CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 2 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning rap boy. I didn't say that. Okay. So says if you remember if you recall and if you don't recall we're doing when he brings a for the is in the head everything is about the kavana about You have to have you have to realize what you're bringing. And there's different types of Here's some of the stuff that our artists put together. Different breads is upon him is what we have in [snorts] every week. 12 breads is on. But let's focus on the two top left ones. You have and they're both very similar, same ingredients. In fact, they have the same exact ingredients, but one it's a little softer than the other. And it's because it's made in a deeper dish, like a deep deep dish pizza. The other one is a flat pizza. And because it's flat, the oil burns out quicker. So the min is harder. two different. So if the kan thinks to himself that he's bringing a but in fact it's a he messed up completely. He messed up and therefore the owner must bring another mah. But what do you do with the mah that he messed up with? What you do is you continue going v. You bring it. The owner is going to have to bring another one. We had the same exact when it came to. If the messes up, he thinks he's bringing instead of a you continue. But the owner over there is going to cost him a lot more. Instead of $6, he's going to have to bring something that cost $500, another carbon. But just like in there was an exception to the rule. If a carbon kas is messed up or a carbon pes only two then you take the carbon and you throw it out in the garbage that a special garbage it's not literally a garbage you burn it somewhere but it doesn't continue you don't continue and the same thing by if you mess up throw it out you toss it the Omar is going to address this word. What it should say is the owner wasn't has to bring another carbon another word. It's a curious word here. What is it doing in here? Allah Ella means only. But what? So we'll see in the there are two exceptions just like we had. We have two exceptions there. When a person sins, there's a way to remember what kind of sins shin test. Those are the three sins. Chin stands for call. Basically, if you hear of and you don't come by, you swear that you don't know about it or with B is that you swear falsely. And the test stands for anybody want to guess who said >> to very good tuma. You're not allowed to bring a carbon when your tom or the carbon is tom. For that, you have to bring a carbon. Now, if you can't afford the carbon, what do you do? If you're very poor, you could get away without bringing a $500 animal. You could bring something made out of flour. Now, another thing that I remember is that there's no oil. No oil. How do you remember that? Because meni from the English here the guy that goes viter know him as Mr. fighter. He asked then he saysar a guy that sins he's going to benefit he doesn't have to pay money and in fact it's the opposite because he did so we treated him like that it's like not even you're going to bring a very cheap kind of carbon you're not going to be able to honor the with a beautiful carbon just flour carbon no no oil when a husband suspects his wife of being with another man He warns her. He says, "Don't have with another man." She doesn't listen. So he brings her to Bikdash. We all know the is a whole process, a very long process. And part of the process is she has to bring a So the we know I'll show you a little bit of a video here. Here we go. You guys ready? Check this out. brand new for today of some of the process of a type of a min. Now, first you pour oil on the bottom. There's three oils we're going to see. Then you put the flour. Then you put oil on top. Then you do bleo. Mix it in good. Then you break it up into pieces. What's this for? If I cry, I say I need to blow my nose. Okay, stop. All of a sudden, I need tissues. I do whatever Benny tells me to do. That's it. All right. Next. Oh, that's the I forgot. We're We're middle still. So you add levina and now he's going to do he's going to move the lavina to the side. Where's the kamita? That's not the kamita. Oh, he's doing it like that. Okay. You put in another cle. You see another cle. Very good. And put salt. Great. And then you put that onto the flame. Look, look how the fire is going to get larger over here. It's great. Oh, mama is like real life. And then the leftovers called And you get to eat that. You go like this. You stick your hand in this way. Straight in. Grab three fingers worth. You break it off with your thumb and your pinky. Make sure it's exactly three. It's very difficult the gumar says to do and that's your that's what goes on this amount. The rest is for the to eat. But if you thought to yourself that it's not a it's a it's not a it's a whatever you messed up the type when you did the so the mission is saying is if you're with us for you know and even if you weren't I think most people know that there's four aid when it comes to a carbon What are the four different things that you do that a does? He does he does after you have to receive the blood in a after that what do you do? What do you do? You walk it to where to the and then you you spray it onto the those are the four corresponding to those four. We have also four aidas when it comes to the the is the is to put it into the second cle like you saw it's a it's made out of gold he did the cle and he moved it he walked towards the what is that called if in one of these four avoidas he had the wrong He could ruin it in any one of the four. He thought it was another type of or he started off good. He said this is a and then he flipped it to he started off bad and then he flipped it to good. Rash just asked a very simple question. What's the If you started off bad, of course it's not good. You can't take something that's bad and make it good. I hear a kadesh if you start off good and then you messed up. Okay, that's a you started off bad. So Rashi says beautifully he says I would think he says you think oh if you started off good and then you went bad that's bad. Why the toughest maybe there's a whole concept in we go by the last thing that you do the first thing. So I think oh if you start off bad but then you realize your mistake and you went to good so it's good you go by the whatever you did last a lot of times in in it goes by the last so maybe also says no that even even if you start good if you start bad and you went good it's still bad this is simple stuff what does it mean you start off good and bad you started off You wanted then you went to the you start off bad and then you went to good you went bad it's not it's but you thought it was a to begin with then you went great as the why do I need the word only how does the word only start just say listen if the messes up the owner has to bring another So says the I already explained in the beginning of the Mishna. The owner is not going to get a kapart from this one. But you continue doing what you need to do. Just because you messed up in the beginning doesn't mean you should continue messing up. You messed up once. Go back to what you were supposed to do. It was supposed to be. You thought it's a Now you figured it out. Go back to I'm in a Now continue doing it. Donor will bring another one. You just think that it's a says that if it was it was a carbon was and thinking that it's a let's say so don't say oh it's a forget it I messed up I messed up so let's continue with the mess up no when you when you sprinkle the blood on the on the you say to yourself this is an He buys him a crow. How does he know this? Either it's pure logic or he has a poss he has a how just because he made a mistake he should continue with his mistake. It's a it's common sense because a person messed up. That's why you should continue with your mistake. So you messed up. You might have to pay a little bit because you messed up. You'll have to bring another carbon. But don't continue with your mistake. You hear the side. Tell people they need to know this. Just as you watch one bad thing on the internet doesn't mean you continue watching the whole night. Well, you messed up once you go. Whatever it is, whatever your is, whatever your thing is, remember this is and some people say it's a We have a big problem with this possible. What's the difference between a nether and a nether means in general? I'm going to bring a carbon. If this one dies, I have to bring another one. Nava is zoo. Only this one. If this one dies. So, how do you remember? Because in middle of the word nava, there's dalid vase, which is a dove, which is a beer. Where does a beer belong? In a zoo. So, here we go. Let me see if I can find it. Dove zoo. Is har zoo. This one right over here. The problem is that in the same p it says both words. It says says you're calling it both. if you do what you're supposed to do. You say that it's a let's say it's a great then but if not it's an then you have to bring another one and if it's an you're not allowed to change things around our must be not going like says if you mess up on your Instead of thinking that it's a think it's an it's by the way I just noticed now it doesn't say the word over here it doesn't say it says like the is asking why doesn't it say it works the a guy doesn't have to bring another carbon that's the opposite of what we said in the mish the says it doesn't work for the owner and I'll tell Why? Says the Gar because a carbon is different. Actions speak louder than words. If I'm making a thin, obviously I'm not making a thick one. So I could say thick thick thick all I want, but it's thin. It's hard like a rock. I could say it's soft. Doesn't matter. So what I say is nothing when I'm when my action is different than my words. I'm not going to listen to my words. If it's dry like a box or I could say blue or whatever or the opposite it's obvious that I try to do don't bring me right from over there. when you there's no there's no what the same thing with says so we have a contradiction between and our says perhaps when a person doesn't use the word he just says that's different when a person says I'm making He sticks the word. So then he ruined it instead of the reason why it doesn't work in our Mishna because he made a he said I'm doing a different type of that's why it's possible you make you say I'm making instead of that's not the end of the world. We're gonna see Rab and Rob in a second perhaps like Rabba answers that what there's a difference another and perhaps that's talking about one thing and is talking about another thing that what he answers over there something else that we'll see later when a person here check this out Yoshi came off a plane he's you know how it is when you fly I know how it is the young guys don't know the coen he can mess up by thinking instead of the guy on the right the guy on the left instead of ru he did that's a big mess up it's different than thinking about two different types of the left he said it's ana instead of okay not the end of the world says when you mess up the owner that's a problem our mission is talking about changing the a change in ownership. Change in ownership. That's no good. That ruins it. How could you say in our case? That's what says it can't be. It says in our Mishna that we're talking about what's the difference according to you should said instead of it said no that's not what it says in our Mishna the says the problem is that you change the designation of of this instead of it's about maybe okay so we'll go a different route we'll go with not person messed up he thought that he's bringing a carbon for for a car for a carbon instead of a for again you can't say a person messes up and he does for a carbon that's no good says I'm sorry our mission says it's no good talking about that's okay again it doesn't fit into our why what's the what's the he didn't bring it for a But he brought it for a different type of like we said before we started off the we can't answer like okay however but we do have a contradiction between himself the say that if you mess up on the type of type of you could it it works for the owner. We have a brace that says it says in the regarding a talking about says is like like really a is like in what way? Sometimes like sometimes like we know the first is that if you mess up on that's it toss it out. So the same thing by if you mess up toss it. You had the wrong intent while you were doing the putting your hand in. Now, how is a similar to? Oh, if I'm bringing a voluntary, what's a I want to give something beautiful to the but I can't afford it. So, I bring a bag of flour to the mdash. That's like if the messes up on the he puts his hand in and thinks, "Oh, it's not an it's now it's the the problem is that we just read here that according to it doesn't work." And says that if you mess up, it does work. He said it's like a if you mess up on the rib is on two things. He holds that even by if you mess up you you continue to bring it. It's good. And over we just read in the B that if you mess up on it's no good. We have to reconcile this when you mess up in the type of carbon the type of that's where was saying it's cauter. Why? Because the mice is what's I could tell from what you're doing that you didn't really mean to say that. Sometimes you know you say the wrong you call your kid anybody that has boys you go from the top. You know what I'm talking about. You don't mean to say it. So the guy's in front of you, right? When your kid is in front of you, you call him the wrong name. You didn't mean to call him that. It just came out of your mouth. When you're talking about and you call it a whatever you didn't mean that it's in front of you that's when it's but when there's another owner you calling it another instead that is possible because over here you don't you can't prove what you meant and what you didn't mean that was in your head what difference does it make I'm learning this from in the when it comes to you can't start making enough. If you mess up, you mess up. This is logic. It's not why would do logic. You could see what the person's was by the action that he's taking. And since he's making a thick, that's what he meant to do. So don't tell me he said a thin one. He made a a thick one. When you can't tell what he was doing, what he didn't do, that's how much time do we have, Mark, for having me. Have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor atmop.com.