf Yomi) Shiur in a concise format - all the clarity of the full daf Shiur, with Reb Eli's unique charts and visual aids, without any extras (emails, stories etc.) Perfect for Chazarah or anyone who wants a quick, focused Daf.
Chapters
Categories:Torah/Gemara
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[music]
>> Good morning boys
and I
When you just ask me what was born to
die Boys are here we go.
We're done with memphis
If you recall, let's just go to the
simple
chart that we had. And I'm only bringing
it up cuz we're familiar with it.
But on the right side, we have seven
sheep
and two rams. Two rams and a bull.
The kind goes
grabs
a bull, the two bulls, the two rams. Two
rams.
And
He hops, sorry, he hops the two shalom.
We're talking about the shalom. So let's
go back to this picture. We could if we
have it even over here.
Oh, doesn't doesn't work now.
It works with the mouse only.
No, I don't have it here. Okay.
But you know what we're talking about.
We're talking about this whole thing is
talking about the two
carbonas that we use on shalom.
What?
Oh.
Now, instead of grabbing the two sheep
that are year old, he goes ahead and he
grabs the two rams
on the side.
Yeah?
It's in there. Okay, good.
He He grabs the two
sheep and says to himself that it's
alom. That it's the It's the
two-year-olds.
But it's shalom today.
And the the rams are also for the snail
of them.
The rams are for the snail of them and
the sheep are for the snail of them. He
grabs the sheep
and he says in his mind that it's rams.
But the rams are oil. And the sheep are
shalom.
But he grabbed the right thing. He
grabbed the right thing, shafted the
right thing. Just in his mind he
switched it to rams.
Shay rim but they all of them are not
liable.
It's okay.
But the owners, who who are the owners
in this case? The tzimbu.
I also have to bring
two more sheep.
All my lay rob.
So he says rob all of all of them.
No, it's good. Why? You grabbed the
right thing. It was on the right day. It
was shalom the the snail of them because
snail of them needs seven sheep,
two rams,
two two shalom sheep,
and the bull.
So he did it for the snail of them. Just
in your mind it's a two-year-old, not a
one-year-old. Okay, in your mind it's an
oil, not a not a shalom. But you did it
shalom the snail of them.
I'm a kid so let me explain something
here.
So it's a little interesting how kids
are saying it.
It's what he means. And
it's a lot of kids if he comes to argue
or comes to explain. So let's say he
comes to explain all of his them.
It's not a lot of them all of them all
of them because all of them all of them
all of them all of them all of them all
of them all of them.
He thought that they were rams.
He reverses it here. In other words,
if he thought that it's that that
they're
that they're rams and he shafted it for
the right thing. They they were sheep
and he shafted it for sheep, but in his
mind
they were rams. In other words, he's
trying to do something bad, but he
actually did what was good.
He he wanted to shaft it for rams, but
they are sheep and he
Yeah?
He grabbed sheep,
but he's trying to flip it in his mind,
but he did the right thing.
It's It's No, the Sugya, the
conversation is whether
a
you could be oiker something,
you could uproot something on purpose or
by accident. That's the Sugya, really.
It's not so much In terms of lave, we
don't know if this is lave cuz a lot I
think a lot of it has to do with saying
it
straight out.
Yeah.
Seems like Yeah, in general there's a
machlokes Rishonim, but over here
Yeah.
But from this Sugya, for the most part
we say that he says it. A lot of times
they point out he said it.
I don't know what the bottom line is
with the Rav cuz because Sover Eilim, he
thought
he thought in his mind that it was the
wrong thing,
but it really it really was the right
thing. Ushchatei lishum pesulim, he
slaughtered it for pesulim and they
weren't pesulim.
Shai pesulim lishum pesulim nishchatu.
At the end of the day, he slaughtered
the right thing
with the right thing. Avuha Kosover
Eilim lishum Eilim, but if he in his
mind he he thought it's an Oila and he
slaughtered it for an Oila, but they
were sheep.
Yeah?
If he made a mistake,
if he made a real mistake, not that he
tried to flip it on purpose, but he made
a real mistake, he thought that they
were an Oila and he slaughtered it for
an Oila, but they happened to be sheep,
they happened to be the Shlamim,
then loy. Why?
Akirei betai havei akira.
If
had he known
had he known what it what it really was,
he wouldn't have done it. He would have
slaughtered it for sheep. So, the only
reason why he slaughtered it as an Oila
because he made a mistake.
It was a mistake, a real honest mistake.
Honest mistake says Rav It says Rav
Chisda in Rav that it's it's a bad it's
a it it ruins it. And honest mistake
ruins it. Rabbi Omar Kirubitos Lo Yaveh
Kiru. So now until the Mishnah we're
just going to be talking about this
concept of a Kirubitos. When you uproot
something by mistake,
is it a real uprooting or not?
Omar Ava Mishnah Shmaitin and I have a
question from what we just learned.
What we're going to learn. Hakoyanim She
Piglu Ba Mikdash.
A lot of us had this question and I
don't know if we ever resolved it, but
here's a good answer to it. When a Kohen
a Kohen, yeah?
When he when he takes a carbon and
shochtses it for the wrong thing or for
the wrong time, let's say. He does pigul
in his mind. He says I'm going to eat it
for four days.
Yeah?
What do you tie in a year Kohen? What if
you mess up the shchita on purpose? You
don't like your neighbor.
Your neighbor shows up with a with a
carbon
and he says I want to bring a carbon
toda and you in your mind you say,
"Okay, this is an oila." You mess him up
gishmak and now afterwards you tell him,
"By the way, I I messed it up. Sorry,
yeah?" It was an oila. You have to go
bring another toda.
The halacha has to bring another toda.
So you you cost him 500 bucks. You got
him good for 500 bucks. Do you have to
pay or not?
But it's grama.
Okay, so it says over here.
Hakoyanim She Piglu Ba Mikdash.
A Kohen who thought
he had the wrong intent during the the
shchita that he's going to eat it after
three days, mezidin chayav. If he did on
purpose, you're chayav. You have to pay
or pay.
Ha'asha Yiftach, seems like if it was by
mistake, patur. Betana Ela, pigul and
pigul. But the pigul doesn't work. By
mistake, he did it by mistake. He didn't
realize that it's an oila.
He he thought it's oila. He really
thought it's an oila. He didn't realize
it's a it's a toda.
So he is chayav.
Ha'asha Yiftach, Betana Ela, pigul and
pigul. It really works. Echa Dami?
What's the case? He lay me the yada the
chatas see he become a chashuv baal
shlamim. He knew it was a chatas and
purposely he went and he did a shlamim.
Meaning, he thought himself, "I'm going
to eat this for two days." What does
shalom mean? You have to stick to this.
It's a little bit of a kinage.
Yeah?
I'm saying a little bit of a kinage here
under my breath. I said it and I'm going
to repeat it cuz I realized it flew over
over the radar.
When he when he when he when he said
when the gamora says he thought it's a
shalom, it doesn't just mean he thought
it's a shalom.
He thought I'm going to eat it for 2
days cuz that's part of the pigel.
Pigel means instead of eating it for 1
day as a hatos, I'm going to eat it for
2 days. I shoy him ze the mavo. Why do
you call it shoyg? He did it on purpose.
He went from a hatos to a shalom
deliberately. So, it's amazing.
And the love of shalom shalom shalom.
Become a chashiva lishum shalom. He
thought it's a shalom even though it's a
hatos. It's a real hatos. The guy comes
in and has a sign on it. The famous
yoshi sign, I'm a hatos. And he says
in his mind he thought it's a shalom by
mistake. And he thought that it's a
shalom when he said it's a shalom. We
thought it'd be good and pigel. So, you
see even by mistake you can make
something pigel. Amakira betos, amakira.
So, over here we have a a raya
that
uprooting something by mistake is a good
uproot. It it works.
Amalia Abaya, so comes Abaya and says a
mighty good thing. He says loy loy loy
loy loy loy loy loy loy loy loy loy loy
loy
I like this chab. I don't know why.
I says Abaya, no. That's not what
happened there. I I don't ever write
that a kiyur betos a kiyur that if you
uproot something by mistake it's
considered a kiyur. No, cuz what
happened was he knew it's a hatos.
Become a chashiva lishum shalom. And he
deliberately says it's a shalom.
So, what is he saying? Ah, he's amazing?
No, he's not amazing. Why? Ubay me
mutar.
The reason why it's not amazing cuz his
shoyg is that he thought that this is a
logically okay.
Almost what the Rebbi Simon did right
now.
Rebbi Simon thought also that the cohen
can take a hatos. He didn't really think
it, but if we would push him a little
bit more
uh
on that gun. You know what I'm saying?
The hatos shows up. He says, you know
what? This guy doesn't need a hatos. I
think he really needs he deserves a
shalom. Like he thought in his mind that
he could he He he could maneuver it.
That was the mistake.
So so you don't have a raya whether
akira bashiga or not because there's no
shiga here. It was deliberate. So it's
not an akira bashiga. It was akira
b'meizid. Just it's not considered
meizid because he thought that it's
mutar.
I didn't know that it was mutar.
Most of Rebbe Zeira
The first mishnah in our masechta, but
on amud beis, the Gemara elaborates on
it, brings up the sefta that elaborates
on it. Now what?
When you bring a mincha, you do the
kmitza. Now you bring flour if you're
new to to mincha. Some people just
started now. The flammets, some guy
said, people start today.
Bring a bowl of flour. You stick your
hand in there. You do kmitza. The kohen
does kmitza. He goes like this.
But he in his mind he thought that it's
a different There's different types of
minchas, right? We have here whole whole
bunch of minchas. Actually, this picture
I think made it into the the Gemara,
probably.
Yeah, minchas mareches. Oh, no, no. Why
do I need this? You also have beautiful
stuff here. Let me show you. Check this
out. Let's do this. I almost missed
this.
This is what? This is minchas mareches.
So here we go.
Into the bigger pot with a lot of oil.
>> [clears throat]
>> What's this?
This is a machmas.
No, it's a machmas.
It's a machmas.
>> [music]
>> It's not like a deep dish pizza or what?
It's a minchas. No, this has oil.
I should have really looked what it is.
Tells
a mincha belula. Is it a mincha belula?
And this is a mincha chareva, meaning it
doesn't have any oil.
So when you watch these videos, when you
watch a person doing this live, you know
what he's making.
So when he when he says the wrong words,
doesn't really have an effect on on on
what's going on here, because I see what
he's doing.
Whereas by a behema, when when you're
shechting,
every shechitah is the same. So you
don't know
we don't know what's going on. You can't
see from you don't my savana machicham.
So it says that's what the Tosefta says.
Even if the coin said, "Oh, I'm doing a
belula." when he's actually doing a
chareva, ksheira is is good. The all the
balance this is unbelievable.
It has zero effect. The owner doesn't
even have to bring another mincha.
A mincha is different than a carbon.
If you're doing a a flatter one, and you
did it
kashas, which is a deep fry,
which has a lot of oil, softer,
you can tell what he's doing. It's a
different pot, different everything. She
machmas, you can see that it's a it's a
flat one.
Chareva is belula. And if a guy says,
instead of
you bring a mincha schoyta, a sinner
doesn't put any oil in it,
and he did it belula, he's saying, "Oh,
it has a lot of oil." Machsem
belula she chareva. You see that it has
no oil. Well, you can say whatever you
want.
Because the carbon is different. It's
all the same shechitah.
Same kabala, same zrika.
Now we have to know
eich idami. Yeah, yeah, I hear what you
say.
But let's say he did one.
Let's say he knows that it's a machas,
but he did it on purpose. He tried to do
like an akira
bakavana. What is it called the opposite
of those? Akira be
yediah.
Bakavana. I don't know what the key
machsem Miami. So what? So what if if
So what if you see what he's doing? How
many acres of land? He decided to uproot
it.
He thought it really is what is it? It
really is a thin one of
but he decided in his mind that it's the
thick one and he said it's a thick one.
The top is a real mistake, honest
mistake. The
we know that's a mistake.
It's nothing. It's not a It's not a real
doesn't It doesn't change the status of
this
but I'm not with
it. You could see the only reason why
it's not a real because everybody could
tell. But in general when people can't
tell it
have a cure it would uproot it.
No, what happened was he knew for a fact
doesn't matter. Then he did it on
purpose. He said I know it's a but I
want to get my neighbor good. I'm going
to call it a because it's a good
So what So So if you knew so what what
do I care if everybody else knows he did
it
when you do it with
you do have the power to to uproot it.
So what if everybody knows that he's
doing it on purpose? No.
And
over here they say before means people.
Sorry.
The people are not
When does it work when you change the
the status when nobody else could tell?
When you know when it's a blatant lie.
I look at a at a at a deep fried at a
deep fried thing and I say it's flat.
It's a blatant lie that doesn't work.
You cannot uproot it. So that's the end
of that so you know boys we have a much
easier so you know
I
Every single morning we're being a
carbon tablet. Like we ah
You think about it. We do the daf in the
morning and the daf in the evening. It's
mamish tamid. Tamid should be tamid. Ah.
Seven days a week.
The temidim
If
if you don't have the tamid, you could
bring the carbon musaf on shabbos.
Shabbos, rosh chodesh, yom tov, you
bring a carbon musaf.
One is not dependent on the other. We
continue with the theme of perek
tehillos, this unbelievable perek. We
had such an onus perek. It's so good to
have it.
People mamish thought that the whole
menachos is like this. Like we forgot
where we came from.
We did have like two, three weeks of
mamish agadata and who knows. Okay.
Be'ezras Hashem, we're going to get back
there.
But for now, uh no, this is easy stuff.
This is mamish agadata. So,
the carbon tamid doesn't hold back the
musaf. The musaf doesn't hold back the
the We're talking about things that are
not makeiv. They don't
What's the word? I don't even know
anymore. Inhibit. They don't inhibit
each other.
Has temidim makeiv musaf? No, musaf
doesn't makeiv temidim.
In other words, if you brought the musaf
before the tamid, you could still bring
the tamid. Because uh one is not makeiv
the other.
Does musaf makeiv zman? Let's say you
have a shabbos rosh chodesh.
So, you only have one. You could bring
one without the other.
Does musaf makeiv zman?
Like you would care about boiker.
Like you would care about bein
ha'arbayim. What if the kohanim decided
not to bring it for whatever reason?
We'll see. The gemara has to be daf
kebesha'igeg. Didn't bring in the
morning. Then you could bring one at
night.
You just continue vaiter, you're saying.
That's in this case. By the tamid,
you're right. Oh. By the tamid, you just
continue vaiter. Omer Rebbi Shimon ben
Masya, oh, that's not the gemara. It's
Mishnah Masya. B'zman she'hayu anussim
u'shogegim, it's only when the kohanim
was a shogeg anus. Aval im hayu mezidim,
lo yakrivu keves baboker. Lo yakrivu
bein ha'arbayim.
>> This we have to understand. If they did
it deliberately and they didn't bring in
the morning, don't bring in in the
evening. What does it mean don't bring
in the morning evening? Why not?
The answer is those Kohanim, we punish
them. They can't bring it in the
evening. Other Kohanim should.
Says Reb Shimon, no, if you miss it in
the evening, you don't just
pick yourself up and go home. You make
up what you didn't do in the morning.
You do two shacharis. How you do
shacharis and mincha together?
Why? And he says an interesting lotion
here that the Gemara is going to have to
explain for us.
This beautiful picture of the mizbeach
hazahav.
How did it become How did we inaugurate
it?
By putting ketores on it. It's not an
order. You can't just
put a mizbeach and then basically say,
"Oh, it's kodesh." You have to make it
kodesh. It becomes How it become How
does the kli become kodesh?
By putting By using it. So, a maila, all
the kelim were like that also. The
mizbach ha'olah, the famous mizbach
ha'olah that you you shacht all the
korbanos on. You I mean, you make all
the korbanos it.
Elah betom shel shachar, the the first
the first korban of the day, which is
the tamid, they put the tamid on it.
Boop.
It became chanach.
You're able to use it now. It has
kedusha.
The shulchan ha'panim on Shabbos. And
the shulchan
This button works? Yeah.
Oh, look at that.
Shh.
Ah.
Mamish schmuck.
>> [laughter]
>> Did I just press the button?
This guy's posing for the
Who's that?
That's the mizbechin.
So, lechem ha'panim you put the the
lechem ha'panim on Shabbos,
beshivah
de'arba'ah. Yeah.
Minora
No, no, no.
The first time that they use the minora
became inaugurated by putting on all the
candles.
So this is this is the question that
we're going to deal with. By the way,
I'm a base is very short.
Cboard
is
here the question. We're going to have
to dig into the question. It's not so
partial.
If you have one of the one of the other,
you only have enough for one for carbon
common or
the first thing that comes to
everybody's mind is you only have enough
for common you only have enough for or
or for muscle which one should you do?
What's the obvious answer?
So that cannot be the question then.
So what is the question?
She
why? Now one minute I'm going to ask you
a question with by you. It's not so
partial.
Muscle has a good show. Has a good show
of Shabbos.
Maybe the maybe the good show of Shabbos
over powers the common.
The what? The what?
That's not THE ANSWER THOUGH.
OH,
OH, THAT'S the answer. So we have to say
with the back the tomorrow is just
What does the tomorrow do?
Let's do Kazara here. Tomorrow is just
going through the steps showing you how
we got to all the steps. Obviously we
know the answers, right? Very. We know
the answer. The tomorrow
is just as smart as us at least.
So they're not They just want to the way
they speak it out instead of saying XYZ
they said it in a
lotion of a cashew but they're saying it
well here. Saying it with with the back
to it.
Either way between the new year and the
new year and the new year and the new
year if you have both
and it's the same day she did to me my
duty why? That have a total or make good
as you see that extra word he sticks in
there.
When you bring a common on Shabbos it's
not just a regular common has a good
show. It's common that has a good show.
So it's common
is a common plus
the kedushah.
Hello, to me the mahkom sofen day in the
ah, so this is a beautiful shailah.
You have the tamid for Sunday, but
you're now on Shabbos. So, what do you
bring first? Do you bring the sheep as a
musaf for Shabbos that has the kedushah,
but tomorrow you're not going to have a
sheep for for for
for Sunday, for the tamid on Sunday. So,
what's the obvious question
that everybody asks here?
A mavin olam is a good kasha.
But, it doesn't apply to this case. To
me the hadashah came to other
On one hand, you have toddah for Sunday
morning. I do so I love you kedush. Or
not cuz the Sunday tamid doesn't have
the kedushah of Shabbos. It's a simple
tamid.
And today's musaf has special kedushah
Shabbos. By the way, there's nothing
more kadosh than Shabbos, right? There's
no Yom Tov, there's no nothing that's is
as kadosh as Shabbos. Not Yom Kippur,
not Rosh Hashanah. Shabbos is the top of
the top.
R' Leish he says, "Then he swore we
learned tamid makom musaf musaf makom
tamid." Our mishna we learned
that a tamid doesn't doesn't doesn't
hold back the musaf and the musaf
doesn't hold back the tamid. Let musaf
makom tamid and the musaf can be makom
one another if it's Shabbos or Rosh
Chodesh or Yom Tov. What's the case? You
learn this later in the column.
If you have enough sheep for the musaf
and the tamid, and the the question is,
could you do the musaf before the tamid?
Let's say you did the musaf before the
tamid. Did you ruin anything? But, Tanya
and actually they have a kadosh in the
tamid shacharis and tamid minchah. You
cannot bring anything before the korban
tamid. The tamid always comes number one
in the morning and it's the last korban
out at night. It's the sandwich. You
cannot do anything before tamid, not in
the morning, you can't do anything after
the tamid at night.
And if she did the less light,
the pshat is you don't have enough
animals. You have just enough for one of
the other, either tamid or musaf. What
comes first?
B'di av may, in our mishna, and if it's
the same day, the carbon tamid animals
of a might tell them what could have
started it. Obviously, we're going to go
with the carbon tamid because you do
this every single day. A lot of the lam
we're talking about no, it's we're
worried about tomorrow's tamid and
versus today, today right now, musaf.
Miktani emak says that I'm okay I don't
need you know. So, this answers the
question. When you have
a musaf today
and a tamid for tomorrow, you only have
one animal, what do you do? And the
answer is whatever you want. There's no
they're equal.
I'm going to buy you a note no right.
This is a local you have enough for
both. And the question is
I want to do the musaf first. With the
kashrut of layer double koidem.
We have an official policy that nothing
comes before tamid. What do you mean?
What's your question how can you do a
musaf before the tamid? Mitzvah by
almahu. This policy is telling you
what's the best way to do it. First
comes tamid, then comes the musaf.
Fishman.
And by the machine of the carbon is very
good smell.
Every single day
you have to have at least six sheep
that are checked.
We're going to see soon. You have to
make sure that these sheep don't have a
mum.
So, you check them out. For how long?
For four days.
And it says over here lashon and I want
to point out the lashon now so it'll be
easier later. K'dei l'shabbos What is
k'dei l'shabbos? It should say
l'shabbos v'lisnei yomim tovim sh'rosh
hashana. I need for shabbos, let's say
shabbos falls out on shabbos, which it
does usually.
And on Sunday you have rosh hashana and
on Monday you have rosh hashana. So, you
have three days in a row, shabbos
rosh hashana rosh hashana. Or if you
want to reverse it you could have
th- Thursday, Friday and then shabbos.
Because it's a three-day yontif. So,
that's why I need six. Two for each day,
two for shabbos, two for the first day
of rosh hashana, two for the second day
of Rosh Hashanah. Hey, Adam.
I lay him in this lay
almost all of them
in this lay this lay If you have enough
carbonas for everything to do with them,
so I'm going to have all Think about it.
You You're going to have a total You
need 22. How do you have 22?
You need seven
musaf for each of the Rosh Hashanah, so
total of 14
plus the six to meet him is 20 plus
Shabbos two musafs
is 22. You need a total of 22 animals.
Well, how is six enough for you?
I don't love the less like
Don't worry, he doesn't have enough.
Which one I'm going to meet him at this
thing? How come you chose six? Cuz we
care. We're focusing on the medium.
>> [cough]
>> Thomas comes before musaf.
So the man said, "No, no, no, no, no.
No, I don't like this lay. You have
enough for musaf. You have enough for
your Thomas."
Cuz only for carbon Thomas do you need
to check it.
What money?
I have a question for you.
And this will this will explain the this
this this carrots.
What if you didn't do the four-day
checking?
You checked the carbon Thomas and you
got lucky. It's not a bummer.
Is this a good carbon Thomas or not? The
whole point of checking it for four days
to make sure it doesn't have a bummer.
You didn't.
But
it happens many times you checked an
animal doesn't have a bummer without
checking it. Doesn't have a bummer.
Good or not good?
There is those who say not good.
Not good. No. No, no, no. Because it's a
here to do be cool.
It's not a It's not a It's a toy. We
were
Make sure you have something good. No.
Part of the
of the Thomas is you have to check it
for days.
To see if it has a moment or not, but
it's part of it. It's not It's not a
It's not a um
a practical thing to make sure it
doesn't have a moment. It's part of the
halacha.
>> [cough]
[clears throat]
>> No. Check it for four days. Yes. Each
day the the the Rambam says or the the
different say each day you got to go and
make a take a check. You don't look at
the last day and the first day. Every
day you go and check. It's part of the
halacha. That's what I'm trying to
explain here.
This halacha was said since the Gemara
only by a tamid.
This doesn't apply to a Muslim.
You have to make sure you have a carbon
that is not a valid moment. You can do
check it one day.
There's a four-day checking nom. That's
That's exactly what I'm trying to tell
you over here.
The list guys at loin are by Yamin.
Call them shrita.
And it's only for a tamid. You money?
Then bag bag you. You know you got to
damage your tongue bigger than boy
you're going to shrita. Tamid martish
marula It's a possuk. So once it's a
possuk, you see?
It says by a tamid. Tishmaru la Yamin by
Adam. Well, Adam by Pesach carbon Pesach
says Elohim mishmaris. You should watch
this by mitzrayim. The world tells us
Yisrael Moshe Rabbeinu Elohim mishmaris.
This sheep should be the mishmaris at
the boss of Yamin. So you got to take
the sheep four days before. Not allowed
to be got by Yamin shrita after don't be
got by Yamin call them shrita.
So
you see it's a possuk. It's a possuk by
by tamid. So it tells you this halacha
you have to
check these animals for four days. I'm
going to go to Rashi. How does she show
when you get sick should have a It's
actually seven. I forgot to tell you all
she could fix it. Like this after the
laws of shabbat. So how are you going to
have a sheep on Tuesday morning? You're
coming off a three-day yom tov. Where
are you going to find that sheep? How
are you going to check it?
So you need extra one for Tuesday
morning. The tamid manual have you. And
so he says says what about you? Like the
party in the mall shabbat. So what about
erev shabbat? So the last one right
before shabbat. Where are you going to
get that one? Holy cow. She was like I
got to come. I'm like yeah. I already
took that into account. You already
checked it the one out of Shabbos. Now
you need at least six.
Later on, Bob become alcohol and rally
become Shiva Hahu.
You need at least this one for for
Tuesday morning. That little arrow shows
where that they have a little chamber
for the
Oops, this cuz that lame.
>> [clears throat]
>> This cuz that lame over here.
Okay. So you need for Shabbos and the
first day of Rosh Hashanah and the
second day of Rosh Hashanah. So he he
put Shabbos on the other way. He put
Shabbos that was
No, it's the first day, not Sunday. It's
not Sunday.
The [clears throat] other one was
No, he had to fix he had to fix it. We
forgot to fix it.
Oh, here it goes. Here goes a
thing jumping in there.
This is the Gmarra says, what are you
going to do for Tuesday?
And what are you going to do for
Friday afternoon?
Yeah, it's a little bit backwards. It's
backwards.
No. [clears throat and cough]
Exactly. So now it's Mazel Tov.
So what is it? It's very interesting.
This this this chart right here over
here is super interesting. Pay attention
to this because it's something we didn't
think about. How in the world do you
have six animals that were checked for
four days?
So the answer is that every day you add
two animals.
You keep on adding. [clears throat]
That that's the difference. You put them
in different pens. But in pen, if you
see, there's a there's a pen all the way
to the left that has six.
The pen right next to it
are animals that were checked for three
days. And the pen the pen next to that
is the animals that were checked for
two. And then the pen next to that and
you keep on At any given time you have
six. Elo ten of all my coin. This is the
Gmarra at the end of the day. The the
our time is not talking about Rosh
Hashanah at all.
The title was saying in general, you
need six days, six animals that were
checked for four days. Well, Mike
what does it say Shabbos and Rosh
Hashanah? See my to remind you that you
remember in a year from now we're going
to ask you how many sheep do you need?
You're not going to know if it's six or
eight. You'll remember there's a Shabbos
and two day Yom Tov. Another three day
Yom Tov, that's when Ellie Stefansky
spoke about his wife saying that she
loves living in Eretz Yisrael because
it's not a three day Yom Tov. Oh, so you
need six animals.
They cannot mean approved to you the
Tony could be the Shabbos. It doesn't
say enough for the Shabbos and Rosh
Hashanah. It's Kiday as if Shabbos. Look
Tony, it should say Lishabbos Bishnei
Yom Tov. For Shabbos and two day No,
we're not talking about Shabbos and and
Rosh Hashanah. It's not a real thing.
It's just a siman shmona that we're
talking about the middle of the year
that you need six.
Kilu it's Shabbos and to the Rosh
Hashanah Raboisai. Have a wonderful day
and surus toyvus bimheira.
Merit the zchus of spreading Torah
throughout the world. Sponsor a shiur
today. mdy.sponsor.com [music] or
[email protected].