CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 46 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Ra boy. We're holding 17 lines from the bottom of where it says we learned in the we had what's more important the two breads that you bring on or the two in other words which one if you don't bring you can't bring the other which one is the which one is the more important one thing we know for sure that you can't eat the bread we don't know for sure we're going to see a little bit of a difference today but up until now we understood you can eat bread until you sh the we also saw something very interesting that is going to go into that it's something that we don't really talk about throughout chass we always say the the two breads the two sheep we saw a lifting up when did I show it the last time I want to show it again just recently right this saw a lift up the sheep and he had two rolls in his hand the sheep and the rolls they go together what we what we saw yesterday is super interesting interesting is going to address it. All of a sudden, the Tur talks about talks about a bull, two rams, seven sheep, and we focus focus the whole time on two sheep. But there's a whole lot more to the than the two sheep. And the say, "No, no, you're right for focusing on those two. Those are very important. Those are special. They're in different category. These are but not not okay. So now we need to understand what the ML is between Raka and bananas. Rabika says the most important thing out of this is the bread and bananas says the most important thing are the sheep and he proves it in the mish he proves it and he was wrong. His proof wasn't so good but he says look in the midbar all they did was sheep. They didn't have bread. There's no bread. You have to grow it and everything. There's no bread. So sheep are more important. They told him no it's not true. They never shifted any sheep in the midbar. You're right anyway. We passing like so what's the So to understand the I did this real quickly. This is what it looked like yesterday. I just redid it into this format because I think it's it's more important like for us. Does go with the right on top of it or the left on top of it? Does it go with what's the difference? Talks about bread and talks about sheep. Talks about both. And says you that it's this is you means as is. So we're focused now on the one on the bottom the long one. Does it go with or does it go with banana says that it goes with it goes with sheep? Sheep is the most important thing. It says in you also and it says you perfect match says no goes with the is the most important thing it says and you are very similar which is what's going on here I mean you is a much better match so that's the do we care about perfect matches or not what's the famous famous gimmar we had many many times You don't need a perfect match. My time is he says I'm going to go I'm going to learn it says in what does it say in Zion? It says the breads breads is the So bread is the number one bananas learns it's better to learn the exact word I'm going to learn from says sheep is the main how come doesn't learn like that bread is the most oh makes why should I it's a perfect match you and you you you whatever okay you want to remember that way Great sheep use is not a perfect match says the famous question. What's the difference if it's a perfect match? The second week the point is for for the purpose of Shva to learn one thing from the other even though they're completely different words they mean the same exact thing that's enough. So the gar is asking that and you mean the same exact thing. So what's the difference if you learn from or from which is you? It's the same and you are the same thing. So that everybody knows the answer. The Gumar says the same question, same answer everywhere. I I don't even know how many times this is. Look in the side. But the Gar usually says, "Yes, when am I going to learn even though there's two different words?" Because there's no other word over there that's similar but over here that we could learn you from you. Why would I learn you from which is slightly different? I'm going to learn from the one that's the same. as how come Rabu doesn't learn like bananas that he has a perfect match. And then then I'll say what that the sheep is the most important thing not the bread says we're going says it makes more sense even though the word is slightly off to learn something that's similar in terms of the things are the same these are gifts that you give to the but is talking the over there is talking about here it says uh I just did this you know I'm using the old one because I didn't have time to fix everything but you it says It's no no good. Their argument is in the in the final all the way on the left on what the says what it means. Now if we look at it look at the the end of the P says it should be what in the world he is a the is hem. It's both Hashem and the cayenne. What does it mean? These sheep should be for who? what we have to explain it. So there's two ways to learn it. Either you learn it that it goes to both to Hashem and the and that's more like a a carbon that you give a little bit to the and a little bit to >> or it can mean that Hashem takes it. Hashem takes it for himself and then he gives it off. He passes the entire thing to the and that would mean what? Bread. Bread. The entire thing goes to the coin. So that's what's completely to the coin. Does it say it doesn't say it? Don't forget there's in there. Forget about for a second. So it has to be is it's a little bit to both. These are the the sheep. little bit toe little bit to the should be both says the says what do you mean it goes to toem grabs it takes all the $5 million and then he kind of then he gives it back so to speak first it goes to hem then it goes to but it's 100% the kind it's the it goes 100% to hem 100% back to the it's not the split. It's 100% when we're learning and we had to mention today the Bulman brothers we learned the concept of zika it's one of these words that there is no definition in English really the best definition is zika it's like there's a bond bond there's a bond between the bread in yum it's when a brother dies is without children. So his brother that's alive and his wife the alman they have a bond. They're not married but they have a bond and they have to choose are they going to do khalita or going to do or the other chooses. So there's a certain bondic bond. Nobody else could get engaged with this woman. Nobody could do it. There's a bond over here. Also the bread and the and the two sheep they have a bond at a certain point. When's the bond? The starts off saying the bond is by once there's a certain bond here like this here there's a picture he did two things I don't know why he's stuck in I'm not so clar with the raika here but uh it's very aesthetically uh pleasing check this out there's a bond [clears throat] woman you're going to like this one even Zaban now this doesn't work so well because says in a second this happens after these two sheep are not alive but okay I I would view it almost like like a marriage they're married you can't get away from each other when one goes on a vacation the other one comes with the the together now there's also something called an engagement they're not married there's an engagement is it's in between. So that's what says over here says once there's a zika and you lose one bread you can't do anything with the other thing it's it's done you're done one could hold back the other only when the zika came in how do you get to the zika through once you the sheep now they're connected the breads and the sheep are connected You miss one, you don't have the other. They asked a question. What about when you lift up the animal before? Is there some sort of connection with them? Says, "What do you mean?" It's very simple to answer this just said a second ago. Obviously, if makes the zika and you have to do twice, right? Right? You have to do when the animals are still alive. Also, when the animals are dead, but when they're alive, you do. So, if the what what creates the zika, why would say they have to wait till the next step of know says no himself wasn't 100% sure. We are not sure what meant for sure that perhaps he knew for a fact that yes definitely maybe wasn't so sure that's why he never said it but he was sure about he said what he knew for sure and he himself had a suff to to mashia to understand this does work or not we'll see later this yes it does work. They should be the the breads become yet which one is the more important one the bread theft says yet. So what you see that does not create a zika otherwise it wouldn't be a mus what's the whole if you if you have bread but you don't have theim could you bring could you bring the bread no you can't bring the bread this there's a there's a no uh if you bring the without the they're they're interconnected it doesn't matter what you bring what you don't bring you have to bring everything if you don't if you're missing one part of everything you can't bring it at all that's called zika so where's the where's where's a place to have between afterm that they're arguing in that is after okay so what and what are you going to say that after there's no so that's impossible after he talk this is not talking about after anything he's talking about all the way in the beginning but in the beginning how does it make any sense what does it mean they're kaidesh It means after in one day from now in a few hours from now they're going to be they're going to go it's going to go to the so there's no right from this and also when it comes to it's in the future it goes to the okay now we have to know and understand the not every time there's zika there's certain things there's never zika in carbonas who says that creates a zika again a bond between the bread and the animal that if you let's say the one bread gets lost somewhere it's eaten by a by a rat then you got to you got to just I don't know what to do you can't know maybe it's not possible we'll see in a second maybe could use it as a schlam but it's not a it's not a it's not a it's not a it's not a If the bread breaks, the bread breaks before the it's worthless. I call upon him. If it breaks, if it's you have to bring a new bread because we have to understand there's no on this bread yet. Just bring another one. But once he did the and then afterwards, so now the bread is called one of the breads broke. Now you treat it like a that's what it showed you over here in this video. This you treat it like a but it's not a you got to you got to start over again. All the breads are right. So that maybe that's what he means all the breads are possible even though only one broke once there's already soap they have to give one out of 10 every 10 every type of bread you give one to the to the so you give to the from the good ones and it'll take care of the broken one actually now Another if the the uh the bread went outside went outside of what did it go outside of? >> Why outside of the No. >> No. Because in kachenum in order for it to be kim is outside of the bdash but you're permitted all over. So outside means outside of at that point if it's after and the bread went out. So you do, you eat the meat again, you treat it as the bread is no good because it went outside, but if it went outside after you you did the you could do you could do truma. You give one for every 10, you could count the bread that went outside as one. It has to be one out of 10. So you count that bread even though it went outside. Oh, now if we go back to if the bread became before the maybe so you bring another same thing as we said before but here's what then the bread became to everything's Now it's a good why here's a trick a little trick you have bread that's is could a eat it could you eat the bread that sits is marata huh >> you don't think so why because it sits This is means forap but it does doesn't remove doesn't remove the tum here's no good okay you do the the one from the from the good stuff on the bad stuff here we finally got to the question now if this you assume that if the for sure said for Sure. In a case of there's a bond. Now if there's a bond once there's a bond once you decided that this bread is possible. Yeah. And also by the other one let's call it. So it's possible once it's once the bread is possible, everything is possible. There's a bond. Whatever happens to one happens to all. So then the the sheep are also possible. You can't eat the you can't eat the says you should be right because of the zik thing. The calls it calls it. Therefore, it's a special that you could bring the title without bread. Even though this is we have that that just lifting it up creates a bond. If if the bread got lost after the then everything is gone. There's a zik there's a bond. So one one bread got lost everything gets lost there's a bond. So if one sheep got lost oh yeah if the sheep got lost now if doesn't create a bond if and the bread got lost. So ask the what happens if you replace the bread you lost the bread you replace the bread. There's already aufa done. You hear the question? There's on the sheep, no on the new bread. Theufa that you did on the bread, the bread got lost. So, do we have to do another a second on the bread? And the explains the question doesn't apply to the sheep. Certainly the sheep, the new sheep are going to require. The question is also on the bread not also on the bread only according to not according to why banana says that the main thing we have to focus on the sheep and it brought the positive all thing since the bread is the most important thing and the bread got lost and you didn't do to the new breads it requires but at the end of the day what permits you to eat the bread when you sh the the the so the have what >> those are still there >> and those are still there and you're ready on them no requirement it's not necessary to do on the new breads I don't know so in the look look at the the has all these all these seven sheep one one bull and two rams So what's the whole focus on the whole day and the bread and the bread? Why are we talking about the whole time the two that come together with the bread? They're the ones that have a bond. They're the ones that are what happened to everything else in the that they don't seem to have any any control over the breads and one is not important to the other. If you if you lose a bread, you could still bring a a bowl and you still bring the no connection. So here we all of a sudden we're saying there isn't. Remember we had we weren't sure no there's a bond between the two sheep and the bread. There's no bond between the bread and the bulls and everything else. The bull and everything. So what's the second thing that has bread? What's the third thing that has bread? Holding. So if anybody from another sheer starts giving you a hard time, you ask them, "What are the three carbonas that have bread?" What do you mean? There's no there's no there's no yet the the breads and you need a carbon in order for the bread. You need the one is dependent on the other says just like a is like the bread. So too here by the the bread says I don't understand by there's only the carbon but over here we have so many other carbonas we have 10 more carbanas that we're talking about right the one bull two ram seven sheep what happened to them how come they're not says so Maybe the the seven sheep should also do the same thing. They should be the third thing that has bread with just like the aisle of the What's the What's the in the front seat? He is a Nobody knows the answer after that whole video. He's aim. >> I'm sitting in the aisle seat. Ah. [laughter] Oh, what gives the the guy? This guy. This aisle guy, the Dodge Ram in the aisle. Not the guys in the back. Not the in the and the You want to continue? Not the and the guys in the back. We're going to learn from the that it's only the and not the other guys, the don't give any How do you know that the is the bread of sales? Is the one that's Let's just do one more little here. Yunfu the two if the two breads come by themselves without here this maybe I'll show the video here the kids are they get they have bread they have enough for bread but there's zero so what do you do you make the bread you bake the bread like you see over here but you don't eat it you leave it overnight tubas means you leave it overnight it's ple now because of >> lina >> it's overnight and then what do you You take it to you burn it. So you do with it and you just leave it. I don't understand. If you're telling me you don't need a matter of the sheep, you don't have sheep. Sheep is what allows you to eat the bread. But maybe perhaps if there's no sheep, you could eat the bread without the sheep. So let them eat it. And if you're going to tell me no, regardless sheep, no sheep, you need sheep to to eat the bread and you can't eat the bread. So what are you waiting overnight? Just burn it right now. Why do you need to leave it overnight? No, you bring it to eat. But in this particular case, we're not going to allow you to eat because of the next year. There's going to be there's going to be sheep. And people say last year you remember last year we ate we didn't eat the bread without didn't we eat without bread. So today also we can eat the bread without without the sheep. We don't have to wait for the sheep. Just eat the bread. You know they didn't know. Lastly when there's no sheep you're allowed to eat the bread on its own. You don't need a matter. They are their own matter. The matter themselves when there's no sheep. But today that the sheep, it's the sheep that are the matter. Have a wonderful day. [music and singing] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.