CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 95 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning rap boys live from Lincolnwood Illinois. We're starting from the bottom bottom of bay. You know these are old that we're holding on the daff where we're supposed to be holding. We're not too far behind. This guy is not a very good guy. He's a butcher and he's in a big fight with another person in he tells him if we would have made up if you would come and ask me and I would have forgiven you. He tells him you should have asked me a long time ago. You heard about this big giant fat axe that I cheeded yesterday and oh the steaks. You can't even imagine how good the steaks were. Had you been my friend, you'd have had unbelievable tasty steaks. Oh my. So the guy tells him I already had from your steaks. I heard that one of these animals and I got not the steak. I got the best of the best. There's a part of the animal I forgot what it's called. was only one pound per animal. That's what I got. The the shu of the best of the best where whoa whoa where do you get such a fatish steak. So as we're going to see in the suga was very very prevalent in those days for the g to sell kosher meat everywhere and as we discussed if it's a place that they announce that there's a traa so it's for you to buy from the guy as long as they didn't announce that day that there's a traa you're buying from the guy today nobody would dare buy from a guy it has to have 25 stamples and stuff and this and that and that is not good enough those days they bought from the gut. She says, "Your animal that you tried to make sure that I don't get the stakes. I got the stakes. I got it from the guy. The guy bought it and I got the best of the best." So listen to this. This Russia tells him I did two yesterday. Okay, the first one that did was so I got rid of it. I sold toy and then I did the second one and I didn't tell him to announce it. You bought the meat from the trafe. That's what I'm trying to tell you. If you were my friend, I would give you kosher meat. Now, because you're not my friend, you ate tra like he's the guy's in Russia making fun of him. Here comes my most favorite word because of this idiot this who did against so it's interesting the the word comes from the word that we know in Israel we should we should ask her all the stores that sell meat because this guy didn't announce most of the meat meat in this city is kosher meat. Most of the go that sell meat in the city are selling the kosher meat. There's no reason for us to answer because he just admitted that he did something wrong. If the meat comes from the kosher butchers, most of the meat in the city comes from Jews. I'm allowed to buy meat from a Some say the story is slightly different. Again, my favorite word. He He wasn't being serious. He was trying to as they say in Yiddish, he was trying to bother his friend. He wasn't saying the truth that he that he sold that there was a tra and he gave it to the god. He was lying. He just wanted to to be mitsire the guy. What's a big mire for a Jew? You tell a Jew that he by mistake ate a a tra sandwich that that the the chicken he bought for the last 5 years in in the store was actually tra. It's tremendous. We're so makers and and and the guy comes along and tells me that I ate. He was he was chapping he's pranking him. call him. So the difference between the first le and second is in the first he was being serious. I was a Russia I sold the trade but I can't rely on you and you and your I'm not going to answer everybody. The second one is forget about it. He wasn't even it never even happened. So it's because this guy wanted to bother his friend. But if it wasn't because of that the meat would be there would be why would it be if most of the the butchers are are Jewish and most of the meat is kosher why would it be says I'll tell you why it bec when if if the guy's that he had a tra and he gave it to the go so It's different than a city that has a Jews and we could be on the and say that most of the meat is kosher over here. What we're saying is we know for a fact that 1200 pounds of meat is completely tra is and that went into the marketplace that's problematic. That's why it would be a problem. But because we're saying that he was lying and he's just shepherening then then then it's not a problem. So now we're starting a brand new very very famous comes with stories and stuff. We had similar when it comes to to water left overnight but over here it's a slightly different. If you have meat that wasn't supervised and the gummor is going to say that's not just a supervision supervision by a yid but even a supervision by a if it wasn't being supervised for a moment it's to eat to eat says ra and this is how we ask him what's the concern that a raven will come in and swap the piece of meat says that it's not a real but Rav is basing his on a story that happened but it's not such a problem. Okay. Again, so the whole concern is that a raven swapped it out with non-coosher meat. Otherwise, we don't have an issue. This city has a R. Most of the butchers are Jewish. Most of the meat is kosher. It's not a problem. If you have kosher butchers, what's the problem? The the meat that is by is completely mut. So why do so and by the who's watching the You don't have a Jewish supervisor. You don't have a m sitting there and watching the meat the whole time. You're buying it from a a non-Jewish vendor. So obviously it's this is meat that was not supervised for for at least a moment here and a moment there says it's not true. The go is supervising it and that's the we all we care is the raven. We care that the raven should swap it out from another place. He'll come from another city with a nice with a different steak and swap it out with the with the non-coosher meat that we don't have a problem when the guy is sitting there. Now, how do we know that the go is watching? So, they discussed that also. So says the um oh one of my favorite suggest it's not so much my favorite but I always never understood like it seems like this would not happen in our days in other words nobody would eat such meat today like we're more m than so what's the situation we have nine stores that are Bernstein and uh Mskovski And what's the names here? LG kosher meat. Nine stores that are all kosher and one of them the 10th one is is non-coosher. It's posito's pork store but the rest is is mamish kosher. Nine out of 10 sell kosher meat. The 10th one sells non-coosher meat. dead meat. Meat that wasn't shafted. He bought meat from one of the stores and he's not sure which one of the nine store, which one of the 10 stores he bought. It's for him to eat the meat. Why? There's a concept called when something is stationary, we don't have a we lose the majority. We lose the concept of majority. So since the store is stationary and you went into the store to buy the meat and you purchase from a sta stationary location or object stationary object so that stationary object becomes 50/50 and 50/50 it's 50% kosher 50% non- kosher you can't eat meat that's a 50/50 you can eat meat that's 51% kosher in terms of re that there's a the tells there's 51% chance that you're eating kosher then it's okay to eat the the meat this is called kavore that if it came you went into the store and purchased it. Elderly person forgetful a little bit. It's also why because you went into the store. It's only 50/50. But if you find it, If you find it on the street in front of the stores, then you're permitted to eat it because we say that it came from the roy of the majority which is kosher. says, "So what's the question?" The question is, after everything, the bottom line is, "How could you pick up a piece of meat off the floor and say that it must have come from one of the nine stores and not the 10th store, me, but the the piece of meat was on a sidewalk and nobody's watching it. Isn't that it's meat that was lost from supervision. There's no supervision for a moment. Says no. Was supervised entire time by the nonjew. And you found it. You found it over there by the non-Jew. But somebody's watching it. You went to a city and you found meat in the city. So what do you do? You find out what's the majority of the butchers. Depends. If the majority of the butchers in the city are Jewish, then you could eat it. What if you found a hamburger cooked piece of meat? Look around. If you're in a city with the majority, you're in bar park, majority Jews, I hope. I don't know. Maybe majority Jews. You find a hamburger on the floor, then you could eat it. So what are you going to tell? Oh, so now once again we have the question, how you picked up a hamburger off the floor. So you make a whole are the majority of the eaters of meat, the meat eaters in this city, are they Jewish? The answer is yes. Okay, you can eat it. What about the five minutes that was sitting on the ground and nobody's watching it? Isn't that it should be also according to Rav and if you'll tell me you're going to say you know what over here also a non-Jew is watching it so then how come if it's cooked we should say it's a Jewish hamburger if the is holding on to it then it's non kosher meat and if a Jew is holding it then it's kosher says. So the Jew is watching from a distance and the and he sees that it's not there's no raven over here. What's the whole concern? The concern is that maybe a raven is going to come and switch it out. No, that's not the concern. That didn't happen over here. Okay. So says the if if this me is a non was it was dropped or whatever by a non-Jew, you're allowed to eat it. The concern the only concern we have is the raven that brought it from another city because this city has kosher meat. Even the go is has kosher meat. Concern is the raven. That's not a concern because he was watching from a distance. He saw that there's no raven. If he found me outside depends if it's full limbs, we're going to say that's an animal that's a but if it's now how are you allowed to eat pieces of meat that didn't have supervision? It's which is awesome. So you're watching from a distance. So then why do you say that a a large limb is considered an a right? You're telling me you're talking in terms of Rav but Rav you're asking me in Rav that what Rav is the author of this that is but Rav himself says that these pieces of meat are not like what you think they are to be eaten but they're the only problem is that they're not what's in they're not as in a but they're also to eat and argues and says you're allowed to eat it. Okay. says the Garra very similar to what we had yesterday. Yesterday we had of I already forgot what he said in that he didn't say it was and I Yeah. Where was it? Wow. Oh, right. said, "Yesterday we learned a beautiful sugur says he never said it straight out. It was from a story that went on a boat and he told his shamish to go pay and the shamish either gave the guy a chicken that was strafe or he gave him diluted wine." So you see you're not allowed to be going but says so what's he if he said it was furish or it's for misa because if it was a misa maybe that's not exactly what he meant. Maybe he was just upset at him for having a chicken or upset at him for giving him diluted wine. So the same thing we're going to say to here today is not something that he said straight out in it was a story a good story and the is going to ask so what if it's a story so in the story you could say listen it's not because it's because of another reason you're saying the like story they're sitting there by the by the boat in the place called he sees a person washing off a head of an animal in the water. The head slipped his grip and fell into the water. Whoa, big loss. So the guy goes and brings a basket use as a net. as train you know like sometimes I don't know if it it happened to you it happened to me you go into a mikvah and you drop a fork in the ka mikvah so you go and you bring a whole device and when you pull your fork out you get three forks why cuz the guy before you also dropped the fork mish what happened over here the guy puts in his basket into the river and instead of pulling out one head he pulls out two heads What? This this this is a a daily occurrence. You drop one thing in and you drop one thing in and you pull out two. So he says, "You have no idea where that head came from. One of these heads is 100% maybe. I don't know. The head that you had in your hand was kosher, but what about the head you pulled out? The second one. And you don't know which one is what. They both look the same. They're both sheep. Whatever they are weren't happy. They go to they say, "Why did you say we're talking about in a city where most of the people are Jewish and most of the heads are kosher? What's the problem?" Nope. Over here, we're talking about a problem. the the the idea is that there's more chance that it will be user than so says so but what's the problem you see from here oh you see from here that is aer said look that you can't you can't you can't rely on the on the second head it was it was out of our out of our um supervision maybe a raven came and switched out the heads. So didn't say it specifically. So what's the difference? But from the story you could see that he held in his over there was a port of mainly non-Jews. So that's why perhaps Rav said that you're not allowed to eat the meat because it's most likely came from a non-Jewish person. And I'll prove it to you. He said that's more likely that it's a non-coosher piece of me. In other words, because it was in a place of non-Jews, I can't prove from there. Maybe I can't, but in fact, you can prove that it's because of at the end of the day, how in the world could you eat meat? If you hold that if the meat is out of your eyesight for one moment, you can't eat it. How did Rav ever eat meat? says from the time he didn't remove his eyesight from the piece of meat. He buys him another like we do today. It's packaged. It's sealed. It has uh um like a wax seal on it that has a a good seal or the piece of me has a special identifying mark that you could tell if you ever go to. So when they sell in the bakery they sell uh dairy items items. So they'll they'll be in a shape of a triangle. So if you cut your meat into a triangle, now I know that this is my kosher piece of meat. Rav story time story time special for was going to son-in-law's house, you know. I don't know. Americans are not so used to this, but in people that don't have cars and they wait for buses. How often is it that you go to the bus stop and as you show up to the bus stop, boom, the bus shows up? It's one in a thousand. It barely ever happens. So, it just so happened that Rav, especially a boat, a boat is, you know, very slow. As he shows up to the boat stop, the boat shows up. He said, It's a sim. This is a sign that it's going to be a great day today. It's going to be a today. So, he got there to the son-in-law's house, his daughter's house, and he gets to the door. He peaks inside and he sees inside the house. doesn't say there were animals, a few animals hanging, ready to be eaten, ready to be cooked. So he knocks on the door. Knock knock knock. Oh is here the door. The door is here. The He's here. Even the cooks, the chefs, they all ran to the door. says Ra as they're saying hi and they're all hugging and kissing him but he's looking he's he's staring at the meat. Why? Because Rav holds the meat that loses supervision even for a moment. You're not allowed to eat it. You're lucky that I'm here. Otherwise, there would been for my for my household didn't didn't eat from that meat. But why wouldn't he eat if it's because they lost eyesight on it? But he never lost his eyesight. He was constantly watching it. He was upset with himself, Ra, that he said that because the boat showed up, the bus showed up as he went to the bus stop. The boat showed up as he came to the boat stop. That's a that's going to be a great day. That's called to to to guess and say if this and this happens, then that's a sign and I'm going to do this and this and that. as but wait a minute that wasn't the real that's not like the famous story where said um he said if a if a if a girl comes out and says drink and I'm I'm gonna also give the the the camels to drink that's a that This is the the sim that that's the that's why because he was relying on it 100%. Only if you do that then you're also made a sim and he said if the guards if the push are going to say come to us then we're going to go and we're going to kill out all the pushim. But if they're going to say, "We're going to come to you." Then we're not going to go to war with them. So what was the problem? Why was Rab upset at himself for saying, "Oh, if if the boat shows up, oh it's the fact that the boat showed up, it's a riot that wants me." It's not a real She wasn't relying 100%. Says, "You right, you're not going to believe this. When the daughter of marries, it's not audit. It's not a sudas mitzvah. It's not a regular that there's a mitzvah in the over here. She's stepping down. She's a getting married says didn't want to benefit and enjoy a party that's a different thing. But a party that doesn't that shouldn't really happen that kind of I don't want to benefit from says he said he held it was a good sign when the boat showed up. right when he showed up. He didn't have to wait and would open up a safer like they do at the at the caver or called you open up a safer and you see what it says there in the in the in the or whatever does does refer to to what you're does it answer your question say you tell ask as a child. What do you learn today? When Rab was alive was the and was the gad in. So would write letters to Rav and he would write the of our master when then took over our friend. He didn't call him our he called him our friend. Now took offense to that because he didn't want his to think that he's you know just not isn't there something that I greater than so sent him the calendar for 60 years trying to impress him with a said, "Okay, he's great at math." He sent him 13 camels worth of different and asked him questions on it and showed him his great knowledge in traus. Oh, and that actually convinc he's he's he's tremendous when it comes to traus. I need to go go visit him. I need to go see who this is. So he tells the kid sh make that big journey that that that u I don't want to call it. Okay, we'll call it a journey. A journey from bubble from from Israel to bubble. I got to see this tremendous gud called who's who who had 13 camels worth. They say it's a gisma but a tremendous amount of of traus that he knew. So he tells the kid, he meets a child in the street, he says, "What have you learned today that was his trick whatever the kid would say that that gave him the knowledge of what to do at that moment say over he quotes literally died. In other words, you have nothing to go to bubble because by the time you get there, you're going to miss the sh you're going to miss everything. He's not he's no longer alive that died. says it's not true didn't die didn't want to be tremendous journey all the way from he didn't want him to be if a person built a house or he had a baby or he got married and he was very successful in his business so it's a good sign no it's not considered which But it's a good sim. You're allowed to take this. What is it? A good sim. When is it a good sign? If this happened three times, you made money in the stock market one time, two times. Oh, you're doing well. Keep on going. Says, I don't want to give because died on me is no longer here. Shim is not here. In other words, if you take and they don't return, I'm gonna have three lost and then the rashi will continue coming. Once it's then unfortunately the the keep on going as what happens if you lost meat that's in a string. They used to put pieces of of meat on a on a string. Isn't that a good sim? Once again, my favorite word. Don't Don't be stupid when it comes to toen. Of course, it's a why why are you acting like that? It's a rais. It wasn't a question and answer. He just made a statement. If you lost meat on a string, it's obvious that it's yours and it's kosher. Nahar from Nardau went to Kahano by Naharo by by who's he was at the on the river bank on we just learned in that in that says that in in G one of the there's four days that you must announce that you sold the mother and that you shouldn't sh the son and he adds even on every is a day that there's a lot of meat and people eat there's a to eat there's a mitzah to eat everything you eat on is a big mitzvah also calm the ravens and it starts raining down liver and kidneys you're allowed to eat it why today is a day that it's one of these the days one of the five days he's supposed to announce because it's one of the days the biggest days of in the So it's a kosher meat. There's a there's a sim it's a there's a that kosher a piece of the the animal the rectum of the animal got lost found he lost it by and he found something similar looked like he found his piece do you have a could you recognize it. He says, "Yeah, I can recognize it. I don't have a sim, but I recognize it." MK Zilk, you could take it. So, let's let's finish over here so we don't have an hour. Raoai, have a wonderful day. >> Meritus of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdyop.com.