CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 26 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning rap. What do we have yesterday? We had two bryes that contradicted each other. Bryson number one says that sits that the kangal wears on his forehead doesn't have the power to forgive to allow a carbon that the uh the person through the blood the yed and the other one says is amazed. So he said that Bryce one Bryce is the other is that's what that's where we're holding where did you see the doesn't give a at all smack in the middle of a so when we yet we find that doesn't give any penalty at all when it comes to trauma. So too truma here we go. So you see this idea that there's no if a person he shouldn't take truma he shouldn't give the kay the 2% from the tummy stuff. Why? Because that hurts the kayen. But if he does it works [clears throat] ma everything goes fine. will say it goes like we have a contradiction the B is okay not a contradiction one B goes like one goes like I see okay maybe only said his thing where there's no why because it's something lighter but we know it's a lot lot more severe maybe doesn't say his thing there says he says who you going to throw it at it has to We don't have anybody else. Nobody else is in the lineup. So the only person available is Rebel Raven here again. What's the We have a contradiction. The two braces. One says this is amaz what do we do? Says Raven very simple. There's two steps in the in the whole process. There's when you make the blood to and then when you sprinkle the blood. There's two different things. So he says if you put your hand in the blood, you took a rat, you put it in the blood and you did it on purpose, then the tits will be miratza. That's step one. Because the step one was was deliberate, the tits will will work. But the the more important step of sprinkling the blood that you cannot use blood that's tame on purpose then the tits won't be mirata now of when it became and when you sprinkle it as you can see over here the bra that says that the tits is not miratza that's talking about the second step two when you sprinkle the blood but step one I just put a one and a two to make it more in my mind one and two in the beginning the p when you see the blood and you walk over the blood and you touch the blood that if you did it on purpose we're going to forgive it if later on you do if you sprinkle the blood [snorts] so inside when it became the blood but when you sprinkle it that you cannot do deliberately when you throw it exact Exact opposite. Take a look. Boom. Do this one. That didn't fall in place so well, but okay. The [clears throat] opposite. The second step of when you sprinkle the blood, if you did it deliberate deliberately, then the sits does give you a cup. That's it. But don't start off on the wrong foot. If you if you went and you took a rat and you put it into the bowl of blood and you made a tummy deliberately since it's not going to help you out. But when you do the zika step two of throwing the blood, you could even do it deliberately and the has superpowers to overcome that. But the initial step of making and the story number two. So look look look rice number two on the left we're talking about but it says shinma which seems like what we say we we typed up number one not talking about we're talking about that it became says the I found that today's has a few of these like kind of like this is what he really meant let's count them even you have to stick in a And he sprinkled it. Yeah. No, we're talking about we're not talking about. Okay. Another question in number one. It says that the blood was and then it says you said number one is talking about and all all of a sudden over here it says like you you explain Bryson number two. Really? Bryson number one is talking about another one. In other words, even if it's okay, fine, says the Mishna. So, how does it work? You take the kamita out of the maha. You put the kamita on the mak and then you get to eat the shir. What happens if there's no shim? No sh. Can you put the kamita? Are they depend on each other? Can you put a kamita on a when there's no shim? What happened to the shim? One of three things other either the became. So they're right here in front of us, but you can't do anything with it. Or they were completely destroyed or they were lost. So we have a what does mean? We have a similar elsewhere. Can you perform when there's no meat? Same exact thing. Can you be mac the can you put the kit on the mb if there's no dough no flour can you put can you sprinkle blood on the when the meat disappeared here the says so it seems like they're connected you need baser you need in order to have dam you need boser here's the dam and you could sprinkle the blood If there's meat that Yes. But what happens if the meat disappears somehow? I don't know how it got destroyed then it goes from to what is that called a dam. If there's no bosser, no dam fine [clears throat] according to one. So just like the says by the meat and the blood that if the meat disappears you can still sprinkle the blood. So he says over here if the disappears you can still put the the and on the flip side who holds by meat that you cannot throw the blood if there's no meat. You need meat a boss or a dam he holds. So over here also same idea. So we have three things in the mishna. We had it became tame it got burnt and it got lost. He says referring to the t the only time you can't put it on is if 100% of the shim became t. So the kima has nothing to work with. It's not coming to be m or anything. So then you can't put it on. But if there's even a small amount of left over, that's okay. How come he mentions the word? How come Rav says only the word? There's three case in the he only brings one. The answer is he meant all three, but he brought the first one in the Mishna as just an example. And for that we have to wait a minute that that makes no sense. Why? What does he hold? If you have a little piece left over, that's enough. You don't need the full. So then what's the difference or got lost or got burnt? If 90% got burned and there's 10% left, you have 10% left. What's the problem? If 10% is not enough, so then why if it becomes to is it okay? So what are you going to say? Because special you have the has superpowers on. So then why does Raf say that if the entire thing it's only when the entire became there's a difference between the entire thing and and 90%. Why is there a difference? The tits should have the superpowers that overcome even a full truth that when you have 10% left it's fine. It's Rav was going on all three cases. There's no your question is a great question and it just comes to prove that ra meant all three cases that if if 90% got lost 10% remains 90% got burnt 10% remains it's fine you can do of the why so why did he say grab the first case what do you what are we trying to prove here that if you have some of the left over you can put on side this is a freebie because we had it exactly two weeks ago every word when you when we're talking about whether you have enough meat to do the even if you have one kaz of the animal 99% of the animal when but one kaz is left over I could throw the blood on the not only that even a part of the fats that go on the what's the difference is edible for human consumption and is for the consumption but they're different. One is for humans, one is for the for the for the so you cannot combine the two. You can't say oh I have a half a kaz of meat that's steak and I have a and put them together to have a full no you cannot throw the blood because they don't combine. One is for humans and one is for the however the you could combine the two. Why? Because the entire thing goes on. There's zero between there's no steak and there's no it's all one. It's all so you take a half a of what should have been a steak but it's not. It goes in and I have of fat. It goes on. It combines for a for a kaz and then you can do mipul because it all gets burnt. The bottom line is you see that if you have a little piece left over even a kaz you do great this is wow what's going on here and if you have a you shouldn't throw the blood even if the entire is left over. What are you talking about? Where's the on is made out of flour, not out of blood. We're talking about or so let's take aim. You have aim. How do you bring? You bring together with the wine, together with a in the you put some oil and then the schlam went bye-bye. It disappeared. So, can I throw the blood of the schlam? Well, I have a whole bowl of which goes together with the So why shouldn't I be able to throw the blood? [clears throat] It's together. They come together. It's part of the same carbon. So maybe I should be able to throw the blood based on the fact that I still have leftover flour. No, you need leftover meat, not flour. Okay. How do I know that you need a kazayas? That a kazayas of fat is good enough. Now there's different things. Let me ask you if you have kaz of a kidney left over, could you do sadam? Kaz of a kidney. Kaz of fat. I don't know what could you do. The answer is yes. So the goes through it real quickly. >> Is left [clears throat] over. >> What did I say? >> Of meat. >> I said fat. Noat fat. >> Fat. Maybe because it's not say oh it says the whole is talking about the goes like this he throws the blood so you see that has to do with if you have good even though there's no meat left How do you know that the skirt steak that diaphragm that divides the body of the animal? It's like a wall between the the lungs and the the lungs and the the heart because I'll prove it to you. It says that if you have flour left over, you cannot do anything else but flour, you could say. But how do I know it from the [clears throat] Anything that gives a good fragrance, anything that you put on the including a kidney gives you the ability to do and I need the two things simple here. I need those two words only. I need it to tell me that kidneys and and a diaphragm which is meat today. Yeah, that's a skirt steak. People like it including myself is is is meat because we only say I think anything that brings fragrance. In other words, even flour, no flour doesn't count because it has to be fatty. It has to be meaty. It cannot be that comes from cake, from flour. This is favorite video. So, watch it again. Not mish but you know the whole process of a taking flour out of a clich. So that well no not that one. This is a clich. Pour it. No no no this one. This one right here. Pour the oil into kishar. Pour the flour into you put another layer of oil. Two layers of oil. Do bilo. That that bowl that he's doing the bloao in is a kishar. Fine. So it gives it gusha. This is I wish I could fast forward a little bit. So now he's baking it. And what does he have to do now? Now he has to break it up into pieces. He has to do them from this cuz it's a certain type of middle to them with. No, not necessarily. Now this is called third time of oil. Now this is called hagosa. He puts the touches in his bath. Southwest corner. There's leavine over there. The frankincense. Put the laser in. Now you have to move the leava to the side. Before you do kiche, you have to move the laser to the side. And now he's going to do kicha from this type of bread. Sometimes it's from flour, some from uh doing kamita now. Now he puts it in. This is what I wanted to show you. Puts in another kicharis. And that gives it added gusha. It goes up in in the the level of gusha. second cle. Then he puts salt and we're pretty much done here. Now he's going to do aara. There's one step after this. After what do you do after a >> Yeah, you get to eat the shrian. Look at them go like this with their head. The nuances. Anyway, so I don't know if you can bring Harry into me. It's >> here's the question. that step. Everybody agrees that everybody agrees that the mil is done in a cliches. The initial part is a clichus. Everybody agrees that the going to the misbeh [clears throat] is it necessary or not necessary. So says the Mishna and that's even in the question we'll see in a second says the Tanakama that if you take the step two here like he already did something just for that. It's kind of strange like it looks like his hand AI like it looks like it's going right through the marble. [laughter] Look, he took the kamita and he didn't put it in a second vessel. He took it directly from his hand onto the misbeh says the Mishna pleim says it's kosher when it seeas in itself. what he meant exactly. After you took the kumitz, you have it in your hand, you put it down, you take a knife, you chop it in half and you take one half and put it on the mb. Then you take another half and put on the kit was done 100%. But you m it in two times. What about if you moctar in four times? The mish says if you m twice, what if you cut it up into four pieces? Is that okay? >> Is whether or not it has to be or not. That's why it says or maybe why does say it's kosher also freebie. We had this number of times. If you want to use your hand, you must use your right hand just like says. We need to see this here says you need a right hand. If you're going to use your hand, it has to be right. If you're using a vessel, then it can be even the left. But clearly, what's a let's just show this real quickly. Brand new for today. I didn't like the size of the Kin, but that's okay. The the the there's only one carbon that you apply the blood by hand. Other carbon is you take you sprinkle it with a clean. The you take it, you smear it on the corner with your hand. That's if you want to do it with your hand, you have to use your right. You want to use a k then you're doing it like a asham >> here. Asham. Boom. That's a I think he does it with his right hand. Great >> what? >> Correct. Even with the left. >> Even with the left. >> Oh, even the left. And that is right over here with the left. With the left. Use it with the left. Right. You do right says, check this out. Just so we we're on the same page over here. Ribiani says that according to you don't need a you don't mean you don't need anything. You could even use your belt. Here's the belt. You could put it in your belt and walk around with it. You could even use earnware. No, no, no, no, no. He says no such thing. Everybody agrees that step two, you need a cle here. As you see, he did it great. You can see in picture number one on the on the all the way on the right, he's holding with his right hand because he's using his hand as right. The cle is holding the left. the he says you could even use you don't need a cle you don't need anything use your your belt and he should have had the belt picture there and says you can see over here you need a cle you need to put it in a cle the second step the after you do the put in a I have a question on the first that says that if you do it with your hand has to be in the right Okay, that's not so important to us. It's not the the question. You put all the stuff you put on the you could do it with your left hand. That's [clears throat] for us. That's what we're talking about. The frank smile. What does say with your hand? It needs to be over here. It says it could be with your left hand. It says it's great. No, you didn't read [clears throat] it. Well, this is what it says. Whether you do it with your hand or with a vessel, guess what? Goes on the word. with a clay you can do with small but you mean here take a look at the chart for a second just the the when it comes to the last part of the sentence is referring to the last word in the sentence the word that comes before the is it says this is a question what say, let's go back to the chart. [clears throat] Says you need a you need a vessel. So, we're going to have a couple questions on him. You didn't do all the way in the beginning or you didn't or you take or they make it one sentence and they take out the >> depends what you're using. I'm saying they used for anything possible. They say step two, you don't need a cle. They don't need a cle. You can use a plastic vessel. You put it in a paper cup. In a plastic cup, but says, what does say again? You need a Here it is. What is that number? >> Four. We had one on the bottom, one on the top, one before. Now this four oh it's referring to from when after you did the meeting you put it into step two you took it out of the and you went from there what are we talking about now >> what what are we talking about [snorts] he already did the kit he already put into what comes after that and says those two you don't need a kishar to do the you got to put it into the from a vessel that's and you put it and you add another in the second and even the has to be from when you as long as you do the what's a question on who says you need a clement says once you do the kam from you done you don't have to put it step two in a what does say you have to do step two put in maybe could say like the fifth one he sticks in another word no that there was a step two after step two then you don't need he did so with his right hand. And where did he put it in? In his left. Now, this is to us because if you have to put it into then putting in the left hand would be a big no no. He put it in his in his left hand without a cle no at all. What should you do? There's a way out of it. Put it back into your right hand. What if you put it in your left hand and you started having different thoughts of pigle it's not a real piggle. Why? Because it's in the left hand. Now if he put it in his right hand you have to stick in the word. If it's in his right pos then it's it's where I did I said that I said once you put it into the left hand it's all over. Why do they say you can't put it in the left hand? If you put in left hand there's no way out of it because you have to do you have to be in the second and once you put into the left hand we it was a little tricky it was simple we got it at the end but we had that if the blood falls on the floor you cannot pick it up and do but if the blood was in a cle and then fell on the floor then you could grab it up like you do on pes you take one scoop of blood from all the bloods and you do a aim it says that if it fell on the floor you can't it's possible they say that it's not possible if the you put the in the left hand why because you don't need a cle at all says you need a and over you see you don't need a bomb question what does say on the chart that you need a right hand so it's great why because it says that you have put it back in your right hand. Says you could even use your belt. Why do you have to Why do you have to put it back in your right hand? You could even use a belt. You don't need any. It's a good question. If you remember, very simple, we did a whole stick over here that when it comes to you, you need to use right and left. Uh even left when it comes to your hand, left is no good. only right but that was like let's him he says no no let's d him I'm reading the as is when it comes to your hand you could even use a left and small goes also before we said our was when it comes to hand is only I it says in the small no that's going on the the second the second words he says no I don't like that that's a that's going for real what it says like you and I would read it. If you use your hand or a cle, you can use the right and the left. So, it's not a question on me. I go like this that says you can use your left. Great. from the from the bowl and then you cut it in half and you put it on the it's good. You can't you can't chop that into you can't have four pieces. You can only have two pieces. Why? As you guys said and says, "No, as many pieces you want, you got 20 pieces put on his 20 times in a row. Do is there a minimum of how much the must be? and and a big sh is how much can you do you need to put onto the at any given time. So in other words again is there a minimum? How much must be contained in my hand? A you says yes there's a minimum two. Second of all every time I put on it must be one za. There's a minimum. It has to be two. You can't chop it up into four pieces. You chop it in four pieces. The pieces are too small. You can't put it on. Guess what? This is how we pass it. So it comes out a big big thing here. So note there's no there's no shares. I could chop it up in 20 pieces, put it on as much as I want. Check this out. Is you must contain in your hand at least two says the stipler that no one in our generation has a hand large enough to hold the tuk of of that time. And the says that if you cannot hold in your hand, your puzzle for what means does he mean any at all or just of so comes out according to the say that you're puzzled for all. So there's nobody alive today that could that could do unless you are um but he's not a okay. Think about it. You take the you put it on you get to eat the do you have to wait 5 minutes? Could you eat it immediately? As soon the millisecond that it touches the fire, boom, you can eat it. No, it has to grab most of it. 51%. You need 51%. I'll prove it to you. It says there was a a great amount of smoke. When when does the furnace give a bunch of smoke? When you have a majority of of fire things that are usually put on you could put at night. You put the at night means after and you it goes and and it gets um eaten up the entire night. You hear this things that are usually done during the day. You put the during the day [laughter] usually says and all of a sudden it switches the language. You put it after it just said it's something you put in the day. How do you know that it's allowed? You allowed to let it there be all night. One extra word. If you're putting it on, we just explained. Sorry. Means, let's go back 10 seconds. A minute, a second before. You put it on. You can't put it on after. You put it right before. That's why I said the joke. It's right before. But if you're putting on a moment before, how is it going to grab the entire animal? How's it going to grab 51%. like you know like sometimes I don't know like uh if you if you give in like let's say your tax returns just an example you give in some then you could later on send them documents or whatever as long as you're like you have to be in the game >> in the you have to be in the system at a certain time and then on it so you put it on to them boom okay then what happens after what you have to go a second before like you wash your hands before it's a good example right before you wash And then you you able to eat child's shoulders. >> But if you want to eat it, then you have to then it has to be completely done just to grab it. Okay, that's right before. But if to eat the whole has to be 51% eaten. We're talking about the famous. So I'm just going to skip to here real quickly. Means if something flies off the uh from the heat so that you're allowed to put back on. That's what we're talking about. Yes, it's after but you allow to put it back on because it's already flew off. If you notice talking about the things that flew off, but 10 lines earlier, eight lines earlier, it says one of the things I'm just going to read it. Something that falls off from you put back on. You can't get back onto you don't put back the and it says in the one of the three things I'm going to read. I can't read it. Where is it? Oh, one of the things is says take the word out. Stop right there doesn't apply. Have a wonderful day. >> [music and singing] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdyop.com.