CHAZARAH - Menachos Daf 10 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Good morning. We are holding on like nine 10 lines from the bound of it says in the Mishna that you do kam is you bring a flower offering to the and the procedure is either you put oil first and you put the flour or it's one of these that you don't put oil but if this flour regardless of what it is with with oil without oil eventually the kite is going to have to take his hand. Put it in. We actually have a new one. I could show it to you if starting off if this is your very very first time because there are people that it's their first day. So, here we go. It's new for today. Kita. He puts his hand in like this. He grabs some flour. Three fingers. This was dumb, by the way. Guess how they did this new technology. I'll explain to you in a second. Is that the the cutting goes like this. That's kamita supposed to be done with the right hand. And he puts it into the second bowl because that's we're going to discuss for a moment later on also. So remember the second bowl. It must be done with the right hand. What if he did it with the left hand? No good. Not immediately. How do we know this? It says that you should fill your hand with the Now what is what does a mean? Now we're going back to the even though we saw the videos a bunch of times to to knock it into our head. Now I want to show you this video because it's important because it's wrong. We're going to learn today that this video is bad. And let's see if you can notice what's bad about it. First of all, here let's just show this for now. One kayen is pouring from the L. This is a cliche is this golden thing is has gusha. All the oil in it is kadesh. He pours it into his left hand. The Tory says left. And from here we can learn that everywhere else in the Torah it's in the right. The kaf means right. Over here it says kaf smallest. has smallest the left. So far, this video is good. Okay, what we're going to see is that there's actually fourukim that say the word left by the mits. Two sukim are by a normal wealthy person. We'll call him wealthy. That's how the gar calls. Well, it means he has money to buy an animal that cost 500 bucks. But if the messiah doesn't have money, so what does he do? So he's so he's able to do what's called a carbon. So we have four lefts. Two for the rich guy, two for the poor guy who brings a carbon. Meaning instead of a animal, he brings a bird. Why did he goes through it? says, "We're going to use up all four just to learn one thing that everywhere else in the you have to use your right hand, not a left. left is reserved only for the what does it say anywhere else in the means the right only it's the left but I need it for the actual to tell me that the that one pours it into the other's left not to teach me that in other places the right says the small So here we go. So this is our by says the word the pal now first by says that I need for itself says it the second time. It says also by a wealthy person the left hand. So now I know in other places no a double negative a double negative is a >> positive. So says the Garra when you have we have a concept in the Tory that when you have two negatives two don't do this don't don't use the left hand means you should use the left hand. So let's use that and say that you could use your left hand when it comes to says okay fine. Now we're going to the third which is by the poor person meaning somebody that can't afford an animal over there it says still not happy only over here. Maybe the third brother is coming to teach us that to the whole a lot of times you see these what's a limud sometimes it says in the p a and I take that idea and I use it for the whole tyra why would I say that's da over here not in another in another place okay for that that's why it actually says oh I've never seen this it says I just noticed over here this four letters hey in a row funny I I don't remember that. Okay, cool. You see that in your cuz you're looking over there where it says smallest. It brings all four in one shot. Anyway, okay. And here, let me just show you. Here's the fourth and look what Yoshi did. All four together. You see all the four smokes. Great. End of that. So, what do we learn? That left is reserved only for the when it comes to it's the right you take out the word here. So and it says in parenthesis which I I I'm pretty sure is like a that's why we take it out. It says in the peers, in other words, we already know that the the oil goes on top of the blood and blood we know is on the right. Let's see if this is going to work now. I don't know. Okay. You're supposed to put pay attention. You're supposed to put this very easy. You're supposed to put the the the oil on top of the thumb. I don't know if this is going to stick. Oh, yeah. Like this. Now, what about this part? Over here. Right over here. M. That's why I I put it like in green. I now it looks blue. Green. Blue. M. What about over here? Says the one over here to tell me that the side is okay. Right over here the lift right over here. It's also red. The the part that's part of the palm, the side of the palm that's no good. So we got to tell Yoshi he has to better switch it up quickly. Okay. She says the This is by the wealthy person says on put the blood on top put the oil on top of the blood and then it says and that that's by the poor person says on the place of the blood of the why I need both of those says beautifully this is something that you and I didn't know until today if I were to ask you I'll stop right here let's Let's think about it. Can I remove the blood before I put the oil on or does the oil have to be on the blood? Spicy. What do you say? Take a guess. What does logic tell you? Again, if I put the I have blood on on on my ear. I have blood on my finger, blood on my toe. Now, I want to take I want to put oil. I'm supposed to take oil and put it on my ear. The client does it. Puts on the ear. Puts it on the thumb. Put Can I remove the blood first? If I clean off the hand and then put the oil, what do you say? You say no. Anybody agree with him? I would say no. This is what I would say. I would say no. I agree with spicy. He goes, meaning if the blood is there, but if you removed it, you wiped it off, no good. You cannot put oil on a nice dry hand. It has to be on top of the blood. I would think no it has to be on the spot on the place of the blood not on top of the blood. Wherever you put the blood before that's where you should put it. But if it would just say the place I think oh on the place but not if you wiped it off say I think if it's there it's no good. Why? Because you didn't put the oil on top of the guy's thumb. You put it on top of blood which is you can't go into with that blood. You could put it on top of the blood. In other words, you could put on top of the blood and you could also wipe it down if you want. You could do whatever you want since it says both on the blood of the place and it also says right the right blood. Why do I need the What's going on here? We're going to learn three beautiful. Here we go. Check this out. First of all, for whatever reason, I'm I'm talking to Mark, not to you guys. For whatever reason, when I my touch screen, when I touch the the box, it doesn't work unless I do with the the mouse. Interesting stuff. It says the right ear, the right hand, and the right foot. Says the Gmorus says, "Rabbi, I'm learning three completely new. I forever been to the D, you all know these basically, but if you're new, it's cool stuff. This we learned that in order to do you have to do with your right hand, okay? Regular regular." Oh, khalita. What's khalita? Khalita is if you have two brothers that one of them got married and died without children. So typically speaking, you're not allowed to marry your sister-in-law. But if she doesn't have any children from her husband, then it's a mitzvah to marry her. And if not, then you do khalit. Nowadays, we only do khalita. What is khalita? She removes the shoe, special shoe, and it's tied a special way. You'll see in the video she must remove it. But the is that this shoe has to be on the right foot. That's regal. We learned that from Sha that has to be on the right. We learned from this P right over here. She has to toss the shoe far. She has to spit a spit that's you could see with your eyes. And there's they say back and forth. Okay. And then says at the end says what about a ear smallest. What does Rabb do with the four smiles? So you need two for the actual that it should be in the left hand of the of the of the but what does he do with the other two? First of all to tell you that if you put it in the right hand you are doing something wrong this makes a lot of sense because when the Torah says left I would think you know typically especially you know don't start off with the right you know you try to give a your left hand you're in big trouble you know no right you know so maybe the also the left not only the in a place where typically you have to do only with your rights. So when the Torah says you should do with your left so certainly should be able to do with your right. So that's one one tells you no if you do it your right over here it's possible what do I do the fourth one in other words sometimes the repeats itself just like over here start off telling you about the rich the rich man's and then the poor man's theory will go through all the steps in order to teach you one thing what's the what's the thing the one thing the Tyra taught us that you don't have to if you're poor You don't have to bring a whole animal. You can bring a bird. But all the little details that the Torah tells you with it are not there for you to learn new stuff. Say, "Oh, look. The Torah repeated itself. Oh, so I have extra words. I can learn something." No, no, no, no. The Torah repeated it just to tell you one. The is that you could use a bird, not an animal. What I do with all the extra words? Nothing. They're not there for for for a there just to be part of the whole of that little kadesh. the entire said twice only for one little thing. We had the sug Oh, twice in there you go. When the Tyra says the word finger or is not or we're gonna see or finger and it means you must do with your right says I think [clears throat] you need the the takes the blood of the with his finger. Important to notice this because it's the only carbon we learned the only carbon that you do with your finger. All other carbonas the takes the vessel and gives a spritz with his hand but he does it with his finger. But it says in this both words And I learned from he dunks his right finger as okay fine. So he knows them the right. You tell me you need both and finger but we just finished the about comes with a small puzzle. We start off today. does with the left hand. No good. Ah, it only says doesn't say anything about a hand or a finger. You got it wrong. You didn't understand. Doesn't mean you need both words. One of the two words. If it says in the means the right over here, it says that's it. I don't need it means the right. Check this out. Another beautiful video. Just this is just for learning purposes, no humor. Here we go. Take a look at the center guy. What is he holding? He's holding a sheep's head and in his left hand he's holding like some sort like a thigh and in his left hand. That's a problem. Why says one word? We just said, we just established. It says one word. means in the right how is he holding the leg in the left hand. So I I get what you're asking. He doesn't have another hand to hold it because he's holding the the head but it has to be in the right. So bring another maybe it only says hand they bring the the all the limbs the the right foot the should be holding the right foot in his left hand it should be proper you should hide the incision mark of the animal where you cut the the leg off, put it against his just show nice a nice piece with the with the skin could hold it in his left hand. Let's say when I'm doing whatever things that are that has to be in the right walking the environment to them is I don't do it the carbon is still good. What about to receive the blood here? If you don't like blood, do not look with the with the right hand. You receive the blood. What if you do with the left? It doesn't say hand. It says the word. We learned is small. If he accepted it, he received the blood with his left hand as possible. But it doesn't say hand over there. only says the problem is how in the world could say that it's good just said you need one word or can says over here one word it says how could say that's okay asking says you need both the word and hand then then it becomes possible but over here it only says therefore says you can receive the blood with your left Well, the problem is really require two words. Handb or and the word says one word. If it just says it means the right hand. If it just says it means the right. Nothing to do with kayen. Doesn't say the word kayir. says it more like this. You're right. If it says the word by itself, it doesn't require a second word. That's why says if you do with your left hand, it's possible because it says where sorry over here it says it says the word. Okay, fine. No. So if it says it means says caution. If it says the word, that's enough. One is enough. It means right. But if it says, that's not enough to to tell me that I need the right. I need another word together with it. And now I know that it's on the right. The problem is so why in the world does it say the word by itself doesn't mean the right hand. You need the word in conjunction with so but the word by itself means right. So why do I need the word? What does kind help me ever? You know what it does for me that must be wearing the big day when he performs otherwise it's no good. It's to wear the big day. What about it? It only says the word's argument. If you do with your left hand and even agrees to that, how do I know he agrees? Because he doesn't argue. You don't know that he argues the small puzzle says that could be with the right small puzzle. Remember this called who says you can do this of the blood on with your left hand. You can do with your left hand. You can do with your left hand. It's all good. It says it says what's the next word? So means the right. So what I need the special words to tell me that it's with the right. If one word is enough is enough to tell me that it's with the right. So why need yad? went in I learned from the word says. So that's what we saw in the beginning of this year right over here. He the kamita must be done right over here. He's doing it with his right but also putting it into the second vessel must be done right over here with the right. That's what I do with both. But the problem is doesn't need this last step that we saw. This last step and he takes the the and he puts it into the second vessel. You don't need that. You can take your from the first vessel directly to the and put it on the but says the does require to put it into a second vessel. And he allows it with the left hand. So what he's going to do with the two words that say which mean with the right tell me that you should do with your right hand. He already learns learns from somewhere else. What does he what does he hold? He can do what he left. I'm sorry that the comm has to be done with the right. How does he know that? It says in the is like what does that mean? If you're performing with your hand, meaning you must do the with your right hand. We said that is the only one of the kurbanas that you do the sadam with your right hand not with a cle with the with your hand whereas other carbonas here this is like a regular za it's a little weird this one cuz he goes backwards but he he throws it with the ple that's every other car you have to do it like that on the southwest corner etc But the bottom line is why what does do with the word two words? If he's going to do if he's going to use a vessel, he should do it with the left hand. If he does, he should do with his right hand. But I don't need yad for that. When does a sinner, a guy that does and he has to bring a carbon, but he can't afford it. So he brings flour and he doesn't add any oil. Why? Because I want to make him feel that he did a he's not going to bring a beautiful carba. So explains that you don't put any oil in it. You don't put any in it. Why? You don't want him to give a beautiful carbon. He comments if you do with the left hand. Nope. It fits right in. No oil, no just left. That even With the word yad I learned it has to be with the right hand. Have a wonderful day. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atmop.com.